Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 13 (2020) 667e678
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity
journal homepage: http://www.elsevier.com/locate/japb
Original Article An updated checklist of Primula species (Primulaceae) in Uzbekistan
Komiljon Tojibaev a,b, Farkhod Karimov a, Furkat Khassanov a, Alexander Sennikov c,d, Mansur Usmonov a,e,* a National Herbarium, Institute of Botany of Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Uzbekistan, Durmon yuli str., 32, 100125, Tashkent, Uzbekistan b National University of Uzbekistan, Almazar distr., Universitet shakharchasi 4, 100174, Tashkent, Uzbekistan c Komarov Botanical Institute of Russian Academy of Sciences, Prof. Popov Str. 2, RUe197376 St Petersburg, Russia d Botanical Museum, Finnish Museum of Natural History, P. O. Box 7, University of Helsinki, FIe00014, Finland e Department of Biology Education, Kongju National University, Gongju-si, 32582, South Korea article info abstract
Article history: A taxonomic revision of the genus Primula in Uzbekistan is presented including a key, complete syn- Received 15 April 2020 onymy and distribution for all taxa with distribution maps. The present study has established the rich Received in revised form diversity of Primula species in Uzbekistan with a record total of 13 species. The species is recognized and 29 May 2020 grouped into seven sections. Most of the species (38%) belong to the section Cortusa. Two species, Primula Accepted 7 August 2020 pamirica and Primula pskemensis were recorded as a new species for the flora of Uzbekistan. Available online 26 August 2020 Ó 2020 National Science Museum of Korea (NSMK) and Korea National Arboretum (KNA), Publishing Services by Elsevier. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http:// Keywords: Distribution creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Kazakhstan Kyrgyzstan Tajikistan Uzbekistan
Introduction been described for last 25 years (Turakulov and Gazybaev 1995; Lazkov 2004). Primula L., comprising more than 500 species, is the largest genus The genus Primula L. can explicitly be recognized by its peren- of Primulaceae (Fedorov 1952; Kovtonyuk and Goncharov 2009; nial habitat, basal rosette of leaves, heterostylous flowers with Kovtonyuk 2011; Yan et al 2015; Xu et al 2016). The genus is mainly obvious tube and capsular fruits (Xu et al 2016). The majority of distributed in the North Temperate Zone, with only a few outliers in Primula species are perennial short-root herbs, sometimes mono- the mountainous regions of Africa, tropical Asia, and South America. carps. Many species are ornamental plants and have been used to Its modern species richness center is in West China, with approxi- breed numerous cultivars of garden primroses (Kovtonyuk 2006). mately 300 species, most of which occur in Western Sichuan, Eastern The complete Primula diversity of the Middle Asian Mountains Tibet, and Northwestern Yunnan, which are largely located in the region (including Uzbekistan) is still unknown, as no extensive Himalayan-Hengduan Mountains region (Xu et al 2016). Over the study on Primula species has so far been conducted in this area, past ten years, it has been reported several of new species (Xu et al which is biogeographically linked with Tajikistan, Kyrgyzstan, and 2019) described from the primary center of species diversity (west- Kazakhstan. In 5th volume of the old “Flora of Uzbekistan” ern Sichuan, eastern Xizang, and northwestern Yunnan), which (Kovalevskaya 1961) provided the first detailed treatment of ten confirm to the special attention of scientists to species of the Primula. Primula species of Uzbekistan. This treatment, although of the Middle Asia is harboring a smaller number of Primula species. highest quality possible in those times, is largely outdated. There- Kovalevskaya (1986) reported 25 species of Primula from the different fore, an extensive field survey of Primula in the mountains of parts of this region, and only two new species from this region have Uzbekistan and herbarium revisions was carried out to know the diversity, distribution of the species so that conservation and management practices could be initiated. In accordance with the concept of the Flora of Uzbekistan * Corresponding author. Tel.: þ10 8603 6909. project (Sennikov et al 2017), it carried out a critical treatment of E-mail address: [email protected] (M. Usmonov). herbarium specimens collected from the territory of the Flora. In Peer review under responsibility of National Science Museum of Korea (NSMK) and accordance with analysis of literature data (Hu and Kelso 1996; Korea National Arboretum (KNA). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.japb.2020.08.004 pISSN2287-884X eISSN2287-9544/Ó 2020 National Science Museum of Korea (NSMK) and Korea National Arboretum (KNA), Publishing Services by Elsevier. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). 668 K Tojibaev et al. / Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 13 (2020) 667e678
