"The Cost-Of-Living Index and Wage Determination"
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Article "The Cost-of-Living Index and Wage Determination" Jean-Marie Martin Relations industrielles / Industrial Relations, vol. 4, n° 5, 1949, p. 41-42. Pour citer cet article, utiliser l'information suivante : URI: http://id.erudit.org/iderudit/1023468ar DOI: 10.7202/1023468ar Note : les règles d'écriture des références bibliographiques peuvent varier selon les différents domaines du savoir. Ce document est protégé par la loi sur le droit d'auteur. L'utilisation des services d'Érudit (y compris la reproduction) est assujettie à sa politique d'utilisation que vous pouvez consulter à l'URI https://apropos.erudit.org/fr/usagers/politique-dutilisation/ Érudit est un consortium interuniversitaire sans but lucratif composé de l'Université de Montréal, l'Université Laval et l'Université du Québec à Montréal. Il a pour mission la promotion et la valorisation de la recherche. Érudit offre des services d'édition numérique de documents scientifiques depuis 1998. Pour communiquer avec les responsables d'Érudit : [email protected] Document téléchargé le 20 juillet 2016 10:03 Rulletiu du n&UUiouâ. iuduitfuellu Volume 4, number 5 QUEBEC January 1949 Published by the Department of Industrial Relations, THE COST-OF-LIVING INDEX AND Faculty of Social Sciences, Laval University. WAGE DETERMINATION GEORGES-HENRI LÉVESQUE, o.p., Dean GÉRARD TREMBLAY, Director JEAN-MARIE MARTIN GÉRARD DION, Assistant-Director JEAN GAGNÉ, Secretary CHARLES BÉLANGER, Administrator The Bulletin is published monthly, Septem• To what extent can the cost of living index be used ber to June inclusively (ten issues a year). in the negotiation of wage agreements ? Annual subscription: Canada: $1.50; Fo• reign: $2.00. Single copies: twenty-five cents. Tbe Cost-of-Living Index of the Federal Bureau of Sta• Publication indexed in the tistics functions to express, with the aid of percentages, the "Canadian Index". changes in the retail prices of a certain number of commo• AU correspondance must be addressed dities and services — constant as to quahty and quantity to the Literary Editor — entering into the composition of the budget of a typical GÉRARD DION 2, University Street, Quebec. family for a determined period. BuUetin des relations industrieUes This description requires some further explanation. We Volume 4, number 5 January 1949 must ask ourselves, first of all, what we understand by a « typical family », then what we mean by a « budget » and Contents finally what is signified by a « determined period ». These The cost-of-living index and wage determination are the three essential elements which enter into the compo• Jean-Marie MARTIN 41 sition of the Cost-of-Living Index. Some aspects of the vocational training system in use in the The « typical family » with which the official Canadian printing industry of Montreal Index is concerned, is not a real family. It is the average Marcel FORGET 43 Who must administer the family resulting from a certain number of families actually oath to the withness living in the country during the years serving as the basic Marie-Louis BEAULIEU 45 Statistics on labour relations 47 period for the setting up of the index. Union security in the The Cost-of-Living Index was calculated by making Province of Quebec Gérard DION 48 first of all an enquiry in some 45,000 to 50,000 homes in a Our Readers' comments 50 dozen cities of Canada. From these 45,000 to 50,000 homes, 1,439 workingmen's families considered as typical1 by the Contributors BANCROFT, (Mrs.) M.-T., Translator of the Federal Bureau of Statistics, were chosen to take a detailed Bulletin. count of their costs of maintenance, reckoning from October 1, BEAULIEU, Marie-Louis, K.C., B.A., L.Ph., LL.D., Lawyer, Quebec Bar; Professor 1937 up to September 3, 1938. These famiUes lived in the fol• in the Faculty of Law and the Faculty lowing cities: Charlottetown, Halifax, St. John, Quebec, of Social Sciences of Laval University. DION, Gérard, L.Th., L.PhiL, M.Soc.Sc, Montreal, Ottawa, Toronto, London, Winnipeg, Saskatoon, Professor Assistant-Director of the In• Edmonton and Vancouver. The revenue of the 1,439 selected dustrial Relations Department, Faculty of families varied from $600.00 to $2,800.00 a year, the greater Social Sciences, Laval University. FORGET, Marcel, B.A., L.Ph., maitre en rela• number of the families though, receiving between $1,200.00 tions industrielles (Montréal); Assistant- and $1,600.00 in revenue per year. The mean revenue of Secretary, Apprenticeship Commission of the Printing Trades of the City of Mont• all the families was established in the neighbourhood of real. $1,500.00. MARTIN, Jean-Marie, B.A., L.A.S. (Mont• real), M.S.A. (Cornell), Professor, Di• rector, Department of Economics, Faculty of Social Sciences of Laval University. (1) The choice of families as being typical was made following an elaborate study of the 1931 Canadian Census with the purpose Authorized as second class mail of establishing the principal attributes of the workingmen's Post-office Department, families of the country and also of choosing the cities facilitat• Ottawa, Canada. ing the best possible sampling. 