Gait Analysis in Prosthetics by James R
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Gait Analysis in Prosthetics by James R. Gage, M.D. Ramona Hicks, R.P.T., M.A. REVIEW lems faced by lower limb amputees. Inman's measurement techniques included motion pic Objective measurement systems which quan tures of coronal and sagittal views, as well as tify locomotion have been in use for the past transverse rotations from below using a glass century. But not until World War II, when walkway. Using interrupted light photography, thousands of men returned home to the United the Biomechanics Laboratory team studied the States with amputations, was technology really motion of body segments during gait. Force applied to the understanding of prosthetic gait. plates measured the subject's ground reaction Inman and colleagues1 founded the Biome forces, and muscle activity was recorded using chanics Laboratory at the University of Cali electromyography (EMG), which measures the fornia to establish fundamental principles of electrical signals associated with contraction of human walking, particularly in relation to prob a muscle. Prior to Inman's fundamental studies, prostheses were customized for the individual Temporal and kinematic data, which were col amputee, without any particular regard to ra lected at slow, free, and fast speeds, showed tional structural design. Inman's goal was to that the hydraulic knees improved the symmetry provide fundamental data essential for the de between the prosthetic limb and the sound limb, sign of prosthetic limbs. By analyzing normal especially at the fast and free speeds. This human walking, he and his colleagues laid the finding was true for both cadence and the groundwork for biomechanical analysis of am amount of knee-flexion at swing phase. putee gait.2 Since that time, numerous tech Hoy and colleagues,10 in one of the few niques have been developed to study human lo studies on gait in juvenile amputees, collected comotion,3 and numerous studies have been un kinematic data at various speeds to compare the dertaken to evaluate prosthetic gait. solid ankle cushioned heel (SACH) foot to a Child Amputee Prosthetic Project (CAPP) ex perimental foot. The authors found hip range RESEARCH APPLICATIONS of motion to be closer to normal and signifi Eberhart, et al.4 described the locomotor cantly less with the CAPP foot than the SACH mechanism of the above-knee amputee from ki foot. 11 nematic and kinetic data. They compared lateral Hannah and Morrison studied the effect of stick figures of amputees to normal subjects as alignment of the below-knee prosthesis on gait. a means to objectively identify gait deviations Using electrogoniometers to measure hip and in the sagittal plane. Force plate data were used knee joint rotations in the coronal, sagittal, and to compare the weight-bearing characteristics of transverse planes, they found that malalignment the prosthetic limb and the sound limb. From of the prosthetic foot was the most crucial for these comparisons, the authors identified am gait symmetry. 12 putees who walked well with their prostheses Grevsten and Stalberg used electromyog and those who were less adept. Eberhart be raphy to compare muscle activity in below-knee lieved that ultimately "optimal" patterns of amputees walking with patellar tendon-bearing gait could be determined for amputees and used (PTB) and PTB-suction prostheses. Surface as a reference for evaluating prosthetic gait. electrodes were placed over the tibialis anterior Zuniga, et al.5 studied gait in 20 above-knee and gastrocnemius muscles which, in normal amputees by using electrogoniometers attached gait, usually fire at opposite phases. The data to the knee and foot switches. Their data doc showed that these muscles contracted for longer umented asymmetry in the stance and swing periods when the PTB prosthesis was used than phase times between the prosthetic and sound with the PTB-suction prosthesis, suggesting limb. that the suction mechanism improved the adap In similar investigations, James and Oberg6 tation to the prosthesis. 13 and Murray, et al.7 studied temporal stride pa Thiele, et al. investigated possible neuro- rameters and knee flexion-extension angles, physiological reasons for weakness in above- and also examined above-knee gait at various knee amputees by recording electromyographic speeds. They confirmed the stance and swing activity of the quadriceps during gait. They did phase asymmetry between the prosthetic and not find abnormal recordings and concluded sound limb. They also showed that the asym that muscle weakness was secondary to bio metry was present regardless of the speed of mechanical, rather than neurophysiological, walking. factors. The collection of baseline data in above-knee amputees clearly demonstrated some shortcom CLINICAL APPLICATIONS ings in prosthetic gait. One of these, the longer swing time which is required on the prosthetic Until the present, gait analysis has been ap side, has led to the development of dozens of plied to prosthetics only for research purposes. prosthetic knees. Gait analysis