Report Sample

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Report Sample Willowmoor Restoration Design Hydrology Phase 1 – Hydrologic Characterization October 2013 Willowmoor Restoration Design Hydrology Phase 1 – Hydrologic Characterization Prepared for: King County River and Floodplain Management Section Prepared by: Northwest Hydraulic Consultants Seattle, WA October 2013 Executive Summary King County (County) is planning the Willowmoor Project, a flood control and habitat restoration project for the Sammamish River Transition Zone (TZ), which extends from the Lake Sammamish outlet weir approximately 1,400 feet downstream through Marymoor Park. Northwest Hydraulic Consultants (NHC) was contracted by the County to provide recommendations for design hydrology for the Willowmoor project. The initial phase of this work focuses on characterizing the original U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) design hydrology within the current hydrologic context and on identifying potential future hydrologic conditions to provide background for a robust project design. The Sammamish River Flood Control Project was completed by the Corps in 1964 to provide spring flood control for the Sammamish River valley. The project was designed to accommodate an event similar to the March 1950 storm, which was the spring flow of record at the time. The design objectives were to eliminate flooding for a design flow of 1,500 cfs in the Sammamish River downstream of Bear Creek while keeping Lake Sammamish levels below 29.0 feet NGVD (32.6 feet NAVD).1 The design flow was characterized by the Corps as a 10-year annual flood or a 40-year spring flood, meaning that on average that flow had a ten percent chance of occurring at all or a 2.5 percent chance of occurring after March 1 in any given year. This frequency estimate is relatively consistent with results of current frequency analysis on 18 years of peak flow data (1940-1957) from the discontinued Sammamish River near Redmond gage that would have been available to the Corps during project design. The original Lake Sammamish outlet weir was modified in 1998 to enhance summer flows to improve fish passage into Lake Sammamish. Modifications included adding a low flow notch and flattening the weir profile on either side of the notch. The change to the weir profile resulted in raising the crest elevation by up to half a foot. Water levels in Lake Sammamish, and corresponding discharges, have been shown to be affected by conditions through the TZ and downstream to Bear Creek. Vegetation management practices in the TZ downstream of the weir have varied over time, and impacts of different vegetation conditions on flow capacity in the TZ have been demonstrated in several previous studies and by shifts in the stage- discharge relationship at the weir corresponding to changes in vegetation management. A reduction in lake outflows associated with high Bear Creek discharges—the Bear Creek backwater effect—has been demonstrated with measurements showing variable discharge at the weir for the same lake level during large events and can be reproduced by a hydraulic model of the system. Existing hydrologic and hydraulic models of the Lake Sammamish/Sammamish River system have been used to characterize existing conditions—e.g., to determine flood inundation extents for FEMA mapping—and to explore the sensitivity or impact to the system of observed and proposed changes in the TZ, such as vegetation and sediment levels. The hydraulic model is well-calibrated to water levels at the weir and downstream of the TZ and reproduces lake levels quite well. The hydrologic models, which have been used to estimate long periods of inflows for the hydraulic model, are less accurate in reproducing observed flows on Bear Creek and Issaquah Creek. Based on nearly 50 years of observed peak flows since construction of the weir, the 10-year flow in the Sammamish River downstream of Bear Creek is currently about 2,000 cfs, which is 33 percent higher than the 10-year flow characterized by the Corps during project design. It seems likely that this increase 1 Lake Sammamish water levels have been customarily expressed relative to the NGVD29 (or MSL) datum. The conversion factor to the NAVD88 vertical datum is +3.59 feet. This report will clearly indicate the datum for any elevations and provide elevations on both scales where reasonable. Willowmoor Design Hydrology Phase 1 i October 2013 is primarily a result of the original project, which increased the capacity of the lake outlet and downstream channel. Development in parts of the basin, especially Bear Creek and east Lake Sammamish, has likely contributed to increased peak flows, but would not be expected to have so substantial an impact in a system with significant storage, as is provided by Lake Sammamish. Examination of precipitation and streamflow trends indicates that climate is also not a driving factor; there is no long-term evidence of increasing precipitation or streamflow trends. Analysis of lake