Marco Polo — a Mission to Return a Sample from a Near-Earth Object – Science Requirements and Operational Scenarios
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Trans. JSASS Aerospace Tech. Japan Vol. 8, No. ists27, pp. Tk_13-Tk_21, 2010 Topics Marco Polo — A Mission to Return a Sample from a Near-Earth Object – Science Requirements and Operational Scenarios 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) By Detlef KOSCHNY , Antonella BARUCCI , Makoto YOSHIKAWA , Hermann BÖHNHARDT , John BRUCATO , Marcello 6) 7) 8) 8) 9) 3) 10) CORADINI , Elisabetta DOTTO , Ian FRANCHI , Simon F. GREEN , Jean-Luc JOSSET , Junichiro KAWAGUCHI , Patrick MICHEL , 11) 12) 3) 13) 1) 1) Karri MUINONEN , Jürgen OBERST , Hajime YANO , Richard BINZEL , David AGNOLON and Jens ROMSTEDT 1)European Space Agency/ESTEC, Noordwijk, The Netherlands 2)LESIA, Paris Observatory, Paris, France 3)JSPEC/ JAXA, Tokyo, Japan 4)Max-Planck-Institute for Solar System Research, Katlenburg-Lindau, Germany 5)INAF-OAA, Florence, Italy 6)European Space Agency/HQ, Paris, France 7)INAF-OAR, Rome, Italy 8)The Open University, Milton Keynes, United Kingdom 9)Space Exploration Institute, Neuchâtel, Switzerland 10)Univ. Nice Sophia-Antipolis, Obs. de la Côte d’Azur, Nice, France 11)Univ. Helsinki Observatory, Helsinki, Finland 12)Institute for Planetary Sciences, DLR Berlin, Germany 13)Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, U.S.A. (Received August 18th, 2009) Marco Polo is a mission to return a sample from a near-Earth object of primitive type (class C or D). It is foreseen as a collaborative effort between the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) and the European Space Agency (ESA). Marco Polo is currently in a Phase-A study (status as of summer 2009). This paper focuses on the scientific requirements provided to the industrial study consortia in Europe as well as the possible mission scenario at the target object in order to achieve the overall mission science objectives. The main scientific reasons for going to a near-Earth object are to understand the initial conditions and evolution history of the solar nebula, to understand how major events (e.g. agglomeration, heating) influence the history of planetesimals, whether primitive class objects contain presolar material, what the organics were in primitive materials, how organics could shed light on the origin of molecules necessary for life, and what the role of impacts by NEOs would be in the origin and evolution of life on Earth. Key Words: Marco Polo, Asteroid Sample Return, Science Goals, Mission Design 1. Introduction 2. Science Objectives In response to a call for mission proposals as part of the Near-Earth objects (NEOs) are part of the small body European Space Agency’s (ESA) Cosmic Vision Programme, population in the solar system, which are leftover building soliciting ideas for scientific space missions with a possible blocks of the solar system formation process. They offer launch date in the time frame 2015-2025, a team of more than important clues to the chemical mixture from which planets 400 scientists led by A. Barucci and M. Yoshikawa proposed formed about 4.6 billion years ago. Studying samples from a a mission to return a sample from a near-Earth object of NEO will be an excellent opportunity to study the formation primitive type (spectral class C or D) to the Earth 1). This and the evolution of the solar system, and the potential would allow the detailed analysis of this sample in contribution of NEOs to the formation of life. ground-based laboratories, which are more capable than any The main objective of the mission is: space instrument. In the baseline proposal, this would be a collaboration between the Japanese Aerospace Exploration To return a sample from a near-Earth object belonging to a Agency JAXA and ESA. primitive class to the Earth. The following paper summarizes the science and mission objectives of Marco Polo. It focuses on the scientific This will allow the study of the formation of the solar requirements provided to the European industrial study system and the planets, characterisation of a near-Earth object consortia, and the mission scenarios at the target object, which as a representative of a primitive solar system body, and are required to achieve the overall mission science contribute to the field of astrobiology. In addition, scientific requirements. The results of an internal ESA study, which was information shall be collected to provide the context of the performed in spring 2008, and the advantages of a sample. collaborative mission between JAXA and ESA are described. The detailed scientific objectives are: Copyright© 2010 by the Japan Society for Aeronautical and Space Sciences and ISTS. All rights reserved. Tk_13 Trans. JSASS Aerospace Tech. Japan Vol. 8, No. ists27 (2010) (a) What were the initial conditions and evolution history of Table 1. Resolution requirements for global characterization, local the solar nebula? characterization, and context measurements. (b) Which