Park Avenue, Pineville, N.C
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SURVEY AND RESEARCH REPORT On Park Avenue, Pineville, N.C. 1. Name and location of the property: The property is known as Park Avenue and is located at 408 – 427 Park Avenue, Pineville, North Carolina. 2. Name and address of the present owners of the property: Thomas E. White 408 Park Avenue Pineville, N.C. 28134 Haley Wilson Hobbs 409 Park Avenue Pineville, N.C. 28134 Vivian Vick Moore 10862 Rise Ln. Fort Mill, SC 29715 (410 Park Avenue) LLC PMC of Charlotte P.O. Box 12461 Charlotte, N.C. 28220 (411 Park Avenue) Charles Bradford Smith 3913 Lakeside Drive Charlotte, NC 28270 (412 Park Avenue) Betty B. Kimbrell C/O Linda Bass 870 Spring Garden Road Conway, S.C. 29527 (413 Park Avenue) Joseph Gerald Landry 414 Park Avenue Pineville, NC 28134 William E. Smith 13909 Woody Point Road Charlotte, NC 2827 (415 Park Avenue) Gary F. Workman, Rebecca B. Workman, and Mark A. Dymock 2428 Quail Lake Drive Charlotte, NC 28210 (416 Park Avenue) Ricky and Maria Clark 417 Park Avenue Pineville, NC 28134 William E. Smith 13909 Woody Point Road Charlotte, NC 28278 (420 Park Avenue) Nina O. Earnhart C/O William Earnhart P.O. Box 192 Pineville, NC 28134 (421 Park Avenue) Robert E. Smith 3475 Pikeview Road Fort Mill, S.C. 29715 (422 Park Avenue) George L. Beyer and Jessica M. Arce 423 Park Avenue Pineville, N.C. 28134 Dorothy B. Adams 424 Park Avenue Pineville, N.C. 28134 Ronald and Sylvia Moore 1400 Nettleton Drive Desoto, TX 75115 (425 Park Avenue) Michael Keigh McCoy 426 Park Avenue Pineville, NC 28134-8514 Charles Morris and Dolly Howard P.O. Box 548 Pineville, N.C. 28134 (427 Park Avenue) 3. Representative photographs of the property: This report contains representative photographs of the property. 4. Maps depicting the location of the property: This report contains a map depicting the location of the property. 5. Current deed book reference to the property: The tax parcel numbers associated with the property are: 22107109, 22107110, 22107111, 22107112, 22107113, 22107114, 22107115, 22107116, 22107117, 22107201, 22107202, 22107203, 22107204, 22107205, 22107206, 22107207, 22107208, 22107209 6. A brief historical sketch of the property: This report contains a brief historical sketch of the property. 7. A brief architectural description of the property: This report contains a brief architectural description of the property. 8. Documentation of why and in what ways the property meets criteria for designation set forth in N. C. G. S. 160A-400.5: a. Special significance in terms of its history, architecture, and/or cultural importance: The Commission judges that the property known as the Pineville Commercial Block does possess special significance in terms of Charlotte- Mecklenburg. The Commission bases its judgment on the following considerations: 1. Park Avenue is a well defined and intact element of the Pineville Mill Village. 2. Park Avenue's wide divided street is the most significant element of the landscape plan developed for the village by noted Charlotte planner Earle Sumner Draper. 3. Park Avenue's one-story, frame T-plan mill houses have retained, in aggregate, a high degree of integrity, and the one-story, frame hip-roofed mill cottages with front and rear gable-roofed wings are unique in terms of the mill villages in Mecklenburg County. 4. In consideration of its intact houses and significant landscape features, Park Avenue possesses special significance as the most distinctive surviving element of the Pineville mill village. b. Integrity of design, setting, workmanship, materials, feeling and/or association: The Commission contends that the physical and architectural description which is included in this report demonstrates that Park Avenue meets this criterion. 9. Ad Valorem tax appraisal: The Commission is aware that designation would allow the owner to apply for an automatic deferral of 50% of the Ad Valorem taxes on all or any portion of the property which becomes a designated "historic landmark." 10. Portion of property recommended for designation: The exterior of the houses, the road and median, and the land delineated in the above map are recommended for historic designation. Date of preparation of this report: January 10, 2011 Prepared by: Stewart Gray Narrative Description Rick Mattson and Francis Alexander, edited by Stewart Gray Park Avenue is a well preserved block of eighteen mill houses situated along a wide street divided by a grassy median. Park Avenue is a component of the Pineville Mill Village, in Pineville, NC. The mill village was developed in two phases. Park Avenue was developed during the first phase which occurred with the opening of Dover Yarn Mills in 1894. The village is located south of Pineville's Main Street, and encompasses most of the south side of this small, Mecklenburg County railroad town as it existed into the mid-twentieth century. Park Avenue is roughly centered in the village. Immediately to the west of Park Avenue