Dissecting the Erotic: Art and Sexuality in Mid-Victorian Medical Anatomy

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Dissecting the Erotic: Art and Sexuality in Mid-Victorian Medical Anatomy DISSECTING THE EROTIC: ART AND SEXUALITY IN MID-VICTORIAN MEDICAL ANATOMY by MEREDITH MCINNIS B.A., The University of British Columbia, 2006 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS in THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES (History) THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (Vancouver) June 2008 © Meredith McInnis, 2008 ABSTRACT In the mid-nineteenth century, anatomical illustration in England underwent a crisis of representation. Moral authorities were growing increasingly concerned with the proliferation of images of the naked body and the effects they might have on public “decency.” The anatomical profession was sensitive to this hostile climate to nude representations. In the years immediately preceding the Obscene Publications Act of 1857 that defined the category of “pornography,” anatomical illustration was being purged of sexual connotations as part of an attempt to consolidate medicine as a respectable “profession.” In the eyes of this new professional body, there was no space for sexual associations in anatomical texts. Artistic medical anatomy’s rejection was driven by its links to problematic erotic traditions. Specifically, anatomy’s proximity to pseudo-medical pornography, the same- sex eroticism of the Hellenic tradition, and the problem of the male and female nude in “high art” were at issue. In representing the naked body artistically, anatomists brought their illustrations into dangerous proximity with these traditions. By systematically putting the work of one Victorian anatomist, Joseph Maclise, into dialogue with these erotic traditions, it becomes clear that medicine was not isolated from the broader sexual culture. This study demonstrates that viewing publics and viewing practices are historically specific and are brought into being by the interaction of visual phenomena by emphasizing the fluidity between representational fields of art, medicine and sexuality. The effort to excise the sexual meanings contained in anatomy ultimately led to the emergence of a new diagrammatic style of anatomical drawing that became the orthodox style of medical illustration, and that persists to this day. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract…………………………………………………………………………………....ii Table of Contents…………………………………………………………………………iii List of Figures…………………………………………………………………………….iv Acknowledgments..………………………………………………………………………vi “Dissecting the Erotic: Art and Sexuality in Mid-Victorian Medical Anatomy”….…..….1 Bibliography.…………………………………………………………………………….57 iii LIST OF FIGURES 1. The External Oblique Muscle. Anatomy, Descriptive and Surgical (“Gray’s Anatomy”)………………………………………………………...………………….14 2. Plate 10: The surgical dissection of the sterno-clavicular or tracheal region, and the relative position of its main bloodvessels, nerves, &c. Surgical Anatomy…………..15 3. Plate 65-66: The surgical dissection of the popliteal space and the posterior crural region. Surgical Anatomy……………………………………………………………15 4. Plate 64, fig. 6: Deformities of the urinary bladder-the operations of sounding for stone, of catheterism and of puncturing the bladder above the pubes. Surgical Anatomy………………………………………………………………………………...……..16 5. Plate X: External Views of the Male and Female Organs of Generation. Kalogynomia………………………………………………………………………… 21 6. Plate XVI: Suction and Collapse of the Vagina. Generative System of John Roberton……………………………………………………………………………... 23 7. Plate 8: The surgical dissection of the subclavian and carotid regions, and the relative anatomy of their contents. Surgical Anatomy………………………………………..25 8. Plate 18: The surgical dissection of the wrist and hand. Surgical Anatomy………... 25 9. Plate 7: The surgical dissection of the subclavian and carotid regions, the relative anatomy of their contents. Surgical Anatomy………………………………………..27 10. Plate 26: The relation of the internal parts to the external surface. Surgical Anatomy……………………………………………………………………………...28 11. Plate 11: The surgical dissection of the axillary and brachial regions, displaying the relative order of their contained parts. Surgical Anatomy…………………………... 29 12. Plate 49: The relative anatomy of the male pelvic organs. Surgical Anatomy……….30 13. Plate 48: The relative anatomy of the male pelvic organs. Surgical Anatomy……... 30 14. Plates 66: Surgical dissection of the popliteal space, and the posterior crural region. Surgical Anatomy…………………………………………………………………….32 15. Plate 50: The surgical dissection of the superficial structures of the male perinæum. Surgical Anatomy……………………………………………………………………. 33 iv 16. Plate 13: The surgical form of the male and female axillæ compared. Surgical Anatomy…………………………………………………………………………… 44 17. The Wrestlers. William Etty, ca. 1840………………………………………………. 49 18. Guardsman Higgins. William Etty………………...……………………………….... 50 19. Male nude. Eugènè Durieu, 1853. …………………………………………………………...… 52 20. Plate 23: The relative position of the deeper organs of the thorax and those of the abdomen. Surgical Anatomy …………………………………...