Great Basin Naturalist

Volume 48 Number 1 Article 4

1-31-1988

Migrating Mormon crickets, Anabrus simplex (: ), as food for stream fishes

Harold M. Tyus U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Vernal, Utah

W. L. Minckley Arizona State University, Tempe

Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/gbn

Recommended Citation Tyus, Harold M. and Minckley, W. L. (1988) "Migrating Mormon crickets, Anabrus simplex (Orthoptera: Tettigoniidae), as food for stream fishes," Great Basin Naturalist: Vol. 48 : No. 1 , Article 4. Available at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/gbn/vol48/iss1/4

This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Western North American Naturalist Publications at BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in Great Basin Naturalist by an authorized editor of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. MIGRATING MORMON GRICKETS, ANABRUS SIMPLEX (ORTHOPTERA: TETTIGONIIDAE), AS FOOD FOR STREAM FISHES

Harold M. Tyus' and W. L. Minckley"

Abstract —Migrating hands oi Mormon crickets (Anahni.s simplex) were oI)served crossing the Green and Yampa rivers in Dinosaur National Monument, Colorado and Utah, in 1986 and 1987. Swimming crickets were swept downstream and eaten by loin- endemic and seven introduced fish species. Included were two endangered fishes,

Colorado squawfish {Ptycliochcilus luciiis ) and humpback chub (Gila cyplia ). Direct and indirect effects to aquatic food webs associated with application ol pesticides for Mormon control may pose a threat to these fishes and to man.

The {Anahrus simplex controversy concerns Park Service policy to Haldeman) occurs only in western North treat crickets with natural controls, if needed

America where it is generally regarded as an (National Park Service 1986), since aerial agricultural pest (Wakeland 1959). This spraying could adversely affect endangered flightless, long-horned grasshopper is primar- species in DNM. The objectives of this study ily solitary in low-density subpopulations but are to evaluate fish predation on Mormon becomes gregarious and migratory with high crickets in DNM, discuss possible signifi- densities, moving from its mountain breeding cance to fishes of a periodic, massive, and areas to plague croplands (Gapinera and seasonal food supply, and comment on possi- MacVean 1987). Earliest records oi this ble impacts of cricket controls on fishes, date to Mormon pioneers in the Salt Lake acjuatic communities, and man. Valley in 1847 and to the legendary cricket plague of 1848 (Bancroft 1889, Whitney 1892). Methods Although most reports stress the detrimen- The availability of Mormon crickets in tal effects of Mormon cricket outbreaks. Mor- streams and predation on them by fishes were mon crickets potentially provide an abundant evaluated by visual observations, use of crick- and high-quality food source (Defoliart et al. ets as bait, and direct inspection of stomachs 1982). Predation by terrestrial in- of nonnative species taken by angling, tram- cludes about 50 species of birds, mammals, mel nets, and electrofishing. Angling in- and reptiles; however, references to preda- cluded bottom-fishing with weighted hooks tion by aquatic animals are few (Wakeland and surface-fishing with floats. Mormon crick- 1959). Mormon crickets swim readily (LaRiv- ets were hooked through the thorax and abdo- ers 1956), as do other Orthoptera, and refer- men. Weekly trips through the Green and ence to their movements into Utah streams Yampa rivers in 1986 and 1987 (May through and lakes dates to 1848 (Bancroft 1889). Swim- July) included the season when crickets were ming crickets would be exposed to aquatic present. predators during migrations, but we found no Average weights of late instar and adult reference to predation on this species by Mormon crickets were obtained in 1987 by fishes. weighing 20-50 individuals from several large Annual Mormon cricket outbreaks and mi- bands. All crickets in a 5-30-m section of road grations in Dinosaur National Monument were collected and weighed on a 1,000 x 2-g

(DNM), Golorado and Utah (Fig. 1), have re- platform scale. Grickets were placed in previ- newed an old controversy about control of ously tared plastic bags, and subsamples were crickets by aerial spraying of pesticides (Gap- separated by sex. Gricket bands were located inera and MacVean 1987), U.S. Fish and on Harpers Gorner Road in DNM from 19 Wildlife Service 1986, 1987). A part of this July to 14 August 1987.

