Marine Ecology Progress Series 607:85
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The following supplement accompanies the article Artificial structures versus mangrove prop roots: a general comparison of epifaunal communities within the Indian River Lagoon, Florida, USA Dean S. Janiak*, Richard W. Osman, Christopher J. Freeman, Valerie J. Paul *Corresponding author: [email protected] Marine Ecology Progress Series 607: 85–98 (2018) Figure S1. nMDS plots for each sampling event using Bray-Curtis similarity matrix. Each point represents the average of 3 replicates taken at each site. Triangles, labeled A, represent artificial habitat and open circles, labeled MG, represent mangrove habitat. Some events have two graphs, the first to include all sites and the second, a subset with outliers removed. a) b) Quarterly Sites Quarterly Samples 10/2014 01/2015 Resemblance: S17 Bray-Curtis similarity Resemblance: S17 Bray-Curtis similarity 2D Stress: 0.11 2D Stress: 0.13 Habitat M_01 Habitat A A MG MG IRL_05 M_05 B_01 IRL_11 M_05 B_05M_06IRL_07M_02M_04 IRL_03IRL_09 IRL_06IRL_04IRL_02 M_02 B_04 IRL_13mgIRL_13dIRL_08 IRL_11 IRL_01B_02IRL_09IRL_12IRL_10B_07 IRL_07IRL_08IRL_06B_05 M_04M_06IRL_10 B_06alt B_06 B_04 IRL_02 IRL_04 B_03 M_01 IRL_01 IRL_13mgB_02 IRL_03 IRL_13d B_01 B_07 B_03 B_08 IRL_12 B_06 B_08 IRL_05 B_06alt c) d) Quarterly Samples Quarterly Samples - B_03 Included 04/2015 07/2015 Resemblance: S17 Bray-Curtis similarity Resemblance: S17 Bray-Curtis similarity 2D Stress: 0.12 Habitat 2D Stress: 0.01 Habitat B_04 IRL_12 A A IRL_05 MG MG IRL_04IRL_10IRL_11IRL_01B_05IRL_09 B_06altIRL_08B_02 IRL_06IRL_13mgIRL_13d IRL_02IRL_07M_04B_07 B_01 B_06 M_06 IRL_03 M_02 B_08 IRL_13mgIRL_13dIRL_11B_06altIRL_01IRL_04IRL_06IRL_08IRL_03IRL_07IRL_09IRL_02IRL_05IRL_12IRL_10M_02M_06M_04M_05B_04B_07B_02B_01M_01B_05B_08B_06 B_03 M_05 B_03 M_01 1 e) f) Quarterly Samples - B_03 Removed Quarterly Samples - B_03 & IRL_03 Included 07/2015 10/2015 Resemblance: S17 Bray-Curtis similarity Resemblance: S17 Bray-Curtis similarity 2D Stress: 0.13 Habitat 2D Stress: 0.01 IRL_10 B_03 Habitat A A MG MG IRL_12 IRL_09 B_05 IRL_05 IRL_02 IRL_13mg IRL_11IRL_01 B_04IRL_13dIRL_04 M_06 IRL_06B_07 M_04 B_06alt IRL_08M_05 IRL_03 IRL_13mgIRL_05IRL_13dIRL_01IRL_12IRL_09IRL_08IRL_02IRL_10IRL_11IRL_06IRL_07IRL_04M_04M_01M_05B_02B_06B_05B_04B_08M_02B_07B_01 IRL_07 B_02 B_06alt M_02 B_01 M_01 B_08 B_06 IRL_03 g) h) Quarterly Samples - B_03 & IRL_03 Removed Quarterly Samples - B_03 Inlcuded 10/2015 01/2016 Resemblance: S17 Bray-Curtis similarity Resemblance: S17 Bray-Curtis similarity 2D Stress: 0.1 B_06alt Habitat 2D Stress: 0.01 Habitat A A MG MG IRL_05 IRL_01 IRL_13mg B_05 IRL_12 M_01 M_01 B_04B_07 IRL_02 IRL_13mgIRL_13dB_06altIRL_01IRL_05IRL_12IRL_06IRL_11IRL_09IRL_02IRL_08IRL_03IRL_10IRL_04M_04B_06M_02B_01B_04B_05B_08M_05M_06B_02B_07 B_03 B_08IRL_11IRL_08 B_02 IRL_06IRL_07 IRL_10 IRL_13d IRL_09 B_01 IRL_04 M_04 M_05 M_02 B_06 i) j) Quarterly Samples - B_03 Removed Quarterly Samples 01/2016 04/2016 Resemblance: S17 Bray-Curtis similarity Resemblance: S17 Bray-Curtis similarity 2D Stress: 0.12 2D Stress: 0.15 B_01 Habitat Habitat A M_06M_05 A B_07 IRL_03 MG M_04 IRL_02 MG B_08 IRL_05 M_02 B_01 B_02 B_04 M_02 IRL_02 IRL_07IRL_13d IRL_06 IRL_08 IRL_06 B_07 IRL_04 IRL_11 IRL_11IRL_09 B_08 IRL_10 IRL_03 IRL_04 B_03 M_04 M_05 IRL_05 IRL_10 B_04 