DOCSLIB.ORG

A Friend in Need...1) Your Friend Is Saying Something VERY Wrong

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
A Friend in Need...1) Your Friend Is Saying Something VERY Wrong A Friend in Need.... 1) Your friend is saying something VERY wrong here. While it's true that the integral converges, that is NOT the reason. Certainly, functions that DONT go to zero cannot have convergent improper integrals, but improper integrals of functions that DO go to zero can do anything they want (just like a limit of type 0 · 1). This is the whole reason that we study improper integrals and series!!! You should explain to your friend that it's true that any positive decreasing function like this one will have an increasing concave down antiderivative. Yet, some increasing concave down functions go to infinity e.g. ln(x) while some never even reach one e.g. 1 1− x . The limit she evaluated only tells you that the slope of the antiderivative is even- tually trending toward zero- the question is: is it doing so quickly as the antiderivative approaches a finite vertical asymptote, or is it doing so slowly as the antiderivative increases to infinity? To do the problem correctly, your friend should integrate the function and take the limit. Alternatively, she could argue that since this is a continuous decreasing function, P1 1 n and n=1( e ) is a convergent geometric series, this integral must converge by the integral test. R 1 dx 2) 0 x2 converges by the p-test. R 1 dx Your friend did not notice that the integral was starting at zero. 0 xp does not 1 converge for any p. While x2 is good at getting to zero as x approaches infinity, it is symmetrically good at rushing up to infinity as x approaches zero. R 1 dx R 1 dx R 1 dx Since 0 x2 = 0 x2 + 1 x2 = divergent + convergent = divergent P P P 3) The rule that an +bn = an + bn only applies when all of the sums involved con- verge. This was a homework exercise you may recall. She should use partial fractions 3 to make this into a telescoping sum that goes to 4 cos(πn) 4) These terms are not alternating! In order to use the alternating series test, n would have to be positive for all n. In reality, cos(πn) = (−1)n, so every term of 1 P1 (−1)ncos(πn) P1 1 this series actually equals n . Thus, n=1 n = n=1 n which is a divergent p-series. 5) While it's true that x = 1 makes this a geometric series, any value of x would make P1 xn P1 x n this geometric! Which values of x will converge? Well, n=1 2n = n=1( 2 ) , which x converges if and only if j 2 j < 1 i.e. −2 < x < 2 6) Oh no, don't break up the denominator! Honestly, graders hate that. Doing so can easily make a problem impossible to solve (especially when you're doing integrals), or so easy that the solution is trivial. This series could easily be directly or limit compared P1 1 with n=1 n3 , a convergent p-series. 7) This formula only applies when jrj < 1 and the series converges! This series is very divergent by the nth term test. Furthermore, her indexes and powers don't match up for the geometric series formula. 8) Hm, looks like she mixed up the statement of the Ratio Test. You are supposed to look at the limit of an+1 , but she is looking at the reciprocal. After flipping her fractions an around, the limit will be 0 and the series converges by the ratio test. She should have realized that n! is MUCH larger than any power of n in the long term, so the series really ought to converge. 9) Oh noooooo! Every positive series has an increasing partial sum, and they certainly don't all diverge! She should know that not every increasing sequence diverges (in particular, we have a theorem that any bounded monotonic sequence converges). Sim- ilarly, not every increasing function goes to infinity. It matters a LOT how quickly the terms of the sequence of partial sums are increasing. You should show her that P1 1 n=1 n2 has increasing partial sums but the series converges, so she'll see the flaw in her reasoning. She should have said the sum diverged since it was a p-series with p ≤ 1 10) Her inequality is false. When you make the denominator bigger, the fraction gets smaller. She would be better off avoiding inequalities entirely by using the limit com- parison test. The worst mistakes seem to be in questions 1 and 9 they show that your friend really does not understand how series behave (or how functions can behave as the go toward infinity). Thinking that 7 converges and 8 diverges is not a great sign either. You should always take a moment to consider what you know about the relative strengths of the numerator and denominator before you begin a problem. Usually, reasoning to yourself why the series con- verges will actually give you a hint as to which test to use! (especially if a limit comparison is possible) Your friend should definitely talk to her instructor. She doesn't seem to really under- stand why some series converge and others diverge, or how and why the convergence tests work. With her instructor, she should make a plan to catch up that includes a one-on-one explanation, extra exercises, reading the book, office hours, etc. She should also try going to the math support center and attending Math 1102 for the rest of the semester..
