DOCSLIB.ORG

Changing Definition of Debentures – Forcing Impasse for Commercial Papers in Times to Come?

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Changing Definition of Debentures – Forcing Impasse for Commercial Papers in Times to Come? Article Changing definition of Debentures – Forcing impasse for commercial papers in times to come? Nidhi Bothra [email protected] 13th May, 2014 Check at: http://india-financing.com/staff-publications.html for more write ups. Copyright: This write up is the property of Vinod Kothari Consultants P. Ltd. and no part of it can be copied, reproduced or distributed in any manner. Disclaimer: This write up is intended to initiate academic debate on a pertinent question. It is not intended to be a professional advice and should not be relied upon for real life facts. Changing definition of Debentures – Forcing impasse for commercial papers in times to come? Article The new Companies Act 2013 has changed the regulatory face of the corporate India; “raising the bar on Corporate Governance.” The new regulatory changes including need for CSR activities, increased investor protection, greater transparency in business and have been the larger issues of discussion with the elite section of the corporate sector. However smaller refinements in the new Act against the old one have also created quite a buzz. Recently an issue was raised by some members of the legal fraternity on an age old settled issue of the difference between negotiable instruments and transferable/ marketable instruments and whether the new definition of “debentures” u/s 2 (30) of the Companies Act, 2013 now includes instruments such as commercial paper as well. Some of the counsels are holding the view that commercial paper will now be included within the ambit of the definition of debentures forcing people to re-think on a question that must have been concluded some hundreds of years ago. This article tries to discuss the merit in the thought. What is the change? To be able to see the genesis of the discussion one needs to see the change that has been introduced vis-à-vis the Act, 1956. Textually the changes are small but none the less it is extremely crucial to address their interpretation so as not to start on the wrong foot from the very beginning. Section 2 (12) of the Companies Act 1956 debentures were defined as- ‘debenture’ includes debenture stock, bonds and any other securities of a company, whether constituting a charge on the assets of the company or not” Under the Act, 2013 the definition of debentures u/s 2 (30) has been changed to: ‘debenture’ includes debenture stock, bonds and any other instrument evidencing a debt, whether constituting a charge on the assets of the company or not”. Syntactically the new definition replaces “any other securities” with “any other instrument evidencing a debt”. Debenture is creation or acknowledgment of debt instrument whether or not it constitutes charge over the assets of the company. The intent of the law makers with the change seemingly is to include any such instrument which is in garb is nothing but an instrument evidencing debt, i.e. debentures even if by nomenclature it may be any different1. Commercial paper on the other hand is in the form 1 In its judgment in Narendra Kumar Maheshwari vs Union of India, 1990 case, Supreme Court has defined debentures to mean essentially as an acknowledgement of debt, with a commitment to repay the principal with interest. Changing definition of Debentures – Forcing impasse for commercial papers in times to come? Article of usance, a promissory note2 negotiable by endorsement and delivery. It is a short-term unsecured promissory note sold by large business firms to raise funds. At the first blush, if commercial paper being a promissory note can be included in the definition of debentures then any negotiable instrument could be included in the definition of debentures as well. The intent of the lawmakers could not have been to include negotiable instruments within its periphery at all. In the case of Essar Steel Ltd. vs. Gramercy Emerging Market Fund3, judgment dated 17 October, 2002, the company had issued floating rate notes (FRNs) and the issuer company defaulted in paying the dues in connection with the notes and hence the note holders took the company for winding up. The defence by the issuer company among other things also included that the FRN holders were not debenture holders or holders of any security as contemplated by the Companies Act read with the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956. The relevant extracts of the ruling are reproduced below – The fundamental purpose underlying Securities Acts is to eliminate serious abuses in a largely unregulated securities market. There is virtually limitless scope of human ingenuity especially in the creation of the numerous schemes devised by those who seek the use of money of others on promise of profits. The inclusive definition of the term 'security' is wide enough to include within that definition many types of instruments that might be sold as an investment. The term 'Note' is relatively broad to encompass instruments having different characteristics depending on whether issued in a consumer context as a commercial paper or in some other investment context. If the notes are issued in a commercial or consumer context, they will not be treated as securities while those issued in investment context would be securities. Whether the Note is issued in investment context can be ascertained on the basis of the circumstances surrounding the transactions. In order to determine whether a transaction involves a 'security', the transaction has to be examined to assess the motivations that would prompt a reasonable seller and buyer to enter into it. If the seller's purpose is to raise money for the general use of a business enterprise or to finance substantial investments and the buyer is interested primarily in the profit the note is expected to generate, the instrument is likely to be a 'security'. On the other hand, if the note is exchanged to facilitate the purchase and sale of a minor asset or consumer goods, or to advance some other commercial or consumer purpose, such note cannot be classified as 'security'. One other factor 2 Section 4 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 defines a promissory note as - an instrument in writing (not being a bank-note or a currency note) containing an unconditional undertaking signed by the maker, to pay a certain sum of money only to, or to the order of, a certain person, or to the bearer of the instrument. 