sign in sign up
<<
Home , Christine Tell, Donna Harpauer, Don McMorris, Gordon Wyant, Lori Carr, Prince Albert Carlton

FIRST SESSION — TWENTY-NINTH LEGISLATURE

of the

Legislative Assembly of ______

DEBATES AND PROCEEDINGS

______

(HANSARD) Published under the authority of The Hon. Speaker

N.S. VOL. 62 NO. 30A TUESDAY, MAY 4, 2021, 13:30

LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF SASKATCHEWAN 1st Session — 29th Legislature

Lieutenant Governor — His Honour the Honourable Russ Mirasty, S.O.M., M.S.M.

Speaker — Hon. Randy Weekes Premier — Hon. Leader of the Opposition —

Beck, Carla — (NDP) Love, Matt — Eastview (NDP) Belanger, Buckley — Athabasca (NDP) Makowsky, Hon. Gene — (SP) Bonk, Steven — Moosomin (SP) Marit, Hon. David — Wood River (SP) Bowes, Jennifer — Saskatoon University (NDP) McLeod, Tim — (SP) Bradshaw, Hon. Fred — Carrot River Valley (SP) McMorris, Hon. Don — Indian Head-Milestone (SP) Buckingham, David — (SP) Meili, Ryan — (NDP) Carr, Hon. Lori — Estevan (SP) Merriman, Hon. Paul — Saskatoon Silverspring-Sutherland (SP) Cheveldayoff, Ken — (SP) Meyers, Derek — (SP) Cockrill, Jeremy — The Battlefords (SP) Moe, Hon. Scott — Rosthern-Shellbrook (SP) Conway, Meara — Regina Elphinstone-Centre (NDP) Morgan, Hon. Don — (SP) Dennis, Terry — Canora-Pelly (SP) Mowat, Vicki — (NDP) Docherty, Mark — (SP) Nerlien, Hugh — Kelvington-Wadena (SP) Domotor, Ryan — Cut Knife-Turtleford (SP) Nippi-Albright, Betty — (NDP) Duncan, Hon. Dustin — Weyburn-Big Muddy (SP) Ottenbreit, Greg — Yorkton (SP) Eyre, Hon. Bronwyn — Saskatoon Stonebridge-Dakota (SP) Reiter, Hon. Jim — Rosetown-Elrose (SP) Fiaz, Muhammad — (SP) Ritchie, Erika — (NDP) Francis, Ken — Kindersley (SP) Ross, Alana — (SP) Friesen, Marv — (SP) Ross, Hon. Laura — (SP) Goudy, Todd — Melfort (SP) Sarauer, Nicole — (NDP) Grewal, Gary — (SP) Skoropad, Dana — Arm River (SP) Hargrave, Joe — (SP) Steele, Doug — Cypress Hills (SP) Harpauer, Hon. Donna — Humboldt-Watrous (SP) Stewart, Hon. Lyle — Lumsden-Morse (SP) Harrison, Daryl — Cannington (SP) Tell, Hon. Christine — (SP) Harrison, Hon. Jeremy — Meadow Lake (SP) Vermette, Doyle — Cumberland (NDP) Hindley, Hon. Everett — Swift Current (SP) Weekes, Hon. Randy — Biggar-Sask Valley (SP) Jenson, Terry — Martensville-Warman (SP) Wilson, Nadine — (SP) Kaeding, Hon. Warren — Melville-Saltcoats (SP) Wotherspoon, Trent — (NDP) Keisig, Travis — Last Mountain-Touchwood (SP) Wyant, Hon. Gordon — (SP) Kirsch, Delbert — Batoche (SP) Young, Aleana — (NDP) Lambert, Lisa — Saskatoon Churchill-Wildwood (SP) Young, Colleen — Lloydminster (SP) Lawrence, Greg — (SP)

Party Standings: (SP) — 48; New Democratic Party (NDP) — 13

Clerks-at-the-Table Clerk — Gregory A. Putz Law Clerk & Parliamentary Counsel — Kenneth S. Ring, Q.C. Hansard on the internet Deputy Clerk — Iris Lang Hansard and other documents of the Clerk Assistant — Kathy Burianyk Legislative Assembly are available within hours after each sitting. Sergeant-at-Arms — Terry Quinn https://www.legassembly.sk.ca/Calendar CONTENTS

ROUTINE PROCEEDINGS PRESENTING PETITIONS Bowes ...... 741 Conway ...... 741 Nippi-Albright ...... 741 STATEMENTS BY MEMBERS Rare Earth Processing Plant Planned for Saskatoon Friesen ...... 741 Investment in Early Childhood Education Beck ...... 742 First Nation Opens New Business Ross, A...... 742 Support for Workers during Pandemic Bowes ...... 742 Renewal of Prince Albert Victoria Hospital Hargrave ...... 742 Be Ready for Anything during Emergency Preparedness Week Keisig ...... 743 Saskatchewan Government Donates Ventilators to India Grewal ...... 743 QUESTION PERIOD Government Response to COVID-19 Pandemic Meili ...... 743 Moe ...... 743 Construction Industry in Saskatchewan Wotherspoon ...... 744 Harpauer ...... 744 Harrison, J...... 745 Vaccination of Early Childhood Education Staff Beck ...... 745 Duncan ...... 745 Child Care Subsidies and Tax Reductions for Families Conway ...... 746 Harpauer ...... 746 PRESENTING REPORTS BY STANDING AND SPECIAL COMMITTEES Standing Committee on Crown and Central Agencies Dennis ...... 747 THIRD READINGS Bill No. 17 — The Traffic Safety (Miscellaneous) Amendment Act, 2020 Morgan ...... 747 Bill No. 18 — The All Terrain Vehicles Amendment Act, 2020 Morgan ...... 748 Bill No. 24 — The Vehicles for Hire Amendment Act, 2020 Morgan ...... 748 ORDERS OF THE DAY GOVERNMENT ORDERS ADJOURNED DEBATES SECOND READINGS Bill No. 34 — The Fuel Tax Amendment Act, 2021 Conway ...... 749

LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF SASKATCHEWAN 741 May 4, 2021

[The Assembly met at 13:30.] The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Saskatoon Centre. [Prayers] Ms. Nippi-Albright: — miigwech, Mr. Speaker. I’m pleased to ROUTINE PROCEEDINGS rise today to speak about the petition calling for the government to reject the proposed Lambert Peat Moss development. PRESENTING PETITIONS We, the undersigned residents of the province of Saskatchewan, The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Saskatoon wish to bring to your attention the following: Quebec-based University. Lambert Peat Moss has proposed the creation of a peat moss mine near La Ronge in northern Saskatchewan. Many local Ms. Bowes: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It’s my pleasure to residents, hunters, trappers, and traditional land users are present a petition again today calling for pay equity legislation. opposed to the proposed peat moss mine and are concerned about The signatories would like to bring to our attention the following the potential for damage to habitats, including critical habitat for points: the Saskatchewan Human Rights Commission has caribou, woodland caribou, traplines, and drinking water sources, recommended proactive and comprehensive pay equity as well as climate impacts. legislation which has not been pursued by the Government of Saskatchewan. Pay equity is a human rights issue, Mr. Speaker. More than 20,000 people have signed an online petition calling Economic equality for women is a basic human right, and pay for the proposed peat moss mine to be stopped: equity legislation is fundamentally necessary in order to achieve women’s economic equality. We, in the prayer that reads as follows, respectfully request that the Legislative Assembly of Saskatchewan call on the I’ll read the prayer: provincial government to protect the boreal forest and reject the proposed Lambert Peat Moss development. We, in the prayer that reads as follows, respectfully request that the Legislative Assembly of Saskatchewan call on the With that, I present. Government of Saskatchewan to introduce pay equity legislation. STATEMENTS BY MEMBERS

Mr. Speaker, today the petition has been signed by people from The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Saskatoon Regina. I do so present. Riversdale.

The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina Rare Earth Processing Plant Planned for Saskatoon Elphinstone-Centre. Mr. Friesen: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. For many years Ms. Conway: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It’s a pleasure to rise technology has been advancing at a rapid pace, and sophisticated and present a petition to save the Lighthouse and provide core technology requires the rare earth elements that can be found funding to emergency homelessness shelters. The Lighthouse right here in Canada. Last year, in collaboration with the serving The Battlefords is the only general emergency shelter of Saskatchewan Research Council, our government announced the its kind in the area. It was opened in 2015 to fill a need in the construction of a rare earth processing facility in Saskatoon. And community for people struggling with homelessness, with mental that investment, Mr. Speaker, is already paying off. health challenges, with addiction, Mr. Speaker, and it faced a 90 per cent cut to its core funding within the first year. That funding Mr. Speaker, Cheetah Resources, a Canadian subsidiary of Vital has never been reinstated, and The Battlefords serving North Metals, announced today that they are planning a $5 million rare Battleford is at risk of closing. earth extraction plant in Saskatoon. This extraction plant will complement Cheetah’s mining investments in the Northwest This petition also speaks to the larger issue of the lack of core Territories and allow for the complete rare earth metal supply funding for shelters, which is of course an issue that plagues chain to occur here in Canada. Mr. Speaker, ore will be mined in shelters across the province. Canada’s North, transported to Saskatoon, and turned into carbonate at Cheetah’s new facility and refined into oxides by I’ll read the prayer: Saskatchewan Research Council, ready to be exported to market.

We, in the prayer that reads as follows, respectfully request When asked why they chose Saskatchewan for their investment, that the Legislative Assembly of Saskatchewan call on the Cheetah noted that SRC’s [Saskatchewan Research Council] Government of Saskatchewan to immediately provide capability, accessibility of land, and the ease of permitting all stable, guaranteed core funding to the Lighthouse serving made Saskatchewan their province of choice. The Battlefords and to expand supports for emergency shelters across Saskatchewan by moving to a core funding Mr. Speaker, investments like this show that Saskatchewan will model. rebound from the pandemic, despite the doom and gloom coming from the members opposite. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The signatories of this petition, Mr. Speaker, reside in North Battleford. I do so present. The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina 742 Saskatchewan Hansard May 4, 2021

Lakeview. Support for Workers during Pandemic

Investment in Early Childhood Education Ms. Bowes: — Mr. Speaker, I rise today in support of Saskatchewan workers. The pandemic has caused increased Ms. Beck: — Mr. Speaker, it is my honour to rise as the critic for mental health challenges for so many in this province. This week Education in recognition of early childhood educators around the is Mental Health Awareness Week, and I stand here in solidarity province today. Early childhood educators are some of the most with all Saskatchewan workers. impactful people in children’s lives. They’ve been on the front line throughout this pandemic, ensuring families receive the Many have been laid off and many continue to work on the front quality care and education crucial to the healthy development and lines to support our province, while not receiving the support growth of our youngest citizens. Despite being named essential they deserve from the government. Burnout, anxiety, depression service providers during this pandemic, these critical workers — — these are all on the rise. What many of us may not be aware primarily women and often newcomers to Saskatchewan — of is that COVID-19 is considered a traumatic event. Traumatic remain some of the lowest paid people in the education sector. events can cause physical, emotional, and psychological harm.