'us. Fish and Wildlife Sen ice, 1680 West Hwv 40, Kooin 1210. Vernal, Utah 84078. "Department of Zoology. Arizona State University. Tempe, Arizona 85287.

25 26 Great Basin Naturalist Vol. 48, No. 1

WYOMING

Yampa y River

Dinosaur National Monument

Duchesne River White ^\ River UTAH COLORADO

'^^' ^^^

.^^ \o' 4^ ^0

40 80 km

V\%. 1. Map ol iipiKT (Colorado and Cr-cii lixcr basins, (^jloiado and I'lali

Results unicjue and substantial oruanic input to the (wren and Vampa rixcrs in DNM in 1986 and Migratory Mormon erickets formed a 1987. Voun

Table 1. Numbers of fish captured usiug Mormon cricket, Analinis simplex, as bait or fish whose stomachs contained crickets. All fish were captured in DNM 1986-1987 ([ — ] indicates no records kept). 28 Great Basin Naturalist Vol. 48, No. 1

upstream of the confluence (13-km reach), food might enhance fish reproductive success, and none of 25 individuals of the same three postreproductive recovery, or both. species collected there had consumed crick- We do not advocate that native fishes time ets. reproductive behavior to cricket input. How- ever, a demonstrable relationship between Discussion nutrition and reproductixe success in these fishes would be of interest, and long-lived Mormon Crickets and Stream Ecology fishes could incorporate such unpredictable The movements of large bands of Mormon major outbreaks to advantage in life-history crickets into the Green and Yampa rivers in strategies (Smith 1981, Tyus 1986). Longevi- DNM in 1986 and 1987 provided a substantial ties of endemic Colorado River fishes studied and high-quality organic input to this system. to date indicate long life is an exceptional This must have been the case in other years of attribute of this fauna. Bonytail chub (Gila major outbreaks, such as from 1980 to 1987 in elegans) older than 40 years have been re- DNM (Gapineraand MacVean 1987, National ported, razorback sucker (Xyrauclien tex- Park Service 1986). Mormon cricket availabil- aniis) commonly reach 30 to 40 years, and ity may be important to the ecology of both Colorado sciuawfish that formerly achieved native and nonnative fishes. This is especially 1.8 m in length must have lived even longer true in DNM, which contains the only known (McCarth)' and Minckley 1987, Rinne et al. spawning site for the endangered humpback 1986). Periodic outbreaks of Mormon crickets chub in the Green River Basin, and one of the could contribute significantly to nutrition, di- two confirmed spawning sites for the endan- rectly or indirectly, tor a number of consecu- gered Colorado squawfish (Tyus et al. 1987). tive or disjunct years during such a long pe- Various investigators have studied Green riod of life. River fishes (Holden and Stalnaker 1975, High Hows and seasonal flooding in the

Miller 1964, Miller et al. 1982, Vanicek and mainstream Green River are now reduced by Kramer 1969) with emphasis on rare, native dams (Joseph et al. 1977). This alters or pre- species listed or considered for listing as cludes floodplain inundation and removes threatened or endangered (U.S. Department particulate organics through reservoir entrap- of the Interior 1985). The fauna also includes ment (e.g., Minckley and Rinne 1986). numerous nonnative fishes introduced for Flooded lowlands were formerly expansive sport, forage, food, or by accident (Tyus et al. during sustained high flows, which often ex- 1982). Food habits of native fishes are gener- ceeded mean discharge (181 m'Vsecond, based ally known (Vanicek and Kramer 1969, Jacobi on an 86-year record at Jensen, Utah) b\' more and Jacobi 1982), but their seasonal use of than an order of magnitude during snowmelt

