And Below-Ground Microbial Interactions with Arabidopsis

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

And Below-Ground Microbial Interactions with Arabidopsis Impacts of sub-ambient and elevated CO2 on above- and below-ground microbial interactions with Arabidopsis. Alex Williams Department of Animal and Plant Science, The University of Sheffield Thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Submitted: December 2017 This work is dedicated to Pauline Williams. The most beautiful life I knew. iii Abstract Over recent years, an increasing body of evidence has suggested that elevated atmospheric CO2 concentrations can alter plant microbial interactions. However, there is limited consensus whether these impacts will be positive or negative for plants in terms of disease resistance. Accordingly, there is a pressing need to gain a better understanding of the molecular and physiological mechanisms by which CO2 shapes the plant’s ability to interact with its biotic environment, which is essential to predict impacts of future climate scenarios on crop production. The work described in this thesis has used a range of CO2 concentrations, from past through present to future predicted concentrations, to study the immune response of the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana to aboveground pathogens and belowground rhizosphere bacteria. Furthermore, a novel developmental correction was established, which enables assessing the direct immunological effects of CO2 on microbial interactions without bias from age-related resistance arising from the stimulatory effects of CO2 on plant development. Changes in disease resistance at elevated CO2 (eCO2), against the necrotrophic fungus Plectosphaerella cucumerina (Pc) and the obligate biotrophic oomycete Hyaloperonospora arabidopsidis (Hpa) were associated with changes in production and sensitivity of the phytohormones jasmonic acid (JA and salicylic acid (SA), respectively. However, priming of SA-dependent defence was not the only mechanisms contributing to eCO2-induced resistance against Hpa. The increased resistance to Hpa at sub-ambient CO2 (saCO2) against Hpa operated independently of SA signaling and was associated with changes in cellular redox state and priming of pathogen-inducible intracellular ROS. Based on the defence phenotypes of knock-down mutants in glycolate oxidase, the H2O2-generating enzyme of the photorespiration cycle, and transcriptional profiling of the peroxisomal catalase gene CAT2, it is proposed that the enhanced Hpa resistance at saCO2 is controlled by photorespiratory ROS. Below-ground, the root colonisation of a specialised rhizobacterial strain Pseudomonas simiae WCS417 was found to be dependent on CO2 concentration v and soil-nutritional status, whereas root colonisation by the soil saprophytic strain Pseudomonas putida KT2440 was largely unaffected by these variables. Hence, changes in atmospheric CO2 have a greater impact on specialist rhizosphere microbes. Furthermore, the ability of P. simiae WCS417 to promote plant growth and elicit an induced systemic resistance (ISR) was highly dependent on CO2 and nutritional status of the soil. These results suggest that the effects of atmospheric CO2 on rhizosphere microbes depend on the rhizosphere species in question and the nutritional status of the soil. To obtain a more global impression of the impacts of CO2 on rhizosphere interactions, rhizosphere soil was studied for bacterial community diversity and composition using PCR-based community profiling techniques. This revealed that CO2 has a measurable impact on microbial communities in a time-point dependent manner, whereby the effects of eCO2 are more pronounced at earlier stages and the effects of saCO2 are more pronounced at later stages. To study the biochemical basis of these CO2 effects on the rhizosphere effect, a new mass spectrometry-based method was developed to study quantitative and qualitative impacts of CO2 on non-sterile rhizosphere chemistry. These experiments revealed that the diversity of chemical signals greatly increases with rising CO2 concentrations, and that saCO2 and eCO2 are associated with rhizosphere enrichment of different classes of chemicals. Together, the results presented in this thesis provide novel insights into the mechanisms by which plants have adapted to past CO2 climates, and the potential impacts by which future CO2 scenarios will affect interactions with hostile and beneficial microbes. Further research is required to explore the combined impacts of eCO2 and other environmental changes due to global climate change, such as elevated temperatures and drought. vi Table of Contents Abstract ............................................................................................................. v Abbreviations and nomenclature .................................................................... x List of tables and figures................................................................................ xii Chapter 1: General Introduction ...................................................................... 1 1.1 Introduction ................................................................................................ 1 1.2 Shifting global climate. ............................................................................... 2 1.2.1 The greenhouse effect and the importance of CO2. ............................. 2 1.2.2 Past CO2 concentrations. .................................................................... 3 1.2.3 Current and future CO2 projections. .................................................... 4 1.3 Plant perception, recognition and responses to pathogenic microbes. ...... 6 1.4 Elevated CO2 effects on plant pathogen interactions. ................................ 