, for and

eorge Gershwin, his brother Ira, and Gershwin rose to the challenge, although Gthe songwriter “Buddy” De Sylva were not without extracting certain concessions killing time in a pool hall on January 3, 1924, from Whiteman. Given the short lead time when Ira, engrossed in the Tri- (not to mention the novelty of such a piece), bune, happened on an article announcing a full-length was out of the ques- that the bandleader — a one- tion. But he would commit to a free-form time violist with the Denver and San Francis- work, a rhapsody of some sort, that would co Symphony but now a leading spotlight him as the soloist backed by the light of popular — would shortly pres- Whiteman band, which was to be expanded ent a concert in New York that promised to for the occasion by quite a few instruments. broaden concertgoers’ conception of serious Furthermore, Gershwin was uneasy about American music. Neither Ira nor his broth- the prospect of orchestrating his piece; in er were prepared for the article’s revelation his work, he had always followed that “George Gershwin is at work on a the customary practice of simply writing concerto, is writing a syncopat- the tunes and leaving the instrumentation ed tone poem, and is working to an arranger. “No problem,” Whiteman on an American suite.” A new Gershwin jazz responded — and promptly informed Ferde concerto was news to Gershwin. A phone call to Whiteman the next day elic- ited the explanation that the bandleader had In Short been planning such a concert for some time in Born: September 26, 1898, in , the future, but a rival conductor had sudden- New York ly announced plans for a similar program of pieces drawing on both the classical and jazz Died: July 11, 1937, in , styles, a development that forced Whiteman Work composed: January 7–February 3, to move up his schedule. Whiteman also re- 1924, with (1892–1972) creating minded Gershwin that he had broached the the work’s original scoring for solo piano with idea of such a work a year and a half earlier, . In 1926 Grofé followed up with when his orchestra had unveiled Gersh- the version for solo piano and full symphony orchestra heard in this performance. win’s song I’ll Build a in George White’s Scandals of 1922. Gershwin World premiere: February 12, 1924, at Aeolian would later allow that there was at least some Hall in , with Paul Whiteman connection between the two projects, when leading his orchestra and the as soloist he wrote of the George White’s Scandals: premiere: July 25, My association with Whiteman in this 1927, Willem von Hoogstraten, conductor, with show I am sure had something to do with the composer as soloist Paul’s asking me to write a composition Most recent New York Philharmonic for his first jazz concert. As you may know, performance: July 21, 2018, at Bravo! Vail in I wrote the Rhapsody in Blue for that occa- Colorado, with Bramwell Tovey as conductor sion, and there is no doubt that this was and soloist my start in the field of more serious music. Estimated duration: ca. 17 minutes

32 | NEW YORK PHILHARMONIC Grofé, his own staff arranger since 1920, to ment in Grey and Black (popularly nicknamed clear his desk for a new project. “Whistler’s Mother”). The Gershwin brothers On January 7, Gershwin began setting took a shine to the concept and found a down his rhapsody, notated in a score for musical equivalent in the title Rhapsody two — one representing the solo part, in Blue. The word “blue” naturally evokes the other the orchestra (including certain “the ,” and, by extension, jazz. Vari- suggestions about possible instrumenta- ous aspects of jazz vocabulary certainly are tion). Grofé later recalled: prominent in the Rhapsody in Blue — this was the point of the repertoire Whiteman I practically lived in their uptown Am- programmed in his “Experiment in Modern sterdam and 100th Street apartment, for Music” — but at heart this is a symphonic I called there daily for more pages… . He work, and its ancestry lies more in the di- and his brother Ira had a back room where rection of Rachmaninoff, Tchaikovsky, and there was an upright piano, and that is Liszt than , King Oliver, where Rhapsody in Blue grew into being. and W.C. Handy.

It was Ira, the family wordsmith, who Instrumentation: two flutes, two , came up with the title, inspired by a visit to two and bass , two bas- a gallery showing an exhibit of paintings by soons, two alto and one tenor James Abbott McNeill Whistler. Whistler , three horns, three , was drawn to titling his paintings — no mat- three , , , , ter how representational — with completely , , triangle, , ban- abstract titles, such as the famous Arrange- jo, and strings, in addition to the solo piano.

Listen for . . . the Clarinet’s

The famous ascending glissando with which the clarinet launches this piece is one of the most instantly identifiable sounds in all of music. It is said to have been essentially the invention of Ross Gorman, clarinetist of the Paul Whiteman Orchestra. Gershwin had written the opening measure as a low trill followed by a scale rising rapidly through 17 notes. The tale is told that Gorman, grow- ing either exhausted or bored as the piece began yet again in the course of a long rehearsal, sim- ply elided the disparate notes into a sweeping, rather suggestive ribbon of uninterrupted pitches — after which there was no turning back to Gershwin’s original scale.

The opening notation in Gershwin’s manuscript

JANUARY 2020 | 33