were the properties of the building blocks of the terrestrial planets? Spatial Spatial Spatial (c) How did major events (e.g. agglomeration, heating) resolution resolution for resolution influence the history of planetesimals? for imaging VIS/IR for mid-IR in the visual spectrometer instrument (d) Do primitive class objects contain presolar material yet unknown in meteoritic samples? Global Order of dm Order of m Order of 10 m (e) What are the organics in primitive materials? characterisation (f) How can organics in NEOs shed light on the origin of Local Order of mm Order of dm Order of dm molecules necessary for life? characterisation (g) What is the role of impacts by NEOs in the origin and evolution of life on Earth? Context 100 μm - - measurements All of these objectives are explained in more detail in the proposal which was sent to the European Space Agency by a common European and Japanese proposal team1). 4.1. Requirements related to target selection The main scientific goal is to return a sample from a NEO 3. Mission Objectives of primitive type. This constrains the taxonomic class of the target. We thus require the target to be a NEO of type C or D 3) In addition to the science objectives as given above, the according to the Tholen taxonomy . Subtypes of these as well technical studies were driven by the following prioritized as B or T are acceptable, as all of these types are expected to mission objectives: consist of primitive material. i. To enable the safe operation and maneuvering of the There is no strong scientific requirement for a minimum spacecraft in close proximity to the NEO and safe target size. However, the target should be of a size such that: collection of the sample. i) it has sufficient gravity to allow the determination of ii. To place the sample in its global and local context. the gravity field to an accuracy good enough to iii. To provide complementary science results not achievable provide some constraint to the internal structure (e.g. from the sample itself. determine the J2 coefficient to 10 %). ii) it is bright enough for fundamental properties (size, 4. Detailed Science Requirements shape, albedo, rotation) to be estimated from ground-based observations. The so-called Science Requirements Document2) derives As no precise numbers can currently be given for the above science requirements as studied by the ESA Science Study points, for the purpose of this study a minimum absolute Team from the scientific objectives. These requirements are visual magnitude of H ≤ 21 mag shall be assumed, the formal top-level requirements for the study contractors in corresponding to a diameter D ≥ 340 m for a representative European industry and the science community and define in primitive body assuming a visual geometric albedo of 0.06. detail what the scientific accomplishments of the space To properly perform mission planning, it is important that mission shall be. The following sub-sections will give a asteroid size and shape are known at least roughly. Also, its top-level summary of these science requirements. Note that at rotation period must be known. If it rotates too fast, it will be the current phase of the study, the science requirements for the difficult to approach one particular point on the NEO and ground-based analyses of the sample are not yet given in complete the sampling activity without coming onto the night detail, the focus lies on the science requirements of the space side of the object. Additionally, very fast rotators may have segment. ejected away all their loose regolith and consist of competent We first summarize requirements for target selection and rock surface only. Thus, fast rotators should be avoided and the size and properties of the returned sample. After that, the we require a minimum rotation period of ~2.5 hours. required characterization of the target needed to place the On the upper end of the rotation period, there again is no sample in its global and local context is described. There, strong scientific requirement. However, as was shown in the three phases are distinguished: internal ESA study, the longer the rotation period, the longer it • Global characterization’ means to measure the properties will take to map the complete asteroid from orbit. We thus of the whole NEO, on a global scale; require that the rotation period should not exceed 5 days. • ‘Local characterization’ is the characterization of up to 5 4.2. Sample requirements dedicated areas which are identified as potential sampling 4.2.1. Sample mass sites; Certain analysis techniques envisaged for the analysis of • ‘Sample context’ are measurements being performed at NEO material, like transmission and reflection spectroscopy the actual sampling site. or fluorescence analyses can already be done with a few milligrams of sample mass. However, for dating or rare Table 1 gives an overview of the required orders of isotope analyses, tens to hundreds of milligrams of a specific measurement resolution for the different scenarios.