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Series: Convergence and Divergence Comparison Tests
    Series: Convergence and Divergence Here is a compilation of what we have done so far (up to the end of October) in terms of convergence and divergence. • Series that we know about: P∞ n Geometric Series: A geometric series is a series of the form n=0 ar . The series converges if |r| < 1 and 1 a1 diverges otherwise . If |r| < 1, the sum of the entire series is 1−r where a is the first term of the series and r is the common ratio. P∞ 1 2 p-Series Test: The series n=1 np converges if p1 and diverges otherwise . P∞ • Nth Term Test for Divergence: If limn→∞ an 6= 0, then the series n=1 an diverges. Note: If limn→∞ an = 0 we know nothing. It is possible that the series converges but it is possible that the series diverges. Comparison Tests: P∞ • Direct Comparison Test: If a series n=1 an has all positive terms, and all of its terms are eventually bigger than those in a series that is known to be divergent, then it is also divergent. The reverse is also true–if all the terms are eventually smaller than those of some convergent series, then the series is convergent. P P P That is, if an, bn and cn are all series with positive terms and an ≤ bn ≤ cn for all n sufficiently large, then P P if cn converges, then bn does as well P P if an diverges, then bn does as well. (This is a good test to use with rational functions.
    [Show full text]
  • Drainage Geocomposite Workshop
    January/February 2000 Volume 18, Number 1 Drainage geocomposite workshop By Gregory N. Richardson, Sam R. Allen, C. Joel Sprague A number of recent designer’s columns have focused on the design of drainage geocomposites (Richard- son and Zhao, 1998), so only areas of concern are discussed here. Two design considerations requiring the most consideration by a designer are: 1) assumed rate of fluid inflow draining into the geocomposite, and 2) long-term reduction and safety factors required to assure adequate performance over the service life of the drainage system. In regions of the United States that are not arid or semi-arid, a reasonable upper limit for inflow into a drainage layer can be estimated by assuming that the soil immediately above the drain layer is saturated. This saturation produces a unit gradient flow in the overlying soil such that the inflow rate, r, is approximately θ equal to the permeability of the soil, ksoil. The required transmissivity, , of the drainage layer is then equal to: θ = r*L/i = ksoil*L/i where L is the effective drainage length of the geocomposite and i is the flow gradient (head change/flow length). This represents an upper limit for flow into the geocomposite. In arid and semi-arid regions of the USA saturation of the soil layers may be an overly conservative assumption, however, no alternative rec- ommendations can currently be given. Regardless of the assumed r value, a geocomposite drainage layer must be designed such that flow is not in- advertently restricted prior to removal from the drain.