3 2003 116 CompCas 248 Guj, http://www.indiankanoon.org/doc/1142750/ Changing definition of Debentures – Forcing impasse for commercial papers in times to come? Article to be examined would be whether the Note in question is an instrument in which there is common trading for speculation or investment and how is it views by the investing public [See Reves v. Ernst & Young 494 US 56 (1990)]4. The ruling clearly explains that any instrument cannot be considered to be a security, one has to look at the intent whether the instrument was representing commercial loan or was it issued for investment and trading. In several Indian and U.S. rulings the question has been considered but in the context of U.S. law the purpose of debentures being defined in the Indian law is completely different. The intent in India it is to regulate issue of debentures by companies and provide for debenture redemption reserve, debenture trustees etc to ensure that the investors interest is protected at all times. Commercial paper on the other hand is a money market instrument, largely issued for working capital needs of the business houses. Conclusion If for the sake of argument one had to include commercial paper within the periphery of debentures, any issuance of commercial paper would also require maintenance of DRR, liquid funds for yearly redemption (not to forget these are less than a year instrument), trustee and so on, apart from the RBI guidelines existing on the instrument already. Money market instruments are regulated by RBI as per the powers vested in RBI by virtue of Section 45W of the RBI Act and there are already elaborate guidelines laid down with regard to issuance of commercial paper already. Such onerous compliance requirements surely would neither have been envisaged by the lawmakers nor could have been required considering the short-term nature of the instrument. Further, Section 1 (4) (e) of the Companies Act, 2013 states that the provisions of the Special Act shall prevail over the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013. Considering the fact that commercial paper issuance is regulated by RBI under the powers derived from the RBI Act which is a special Act, commercial paper shall continue to be regulated by RBI and cannot be considered under the so called inclusive and expansive definition of debentures under the Companies Act, 2013. Commercial paper has existed for almost 500 years and nay, debentures have also existed for 500 years. There is nothing new in the definition of debentures in the Act, 2013 and the definition was substantively the same earlier as well. One cannot interpret the law so 4 In case of Reves v. Ernst & Young, Fletcher International Ltd vs. ION Geophysical Corp., Pollack v. Laidlaw Holdings, Inc., 27 F.3d 808, 813 (2d Cir. 1994), the Courts held that all notes are presumptively securities, unless presumption is rebutted. The Courts used the „family resemblance test‟ to examine the question whether a note in question is an investment or whether the note represents a commercial or consumer loan transaction. The Court held that short-term notes that are situational to the particular lender and borrower, and not the types of instruments that are easily traded. if the note in question looks more like a corporate bond, debenture, or other instrument the value of which rises and falls with the success of the issuer‟s business, has a term of several years, and is easily traded, then that presumption will not be rebutted, because the note will not bear a strong resemblance to any of the notes listed in Reves for the basic reason that such a note is easily characterized as an investment, and thus a security.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Corporate Bonds and Debentures
    Corporate Bonds and Debentures FCS Vinita Nair Vinod Kothari Company Kolkata: New Delhi: Mumbai: 1006-1009, Krishna A-467, First Floor, 403-406, Shreyas Chambers 224 AJC Bose Road Defence Colony, 175, D N Road, Fort Kolkata – 700 017 New Delhi-110024 Mumbai Phone: 033 2281 3742/7715 Phone: 011 41315340 Phone: 022 2261 4021/ 6237 0959 Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected] Website: www.vinodkothari.com 1 Copyright & Disclaimer . This presentation is only for academic purposes; this is not intended to be a professional advice or opinion. Anyone relying on this does so at one’s own discretion. Please do consult your professional consultant for any matter covered by this presentation. The contents of the presentation are intended solely for the use of the client to whom the same is marked by us. No circulation, publication, or unauthorised use of the presentation in any form is allowed, except with our prior written permission. No part of this presentation is intended to be solicitation of professional assignment. 2 About Us Vinod Kothari and Company, company secretaries, is a firm with over 30 years of vintage Based out of Kolkata, New Delhi & Mumbai We are a team of qualified company secretaries, chartered accountants, lawyers and managers. Our Organization’s Credo: Focus on capabilities; opportunities follow 3 Law & Practice relating to Corporate Bonds & Debentures 4 The book can be ordered by clicking here Outline . Introduction to Debentures . State of Indian Bond Market . Comparison of debentures with other forms of borrowings/securities . Types of Debentures . Modes of Issuance & Regulatory Framework .