is the expansive, red-brick textile mill. Park Avenue is comprised of one-story, frame T-plan mill houses, and one-story, frame hip- roofed mill cottages with front and rear gable-roofed wings. Although the original house designs have been modified by later sidings, and replacement window sash and porch posts, the original forms remain remarkably unchanged, with only minor additions that are primarily to the rear. Most new construction consists of backyard storage sheds and garages that do not detract from the integrity of the houses. The roughly quarter-acre house lots are original and were laid out to accommodate gardens and sheds. Mature trees shade the streets and houses. Many were probably planted during the 1920s expansion and renovation of the mill village, when Chadwick-Hoskins commissioned planner Earle Sumner Draper to update the village. Others were planted over time by the residents. With its small variety of evenly distributed and intact house types, Park Ave well represents the distinctive architectural rhythm that sets the mill village apart from the rest of the town. The street runs east-west and is broader than the other streets in the village and features a unique, tree-lined median that was part of Draper’s plan. The mill houses along Park Avenue are some of the earliest dwellings in the village, and stand in contrast to the 1920s side-gable and hip-roofed bungalows in much of the rest of the village. Statement of Significance Park Avenue possesses special significance as a well defined and intact element of the Pineville Mill Village. The block's wide divided street is a distinct element of the landscape plan developed for the village by noted Charlotte planner Earle Sumner Draper. Park Avenue's one-story, frame T-plan mill houses have retained, in aggregate, a high degree of integrity, and the one-story, frame hip-roofed mill cottages with front and rear gable-roofed wings are unique in terms of the mill villages in Mecklenburg County. Portion of Earl Sumner Draper's plan for the "Village Development, Chadwick Hoskins Co." Parks Avenue as shown on survey of the mill property, ca. 1946 Historical Background Located eleven miles south of Charlotte near Little Sugar Creek, Pineville has its roots in a small community established here in the early nineteenth century The settlement was named Morrow’s Turnout for one of the area’s early white families. In 1869, the Charlotte, Columbia, and Augusta Railroad--created from the merger of the Charlotte and South Carolina Railroad and the Columbia and Augusta Railroad--established a passenger and freight station at Morrow’s Turnout. In 1873 the community was incorporated as Pineville, according to local lore named for a nearby stand of pine trees. In 1894, the railroad became part of the vast Southern Railway system that integrated Pineville, Mecklenburg County, and the Piedmont into a national network of rail lines. This new connectivity would ultimately link Pineville to far-flung markets, and draw industries—especially cotton mills—to the town and the region (Blythe and Brockman 1961: 259-262, 417-422; Charlotte Observer 21 May 1967). Pineville was part of a great network of small railroad towns that emerged throughout region after the Civil War. Between the Civil War and 1900, new rail lines spurred the growth of over 200 towns in North Carolina. The majority of these rail towns were in the Piedmont, which by the early twentieth century was becoming the center of the nation’s textile industry. In Mecklenburg County, the towns of Pineville, Matthews, Huntersville, and Cornelius were founded along railroad lines in this period. (Tullos 1989: 135-140; Glass 1992: 57-58). In Mecklenburg County and throughout the Piedmont, railways tied the towns not just to each other and southern ports, but to northern markets and greater sources of building materials and finished goods. Railroads and advances in steam and electrical power transformed the industrial geography of the region. They liberated factories from traditional sites beside rivers and created surging industrial districts along railways near cities and towns. Trains opened the Appalachian coal fields and hauled into the Piedmont the fuel necessary for operating massive steam engines. By the 1900s, James Buchanan Duke’s Southern Power Company (now Duke Energy) was constructing a series of hydroelectric power plants along the Catawba River to supply nearby industries with inexpensive electricity. By 1900, six railroads were routed through the city of Charlotte, located near the center of Mecklenburg County. Charlotte enjoyed more rail connections than any other place between Washington, D.C. and Atlanta, and became the hub of the Piedmont textile belt (Goldfield 1982: 86-90; Bishir 1990: 434-435). To many southerners, railroads promised industrialization. Civic leaders in Charlotte and other southern cities envisioned a new order based on textile production and urban growth to replace the agrarian society of the past.