    [Show full text]
  • Summary of Tests for Series Convergence
    Calculus Maximus Notes 9: Convergence Summary Summary of Tests for Infinite Series Convergence Given a series an or an n1 n0 The following is a summary of the tests that we have learned to tell if the series converges or diverges. They are listed in the order that you should apply them, unless you spot it immediately, i.e. use the first one in the list that applies to the series you are trying to test, and if that doesn’t work, try again. Off you go, young Jedis. Use the Force. Remember, it is always with you, and it is mass times acceleration! nth-term test: (Test for Divergence only) If liman 0 , then the series is divergent. If liman 0 , then the series may converge or diverge, so n n you need to use a different test. Geometric Series Test: If the series has the form arn1 or arn , then the series converges if r 1 and diverges n1 n0 a otherwise. If the series converges, then it converges to 1 . 1 r Integral Test: In Prison, Dogs Curse: If an f() n is Positive, Decreasing, Continuous function, then an and n1 f() n dn either both converge or both diverge. 1 This test is best used when you can easily integrate an . Careful: If the Integral converges to a number, this is NOT the sum of the series. The series will be smaller than this number. We only know this it also converges, to what is anyone’s guess. The maximum error, Rn , for the sum using Sn will be 0 Rn f x dx n Page 1 of 4 Calculus Maximus Notes 9: Convergence Summary p-series test: 1 If the series has the form , then the series converges if p 1 and diverges otherwise.
    [Show full text]
  • The Direct Comparison Test (Day #1)
    9.4--The Direct Comparison Test (day #1) When applying the Direct Comparison Test, you will usually compare a tricky series against a geometric series or a p-series whose convergence/divergence is already known. Use the Direct Comparison Test to determine the convergence or divergence of the series: ∞ 1) 1 3 n + 7 n=1 9.4--The Direct Comparison Test (day #1) Use the Direct Comparison Test to determine the convergence or divergence of the series: ∞ 2) 1 n - 2 n=3 Use the Direct Comparison Test to determine the convergence or divergence of the series: ∞ 3) 5n n 2 - 1 n=1 9.4--The Direct Comparison Test (day #1) Use the Direct Comparison Test to determine the convergence or divergence of the series: ∞ 4) 1 n 4 + 3 n=1 9.4--The Limit Comparison Test (day #2) The Limit Comparison Test is useful when the Direct Comparison Test fails, or when the series can't be easily compared with a geometric series or a p-series. 9.4--The Limit Comparison Test (day #2) Use the Limit Comparison Test to determine the convergence or divergence of the series: 5) ∞ 3n2 - 2 n3 + 5 n=1 Use the Limit Comparison Test to determine the convergence or divergence of the series: 6) ∞ 4n5 + 9 10n7 n=1 9.4--The Limit Comparison Test (day #2) Use the Limit Comparison Test to determine the convergence or divergence of the series: 7) ∞ 1 n 4 - 1 n=1 Use the Limit Comparison Test to determine the convergence or divergence of the series: 8) ∞ 5 3 2 n - 6 n=1 9.4--Comparisons of Series (day #3) (This is actually a review of 9.1-9.4) page 630--Converging or diverging? Tell which test you used.
    [Show full text]
  • Series Convergence Tests Math 122 Calculus III D Joyce, Fall 2012
    Series Convergence Tests Math 122 Calculus III D Joyce, Fall 2012 Some series converge, some diverge. Geometric series. We've already looked at these. We know when a geometric series 1 X converges and what it converges to. A geometric series arn converges when its ratio r lies n=0 a in the interval (−1; 1), and, when it does, it converges to the sum . 1 − r 1 X 1 The harmonic series. The standard harmonic series diverges to 1. Even though n n=1 1 1 its terms 1, 2 , 3 , . approach 0, the partial sums Sn approach infinity, so the series diverges. The main questions for a series. Question 1: given a series does it converge or diverge? Question 2: if it converges, what does it converge to? There are several tests that help with the first question and we'll look at those now. The term test. The only series that can converge are those whose terms approach 0. That 1 X is, if ak converges, then ak ! 0. k=1 Here's why. If the series converges, then the limit of the sequence of its partial sums n th X approaches the sum S, that is, Sn ! S where Sn is the n partial sum Sn = ak. Then k=1 lim an = lim (Sn − Sn−1) = lim Sn − lim Sn−1 = S − S = 0: n!1 n!1 n!1 n!1 The contrapositive of that statement gives a test which can tell us that some series diverge. Theorem 1 (The term test). If the terms of the series don't converge to 0, then the series diverges.