8 1.4.1 Impacts of eCO2 on plant physiology. .................................................. 8 1.4.2 A meta-analysis of the impacts of eCO2 on plant disease. .................. 9 1.4.3 CO2 and pre-invasive resistance. ...................................................... 10 1.4.4 CO2: an enhancer or suppressor of post-invasive defences? ............ 11 1.4.5 Host defence responses to sub-ambient CO2. .................................. 16 1.5 Interactions with below-ground beneficial microbes................................. 18 1.6 Effects of CO2 on belowground interactions in rhizosphere. .................... 21 1.6.1 Effects of CO2 on rhizosphere chemistry. .......................................... 21 1.6.2 Effects of eCO2 on rhizosphere microbes. ......................................... 23 1.6.2 Effects of saCO2 on rhizosphere microbes. ....................................... 24 1.7 Thesis outline. ......................................................................................... 24 Chapter 2: Materials and Methods ................................................................. 27 2.1 Reagents and chemicals. ..................................................................... 27 2.2 Plant cultivation and growth conditions. ................................................ 27 2.3 Experimental set-up of growth system for metabolite collection. .......... 27 2.4 Development measurements and correction. ....................................... 28 2.5 Plant developmental correction (DC). ................................................... 28 2.6 Pathogenicity assays using Hpa and Pc. .............................................. 28 2.7 RT-PCR quantification of pathogen DNA. ............................................ 31 2.8 In situ detection of reactive oxygen species. ........................................ 32 vii 2.9 Targeted quantification of hormones. ................................................... 32 2.10 Metabolite extraction for untargeted profiling...................................... 33 2.11 Untargeted metabolic profiling by UPLC-qTOF-MSE. ......................... 33 2.12 Data preparation of MS data for statistical analysis. ........................... 34 2.13 Soil inoculation with Pseudomonas simiae WCS417 and Pseudomonas putida KT2440. ........................................................................................... 38 2.14 Induced systemic resistance assays. ................................................. 39 2.15 Bacterial community profiling by terminal-restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis. .............................................................................. 39 2.16 Community diversity and composition. ............................................... 40 2.17 Analysis of dissimilarity in T-RFLP patterns between samples. .......... 41 Chapter 3: Mechanisms of glacial-to-future atmospheric CO2 effects on plant immunity (adapted from Williams et al. 2017) ................................... 43 3.1 Abstract ................................................................................................... 43 3.2 Introduction .............................................................................................. 44 3.3 Results..................................................................................................... 46 3.4 Discussion ............................................................................................... 53 3.5 Supporting figures ................................................................................... 57 Chapter 4: Impacts of glacial-to-future atmospheric CO2 on bacterial rhizosphere colonisation in relation to plant growth and systemic resistance responses. .................................................................................... 67 4.1 Abstract ................................................................................................... 67 4.2 Introduction .............................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Ambient Pressure Diving – Firmware Update Notice V05.02.01
    Ambient Pressure Diving – Firmware Update Notice V05.02.01 New Firmware Firmware Release Date: 19th July 2013 New Firmware (embedded software) has been released for your Vision oxygen controllers and handset. For Quick Install Instructions go to Page 11. IMPORTANT: with thousands of users updating their firmware – we will not be able to give “one on one talk through help” to everyone within the first two weeks of release – even with extra man power we will not be able to cope. It is very easy to upload the new firmware, the new APD Communicator is also upgraded to work better with both types of USB/Serial adaptors, it’s a safe, secure process… you can do it. Please though, read this document and follow the instructions instead of phoning for help. Please don’t tie us up asking questions which are answered in this document, please free up our email and phone system for those who really need help – MP. The last general release firmware was V02.01.04, released in January 2008, while the last hardware specific firmware, V05.00.01 was released on new “lids”, which had updated processors, in October 2012. The new firmware, V05.02.01, is suitable for upload to all “lids” and offers significant improvements on previous versions. It is the result of many years of development, updates, improvements and testing with the software, firmware & hardware development conforming to Annex B of the soon to be released European Standard, EN14143:2013/4 and audited by Lloyds Quality Assurance’s Critical Safety Experts. Firmware Version 05.02.00 is now available for download from the website: http://www.apdiving.com/downloads/software/ .