terrestrial animals is not. Foods of nonnative (Remilliard et al. 1986). Floodplain connnuni- species are described for other rivers (e.g., ties were thus made available to predation by Carlander 1977), but few data exist in DNM. riverine fishes, as observed elsewhere Mormon cricket movements into rivers in (Welcomme 1979). In the Green River, Colo- DNM in spring provide food for stream fishes. rado scjuawfish and ra/orback sucker have This is a time when flooding, scouring, and been radiotracked to flooded lowlands, where annual insect emergence reduce food they presumably feed (Tyus 1987, Tyus et al. availability. High-water turbidity presumably 1987). Flood reduction and loss of al- reduces visual feeding efficiency of predatory lochthonous inputs ma>' make seasonal inputs fishes, yet large nmnbers of crickets at or near of terrestrial animals, including Mormon the water surface are vulneral)le to a((uatic crickets, more important now than histori- predators. Cricket availability c()incid(\s with cally. prereproductive periods lor some native spe- Mormon Cricket Control cies, including roimdtail and humpback chubs, flaimelmouth sucker, and Colorado In their natural grassland or sagebrush- s(|uawfish. As reported by Defoliart et al. dominated habitats. Mormon crickets prefer (1982), adult Mormon crickets have a mean lo irvd on succulent, herbaceous vegetation. crude protein content of 58% and a iat content Damage to range grasses is considered so of 16.5%. Such abundant and high-(jualit\ slight that the\ are not generalK considered a January 1988 Tyus, Minckley: Mormon Crickets 29 serious livestock competitor (Capinera and Contamination of aquatic habitats may fur- MacVean 1987, Corkins 1923, Cowen 1932). ther occur through mass movements of pesti- Bands of crickets migrating into croplands cide-laden Mormon crickets into streams, and have resulted in economic damage that is leg- entrainment of other contaminated animals. If endary. However, reports of flying grasshop- crickets consumed by fishes contain pesti- pers in early accounts (Bancroft 1889), indi- cides, the large number eaten by fishes sug- cate Mormon crickets did less than all the gests that substantial amounts of pesticides damage. Psychological effects of hordes of could likewise be consumed. This would re- large, black invading gardens and sult in death or physiologic impairment. Coin- dwellings during periodic outbreaks were cidence of cricket outbreaks, pesticide appli- nonetheless sufficient to stimulate severe cation, and fish reproduction may result in countermeasures. Mechanical barriers, poi- potential pesticide influence on gamete pro- soned baits, aerial application of pesticides, duction, gametes, or young. A high incidence and biological controls have all been used (An- of vertebral anomaly (lordosis) in roundtail imal and Plant Health Inspection Service chub in DNM has been tentatively linked to 1986, Capinera and MacVean 1987, Swain pesticide applications (Haynes and Muth 1944, Wakeland 1959). 1985). As mentioned. Mormon crickets provide Lastly, streams within and near DNM are food for many terrestrial and aquatic animals. renowned for sport fishing. Substantial har- They are also potentially valuable to man. vests are recorded for trouts in the Green

Defoliart et al. (1982) found that dried Mor- River below Flaming Gorge Dam and channel mon crickets contained 2,800 Kcal/kg and val- catfish throughout the upper Green River ued the powder at $300/metric ton. A small (1 Basin. Other carnivorous fishes, including km") band of crickets (10-20 crickets/m") northern pike {Esox hicius), are also taken and would be worth about $3,000-$7,000 based on eaten. If pesticides are bioaccumulated by these values. Mormon crickets are also sport fishes, an avenue exists for direct trans- beneficial because they feed on other insect fer of potentially damaging substances to the pests, including aphids (Ueckert and Hanson public. 1970), and are known to scavenge on feces or carrion, converting these energy sources into Acknowledgments food more readily usable by higher predators. This paper was developed research Control may therefore conflict with perpetua- from supported, in part, the Fish and Wildlife tion and management of desirable species, by Service, of National either through direct poisoning or indirectly Bureau Reclamation, and Park Service. states of Colorado and Utah through reduction in the terrestrial and The aquatic food supply (Capinera and MacVean furnished needed collecting permits and other assistance. L. A. Trinca, C. A. Karp, 1987, Mont and Oehme 1981). Although government agencies currently and other Fish and Wildlife Service em- aided in field data collection utilize pesticides of relatively low toxicity to ployees and manuscript preparation. P. C. Marsh also vertebrates (i.e., carbaryl, malathion), these read and improved a draft of the manuscript. chemicals can cause adverse impacts to the avifauna (Moulding 1976) and to aquatic in- vertebrates (Mont and Oehme 1981). Private Literature Cited