    [Show full text]
  • Four Decades of Change in the Commercial Paper Market
    This PDF is a selection from an out-of-print volume from the National Bureau of Economic Research Volume Title: Trends and Cycles in the Commercial Paper Market Volume Author/Editor: Richard T. Selden Volume Publisher: NBER Volume ISBN: 0-87014-399-9 Volume URL: http://www.nber.org/books/seld63-1 Publication Date: 1963 Chapter Title: Four Decades of Change in the Commercial Paper Market Chapter Author: Richard T. Selden Chapter URL: http://www.nber.org/chapters/c1919 Chapter pages in book: (p. 6 - 30) 2 Four Decades of Change in the Commercial Paper Market The Market in 1920 The earliest available estimate of commercial paper outstanding is for July 1918, when the Federal Reserve Bank of New York began reporting end-of-month figures. At that time, outstanding paper of thirty dealers, who presumably handled virtually all commercial paper, was $874 million—probably a record level.' During the next year and a half, outstanding dealer paper grew by nearly 50 per cent, reaching a peak of $1,296 million in January 1920. There was no direct paper until later in that year, when General Motors Acceptance Corporation began borrowing on short-term notes without the assistance of a dealer.2 Table 1 provides perspective on the size of the market at the begin- fling of 1920. The figures show that commercial paper was a distinctly 'See Appendix A for a complete record' of monthly outstandings (without seasonal adjustment), July 1918 to December 1961. Note that before 1948 these data include only paper maturing within seven months. 2A number of other finance companies were borrowing short-term funds at this time through collateral trust notes, which in some cases were placed directly with banks (or possibly other lenders).
    [Show full text]
  • GUIDELINES for the ISSUANCE of CORPORATE BONDS, MUNICIPAL BONDS and COMMERCIAL PAPERS Issued By
    GUIDELINES FOR THE ISSUANCE OF CORPORATE BONDS, MUNICIPAL BONDS AND COMMERCIAL PAPERS Issued by: CAPITAL MARKETS AND SECURITIES AUTHORITY - TANZANIA Issue Date: September, 2019 1 Contents 1. INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................... 5 1.1. Legal and Regulatory Oversight ..................................................................................... 5 1.2. Rationale for the Guidelines ............................................................................................. 6 1.3. General Scope of the Guidelines .................................................................................... 7 PART 1: GUIDELINES FOR THE ISSUANCE OF CORPORATE BONDS ............................... 10 1.1 Scope ...................................................................................................................................... 10 1.2 Prospectus or Offering Memorandum ......................................................................... 10 1.3 Approval and Fees.............................................................................................................. 10 1.4 Other Requirements .......................................................................................................... 10 1.4.1 Solvency Requirements ................................................................................................... 11 1.4.2 Assessment of Leverage .................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Federal Reserve's Commercial Paper Funding Facility
    Tobias Adrian, Karin Kimbrough, and Dina Marchioni The Federal Reserve’s Commercial Paper Funding Facility 1.Introduction October 7, 2008, with the aim of supporting the orderly functioning of the commercial paper market. Registration for he commercial paper market experienced considerable the CPFF began October 20, 2008, and the facility became Tstrain in the weeks following Lehman Brothers’ operational on October 27. The CPFF operated as a lender- bankruptcy on September 15, 2008. The Reserve Primary of-last-resort facility for the commercial paper market. It Fund—a prime money market mutual fund with $785 million effectively extended access to the Federal Reserve’s discount in exposure to Lehman Brothers—“broke the buck” on window to issuers of commercial paper, even if these issuers September 16, triggering an unprecedented flight to quality were not chartered as commercial banks. Unlike the discount from high-yielding to Treasury-only money market funds. window, the CPFF was a temporary liquidity facility that was These broad investor flows within the money market sector authorized under section 13(3) of the Federal Reserve Act in severely disrupted the ability of commercial paper issuers to the event of “unusual and exigent circumstances.” It expired roll over their short-term liabilities. February 1, 2010.1 As redemption demands accelerated, particularly in high- The goal of the CPFF was to address temporary liquidity yielding money market mutual funds, investors became distortions in the commercial paper market by providing a increasingly reluctant to purchase commercial paper, especially backstop to U.S. issuers of commercial paper. This liquidity for longer dated maturities.