    [Show full text]
  • Long Term Test of Buffer Material. Final Report on the Pilot Parcels
    SEO100048 Technical Report TR-00-22 Long term test of buffer material Final report on the pilot parcels Ola Karnland, Torbjorn Sanden, Lars-Erik Johannesson Clay Technology AB Trygve E Eriksen, Mats Jansson, Susanna Wold Royal Institute of Technology Karsten Pedersen, Mehrdad Motamedi Goteborg University Bo Rosborg Studsvik Material AB December 2000 Svensk Karnbranslehantering AB Swedish Nuclear Fuel and Waste Management Co Box 5864 102 40 Stockholm Tel 08-459 84 00 Fax 08-661 57 19 32/ 07 PLEASE BE AWARE THAT ALL OF THE MISSING PAGES IN THIS DOCUMENT WERE ORIGINALLY BLANK Long term test of buffer material Final report on the pilot parcels Ola Karnland, Torbjorn Sanden, Lars-Erik Johannesson Clay Technology AB Trygve E Eriksen, Mats Jansson, Susanna Wold Royal Institute of Technology Karsten Pedersen, Mehrdad Motamedi Goteborg University Bo Rosborg Studsvik Material AB December 2000 Keywords: bacteria, bentonite, buffer, clay, copper, corrosion, diffusion, field experiment, LOT, mineralogy, montmorillonite, physical properties, repository, Aspo. This report concerns a study, which was conducted for SKB. The conclusions and viewpoints presented in the report are those of the authors and do not necessarily coincide with those of the client. Abstract The "Long Term Test of Buffer Material" (LOT) series at the Aspo HRL aims at checking models and hypotheses for a bentonite buffer material under conditions similar to those in a KBS3 repository. The test series comprises seven test parcels, which are exposed to repository conditions for 1, 5 and 20 years. This report concerns the two completed pilot tests (1-year tests) with respect to construction, field data and laboratory results.
    [Show full text]
  • Dear Undergraduate Advisor, I'm Writing to Give You Some Information
    Dear Undergraduate Advisor, I’m writing to give you some information about the introductory courses that the Mathematics Depart- ment will run this academic year, as well as other courses your students may be interested in. A descrip- tion of the topics covered in each course is included in this packet; please take a look at the topic lists for the courses that you want your concentrators to take. If you don’t find a particular topic that you feel should be required, or you’d like to talk more generally about course content, please email me at [email protected]. Here is a brief synopsis of the courses. First, our introductory courses: • Math Ma,b is a two semester sequence that integrates calculus with pre-calculus. The Math M sequence covers all of the material in Math 1a, so a student who completes the Math M sequence is ready for Math 1b. Math Ma is offered in the fall, and Math Mb is offered in the spring. • Math 1a is a fairly standard first-semester calculus course, covering differential calculus and an introduction to integral calculus. It is taught both semesters but in slightly different formats — in the fall, it is taught in sections of 20-30 students; in the spring, it is taught in a single class. We encourage students to take Math 1a in the fall, both because of the smaller section size and because this gives students the option of switching to Math Ma if that seems appropriate. • Math 1b is second-semester calculus, covering applications of integration, series, and differential equations.