……………………52 21. Plate 51: The surgical dissection of the superficial structures of the male perinæum. Surgical Anatomy………………………………………………………...53 v ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to express my gratitude to Joy Dixon for her support and her enthusiasm for this project. I would also like to thank Bill French and Maureen Ryan whose insights were instrumental. Thanks as well to Lee Perry at the Woodward Memorial Room and Christine Ruggere at the Johns Hopkins Institute for the History of Medicine. Thank you to the staff, faculty and graduate students in the Department of History at the University of British Columbia. I would also like to thank the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council for funding this project. My family has provided unwavering support, and I am appreciative to Frances for pushing my intellectual agenda. Finally, thanks to Andrew. vi Dissecting the Erotic: Art and Sexuality in Mid-Victorian Medical Anatomy In medical anatomy, the interior and exterior of the body are in dialogue. Muscles, veins and arteries, bones and organs that are veiled by the skin are exposed for viewing by the medical gaze. For the mid-nineteenth century surgeon and anatomist, Joseph Maclise (c.1815-1880), the exterior of the body was as pertinent to medical study as the interior. According to Maclise, the “unbroken surface of the human figure is as a map to the surgeon, explanatory of the anatomy arranged beneath.” As he argued in his 1851 anatomy volume Surgical Anatomy, it is impossible to understand the internal body without looking at its external “superficies.”1 At this moment in medicine when anatomical drawing was turning towards the diagrammatic and schematic, Maclise’s valuation of the artistic exterior was an interesting—and puzzling—representational choice. In choosing to represent these “superficies”—the exterior of unclothed male bodies including their faces and skin—Maclise elected to work within a representational field that was full of potential problems. Erotic traditions were associated with all of the representational modes and scripts that were available for drawing the unclothed male body; the erotic legacies of pornographic pseudo-medical texts, Hellenism and the neoclassical aesthetic, and high art nudes made Maclise’s illustrations ambiguous. The images are both erotic and non-erotic and they blur the boundaries between these categories, suggesting a representational fluidity. Representations of anatomical bodies are unstable; they are ostensibly licit, but simultaneously tremble on the edge of the illicit and erotic by virtue of their proximity to these other representational traditions. Thus, in order to protect his professional 1 Joseph Maclise, Surgical Anatomy (Philadelphia: Blanchard and Lea, 1851), viii. 1 reputation at this moment when medical practitioners were closing ranks as a professional body, Maclise needed to carefully navigate his way through this web of connections. The problem that Maclise faced—the impossibility of completely eliminating erotic interpretations because of the ubiquity of these erotic meanings in representational traditions of the human body—was created by two broader currents. Firstly, it was an issue of what had been seen and continued to linger in the public’s visual consciousness. The publication of several quasi-medical works that deliberately elided the distinction between the medical and the pornographic in the 1820s, The Kalogynomia (1821) and The Generative System of John Roberton (1824 edition), made both doctors and legislators sensitive to the potential overlap between medical texts and pornography. The idea that medicine could be used for erotic stimulation and gratification was highly problematic to these authorities. Secondly, it was an issue of who was doing the looking. The Generative System of John Roberton became controversial only after it was found in the possession of lower class prisoners which suggests the relevance of concerns over class-based viewing practices to the emerging legal definition of obscenity.2 Maclise’s images were not confined to the medical community but seemed to be part of a broader marketplace and the profession received this with unease. By marketing to an elite audience through expensive volumes, use of Latin, and restricting sales to medical students and practitioners, the orthodox medical profession resisted the popularization of anatomy and expressed its anxieties about image circulation. By systematically placing Maclise’s images in dialogue with other images from the representational traditions noted above, it is
Recommended publications
  • Hot Or Not.Pdf
    PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE Research Article If I’m Not Hot, Are You Hot or Not? Physical-Attractiveness Evaluations and Dating Preferences as a Function of One’s Own Attractiveness Leonard Lee,1 George Loewenstein,2 Dan Ariely,3 James Hong,4 and Jim Young4 1Columbia University, 2Carnegie Mellon University, 3Duke University, and 4HOTorNOT.com, San Francisco, California ABSTRACT—Prior research has established that people’s Such attractiveness matching can potentially be explained own physical attractiveness affects their selection of by various theories, including evolutionary theories, which posit romantic partners. This article provides further support that assortative mating maximizes gene replication and in- for this effect and also examines a different, yet related, creases fitness (Thiessen & Gregg, 1980); equity theory, which question: When less attractive people accept less attractive proposes that a relationship built on attribute matching could dates, do they persuade themselves that the people they be perceived to be more equitable and satisfactory than a choose to date are more physically attractive than others relationship that involves a mismatch of personal attributes perceive them to be? Our analysis of data from the pop- (Walster, Walster, & Berscheid, 1978); market theories, which ular Web site HOTorNOT.com suggests that this is not the indicate that attractive people seek one another as mates, case: Less attractive people do not delude themselves into leaving the less attractive people to choose among themselves thinking that their dates are more physically attractive (Hitsch, Hortacsu, & Ariely, 2006; Kalick & Hamilton, 1986); than others perceive them to be. Furthermore, the results and parental-image theories, which claim that people are at- also show that males, compared with females, are less tracted to others who resemble their parents and thus indirectly affected by their own attractiveness when choosing whom themselves (Epstein & Guttman, 1984).