Richards 2002; Lazkov 2004; Byalt 2006; Kovtonyuk and The symbols used in this study are as follows: Homotypic syn- Goncharov 2009; Kovtonyuk 2013; Yan et al 2015) and the results onym (nomenclatural synonym) indicated by the symbol “h”; of taxonomic treatments, we found 13 species of Primula for the Heterotypic synonym (taxonomic synonym) indicated by the symbol Flora of Uzbekistan. Among them, two species were discovered first “¼”. time from the territory of Uzbekistan (indicated by the symbol an asterisks e *). Systematic accounts The particular aims of our study are as follows: (1) obtaining a better understanding of systematical composition within the sec- Genus Primula Linnaeus, Sp. Pl. ed.1: 205 (1753) tions; (2) clearly show their occupied areas by the botanic- Type species: Primula vera Linnaeus geographical regions in Uzbekistan, and so on. In addition, an ¼ Cortusa Linnaeus, Sp. Pl. 1: 144 (1753). identification key of useful distinguishing characters of species are Type species: Cortusa matthioli Linnaeus given. ¼ Dionysia Fenzl, in Flora 26: 389 (1843). Type species: Dionysia odora Fenzl Material and methods Calyx tubular, campanulate or funnel form, persistent, rather Study area deeply lobed; corolla tube distinct and usually fairly long, some- what enlarged at the mouth; corolla limb flat or funnel form, very The study has been carried out in Central and Eastern Uzbeki- rarely subcampanulate, the lobes entire or bifid; stamens inserted stan biogeographical regions: (1) South Western Hissar lies be- in the throat, the filaments very short, the anthers obtuse; ovary tween 67o0`Ne37o0`E, 67o0`Ne36o0`E and 66o0`Ne37o0`E, SW superior, globose or ovoid; style filiform, with a capitate stigma. boundary adjoins to the mountains of the NE Turkmenistan. The Many species display heterostylism, the style in long styled flowers region includes Kuhitang district which is bordered with of usually equaling the tube and in short-styled flowers half as long as Tajikistan in the southwest, Kashkadarya, and Baysun; (2) Hissar- the tube; ovules numerous, usually amphitropous; on a free central Darvaz (Sangardak-Tupalang dist.), lies between 66o0`Ne38o0`E, placenta; capsule globose or cylindrical, many seeded, 5e10-lobed; 67o0`Ne38o0`E. The region is bordered by mountains of Tajikistan seeds dorsally flattened, convex ventrally, commonly angular; in the east and north. The vegetation types range from lower to embryo transverse. Perennial herbs, rarely monocarpic plants. alpine between altitudinal ranges of 500 m to 4500 m; (3) Kuhistan Leaves exclusively rosulate, entire or spatulate, petiole or sessile; region (Malguzar and North Turkestan dist.) lies between 67o0`Ne flowers in umbellate or subglobose inflorescences in whorls 40o0`E and 68o0`Ne40o0`E. Its southern and eastern part located in (proliferated umbels), rarely solitary (on subradical peduncles boundary Tajikistan, a river basin Zeravshan separate it from north when scape undeveloped); bracts usually narrow, lanceolate, Zeravshan range. The vegetation types range between altitudinal sometimes gibbous or saccate. ranges of 700 m to 5500 m; (4) Western Chatkal is one of the Western mountains part of Tien Shan and include the researched I. Primula sect. Cortusa (Linneanus) V.A.Richt., in Természetrajzi areas Ugam-Pskem, Arashan, and Kurama districts, lies between Füz. 17: 134 (1894). 