GEOGRAZ 68 - 2021 SCHWERPUNKT

ADAM EMMER ON THE AUTHOR

Adam Emmer is physical geographer Mapping and member of the re- search group Cascade with specialization in outburst landforms high mountain geomor- phology and natural hazard science. In his for enhanced understanding research, he focuses on hazardous conse- of their occurrence quences of retrea­

Sudden release of water retained in a glacial lake can produce a glacial lake outburst flood (GLOF), which is among the most effective geomorphic agents in mountain regions during the time of glacier ice loss. Extreme GLOFs imprint in relief with specific landforms (e.g. failed moraine dams, outwash fans) which can be used to document their occurrence in space and time. This contribution introduces typical landforms associated with GLOFs and outlines their utilization ting in reconstructing timing and magnitude for enhanced hazard identification and glaciers, mainly lake outburst . assessment.

1 Introduction: GLOFs in a range of triggers including into areas as well as agricultural land (Haeber- changing world the lake, extreme precipitation and snow- li et al. 2016). Concerns about increasing melt or earthquake (Clague and O’Con- risk of GLOFs are driven by two factors: (i) Glacial lakes are typical features of re- nor 2015). GLOFs are rare, low frequency, increasing population pressure and settle- cently deglaciated high mountain regions high magnitude events with extreme char- ment expansion in mountain regions (espe- across the world (Shugar et al. 2020). acteristics (peak discharge, flood volume), cially in South America and Central Asia); While glacial lakes contribute to human with thousands of fatalities and tremen- and (ii) increasing number of glacial lakes well-being by providing goods and ser- dous material damages claimed globally and volume of stored water. While urbani­ vices (e.g. fishing, hydropower generation, (Carrivick and Tweed 2016). zation and landscape planning can be (at tourism), they can also represent a threat if Hand in hand with retreating glaciers, new least to some extent) managed and so can retained water is released suddenly. Such a glacial lakes form and grow upstream sett­ reflect these potential risks, the occurrence release is called glacial lake outburst flood led piedmont areas, raising the question of GLOFs is largely stochastic. (GLOF) and may occur as a result of lake of GLOF risk to societies and assets such As such, understanding the occurrence dam overtopping or failure due to a wide as hydropower plants and bridges, mining of GLOFs is an everlasting need in effec- tive hazard and risk identification, assess- ment and mitigation. Since the occurrence of potential future GLOFs is complicated to predict in space, time and magnitude, our efforts often rely and build on the analysis of past events and extrapolation of observed trends into the future as well as knowledge transfer in between regions. While GLOF inventories in some of the re- gions are fairly complete and reliable with centuries long records in documentary data sources (e.g. European Alps, Iceland), some others suffer from missing, incom- plete and / or questionable records (Em- mer et al. 2016; Fig. 1). Strikingly, GLOF records were documented to be largely in- complete in the regions where documenta- ry data are not available, such as the Third Fig. 1: Eleven hotspots of GLOF occurrence which account for a total of >1,300 GLOFs globally (modified and Pole region (Hindu Kush, Himalaya) or updated from Emmer, 2018). Note that only documented events are considered in this figure and real numbers are likely higher in regions with incomplete records (see the text). extensive regions of the South American Andes (Peru, Bolivia, Chile). 26 Tab. 1: Gegenüberstellung der unterschiedlichen Paradigmen im Naturschutz (eigene Darstellung, nach Pimbert und Pretty 1995, Phillips 2003, Mose und Weixlbaumer 2006).

SCHWERPUNKT

Fig. 2: Visual appearance of breached moraine ON THE AUTHOR dam and outwash fan of the 1951 GLOF from Lake Artesoncocha (Cordillera Blanca, Peru). (A) shows upstream view through breached moraine dam with outwash fan deposition (OF) located in the forefield; pre-GLOF dam crest is roughly indicated with orange dashed line, arrow indicates breach depth and dotted line indicates typical trapezoidal cross-profile of the breach. Steep moraine slopes exposed during the breach (ES) are also visible. (B) shows almost vertical inner slopes (IS) of breached moraine dam; note no grain sorting and chaotical placement of large boulders forming the dam; material reworked by (L) after the breach is visible; (C) shows aerial view 3 years before the GLOF, i.e. in 1948 (image: archive of the Autoridad Nacional del Agua, Huaraz, Peru; acquisition date: 2nd September 1948); pre-GLOF images from pre- satellite period are quite rare; (D) shows 2020 satellite image of the same area as displayed in (C); note decreased lake size as a result of partial drainage during GLOF (image: Maxar Technologies, Google Earth Digital Globe, acquisition date: 3rd August 2020). Field images taken by the author in 2014. Ground control points (GCPs) from (A) and (B) are displayed on (C) and (D).

