The Inalienable Right of Publicity

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Inalienable Right of Publicity University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository Faculty Scholarship at Penn Law 11-2012 The Inalienable Right of Publicity Jennifer Rothman Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/faculty_scholarship Part of the Commercial Law Commons, Constitutional Law Commons, Contracts Commons, Intellectual Property Law Commons, Jurisprudence Commons, Labor and Employment Law Commons, Law and Politics Commons, Law and Society Commons, Privacy Law Commons, Property Law and Real Estate Commons, and the Torts Commons The Inalienable Right of Publicity JENNIFER E. ROTHMAN* TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION .......................................... 186 I. CONTESTED AREAS OF ALIENABILITY ....................... 190 A. VOLUNTARY ASSIGNMENTS ........................... 191 B. BANKRUPTCY AND CREDITORS ......................... 199 C. MARITAL PROPERTY ................................ 201 D. POSTMORTEM RIGHTS AND DESCENDIBILITY ................ 203 II. THE RED HERRING OF THE PROPERTY VERSUS PRIVACY DEBATE .... 204 III. RECONSIDERING THE ALIENABILITY OF PUBLICITY RIGHTS ......... 208 A. FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS ............................. 209 B. COMMODIFICATION AND FORCED COMMERCIALIZATION ........ 217 C. SOCIAL WELFARE AND ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY .............. 220 IV. OTHER SALIENT CONSIDERATIONS FOR LIMITING ALIENABILITY ..... 224 A. SEPARABILITY ................................... 225 B. JUSTIFIABILITY: FURTHERING THE GOALS OF THE UNDERLYING ENTITLEMENT .................................... 228 C. RECIPROCITY: EQUITABLY DISTRIBUTING THE BENEFITS AND BURDENS OF ALIENABILITY ........................... 232 * Professor of Law and Joseph Scott Fellow, Loyola Law School (Los Angeles), Loyola Marymount University. © 2012, Jennifer E. Rothman. I thank Barton Beebe, Sarah Boyd, Julie Cohen, David Dolinko, Lee Fennell, Laura Heymann, David Horton, Melissa Jacoby, Roberta Kwall, Douglas NeJaime, Eduardo Pen˜alver, Seana Shiffrin, Stewart Sterk, Rebecca Tushnet, Eugene Volokh, Michael Waterstone, Diane Zimmerman, and participants at the UCLA faculty colloquium for their thoughtful comments. For their suggestions at early stages of this project, I thank participants at the Association of Law, Property, and Society Conference at Georgetown; the Privacy Law Scholars Conference at George Washington; the IP Scholars Conference at U.C. Berkeley; and the Loyola Law School faculty workshop. Finally, I thank the editing staff of The Georgetown Law Journal, Lisa Schultz (my outstanding librarian), Michael Boardman, Stefanie DeSeve, Kanika Shah, and Armineh Yousfian for their research assistance. 185 ElectronicElectronic copycopy availableavailable at:at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2174646http://ssrn.com/abstract=2174646 186THE GEORGETOWN LAW JOURNAL [Vol. 101:185 V. IMPLICATIONS OF LIMITING THE ALIENABILITY OF THE RIGHT OF PUBLICITY ......................................... 233 A. REVISITING THE ALIENABILITY OF INTER VIVOS PUBLICITY RIGHTS . 234 B. REVISITING POSTMORTEM PUBLICITY RIGHTS AND DESCENDIBILITY .................................. 237 CONCLUSION ............................................ 