    [Show full text]
  • Sources of Business Finance
    CHAPTER 8 SOURCES OF BUSINESS FINANCE LEARNING OBJECTIVES After studying this chapter, you should be able to: • state the meaning, nature and importance of business finance; • classify the various sources of business finance; • evaluate merits and limitations of various sources of finance; • identify the international sources of finance; and • examine the factors that affect the choice of an appropriate source of finance. 2019-20 186 BUSINESS STUDIES Mr. Anil Singh has been running a restaurant for the last two years. The excellent quality of food has made the restaurant popular in no time. Motivated by the success of his business, Mr. Singh is now contemplating the idea of opening a chain of similar restaurants at different places. However, the money available with him from his personal sources is not sufficient to meet the expansion requirements of his business. His father told him that he can enter into a partnership with the owner of another restaurant, who will bring in more funds but it would also require sharing of profits and control of business. He is also thinking of getting a bank loan. He is worried and confused, as he has no idea as to how and from where he should obtain additional funds. He discusses the problem with his friend Ramesh, who tells him about some other methods like issue of shares and debentures, which are available only to a company form of organisation. He further cautions him that each method has its own advantages and limitations and his final choice should be based on factors like the purpose and period for which funds are required.
    [Show full text]
  • Frequently Asked Questions About Commercial Paper and Commercial Paper Programs
    FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS ABOUT COMMERCIAL PAPER AND COMMERCIAL PAPER PROGRAMS Why is commercial paper attractive? Understanding Commercial Paper CP is an attractive funding alternative for issuers for What is commercial paper? several reasons. First, CP issuers frequently use Commercial paper (“CP”) is a term used to refer to CP proceeds to fund short‐term liquidity needs instead short‐term debt securities that are in the form of a of relying on short‐term borrowings under revolving promissory note and have maturities of nine months or credit facilities and other lines of credit from banks. less (although typically 30 days or less). CP is usually Second, CP issuers can easily roll over CP, which means unsecured, issued in large denominations of $100,000, that the proceeds from new issuances are used to pay €100,000, £100,000 or more and sold at a discount from the obligations resulting from maturing issuances. As the face value. CP is typically non‐interest bearing. such, CP issuers can often continue to utilize CP Institutional money market investors, including money proceeds uninterrupted. Third, there are clearly defined market funds, insurance companies and banks, have exemptions from registration under the Securities Act of been the main purchasers of CP, and these purchasers 1933, as amended (the “Securities Act”), for CP. Fourth, are almost always (1) in the United States, either CP programs are relatively straightforward to set up qualified institutional buyers (“QIBs”) or institutional and do not require extensive disclosures. accredited investors (“IAIs”) and (2) in Europe, CP has been attractive to institutional money market qualified investors.