2 Employing in interpretation of field and remote sensing is decreased (longitudinal profile gets less GLOF studies images and geomorphological mapping. steep). Some of these landforms are iden- The use of these methods in the context of tical to those produced by “classical” hy- Since landscapes and landforms are pro- understanding GLOF occurrence in space dro-meteorologically-induced floods (e.g. minent archives of palaeo-geographic in- and time for enhanced GLOF hazard undercut river banks, in-stream deposition formation, understanding them and their identification and assessment is outlined. bars, etc.) and debris flow depositions, but dynamics can help us better understand some are only associated with GLOFs. processes and physical conditions during 3 Landforms associated with The most distinct landforms associat- their formation and evolution. Geomor- GLOFs ed with GLOFs are those created during phology – a study of landforms and pro- the outbursts of extraordinary large Late cesses of their formation – is a vital tool in GLOFs were documented to rank ice-dammed lakes, with de- these efforts. For instance, moraines are among the most effective geomorphic cline of extensive ice sheets. Thousands traditionally used to reconstruct and date agents in high mountain regions when cubic kilometers of meltwater were recon- past glacier extents, river terraces help us glaciers are retreating (Cook et al. 2018). structed to be released during individual to understand landscape polygenesis, i.e., GLOFs are characterized by enormous episodes, producing the most powerful interactions between tectonic uplift and erosion and transport potential and sedi­ floods in Earth’s history with reconstruc­ exogenic processes, and the extent of de- ment yield and can also transform into ted peak discharges overcoming 107 m3/s positions of pyroclastic material give us an flow-type movements, for instance hy- in the most extreme cases (O’Connor insight into the past volcanic activity and per-concentrated flow or debris-flow. and Costa 2004). These mega-floods left frequency-magnitude relationships of the- Landforms associated with glacial lake behind continental-scale geomorphic se processes. outburst floods can be classified into two imprints and formed characteristic land- Analogically to these examples, specific basic groups: (i) erosional landforms, and scapes in and Siberia. For landforms can indicate past occurrence of (ii) depositional landforms. Clearly, ero- example, the Late Pleistocene outburst GLOFs, infer about their hydrodynam- sion dominates in the sections of the val- from ice-dammed palaeo- in ic characteristics and magnitudes (Costa ley where the stream power is high (for North America shaped entire landscapes and O’Connor 1995). In this contribution, instance where the longitudinal profile along the Columbia and Snake Rivers in some of the typical landforms associated gets steeper) while deposition generally contemporary Idaho, Washington and with GLOFs are presented, building on the occurs in the sections where stream power Oregon states.

27 GEOGRAZ 68 - 2021 SCHWERPUNKT

Fig. 3: A conspicuous outwash fan associated with repeated lake outburst / debris flow activity on the east-facing slopes of the main massif of the Cordillera Huayhuash, Peru. While the fresh scars and depositions are clearly identifiable, the attribution to the outburst of upstream located Lake Chaclan or rainfall-induced remobilization of moraine material with only marginal role of the lake is ambiguous (see also Bat’ka et al., 2020).

Recent GLOFs (i.e. those which oc- (Fig. 3), maybe up to kilometers long, sev- channel is buried by GLOF depositions curred since the end of the Little Ice Age) eral hundred meters wide, and is mainly and a new channel is formed nearby. Ex- have comparably smaller magnitudes (with composed of the material eroded from the treme, up to several tens of meters deep peak discharges rarely exceeding 104 m3/s) dam (i.e. moraine material previously de- erosion down to the bedrock bottom of the and spatially limited geomorphic imprints. posited by a glacier). While moraine ma- valley floor has been documented during However, they are still capable of produc- terial is generally poorly sorted with clay, major events. GLOFs were also documen­ ing extreme geomorphic disruptions in a silt and sandy fractions to pebbles and ted to move extremely large boulders with local geographical context. Striking evi- randomly located boulders (up to several several meters in diameter (Richardson dence of GLOFs from moraine-dammed meters in diameter; Fig. 2B), outwash fan and Reynolds 2000). While large boulders lakes include failed moraine dams (ero- deposition shows good particle sorting with are mainly transported over short dis- sional landforms) and outwash fans locat- boulders located in steeper parts (closer to tances, fine-grained material is typically ed downstream (depositional landforms). the dam) and pebbles deposited further transported far from the source (e.g. the Incision through the moraine dam may be downstream. However, outwash fans may breached moraine dam) and deposited in up to several tens of meters deep and has not be always associated with GLOFs (e.g. gently-sloped parts of the valley (Fig. 4). triangular or trapezoidal cross-profiles, up rainfall-induced debris-flow originating in to hundred meters wide in the crest part moraine slopes) and their observation and 4 Outlook and conclusions of the dam (Fig. 2). The inner sides of the interpretation should always be done in incised dam are typically very steep (up the context of upstream located lakes. Our understanding to occurrence and to 80°) and often a subject of post-GLOF Sections of the valley downstream the characteristics of GLOFs relies to a large reworking by landslides. Despite this re- GLOF-producing lake can be a subject of extent on mapping and analysis of past working, breached moraine dams can be extreme geomorphic disruptions such as events. For more reliable identification of identified in relief even centuries after the shifted stream channels, extreme depth GLOF-producing lakes, these purely geo­ event. and lateral erosion. Shifted stream chan- morphic features can be combined with The outwash fan is usually located nels are likely to occur in rather wide other indicators (e.g. temporal or perma- directly downstream of the failed dam sections of the valley, where the original nent lake level drawdown), putting to-

