The Case of Bulent Ersoy Author(S): Rustem Ertug Altinay Source: Women's Studies Quarterly, Vol

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Case of Bulent Ersoy Author(S): Rustem Ertug Altinay Source: Women's Studies Quarterly, Vol Reconstructing the Transgendered Self as a Muslim, Nationalist, Upper-Class Woman: The Case of Bulent Ersoy Author(s): Rustem Ertug Altinay Source: Women's Studies Quarterly, Vol. 36, No. 3/4, Trans- (Fall - Winter, 2008), pp. 210-229 Published by: The Feminist Press at the City University of New York Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/27649796 . Accessed: 11/02/2015 17:14 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. The Feminist Press at the City University of New York is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Women's Studies Quarterly. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 194.27.149.45 on Wed, 11 Feb 2015 17:14:25 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions RECONSTRUCTINGTHETRANSGENDERED SELFAS A MUSLIM, NATIONALIST,UPPER-CLASS WOMAN: THECASEOFBULENTERSOY RUSTEMERTUG ALTINAY Winter of Another a new of 2007. Sunday night, episode Popstar Alaturka, a version Hrant Turkish of Pop Idol. Minority and human rights activist an Tur Dink has recently been assassinated by ultranationalist youth and one key is experiencing of the few notable instances of spontaneous col in two It tens lective action the past decades.1 has been only days since of are thousands of people marched in the streets, chanting, "We all Arme to nians!" express their sympathy for Dink and the Armenian communi the ty. Hence, TV show opens with the popular Armenian folk song "Sari later in the will to a Gelin"?which, evening, lead rather long and one a interesting monologue by of the jury members. This member is in a couture glamorous lady her fifties, wearing haute dress revealing her and breasts. She long legs shapely expresses her discontent with the slogan "We are all Armenians!" Underlining the fact that she is "the Muslim no one can ever daughter of Muslim parents," she emphasizes that make or more her say she is Armenian Christian. Claiming that it would be acceptable if the slogan had been "We are all Hrant," she deems it intol erable for a Muslim person to say that s/he is Armenian?and therefore Christian. woman seems in need to But who is this glamorous who desperate an even underline her Muslim, nationalist identity? For readers who take in answer slight interest Turkish popular culture, the would be quite a on obvious. The person is Bulent Ersoy: self-proclaimed expert classical a Ottoman music?though singer of the popular genre arabesk?one of the men to sex one to first Turkish undergo change and the very first ask a a for female passport, and hater of transgendered prostitutes. Ersoy has been an extremely popular public figure in Turkey since the early 1970s to remain so. and is very likely not Following Simone de Beauvoir's claim that "one is born, but, a I to trace rather, becomes woman," in this essay seek how Bulent Ersoy [WSQiWomen's Studies Quarterly 36: 3 & 4 (Fall/Winter 2008)] ? 2008 by Rustem Ertug Altinay. All rights reserved. This content downloaded from 194.27.149.45 on Wed, 11 Feb 2015 17:14:25 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions ERTUGALTINAY 211 has "become" a woman. In I Muslim, nationalist, upper-class doing so, to aim understand the strategies that define spaces of abjection reserved in in the examine for transgendered individuals Turkey post-1980s and are to I to the tactics for survival that available them.2 will try explore in the context of events in since the Ersoy's personal history Turkey 1970s and discuss the cultural atmosphere and dynamics of gender in the in narrative. country the light of Ersoy's A YOUNG,FLAMBOYANT MALE SINGER was born as The renowned singer of classical Turkish music Bulent Ersoy Bulent Erkoc in 1952 in Istanbul. Named after a soccer player, Bulent was son an was to the only of urban middle-class family. He introduced classical Turkish music by his grandfather,who played the zither, and his the lute. Shown to have he took grandmother, who played talent, private at an lessons with acclaimed musicians early age and later attended the was a conservatory. While he still student, he began singing profession name name ally under the stage Bulent Ersoy?the Erkoc, meaning was too "brave ram," probably masculine for this rather androgynous so it was "brave young man, replaced by Ersoy, lineage." Ersoy is also on easier the tongue. first record came out in 1971. At that in Ersoy's time, nightlife the big cities, especially Istanbul, mainly consisted of Greek tavernas and nightclubs called