    [Show full text]
  • Judith Bernstein, Trailblazer in Erotic Art an Interview with the Feminist Visionary About Her Art and Its Current Revival
    805 Traction Avenue Los Angeles CA 90013 213.625.1747 www.theboxla.com Judith Bernstein, Trailblazer in Erotic Art An interview with the feminist visionary about her art and its current revival. BY HAZEL CILLS | JAN 20, 2016 (ELENA POLSON AND STEFANIE APPLE) As one of the founders of New York City's A.I.R. Gallery, the first-ever all-female art gallery in the United States, artist Judith Bernstein had a career that seemed to be on the rise in the early 1970s. The Newark-born, Yale-educated artist made bold, erotic large-scale charcoal drawings of phalluses that stood apart from the clean, conceptual minimalist works that populated galleries at the time. But when one of these pieces, a scratchy, mural-size illustration of a screw-shaped phallus titled Horizontal, was censored from the 1974 show "Women's Work" in Philadelphia, Bernstein had trouble getting her graphic art into galleries. 805 Traction Avenue Los Angeles CA 90013 213.625.1747 www.theboxla.com It wasn't until decades later, in 2008, that gallerist Mitchell Algus gave Bernstein a solo show in New York and Paul McCarthy fell in love with her work and exhibited her at his West Coast gallery the Box. Suddenly, Bernstein's long-underrated art was being given positive reviews at contemporary galleries, and from there, her textured penises, anti-war paintings, and vaginal icons made their way into the collections of the Whitney, MoMA, and the Jewish Museum, among others. Today, the art world is just beginning to recognize Bernstein as a trailblazer in erotic art, and her work that was once relegated to storage has a newfound audience.
    [Show full text]
  • Inserting Hans Bellmer's the Doll Into the History of Pornography
    Claremont Colleges Scholarship @ Claremont Scripps Senior Theses Scripps Student Scholarship 2020 Softcore Surrealism: Inserting Hans Bellmer's The Doll into the History of Pornography Alexandra M. Varga Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.claremont.edu/scripps_theses Recommended Citation Varga, Alexandra M., "Softcore Surrealism: Inserting Hans Bellmer's The Doll into the History of Pornography" (2020). Scripps Senior Theses. 1566. https://scholarship.claremont.edu/scripps_theses/1566 This Open Access Senior Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Scripps Student Scholarship at Scholarship @ Claremont. It has been accepted for inclusion in Scripps Senior Theses by an authorized administrator of Scholarship @ Claremont. For more information, please contact [email protected]. 1 SOFTCORE SURREALISM: INSERTING HANS BELLMER’S THE DOLL INTO THE HISTORY OF PORNOGRAPHY, 2020 By ALEXANDRA M. VARGA SUBMITTED TO SCRIPPS COLLEGE IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE DEGREE OF BACHELOR ARTS FIRST READER: PROFESSOR MACNAUGHTON, SCRIPPS COLLEGE SECOND READER: PROFESSOR NAKAUE, SCRIPPS COLLEGE MAY 4TH 2020 2 Contents Acknowledgments. 3 Introduction: Finding The Doll. 4 Critical Reception: Who Has Explored The Doll?. 10 Chapter 1: Construction of the Doll and Creation of the Book. 22 Chapter 2: Publication in Germany and France. 37 Conclusion: Too Real For Comfort. 51 Bibliography. 53 Figures: Die Puppe Sequence, 1934. 56 Figures: La Poupée Sequence, 1936. 64 Figures: 19th and 20th Century Pornography. 71 3 Acknowledgments This thesis could not have been written without the support of my thesis readers, Professors Mary MacNaughton and Melanie Nakaue. I would like to thank them for their unwavering support. Their guidance gave me the confidence to pursue such an eccentric topic.
