DOCSLIB.ORG

ETD Template

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
ETD Template View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by D-Scholarship@Pitt The Rhetoric of AIDS Policy in South Africa by Marcus Paroske B.A. in Political Science and Philosophy, Regis University 1997 M.A. in Speech Communication, Colorado State University 1999 M.A. in Philosophy, University of Pittsburgh 2005 Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of Arts and Sciences in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Pittsburgh 2006 UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH FACULTY OF ARTS AND SCIENCES This dissertation was presented by Marcus Paroske It was defended on December 9, 2005 and approved by Lester Olson, PhD, Professor Gordon Mitchell, PhD, Associate Professor Lisa S. Parker, PhD, Associate Professor Dissertation Director: John Lyne, PhD, Professor ii Copyright by Marcus Paroske 2006 iii The Rhetoric of AIDS Policy in South Africa Marcus Paroske, PhD University of Pittsburgh, 2005 This dissertation examines the rhetorical dynamics of South African AIDS policy under President Thabo Mbeki. From 1999-2004, Mbeki bucked global consensus surrounding the etiology and treatment of AIDS and prohibited government distribution of anti-retroviral drug treatments. In defense of these policies, the President offered scientific arguments founded on the theories of Western “AIDS dissenters.” He also made the case that South Africa’s unique experiences under apartheid demanded a strong tolerance of dissent and debate. The international condemnation of these views was striking. Over the course of the controversy, rhetoric played a central role in shaping the views of both sides. Advocates marshaled public arguments in response to the exigencies of the controversy. Contextual constraints also forced the rhetors to adapt their messages. Each chapter of this dissertation examines a different rhetorical element of the controversy. They include the cultural context of South Africa’s transition to democracy, the development of AIDS dissent in the Mbeki administration, the early development of AIDS dissent in the West, the technical clash of scientific arguments in Mbeki’s Presidential AIDS Advisory Panel, and indigenous social movement resistance to the government’s policies. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS PREFACE …………………………………….…………………………………….viii 1.0 CHAPTER ONE …………………………………………………………..……..1 1.1 JUSTIFICATION FOR THE STUDY …………………….……..………3 1.2 HISTORY OF THE CONTROVERSY …………………………...……..7 1.3 REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE ……………………………….……..9 1.4 DISSERTATION PREVIEW ……………………..……………………11 1.5 CRITICAL PERSPECTIVE …………………….….…………...….…..13 1.5.1 Post-Colonialism ……………………….….…………...……..13 1.5.2 Afrocentrism ……………………………….……..…….…….15 1.5.3 Rhetoric of Science ……………………….………...…….…..17 1.6 THEORIZING THE CONTEXT …………………...……………….….19 1.6.1 Post-Apartheid South Africa ………………..……….….…….19 1.6.2 The Impact of an Epidemic ………………….…………..……22 1.6.3 Mbeki’s Background ………………………….………..……..25 2.0 CHAPTER TWO …………………………………………….………….……...33 2.1 THE QUICK FIX OF VIRODENE …………………………….………36 2.2 MBEKI AS DEFENDER OF AIDS DRUGS ………………….……….39 2.3 THE TRIPS CONTROVERSY ……………………………….….……..42 2.4 AIDS DISSENT COMES TO SOUTH AFRICA …………….………...46 v 2.5 MBEKI THE DISSIDENT ………………………………...…………….51 2.6 THE LETTER ……………………………………………...…………….53 2.7 THE LETTER’S RECEPTION ………………….………..……………..60 2.8 ANALYSIS OF THE LETTER ………………….....……..……………..62 2.9 THE REJOINDERS ……………………...……..….…….………………68 2.10 THE DURBAN CONFERENCE ………...…..…………….…………..73 3.0 CHAPTER THREE ………………………………..………………….…………77 3.1 THE SCIENCE OF AIDS DISSENT ………..…………….…………….79 3.1.1 The Advocates ………………………..………….…………….79 3.1.2 Virology ……………………………..…………….…………...81 3.1.3 Anti-Retroviral Drugs ……………......…………….…………..83 3.1.4 Epidemiology ………………………..…………..……………..84 3.1.5 HIV Testing …………………………..…………..…………….86 3.2 AIDS DISSENT GOES PUBLIC ………………...……….……………..88 3.3 THE DUESBERG PHENOMENON ………….…..……..………………90 3.4 CHRISTINE MAGGIORE …………………….…..………..……………94 3.5 THE CULTURE OF AN EPIDEMIC …………….……………………..100 3.6 THE SCIENCE POLICY FORUM DEBATE …….…………………….106 4.0 CHAPTER FOUR ………………………………………….……………………116 4.1 THE PRESIDENTIAL AIDS ADVISORY PANEL .………...…………117 4.2 THE RHETORIC OF SCIENCE POLICY ………….