gazinos. Those nightclubs provided the middle- and with upper-classes hours-long programs bringing together several singers as well as one comedians and belly dancers. There would often be lead an singer, called assolist, who would take the stage last and sing classical it Turkish music. The extremely competitive atmosphere made difficult to a become lead singer. At the time, many established lead singers sang arabesk, a genre influenced by Turkish folk and Middle Eastern music, that had come out inTurkey in the 1950s and 1960s. Martin Stokes, one on it is of the leading experts arabesk, claims that "a music inextricably linked with the culture of the gecekondu, literally the "night settlements" around the Men which mushroomed Turkey's large industrial cities after a deres government program of rural regeneration in the 1950s produced urban arabesk was a large rural labor surplus" (1989, 27). To the elite, new In decided to and lower-quality musical form. this context, Ersoy as a use this dissatisfaction with arabesk and constructed his public image This content downloaded from 194.27.149.45 on Wed, 11 Feb 2015 17:14:25 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 2 12 RECONSTRUCTINGTHETRANSGENDERED SELFAS A MUSLIM, NATIONALIST, UPPER-CLASS WOMAN "classicist." In other he Turkish classical music and words, appropriated it so as to a in a made his trademark win place highly competitive market. He catered to an audience that wanted to consume "authentic" or "elite" classical Turkish music as to the "commercial" vari opposed "popular," a to ety. With singing style extremely similar that of Muzeyyen Senar?a of classical Turkish who at was at popular singer music the time the height of her career in some and, sense, Ersoy's patron?he became the lead at the most was singer Maksim, prestigious nightclub in the country. He second lead at the male singer that time, after Zeki Muren (1931?96)?a male as was one flamboyant queer singer, Ersoy. In fact, could argue that Ersoy had appropriated an image with which the audience was already familiar, through Zeki Muren, who maintained it until the late 1960s, when he a that was an adopted style interesting combination of Elvis and Liberace. In other while Muren was a new words, adopting image, Ersoy was on Muren's one. name taking previous After Ersoy established his in the Turkish music he started reasons scene, singing arabesk, for financial (Tulgar 2004). This increased his both popularity and income immensely. was As customary for such singers, Ersoy, like Muren, also made a number of with stars movies popular female of the Turkish cinema. In these mainstream love would act the stories, Ersoy young, naive, maybe somewhat man. androgynous, yet heterosexual, This accorded with his public image. Even though, later,Ersoy would claim that her friends had seen as a at always her woman, the time Ersoy would be visible in the with his fake his as press fiancees, constructing image heterosexual and male. as Pinar Yet, Selek argues, Ersoy and Muren challenged the codes of masculinity in Turkey with their public personas (2007, 111). They did not have the of male as masculinity other singers such Munir Nured din Orhan or most Selcuk, Gencebay, later, Ibrahim Tatlises. Ersoy's sig nificant were his attributes probably rather naive politeness and somewhat a as androgynous style. Thus, through bodily and linguistic performance a man who was a openly gay in his private life, yet with heterosexual a public image, Bulent Ersoy opened liminal sphere that challenged the codes of masculinity. According to Selek, thiswas why he was loved by women. In the Turkish movie EvlidirNe Yapsa Yeridir,from 1978, women on a embark kind of feminist revolution; among their demands are male domestic new and to help, clothes, listening Bulent Ersoy. This content downloaded from 194.27.149.45 on Wed, 11 Feb 2015 17:14:25 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions ERT?GALTINAY213 EARLYPOST-OPERATION YEARS When was he wear a Ersoy physiologically male, would usually white tuxedo or a dark suit and bow tie. Unlike Muren, at the time, he never in or accessories appeared garments that challenged established masculine as or or wore dress codes, such mini-shorts, ostrich feathers, sequins hair or were seen on women. was styles jewelery that normally It only after treatment to on in his hormone began that he started appear stage female to cos attire. Arguably because Ersoy wanted claim the female body, his tumes were In particularly revealing. 1980, after the military coup, when she was singing in a nightclub at the Izmir International Fair, Ersoy did not its to see deny the audience desire her newly developing breasts.