levels, however, shows a significant increase in the amount of time that Lake Sammamish exceeds the Corps-defined ordinary high water (OHW) level of 27 feet NGVD (30.6 feet NAVD). This is consistent with anecdotal reports from lakeside homeowners. Both visual inspection and statistical tests suggest that higher lake levels begin around 1998, and these changes would be consistent with weir modifications that reduce lake outflow at low to moderate lake levels. The data do not link the weir modifications as clearly to maximum lake levels (above about 28 feet NGVD). In looking at the historic events with the highest observed lake levels, we can identify a number of contributing factors. Inflow is certainly a primary driver but cannot explain the lack of strong correspondence between the events with the highest peaks or inflow volumes and those with the highest lake levels. Examination of the record indicates that lake level prior to the event (i.e., the starting condition) and coincident high flows on Bear Creek are also recurring factors in several extreme lake level events. Different lake level response to events where inflow, starting level, and Bear Creek flows are similar also suggests that vegetation conditions in the TZ have an influence on high lake levels. It is interesting to note that nearly 90 percent of the events where the lake has exceeded 29 feet NGVD (32.6 feet NAVD) since 1964 have occurred since 1989, when annual TZ maintenance was discontinued. In contrast, only half of the highest Issaquah Creek flows in the same period have been since 1989. (Issaquah Creek is the largest tributary to Lake Sammamish and the only one with a streamflow record extending back to completion of the Sammamish River project.) The review and analyses documented in this report provide a characterization of the current hydrologic setting and the various factors and influences that have affected performance of the weir and TZ over the past couple of decades. Hydrologic design conditions for the Willowmoor project will need to take into account these various influences on flow and lake level. For this reason, and because the project is expected to have a broader range of objectives, it is unlikely that a single design flow and lake elevation can continue to be used. The design process will also need to take some account of potential future hydrologic conditions to ensure that the selected project will continue to meet performance objectives going forward. Willowmoor Design Hydrology Phase 1 ii October 2013 Table of Contents 1 Introduction ......................................................................................................................................... 1 2 Review of Previous Studies .................................................................................................................. 1 2.1 Project History .............................................................................................................................. 2 2.2 Hydrologic Data Analysis ............................................................................................................... 4 2.2.1 Lake Levels ............................................................................................................................ 4 2.2.2 Hydrologic Trends ................................................................................................................. 6 2.3 Existing Models ............................................................................................................................. 7 2.3.1 HSPF Models ......................................................................................................................... 8 2.3.2 HEC-RAS Model ................................................................................................................... 12 3 Statistical Analysis .............................................................................................................................. 13 3.1 Corps Design Flows ..................................................................................................................... 13 3.2 Lake Level Analysis ...................................................................................................................... 14 3.2.1 Exceedance Analysis ........................................................................................................... 17 3.2.2 Lake Level Trends ................................................................................................................ 19 3.3 Extreme Lake Level Events .........................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Annual Report 1998 Sammamish River Sockeye Salmon Fry