240 INTRODUCTION This Article challenges the conventional wisdom that the right of publicity is universally and uncontroversially alienable. Although there are different defi- nitions of alienability, I use the term in a broad sense to indicate that an entitlement is transferable in gross without any restrictions on its sale, donation, or ownership.1 Courts and scholars have routinely described the right of public- ity as such a freely transferable property right. The leading treatise author in the field, J. Thomas McCarthy, has observed that the “rule of free assignability in gross of the right of publicity has never been seriously questioned.”2 The Supreme Court of Georgia has gone even further, concluding that the right of publicity “could hardly be called a ‘right’” if it were not freely assignable.3 Thus, the right of publicity is most often described as sitting at one end of the alienability spectrum—that of free or complete alienability.4 Despite such broad claims of unfettered alienability, courts have limited the transferability of publicity rights in a variety of instances. No one has developed a robust account of why such limits should exist or what their contours should be. This Article remedies this significant omission. In the process of doing so, 1. See Terrance McConnell, The Nature and Basis of Inalienable Rights,3LAW &PHIL. 25, 27 (1984) (defining something as inalienable when it “is not transferable to the ownership of another”); Susan Rose-Ackerman, Inalienability and the Theory of Property Rights,85COLUM.L.REV. 931, 931 (1985) (“Inalienability can be defined as any restriction on the transferability, ownership, or use of an entitlement.”); see also Margaret Jane Radin, Market-Inalienability, 100 HARV.L.REV. 1849, 1849–55 (1987) (noting that there are a number of different possible meanings for “inalienability”). I include for purposes of this discussion both voluntary and involuntary transfers, although some have suggested that only prohibitions on voluntary transfers should be included in the definition of inalienability. See, e.g., Radin, supra, at 1853. 2. 2 J. THOMAS MCCARTHY,THE RIGHTS OF PUBLICITY AND PRIVACY § 10:13 (2d ed. 2011); see also RESTATEMENT (THIRD) OF UNFAIR COMPETITION § 46 cmt. g (1995) (stating that “[t]he interest in the commercial value of a person’s identity...isfreely assignable to others”). 3. Martin Luther King, Jr., Ctr. for Soc. Change, Inc. v. Am. Heritage Prods., Inc., 296 S.E.2d 697, 704 (Ga. 1982). 4. Alienability is not a simple on–off switch. Instead, it can best be thought of as a spectrum, ranging from free or complete alienability (where there are no restrictions on transfers or ownership) to partial or limited alienability (where a variety of restrictions limit alienability, such as prohibitions on sales but not on donations or gifts) to complete inalienability (where no transfers are possible). See Lee Anne Fennell, Adjusting Alienability, 122 HARV.L.REV. 1403 passim (2009) (suggesting a broad spectrum of alienability); Rose-Ackerman, supra note 1, at 935–37 & passim (providing a taxonomy of different types of restrictions on transferability, ownership, and use). ElectronicElectronic copycopy availableavailable at:at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2174646http://ssrn.com/abstract=2174646 2012]INALIENABLE RIGHT OF PUBLICITY 187 the Article presents a shift in right of publicity law from thinking about “publicity-holders” to thinking about “identity-holders.” For those less familiar with the right of publicity, it has sometimes been described as a property right in one’s personality.5 More precisely, it is a state law cause of action (either at common law or by statute) that provides damages and injunctive relief if a person or business uses another person’s name, like- ness, voice, or other indicia of identity without permission, usually for a commercial purpose (though sometimes for any purpose or advantage).6 Pub- licity rights have been justified on a variety of grounds including autonomy, dignity, natural rights, labor-reward, and unjust enrichment.7 Each of these primary justifications for the right of publicity is rooted in the rights and interests of the underlying person upon whom the right initially vests. If publicity rights are alienable, then the publicity-holder (the person who owns the right of publicity) need not be the same person as the person upon