70o0`Ne41o0`E and 69o0`Ne41o0`E; (5) Kyzylkum (Kyzylkum Relic Section type: Cortusa matthioli Linneanus Mountains) lies on 65o0`Ne41o0`E; (6) Fergana-Alay, the only dCortusa Linneanus, Sp. Pl. 1: 144 (1753) enclave zone of Uzbekistan and the region is located at 71o0`Ne ¼Primula sect. Cortusoides Balf.f., in J. Roy. Hort. Soc. 39: 140 (1913) 39o0`E. All regions are mostly mountainous. Type species: Cortusa matthioli Linneanus ¼Primula sect. Cortusoides Balf.f. in J. Roy. Hort. Soc. 39: 140 (1913) Data analysis Type species: Primula cortusoides Linneanus Our taxonomic revision is based on the use of living and her- 1. *Primula pskemensis Lazkov, Novosti Sist. Vyssh. Rast. 36: 36 barium material from various systematic collections. Herbarium (2004). specimens, including type materials, were examined. Extensive (Figure 1E) field surveys were conducted during the growing season from Type. KYRGYZSTAN: PSKEM RANGE. In headwaters Alma-Sai, right March 2012 to September 2017 at elevations between 1.500 m and tributary. Chandalash, 17.06.2003, G. Lazkov, N. Kenjebaeva (holo- 4.500 m in the selected area for the analysis of diversity and dis- type, LE!, isotype, FRU!) tribution of the Primula species. Specimens of various associate dPrimula minkwitziae auct. non W.W. Sm.: Kovalevskaya in Fl. plant species were collected and herbarium of each species was Uzbekistan 5: 35 (1961); Kovalevskaya in Consp. Fl. Asiae Med. 8: 12 prepared and preserved for identification. The herbarium speci- (1986). mens thus prepared have been deposited in the herbarium of Na- Type. KYRGYZSTAN: in Talas Alatau, pass Ulkun-Kaindy (LE!) tional Herbarium Institute of Botany (TASH) of Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Uzbekistan. The species were identified with the Diagnosis. Perennial, rhizome short, with tufts of roots. Scape 7e help of various floras (Fedorov 1952; Kovalevskaya 1961, 1986; Hu 15 cm long, densely pubescent with long glandular hairs. Leaves and Kelso 1996; Kovtonyuk 2006, Lazkov and Sultanova 2011; with petioles 4e12 cm long and reniform short-lobed plate 2.5e8 Sennikov 2017) and herbarium specimens at the major herbaria cm long, 2e5 cm wide, along the edge serrated or toothed, densely namely TASH, the Moscow State University MW, Komarov Botanical pubescent with long glandular hairs. Involucral bracts 4e6, lance- Institute LE, Institute of Biology of National Academy of Sciences of olate, 0.5e1 cm long, pubescent with glandular hairs. Calyx 7e11 Kyrgyzstan FRU and Institute of Botany and Phytointroduction mm long, cylindrical, up to 1/2 incised into acute lanceolate lobes, Ministry of Science, Academy of Sciences of Kazakhstan AA. The green, with short glandular hairs. Corolla greenish-yellow, pubes- coordinates of plant records were imported into ArcGIS 10.0 and cent on the outside with long and short glandular hairs; corolla transformed to a point map layer. A WGS84 Geographic coordinate tube cylindrical, about 1e1.5 cm long; limb flat, 1e1.5 cm in diam. system was used as a reference datum. Digitizing of the herbarium Fl. June. specimens was carried out by scanning with HerbScan TM 224 þ Taxonomic notes. This species is very close to Primula Eugenie but Epson Expression 10000 XL. differs by the glandular, pubescent calyx, and smaller flowers. K Tojibaev et al. / Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 13 (2020) 667e678 669
Figure 1. Morphological comparisons between species at blooming stage: A, Primula algida (photo by Tojibaev); B, Primula baldshuanica (Shevyreva); C, Primula capitellata (Gaziyev); D, Primula geranophylla (Tojibaev); E, Primula pskemensis (Kolbinsev); F, Primula fedtschenkoi (Tojibaev); G, Primula kaufmanniana (Epiktetov); H, Primula matthioli (L.) V.A.Richt. subsp. turkestanica (Usmonov); I, Primula olgae (Banketov); J, Primula pamirica (A. Naumenko); K, Pprimula turkeviczii (Epiktetov); L, Primula hissarica (Turginov); M, Primula iljinskii (Suyunkulov).
Habitat. In the cracks of the rocks, with snowfields in the upper 2. Primula turkeviczii V.V. Byalt, in Novon 16(1): 23-24 (2006). mountain belt, 2.500e3.200 m. nom. illeg., non (Fisch.) Kuntze (1891); Fedorov in Fl. USSR 18: 125 General distribution. Middle Asia: (Tien Shan: Pskem): (1952); Kovalevskaya in Fl. Uzbekistan 5: 35 (1961); Kovalevskaya Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan. in Consp. Fl. Asiae Med. 8: 11 (1986). Distribution in Uzbekistan. I-1 Western Tien-Shan region. I-1-a (Figure 1K) Ugam-Pskem district: PSKEM RANGE (right bank of Jiydasay, Type. TAJIKISTAN: TURKESTAN RANGE. In Mogian, 4.500, the decid- 03.07.1967, Blajeevich [TASH!]; in the crevices of the rocks at the uous trees zone, May 1893, Mosquitoes (holotype and isotype, LE!) very top of Aksar-sai near the settlement Nanay, 06.23.1948, Pavlov dPrimula lactiflora Turkev. in Not. Syst. Herb. Horti Bot. Petrop. [MW!]). 2: 13 (1921). 670 K Tojibaev et al. / Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 13 (2020) 667e678
Figure 1. (continued).