Mr. Speaker, this government has, and I quote, proclaimed May I stand to bring awareness because I worry for the people of this to be “. . . Early Childhood Education Month and is an province. I worry deeply that this government is not doing what opportunity to acknowledge the important role early childhood it needs to do to protect the mental health of those who are education plays in the growth and development of children.” suffering. No paid sick leave, a grossly low minimum wage, increased stressors, limited access to resources and support — With the recent announcement of funding available in the federal this is a crumbling system, yet this government continues to budget, this government now has an opportunity to act on this throw scraps at working-class people. acknowledgement and finally address long-standing issues in early childhood education. This government has an incredible So to all the workers in this province, those on the front lines, opportunity to invest in the economic infrastructure that is child those working from home, those laid off and unemployed: we care and to ensure that our next generation is being set up for hear you, we see you, and we will continue to fight for you. success. The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Prince Albert I ask this government to truly recognize the contributions of our Carlton. early childhood educators and not leave one penny of the federal money available on the table. Thank you. Renewal of Prince Albert Victoria Hospital

The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Prince Albert Mr. Hargrave: — Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Northcote. Speaker, I’m very pleased to stand today to announce that the renewal of the Prince Albert Victoria Hospital is moving ahead. First Nation Opens New Business Stantec has been selected as the design firm for this very important project. Stantec’s team of local architects and Ms. A. Ross: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise in this Chamber engineers have a proud history of infrastructure project delivery today to recognize a First Nations business locating in Prince throughout Saskatchewan. Albert. Mr. Speaker, on April 21st, Sturgeon Lake First Nation, along with their partners Lake Country Co-op and Federated Mr. Speaker, as you know, Victoria Hospital in Prince Albert is Co-operative’s new brand, Western Nations, announced they will the major hub for essential health care services across northern be building a new gas station with a convenience store and a Saskatchewan. Our government is pleased to see this Chester’s Chicken drive-through. redevelopment project moving ahead. We look forward to working with the local community and our Indigenous partners Mr. Speaker, Sturgeon Lake First Nation’s Chief Greg Ermine at to ensure it includes all the services and amenities they require. the ribbon-cutting ceremony noted, “Tipi Fuel and Convenience Store is an exciting new venture for both the city of Prince Albert We are investing more than $300 million in the redesigned and the Sturgeon Lake First Nation. As referenced in the name hospital for a new acute care tower, the replacement of existing Tipi, this project will be designed to include the traditions and mental health space, and renovations to the current facility. Upon the values of the First Nations.” Mr. Speaker, Chief Ermine completion, the total number of beds available is expected to indicated this will not be the last business venture that the increase by about 40 per cent, with space to expand further as Sturgeon Lake First Nation hopes to bring to the city of Prince needed. Albert. This project and others will benefit Sturgeon Lake First Nation and the city of Prince Albert. Mr. Speaker, the Prince Albert Victoria Hospital is a critical component of our province’s health infrastructure. This Mr. Speaker, I ask that all members of this Assembly join me significant investment will serve not only the people of Prince today in congratulating Sturgeon Lake First Nation and their Albert but the entire northern half of the province for years to partners in their construction of a new fuel and convenience store come. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. in Prince Albert. The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Last The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Saskatoon Mountain-Touchwood. University. May 4, 2021 Saskatchewan Hansard 743