    [Show full text]
  • Report Title Here
    Executive Summary SIFMA Research Quarterly – 3Q19 US Fixed Income Markets December 2019 US Fixed Income Page | 1 Executive Summary Contents Executive Summary ................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Quarterly Performance ............................................................................................................................................................................... 5 Chart Book: Total Fixed Income ................................................................................................................................................................. 6 Chart Book: US Treasuires (UST) .............................................................................................................................................................. 7 Chart Book: Mortgage-Backed Securities (MBS) ....................................................................................................................................... 9 Chart Book: Corporate Bonds (Corporates) ............................................................................................................................................. 10 Chart Book: Municipal Securities (Munis) ................................................................................................................................................. 12 Chart Book: Federal Agency Securities (Agency) ...................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Model Commercial Paper Dealer Agreement Guidance Notes
    Model Commercial Paper Dealer Agreement Guidance Notes [4(2) Program; Guaranteed] The Bond Market Association (“the Association”) is publishing a guaranteed form of Model Commercial Paper Dealer Agreement (the “Agreement”) for use by issuers and dealers in establishing guaranteed commercial paper programs which are exempt from registration under the U.S. Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the “1933 Act”), pursuant to the exemption contained in Section 4(2) of the 1933 Act. A separate model agreement is being published contemporaneously herewith, for use in establishing commercial paper programs which are exempt from 1933 Act registration pursuant to the exemption contained in Section 3(a)(3) of the 1933 Act. After consideration by representatives of market participants, it was decided that a guaranteed form of model commercial paper agreement would be useful in providing guidance to market participants and would also provide increased consistency and precision in documenting the relationship among issuers, guarantors and dealers of commercial paper. As with other Association model agreements, use of this Agreement is not intended to be mandatory, and indeed even the firms that participated in its preparation may vary its terms from transaction to transaction. However, it is hoped that market participants will become comfortable with most of the Agreement’s provisions, thereby limiting negotiation in any particular case to a relatively small number of provisions. To assist users of the Agreement, the Association has prepared the following Guidance Notes that explain certain sections of the Agreement. They are aimed principally at issuers and guarantors and their counsels, who may be unfamiliar with this model agreement and the reasons behind certain of its provisions.
    [Show full text]
  • Download Fixed Income Brochure
    Amplify your potential with Fixed Income BNY Mellon. It’s all right here. BNY Mellon Capital Markets, LLC, member FINRA/SIPC For US Institutional Distribution Only “Whether you’re looking for exceptional fixed income execution or world-class custody, at BNY Mellon, we give you the best of both worlds.” Adam Vos Head of BNY Mellon Markets 2 3 Fixed Income Why Choose at BNY Mellon BNY Mellon? We’ve been at the forefront of US fixed income Whether you’re simply seeking exposure to debt securities since the founding of the nation. or you’re a custody* client looking to enhance the performance of your assets, our fixed income offering is guided by six principles designed to help you achieve your goals. Warrant No. 1 issued by The facilitating primary and secondary 1. TRANSACTION EFFICIENCY Bank of New York on September trading in instruments from Transacting within our custody construct enables you to access straight- 13, 1789, represented the first US Treasuries to commercial through processing at settlement. This means as soon as your transaction tranche of a $200,000 loan to the paper and corporate bonds to settles, your cash or securities are in your account and available. newly established US government, mortgage-backed securities. extended to enable the fledging 2. MARKET CONNECTIVITY body to commence repayment Our fixed income specialists are We can connect you to a unique universe of counterparties, including of its Revolutionary War debt. here to assist you in meeting your 1,300 broker-dealers, fund managers, registered investment advisors, investment goals, informed by family offices and wealth managers through the Pershing network,** More than 230 years later, BNY decades of market experience over 5,000 credit unions and a large community of small and midsize Mellon remains at the center and supported by advanced US mortgage banks.