    [Show full text]
  • Bismis-2016 Abstract Book
    BISMiS-2016 Abstract Book Third Meeting of Bergey's International Society for Microbial Systematics on Microbial Systematics and Metagenomics September 12-15, 2016 | Pune, INDIA PUNE UNIT Abstracts - Opening Address - Keynotes Abstract Book | BISMiS-2016 | Pune, India Opening Address TAXONOMY OF PROKARYOTES - NEW CHALLENGES IN A GLOBAL WORLD Peter Kämpfer* Justus-Liebig-University Giessen, HESSEN, Germany Email: [email protected] Systematics can be considered as a comprehensive science, because in science it is an essential aspect in comparing any two or more elements, whether they are genes or genomes, proteins or proteomes, biochemical pathways or metabolomes (just to list a few examples), or whole organisms. The development of high throughput sequencing techniques has led to an enormous amount of data (genomic and other “omic” data) and has also revealed an extensive diversity behind these data. These data are more and more used also in systematics and there is a strong trend to classify and name the taxonomic units in prokaryotic systematics preferably on the basis of sequence data. Unfortunately, the knowledge of the meaning behind the sequence data does not keep up with the tremendous increase of generated sequences. The extent of the accessory genome in any given cell, and perhaps the infinite extent of the pan-genome (as an aggregate of all the accessory genomes) is fascinating but it is an open question if and how these data should be used in systematics. Traditionally the polyphasic approach in bacterial systematics considers methods including both phenotype and genotype. And it is the phenotype that is (also) playing an essential role in driving the evolution.
    [Show full text]
  • Our World-Underwater Scholarship Society ®
    our world-underwater scholarship society ® 47th Annual Awards Program – June 3 - 5, 2021 Welcome to the 47th anniversary celebration of the Our World-Underwater Scholarship Society®. It has always been a great pleasure for me as president of the Society to bring the “family” together each year in New York City, so of course it is with great disappointment that for the second year we are unable to do so. A year ago, as the pandemic was beginning to spread throughout the world, the board of directors made the difficult decision to put all scholarship and internship activities on hold. 2020 was the first time in the Society’s history that we did not put Scholars or Interns in the field. But there is good news – the Society has new energy and is working with our hosts and sponsors to safely get our incoming 2021 Scholars and Interns started on their journeys. We bring three new Rolex Scholars and five new interns into our family for a total of 103 Rolex Scholars and 107 interns since the inception of the Society, and all of this has been accomplished by our all-volunteer organization. Forty-seven years of volunteers have been selfless in their efforts serving as directors, officers, committee members, coordinators, and technical advisors all motivated to support the Society’s mission “to promote educational activities associated with the underwater world.” None of this would have been possible without the incredible support by the Society’s many organizational partners and corporate sponsors throughout the years. The one constant in the Society’s evolution has been Rolex which continues to support the Society as part of its Perpetual Planet Initiative.
    [Show full text]
  • Supplementary Information
    Supplementary Information Figure S1. Sequential FISH imaging of microbial communities. A) Workflow of SEER-FISH experiments. For each round of hybridization, hybridization buffer with fluorescent probes flow through the sample for 2 min, flow is stopped and sample is incubated for 3 min at 46℃. Then sample is rinsed with washing buffer for 2 min at 46℃ to eliminate residual and nonspecific binding of probes. Images are captured right after the washing. After image acquisition, dissociation buffer is flowed through the samples at 46℃ for 2 min to strip off hybridized probes. Then dissociation image is captured with the same parameter above for checking the dissociation efficiency. The whole hybridization cycle can be finished in ~15 min and repeated for N rounds. B) Schematic diagram of SEER-FISH experimental setup. A flow chamber (Bioptech FCS2) is secured into a stage adapter to interface with a microscope for imaging. Silicone gasket (40 mm round, 0.75 mm thick) with a rectangle cavity internal that separates the micro-aqueduct slide from the coverslip is used to create an optical cavity in the chamber. Laminar flow perfusion that comes into one of the ports (INLET) on one side of the chamber is collected within the optical cavity and then directed out of the chamber on the other side (OUTLET). Uniform temperature across the entire field is maintained by a temperature controller. Flow through this chamber is controlled via an extraneous peristaltic pump. C) Representative images of microbes after multiple rounds of hybridization and dissociation (hybridization round 1, 10, 20, and 26). Dissociation images demonstrate the efficient removal of fluorescent probes.