Recommended publications
  • Armenophobia in Azerbaijan
    Հարգելի՛ ընթերցող, Արցախի Երիտասարդ Գիտնականների և Մասնագետների Միավորման (ԱԵԳՄՄ) նախագիծ հանդիսացող Արցախի Էլեկտրոնային Գրադարանի կայքում տեղադրվում են Արցախի վերաբերյալ գիտավերլուծական, ճանաչողական և գեղարվեստական նյութեր` հայերեն, ռուսերեն և անգլերեն լեզուներով: Նյութերը կարող եք ներբեռնել ԱՆՎՃԱՐ: Էլեկտրոնային գրադարանի նյութերն այլ կայքերում տեղադրելու համար պետք է ստանալ ԱԵԳՄՄ-ի թույլտվությունը և նշել անհրաժեշտ տվյալները: Շնորհակալություն ենք հայտնում բոլոր հեղինակներին և հրատարակիչներին` աշխատանքների էլեկտրոնային տարբերակները կայքում տեղադրելու թույլտվության համար: Уважаемый читатель! На сайте Электронной библиотеки Арцаха, являющейся проектом Объединения Молодых Учёных и Специалистов Арцаха (ОМУСA), размещаются научно-аналитические, познавательные и художественные материалы об Арцахе на армянском, русском и английском языках. Материалы можете скачать БЕСПЛАТНО. Для того, чтобы размещать любой материал Электронной библиотеки на другом сайте, вы должны сначала получить разрешение ОМУСА и указать необходимые данные. Мы благодарим всех авторов и издателей за разрешение размещать электронные версии своих работ на этом сайте. Dear reader, The Union of Young Scientists and Specialists of Artsakh (UYSSA) presents its project - Artsakh E-Library website, where you can find and download for FREE scientific and research, cognitive and literary materials on Artsakh in Armenian, Russian and English languages. If re-using any material from our site you have first to get the UYSSA approval and specify the required data. We thank all the authors
    [Show full text]
  • Azerbaijan Investment Guide 2015
    PERSPECTIVE SPORTS CULTURE & TOURISM ICT ENERGY FINANCE CONSTRUCTION GUIDE Contents 4 24 92 HE Ilham Aliyev Sports Energy HE Ilham Aliyev, President Find out how Azerbaijan is The Caspian powerhouse is of Azerbaijan talks about the entering the world of global entering stage two of its oil future for Azerbaijan’s econ- sporting events to improve and gas development plans, omy, its sporting develop- its international image, and with eyes firmly on the ment and cultural tolerance. boost tourism. European market. 8 50 120 Perspective Culture & Finance Tourism What is modern Azerbaijan? Diversifying the sector MICE tourism, economic Discover Azerbaijan’s is key for the country’s diversification, international hospitality, art, music, and development, see how relations and building for tolerance for other cultures PASHA Holdings are at the future. both in the capital Baku the forefront of this move. and beyond. 128 76 Construction ICT Building the monuments Rapid development of the that will come to define sector will see Azerbaijan Azerbaijan’s past, present and future in all its glory. ASSOCIATE PUBLISHERS: become one of the regional Nicole HOWARTH, leaders in this vital area of JOHN Maratheftis the economy. EDITOR: 138 BENJAMIN HEWISON Guide ART DIRECTOR: JESSICA DORIA All you need to know about Baku and beyond in one PROJECT DIRECTOR: PHIL SMITH place. Venture forth and explore the ‘Land of Fire’. PROJECT COORDINATOR: ANNA KOERNER CONTRIBUTING WRITERS: MARK Elliott, CARMEN Valache, NIGAR Orujova COVER IMAGE: © RAMIL ALIYEV / shutterstock.com 2nd floor, Berkeley Square House London W1J 6BD, United Kingdom In partnership with T: +44207 887 6105 E: info@businessoutlook.co.uk LEADING EDGE AZERBAIJAN 2015 5 Interview between Leading Edge and His Excellency Ilham Aliyev, President of the Republic of Azerbaijan LE: Your Excellency, in October 2013 you received strong reserves that amount to over US $53 billion, which is a very support from the people of Azerbaijan and were re-elect- favourable figure when compared to the rest of the world.
