CQY Volume 36 Cover and Front Matter

THE • CHINA

Problems of Village Leadership after Land Reform Thomas P. Bernstein The Influence of the Past: How the Early Years Helped to Shape the Future of the Chinese Communist Party C. Martin Wilbur Transfer of Legitimacy in the Chinese Communist Party: Origins of the Maoist Myth William F. Dorrill The Institutionalisation of the Chinese Communist Revolu- tion: The Ladder of Success on the Eve of the Cultural Revolution Michel Oksenberg Chinese Foreign Policy after 1963: The Maoist Phases Michael B. Yahuda The Cultural Revolution in Inner Mongolia Paul Hyer & William Heaton

The Contemporary China Institute Stuart R. Schram

Hong Kong and Taiwan Sources for Research into the Cultural Revolution Period Gordon A. Bennett

QUARTERLY CiJJWfKT AND DOCUMENTATION

I9o9

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.203.244, on 04 Oct 2021 at 18:52:25, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0305741000005579 iOs -; 5,0 OCTOBER-DECEMBER, 1963 Chinese Studies in Sociology and Anthropology

Editor Sidney L. Greenblatt, Drew University Advisory Committee Bernard Gallin, Michigan State University; Robert J. Lifton, Yale University; Burton Pasternak, State University of New York; Jack Potter, University of California, Berkeley; Franz Schurmann, University of California, Berkeley; Ezra Vogel, Harvard University.

It is a pleasure to announce the publication of a new quarterly journal of translations from Chinese sources—CHINESE STUDIES IN SOCIOLOGY AND ANTHROPOLOGY. The journal carries unabridged translations from scholarly periodicals and other sources ordinarily untapped by existing translation services.

Sample Selections The Party Supports Me in My Struggle for Self-determination in Marriage Ning Ming-Yeh Marriage by Purchase Liu Kuei-Hua New Wind in a Border Village Chang Ch'cmg The Collective's Things are More Important than the Individual's Chang Yu, Li Chen, TUng Hsin A Female General in Three Great Revolutionary Movements Chao Yun-Nan Thrust Politics Forward, Train the Children to Become the Successors of the Proletarian Revolutionary Cause

Published Quarterly Publication began Fall 1968

Annual Subscriptions: Institutions: $40 Individuals associated with subscribing institutions: $15 tej.INTERNATIONAL ARTS AND SCIENCES PRESS 901 North Broadway, White Plains, New York 10603

SECOND CLASS POSTAGE RATES PAID AT NEW YORK, N.Y.

INDEX OF AUTHORS ISSUE NO. AVBRY, DOROTHY R., Book Review 33 BAUM, RICHARD, Comment 34 BELL, CORAL, Book Review 35 BENNETT, GORDON A. (notes), Hong Kong and Taiwan Sources for Research into the Cultural Revolution Period 36 BERGER, VERGIL, Book Review 36 s BERNSTEIN, THOMAS P., Problems of Village Leadership after Land Reform 36 BOORMAN, HOWARD L., Book Review 35 BOWMAN, GERRY, Book Review 34 BRIDGHAM, PHILIP, Mao's Cultural Revolution in 1967: The Struggle to Seize Power 34 CAVENDISH, PATRICK, Book Review 33 CH'EN, JEROME (trans.), Chingkangshan Revisited: An Unpub- lished Poem by Mao Tse-tung 34 DORRILL, WILLIAM F., Transfer of Legitimacy in the Chinese Communist Party: Origins of the Maoist Myth 36 DREYER, JUNE, China's Minority Nationalities in the Cultural Revolution 35 DUNCANSON, DENNIS J., Book Review 33 ETO, SHINKICHI, Book Review 35 . FIELD^ROBERT MICHAEL, Hfa^MuchGrain DoesJZommunist China Produce? ~~ ~~ 33 FREEBERNE, MICHAEL, Book Review 36 FREEDMAN, MAURICE, Book Review 34 , Book Review 36 , Book Review 36 GALENSON, WALTER, Book Review 34 GmsBURG, GEORGE, The People's Procuratorate in Communist China: The Institution in the Ascendant 1954-1957 34 GOODMAN, CHERYL PAYER, Book Review 34 A, BHABANI SEN, A Maoist Line for India 33