    Annual Report 1998 Sammamish River Sockeye Salmon Fry Production Evaluation Dave Seiler Lori Kishimoto Laurie Peterson Greg Volkhardt Washington Department of Fish & Wildlife Olympia, Washington 98504-1091 December 2001 Funded by: Lake Washington/Cedar River Forum Table of Contents List of Tables................................................................ ii List of Figures ............................................................... iii Acknowledgments ............................................................ iv Executive Summary............................................................v 1998 Sammamish River Sockeye Salmon Fry Production Evaluation .....................1 Introduction ............................................................1 Goals and Objectives.....................................................2 Methods ...............................................................2 Trapping Gear and Operation ........................................3 Trap Calibration...................................................3 Fry Estimation ....................................................4 Results...............................................................11 Catch ..........................................................11 Efficiency and Flow...............................................11 Effect of Release Location..........................................12 Migration Estimate: Average vs. Predicted Efficiency ....................13 Fry Production ...................................................13 Migration timing
    [Show full text]
  • Sammamish River Temperature and Dissolved Oxygen Total Maximum Daily Load Study Design
    Quality Assurance Project Plan Sammamish River Temperature and Dissolved Oxygen Total Maximum Daily Load Study Design October 2015 Publication No. 15-03-123 Publication Information Each study conducted by the Washington State Department of Ecology (Ecology) must have an approved Quality Assurance Project Plan. The plan describes the objectives of the study and the procedures to be followed to achieve those objectives. After completing the study, Ecology will post the final report of the study to the Internet. This Quality Assurance Project Plan is available on Ecology’s website at https://fortress.wa.gov/ecy/publications/SummaryPages/1503123.html Data for this project will be available on Ecology’s Environmental Information Management (EIM) website at www.ecy.wa.gov/eim/index.htm. Search Study ID MROS0001. Ecology’s Activity Tracker Code for this study is 15-035. Federal Clean Water Act 1996 303(d) Listings Addressed in this Study. See “Study area” and “Impairments addressed by this TMDL” sections. Author and Contact Information Teizeen Mohamedali P.O. Box 47600 Environmental Assessment Program Washington State Department of Ecology Olympia, WA 98504-7710 Communications Consultant: phone 360-407-6834. Washington State Department of Ecology - www.ecy.wa.gov o Headquarters, Lacey 360-407-6000 o Northwest Regional Office, Bellevue 425-649-7000 o Southwest Regional Office, Lacey 360-407-6300 o Central Regional Office, Union Gap 509-575-2490 o Eastern Regional Office, Spokane 509-329-3400 Cover photo: The Sammamish River, north of Redmond looking upstream (south) from the NE 116th St. Bridge. Photo taken by Ralph Svrjcek in July 2014.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 2 3 Onebothell Represents the Voice of Members of the Surrounding Area
    1 2 3 OneBothell represents the voice of members of the surrounding area. Since establishing ourselves at the start of the year we have had over 7500 hits from members of the community visiAng our website. It is clear to us that people from Bothell, Snohomish, Redmond, Woodinville, Kirkland, Kenmore and Seale ciAes all along the Burke-Gilman Trail believe Wayne land is very important. to them. At this Ame, over 99% of our registered visitors have voted to reject the rezone and future development on Wayne land, and we're working to represent their concerns. We have people talking today from Bothell, Mill Creek, Kirkland and Seale from our team. 4 5 6 This precious land, along the Burke-Gilman Trail, has been a recreaonal corridor since Joseph Blythe established it in 1931 for the local community. The Richards family bought it in 1950, and its been through three Generaons of ownership. In 1989 the council applied for a bond to purchase Wayne Golf Course for the City, to eXtend Blythe Park to create the Sammamish River Trail Greenway. They were quoted as wanAng to protect the open space before it was lost to developers. They tried again in 1990. In 1996 this land was recognized as important through the purchase of development rights on the front 9 when a Conservaon Easement was established for residents of Bothell and King County to enjoy the open space in perpetuity. The owners were quoted as saying they wanted to preserve this land so their kids could enjoy it. In 1997 The Open Space Taxaon was approved, reducing taxes by 90% for the Richards.
    [Show full text]
  • Willowmoor Cold-Water Supplementation Concepts