    [Show full text]
  • Solutions to the Second Exam for Mathematics 1B April 15, 2004
    Solutions to the Second Exam for Mathematics 1b April 15, 2004 1. (a) answers: (ii) and (iii). (iii) is the definition of convergence. If a series converges, then its terms must approach 0. Neither (v) nor (vi) need be true. For example, think about an alternating series. (i) is definitely false. P∞ 1 (b) i. Not necessarily true. For example, consider k=1 k . This series, the har- monic series, diverges (this can be proven using the integral test), and yet 1 limk→∞ k = 0. 1 P∞ k ii. Not necessarily. For example, the Taylor series for f(x) = 1−x = k=0 x converges only for |x| < 1. P∞ k (Note: some people thought that the series k=1 akx is necessarily a geo- k 1 metric series. This is not so. Let f(x) = e for instance. ak = k! and the series is not geometric (and converges for all x.) (c) The center of the series is −3. The radius of convergence is greater than or equal to 4 and less than or equal to 5. Recall that at the endpoints −3−R and −3+R the series may converge or may diverge. Therefore, the series is certain to converge for x ∈ (−7, 1]. The series is certain to diverge for x ≥ 2 or x < −8. P∞ 3n 2. (a) Converges, by direct comparison to n=1 5n . 3n 3n P∞ 3n 5n+3n < 5n . n=1 5n converges, since it is a geometric series with |r| = 3/5 < 1. P∞ 1 (b) Diverges, by limit comparison to n=1 n .
    [Show full text]
  • Mathematics 116 Term Test Or Test for Divergence to Apply the Term Test
    Mathematics 116 Term Test or Test for Divergence To apply the Term Test (for Divergence): ∞ Testing an for convergence or divergence. X Investigate lim an. n →∞ ∞ If lim an = 0, conclude that an diverges. n →∞ 6 X∞ If lim an = 0, conclude that an has a chance to converge but further testing is needed to n →∞ decide whether it does or not. TheX series an might converge or it might diverge. In sum, the Term Test give no information in this case.X A formal look at why the Term Test is legitimate. Theorem. If lim Sn = L for some number L, then lim an = 0. In other words, if the partial-sum n n sequence converges,→∞ then the term sequence must converge→∞ to 0. Proof. The idea behind the proof is to find a way to write an by using the partial-sum sequence. Notice that an = Sn Sn 1. Now suppose that lim Sn = L (where L is a number, not or − n − →∞ ∞ ). Then lim Sn 1 = L, as well. Use the appropriate limit theorem for sequences we can write n − −∞ →∞ lim an = lim (Sn Sn 1) = lim Sn lim Sn 1 = L L = 0. n n − n n − →∞ →∞ − →∞ − →∞ − By what’s often called contraposition, we can reformulate this theorem in a different way. Corollary. If lim an = 0 (in other words if this limit either does not exist at all or is not zero), n →∞ 6 ∞ then an diverges. X Proof. Contraposing the previous theorem tells us that if lim an = 0, then lim Sn cannot be a n n →∞ 6 →∞ ∞ number, and the definition of convergence for series then tells us that an diverges.
    [Show full text]
  • RATIO and ROOT TEST for SERIES of NONNEGATIVE TERMS Elizabeth Wood
    RATIO AND ROOT TEST FOR SERIES OF NONNEGATIVE TERMS Elizabeth Wood Here are the last two tests we can use to determine the convergence or divergence of a series of nonnegative terms. THE RATIO TEST THE RATIO TEST a. the series converges if < 1 b. the series diverges if > 1 or is infinite c. the test is inconclusive if = 1. EXAMPLE Does the following series converge or diverge? 1: SOLUTION: Since this series has a factorial in it, I am going to use the ratio test. FACT: The ratio test works well with series that include factorials and exponentials in there nth term. EXAMPLE Does the following series converge or diverge? 2: SOLUTION: Since this series has an exponential term included in it, I will use the ratio test to determine the convergence or divergence of this series. Source URL: http://faculty.eicc.edu/bwood/ma155supplemental/supplemental23.htm Saylor URL: http://www.saylor.org/courses/ma102/ © Elizabeth Wood (http://faculty.eicc.edu/bwood/) Saylor.org Used by Permission. 1 of 4 Therefore, this series converges by the ratio test. EXAMPLE 3: Does the following series converge or diverge? SOLUTION: Since this series is made up with factorial, I will use the ratio test to determine the convergence or divergence of this series. Therefore, this series diverges by the ratio test. EXAMPLE 4: Does the following series converge or diverge? Source URL: http://faculty.eicc.edu/bwood/ma155supplemental/supplemental23.htm Saylor URL: http://www.saylor.org/courses/ma102/ © Elizabeth Wood (http://faculty.eicc.edu/bwood/) Saylor.org Used by Permission. 2 of 4 SOLUTION: Therefore, this series converge by the ratio test.