    [Show full text]
  • Schedule Rc-B – Securities
    FFIEC 031 and 041 RC-B - SECURITIES SCHEDULE RC-B – SECURITIES General Instructions This schedule has four columns for information on securities: two columns for held-to-maturity securities and two columns for available-for-sale securities.1 Report the amortized cost and fair value of held-to- maturity securities in columns A and B, respectively. Report the amortized cost and fair value of available-for-sale debt securities in columns C and D, respectively. Information on equity securities with readily determinable fair values is reported in the columns for available-for-sale securities only (columns C and D). For these equity securities, historical cost (not amortized cost) is reported in column C and fair value is reported in column D. Exclude from this schedule all securities held for trading and securities the bank has elected to report at fair value under a fair value option even if bank management did not acquire the securities principally for the purpose of selling them in the near term. Securities held for trading and securities reported under a fair value option are to be reported in Schedule RC, item 5, "Trading assets," and, for certain banks, in Schedule RC-D – Trading Assets and Liabilities. Trading assets and securities reported under a fair value option are also reported in Schedule RC-Q – Financial Assets and Liabilities Measured at Fair Value. In general, amortized cost is the purchase price of a debt security adjusted for amortization of premium or accretion of discount if the debt security was purchased at other than par or face value.
    [Show full text]
  • Commercial Paper Commercial Paper
    HNW_NRG_C_Inset_Mask Commercial paper Overview For many corporations, borrowing short-term money from banks is often a labored and annoying task. Their desire to avoid banks as much as possible has led to the widespread popularity of commercial paper. Commercial paper is typically an Commercial paper • Commercial paper trades unsecured, short-term funding option characteristics short-term credit ratings issued by a corporation, typically • Used initially to provide short-term and has varied buyers for financing accounts receivable funding for working capital 3(a)3 • Short-term ratings A1+, A1, A2, A3; and inventories. The corporation is no long-term rating required called the borrower, and buyers— • Exempt from registration and individuals or institutional, for delivery requirements • Well-established, $1.3 example—are called lenders, as • Quoted on a discount basis trillion dollar market they are funding the corporation via • Primary investors are money- the commercial paper. It is usually • Unsecured promissory note with market funds, banks, insurance issued at a discount, reflecting maturities overnight to 270 days companies, municipalities, current market interest rates. • Typical minimum denominations corporations and high- Maturities on commercial paper of $100,000 3(a)3 net-worth individuals are usually no longer than nine months, with maturities of one to • Proceeds utilized for two months being the average. current transactions Discount rate is determined on the morning of issuance For the most part, commercial • Programs rates A1+/P1 to A3/P3 • The rate is based off of a paper is a less risky investment • Appropriate for individual and spread versus LIBOR because the financial situation of institutional investors dependent a company can easily be predicted upon their investment objectives • There is no maximum rate over a few months.
    [Show full text]
  • Collateralised Loan Obligations (Clos) - a Primer Andreas A
    No. 2002/13 Collateralised Loan Obligations (CLOs) - A Primer Andreas A. Jobst Center for Financial Studies an der Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Universität § Taunusanlage 6 § D-60329 Frankfurt am Main Tel: (+49)069/242941-0 § Fax: (+49)069/242941-77 § E-Mail: [email protected] § Internet: http://www.ifk-cfs.de CFS Working Paper No. 2002/13 Collateralised Loan Obligations (CLOs) - A Primer Andreas A. Jobst* December 2002 Abstract: The following descriptive paper surveys the various types of loan securitisation and provides a working definition of so-called collateralised loan obligations (CLOs). Free of the common rhetoric and slogans, which sometimes substitute for understanding of the complex nature of structured finance, this paper describes the theoretical foundations of this specialised form of loan securitisation. Not only the distinctive properties of CLOs, but also the information economics inherent in the transfer of credit risk will be considered, so that we can equally privilege the critical aspects of security design in the structuring of CLO transactions. JEL Classification: D81, G15, G21, M20 Keywords: Loan securitisation, structured finance, CLO, ABS * London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE), Financial Markets Group (FMG), Houghton Street, London WC2A 2AE, England, U.K., and Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Universität, Lehrstuhl für Kreditwirtschaft und Finanzierung, Mertonstraße 17-21, 60325 Frankfurt am Main, Germany. E-mail: [email protected]. This paper is the result of a research project on loan securitisation, sponsored by the Deutsche Forschungs- gemeinschaft (DFG) and the Center for Financial Studies (CFS). 1 INTRODUCTION In the lexicon of previous decades financial intermediation occurred when banks and non- bank financial institutions, such as insurance companies, accepted funds from depositors or other investors and channelled these funds at some margin to businesses and households by means of lending.
    [Show full text]