    [Show full text]
  • The Allure and Magic of Renée Jacobs by Prof
    the allure and magic of renée jacobs by Prof. John Wood (From the introduction to PARIS) This is a book about Paris, about passion, into our lives the most essential creative mo- one of women as free spirit—as free as any and about pleasure. …Erotic art, like any ments in the lives of artists, such as Renée man. When I look at Jacobs’ images, I see other visual art, is only good if it pulls us Jacobs, and the lives of her models, as well. something universal: Everywoman—or at back again and again to gaze, to wonder, least the potential of every woman. In her and to consider. Its power is the same as Jacobs, of course, shapes the aesthetic di- work we see the quintessence of style, im- that of great music which demands we lis- mension of her photographs, but part of her ages that could have served as models for ten again and again, no matter how many work’s gift to the viewer is also shaped by that great painter Tamara de Lempicka, times we already have, or great poetry her models’ creative partnership with her. who captured “the woman” like no other whose melodies and metaphors make us Erotic art is clearly the most generous of the painter of the 20th Century. Jacobs pres- read, reread, and then read again. The visual arts. Artist and model jointly agree ents formal elegance, desire, and beauty mark of great art is that it is forever fresh to create and share with others a moment all coupled within the allure of sexual and forever rewarding.
    [Show full text]
  • Erotic Ambiguities : the Female Nude in Art / 30111 Helen Mcdonald
    1111 2 3 4 5111 EROTIC AMBIGUITIES 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 Art is always ambiguous. When it involves the female body it can also be erotic. 4 Erotic Ambiguities is a study of how contemporary women artists have recon- 5 ceptualised the figure of the female nude. Helen McDonald shows how, over 6 the past thirty years, artists have employed the idea of ambiguity to dismantle 7 the exclusive, classical ideal enshrined in the figure of the nude, and how they 8 have broadened the scope of the ideal to include differences of race, ethnicity, 9 sexuality and disability as well as gender. 20111 McDonald discusses the work of a wide range of women artists, including 1 Barbara Kruger, Judy Chicago, Mary Duffy, Zoe Leonard, Tracey Moffatt, Pat 2 Brassington and Sally Smart. She traces the shift in feminist art practices from 3 the early challenge to patriarchal representations of the female nude to contem- 4 porary, ‘postfeminist’ practices, influenced by theories of performativity, queer 5 theory and postcoloniality. McDonald argues that feminist efforts to develop 6 a more positive representation of the female body need to be reconsidered, 7 in the face of the resistant ambiguities and hybrid complexities of visual art in 8 the late 1990s. 9 30111 Helen McDonald is an Honorary Fellow in the School of Fine Arts, Classical 1 Studies and Archaeology at the University of Melbourne. 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111 i RUNNING HEAD 1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111 ii RUNNING HEAD
    [Show full text]
  • Art and Obscenity
    STEFAN MORAWSKI Art and Obscenity i no, can obscenity arise in art and, if so, what place does it occupy in the artistic IN EXPLORING the relationship between structure as a whole? These questions are of art and obscenity it is easy to stray into a a structural nature, but to answer them we whole labyrinth of disconnected issues. The must also investigate the genesis and func- problem lends itself to examination from tion of the views which maintain there is a variety of viewpoints: the purely analy- such a thing as pornography, a designa- tic, the purely pragmatic (the moral, tion, be it noted, often applied to objects religious, or political angle, for example), which do not, from the aesthetic point of or a combination of the two when it is view, admit of qualification as obscene. hoped that theoretical inquiry will yield Our first task, then, must be to clarify the guidance for a working strategy. Here I two key concepts used in the title of this have chosen for the path of analysis, but essay, which, according to some, may be even this is far from being clear-cut since complementary and, according to others, there are a number of avenues to choose are mutually exclusive. Obscenity and from: sociology (or, in broader terms, pornography, let me add, are used here as culturology), psychology, ethics, aesthetics. synonymous terms. Though obscenity us- Finally, this field can be observed from a ually is understood in a larger sense, com- wider perspective, not so much scientific prising also description of acts which do in the strict sense as philosophical.