    [Show full text]
  • 9.2 NOTES-ANSWERS.Jnt
    AP CALCULUS BC Section 9.2: SERIES AND CONVERGENCE, pg. 606 INFINITE SERIES If an is an infinite sequence, the aaaaann 1234... a ... is an infinite series. (For n1 some series is convenient to begin the index at n=0) To find the sum of an infinite series, consider the following sequence of partial sums. Sa11 Saa212 Saaa3123 ... Saaann123... a If this sequence of partial sums converges, the series is said to converge and has the sum indicated in the following definition. AP CALCULUS BC Section 9.2: SERIES AND CONVERGENCE, pg. 606 Sample problem #1: CONVERGENT AND DIVERGENT SERIES Determine if the given series is convergent or divergent. 3 a) 3 n2 52n AP CALCULUS BC Section 9.2: SERIES AND CONVERGENCE, pg. 606 n 4 b) n1 3 AP CALCULUS BC Section 9.2: SERIES AND CONVERGENCE, pg. 606 11 c) n1 nn1 The series in (c) is a telescoping series of the form bb12 bb 23 bb 34 bb 45 ... Note that all b(s), from b2 to bn , are canceled, therefore in a telescoping series Sbbnn 11 It follows that a telescoping series will converge if and only if bn approaches a finite number as n . Moreover, if the series converges, its sum is Sb 11 lim bn n AP CALCULUS BC Section 9.2: SERIES AND CONVERGENCE, pg. 606 Sample problem #2: WRITING SERIES IN TELESCOPING FORM 3 Determine the sum of the series 2 n1 12n 2 AP CALCULUS BC Section 9.2: SERIES AND CONVERGENCE, pg. 606 GEOMETRIC SERIES A geometric series has the form arnn a ara r 2 ..
    [Show full text]
  • Syllabus for Math 297 Winter Term 2019 Classes MWF 1-2:30, 3866
    Syllabus for Math 297 Winter Term 2019 Classes MWF 1-2:30, 3866 East Hall Instructor: Stephen DeBacker Office: 4076 East Hall Phone: 724-763-3274 e-mail: [email protected] Office hours: DeBacker’s: M: 10:45 – 11:45am; M: 8:30 – 9:30pm; T: 2 – 3pm ; θ: 11 pm – midnight Annie’s: W: 7 – 8pm (EH3866) Problem Session: T: 4 – 5pm (EH3866) Text: Abbott, Stephen. Understanding Analysis, Second edition. Undergraduate Texts in Mathematics. Springer, New York, 2015. ISBN: 978-1-4939-2711-1.1 Philosophy: “He was not fast. Speed means nothing. Math doesn’t depend on speed. It is about deep.” (Yuriu Burago commenting on Fields Medal winner Grigory Perelman in Sylvia Nasar and David Gruber, Manifold Destiny, The New Yorker, August 28, 2006, pp. 44–57.) An Overview: It is assumed that you have acquired a solid foundation in the theoretical aspects of linear algebra (as in Math 217). This includes familiarity with how to read and write proofs; the notions of linear independence, basis, spanning sets; linear transformations; eigenvalues and eigenvectors; the spectral theorem; and basic results about inner product spaces including the Gram-Schmidt process. This is a course in analysis, the study of how/why calculus works. Over the course of the semester, we will develop an appreciation for the importance of the completeness and ordering of R. We will also learn how to read, write, and understand "–δ style arguments as we cover topics including basic topology, uniform continuity, and the properties of derivatives, definite integrals, and infinite sequences and series. To the extent possible, we will carry out our investigations in the setting of inner product spaces.
    [Show full text]