    [Show full text]
  • Double Dialogues : In/Stead, No
    This is the published version: Scicluna, Joanne 2010, Each doppelganger love, Double dialogues : In/Stead, no. 3, pp. 1‐1. Available from Deakin Research Online: http://hdl.handle.net/10536/DRO/DU:30041028 Reproduced with the kind permission of the copyright owner. Copyright : 2010, Double Dialogues Issue Three Expositions & Revelations home current issue archives gallery contact Return to Contents Each Doppelgänger Love Joanne Scicluna Deakin University "Yes, there is beauty and there are the humiliated. Whatever difficulties the enterprise may present, I should like never to be unfaithful either to the second or the first" (Camus 1967, p 132). Part 1 Accordion If fiction has a nature then its nature is to hide as soon as it utters the words we cannot speak I believe in fiction's wishful codes for bringing back the dead but can it atone our treachery? There is one diary you cannot look at It is the one with the roses and the threat of Bluebeard: Do not enter though I give you the key Find me instead in the flesh of your dream pictures I cannot discern and you can't remember. It is dark in here and as always no words - just the tones of abandonment Remember the courtly truth about rivals: The other is more important than the object of rivalry. She becomes an objective a limited third person There are three people inside this room right now who know the code their only shifting cover. He was from the city He was from the river and she was pretty suburban You said if the city is mine then I am your counsel your longing so I ran down your alley and ran up your stairs carried on the surge of your bright Smith Street.
    [Show full text]
  • The Reconstruction of Armenian Identity in Turkey and the Weekly Agos*
    THE RECONSTRUCTION OF ARMENIAN IDENTITY IN TURKEY AND THE WEEKLY AGOS* BASKIN ORAN ABSTRACT I delivered this paper in March 2002 at the Turkish-Armenian conference in Ann Arbor, Michigan. "A lot of water has run under the bridges", as we say in Turkish, to mean that a lot has happened since I read it at that date. I'll not go into it because Agos has come to be internationally known since the loss of my great friend (and editor-in-chief) Hrant. I'll only say this much: Agos is now 24 pages, is sold throughout Turkey, is widely followed and respected in intellectual circles, is available on the Internet. Hrant has founded this paper, has placed it right in the middle of the Turkish ordeal for real democracy, and made it famous by his death. Martyrs accomplish more after they pass away. KEYWORDS Armenian identity, Agos, nationalism, minorities. *The title of this paper was inspired by a seminar paper in French prepared by Mehmet Timuc,in Hastas, student at Marmara University in Istanbul, for the academic year 1997-98, under the direction of Associate Professor Fusun Ustel: Agos ou La Reconstruction de I'Identite Armenienne. 124 THE TURKISH YEARBOOK [VOL. XXXVII Introduction: The Road to the Birth of Agos Since about five or six years the Armenian identity in Turkey has been going through a very radical process of reconstruction. This non-Muslim minority, to use the terms of the Lausanne Peace Treaty of 1923, has started to participate in the country's politico-cultural life very actively.
    [Show full text]
  • Print This Article
    Historein Vol. 11, 2011 From Oblivion to Obsession: The Uses of History in Recent Public Debates in Turkey Kechriotis Vangelis Boğaziçi University https://doi.org/10.12681/historein.143 Copyright © 2012 Vangelis Kechriotis To cite this article: Kechriotis, V. (2012). From Oblivion to Obsession: The Uses of History in Recent Public Debates in Turkey. Historein, 11, 99-124. doi:https://doi.org/10.12681/historein.143 http://epublishing.ekt.gr | e-Publisher: EKT | Downloaded at 28/09/2021 19:24:28 | Debating history From Oblivion to In early 2011, two scandals related to his- tory tormented Turkish public opinion. The Obsession: The Uses first one was the television series Muhteşem Yüzyıl [The magnificent century], which re- of History in Recent fers to the era of Sultan Süleyman the Mag- nificent (1494–1566), and the second the film Hür Adam: Bediüzzaman Said Nursi [The free Public Debates in man: Bediüzzaman Said Nursi], which refers to the Muslim Kurdish scholar and political Turkey leader (1868–1960) of the early republican period who was at odds with the elite of the newly founded state. For more than a week, the productions dominated television talk shows and some newspaper front pages. The television series, in particular, triggered a huge uproar. Even before the series began, tens of thousands of people emailed the Ra- dio and Television Supreme Council (RTÜK), which supervises broadcasting, complaining about the trailer. When the first episode was broadcast, an angry mob gathered in front of the private television station airing it. Some among the crowd were even dressed up in Ottoman attire to protest against what they Vangelis Kechriotis perceived as the mistreatment of their glo- Boğaziçi University rious forefathers.