whom the publicity rights are based (the individual with whom publicity rights first vest and whose identity is the one that must be used to show a violation of those publicity rights). Accordingly, it is necessary to make a distinction between the publicity-holder and what I call the identity-holder. The identity- holder is the person whose name, likeness, or other indicia of identity is used and, when used without permission, forms the basis of a right of publicity violation. The publicity-holder, by contrast, is the person who owns the property interest in (commercial) uses of that identity.8 So, for example, the talented musician and composer Prince is an identity-holder, but if he assigns his right of publicity to his music label, let’s say Warner Brothers Records, then Warner Brothers would be the publicity-holder.9 The distinction between identity- holders and publicity-holders is a crucial one, but one that I have not seen made elsewhere. Without making such a distinction, it is impossible to describe (let alone justify) an alienable right of publicity. Alienability unquestionably serves publicity-holders, but it is less clear that it is in the best interests of identity-holders. Many scholars and courts have assumed (often implicitly) that publicity-holders’ and identity-holders’ interests are aligned, but this is not always the case.10 A number of recent and high- 5. It was in part from this proposition—that there is a property right in one’s personality—that Samuel Warren and Louis Brandeis divined the right to privacy. See Samuel D. Warren & Louis D. Brandeis, The Right to Privacy,4HARV.L.REV. 193, 205, 207, 211 (1890). 6. More than half of the states have recognized a right of publicity either at common law or by statute. See 1MCCARTHY, supra note 2, §§ 6:1, 6:3; see also Jennifer E. Rothman, Copyright Preemp- tion and the Right of Publicity, 36 U.C. DAVIS L. REV. 199, 202 n.9 (2002). 7. See discussion infra section IV.B. 8. As I will discuss, publicity rights are not universally limited to commercial
Recommended publications
  • South Park: (Des)Construção Iconoclasta Das Celebridades
    PONTIFÍCIA UNIVERSIDADE CATÓLICA DE SÃO PAULO Programa de Estudos Pós-Graduados em Comunicação e Semiótica ÉRICO FERNANDO DE OLIVEIRA South Park: (des)construção iconoclasta das celebridades São Paulo Agosto de 2012 2 PONTIFÍCIA UNIVERSIDADE CATÓLICA DE SÃO PAULO Programa de Estudos Pós-Graduados em Comunicação e Semiótica ÉRICO FERNANDO DE OLIVEIRA South Park: (des)construção iconoclasta das celebridades Dissertação de mestrado apresentada ao Programa de Estudos Pós-Graduados em Comunicação e Semiótica da PUC-SP Orientador: Prof. Dr. José Luis Aidar Prado São Paulo Agosto de 2012 3 PONTIFÍCIA UNIVERSIDADE CATÓLICA DE SÃO PAULO Programa de Estudos Pós-Graduados em Comunicação e Semiótica ÉRICO FERNANDO DE OLIVEIRA South Park: (des)construção iconoclasta das celebridades Dissertação de mestrado apresentada ao Programa de Estudos Pós-Graduados em Comunicação e Semiótica da PUC-SP Orientador: Prof. Dr. José Luis Aidar Prado Comissão examinadora: __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ São Paulo Agosto de 2012 4 AGRADECIMENTOS À CAPES, pelo financiamento parcial da pesquisa. Ao Prof. Dr. José Luis Aidar Prado pela paciência e disponibilidade. Aos meus pais, irmãos e amigos, pela compreensão diante de minhas recusas. Aos meus colegas de curso, em especial, André Campos de Carvalho, Cynthia Menezes Mello e Fabíola Corbucci, Pela amizade e inestimável incentivo. Aos professores integrantes das bancas de qualificação e defesa, pelas orientações e disponibilidade. À Celina de Campos Horvat, por todos os motivos descritos acima. Toda piada é uma pequena revolução. (George Orwell) 5 Resumo O intuito desta pesquisa é estudar a construção social contemporânea das celebridades, bem como o papel que ela exerce na civilização midiática.