Be Ready for Anything during Government Response to COVID-19 Pandemic Emergency Preparedness Week Mr. Meili: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Whether the Premier is Mr. Keisig: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Our government has willing to admit it or not, he’s made serious mistakes in these past proclaimed May 2nd to the 8th as Emergency Preparedness few months, mistakes that have cost people their lives and put Week. This year’s national theme is Be Ready for Anything. people out of work. Citizens across Saskatchewan and Canada are urged to identify the risks to their home and property, make a plan to respond to In November the Premier downplayed the second wave. He those risks, and prepare an emergency kit containing at least 72 boasted how Saskatchewan long-term care facilities hadn’t been hours of supplies in the event that local services are disrupted hit the way other provinces were, but he did nothing to do the during a natural or human-caused hazard. work to prevent those deadly outbreaks happening here in Saskatchewan. As a result, over 100 people died in seniors’ care As we have all seen, Saskatchewan is not immune to emergency homes here in the province. events like wildfires, floods, or severe weather events. In order to implement an emergency plan, residents need to know that an Why did he do that, Mr. Speaker? Did he have information emergency is happening nearby. Mr. Speaker, the residents of saying that somehow our long-term care homes would be spared, Saskatchewan rely on the SaskAlert system to notify them of or was he just crossing his fingers and hoping for the best? Mr. active emergencies in their area. A test of this system is timed for Speaker, does the Premier regret acting on wishful thinking Wednesday, May 5th, at 1:55 p.m. This alert will be broadcast to instead of taking every step he could to protect Saskatchewan wireless devices, radio, TV, and the SaskAlert app and website. seniors? We encourage everyone to download the SaskAlert app from their app store or from SaskAlert.ca. During Emergency The Speaker: — I recognize the Premier. Preparedness Week, let’s all take the time to Be Ready for Anything. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Hon. Mr. Moe: — Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Right at the outset of this pandemic, I can remember conversations — The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina Northeast. myself and the previous Health minister — with respect to long-term care and some of the decisions that were brought Saskatchewan Government Donates Ventilators to India forward from the Saskatchewan Health Authority around, you know, cohorting of staff, Mr. Speaker, keeping our staff in one Mr. Grewal: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, we have location as opposed to working at multiple long-term care all seen and heard the upsetting news out of India where they locations, Mr. Speaker. There was funding provided to ensure have been struggling with a massive surge of COVID-19. The that that could actually be the case for our staff, our very valued situation is critical. And we want to express our deep concern and staff that work in long-term care facilities taking care of our sincerest sympathies to the residents of India and to our own family members across the province. Saskatchewan residents who are worried about friends and family in India. That’s but one example, Mr. Speaker, of the measures that were put in place very early. They were built on by public health Mr. Speaker, our government is doing more than extending our measures that were put in place for communities and in long-term sympathies and words. I’m proud to report that our government care facilities where, sadly, family members have not been able is reaching out and donating 100 ventilators to India. The to enter into those long-term care facilities for some period of donation will include 30 critical-care ventilators and 70 subacute time. ventilators. This donation will help provide critical resources to support care for the seriously ill in a country which has recently Thankfully, more recently, due to how Saskatchewan people been suffering greatly. have met the challenges of COVID-19 by adhering to the public health measures and, yes, going out and getting vaccinated when [13:45] it’s their turn, we’ve been able to loosen up some of those opportunities so that people, family members, are able to go in Mr. Speaker, this is a global pandemic, and we are fortunate that and see their family in these facilities over the course of the now we can make this donation while ensuring our own residents last number of days, Mr. Speaker. continue to have access to all necessary medical equipment. Early in the pandemic Saskatchewan proactively sourced several The Speaker: — I recognize the Leader of the Opposition. hundred additional ventilators. Thankfully we have not had to use anything near our capacity. Mr. Meili: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The question of course was about the over 100 seniors who died in long-term care homes We all share the desire to see India, its residents, and the world because this government chose to do nothing to protect them. come through this pandemic as safely, quickly, and healthy as possible. We are very happy to do our part to help. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, he doesn’t want to look at his own record. But let’s Mr. Speaker. talk about March. In March the Premier saw variants on the rise, and he inexplicably chose that time — the worst possible time — QUESTION PERIOD to relax restrictions. A hundred more Saskatchewan people have died since that fateful choice. The Speaker: — I recognize the Leader of the Opposition. Mr. Speaker, the Premier said he made that choice based on the 744 Saskatchewan Hansard May 4, 2021 information he was given. Surely then he wouldn’t have any this province. We’ve been very clear with the public health problem releasing that information to the public, because measures that we’ve had in place across this province over the otherwise we have no option but to conclude that once again this various number of months, Mr. Speaker. And we’ve been very Premier has put his own political desires ahead of public safety. clear on our message with respect to, when it’s your turn, make your appointment; go to a drive-through; phone your pharmacy, To the Premier: will he release the public health advice that and get vaccinated. Mr. Speaker, we can’t be any more clear than guided this and other key decisions? Or do we simply have to that. assume he has a good reason to want to hide his role and his responsibility? And saying that, as we move ahead here, Mr. Speaker, we are going to ensure that we continue with the cautious and measured The Speaker: — I recognize the Premier. approach that we have, Mr. Speaker, but understanding the rates of vaccination that we have in this province. And when you look Hon. Mr. Moe: — Mr. Speaker, every week I go out myself, at examples of other areas of the world, and I would take note in multiple times with the media, once a week with Dr. Shahab. The Israel or the UK [United Kingdom] or the USA [United States of Minister of Health goes out, Mr. Speaker, and we speak quite America], but the UK in particular started their conversations and clearly to the public health advice that we have been provided. moving forward with their reopening road map, Mr. Speaker, in And we speak to the decisions that we have come to with public that country at about 43 per cent of their adult population health and the Government of Saskatchewan on behalf of the vaccinated. Today we’re at 44 per cent, Mr. Speaker. people of this province. Mr. Speaker, we have done that for many, many months now with respect specifically to COVID. Mr. Speaker, we are going to put these metrics in place. The metrics will be based on vaccination rates as ultimately as has And I would say that we are going to have a little bit more to say shown in these other areas of the world where their vaccination on this later today, Mr. Speaker, due to the effort of rates are higher than us. They drive the other rates of COVID, the Saskatchewan people in adhering to the public health advice, other metrics of COVID, Mr. Speaker, the severe outcomes of going out and getting vaccinated. And we have people that are COVID down. And that’s what we want to do here in this being vaccinated as we speak, 37 years old and over in this province. province, Mr. Speaker, the drive-through right in our capital city. The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina Mr. Speaker, we are going to have a very clear conversation with Rosemont. the people of this province as to what the metrics are for us to move through the COVID pandemic, and what we all need to Construction Industry in Saskatchewan continue to do to ensure that we’re able to move through this COVID pandemic together, Mr. Speaker, get back to the way that Mr. Wotherspoon: — Mr. Speaker, the Premier should show his life used to be, like they are in other areas of the world. Mr. work with respect to public health facts, plain and simple. And Speaker, better days ahead for this province. that government and that Premier needs to do so much more to get people back to work, to get our economy on its feet. The Sask The Speaker: — I recognize the Leader of the Opposition. Party’s damaging decision to add the PST [provincial sales tax] to construction labour has driven jobs and investment and people Mr. Meili: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This Premier continues out of this province. to show no humility, no responsibility, no accountability for the pain caused by the choices he has made, no respect for the people The government is apparently launching a plan to reopen the of Saskatchewan and the suffering he has put them through, Mr. economy later today. So why not take this as an opportunity to Speaker. admit their mistake, to scrap the PST on construction labour, to get people back to work, and to get this economy back on its feet? But as always, today’s a new day. It’s an opportunity to do better. The Premier said today he plans to put out the next steps for the The Speaker: — I recognize the Finance minister. road ahead, Mr. Speaker. Well any kind of plan would be preferable to the erratic blind driving we’ve seen thus far from a Hon. Ms. Harpauer: — Mr. Speaker, if nothing else, I have to Premier who brings out new surprises every Tuesday without any say the member opposite is very persistent on this. He’s brought explanation of whether or why he’ll make any particular change. it up now for three years. They ran an election on it and lost, Mr. Speaker, and quite frankly the facts fly in the face of what he has Mr. Speaker, will the Premier commit to a plan that is guided not said time and time and time again. only by vaccination numbers, as important as we all know those are, but also by clear benchmarks about what’s happening with When you look at just the recent announcements that we have COVID-19 in Saskatchewan? Test positivity, hospitalization, had of the development here or investment here in the province, community transmission — these need to be part of that plan, Mr. we have the Saskatchewan Food Industry Development Centre. Speaker. Will the Premier show his work and release the public We have the Genesis Fertilizers facility just announced today, health advice that leads to these next decisions? Or will he Mr. Speaker. The North American Helium announcement that continue to keep Saskatchewan people in the dark? we had a member’s statement on. There is the big announcement by Viterra. Cargill is making a huge investment in our province. The Speaker: — I recognize the Premier. Clean Seed Capital Group Ltd. Richardson International Ltd. Hon. Mr. Moe: — Mr. Speaker, no one’s been left in the dark in with the crush plant in Yorkton. We have Highrock Resources May 4, 2021 Saskatchewan Hansard 745