    [Show full text]
  • Graceful Gymnastics Image Wins Teas Azerbaijan – Sport in Focus
    Culture | Public Affairs Business | Philanthropy (Photo: Dilaver Najafov) GRACEFUL GYMNASTICS IMAGE WINS TEAS AZERBAIJAN – SPORT IN FOCUS COMPETITION Also in this issue: Summing up 2015 – expert roundtable on Nagorno-Karabakh Marc Verwilghen – new directions for TEAS Belgium Ambassador Isgandarov – striving to enhance EU political dialogue Inspired Buta concerts transcend genres and traditions 12 / 2014 TEAS Press launches a new era in children’s publishing www.teas.eu 12 / 2014 Please see inside for how to win £100 of Amazon vouchers www.teas.eu Printed by www.turquoisemedia.eu Welcome to the TEAS Magazine The European Azerbaijan Society (TEAS) is a UK-registered pan-European organisation dedicated to raising awareness of Azerbaijan and fostering closer economic, political and cultural links Mailing List between that country and the nations of Europe. TEAS is always bringing the latest news, views and interviews from Azerbaijan. Sign up to our mailing-list to receive the latest information As well as promoting the positive aspects of Azerbaijan, TEAS also highlights the plight of the straight to your inbox: www.teas.eu 875,000 refugees and Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) within the country. These people are unable to return to their homes and lands because of the illegal occupation of Nagorno-Karabakh and seven surrounding districts by Armenia’s armed forces – in defiance of four UN Security Facebook Council resolutions. The TEAS Facebook page is your chance to learn about the latest news, events, campaigns and other Azerbaijan-related items. Visit and TEAS has three main facets to its operations: ‘like’ our page at: http://bit.ly/TEASFB.
    [Show full text]
  • Turkey and Armenia Move to Bury the Hatchet (ARI)
    Area: Europe ARI 72/2009 Date: 6/5/2009 Turkey and Armenia Move to Bury the Hatchet (ARI) William Chislett * Theme: Turkey and Armenia, backed by the US and Russia, agreed a framework on 23 April 2009 to normalise their relations and end one of the most intractable disputes left from the collapse of the Soviet Union. Turkey closed its border with Armenia in 1993 in support of its ally Azerbaijan, which was in conflict with Armenia over the enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh. Summary: Abdullah Gül, Turkey’s President, kicked off the rapprochement with Armenia with some football diplomacy. In September 2008 he watched a World Cup qualifying game between Turkey and Armenia in Yerevan, the Armenian capital. It was the first-ever visit by a Turkish President to Armenia and broke the ice. Resolving the dispute between the two countries, however, requires a great deal of political will and compromise on both sides as their positions are very entrenched. The thorniest issue is how to address the 1915 massacre of up to 1.5 million Armenians, which Armenia and its diaspora label genocide, a term that Turkey virulently refuses to accept. The other major issue is to what extent the conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh has to be resolved before diplomatic relations are restored and the border opened. The economies of both countries, but particularly landlocked Armenia’s, would benefit from normal relations. And Turkey’s bid to become a full member of the EU, moving at a snail’s pace, would receive a boost as one more obstacle would be removed.
