Book Reviews the Jews in Canada
Book Reviews The Jews in Canada. Edited by Robert Brym, William Shaffir, and Morton Weinfeld. Toronto: Oxford UP, 1993. Pp. x, 435. Paper, $24.95. "Jewish is not Jewish .. Anyone or no one may be Jewish." Thus spake Jacques Derrida, the guru of deconstruction and master of bafflement, irony, and paradox. Derrida's slippery philosophy dismantles anti-Semitic stereotyping by reversing categories and making definitions extremely problematic: for every "Jewish" characteristic, an elusive counterlife arises to challenge any facile notions of Jewishness. Where Derrida blurs into shades of grey, social scientists demystify abstract speculation into the black-and-white clarity of charts, statistics, and polls. The sociologists in Brym, Shaffir, and Weinfeld's The Jews in Canada are no exception. At the end of his "Preface" Brym states his two analytical themes survival, and comparison with the Jewish community in the United States-and trusts that these "reflect the hopes and anxieties not just of Canadian Jewish academics" (a small audience indeed), "not just of educated Canadian Jews, but of educated Canadians in general." Having established the seriousness of his undertaking, Brym abruptly shifts gears: Editing this book was so mucb fun I am still not sure how it got finished at all, let alone on schedule. Our editorial meetings were utterly anarchic and our frequent e-rnail messages more or less beside the point. As a result, errors doubtless remain in the manuscript. The public should know, however, that that is completely the fault of the other two editors. Editors frequently celebrate the pleasures of the text, but rarely is the activity described as so much fun, and one wonders how many sociologi- 400 DALHOUSIE REVIEW cal editors subscribe to this kind of hedonism.
[Show full text]