Ltd., and Kindersley-based Verdera Energy is expanding, Mr. The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Trade and Export Speaker. We also have Benchmark PPE. We have Proton Development. Technologies, Prairie Lithium corporation, the NRGen, the Dunkley Lumber and Nutrien announcements just within this last Hon. Mr. J. Harrison: — Well, Mr. Speaker, it shouldn’t year. surprise people in this Chamber, but that member is completely wrong. The construction numbers, I have them right in front of Mr. Speaker, that is incredible investment in this province. me from March, the last StatsCan jobs report: construction, up 7.9 per cent, Mr. Speaker, year over year. I have no idea what The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina that member is talking about. Rosemont. And more good news today, Mr. Speaker, from Statistics Canada. Mr. Wotherspoon: — That’s a lot of spin, Mr. Speaker. The fact Merchandise exports, these are the exports from this province of the matter is that we’ve lost 23,000 jobs in Saskatchewan this that go around the globe. Mr. Speaker, how much were they up year, the worst jobs creation record of all of the country, of all of over the course of the last month? Twenty-six per cent, Mr. the provinces. And according to the building permit numbers out Speaker. Twenty-six per cent increase in exports. How much today, the hardest hit construction sector in Canada too. were they up over the course of the last year, Mr. Speaker? A Saskatchewan was the only province, the only province to see a remarkable 14 per cent increase in exports year over year. decline, year over year, in the value of building permits. And that’s after years of losses after the tax hike. Our job creators are doing a wonderful job in this province, Mr. Speaker, and that would never have happened if those guys were It’s no wonder that this is happening, with the imposition of the in government. PST onto construction labour that’s driving the cost of projects up, and projects away, and people out of this province. The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina Lakeview. The Sask Party’s keen to talk about their plan to reopen, but they’ve got no plan to get us out of last place when it comes to Vaccination of Early Childhood Education Staff construction and when it comes to jobs. Why won’t the Sask Party simply take the PST off of construction and get people back Ms. Beck: — We’re expecting this government’s second crack to work? at a reopening plan later this afternoon. But we know this: this plan is doomed to fail if we’re opening up our economy while The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Finance. child care workers are left unprotected by vaccines.

Hon. Ms. Harpauer: — The one thing, quite frankly, that’s a lot This government’s patchwork approach has child care workers of spin is what that member just said. This is over $2 billion in centres attached to schools eligible for their shot, but those in worth of investment in our province. I hardly think that’s just a stand-alone centres left out. How does it make any sense to pick lot of spin. This is real investment within our province, real and choose which essential workers are worth protecting based construction, real jobs, and we’ll add to that the number of on which building they work in? housing starts has gone up incredibly in the last several months. The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Education. So, Mr. Speaker, he may think that’s just a lot of spin. We view that as investment. We view that as economic growth. We view Hon. Mr. Duncan: — Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Mr. that as jobs that are going to be created right here in this province. Speaker, I think the SHA [Saskatchewan Health Authority] has It shows confidence in this province. It shows confidence in this done a tremendous job in prioritizing people in this province government. And it would not happen if the NDP [New based on age. Mr. Speaker, that’s where we have seen the most Democratic Party] were in government. severe outcomes in terms of hospitalizations and deaths, and it’s why Saskatchewan is one of the leading countries not only in the The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina rollout of vaccines, but also getting us to a position wherein today Rosemont. in Saskatchewan those that are 37 years old and over are able to get a vaccination, Mr. Speaker, are eligible to be vaccinated. Mr. Wotherspoon: — You know, Mr. Speaker, don’t let the facts get in the way, hey? Stats Canada: a 12 per cent decrease, [14:00] the worst in Canada in construction this year, year over year. Listening to those members you’d think that everything’s just That’s not the case in most other provinces, Mr. Speaker, that fine in Saskatchewan, but the numbers don’t lie, Mr. Speaker. have gone a different route in terms of their vaccination rollout, The worst job numbers in the country, the worst decline in Mr. Speaker. What we’re going to see, as vaccine supply construction in the country, the worst population decline in years increases in the province, we’re going to see that age eligibility — all from a jobs minister with the worst jobs record in Canada. continue to go down. I think it’s going to go down in a pretty significant way, Mr. Speaker, as we see more vaccines delivered Saskatchewan people just can’t afford to wait another day longer to the province by the federal government, Mr. Speaker. for this government to turn things around. Why won’t the Sask Party admit this was a mistake, scrap this damaging tax, and use I would urge those workers in any of those occupations that have this summer’s construction season to get people back to work and been designated, Mr. Speaker, that are eligible to get their our economy back on its feet? vaccinations. At a time when, for example, the members opposite 746 Saskatchewan Hansard May 4, 2021 were calling for teachers, Mr. Speaker, more than 50 per cent of offering vaccines to essential child care workers today? teachers were already eligible. There are child care workers that are eligible today to get a vaccination, and I encourage them to The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Education. do so. Hon. Mr. Duncan: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina again if the federal government was able to increase the supply Lakeview. coming to Saskatchewan, that could mean that we could prioritize additional people based on occupation, Mr. Speaker. Ms. Beck: — “A complete oversight and it’s wrong.” That’s how But the quickest way to get vaccinations to the greatest number Dr. Alex Wong described this government’s choice to leave our of people and has been proven to work is here in Saskatchewan, child care workers out of the vaccine plan. It isn’t surprising that where we have largely focused on age-based vaccinations, which this government continues to treat child care as an afterthought. means that we’re down to 37 years old, Mr. Speaker. This government sat on federal child care funding for a full year before they deployed it to the already struggling sector. And now That’s likely going to decrease further this week, Mr. Speaker. this government is musing about opening up the economy That’s great news for this province. The quickest way that we can without providing protection to all child care staff. get back to what normal is going to look like is getting shots in arms as quickly as possible. I had mine on Sunday night, Mr. These essential workers, Mr. Speaker, cannot work from home, Speaker. I was about 15 minutes behind the member from Regina and if they’re sick they have to stay home, meaning the rest of us Rosemont. Mr. Speaker, that is the quickest way that we’re going can’t work. There is nothing more essential to an economic to get back to what normal is going to look like in this province. recovery, Mr. Speaker. Will this minister commit to vaccinating Thank you, Mr. Speaker. all child care workers today? The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Education. Elphinstone-Centre.