    WILLOWMOOR COLD-WATER SUPPLEMENTATION CONCEPTS June 2014 Department of Natural Resources and Parks Water and Land Resources Division King Street Center, KSC-NR-0600 201 South Jackson Street, Suite 600 Seattle, Washington 98104 www.kingcounty.gov WILLOWMOOR COLD-WATER SUPPLEMENTATION CONCEPTS Prepared by: Tetra Tech, Inc. 1420 Fifth Avenue, Suite 550 Seattle, Washington 98101 Department of Natural Resources and Parks Water and Land Resources Division Table of Contents Executive Summary ....................................................................................................................................... ii Introduction .................................................................................................................................................. 1 Project Area .............................................................................................................................................. 1 Contents of this Memo ............................................................................................................................. 1 Summary of Water Temperature Problems ................................................................................................. 4 Conceptual Alternatives ................................................................................................................................ 8 Hypolimnetic Withdrawal of Cold Water from Lake Sammamish ............................................................ 8 Pump Deeper Groundwater to Transition Zone ....................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Sammamish River, North Creek, and Swamp Creek
    FINAL Shoreline Analysis Report for the Cities of Bothell and Brier Shorelines: Sammamish River, North Creek, and Swamp Creek Prepared for: City of Bothell City of Brier Planning and Community Development Community Development Department Department 9654 NE 182nd Street 2901 228th St. SW Bothell, WA 98011 Brier, Washington 98036 February 2011 FINAL CITIES OF BOTHELL & BRIER GRANT NOS. G1000013 AND G1000037 S HORELINE A NALYSIS R EPORT for the Cities of Bothell and Brier Shorelines: Sammamish River, North Creek, and Swamp Creek Prepared for: City of Bothell City of Brier Planning and Community Community Development Department Development Department 9654 NE 182nd Street 2901 228th St. SW Bothell, WA 98011 Brier, Washington 98036 Prepared by: 710 Second Avenue, Suite 550 Seattle, WA 98104 This report was funded in part February 4, 2011 through a grant from the Washington Department of Ecology. The Watershed Company Reference Number: 090615 The Watershed Company Contact Person: Amy Summe ICF International Contact Person: Lisa Grueter Printed on 30% recycled paper. Cite this document as: The Watershed Company and ICF International. February 2011. Final Shoreline Analysis Report for the Cities of Bothell and Brier Shorelines: Sammamish River, North Creek, and Swamp Creek. Prepared for the City of Bothell Community Development Department, Bothell, WA. TABLE OF C ONTENTS Page # 1 Introduction ................................................................................ 1 1.1 Background and Purpose ..............................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Kenmore Shoreline Inventory and Characterization Preliminary
    Kenmore Shoreline Inventory and Characterization Preliminary Summary of Findings Background and Purpose Cities and counties updating their Shoreline Master Program (SMP) are required to prepare an inventory and characterization of the shoreline resources in their jurisdiction. The City of Kenmore has received a grant from the Washington State Department of Ecology to complete the SMP process. As part of the City’s SMP update, a preliminary draft inventory and characterization report and map folio has been prepared and will be finalized in June of 2008, following review by Ecology and the Technical Advisory Committee (TAC). The purpose of the study is to create a baseline inventory of conditions in the shoreline jurisdiction of the City of Kenmore using existing data sources. The inventory and characterization provides and understanding of the physical, biological, and cultural resources in the shoreline, to be used as a basis for updating the City’s SMP to comply with the Shoreline Management Act (SMA), Revised Code of Washington (RCW) 90.58 and its implementing guidelines, Washington Administrative Code (WAC) 173-26. The waterbodies within the City shoreline planning area include the Lake Washington, the Sammamish River, and the Main stem of Swamp Creek, and these have been broken to 10 “reaches” as outlined in Table 1 below. Table 1. City of Kenmore Shoreline Planning Area Wetlands Reach (Excluding Open Reach Area Reach Name Length (Acres) Water) (Miles) (Acres/percent of shoreline area) Lake Washington 01 18.2 0.8 0.4 2.1% Lake Washington
    [Show full text]
  • King County Water Features