    [Show full text]
  • Armenia, Azerbaijan Urged to Restart Peace Talks Party,” a Police Spokesman Insisted on Tuesday
    AUGUST 1, 2020 MMirror-SpeirTHEror-SpeARMENIAN ctator Volume LXXXXI, NO. 3, Issue 4645 $ 2.00 NEWS The First English Language Armenian Weekly in the United States Since 1932 IN BRIEF Mkhitarian Gifts Armenia, Armenia Team Jerseys Azerbaijan To Soldiers YEREVAN (Armenpress) — On July 27, Armenian national football team captain Henrikh Mkhitaryan Urged to gifted Armenian national team jerseys to the sol- diers, wounded during the military operations in the north-eastern part of Armenian-Azerbaijani Restart state border in July, the Football Federation of Armenia reported. Mkhitaryan promised to meet the soldiers and Peace Talks sign the jerseys when he returns to Armenia. “I thank you for standing firmly and defending YEREVAN (RFE/RL) — US, Russian the borders of our homeland,” Mkhitaryan wrote in and French mediators have urged his letter to the soldiers. Armenia and Azerbaijan to gear up for “serious substantive negotiations” on Armenians at the Federal Building protest in Boston July 22 (photo Vrej Ashjian) resolving the Nagorno-Karabakh con- US House Approves flict after recent deadly clashes on their More Funding For Mine border. In a weekend statement, the three co- Azerbaijanis Attempt to Counter Clearance In Karabakh chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group also welcomed the current “relative stabili- WASHINGTON — The US House of ty” along a section of the border where Two Boston Demonstrations Representatives approved on Thursday, July 23, heavy fighting broke out on July 12 and $1.4 million in fresh US funding for humanitarian left at least 17 soldiers from both sides By Aram Arkun demining operations in Nagorno-Karabakh carried dead.
    [Show full text]
  • Behrooz Parhami's Blog & Books Page
    Behrooz Parhami Home & Contact Behrooz Parhami's Blog & Books Page Page last updated on 2014 December 31 Curriculum Vitae Research This page was created in March 2009 as an outgrowth of the section entitled "Books Read or Heard" in my personal page. The rapid expansion of the list of Computer arithmetic books warranted devoting a separate page to it. Given that the book introductions and reviews constituted a form of personal blog, I decided to title Parallel processing this page "Blog & Books," to also allow discussion of interesting topics Fault tolerance unrelated to books from time to time. Lately, non-book items (such as political Broader research news, tech news, puzzles, oddities, trivia, humor, art, and music) have formed the vast majority of the entries. Research history List of publications Entries in each section appear in reverse chronological order. Teaching Blog entries for 2014 Archived blogs for 2012-13 ECE1 Freshman sem Archived blogs up to 2011 ECE154 Comp arch ECE252B Comp arith Blog Entries for 2014 2014/12/31 (Wed.): Here are nine items of potential interest to close the year. ECE252C Adv dig des (1) Freedom of the press ECE254B Par proc worldwide in 2014: As ECE257A Fault toler assessed by Reporters Without Borders. Student supervision (2) Quote of the day: "Life Math + Fun! isn't about finding yourself. Life is about creating Textbooks yourself." ~ George Bernard Shaw Computer arithmetic (3) The last four death- Parallel processing row inmates in Maryland Dependable comp will get their sentences reduced to life: Outgoing Comp architecture Governor Martin O'Malley Other books has announced plans to commute the sentences Service before leaving office.