    [Show full text]
  • Mission-Tech-Travel-Document-Bh
    Participant Info: Personal and Confidential Print Clearly Name: Birth Date: Last / Family / Surname First / Given Initial Month / Day / Year Address: City: State/Province: Zip/Postal Code: Country: Home Phone: Daytime Phone: Email: Occupation: o Male o Female Emergency Contact: Name: Name: Address: Address: Relationship: Relationship: Home Phone: Home Phone: Work/Cell Phone: Work/Cell Phone: Media Release THIS MODEL AGREEMENT AND RELEASE (“Agreement”) is dated ____________ and is between the undersigned companie(s) (“Photographer”) and the undersigned model/performer (“I”). Agreement as follows: For good and valuable consideration of _______________ , I hereby grant the undersigned Photographer permission to photograph me. I further give my irrevocable consent to Photographer and his/her direct or indirect licensees (International Training, Scuba Diving International, Technical Diving International, Emergency Response Diving International) and assignees to publish, republish or otherwise transmit the images of myself in any medium for all purposes throughout the world. I understand that the images may be altered or modified in any manner. I hereby waive any right that I may have to inspect and approve a finished product or the copy that may be used in connection with an image that the Photographer has taken of me, or the use to which it may be applied. I further release the Photographer and his/her direct or indirect licensees and assignees, from any claims for remuneration associated with any form of damage, foreseen or unforeseen associated with the use of the images. I am of legal age and have the full legal capacity to execute this authorization without the consent or knowledge of any other person.
    [Show full text]
  • Aquatic Microbial Ecology 80:15
    The following supplement accompanies the article Isolates as models to study bacterial ecophysiology and biogeochemistry Åke Hagström*, Farooq Azam, Carlo Berg, Ulla Li Zweifel *Corresponding author: [email protected] Aquatic Microbial Ecology 80: 15–27 (2017) Supplementary Materials & Methods The bacteria characterized in this study were collected from sites at three different sea areas; the Northern Baltic Sea (63°30’N, 19°48’E), Northwest Mediterranean Sea (43°41'N, 7°19'E) and Southern California Bight (32°53'N, 117°15'W). Seawater was spread onto Zobell agar plates or marine agar plates (DIFCO) and incubated at in situ temperature. Colonies were picked and plate- purified before being frozen in liquid medium with 20% glycerol. The collection represents aerobic heterotrophic bacteria from pelagic waters. Bacteria were grown in media according to their physiological needs of salinity. Isolates from the Baltic Sea were grown on Zobell media (ZoBELL, 1941) (800 ml filtered seawater from the Baltic, 200 ml Milli-Q water, 5g Bacto-peptone, 1g Bacto-yeast extract). Isolates from the Mediterranean Sea and the Southern California Bight were grown on marine agar or marine broth (DIFCO laboratories). The optimal temperature for growth was determined by growing each isolate in 4ml of appropriate media at 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 35, 40, 45 and 50o C with gentle shaking. Growth was measured by an increase in absorbance at 550nm. Statistical analyses The influence of temperature, geographical origin and taxonomic affiliation on growth rates was assessed by a two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) in R (http://www.r-project.org/) and the “car” package.
