Report, Situation in the Central African Republic II
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Situation in the Central African Republic II Article 53(1) Report 24 September 2014 Table of Contents EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ............................................................................................................ 6 I. INTRODUCTION ...................................................................................................... 13 II. PROCEDURAL HISTORY ......................................................................................... 14 III. CONTEXTUAL BACKGROUND .............................................................................. 16 IV. PRECONDITIONS TO JURISDICTION .................................................................... 24 V. SUBJECT-MATTER JURISDICTION ......................................................................... 26 A. Alleged crimes ........................................................................................................... 26 B. Legal analysis ............................................................................................................ 28 1. War crimes ................................................................................................................. 28 (a) Contextual elements of war crimes ............................................................ 28 i. Level of organization .................................................................................. 29 ii. Level of intensity of the armed conflict ..................................................... 35 iii. Existence, and geographical and temporal scope, of the armed conflict .. 42 (b) Alleged war crimes ..................................................................................... 42 i. War crimes allegedly committed by FACA ............................................... 43 ii. War crimes allegedly committed by Séléka ............................................... 44 iii. War crimes allegedly committed by anti-balaka ....................................... 48 (c) Nexus between the individual acts and the armed conflict ...................... 51 2. Crimes against humanity .......................................................................................... 51 (a) Contextual elements of crimes against humanity ...................................... 52 (b) Séléka: alleged crimes against humanity ................................................... 55 i. Crimes against humanity allegedly committed by Séléka ........................ 61 ii. Nexus with the attack ................................................................................. 69 (c) Anti-balaka: alleged crimes against humanity .......................................... 70 i. Crimes against humanity allegedly committed by anti-balaka ................. 73 ii. Nexus with the attack ................................................................................. 78 3. Genocide .................................................................................................................... 78 C. Conclusion on subject-matter jurisdiction ................................................................ 79 VI. ADMISSIBILITY ........................................................................................................ 81 A. Complementarity ....................................................................................................... 81 1. Applicable law ........................................................................................................... 82 2. Investigative bodies ................................................................................................... 82 3. Existence of relevant proceedings ............................................................................. 84 4. Assessment ................................................................................................................ 86 5. Conclusion on complementarity ............................................................................... 88 B. Gravity ....................................................................................................................... 89 1. Séléka ......................................................................................................................... 89 2. Anti-balaka ................................................................................................................ 91 VII. INTERESTS OF JUSTICE ........................................................................................... 92 VIII. CONCLUSION........................................................................................................... 93 ANNEX 1: Map of Central African Republic ........................................................................... 94 2 3 List of Abbreviations A2R Alliance pour la renaissance et la refondation, Alliance for Rebirth and Rebuilding AI Amnesty International AU African Union BINUCA United Nations Integrated Peacebuilding Office in the Central African Republic BSS Bataillon de soutien et des services, Support Services Batallion CAR Central African Republic CNT Conseil National de Transition, National Transitional Council CPJP Convention des patriotes pour la justice et la paix, Convention of Patriots for Justice and Peace CPSK Convention patriotique du salut du kodro, Patriotic Convention for National Salvation CSEI Cellule spéciale d’enquêtes et d’instruction, Special Inquiry and Judicial Investigation Unit DDR Disarmament, Demobilisation and Reintegration DSPJ Direction des services de la police judiciaire, Directorate of the Judicial Police ECCAS Economic Community of Central African States EU European Union FACA Forces armées centrafricaines, Central African Armed Forces FDPC Forces démocratiques du peuple centrafricain, Democratic Forces of the Central African People FIDH Fédération internationale des ligues des droits de l’homme, International Federation for Human Rights FPRC Front populaire pour la renaissance de la Centrafrique, Popular Front for the Rebirth of Central Africa FROCCA Front pour le retour à l’Ordre Constitutionnel en Centrafrique, Front for the return to Constitutional Order in Central Africa HRW Human Rights Watch ICC International Criminal Court ICG International Crisis Group ICRC International Committee of the Red Cross ICTY International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia INGO International Non-Governmental Organization MICOPAX Misssion pour la consolidation de la Paix en Centrafrique, Mission for the Consolidation of Peace in the Central African Republic MINUSCA United Nations Multidimensional Integrated Stabilisation Mission in the Central African Republic 4 MISCA Mission internationale de soutien à la République Centrafricaine, International Support Mission for the Central African Republic MLCJ Mouvement de libération centrafricaine pour la justice, Central African Liberation Movement for Justice MSF Médecins sans frontières, Doctors without Borders NGO Non-Governmental organization OCHA United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs OHCHR Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights OTP Office of the Prosecutor RJ Révolution et justice, Revolution and Justice SRI Section de recherches et des investigations, Analysis and Investigation Section TGI Tribunal de Grande Instance, District Court UFDR Union des forces démocratiques pour le rassemblement, Union of Democratic Forces for Unity UFR Union des forces républicaines, Union of Republican Forces UFRF Union des forces républiques fondamentales, Union of Fundamentalist Republican Forces UN United Nations UNDP United Nations Development Program UNHCR Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees UNICEF United Nations Children’s Fund UNSC United Nations Security Council 5 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Article 53 criteria 1. In determining whether there is a reasonable basis to proceed with an investigation, the Rome Statute (“Statute”) of the International Criminal Court (“ICC”) provides that the Prosecutor shall consider the factors set out in article 53(1)(a)-(c), namely in relation to: jurisdiction (temporal, material, and either territorial or personal jurisdiction); admissibility (complementarity and gravity); and the interests of justice. The standard of proof for proceeding with an investigation into a situation under the Statute is ‘reasonable basis’. Although the Office is not required to publicise its report when acting pursuant to a referral under article 53(1), it has decided to do so in the interests of promoting clarity with respect to its statutory activities and decisions. This report on the Situation in the Central African Republic (“CAR”) II is based on information gathered by the Office from December 2012 to August 2014. Procedural history 2. The Office has been analysing the recent situation in the CAR since the end of 2012. During the course of 2013, the Office issued three statements in relation to the situation in the CAR. 3. On 9 December 2013, the Prosecutor expressed her concerns over the unfolding events in the CAR, in particular over reports of serious on-going crimes. The Prosecutor called upon all parties involved in the conflict (including Séléka elements and other militia groups, such as anti-balaka) to stop attacking civilians and committing crimes or to risk being investigated and prosecuted by the Office. 1 4. On 7 February 2014, the Prosecutor announced that the incidents and serious allegations of crimes potentially falling within the jurisdiction of the ICC constituted a new situation unrelated to the situation previously referred