    Middle McAleer Lyon SNO H O M ISH CO U N TY Puget Creek CreekLAKE Swamp North Little SoundSHORELINE Creek Creek Bear K ING CO U N TY North Creek WOODINVILLE Tuck E Boeing FOREST Lake N Woo Creek N175 NE din th St Bo vi Creek Washington the lle S ll 522 ll PARK Wy - Duva Rd k Cherry y Simo Sammamish n BOTHELL Creek k d s River o R m Thornton d S i N145thCreek St N a E Lake Sammamish/ Skykomish/Snoqualmie s m h 522 KENMORE 2 North Puget m Sammamish River (Snohomish) River N130th St East Bear DUVALL Juanita W a Creek NE 125th St Lake o Watershed Watershed o Sound Ave NE Creek d m Washington i n 0 v R i v Drainages i i l e 10 99 405 l e Tolt r NENorthgate Wy s - N River h R Greenwood Ave N C e Snoqualmie SEATTLE y d a Harris m r W d n River Middle o REDMOND NE 95th St R a Creek n y Forbes t t i Puget d o i e n NW 85th St Creek l SKYKOMISH C R Sound a - d D e n R u n v k all Rd N La o E i v o NE 75th St E A Skykomish KIRKLAND v N Ave t Market St NE 85th St e REDMOND River y a NE 65th St r g N W t Red d m 15th Ave NW n 35th Ave NE o 5 v i n n Auror o l d dp B W N50thSt West n i L Sa East y e n a Lake o r h t Lake y g Evans N45th St Washington n Ames W s Washingtoni 520 Lake h Creek a s Lake y Union a YARROW a HUNTSPOINT W W k POINT L ve W S a h E a CARNATION 520 Kelsey d l e R e Griffin 15th A W ve Creek y d Creek r n N o e CLYDE West E m Fall v e d i 3rd A HILL Lake Red 2 m North Fork ond C R e Sammamish i - t Bellevue Wy NE NE Bellevue - R y Snoqualmie w Fa n k o h ll s BELLEVUE - k MEDINA P Tokul River s C C NE 8th S i t t a EMadi a i h
    [Show full text]
  • I-405, SR 522 Vicinity to SR 527 Express Toll Lanes Improvement Project (MP 21.79 to 27.06)
    MAY 2020 ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT Appendix F: Visual Impact Assessment Discipline Report I-405, SR 522 Vicinity to SR 527 Express Toll Lanes Improvement Project (MP 21.79 to 27.06) Mill Creek N 5 405 Canyon Park 527 Bothell Kenmore 522 522 Woodinville Kirkland 405 Lake Washington 520 520 Bellevue Title VI Notice to Public It is the Washington State Department of Transportation’s (WSDOT) policy to assure that no person shall, on the grounds of race, color, national origin or sex, as provided by Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be otherwise discriminated against under any of its federally funded programs and activities. Any person who believes his/her Title VI protection has been violated, may file a complaint with WSDOT’s Office of Equal Opportunity (OEO). For additional information regarding Title VI complaint procedures and/or information regarding our non-discrimination obligations, please contact OEO’s Title VI Coordinator at (360) 705-7090. Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Information This material can be made available in an alternate format by emailing the Office of Equal Opportunity at [email protected] or by calling toll free, 855-362-4ADA (4232). Persons who are deaf or hard of hearing may make a request by calling the Washington State Relay at 711. Notificación de Titulo VI al Público Es la política del Departamento de Transporte del Estado de Washington el asegurarse que ninguna persona, por razones de raza, color, nación de origen o sexo, como es provisto en el Título VI del Acto de Derechos Civiles de 1964, ser excluido de la participación en, ser negado los beneficios de, o ser discriminado de otra manera bajo cualquiera de sus programas y actividades financiado con fondos federales.
    [Show full text]
  • Willowmoor Floodplain Restoration Project Update to WRIA 8 Salmon Recovery Council
    Willowmoor Floodplain Restoration Project Update to WRIA 8 Salmon Recovery Council Kate Akyuz, Project Manager September 20th, 2018 Department of Natural Resources and Parks Water and Land Resources Division River and Floodplain Management Section Briefing Summary • Project Schedule and Background • Sammamish Basin and Transition Zone • Maintaining/Monitoring the Transition Zone • Willowmoor CIP – Goals – Alternatives – Partnerships – Next Steps Project Schedule Background • 1965: Corps constructed Sammamish River Flood Control Project • 1998: Corps modified Transition Zone (TZ) weir • 1999: Puget Sound Chinook listed as threatened - ESA • 2000-2010: Lake Sammamish flooding concerns – Property damage – Shoreline erosion • 2003: Conceptual design TZ • 2011: Maintenance agreement • 2013-15: Alternatives analysis • 2016: Public meeting and FCD adopted Motion FCDECM 2016-04.1 selecting split flow alternative 4 Sammamish River Basin Sammamish River Transition Zone Sammamish River Basin Sammamish River Transition Zone Lake Sammamish Marymoor Park Off-Leash Dog City of Redmond Area King County Weir What are the Issues? • Lakeside landowners concerned about rising lake levels • Habitat for ESA-listed salmon • Increased Transition Zone maintenance and permitting costs Willowmoor - Project Direction FCDECM 2016-04.1 June 22, 2016 “A project that balances flood control, habitat restoration, fish passage, recreational access and on-going maintenance, including beaver mitigation and a dynamic weir.” Split Channel Alternatives’ Performance: Reduction in High Lake Levels Average days/year lake level exceeds: EL 27.0 EL 28.0 EL 29.0 Alt. 1: Ongoing Maint. 97 12 1.1 Alt. 4: Split Channel 47 (-50) 6 (-6) 0 (-1.1) Alt. 5: Widened Channel 94 (-3) 11 (-1) 0.9 (-0.2) 12 years of lake level modelled (#) = Number of days reduced relative to maintenance alt.