    [Show full text]
  • X-Ray Magazine L Issue 62
    THE FACTS AND VIEWPOINTS IN THIS SECTION ARE NOT NECESSARILY THE VIEWS OF X-RAY MAG. EQUIPMENT PRESENTED IN THIS SECTION HAS NOT BEEN TESTED BY X-RAY MAG STAFF, NOR ARE THE ITEMS WARRANTEED. INFORMATION PROVIDED IS CONDENSED FROM MANUFACTURERS’ DESCRIPTIONS. TEXTS ARE USUALLY EDITED FOR LENGTH, CLARITY AND STYLE. LINKS ARE ACTIVE AT THE TIME OF PUBLICATION POINT & CLICK ON BOLD LINKS Edited by Rosemary ‘Roz’ E. Lunn Equipment New Yacht Toy Beach Bag When it comes to purchasing your own pri- Sometimes you just fancy a simple day vate submarine, there is quite a choice. snorkelling or playing on the beach, and want an U-Boat Worx has just unveiled their latest easy solution for carrying your kit, and keeping your wallet and contribution; the Super Yacht Sub 3. This keys safe. This brightly coloured and highly functional beach is capable of taking you, plus two friends bag from Subgear has a discrete zipped pocket at the front to a maximum of 300m / 984f. As you for goodies you don’t want to get wet. Fins are securely would expect it comes complete with luxury stored in a separate pocket, with the mask and snorkel leather seating and an air-conditioned envi- J2 stashed in another compartment. (All kit is easily accessed ronment. U-Boat Worx state the six powerful Fourth Element has aug- via elongated zips). The heavy-duty nylon bag benefits thrusters can handle strong currents, and mented their thermal from a number of integrated mesh panels that allow you can get quite decent bottom times.
    [Show full text]
  • Diving and Hyperbaric Medicine the Journal of the South Pacific Underwater Medicine Society (Incorporated in Ictoria)V A0020660B
    Diving and Hyperbaric Medicine The Journal of the South Pacific Underwater Medicine Society (Incorporated in ictoria)V A0020660B ISSN 1833 3516 Volume 37 No. 3 ABN 29 299 823 713 September 2007 Aerobic fitness and scuba diving Deep decompression stops – do they improve safety? HBO and cancer – friend or foe? The man who thought his wife was a hat Improving diving medicine courses Print Post Approved PP 331758/0015 CONTENTS Diving and Hyperbaric Medicine Volume 37 No. 3 September 2007 Editorial SPUMS notices & news 117 The Editor’s offering – diving medicine education 152 Diploma of Diving and Hyperbaric Medicine requirements 152 Approved extracts of minutes of the SPUMS Executive Review articles Committee Meeting, held on 118 Aerobic fitness and underwater diving 19 April 2007 at Oceans Resort, Neal W Pollock Tutukaka, New Zealand 125 Deep decompression stops 153 Dates and venues of the SPUMS Andrew Fock Annual Scientific Meetings 154 Greetings from the new SPUMS Webmaster 155 ANZ College of Anaesthetists SPUMS ASM 2007 Special Interest Group in Diving 133 Hyperbaric oxygenation in the patient with malignancy: and Hyperbaric Medicine (SIG- friend or foe? DHM) Heather M Macdonald Case report Letter to the Editor 139 Transient prosopagnosia resulting from a cerebral gas 164 Project Stickybeak and DAN embolism while diving AP dive accident reporting Colin M Wilson, Martin DJ Sayer and A Gordon Murchison project John Lippmann Short communication 143 Effects of a single hyperbaric oxygen exposure on haematocrit, prothrombin time, serum calcium,
    [Show full text]
  • Commando Escape
    Commando Escape Buoyancy Compensator User Instruction Manual Contents Important Information ........................................................................................ 3 Intended Use....................................................................................................... 4 Introduction ........................................................................................................ 4 Equipment Stowage ........................................................................................... 6 Zip Pockets .......................................................................................................... 6 Surface Trim & Weighting ................................................................................. 6 Cylinder Mounting Options ............................................................................... 7 Mounting Cylinders ........................................................................................... 8 Pre Dive Inspection .......................................................................................... 10 Donning the BCD ............................................................................................. 10 Buoyancy Control ............................................................................................ 11 Inflating the BCD ................................................................................................ 11 Power Inflator ............................................................................................. 11 Oral Inflation
    [Show full text]
  • IMPORTANT NOTICE Please Read This Document Before Using the Product As New Features Will Require You to Modify Your Operational Techniques
    [Type text] AP Restricted HP Hoses & Progressive-Opening Oxygen Cylinder Valves IMPORTANT NOTICE Please read this document before using the product as new features will require you to modify your operational techniques. Prevention of Oxygen Fires Closed Circuit Rebreathers, over the past 22 years, have brought about the widespread use of pure oxygen by divers. All Nitrox trained divers know that handling pure oxygen requires special care, regarding operation & use, cleanliness, lubrication and replacement regimes but over time it has become clear that protocols for handling oxygen have to be reviewed and improved. Oxygen fires are thankfully quite rare, but when they do occur, they can result in serious damage to people and possessions and every effort has to be made to avoid them. From our research into oxygen fires, six important facts Jump out: 1) Oxygen fires always occur when the valve is opened. 2) The diver’s perception of what is slow opening is WRONG. 3) Rented or borrowed cylinders represent a greater risk than the diver using his original cylinders. 4) 50% of oxygen fires start in the HP hose. 5) 50% of fires start in the 1st stage. 6) The oxygen HP hose always burns in an O2 fire and is falsely seen as the culprit. Type Testing: For type approval testing of oxygen compatibility of AP components and valves; testing is done by instantly pressurising products with hot oxygen to between 290 and 350 bar. (Instant pressurisation = <20mS; hot oxygen = 70oC ). Fast pressurisation is something that divers get away with, while there is no contamination present.