Hon. Mr. Duncan: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, Child Care Subsidies and Tax Reductions for Families there is nothing more urgent in terms of reopening the economy to get as many people as possible as quickly as possible Ms. Conway: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I asked about child vaccinated in this province, Mr. Speaker. And that is what we’re care subsidies last week in committee. The Minister of Social going to do, Mr. Speaker. And that is how we’re going to be Services said it wasn’t appropriate to address my concerns at the successful in this province. Human Services Committee. Perhaps the floor of the Assembly is a better place. Mr. Speaker, again when we deal with a limited supply of vaccination and make determinations of what prioritization looks Mr. Speaker, a single mother of one, two, even three children like, it means that somebody has to come off the list. So we hear making the country’s lowest minimum wage does not qualify for often from the members opposite of who should be added to the the maximum child care subsidy in this province. Many are list, but they never finish that sentence, Mr. Speaker, and explain forced to drop shifts or leave their jobs altogether. The antiquated who should be off the list. child care subsidy system in place for the Ministry of Social Services could direct valuable federal child care dollars to get our We’re able to be at 37 years and over in this province for a very economy back on track and help working people. Will the good reason — because of the way the vaccine rollout has gone minister commit to doing that today? in Saskatchewan. It’s gone very well. It’s been very successful, Mr. Speaker. I would urge all of those that are eligible, Mr. The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Finance. Speaker, to get their vaccinations regardless of their occupation. We’re doing it by age and we’re doing it very quickly. Thank Hon. Ms. Harpauer: — I’m not exactly sure the time, but I was you, Mr. Speaker. told at some point that the member opposite had stated that a single parent making $1,640 a month would not be able to get the The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina child care subsidy, and that simply is not true. For one child the Lakeview. maximum threshold is 3,900 and for two children the maximum threshold is 6,200. Ms. Beck: — Mr. Speaker, it’s very disappointing that the Minister of Education is shilling for the Health minister instead But, Mr. Speaker, I can assure the member opposite that with the of standing up for these essential workers across our province. proposal that the federal government has included in their budget The SHA doctors are reporting that COVID transmission is out this year, and with discussions of both this program and the of control in two-thirds of our province. Our provincial test programming that falls under the Minister of Education, all of positivity rate is above 6 per cent and that rate was more than this will be looked at because it’s very, very difficult to compare 11 per cent in Regina yesterday. the different programs and subsidies that take place in each of the different provinces. We all approach this differently. Community transmission is simply not under control in this Saskatchewan, for example, is the only province that has a province. The decision to keep piling kids from households universal child tax credit that parents all benefit from. across the province into child care centres with unvaccinated workers is a dangerous and even deadly proposition, Mr. The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina Speaker. Again to this minister: will he reconsider and commit to Elphinstone-Centre. May 4, 2021 Saskatchewan Hansard 747

Ms. Conway: — Let’s talk about numbers for a minute. And I Social Services think kids deserve a head start only if they can would ask that the Minister of Finance consult its own website. afford to pay? And listen to my words — the full subsidy. They don’t qualify for the full subsidy. And clients of mine at Legal Aid, who were The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Finance. receiving the full subsidy, were still paying upwards of 450 per month for child care. So the full subsidy doesn’t even cover child Hon. Ms. Harpauer: — Mr. Speaker, it’s obvious that the care, and what you’re talking about is a partial subsidy. member opposite doesn’t understand that if you allow an individual to retain more of their earnings, that allows them to Does the minister know what someone working full time on spend it in how they see fit. And that may be on the child. She minimum wage earns? Seventeen hundred a month, net. A would rather have a subsidy that’s dedicated to one thing and one two-bedroom runs at 1,100 per month, and I know first-hand that thing only. That means the parent that chooses a family member licensed child care is about 700 per month per child, Mr. Speaker. to look after their child does not benefit from it. We shouldn’t expect any single parent in this province to go into debt by the time they pay their rent and put a kid in child care. If a couple, maybe low income, but they make the choice to go without a few things so that they can stay, one of the couple can I was 10 years old the last time you increased the subsidy — 25 stay home with the child, they also benefit. That is the importance years without a change, Mr. Speaker. The subsidy made sense of a universal child tax credit. That is the importance of keeping when the minimum wage was six bucks an hour and rent for a personal income tax low, Mr. Speaker, is that it allows all two-bedroom was less than 500 for a month, but it doesn’t make families to benefit from being able to retain their own income, sense now. Mr. Speaker.