    [Show full text]
  • Gruda Mpp Me Assis.Pdf
    MATEUS PRANZETTI PAUL GRUDA O DISCURSO POLITICAMENTE INCORRETO E DO ESCRACHO EM SOUTH PARK ASSIS 2011 MATEUS PRANZETTI PAUL GRUDA O DISCURSO POLITICAMENTE INCORRETO E DO ESCRACHO EM SOUTH PARK Dissertação apresentada à Faculdade de Ciências e Letras de Assis – UNESP – Universidade Estadual Paulista para a obtenção do título de Mestre em Psicologia (Área de Conhecimento: Psicologia e Sociedade) Orientador: Prof. Dr. José Sterza Justo Trabalho financiado pela CAPES ASSIS 2011 Dados Internacionais de Catalogação na Publicação (CIP) Biblioteca da F.C.L. – Assis – UNESP Gruda, Mateus Pranzetti Paul G885d O discurso politicamente incorreto e do escracho em South Park / Mateus Pranzetti Paul Gruda. Assis, 2011 127 f. : il. Dissertação de Mestrado – Faculdade de Ciências e Letras de Assis – Universidade Estadual Paulista Orientador: Prof. Dr. José Sterza Justo. 1. Humor, sátira, etc. 2. Desenho animado. 3. Psicologia social. I. Título. CDD 158.2 741.58 MATEUS PRANZETTI PAUL GRUDA O DISCURSO POLITICAMENTE INCORRETO E DO ESCRACHO EM “SOUTH PARK” Dissertação apresentada à Faculdade de Ciências e Letras de Assis – UNESP – Universidade Estadual Paulista para a obtenção do título de Mestre em Psicologia (Área de Conhecimento: Psicologia e Sociedade) Data da aprovação: 16/06/2011 COMISSÃO EXAMINADORA Presidente: PROF. DR. JOSÉ STERZA JUSTO – UNESP/Assis Membros: PROF. DR. RAFAEL SIQUEIRA DE GUIMARÃES – UNICENTRO/ Irati PROF. DR. NELSON PEDRO DA SILVA – UNESP/Assis GRUDA, M. P. P. O discurso do humor politicamente incorreto e do escracho em South Park.
    [Show full text]
  • No Terms Expired on Manning Committee
    PANORAMA: How old is your pet in dog or cat years? C1 Another side to the bacon craze Secret video shows abuse of pigs on SERVING SOUTH CAROLINA SINCE OCTOBER 15, 1894 farms, highlights common practices WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 1, 2018 $1.00 A6 City’s audit No terms expired on shows growth financially Manning committee BY ADRIENNE SARVIS [email protected] Council calls meeting to fill an expired term City of Sumter received a positive opin- ion in its audit report for fiscal year 2016- BY SHARRON HALEY The agenda for the cil meetings. 17, according to an independent auditor’s Special to The Sumter Item meeting was received Four items are listed on the agen- report from Sheheen, Hancock & Godwin by The Sumter Item at da: a welcome and introductory re- LLP. MANNING — Manning City 4:53 p.m. Tuesday, marks from Mayor Julia Nelson; The report states the city’s financial Council will hold a special called meeting the state Free- approval of the agenda; discussion statements for its $62.58 million 2016-17 meeting at 5:30 p.m. today to fill an dom of Information of the Municipal Grievance Com- budget fairly present the respective fi- expired term on the city’s Griev- Act’s requirement of mittee to replace an expired term nancial position of governmental activi- SHAFFER ance Committee, though public re- at least a 24-hour no- ending June 30, 2018; and adjourn- ties for the fiscal year that ended on June cords appear to show none of the tice before any meet- ment.