INDEX OF AUTHORS—continued ISSUE NO. HEATON, WILLIAM, The Cultural Revolution in Inner Mongolia 36 HINTON, HAROLD C, Book Review 34 HOOK, BRIAN, Book Review 36 HOWE, CHRISTOPHER, The Supply and Administration of Urban Housing in Mainland China: The Case of Shanghai 33 HYER, PAUL, The Cultural Revolution in Inner Mongolia 36 ITO, KIKUZO, The Dilemma of Mao Tse-tung 35 > 35 , Book Review 35 , Book Review 35 KLEIN, DONALD W., The State Council and the Cultural Revolution 35 , Book Review 34 LAM, S. K., Book Review 35 LARY, DIANA, Book Review 36 LEWIS, JOHN W., Book Review 33 Li, TSE-CHUNG, Book Review 35 Liu, YIN C, Henry McAleavy: A Memorial 36 MACDONALD, JAMES, Book Review 35 , Book Review 36 MAXWELL, NEVILLE, Book Review 35 MEISNER, MAURICE, Book Review 33 MILLS, HARRIET C, Book Review 34 NEUHAUSER, CHARLES, Comment 34 . OKSENBERG, MICHEL, The Institutionalisation of the Chinese Communist Revolution: The Ladder of Success on the Eve of the Cultural Revolution 36 PIKE, DOUGLAS, Book Review 33 POWELL, RALPH L., The Increasing Power of Lin Piao and the Party Soldiers 1959-1966 34 RAY, DENNIS M., Book Review 35 RUBIN, ALFRED P., The Position of Tibet in International Law 35 RUPEN, ROBERT A., Book Review 34 SCHRAM, STUART R. (notes), The Contemporary China Institute 36 SCHWARTZ, BENJAMIN, The Reign of Virtue: Some Broad Pers- pectives on Leader and Party in the Cultural Revolution 35 SHERIDAN, MARY, The Emulation of Heroes 33 SHEWMAKER, KENNETH E., The " Agrarian Reformer " Myth 34 SHIBATA, MINORU, The Dilemmai) Mao[Tse-iungz 35 SIMON, SHELDON W., Maoism and Inter-Party Relations: Peking's Alienation of the Japan Communist Party 35

INDEX OF AUTHORS—continued ISSUE NO. SOLECKI, JAN J. (trans.), Blucher's " Grand Plan " of 1926 35 STANHNKE, ARTHUR, The People's Procuratorate in Communist China: The Institution in the Ascendant 1954-1957 34 THOMPSON, ROBERT, Book Review 33 TSO-LIANG, HSIAO, The Dispute over a Wuhan Insurrection in 1927 33 VAN DER KROEF, JUSTIN, The Sino-lndonesian Rupture 33 WILBUR, C. MARTIN (notes), Blucher's " Grand Plan " of 1926 35 , The Influence of the Past: How the Early Years Helped to Shape the Future of the Chinese Communist Party 36 WITKE, ROXANE, Book Review 33 YAHUDA, MICHAEL B., Chinese Foreign Policy after 1963: The Maoist Phases 36 , Book Review 34

INDEX OF BOOKS REVIEWED ISSUE NO. Arms Control Arrangements for the Far East, HOOVER INSTI- TUTION. Reviewed by Coral Bell 35 Asian Rural Society: China, India, Japan, TADASHI FUKUTAKE. Reviewed by Maurice Freedman 36 Behind the Lines—Hanoi, HARRISON E. SALISBURY. Reviewed by Dorothy R. Avery 33 China in Maps, edited by HAROLD FULLER. Reviewed by Michael Freeberne 36 China Observed, COLIN MACKERRAS, NEALE HUNTER. Reviewed by Diana Lary 36 China: The Other Communism, K. S. KAROL. Reviewed by Gerry Bowman 34 China: Yellow Peril? Red Hope? C. R. HENSMAN. Reviewed by Michael Yahuda 34 China's Economic System, AUDREY DONNITHORNE. Reviewed by Walter Galenson 34 Chine—URSS, La Fin d'une Hegemonie. Les Origines du grand Schisme Communiste 1950-1957, FRANCOIS FEJTO. Reviewed by Robert A. Rupen 34 The Chinese in Australia, ARTHUR HUCK. Reviewed by Maurice Freedman 34 The Chinese in London, NG KWEE CHOO. Reviewed by S. K. Lam 35 The Chinese People's Republic, DENNIS J. DOOLIN, ROBERT C. NORTH. Reviewed by Dennis M. Ray 35 Chou En-lai: China's Gray Eminence, KAI-YU HSU. Reviewed by James Macdonald 35 Communism in Vietnam, ROGER SWEARINGEN, HAMMOND ROLPH. Reviewed by Douglas Pike 33 The Communist World: Marxist and Non-Marxist Views, edited by HARRY G. SHAFFER. Reviewed by Harold C. Hinton 34 Contemporary China, A Research Guide, PETER BERTON, EUGENE WU, edited by HOWARD KOCH JR. Reviewed by Donald W. Klein 34 The Criminal Process in the People's Republic of China 1949- 1963. An Introduction. JEROME ALAN COHEN. Reviewed by John W. Lewis 33 iv