Will this government, with its worst-in-the-country minimum She’s fixated on one program and one program only, without wage, commit to ensuring that parents can access child care? looking at the whole suite of tax reductions that this government has made. The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Finance. PRESENTING REPORTS BY STANDING AND Hon. Ms. Harpauer: — I would hope, quite frankly, that when SPECIAL COMMITTEES that member opposite is talking to her clients that she’s also telling them that in this province we have the lowest income tax The Speaker: — I recognize the Chair of the Standing in the country, or the second lowest, I believe, and it’s because Committee on Crown and Central Agencies. the personal tax exemption is so high in our province, something that we have increased a number of times and now we’ve indexed Standing Committee on Crown and Central Agencies it. What does that mean, Mr. Speaker? That means that each individual in our province gets to keep more of their income to Mr. Dennis: — Mr. Speaker, I’m instructed by the Standing spend as they so choose, and that may be in child care. Committee on Crown and Central Agencies to report Bill No. 17, The Traffic Safety (Miscellaneous) Amendment Act, 2020 I hope she tells her clients that we have the only universal child without amendment. tax credit in the country, and I hope she’s telling her clients we also have a low-income tax credit that is cash that goes directly The Speaker: — When shall this bill be considered in to her clients that they can spend on the child. Mr. Speaker, again, Committee of the Whole on Bills? I recognize the Minister of very few provinces have that. I hope she’s telling the clients SGI [Saskatchewan Government Insurance]. everything that this province has to offer, which is among the lowest taxes in the country for families. Hon. Mr. Morgan: — Mr. Speaker, I request leave to waive consideration in Committee of the Whole on this bill and the bill The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina be now read the third time. Elphinstone-Centre. The Speaker: — The minister has requested leave to waive Ms. Conway: — Mr. Speaker, I don’t even know what to say to consideration in Committee of the Whole on Bill No. 17 and that that pivot. And it just shows how out of touch this government is the bill be now read the third time. Is leave granted? with low-income and working people, Mr. Speaker. Some Hon. Members: — Agreed. Like I said, many single working parents can’t access the child care subsidy. Further, parents on income assistance are excluded, The Speaker: — The minister may now proceed to move third Mr. Speaker. I guess the Ministry of Social Services thinks reading. low-income people couldn’t use or don’t deserve a babysitter. But child care isn’t babysitting, Mr. Speaker. It’s early childhood THIRD READINGS education. And this government is making child care inaccessible to the folks that could benefit from it the most. Bill No. 17 — The Traffic Safety (Miscellaneous) Amendment Act, 2020 The minister’s own social service recommends early childhood education. It’s simply good for kids. It can break the cycle of Hon. Mr. Morgan: — Mr. Speaker, I move that the bill be now poverty. But because of this government’s priorities, children in read the third time and passed under its title. poverty are the least likely to access it. Does the Ministry of 748 Saskatchewan Hansard May 4, 2021

The Speaker: — It has been moved by the minister that Bill No. Some Hon. Members: — Agreed. 17 be now read the third time and passed under its title. Is the Assembly ready for the question? The Speaker: — Carried.

Some Hon. Members: — Question. Clerk: — Third reading of this bill.

The Speaker: — Is it the pleasure of the Assembly to adopt the The Speaker: — Third reading. motion? PRESENTING REPORTS BY STANDING AND Some Hon. Members: — Agreed. SPECIAL COMMITTEES

The Speaker: — Carried. The Speaker: — I recognize the Chair of the Standing Committee on Crown and Central Agencies. Clerk: — Third reading of this bill. [14:15] The Speaker: — Third reading. Standing Committee on Crown and Central Agencies PRESENTING REPORTS BY STANDING AND SPECIAL COMMITTEES Mr. Dennis: — Mr. Speaker, I’m instructed by the Standing Committee on Crown and Central Agencies to report Bill No. 24, The Speaker: — I recognize the Chair of the Standing The Vehicles for Hire Amendment Act, 2020 without amendment. Committee on Crown and Central Agencies. The Speaker: — When shall this bill be considered in Standing Committee on Crown and Central Agencies Committee of the Whole on Bills? I recognize the Minister of SGI. Mr. Dennis: — Mr. Speaker, I’m instructed by the Standing Committee on Crown and Central Agencies to report Bill No. 18, Hon. Mr. Morgan: — I request leave to waive consideration of The All Terrain Vehicles Amendment Act, 2020 without Committee of the Whole on this bill and the bill be now read the amendment. third time.

The Speaker: — When shall this bill be considered in The Speaker: — The minister has requested leave to waive Committee of the Whole on Bills? I recognize the Minister of consideration in Committee of the Whole on Bill No. 24 and that SGI. the bill be now read the third time. Is leave granted?

Hon. Mr. Morgan: — I request leave to waive consideration in Some Hon. Members: — Agreed. Committee of the Whole on this bill and the bill be now read the third time. The Speaker: — The minister may proceed to move third reading. The Speaker: — The minister has requested leave to waive consideration in Committee of the Whole on Bill No. 18 and that THIRD READINGS the bill be now read the third time. Is leave granted? Bill No. 24 — The Vehicles for Hire Amendment Act, 2020 Some Hon. Members: — Agreed. Hon. Mr. Morgan: — I move the bill be now read the third time The Speaker: — The minister may proceed to move to third and passed under its title. reading. The Speaker: — It has been moved by the minister that Bill No. THIRD READINGS 24 be now read the third time and passed under its title. Is the Assembly ready for the question? Bill No. 18 — The All Terrain Vehicles Amendment Act, 2020 Some Hon. Members: — Question.

Hon. Mr. Morgan: — I move the bill be now read the third time The Speaker: — Is it the pleasure of the Assembly to adopt the and passed under its title. motion?

The Speaker: — It has been moved by the minister that Bill No. Some Hon. Members: — Agreed. 18 be now read the third time and passed under its title. Is the Assembly ready for the question? The Speaker: — Carried.

Some Hon. Members: — Question. Clerk: — Third reading of this bill.