    [Show full text]
  • Dead Celebrities Are Haunting Ike - All-New 'South Park' Episodes Begin on Wednesday, October 7 at 10:00 P.M
    Dead Celebrities Are Haunting Ike - All-New 'South Park' Episodes Begin on Wednesday, October 7 at 10:00 p.m. on COMEDY CENTRAL(R) 'South Park Let's Go Defense Play!' Available for Download Exclusively on Xbox Live Arcade October 7 NEW YORK, Oct 05, 2009 -- The boys bring in professional ghost hunters to investigate evidence of paranormal activity in the Broflovski house in an all-new episode of "South Park" titled, "Dead Celebrities," premiering on Wednesday, October 7 at 10:00 p.m. on COMEDY CENTRAL. Powerful forces are tormenting Ike. He's freaked out and the stress could kill him. Kyle and the boys are doing everything they can to save him, but the poltergeists won't leave Ike alone. Launched in 1997, "South Park," now in its 13th season, remains the highest-rated series on COMEDY CENTRAL. "South Park" repeats Wednesdays at 12:00 a.m., Thursdays at 10:00 p.m. and 12:00 a.m. and Sundays at 11:00 p.m. and 2:00 a.m. Co-creators Trey Parker and Matt Stone are executive producers, along with Anne Garefino, of the Emmy® and Peabody® Award-winning "South Park." Frank C. Agnone II is the supervising producer. Eric Stough, Adrien Beard, Bruce Howell, Vernon Chatman and Erica Rivinoja are producers. "South Park's" Web site is www.southparkstudios.com. COMEDY CENTRAL, the only all-comedy network, currently is seen in more than 95 million homes nationwide. COMEDY CENTRAL is owned by, and is a registered trademark of, Comedy Partners, a wholly-owned division of Viacom Inc.'s (NYSE: VIA and VIA.B) MTV Networks.
    [Show full text]
  • 'South Park' Is Back with All New Episodes! the Iconic Series Launches Its 14Th Season on Wednesday, March 17 at 10:00 P.M
    'South Park' is Back With All New Episodes! The Iconic Series Launches Its 14th Season on Wednesday, March 17 at 10:00 p.m. on COMEDY CENTRAL(R) --"South Park" Marks Its 200th Episode On Wednesday, April 14 --"South Park: The Complete Thirteenth Season Uncensored" DVD And Blu-Ray Arrives In Stores On Tuesday, March 16 And For The First Time Ever Will Include Deleted Scenes --All-New Season 14 Episodes Available In HD Exclusively On xBox LIVE, iTunes, Sony Playstation Network, Amazon Video On Demand And New Episodes Also Available On SouthParkStudios.com NEW YORK, March 3, 2010 /PRNewswire via COMTEX/ -- Last season the boys were haunted by dead celebrities, stood up to Harley riders, took a stand against the Japanese to save the whales and Butters became a pimp. Now, the foul-mouthed fourth- graders of "South Park" return for more shenanigans! Kicking off its 14th season, "South Park," winner of the 2009 Primetime Emmy® Award, returns with seven all-new episodes beginning Wednesday, March 17 at 10:00 p.m. ET/PT on COMEDY CENTRAL. The series also reaches a milestone on Wednesday, April 14, by celebrating its 200th episode. On Tuesday, March 16, "South Park: The Complete Thirteenth Season Uncensored" DVD and Blu-Ray will be released nationwide by COMEDY CENTRAL Home Entertainment and Paramount Home Entertainment. For the first time ever, the DVD and Blu-ray will include exclusive deleted scenes and the bonus features include "Inside Xbox: A Behind-the-Scenes Tour of South Park Studios" and free codes to unlock character and challenge levels in the "South Park: Let's Go Tower Defense Play" game on xBox Live Arcade.