laboratories Routine prosthetic fitting and checkout are still have been used to evaluate some of these pros done by means of observational gait analysis. thetic designs. Godfrey, et al.,8 in a limited However, observational gait analysis has many study that compared gait with six cadence-re disadvantages. sponsive knee units, found no significant dif In the first place, even normal human ferences among them. Murray, et al.9 compared walking is extremely complex. With each step, the gait of above-knee amputees with hydraulic more than 30 major muscles have to contract knee units versus constant friction knee units. and/or relax synchronously in each lower ex- tremity. Also, normal human gait is rapid (ap this objective analysis is produced by the com proximately 105 steps per minute), and the puter in such a fashion that preconceived biases human eye is not fast enough to separate the and communication errors between observers various components of gait at this speed. Krebs, are minimized. Furthermore, some of the more et al.14 have shown that data vary widely when modern gait analysis facilities have the ability different examiners have observed a person's to compare records, for example, of a patient's gait and that observational analysis is only a gait pre- and post-operatively, or of an ampu moderately reliable technique. The variations tee's gait with two different prosthetic devices between observers may be due to the precon or components. Through comparisons like ceptions of individual observers, to limitations these, the presence or absence of benefit can be of human perception, or to problems in trans determined objectively. mitting the information or data to colleagues. In light of these findings, it is not surprising that the fit and quality of the limbs fabricated by different prosthetists vary greatly. KINESIOLOGY Technology has now progressed to the point The field of prosthetics can make use of the where automated gait laboratories can be built. new science of kinesiology, or the study of Their capabilities vary, but most labs monitor movement. Kinesiology consists of two major one or more of the following parameters: fields: 1) kinematics or movement measurements 1) kinematics, the study of motion exclusive through a motion analysis system, of the influences of mass or forces, i.e., 2) evaluation of ground reaction forces via without regard to the underlying cause of force plates or pressure sensitive the motion; and switches, and 2) kinetics, which deals with the forces that 3) dynamic electromyography (monitoring produce motion. the electrical activity of contracting mus cles). Kinematic Data The advantage of an automated motion mea Kinematic data can be gathered in a variety surement system is that automated data entry of ways—through interrupted light photog and rapid processing allow routine clinical use raphy, cinefilm, video systems, and/or electro- at a reasonable cost. Since the sampling rate of goniometers—and it can be displayed in many most automated motion systems is in excess of ways. Stick figures provide a visual display of 50 Hz (50 samples/second), all movement in the subject walking. the lower extremities during walking can be ex Figure 1 is a stick figure representation of an amined in detail and with excellent reproduc 11 year old girl with a right knee disarticula ibility. tion. The stick figures facilitate the identifica Thus, the analysis of walking becomes ob tion of gait deviations, e.g., knee hyperexten- jective, rather than subjective, and a record of sion on the prosthetic side at stance phase. With Figure 1. Lateral stick figures of the right gait cycle of an 11-year-old-girl with a right knee disarticulation. Figure 2. Comparison of knee flexion-extension motion in one above-knee amputee with an average composite of knee flexion- extension in seven above- knee amputees. observational gait analysis, this gait deviation Although all above-knee amputees hyperextend might be missed, or two examiners might argue their knees slightly during stance phase, this about its presence. With objective gait analysis, patient has 10 degrees more hyperextension we can prove the deviation's existence by than average. Following the gait analysis, it viewing the stick figures, and we can identify was discovered that the knee extension bumper the cause of the deviation by reviewing the was too soft, and it was replaced with a suff graphs that depict motion. These graphs display er one. motions of each joint of the lower extremities Kinematic data can also be used to compute in all three planes during a representative gait temporal data, such as stride length, cadence, cycle. and walking velocity. Figure 3 compares the Figure 2 is a graph showing knee flexion- temporal data of the child with knee disarticu extension of the same child with a knee disar lation with "normal" children the same age. ticulation. The child's sagittal knee motion is Notice that the stride length is normal but that compared with the mean or average flexion- the walking velocity and cadence are less than extension of seven other above-knee amputees.