The Speaker: — Is it the pleasure of the Assembly to adopt the The Speaker: — Third reading. motion? May 4, 2021 Saskatchewan Hansard 749

ORDERS OF THE DAY change.

GOVERNMENT ORDERS The truth is the industries that have served us so well are changing and we need to adapt. What is the plan to transition in ADJOURNED DEBATES such a way that protects workers, for example, especially our resource workers? There is zero plan, Mr. Speaker. All there is is SECOND READINGS bravado and denial. I have many, many energy workers in my riding, Mr. Speaker, and they’re worried. No matter how hard Bill No. 34 this government tries to sell them a false bill of goods that is in it for them, these workers know this government is in it for their [The Assembly resumed the adjourned debate on the proposed bosses, whoever is cutting the cheques. When the going gets motion by the Hon. Ms. Harpauer that Bill No. 34 — The Fuel tough, this government will not have their back and they know Tax Amendment Act, 2021 be now read a second time.] this intuitively. Energy workers want a plan and they deserve one — a plan that ensures they can keep paying their mortgage, The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina supporting their families. They’re just as interested in leaving a Elphinstone-Centre. healthy and habitable planet for their kids as anyone else, but they’re concerned, rightfully, because no one is taking them into Ms. Conway: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It is a pleasure to enter consideration. into debate on this bill. I did read with delight the comments of my colleague, the critic for Environment. She certainly covered We need an unprecedented change if we are going to tackle the this bill and its implications with far more detail than I can hope crisis of climate change, Mr. Speaker. And this government’s to. discussion on nuclear reactors is just a pathetic distraction.

But generally, Mr. Speaker, I won’t mince words. This The appetite for leadership is so high on this, Mr. Speaker, and I government is completely failing people in Saskatchewan on the am very disappointed to see bills like this come forward for issue of climate change. It is so blinded by its right wing ideology consideration. This bill is more about sending political signals that it throws up childish roadblocks to even minor action on than doing anything meaningful on the greatest challenge facing, climate change. This tax on EV [electric vehicle] vehicles is just at least my generation, and those to come. the tip of the iceberg. So with that, Mr. Speaker, I will close my comments and I’m The climate crisis is not only the single greatest challenge we are adjourning debate on this bill, Mr. Speaker. facing, it is our single greatest opportunity to build a more equitable future and create good sustainable jobs. This The Speaker: — The member has moved to adjourn debate. Is it government really hasn’t achieved anything in terms of reducing the pleasure of the Assembly to adopt the motion? our emissions. Some Hon. Members: — Agreed. And today we could be investing. We could be doing so much more. We could be investing in climate-resilient infrastructure, The Speaker: — Carried. I recognize the Government House public transit, renewable energy, energy conservation, home and Leader. building retrofits, and of course zero-emission vehicles. Hon. Mr. J. Harrison: — Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Solar, wind, geothermal energy, of which this province is rich, is In order to facilitate the work of committee later this day, I move part of the solution. We can harness these natural gifts. Of course that this House do now adjourn. baseload is always an issue, but there are solutions if we have the will to explore them. For example, Manitoba has hydro power to The Speaker: — The Government House Leader has moved to spare. We need only invest in infrastructure to get us where we adjourn the House. Is it the pleasure of the Assembly to adopt the need to be. It can easily be done, Mr. Speaker. motion?

With the planned gas rebate, the tax on EV vehicles, this Some Hon. Members: — Agreed. government is actively making it more difficult to take meaningful action on this important issue and it’s just so The Speaker: — Carried. The House now stands adjourned till embarrassing. They’re actually leaving federal dollars on the 1:30 tomorrow. table. We cannot keep sticking our heads in the sand on this issue, Mr. Speaker. It’s irresponsible and it’s economically stupid. We [The Assembly adjourned at 14:22.] are going to be left behind. Our single-largest trading partner, the United States, has announced historical investments into transitioning to a new economy. The new economy is coming, Mr. Speaker. We can see some gains or we can keep feeling the pain.

This government was ill-prepared for the pandemic. They don’t know how to think ahead to plan proactively for the future, and we’re seeing that same approach play out on the issue of climate GOVERNMENT OF SASKATCHEWAN CABINET MINISTERS ______

Hon. Scott Moe Premier President of the Executive Council Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs

Hon. Hon. Don McMorris Minister of Highways Minister of Government Relations Minister Responsible for Minister Responsible for First Nations, Saskatchewan Water Security Agency Métis and Northern Affairs Minister Responsible for the Hon. Provincial Capital Commission Minister of Social Services Hon. Minister of Health Hon.

Minister of Education Hon. Minister of Labour Relations and Workplace Safety Hon. Minister of Crown Investments Corporation Minister of Energy and Resources Minister Responsible for SaskEnergy Incorporated Minister Responsible for Hon. Saskatchewan Gaming Corporation Deputy Premier Minister Responsible for Minister of Finance Saskatchewan Government Insurance Minister Responsible for Saskatchewan Power Corporation Hon. Minister Responsible for Minister of Trade and Export Development Saskatchewan Telecommunications Minister of Immigration and Career Training Minister Responsible for Minister Responsible for Innovation Saskatchewan Water Corporation Minister Responsible for Tourism Saskatchewan Minister Responsible for the Saskatchewan Workers’ Compensation Board Hon. Minister of Mental Health and Addictions, Hon. Seniors and Rural and Remote Health Minister of SaskBuilds and Procurement Minister Responsible for the Public Service Commission Minister Responsible for Saskatchewan Liquor Hon. and Gaming Authority Minister of Environment Minister Responsible for The Global Transportation Hub Authority Hon. Minister of Advanced Education Hon. Minister of Parks, Culture and Sport Hon. David Marit Minister Responsible for the Status of Women Minister of Agriculture Minister Responsible for Hon. Saskatchewan Crop Insurance Corporation Minister of Corrections, Policing and Public Safety

Hon. Minister of Justice and Attorney General