    [Show full text]
  • Karin Bruns All by Myself Technologies of the Self in Porn
    Vorträge im Rahmen der Tagung Medienamateure: Wie verändern Laien unsere visuelle Kultur? Internationale und interdisziplinäre Tagung der Universität Siegen Prof. Dr. Susanne Regener, 5.-7. Juni 2008 Alle Rechte liegen bei den Autorinnen und Autoren. Bei Verwendung bitte folgenden Quellennachweis angeben: „Vortrag im Rahmen der Tagung ›Medienamateure. Wie verändern Laien unsere visuelle Kultur?‹“ Universität Siegen 5.-7.6.2008, in: www.medienamateure.de Karin Bruns All by Myself Technologies of the Self in Porn Blogs and Web Forums In the pop song “All by Myself”, the American singer Eartha Kitt describes the pleasure felt in self-withdrawal as well as the dangers it brings.1 Since the song was first released in 1976 by Eric Carmen, it stands as a symbol for the ambivalent feelings arising from being famous, being a star, and loneliness.2 Again and again, Eartha Kitt sung “All by Myself”, adding variations and including passages with a seemingly very personal touch. The last time was in a New York revue theater, shortly before her seventieth birthday in 2008. The confession manifest in the lyrics of this version of the song and the related self-publishing of a star suffering under the pressure of publicity refer to the marginalized position of a female afro-American artist. The 1982 documentary film “All by Myself” (USA/D, director: Christian Blackwood) follows this interpretation. The refrain “I wanna be all by myself” is staged over and over again, and the film, just like at the close of the song, reverses it at the end (“don't wanna be all by myself anymore”).
    [Show full text]
  • Writing the Naked Body: Sex and Nudity in Nuala Ní Chonchuír's Nude
    Estudios Irlandeses, Number 11, 2016, pp. 1-11 __________________________________________________________________________________________ AEDEI Writing the Naked Body: Sex and Nudity in Nuala Ní Chonchuír’s Nude Máximo Aláez Corral University of Oviedo, Spain Copyright (c) 2016 by Máximo Aláez Corral. This text may be archived and redistributed both in electronic form and in hard copy, provided that the author and journal are properly cited and no fee is charged for access. Abstract. This essay looks into the deconstruction of the male gaze and the objectification process around the concepts of nudity and nakedness. Starting from the review of some of Martha Nussbaum’s, John Berger’s, or Laura Mulvey’s main ideas on the topic of the gaze and objectification, a practical analysis of some of the short stories contained in Nuala Ní Chonchúir’s Nude (2009) is provided. By so doing, I intend to examine the ways in which conventional objectification phenomena can be turned upside down, challenged or parodied in order to reveal cultural discriminatory undercurrents and offer a new non-objectifying visual and written representation of the naked body. Key Words. Ní Chonchúir, Objectification, Male Gaze, Nude, Naked Body, Feminism. Resumen. Este ensayo analiza la deconstrucción de la mirada masculina y el proceso de reificación en torno al concepto de desnudez en toda su extensión. Tras plantear un breve repaso de algunas de las ideas planteadas por Martha Nussbaum, John Berger o Laura Mulvey acerca tanto de la mirada como de la reificación del cuerpo, realizo un análisis práctico de algunos de los relatos contenidos en Nude (2009), de la autora irlandesa Nuala Ní Chonchúir.
    [Show full text]
  • John Boyle, Greg Curnoe and Joyce Wieland: Erotic Art and English Canadian Nationalism
    John Boyle, Greg Curnoe and Joyce Wieland: Erotic Art and English Canadian Nationalism by Matthew Purvis A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Cultural Mediations Carleton University Ottawa, Ontario © 2020, Matthew Purvis i Abstract This dissertation concerns the relation between eroticism and nationalism in the work of a set of English Canadian artists in the mid-1960s-70s, namely John Boyle, Greg Curnoe, and Joyce Wieland. It contends that within their bodies of work there are ways of imagining nationalism and eroticism that are often formally or conceptually interrelated, either by strategy or figuration, and at times indistinguishable. This was evident in the content of their work, in the models that they established for interpreting it and present in more and less overt forms in some of the ways of imagining an English Canadian nationalism that surrounded them. The dissertation contextualizes the three artists in the terms of erotic art prevalent in the twentieth century and makes a case for them as part of a uniquely Canadian mode of decadence. Constructing my case largely from the published and unpublished writing of the three subjects and how these played against their reception, I have attempted to elaborate their artistic models and processes, as well as their understandings of eroticism and nationalism, situating them within the discourses on English Canadian nationalism and its potentially morbid prospects. Rather than treating this as a primarily cultural or socio-political issue, it is treated as both an epistemic and formal one.