B_05 B_02 B_05 IRL_08 B_06alt IRL_13mg IRL_01 IRL_13d M_06 M_01 IRL_09 B_06 B_06alt IRL_13mg IRL_01 B_06 IRL_12 IRL_12 M_01 k) l) Quarterly Samples - B_03 Included Quarterly Samples - B_03 Removed 07/2016 07/2016 Resemblance: S17 Bray-Curtis similarity Resemblance: S17 Bray-Curtis similarity 2D Stress: 0.01 Habitat 2D Stress: 0.07 Habitat A A MG MG M_05 B_08 IRL_02 IRL_10 IRL_09 IRL_08IRL_11 IRL_07IRL_13d IRL_13mg IRL_06M_04B_07IRL_04 IRL_13mgIRL_13dIRL_04IRL_11IRL_03IRL_07IRL_10IRL_06IRL_08IRL_09IRL_02IRL_01IRL_05B_06aIRL_12B_01B_08M_05M_04B_05M_06B_02B_06B_07M_02M_01 B_03 IRL_03 M_02 B_02 IRL_12 M_01B_01M_06IRL_01B_06a IRL_05 B_06 B_05 2 Table S1. Species list for all taxa identified at least to genus. Letters indicate species origin status (N = native, I = introduced, and U = unknown or cryptogenic) Porifera Clathrina sp. U Cliona sp. U Darwinella rosacea N Halichondria cf magniconulosa N Halichondria melanadocia N Haliclona curacaoensis N Haliclona implexiformis N Haliclona manglaris N Halisarca sp. U Hymeniacidon heliophila N Leucosolenia sp. U Mycale microsigmatosa N Suberites aurantiacus N Sycon ciliatum I Tedania ignis N Platyhelminthes Euplana gracilis N Stylochus ellipticus N Cnidaria Actinia bermudensis N Anemone sp. A U Anemone sp. B U Anemonesp. C U Bimeria vestita I Bunodeopsis antilliensis N Campanularia macroscypha N Clytia linearis I Clytia noliformis I Diadumene franciscana I Diadumene leucolena N Dynamena cornicina I Eudendrium annulatum I Eudendrium carneum I Exaiptasia pallida N Halecium sp. U Hebella scandens N Obelia bidentata I Obelia dichotoma I Obelia geniculata I Obelia sp. U Plumularia floridana N Tubularia sp. U Mollusca Anomia simplex N Arcuatula papyria N Astyris lunata N Bostrycapulus aculeatus N Brachidontes exustus N Cardotes floridanus N Cerithium sp. U Cinctura hunteria N 3 Costoanachis avara N Crassostrea virginica N Crepidula atrasolea N Crepidula depressa N Crepidula fornicata N Diodora cayenensis N Geukensia demissa N Hiatella arctica N Mytella charruana I Mytilopsis sallei N Nassarius vibex N Perna viridis I Petaloconchus varians N Urosalpinx cinerea N Sipuncula Phascolion cryptum N Annelida Alitta succinea N Bispira brunnea N Branchiomma bairdi N Cirratulus grandis N Fabricia stellaris I Ficopomatus enigmaticus I Ficopomatus miamiensis N Hydroides dianthus I Hydroides dirampha N Hydroides elegans I Hydroides floridana N Hydroides sanctaecrucis N Hydroides sp. U Janua sp. U Lumbrinereis sp. U Marphysa sanguinea N Pileolaria berkeleyana I Polydora cornuta N Sabella sp. U Salmacina huxleyi N Serpula sp. U Spirobranchus minutus I Terebella sp. A U Terebella sp. B. U Vermiliopsis infundibulum I Arthropoda Amphibalanus amphitrite I Amphibalanus eburneus N Amphibalanus improvisus N Amphibalanus reticulatus I Amphibalanus subalbidus N Amphibalanus venustus N Balanus trigonus I Caprella penantis I Chthamalus fragilis N Cirolana sp. U Erichsonella attenuata N Ericthonius brasiliensis I 4 Ericthonius punctatus N Eurypanapeus depressus N Leptochelia rapax N Libinia dubia N Megabalanus coccopoma I Menippe mercenaria N Monocorophium insidiosum N Pachygrapsus transversus I Palaemonetes pugio N Petrolisthes armatus I Sphaeroma terebrans I Bryozoa Acanthodesia savartii N Aeverrillia armata N Alcyonidium polyoum N Amathia distans I Amathia gracilis N Amathia verticillata I Amathia