    [Show full text]
  • AW 2012 WEB English-1.Pdf
    We would like to thank the following for their generous support Anonymous $5,000 Jeannette John (Watertown, Mass.), $250 George Aghjayan (Worcester, Mass.), $1,000 d Lucine Karjian (Florham Park, N.J.), Raffy and Victoria Hovanessian in honor of Alice and Antranig Karjian, $250 (New York, N.Y.), $500 Ned and Aroxie Apigian ARF Detroit “Azadamard” Gomideh, $500 (Dearborn Heights, Mich.), $250 Avik Deirmenjian (Bedford, Mass.), $400 Robert Setrakian (New York, N.Y.), $250 Armenian Relief Society of Eastern USA, $250 Vartkes and Alice Anivian Ashod Donikian (Artarmon, NSW, Australia), $250 (San Francisco, Calif.), $225 Harout and Mayda Gigian and Family (Boston, Mass.), $250 John L. Ohanian (Albany, N.Y.), $200 Harry Parsekian (Watertown, Mass.), $250 Varujan and Hilda Ozcan (Boston, Mass.), $150 We would also like to thank the following page sponsors Stephen Mesrobian (Providence, R.I.) Antranik Vartanian (Woodside, N.Y.) The Varjabedian Family in memory of Bedros and Stella Bandazian (Richmond, Va.) Alice Movsessian (Cliffside Park, N.J.), Arsen and Yeran Varjabedian (Waltham, Mass.) in memory of Movses and Sarkis and Mary Garibian (Springfield, Mass.), Ralph Hashoian (West Bloomfield, Mich.) Shamera Movsessian (Sepastia) in memory of Kevork and Vart Garibian Rose Sielian Theriault (Rochester, N.H.) Anne Marderosian (Arlington, Mass.) James Dostoomian (Stoughton, Mass.) Rose V. Asadoorian (Odessa, Fla.) Martha Hananian (North Andover, Mass.) Stephen and Angele Dulgarian (Chelmsford, Marian Amiraian (Latham, N.Y.), Mass.), in memory of
    [Show full text]
  • DAGTAS DISSERTATION Final
    Heterogeneous Encounters: Tolerance, Secularism and Religious Difference at Turkey’s Border with Syria by Mahiye Seçil Dağtaş A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Anthropology University of Toronto © Copyright by Mahiye Seçil Dağtaş 2014 Heterogeneous Encounters: Tolerance, Secularism and Religious Difference in Turkey’s Border with Syria Mahiye Seçil Dağtaş Doctor of Philosophy Department of Anthropology University of Toronto 2014 Abstract This dissertation is an ethnographic investigation into the politics of religious difference in Turkey. Drawing on fieldwork in Antakya, a city near Turkey’s Syrian border populated by Arabs and Turks of Sunni, Alawi, Jewish, and Orthodox Christian backgrounds, it explores the mundane, political, and aesthetic representations of religious difference and demonstrates how such difference is constructed, lived, and configured in everyday realms of sociality. Four such realms are focused on: a multi-religious choral ensemble, Antakya’s historical marketplace, domestic and communal sitings of guesthood (misafirlik), and places and discourses of common worship. Official representations of Antakya’s religious diversity imply a pluralist and “tolerant” form of national citizenship as compared to Turkey’s Republican secularist model. I argue, however, that daily practices, artistic expressions, and networks of exchange between different denominations of Muslim, Christian, and Jewish residents of the city inhabit a more heterogeneous field characterized by interpersonal relations of negotiation, hospitality, intimacy, and hostility. These interrelations are further informed and delimited by structures of power embedded in local, national, and transnational regimes of diversity management and implicated in the minoritization ii of non-Sunni and non-Turkish communal identities.
    [Show full text]
  • Post-Exilic Armenian “Homecoming” Films
    Post-Exilic Armenian “Homecoming” Films: Working-through the Traumatic Postmemory of 1915 ............ by Kumru Bilici, BA (Hons.) A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Film Studies Carleton University OTTAWA, Ontario Submitted August 2016 © 2016, Kumru Bilici i We are two sick nations: Armenians and Turks. The Armenians are suffering an enormous trauma in relation to the Turks who live through a major paranoia towards the Armenians. We are both a clinical case…. Who will heal us? Is it the decision of French or the US Senate? Who is our doctor to write the prescription? The Armenians are the Turks' and the Turks are the Armenians' doctor. There’s no other doctor or prescription. Our medicine is dialogue. Hrant Dink ii Abstract The Armenian Genocide and its multigenerational effects have long been a topic of cinematic representation. Given the scarcity of archival images and the contested history of the events of 1915, filmmakers have historically been preoccupied with proving the genocide and recalling its trauma. Here, I draw attention to a group of recent documentaries by post-exilic Armenians depicting their emotionally difficult return journeys to Turkey against the background of continuing denial; and I propose that these independent and personal “homecoming” films help us better understand the Armenian filmmakers’ multigenerational diasporic rupture and relationship with their ancestral homeland. Through close examination of three of these documentaries, I argue that the post-exilic Armenian “homecoming” films are cautious yet promising cinematic memory work towards the working-through of the trauma of 1915 seeking the possibilities of restoring an unwelcoming space back into a homeland.
    [Show full text]