citizens may employ even more dangerous and Plant Health Inspection Service 1987. chemicals. Direct impacts of pesticides (e.g., Biological assessment for the Rangeland Grass- blow-over, accidental spraying, or washing of hopper Cooperative Management Program. U.S. poisons into aquatic habitats) may be mini- Dept. Agric., Washington, D.C. Bancroft, H, H 1889. History of Utah. In: The works of mized by enforcement of regulations (U.S. Hnbert Howe Bancroft, Vol. 26. The History Fish and Wildlife Service 1986, 1987). Yet Company, San Francisco. (Reprinted 1964 by pesticide contamination remains a possibility Bookcraft, Inc., Salt Lake City, Utah).

if applied near aquatic systems. If direct poi- Capinera. J , andC MacVean. 1987. Ecology and man- agement of Mormon cricket, Anabrus simplex soning of nontarget animals does not occur, Haldeman. Final Report to the National Park Ser- indirect effects, such as reduction in foods, vice. Department of Entomology, Colorado State may affect fishes. University, Fort Collins. .

30 Great Basin Naturalist Vol. 48, No. 1

Caklander, K D 1977. Handbook of freshwater fishery Stroud, ed.. Fish culture in fisheries manage- biology. Vols. 1 and 2. Iowa State University ment. Amer. Fish. Soc, Bethesda, Maryland. Press, Ames. Smith M L 1981. Late Cenozoic fishes of the warm CoRKlNS. C. L. 1923. Mormon cricket control. Cok)rado deserts of North America: reinterpretation of

Office State Ent., Circular 40. desert adaptations. Pages 11-38 in R. J. Naiman CowEN. F T 1932. Mormon cricket control in Colorado. and D. L. Soltz, eds.. Fishes in North American Colorado Office State Ent., Circular 57. deserts. John Wiley and Sons, New York.

Defoeiart. G R , M D Finke. and M. L Sunde 1982. SWAIN. R B 1944. Nature and extent of Mormon cricket Potential value of the Mormon cricket (Or- damage to crop and range plants. U.S. Dept. thoptera: Tettigoniidae) harvested as a high- Agric. Tech. Bull. 866.

II protein food for poidtrv. J. Econ. Ent. 75: Tyls, M 1986. Life strategies in the evolution of the 848-852. Colorado s([uawfish {Ptiichochcihis Iticius). Great Haynes, C. M., and R T Mlth 1985. Lordosis in Gila, Basin Nat. 46: 656-66L Yampa River, Colorado. Proc. Desert Fish. 1987. Distribution, reproduction, and habitat use Counc. 13(1981): 83-84. oi the razorback sucker in the Green River, Utah,

Holden. P B , andC B Stalnaker 1975. Distribution 1979-1986. Trans. Amer. Fish. Soc. 116: and abundance of mainstream fishes of the middle 111-116,

and upper Colorado River Basin 1967-1973. Tyis, H M , B D Bi RDiCK, R A Valdez, C M Haynes, Trans. Amcr. Fish. Soc. 104: 217-231. T A Lytle. and C. R. Berry 1982. Fishes of the

J.\COBl. G Z , AND M D JACOBI 1982. Report No. 9, Fish upper Colorado River: distribution, abundance, stomach content analysis. Pages 284-324 in Part 3, and status. Pages 12-70 in W. H. Miller, H. M. Colorado River Fishery Project Final Report, Tyus, and C. A. Carlson, eds.. Fishes of the upper Contracted Studies. U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv. and Colorado Ri\ er system: present and futme. Amer. Bureau Reclam., Salt Lake City, Utah. Fish. Soc. (WD), Bethesda, Maryland.