vidovici I Anguinella palmata N Bugula neritina I Bugula stolonifera N Conopeum chesapeakensis N Conopeum tenuissimum N Cradoscrupocellaria atlantica N Cradoscrupocellaria bertholleti I Hippoporina indica I Jellyella tuberculata I Membranipora sp. U Membranipora tenella N Nolella stipata I Parasmittina nitida N Savignyella lafonti I Schizoporella pungens I Triticella sp. U Victorella pavida I Watersipora subtorquata I Entoprocta Barentsia sp. U Echinodermata Ophiactis sp. U Chordata Aplidium antillense N Aplidium sp. A U Aplidium sp. B U Ascidia curvata N Botrylloides nigrum N Botrylloides sp. U Botryllus schlosseri N Botryllus sp. U Clavelina oblonga N Cystodytes dellechiajei N Didemnum perlucidum I Didemnum sp. U Diplosoma glandulosum N Diplosoma listerianum I 5 Diplosoma sp. U Distaplia bermudensis N Distaplia corolla N Ecteinascidia turbinata N Eudistoma clarum N Eudistoma hepaticum N Eudistoma obscuratum N Eudistoma sp. N Eusynstyela sp. U Herdmania momus N Lissoclinum fragile N Microcosmus exasperatus N Molgula manhattensis N Molgula occidentalis N Perophora viridis N Phallusia nigra N Polyandrocarpa zorritensis I Polyclinum constellatum I Pyura vittata N Styela canopus I Styela plicata I Symplegma brakenhielmi I Symplegma rubra N 6 Table S2. SIMPER analysis for established communities. 10/14 Ave Diss = 55.48 Mangrove Artificial Species Av.Abund Av.Abund Av.Diss Diss/SD Contrib% Cum.% Amphibalanus eburneus 52.37 55.52 15.62 1.57 28.16 28.16 Open Space 21.17 13.5 9.38 1.01 16.91 45.06 Mytilopsis sallei 8.33 0 3.86 0.39 6.97 52.03 Amphipod tubes 8.4 3.06 3.67 0.72 6.61 58.64 Hydroids 2.73 7.61 3.22 1.07 5.81 64.45 Diplosoma listerianum 3.93 4.15 2.84 0.69 5.12 69.56 Branchiomma bairdi 2.17 2.91 1.51 0.63 2.71 72.28 01/15 Ave Diss = 58.77 Mangrove Artificial Species Av.Abund Av.Abund Av.Diss Diss/SD Contrib% Cum.% Amphibalanus eburneus 54.83 50.48 15.88 1.14 27.02 27.02 Anemone sp. C 0 12.06 6 0.57 10.21 37.23 Amphipod tubes 8.7 1.41 4.22 0.88 7.18 44.41 Open Space 8.7 4.81 3.86 1.32 6.57 50.98 Bugula neritina 1.93 4.31 2.81 0.5 4.78 55.76 Schizoporella pungens 0 5.39 2.65 0.33 4.52 60.28 Victorella pavida 3.7 0.89 2.18 0.59 3.71 63.99 Amphibalanus improvisus 3.47 0.19 1.79 0.28 3.05 67.04 Halichondria cf magniconulosa 0.1 2.5 1.23 0.42 2.1 69.14 Molgula occidentalis 0.37 2.07 1.17 0.26 1.99 71.13 04/15 Ave Diss = 52.59 Mangrove Artificial Species Av.Abund Av.Abund Av.Diss Diss/SD Contrib% Cum.% Amphibalanus eburneus 62.17 48.96 13.3 1.31 25.28 25.28 Open Space 17.23 9.72 6.92 1.02 13.16 38.44 Amphipod tubes 5.57 2.19 2.64 0.68 5.02 43.47 Various Algae 2.27 4.33 2.51 0.66 4.77 48.23 Anemone sp. B 0 4.7 2.17 0.3 4.12 52.35 Schizoporella pungens 0 4.41 2.02 0.37 3.83 56.19 Suberites aurantiacus 0 4 1.85 0.25 3.51 59.7 Hydroids 3.33 1.67 1.76 0.82 3.34 63.04 Conopeum spp. 1.37 1.83 1.41 0.4 2.67 65.71 Halichondria cf magniconulosa 0.47 2.65 1.32 0.61 2.5 68.22 Bugula neritina 2.13 0.65 1.24 0.43 2.35 70.57 07/15 Ave Diss = 52.97 Mangrove Artificial Species Av.Abund Av.Abund Av.Diss Diss/SD Contrib% Cum.% Amphibalanus eburneus 43.4 64.44 15.07 1.45 28.45 28.45 Open Space 19.53 11.74 7.03 1.17 13.28 41.73 Amphibalanus reticulatus 5.77 0.72 2.98 0.46 5.62 47.35 Hydroids 5.23 2.13 2.66 0.85 5.02 52.38 Amphipod tubes 2.97 2.39 1.84 0.9 3.48 55.86 Various Algae 1.53 2.3 1.5 0.76 2.82 58.68 Conopeum spp.