42 Bulletin des relations industrieUes de Laval In analysing the budgets furnished by each One must not forget either that the family of 4.6 of these 1,439 families the conclusion was arrived persons is found nowhere and that, in conse• at that the average annual expenditure established quence, the representative family furnishing the itself at $1,413.90. This sum was therefore chosen budget on which is based the Cost-of-Living Index as base and to it was given the figure of 100. is a family which exists only in the abstract. As explained in the November number of the These remarks are not made to criticize the Bulletin des relations industrieUes, this amount of composition of the Cost-of-Living Index in Cana• family outlay — $1,413.90 — was divided into da. They have for aim only to demonstrate that six important groups of expenses, namely : 1 —- the Cost-of-Living Index is an arbitrary measure Food; 2 — Lodging; 3 — Heat and Lighting; 4 — calculated, it is true, with as much exactness as Clothing; 5 — Furnishings; 6 — Sundries (under the family milieu, which was made the object of this heading of « Sundries » were included family the budget investigations, would permit, but expenses for health, personal items, moving, leisu• which remains, nonetheless, a measure, i.e., a re and recreation, life insurance). term of comparison. It is clear that the Cost-of- In giving to the total figure of $1,413.90 the Living Index does not represent the expenditures value of 100 it was found that this figure of 100 of such a particular family that we could know. was divided for budget purposes in the following The Index is a barometer, a floodometer, as an fashion according to the groupings above : 1 — excerpt from an article appearing in the Februa• Food 31.3%; 2 — Lodging 19.1%; 3 — Heat & ry, 1948 number of the « Revue Statistique du Light 6.4%; 4 — Clothing 11.7%; 5 — Furnishings Canada » recalls, « It is important above all to 8.9%; 6 — Sundries 22.6%. remind ourselves that the Index measures the This budget of $1,413.90 per year, as we changes occurring in the cost of living and not in have seen, represented the average expenditures the forms oi life. It is an index of the movement for the upkeep of 1,439 families. But it was ne• of prices rather than the changes which are pro• cessary that this average should correspond also duced in the total expenses of a family ». « —TTie to an average family and it was discovered that Index, in addition, measures only the average the family which represented the average of the changes which are produced in the cities and 1,439 families studied, consisted of 4.6 persons. towns across the country. By reason of the parti• Finally, the period in the course of which cular circumstances which surround the life of this family - of 4.6 persons spent for its annual certain families it is not at all doubtful that the maintenance an average of $1,413.90 was esta• cost of living with these has increased in a man• blished during the five year interval of the years ner much more marked than the Index. On the 1935-36-37-38 and 39. contrary, with other families, it has risen less By the preceding we can see that what we rapidly. » understand by the family budget in the case of All this is to say that we cannot give to the the official Cost-of-Living Index of Canada is the Cost-of-Living Index all the meaning that per• total of the annual maintenance expenses, during sonal interest or group interests are tempted to a five-year period of a workingman's family com• lend it. We must not lose sight of the fact that posed of 4.6 persons, living in one or other of the a particular measure, for example, the mètre, the urban centres already mentioned, divided accord• gold standard etc., has neither utility nor value ing to the six classes of expenditures. unless interpreted with regard to its own function. From all these explanations it is clearly The mètre, to measure distances or surfaces, the evident that the official Cost-of-Living Index in gold standard, to measure the intrinsic value of Canada applies only to a group of families having money, the Cost-of-Living Index to measure the an annual revenue of around $1,500.00 and that variations in the retail prices of certain specific this annual revenue, since it is taken as repre• services and commodities! Moreover, the word it• sentative, is supposed to reflect the most current self indicates that it is here a question of an in• dex, i.e.