Joseph, T W , J A Sinning, R. J Beiinke, and P B Tyi's, H M , R L Jones, and L A Trinca 1987. Green Holden 1977. An evaluation of the status, life River rare and endangered fish studies, history, and habitat rec}uirements of endangered 1982-1985. Final Report, Colorado River Fishes and threatened fishes of the upper Colorado River Monitoring Project, I'.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Ver- svstem. L^S. Fish and Wildlife Ser\ice Report nal, Utah.

FWS/OBS 24. Natl. Ecol. Center, Fort Collins, Ueckert, D N , AND R M Hanson 1970. Seasonal dry

Colorado. weight composition in diets of Mormon crickets. J.

LaRivers, 1. 1956. Aquatic Orthoptera. Page 154 in R. L. Econ. Ent. 63: 96-98. Usinger, ed.. Aquatic insects of California. Uni- US Department OF THE Interior 1985. Endangered versity of California Press, Berkeley. and threatened wildlife and plants; notice of com-

McCarthy, M S , andW L Minckley 1987. Age deter- pletion of re\ ievv for 1978 and a fi\ e-\ ear review of minatioti for imperiled razorback sucker (Pisces: species listed before 1976, and in 1979 and 1980. C'atostomidae) from Lake Mohave, Arizona- Fed. Reg. 50: 299()()-29909.

Nevada. J. Arizona-Nevada Acad. Sci. 21: 87-97. US Fish AND Wildlife Ser\ ICE 1986. Biological opin-

Miller, W H , H M Tyus. and C.A. Carlson 1982. ion FA/SE/APHIS—Mormon cricket control. Let- Fishes of the upper Colorado River svstem: ter report to the .\nimal and Plant Health Inspec- present and future. Amer. Fish. Soc. (WD), tion Service. U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Denver, Bethesda, Maryland. Colorado.

Minckley, W. L., and J. N Rinne. 1986. Large vvoodx- 1987. Biological opuiion FA/SE/APHIS (6-RO-87- debris in hot-desert streams: an historical rc\ ievv. F-0()4). Letter report to the Animal and Plant Desert Plants 7(1985): 142-153. Health Inspection Service. U.S. Fish Wildl.

Mont, M. E.. and F. W Oeiime 1981. Carbaryl: a litera- S(r\. , Denver, Coloiado. ture review. Residue Rev. 80: 1-64. UsiN(.i.R, R L 1956. Acjuatic insects of Caliiornia. Uni- M<)rLDlN(;.J D 1976. Effects of a low-persistence insec- versity of California Press, Berkele\ ticide on forest bird populations. Auk 93: 692-708. \amcek, C. D., and R H Kramer 1969. Life historN of National Park Service 1986. General management the (Colorado s((uawfisli, Ftijchoclwilus liicius. and

plan. Dinosaur National Momunent. U.S. Nat. the (Colorado chub, C'.ila rohusta. in the Green Park Serv., Dinosaur, Colorado. l^ixcr in Dinosaur National Monument,

ReMilliard, M. D . G. C. Andersen. C A Birdwell. 1964-1966. Trans. Amer. Fish. Soc. 98: 193-208. and G. W. Sandberc. 1986. Water resource data W'akeland, (,' 1959. Mormon crickets in North ,\merica. for Utah, water vear 1985. U.S. Geol. Sur\.. U.S. Dept. Agric. Tech. Bull. 1202. Water-data Report UT-85-1. Welcom.ME, R. L 1979. Fisheries ecologx oilloodplain

Rinne, J. N.. J E Johnson, B L Jensen, A W Ricer rivers. Longman, London. AND R. S0REN.SON. 1986. The role of hatcheries in WiiiiMV F. 1892. The cricket plague. Histor\ of the management and recovery of threatened and Utair George Q. Camion and Sons, Salt Lake endangered fishes. Pages 271-285 in K. II. Cit\, Utah,