    [Show full text]
  • The Black Press, African American Celebrity Culture, and Critical Citizenship in Early Twentieth Century America, 1895-1935
    LOOKING AT THE STARS: THE BLACK PRESS, AFRICAN AMERICAN CELEBRITY CULTURE, AND CRITICAL CITIZENSHIP IN EARLY TWENTIETH CENTURY AMERICA, 1895-1935 A Dissertation Submitted to the Temple University Graduate Board In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY OF MEDIA AND COMMUNICATION by Carrie Teresa May 2014 Examining Committee Members: Carolyn Kitch, Advisory Chair, Media and Communication Susan Jacobson, Journalism & Mass Communication, Florida International University Andrew Mendelson, Media and Communication Linn Washington, External Member, Journalism ABSTRACT Through the development of entertainment culture, African American actors, athletes and musicians increasingly were publicly recognized. In the mainstream press, Black celebrities were often faced with the same snubs and prejudices as ordinary Black citizens, who suffered persecution under Jim Crow legislation that denied African Americans their basic civil rights. In the Black press, however, these celebrities received great attention, and as visible and popular members of the Black community they played a decisive yet often unwitting and tenuous role in representing African American identity collectively. Charles M. Payne and Adam Green use the term “critical citizenship” to describe the way in which African Americans during this period conceptualized their identities as American citizens. Though Payne and Green discussed critical citizenship in terms of activism, this project broadens the term to include considerations of community- building and race pride as well. Conceptualizing critical citizenship for the black community was an important part of the overall mission of the Black press. Black press entertainment journalism, which used celebrities as both “constellations” and companions in the fight for civil rights, emerged against the battle against Jim Crowism and came to embody the spirit of the Harlem Renaissance.
    [Show full text]
  • Sbs Viceland
    WEEK 26: Sunday, 21 June - Saturday, 27 June 2020 ALL MARKETS Start Consumer Closed Date Genre Title Episode Title Series Episode TV Guide Text Country of Origin Language Year Repeat Classification Subtitles Time Advice Captions 2020-06-21 0500 News - Overseas Korean News Korean News 0 News via satellite from YTN Korea, in Korean, no subtitles. SOUTH KOREA Korean-100 2013 NC 2020-06-21 0530 News - Overseas Indonesian News Indonesian News 0 News via satellite from TVRI Jakarta, in Indonesian, no subtitles. INDONESIA Indonesian-100 2013 NC 2020-06-21 0610 News - Overseas Hong Kong News Hong Kong News 0 News via satellite from TVB Hong Kong, in Cantonese, no subtitles. HONG KONG Cantonese-100 2013 NC 2020-06-21 0630 News - Overseas Chinese News Chinese News 0 News via satellite from CCTV Beijing, in Mandarin, no subtitles. CHINA Mandarin-100 2013 NC 2020-06-21 0700 News - Overseas Russian News Russian News 0 News via satellite from NTV Moscow, in Russian, no subtitles. RUSSIA Russian-100 2013 NC 2020-06-21 0730 News - Overseas Polish News Polish News 0 Wydarzenia from Polsat in Warsaw via satellite, in Polish, no subtitles. POLAND Polish-100 2013 NC News from Public Broadcasting Services Limited, Malta, in Maltese, no 2020-06-21 0800 News - Overseas Maltese News Maltese News 0 MALTA Maltese-100 2013 NC subtitles. News via satellite from public broadcaster MRT in Skopje, in 2020-06-21 0830 News - Overseas Macedonian News Macedonian News 0 MACEDONIA Macedonian-100 2013 NC Macedonian, no subtitles. 2020-06-21 0900 News - Overseas Croatian News Croatian News 0 News via satellite from HRT Croatia, in Croatian, no subtitles.
    [Show full text]
  • Attorney Jonathan Faber's Article
    The Promise and Perils of Commercial Partnering with a Personality By Jonathan Faber Commercial use of a person’s name, image and likeness permeates advertising, co-branded products, merchandise, reality shows and social media. Bob Dylan has a licensed whiskey line,1 and Willie Nelson, Bob Marley, Snoop Dog, and Kathy Ireland have branded CBD oils.2 Mathew McConaughey goes ice fishing in Lincoln commercials,3 and cycling legend Major Taylor was brought to life in Hennessy’s Wild Rabbit campaign.4 Social media influencers are compensated for something seemingly as innocuous as a social media post. These are examples of licensed use of a personality, but some uses of a personality occur without permission. Companies may be one social media post away from potential liability, like when Katherine Heigl filed a $10 million claim after Duane Reade reposted on Twitter a picture of Heigl walking out of one of their stores.5 Michael Jordan was awarded $8.9 million for a congratulatory advertisement by a Chicago-area grocery store.6 The COVID-19 outbreak has spawned licensed and unlicensed facemasks from Jimi Hendrix to Marilyn Monroe, thanks to the fluidity of and lack of oversight on maker marketplaces.7 Even the breakout figure of the pandemic has been memorialized via Dr. Fauci doughnuts.8 Whether a negotiated license or an unauthorized use, there is value in affiliating with notable personalities. What are the benefits? How does one go about doing so? Is there a difference between living and deceased personalities? And what’s it worth? Great questions, but answers are elusive.