…………………..125 4.3 THE SCIENCE OF THE REPORT ……………………………………..129 4.3.1 Etiology …………………………………….………………….129 vi 4.3.2 Epidemiology ………………………………………………….135 4.3.3 Policy Prescriptions …………………………………………...140 4.4 RHETORIC IN THE PANEL’S DELIBERATIONS …………………..143 4.4.1 Ethics of Uncertainty ………………………………………….143 4.4.2 Political Standards of Proof …………………………………..146 4.5 CONCLUSION OF THE REPORT ………………….…………………153 5.0 CHAPTER FIVE ………………………………………………….…………….156 5.1 STUDYING SOCIAL MOVEMENTS …………………………………157 5.2 THE TREATMENT ACTION CAMPAIGN …………………………..159 5.3 MORALITY AND ACCESS TO AIDS DRUGS ……………………....161 5.4 DEMOCRATIZATION AND THE POLITICAL PROCESS ……….....166 5.5 RISK ……………………………………………………………………..171 5.6 THE TAC TAKES MBEKI TO COURT ……………………………….173 5.7 MBEKI RECANTS ……………………………………………………...180 5.8 POSTSCRIPT: NEVIRAPINE AND THE NIH ………………………...185 6.0 CHAPTER SIX ……………………………………………………………….....191 6.1 DISSERTATION REVIEW ……………………………………………..191 6.2 ASSESSING THE RHETORIC OF BOTH SIDES ……………………..196 6.3 THE DISSERTATION WITHIN THE RHETORIC OF SCIENCE …....199 6.4 INTERCULTURAL RHETORIC OF SCIENCE ………………………..203 6.5 CALL FOR FURTHER CASE STUDIES ……………………………….205 APPENDIX. THABO MBEKI’S LETTER TO WORLD LEADERS ………………210 BIBLIOGRAPHY ……………………………………………………………………214 vii PREFACE I would like to recognize the many individuals who have helped this project come to fruition. The arguments developed here were forged in numerous conversations with colleagues and mentors throughout my education. Rather than risk omissions, I will thank collectively the students from the 11th floor of the Cathedral of Learning for years of comments. In particular, though, I am indebted to Omri Ceren and Eli Brennan for their long hours of dialogue about my work. Lisa Keranen has been both mentor and cherished friend. Ron von Burg and Alessandra Beasley have been not just my most frequent sounding boards over the years, but my best friends as well. Faculty at the University of Pittsburgh have also been instrumental in this work and my education overall. Jonathan Sterne and Henry Krips have helped hone my craft through several seminars. Gordon Mitchell has provided scholarly opportunities and encouragement that were instrumental in my development. Lisa Parker has selflessly gone beyond the call of duty as outside member, especially in the preparation of this document. John Lyne has been an intellectual example throughout my entire academic career. His stewardship as advisor of this project has helped tremendously. One typically saves the most important acknowledgement for last. No exception here. Michelle Silva has added more to my life than anyone or anything else. Everything I will ever accomplish is dedicated to her. viii 1.0 CHAPTER ONE One of the most powerful stories of freedom in history unfolded during the waning years of the twentieth century. South Africa, long the symbol of colonial oppression, had shed the manacles of apartheid after decades of struggle. From the inevitability of repression under minority rule, the county began its transition into an uncertain new life. While the moral legitimacy of the new regime was assured by the presence of Nelson Mandela at its helm, the policy challenges that would face the fledgling democracy were daunting. As it so happened, a plague lay dormant, known only to a prescient few. The Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome (AIDS) would strike South Africa, most cruelly, right after the moment of its greatest triumph. And AIDS itself was also an enigma. The science of the disease, retrovirology, was new and uncertain. Important scientific factors such as the disease’s etiology, methods of transmission and treatment were speculative. A debate in the Western world about AIDS that had been quietly, occasionally raucously, taking place challenged the entire received view of the disease. Nevertheless, the Western world had come to the conclusion that the science of AIDS was certain enough to justify aggressive health policies to fight the disease. But a handful of dissenters remained, and their texts proliferated on the Internet. Even with all of the disagreement about AIDS, at least one thing was incontrovertible. Something was killing hundreds of thousands of Africans, South Africans most especially, and all signs pointed toward pandemic death tolls in the coming decades on the continent. 