28 SCHWERPUNKT

Fig. 4: Grain size gradation in outburst flood depositions exemplified by the deposition of the 2012 GLOF in the Santa Cruz valley, Cordillera Blanca, Peru (for more details about this event see Mergili et al. 2018). (A) shows deposition of boulders with diameter of up to 100 cm in the part of the valley where the mean slope of the valley floor is between 4° and 7°; (B) shows deposition of cobbles and pebbles with diameter up to 15 cm in the part of the valley where the mean slope is between 2° and 4°; (C) shows deposition of sand and gravel with diameter up to 2 cm in the part of the valley where the mean slope is very gentle (up to 2°). Note the notebook with A5 size for the scale.

LITERATUR

Bat’ka, J., Vilímek, V., Štefanová, E., Cook, S.J., Emmer, A., Vilímek, V., Huggel, C., Klimeš, J., Emmer, A. (2020): Glacial Lake Outburst Schaub, Y. (2016): Limits and challenges Floods (GLOFs) in the Cordillera Huay- to compiling and developing a database huash, Peru: Historic Events and Current of glacial lake outburst floods. Landslides, Susceptibility. Water, 12(10), 2664. 13(6), 1579–1584. Carrivick, J.L., Tweed, F.S. (2016): A global Haeberli, W., Buetler, M., Huggel, C., Lehmann assessment of the societal impacts of gla- Friedli, T., Schaub, Y., Schleiss, A.J. (2016): cier outburst floods. Global and Planetary New lakes in deglaciating high-mountain Change, 144, 1–16. regions - opportunities and risks. Climatic Change, 139(2), 201–214. gether a set of GLOF diagnostic features Clague, J.J., O’Connor, J.E. (2015): Glacier- (Emmer 2017). Recent increase in avail- related outburst floods. In: Haeberli, W., Mergili, M., Emmer, A., Juřicová, A., Cochachin, ability, spatial and temporal resolution Whiteman, C. (Eds.): Snow and ice-related A., Fischer, J.-T., Huggel, C., Pudasaini, S.P. of various satellite products (optical and hazards, risks, and disasters. Amsterdam, (2018): How well can we simulate complex The Netherlands: Elsevier, 487–519. hydro-geomorphic process chains? The multispectral images, digital terrain mo­ 2012 multi-lake outburst flood in the Santa Cook, K., Andermann, C., Gimbert, F., Raj dels) enables observation and analysis of Cruz Valley (Cordillera Blanca, Perú). Earth Adhikari, B., Hovius, N. (2018): Glacial lake various geomorphic features in remote ar- Surface Processes and Landforms, 43, outburst floods as drivers of fluvial ero- 1373–1389. eas in unprecedented detail. For instance, sion in the Himalaya. Science, 362(6410), CNES/Airbus images freely available 53–57. O’Connor, J.E., Costa, J.E. (2004): The world’s largest floods, past and present: Their from Google Earth allow to identify, map Costa, J.E., O’Connor, J.E. (1995): Geomor- causes and magnitudes. Reston, VA: U.S. and characterize extents of rapid geomor- phically effective floods. In: Costa, J.E., Geological Survey, 13pp. phic processes, including GLOFs. While et al. (Eds.): Natural and Anthropogenic certain progress towards (semi-)automated Influences in Fluvial Geomorphology. U.S. Richardson S.D., Reynolds, J.M. (2000): An Geological Survey, 45–56. overview of glacial hazards in the Himala- identification and mapping of GLOF diag- yas. Quaternary International, 65/66, 31–47. nostic features from remotely sensed ima­ Emmer, A. (2017): Geomorphologically effec- Shugar, D., Burr, A., Haritashya, U.K., Kargel, ges has been achieved recently (Veh et al. tive floods from moraine-dammed lakes in the Cordillera Blanca, Peru. Quaternary J.S., Watson, C.S., Kennedy, M.C., Beving- 2018), visual interpretation combined with Science Reviews, 177, 220–234. ton, A.R., Betts, R.A., Harrison, S., Stratt- man, K. (2020): Rapid worldwide growth geomorphological mapping and field vali- Emmer, A. (2018): GLOFs in the WOS: biblio- of glacial lakes since 1990. Nature Climate dation still remain irreplaceable methods metrics, geographies and global trends of Change, 10, 939–945. considering the wide range of processes research on glacial lake outburst floods involved in GLOF process chains and the (Web of Science, 1979–2016). Natural Veh, G., Korup, O., Roessner, S., Walz, A. variety of associated landforms. Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 18, (2018): Detecting Himalayan glacial lake 813–827. outburst floods from Landsat time series. Remote Sensing of Environment, 207, 84–97.

29