    [Show full text]
  • Amber Spa Cosmetic Classic Energetic
    Amber Spa Cosmetic Classic Energetic english edition Philosophy Amber Spa Karawanserai healing oils For us, using of Your safe haven in the mountains to recover in a safe natural active ingredients is a way of expressing atmosphere. That is what the amber stands for – its honesty and individuality. That is one reason original effect as a healing stone and a place in our why we make our oils together with our regional Alpen-Karawanserai. Arrive at your sheltered room, pharmacies in order to save resources. Our full of warmth and hospitality, in a secure refuge recipes are based on natural aromas such as that is the perfect place to recharge your batteries, almond oil, frankincense and cardamom oil and gather your strength and find your bearings. we don‘t use any synthetic additives. To recharge with positive energy, we use healing stones such We will accompany you all throughout your as rock crystal, rose quartz or amber. journey. Experience circumspect attention and a Depending on the composition, our healing oil few relaxing moments of withdrawal here at the treatments can be invigorating or relaxing, and Amber Spa. give you a feeling of nurturing or fill you with new energy. Our Amber Spa symbols are your companions and should help you find your bearings in choo- Babor for the highest demands and sustainably sing your treatment. for healthy skin. We use the finest, natural ingredients from the Alps to give you luxury skin care that is both highly effective and gentle. P Finding peace Reviderm Microdermabrasion was originally R Recharging your batteries developed for the medical sector.
    [Show full text]
  • The Nude Figure in Renaissance Art Thomas Martin
    19 The Nude Figure in Renaissance Art Thomas Martin The establishment of the nude as an independent and vital subject in post-antique western art occurred during the Renaissance and is, along with the use of perspective, one of the most important markers differentiating Renaissance art from medieval art. One factor driving these innovations was the desire to portray a world that conforms to visual reality, where objects decrease in size as they move away from the picture plane, and where human anatomy is rigorously understood. Just as Renaissance artists employed perspective to portray naturalistic spaces, so they also populated those spaces with proportional, anatomically accurate figures and, during the course of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, the occasions when those figures were depicted nude occurred more and more frequently. Naturalism, however, was but one motive for the increased use of the nude, and by the first half of the 1500s, the naked body had achieved a wider and more varied presence in art than had been the case in the Middle Ages or even in antiquity where, with few exceptions, its use was confined to male athletes, heroes, and divinities. This essay will focus on two issues: where is the nude used – i.e., what are its locations – and what are the meanings of its uses? As it is today, the body in the Renaissance was multivalent. European Christian society believed that as a cause of lust and sin, the body was fearful and needed to be covered up. Yet at the same time it was the form the Savior, Jesus Christ, took during his lifetime, and the Catholic Church taught that it is in our very own earthly bodies that, after the last trumpet, we will spend eternity either in bliss in Heaven or in despair in Hell.
    [Show full text]
  • Medieval Erotic Art and Its Audiences
    “Was It Good For You, Too?” Medieval Erotic Art and Its Audiences Martha Easton One challenge of analyzing visual imagery using language is that the cultural filter of language itself inevitably nuances and reinterprets our initial nonverbal experience: applying words to images, we contextualize them, giving them shape, history, and meaning. Especially when the images in question have sexual content, the words selected to describe them can affect the way they are perceived: the same visual material might be deemed suggestive, titillating, erotic, pornographic, or obscene – and each word choice connotes, and at times perhaps promotes, a world of cultural and even physical response. There is really no word that is completely neutral to describe this imagery – even the word “sexual” itself suggests associations that may or may not be accurate. When I selected my title for this article and for the conference paper from which it was derived, I was deliberately attempting to entice, and yes, titillate, my potential audience. My use of the word “erotic” to describe these images is also deliberate, as I am attempting to avoid what I see as the relativistic moral and judgmental potentialities of words such as ‘obscene’ and ‘pornographic,’ even as I acknowledge that the choice of ‘erotic’ has its own connotations of intentional sexual stimulation. This leads me to my larger point -- when we give meaning to images using words, exactly whose meaning is privileged? And further, when we allow images no words at all, what happens to them? Because of the traditional tendency of historians of medieval art to focus on religious imagery and monuments, secular objects become marginalized and secondary; in the case of the erotic images found in medieval art, they disappear, do not become part of the canon, and become all but eliminated from serious scholarship.
    [Show full text]