Synthetic Turf Scientific Advisory Panel Meeting Materials
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
California Environmental Protection Agency Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment Synthetic Turf Study Synthetic Turf Scientific Advisory Panel Meeting May 31, 2019 MEETING MATERIALS THIS PAGE LEFT BLANK INTENTIONALLY Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment California Environmental Protection Agency Agenda Synthetic Turf Scientific Advisory Panel Meeting May 31, 2019, 9:30 a.m. – 4:00 p.m. 1001 I Street, CalEPA Headquarters Building, Sacramento Byron Sher Auditorium The agenda for this meeting is given below. The order of items on the agenda is provided for general reference only. The order in which items are taken up by the Panel is subject to change. 1. Welcome and Opening Remarks 2. Synthetic Turf and Playground Studies Overview 4. Synthetic Turf Field Exposure Model Exposure Equations Exposure Parameters 3. Non-Targeted Chemical Analysis Volatile Organics on Synthetic Turf Fields Non-Polar Organics Constituents in Crumb Rubber Polar Organic Constituents in Crumb Rubber 5. Public Comments: For members of the public attending in-person: Comments will be limited to three minutes per commenter. For members of the public attending via the internet: Comments may be sent via email to [email protected]. Email comments will be read aloud, up to three minutes each, by staff of OEHHA during the public comment period, as time allows. 6. Further Panel Discussion and Closing Remarks 7. Wrap Up and Adjournment Agenda Synthetic Turf Advisory Panel Meeting May 31, 2019 THIS PAGE LEFT BLANK INTENTIONALLY Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment California Environmental Protection Agency DRAFT for Discussion at May 2019 SAP Meeting. Table of Contents Synthetic Turf and Playground Studies Overview May 2019 Update ...... 2-1 Background ................................................................................................. 2-1 Synthetic Turf Study.................................................................................... 2-2 Playground Study ....................................................................................... 2-4 Non-Targeted Chemical Analysis ........................................................... 3-1 Non-Targeted Chemical Analysis ............................................................... 3-1 Background ........................................................................................... 3-1 Non-Targeted Analysis of Volatile Organic Chemicals Emitted from Crumb Rubber ....................................................................................... 3-2 Non-Targeted Analysis Workflow – Extractable Chemicals in Crumb Rubber ................................................................................................... 3-3 Identification of Extractable Non-Polar Chemicals in Crumb Rubber Using Gas Chromatography/Mass Spectrometry ............................................ 3-6 Identification of Polar Organic Chemicals in Crumb Rubber Extracts Using High-Resolution Accurate-Mass Liquid Chromatography/Mass Spectrometry ....................................................................................... 3-14 Results – Confirmed Targeted Chemical Lists and Tentatively Identified Chemical List ....................................................................................... 3-23 References ............................................................................................... 3-46 Synthetic Turf Field Exposure Model....................................................... 4-1 Introduction ................................................................................................. 4-1 Model Design .............................................................................................. 4-1 Source of Chemicals and Exposure Media ............................................ 4-1 Field User Categories ............................................................................ 4-4 Exposure Pathways ............................................................................... 4-4 Inhalation Exposure Pathway ..................................................................... 4-5 Calculating Inhalation Concentration for Non-Cancer Hazard Assessment ........................................................................................... 4-5 Calculating Inhalation Dose for Cancer Risk Assessment ................... 4-13 Ingestion Exposure Pathway .................................................................... 4-27 Direct Ingestion Exposure Pathway ..................................................... 4-27 Table of Contents Page | i Synthetic Turf Advisory Panel Meeting May 31, 2019 Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment California Environmental Protection Agency DRAFT for Discussion at May 2019 SAP Meeting. Indirect Ingestion Exposure Pathway .................................................. 4-28 Calculating Oral Dose for Non-Cancer Hazard Assessment ............... 4-30 Calculating Oral Dose for Cancer Risk Assessment............................ 4-49 Dermal Exposure Pathway ....................................................................... 4-58 Direct Dermal Exposure Pathway ........................................................ 4-58 Indirect Dermal Exposure Pathway ..................................................... 4-59 Calculating Dermal Dose for Non-Cancer Hazard Assessment........... 4-59 Calculating Dermal Dose for Cancer Risk Assessment ....................... 4-67 References ............................................................................................... 4-68 Two-Tiered Non-Targeted Analysis Approach to Identify Tentative Extractable Polar Chemicals in Crumb Rubber .......................................A-1 Chamber Testing SOP ............................................................................B-1 Turf Project Instrument Descriptions Draft v1 ........................................ C-1 Extraction of Crumb Rubber for LC/MS ................................................. D-1 Analysis of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) by Gas Chromatography Mass Spectrometry (GC/MS) with Selected Ion Monitoring (SIM) .....................................................................................E-1 LC/MS Instrumental Settings .................................................................. F-1 Draft Report Assessing Human Time-Activity Exposure Patterns Occurring on Synthetic Turf Fields ......................................................................... G-1 Part I. Final Report on the Quantification of Micro-level Activities from a Pre-existing Dataset of Children Playing on Turf/Playground ................ H-1 Quantification of Micro-level Activities from Recorded Data of Children Playing Soccer on Artificial Turf ............................................................... I-1 Synthetic Turf Scientific Advisory Panel.................................................. J-1 A Handy Guide to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act 2004 ................K-1 Table of Contents Page | ii Synthetic Turf Advisory Panel Meeting May 31, 2019 Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment California Environmental Protection Agency DRAFT for Discussion at May 2019 SAP Meeting. List of Tables Table 3-1. Non-Targeted Chemical Analysis of Extractable Non-Polar Chemicals: Confirmed Targets and Tentatively Identified Chemicals ............................ 3-7 Table 3-2. Eighteen Polar Chemicals, in Crumb Rubber Extracts, Identified by Suspect Screening Analysis and Confirmed Using Reference Standards .............. 3-18 Table 3-3. CFM-ID Validation Results ........................................................................ 3-21 Table 3-4. Confirmed Chemical Target List ................................................................ 3-24 Table 3-5. Tentatively Identified Chemical List of Crumb Rubber............................... 3-33 Table 4-1. Inhalation Exposure—Survey Data of Exposure Times for Female Athletes* ... .....................................................................................................................4-8 Table 4-2. Inhalation Exposure—Survey Data of Exposure Times for Male Athletes* . 4-9 Table 4-3. Inhalation Exposure— Survey Data of Exposure Times for Athletes, No Gender Specified ...................................................................................... 4-10 Table 4-4. Survey Data of Exposure Times for Coach, Referee, and Bystander* ...... 4-11 Table 4-5. Athlete—Inhalation Rate Normalized to Bodyweight (OEHHA, 2012) ....... 4-15 Table 4-6. Bystander—Inhalation Rate Normalized to Bodyweight (OEHHA, 2012) . 4-16 Table 4-7. 3rd Trimester Bystander—Inhalation Rate Normalized to Bodyweight (OEHHA, 2012) ......................................................................................... 4-16 Table 4-8. Coach and Referee—Inhalation Rate Normalized to Bodyweight (OEHHA, 2012) ....................................................................................................... 4-16 Table 4-9. Survey Data of Exertion Levels for Female Athletes* ................................ 4-18 Table 4-10. Survey Data of Exertion Levels for Male Athletes* .................................. 4-19 Table 4-11. Survey Data of Exertion Levels for Athletes, No Gender Specified ......... 4-20 Table 4-12. Exertion Levels for Coach, Referee, and Bystander ............................... 4-21 Table 4-13. Inhalation Exposure—Survey Data for Exposure Frequency for Female Athletes ..................................................................................................