INDEX OF BOOKS REVIEWED—continued ISSUE NO. The Cultural Ecology of a Chinese Village. Cameron High- lands, Malaysia, JAMES D. CLARKSON. Reviewed by Maurice Freedman 36 Defeat in the Dark: The Mark of Mao Tse-tung on War, MICHAEL ELLIOTT BATEMAN. Reviewed by Robert Thompson 33 Dollars, Dependants and Dogma. Overseas Remittances to Communist China. CHUN-HSI WU. Reviewed by W. Klatt 35 Enemies and Friends: The United Front in Chinese Com- munist History, LYMAN P. VAN SLYKE. Reviewed by Cheryl Payer Goodman 34 Far Eastern Economic Review 1968 Yearbook. Reviewed by Brian Hook 36 The First Vietnam Crisis, MELVIN GURTOV. Reviewed by Dorothy R. Avery 33 Formosa, China and the United Nations: Formosa in the World Community, LUNG-CHU CHEN, HAROLD D. LASSWELL. Reviewed by Tze-chung Li 35 Foundations of Maoism, RAM SWARUP. Reviewed by Maurice Meisner 33 The Function of " China " in Marx, Lenin and Mao, DONALD M. LOWE. Reviewed by Maurice Meisner 33 Histoire du Parti Communiste Chinois (1921-1949), JACQUES GUILLERMAZ. Reviewed by James Macdonald 36 A History of Sino-lndian Relations: Hostile Co-existence, JOHN ROWLAND. Reviewed by Neville Maxwell 35 Ho^hi Minh on Revolution, BERNARD B. FALL. Reviewed by Dorothy R. Avery 33 Literary Dissent in Communist China, MERLE GOLDMAN. Reviewed by Harriet C. Mills 34 Mao Tse-tung, STUART R. SCHRAM. Reviewed by Howard L. Boorman 35 Memories for a Chinese Granddaughter, STUART AND ROMA GELDER. Reviewed by Gerry Bowman 34 Moscow and Chinese Communists, ROBERT C. NORTH. Reviewed by Shinkichi Eto 35

INDEX OF BOOKS REVIEWED—continued ISSUE NO. Le Mouvement Ouvrier Chinois de 1919 a 1927, JEAN CHES- NEAUX. Reviewed by Patrick Cavendish 33 The Pakistan-China Axis, B. L. SHARMA. Reviewed by Neville Maxwell 35 Pakistan's Foreign Policy, MUSHTAQ AHMAD. Reviewed by Neville Maxwell 35 The Peking Papers, JACQUES MARCUSE. Reviewed by Vergil Berger 36 M. N. Roy's Mission to China: the Communist Kuomintang Split of 1927, ROBERT C. NORTH, XENIA J. EUDIN. Reviewed by Shinkichi Eto 35 A Short History of Chinese Communism, FRANKLIN W. HOUN. Reviewed by Harold C. Hinton 34 The Spatial Economy of Communist China. A Study on Indus- trial Location and Transportation, YUAN-LI Wu, H. C. LING, GRACE HSIA WU. Reviewed by W. Klatt 35 The United States in Vietnam, GEORGE MCTURNAN KAHIN, JOHN W. LEWIS. Reviewed by Dorothy R. Avery 33 Viet Cong, DOUGLAS PIKE. Reviewed by Dorothy R. Avery 33 Vietnam and the Sino-Soviet Dispute, ROBERT A. RUPEN. Reviewed by Douglas Pike 33 Vietnam Triangle—Moscow j Peking I Hanoi, DONALD S. ZAG- ORIA. Reviewed by Dennis J. Duncanson 33 Vietnam! Vietnam! FELIX GREENE. Reviewed by Dorothy R. Avery 33 Why Vietnam? FRANK N. TRAGER. Reviewed by Dorothy R. Avery 33 Women in Modem China, HELEN FOSTER SNOW. Reviewed by Roxane Witke 33 World Communism: The Disintegration of a Secular Faith, RICHARD LOWENTHAL. Reviewed by Robert A. Rupen 34

The only Indian (bimonthly) journal devoted to current Chinese and Asian affairs. Each issue contains some of the best Indian thought and scholarship. Last two issues contain:

JULY-AUGUST 1968 North Vietnam: The New Symbol of Asian Nationalism C. R. M. Rao Basic Motivations of China's Foreign Policy Rahul The Cult of Mao in Modem Chinese History Patricia Vberoi

SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER 1968 The Essentials of Maoist Literary Doctrine Patricia Vberoi Some First Indian Attempts at Specialist Study of China's Nuclear Threat—A Review G. D. Deshingkar China's Deepening Interest in Himalaysia Mtra Stnha

Other features include: Important Chinese Documents; Biographical Studies of important Chinese leaders; Background Notes; Chronology of important Chinese and Asian events.

ANNUAL SUBSCRIPTION: For Europe, Asia, Africa and Australia—30s.; and for U.S.A., Canada and Latin America —$4.00 by surface mail. Airmail charges extra. Editorial & Business Offices: 5 Haiky Road, New Delhi.