1 In 1999, one further enigmatic element was added to the puzzle. Replacing South Africa’s beloved Mandela as President was Thabo Mbeki. His credentials as a freedom fighter were uncontested, but his skills as a policy maker were not generally known. Questions about his leadership style quickly transformed into derision when, several months after his inauguration, President Mbeki shocked the world by embracing the seemingly discredited AIDS dissenters and refusing to distribute anti-retroviral (ARV) drugs to his people. Transitioning from apartheid to multi-racial democracy, invaded by a deadly disease that little was know about, and ruled by a man who by all accounts was intelligent and capable and yet held a view on AIDS that seemed preposterous to most, South Africa and its health policy faced an uncertain future. And from uncertainty rhetoric is born. The several years following Mbeki’s controversial articulation of AIDS dissent saw a number of important instances of scientific
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The House That AIDS Built
    The House That AIDS Built Liam Scheff This article deals with pharmaceutical abuse in a children’s home in NYC. This is a most controversial story – however, it’s entirely based in fact and good reporting. I hope you’ll find it as compelling and shocking as I did investigating it. This piece was investigated and written in summer / winter 2003 and published in January 2004. Liam Scheff. E-mail : [email protected] Introduction: In New York’s Washington Heights is a 4-story brick building called Incarnation Children’s Center (ICC). This former convent houses a revolving stable of children who’ve been removed from their own homes by the Agency for Child Services. These children are black, Hispanic and poor. Many of their mothers had a history of drug abuse and have died. Once taken into ICC, the children become subjects of drug trials sponsored by NIAID (National Institute of Allergies and Infectious Disease, a division of the NIH), NICHD (the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development) in conjunction with some of the world’s largest pharmaceutical companies – GlaxoSmithKline, Pfizer, Genentech, Chiron/Biocine and others. The drugs being given to the children are toxic – they’re known to cause genetic mutation, organ failure, bone marrow death, bodily deformations, brain damage and fatal skin disorders. If the children refuse the drugs, they’re held down and have them force fed. If the children continue to resist, they’re taken to Columbia Presbyterian hospital where a surgeon puts a plastic tube through their abdominal wall into their stomachs.
    [Show full text]
  • 'I'm a Healthy Person. Our Children Have Excellent Records of Health …'
    AIDS Defiant: IH V-positive Christine Maggiore appeared on the cover of Mothering magazine in 2001, pregnant with daughter Eliza Jane. By 2005, THE DENIALIST Eliza Jane had died of pneumonia resulting from untreated Aids. ‘I’m a healthy person. Our children have excellent records of health …’ Despite the death of her child and being HIV-positive, Christine Maggiore refused to believe she had Aids. by Diana Wichtel he image is confronting, as keep googling her and her organisation, when children with far less – impatient late like a motorway pile-up. Maggiore’s edifice. Maggiore survived for a long time been published in Harpers magazine. In it’s meant to be and, now, Alive and Well, to see what she was up to. distracted parents, a small apartment on book was called What If Everything You without drugs. “Mathilde Krim would this country, Joel Hayward’s thesis claim- unbelievably sad. A vibrant One such search revealed that, in 2005, a busy street, extended day care, Oscar Thought You Knew About Aids Turned out to describe me as a slow progressor,” said ing the Nazi gas chambers were “atrocity woman sits smiling into weeks after that radio show, Eliza Jane Mayer Lunchables – will happily stay?” be Wrong? There was a certain amount of Maggiore, of a doctor interviewed on propaganda” was awarded first class hon- the camera, flanked by her was dead. After being ill for a couple of The site was soon taken down. schadenfreude on websites where denial- 20/20, “as if to make ‘progress’ I need ours. Climate change deniers are regularly Thusband and small son.