    [Show full text]
  • City Budget Passes with No Tax Hike
    OPINION Treatments exist for those struggling with suicidal thoughts A7 THURSDAY, JUNE 21, 2018 | Serving South Carolina since October 15, 1894 75 cents WHAT YOUR GOVERNMENT IS DOING: SUMTER CITY COUNCIL City budget passes with no tax hike BY ADRIENNE SARVIS COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK LEASE-PURCHASE AGREEMENT WEST HAMPTON AVENUE WATER AND [email protected] GRANT ENTITLEMENT ALLOCATION FOR PUBLIC WORKS VEHICLES SEWER REPLACEMENT PROJECT AMENDMENT AND EQUIPMENT Reading: Resolution, which requires only one vote from Sumter City Council ap- Reading: Second and final Reading: Final council proved second and final What it means: CDBG entitlement funds are allocated What it means: A financial agreement not to What it means: Water and sewer lines located along reading of the city’s 2019 to the city of Sumter annually by the U.S. Department exceed $1,407,000 to purchase vehicles and Hampton Avenue, between Salem Avenue and Purdy fiscal year budget. of Housing and Urban Development to address issues equipment for the public works department, Street, will be replaced. They were installed nearly 100 Balanced at $67,218,077, unique to the community and its residents. In the city, including a street sweeper valued at $277,052.31; a years ago. Barwick Construction Co. of Sumter was this the 11th consecutive CDBG funds are used to provide housing, economic fire pumper truck valued at $426,9494.32; a front- selected as the contractor for the project after budget without a millage development opportunities and other assistance to load garbage truck valued at $261,557; a recycling submitting the lowest bid of $470,593.50.
    [Show full text]
  • Dolled up Commission Doesn’T End Park Dispute County Shoots Down City to Move a Controversial Quitclaim Deed After Confederate Monument
    A4 LOCAL NEWS DAILY! PRINT AND DIGITAL NEW or CURRENT SUBSCRIPTIONS FOR $ CALL: 386-752-1293 13 WEEKS ONLY 13 EMAIL: [email protected] ALSO SERVING LIVE OAK, SUWANNEE & HAMILTON COUNTIES (Must be paid in advance. No refunds. Expires October 2, 2020) HIGH SCHOOL FOOTBALL SWIMMING SHS hopes experience Tigers open season with leads to success Purple & Gold meet See Page 12A See Page 12A FRIDAY EDITION FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 4, 2020 | YOUR COMMUNITY NEWSPAPER SINCE 1874 | $1.00 Lake City Reporter LAKECITYREPORTER.COM CONFEDERATE MONUMENT All dolled up Commission doesn’t end park dispute County shoots down city to move a controversial quitclaim deed after Confederate monument. heated public debate. But after a heated public debate, much of which was spent relitigating the Civil By CARL MCKINNEY War, commissioners opted [email protected] to let the city sort out the The Columbia County problem on its own. Commission on Thursday By a unanimous vote, the commission voted to was asked to clear up a deny a request from the land ownership issue stem- ming from a request for the DISPUTE continued on 3A Standoff ends with arrest FILE Man faces battery around 7:25 a.m., a white Shirley Marshall talks about her doll collection with guests during a diorama at the Stephen Foster Folk charges following man walked into the police Culture Center State Park. Marshall owns more than 600 dolls, including more than 300 black dolls. domestic dispute. station lobby and told authorities White Springs native aims to turn collection into museum Staff report he was A Lake City man, who battered by his boy- By TONY BRITT when she was a child, to overcome Toys introduced the first black dolls barricaded himself in his home for roughly five hours friend at [email protected] childhood tragedy as well as her own in the popular Barbie line, Francine their resi- inspirational tool to show others the and Christie, in 1967 and 1969, after a domestic dispute, was arrested Wednesday dence.