    [Show full text]
  • Sammamish River
    APPENDIX F WRIA 8 Salmon Habitat Project List Monday, October 02, 2017 Sammamish River APPLICABLE STRATEGIES LEGEND: Protect and restore Protect and Protect and Protect and restore marine water and restore restore cold water forest cover and sediment quality, Site-Specific ProjectsList floodplain sources and reduce headwater areas connectivity thermal barriers to especially near migration commercial and industrial areas Protect and Improve juvenile Provide adequate Improve water restore functional and adult survival stream flow quality riparian at the Ballard Locks vegetation Integrate salmon Restore sediment Protect and Reduce predation recovery priorities into processes necessary restore channel on juvenile local and regional for key life stages complexity migrants and lake- planning, regulations, rearing fry and permitting (SMP, CAO, NPDES, etc.) Restore shallow Remove (or Restore natural Continue existing and water rearing reduce impacts of) marine shoreline conduct new research, and refuge overwater monitoring, and adaptive habitat structures management on key issues Reconnect and Remove fish Reconnect Increase awareness enhance creek passage barriers backshore areas and and support for mouths pocket estuaries salmon recovery F- l Lake Washington/Cedar/Sammamish Watershed (WRIA 8) ChinookPage Salmon 1 of 18Conservation Plan l 10-YEAR UPDATE l 2017 67 APPENDIX F Sammamish River F- APPENDIX F Lake Washington/Cedar/Sammamish Watershed (WRIA 8) Chinook Salmon Conservation Plan 10-YEAR UPDATE 2017 68 l l l Sammamish River APPENDIX F Opportunities,
    [Show full text]
  • Bellevue Salmon Spawner Surveys (1999-2020)
    Bellevue Salmon Spawner Surveys (1999-2020) Kelsey Creek, West Tributary, Richards Creek, and Coal Creek Prepared for Christa Heller Water Resources Planning City of Bellevue, Utilities Engineering Division 450 - 110th Ave NE Bellevue, WA 98009 Prepared by Washington Dept. of Fish and Wildlife Region 4 Office 16018 Mill Creek Blvd. Mill Creek, Washington 98012 February 2021 1 CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .............................................................................................................5 1. INTRODUCTION .....................................................................................................................6 2. SPAWNER SURVEYS AND RESULTS .................................................................................8 2.1 PROFESSIONAL SURVEY METHODS ........................................................................................8 2.2 SALMON WATCHERS PROGRAM METHODS ..........................................................................8 2.3 PROFESSIONAL SURVEY RESULTS .......................................................................................12 2.4 SALMON WATCHERS PROGRAM .........................................................................................17 3. SUMMARY .............................................................................................................................19 3.1 CHINOOK SALMON USE .......................................................................................................19 3.2 SOCKEYE SALMON USE .......................................................................................................23
    [Show full text]
  • Endangered Species Act - Section 7 Consultation
    Endangered Species Act - Section 7 Consultation BIOLOGICAL OPINION USFWS Log# 13410-2007-F-0641 Interstate-405, State Route 520 to Interstate-5 Improvement Project King and Snohomish Counties, Washington Agency: Federal Highway Administration Olympia, Washington Consultation Conducted By: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Western Washington Fish and Wildlife Office Lacey, Washington December 2008 Ken S. Berg, Manager Date Washington Fish and Wildlife Office TABLE OF CONTENTS CONSULTATION HISTORY ....................................................................................................... 1 BIOLOGICAL OPINION............................................................................................................... 2 DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSED ACTION .......................................................................... 2 Construction Impacts and Summary of Quantities ............................................................. 5 Stormwater Design.............................................................................................................. 6 Conservation Measures....................................................................................................... 8 STATUS OF THE SPECIES (Bull Trout).................................................................................... 11 Life History....................................................................................................................... 15 STATUS OF CRITICAL HABITAT (Bull Trout; Coterminous Range)....................................
    [Show full text]