    [Show full text]
  • Download the Full Article As Pdf ⬇︎
    TipFrom ofthe an Iceberg Text by Nathalie Lasselin. Photos by Nathalie Lasselin, Mjee De Carufel and Benedicte Lasselin to My Tap Water — Diving the Arctic Underworld & the St Lawrence River 46 X-RAY MAG : 91 : 2019 EDITORIAL FEATURES TRAVEL NEWS WRECKS EQUIPMENT BOOKS SCIENCE & ECOLOGY TECH EDUCATION PROFILES PHOTO & VIDEO PORTFOLIO feature Fresh Water Dramatic scenery in the Great Canadian North. PREVIOUS PAGE: Ice forms into strange shapes in the Arctic. Award-winning underwater cin- ematographer and documen- tary producer Nathalie Lasselin reflects upon her dive expedi- tions in the Arctic and her epic project to raise awareness about the state of fresh water in the St Lawrence River, closer to home in Montreal. It was the end of April, and it was sup- posed to be the end of winter. But once again, I had to refrain from putting my thick winter coat on the very top shelf of my wardrobe. I was already looking for the first barbecue party with friends, but the north was calling me—the Great Canadian North—and how could I say no to going back to the floe edge? So, I packed my winter coat, my diving and filming gear, and headed to a small vil- lage in the remote north the endless white sheet of ice, punctuat- amazing animals like polar bears, walrus anchored to the bottom of the ocean called Pond Inlet. It was ed by some iceberg raising from the fro- and, of course, narwhals. With a bit of and the floe, then we test the edge to one of the isolated ham- zen sea, the magic just starts.
    [Show full text]
  • Ambient Pressure Diving Ltd
    Ambient Pressure Diving Ltd Equipment Inspection following a diving incident. A step by step guide: 1) Photography: It is absolutely essential to photograph everything. Sometime later when you are working through scenarios, you will need to know what was connected to what, which side each cylinder was, how close to his body was it mounted, did he have dive reel etc – the possibilities of future questions are endless and the photos taken at this stage could prove invaluable. I would strongly advise that the photographer be a separate person to the equipment examiner and ensure the photographer is briefed on getting a shot of everything both prior and during dis-assembly. 2) Record Keeping: Again, it is absolutely essential to record everything you do and find. E.g. If you are inspecting the diluent side and find no fault then write “No fault found” – you are going to need this data later. The equipment inspection is a time for data collection – leave the analysis of the cause of the incident until afterwards, when you have all the data in and you have time to cross- reference with autopsy findings and statements. 3) Autopsy: All too often a verdict of “death by drowning” is recorded. A proper autopsy can reveal much: Contact Dr M. Calder – [email protected] Telephone: 01223 277220 – he’s a pathologist specialising in deaths in water. 3) Recovery: On the bottom: The divers need to be briefed on what to look for: Does the diver have his mouthpiece in? Mask On? Is he heavy on the bottom or semi-floating? Is there a beeping noise? If so –where is it coming from? Are there any bubbles – if so where from? Ensure they do not touch the cylinder valves.
    [Show full text]