    [Show full text]
  • Sbs Viceland Guide
    WEEK 20: Sunday, 10 May - Saturday, 16 May 2020 ALL MARKETS Start Consumer Closed Date Genre Title Episode Title Series Episode TV Guide Text Country of Origin Language Year Repeat Classification Subtitles Time Advice Captions 2020-05-10 0500 News - Overseas Korean News Korean News 0 News via satellite from YTN Korea, in Korean, no subtitles. SOUTH KOREA Korean-100 2013 NC 2020-05-10 0530 News - Overseas Indonesian News Indonesian News 0 News via satellite from TVRI Jakarta, in Indonesian, no subtitles. INDONESIA Indonesian-100 2013 NC 2020-05-10 0610 News - Overseas Hong Kong News Hong Kong News 0 News via satellite from TVB Hong Kong, in Cantonese, no subtitles. HONG KONG Cantonese-100 2013 NC 2020-05-10 0630 News - Overseas Chinese News Chinese News 0 News via satellite from CCTV Beijing, in Mandarin, no subtitles. CHINA Mandarin-100 2013 NC 2020-05-10 0700 News - Overseas Russian News Russian News 0 News via satellite from NTV Moscow, in Russian, no subtitles. RUSSIA Russian-100 2013 NC 2020-05-10 0730 News - Overseas Polish News Polish News 0 Wydarzenia from Polsat in Warsaw via satellite, in Polish, no subtitles. POLAND Polish-100 2013 NC News from Public Broadcasting Services Limited, Malta, in Maltese, no 2020-05-10 0800 News - Overseas Maltese News Maltese News 0 MALTA Maltese-100 2013 NC subtitles. News via satellite from public broadcaster MRT in Skopje, in 2020-05-10 0830 News - Overseas Macedonian News Macedonian News 0 MACEDONIA Macedonian-100 2013 NC Macedonian, no subtitles. 2020-05-10 0900 News - Overseas Croatian News Croatian News 0 News via satellite from HRT Croatia, in Croatian, no subtitles.
    [Show full text]
  • Hollywood Forever: Culture, Celebrity, and the Cemetery Linda Levitt University of South Florida
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Scholar Commons | University of South Florida Research University of South Florida Scholar Commons Graduate Theses and Dissertations Graduate School 3-28-2008 Hollywood Forever: Culture, Celebrity, and the Cemetery Linda Levitt University of South Florida Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd Part of the American Studies Commons Scholar Commons Citation Levitt, Linda, "Hollywood Forever: Culture, Celebrity, and the Cemetery" (2008). Graduate Theses and Dissertations. https://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd/360 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Graduate Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Hollywood Forever: Culture, Celebrity, and the Cemetery by Linda Levitt A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Communication College of Arts and Sciences University of South Florida Co-Major Professor: Mark A. Neumann, Ph.D. Co-Major Professor: Marcyrose Chvasta, Ph.D. Janna Jones, Ph.D. Michael LeVan, Ph.D. Louis Marcus, M.F.A. Gilbert B. Rodman, Ph.D. Date of Approval: March 28, 2008 Keywords: commemoration, fandom, cultural memory, popular culture, Cinespia, Dia de los Muertos © Copyright 2008, Linda Levitt Acknowledgements I am grateful for the extraordinary support of a group of people who helped see this dissertation to fruition. Mark Neumann has been an exceptional mentor who embraced this project with enthusiasm.
    [Show full text]