    [Show full text]
  • Leon Chaitow Protease Inhibitors the Drug-AIDS Hypothesis Leon
    CONTINUUM LeonLeon ChaitowChaitow ––holisticholistic healinghealing && AIDSAIDS ProteaseProtease InhibitorsInhibitors ––thethe hypehype fadesfades TheThe Drug-AIDSDrug-AIDS HypothesisHypothesis —what’s—what’s thethe link?link? changing the way we think about aids vol 4 no 5 february/march 1997 UK £3 USA $5 CONTINUUM a magazine by the living for the living vol 4, no 5 why CONTINUUM? focus february/march 1997 Protease Inhibitors The orthodox view on AIDS holds that it is caused by a virus known as HIV that is PIs in Provincetown 8 JOHN LAURITSEN wonders how hope can transmitted through the exchange of body exact such a price fluids. Once infected, a person will remain well for a time, though infectious to others, From Hype to Hesitation 11 before going on to develop AIDS and dying. Recent research has led to serious caution Despite the huge sums of money spent on reports HUW CHRISTIE medical research, there is still no cure, just drug therapies said to slow the progress of the disease, and regular T-cell counts to measure health. features A whole industry has evolved around New Wave in France 13 AIDS, on which many careers and A recent health conference opened doors to businesses depend, but which offers little freedom of treatment hope to those affected. It works on the premise that HIV=AIDS=DEATH. Interview 14 CONTINUUM began as a newsletter Holistic doctor LEON CHAITOW says AIDS is a encouraging those effected to empower complex scenario which natural healing themselves to make care and treatment methods can address choices. As we look further, anomalies in the orthodox view continue to appear.
    [Show full text]
  • HIV Twenty-Eight Years Later: What Is the Truth? Gary Null, Phd December 3, 2012
    HIV Twenty-Eight Years Later: What is the Truth? Gary Null, PhD December 3, 2012 In the May 4, 1984 issue of the prestigious journal Science, one of the most important research papers of the last quarter century was published. “Frequent Detection and Isolation of Cytopathic Retroviruses (HTLV-III) from Patients with AIDS and at Risk for AIDS” would rapidly become the medical Magna Carta for the entire gold rush to develop diagnostic methods to identify the presence of HIV in human blood and to invent pharmaceutical drugs and vaccines in a global war against AIDS. This paper, along with three others published in the same issue of Science, was written by Dr. Robert Gallo, then head of the Laboratory of Tumor Cell Biology (LTCB) at the National Cancer Institute (NCI) in Bethesda, Maryland, and his lead researcher Dr. Mikulas Popovic. To this day, this article continues to document the most cited research to prove the HIV hypothesis in scientific papers and places like the nation’s Centers of Disease Control (CDC) website. For virologists, molecular biologists and other infectious disease researchers, particularly those tied to the biotechnology and pharmaceutical industries and the national medical and health institutions, the news of Gallo’s discovery was manna rained down from heaven. All research into other possible causes for the AIDS crisis ended abruptly. As soon as the winds shifted away from earlier efforts to find the cause of AIDS —people’s lifestyles, immune suppressing illicit drug use and other health risks and illnesses that adversely affect the body’s immune system — to that of a single new virus, the case was closed.
    [Show full text]
  • The AIDS Conspiracy: Science Fights Back by Nicoli Nattrass
    Journal of Scientifi c Exploration, Vol. 26, No. 4, pp. 885–891, 2012 0892-3310/12 BOOK REVIEW The AIDS Conspiracy: Science Fights Back by Nicoli Nattrass. Columbia University Press, 2012. 225 pp. $14.99 (Kindle). $34.50 (hardcover). ISBN 978-0231149129. The offi cial position, the mainstream consensus, is that HIV causes AIDS and that anti-HIV drugs are benefi cial. Both are denied by many people: Some of them are eminently qualifi ed to critique the technicalities, others are persuaded by personal experience or that of friends of being “HIV- positive” but healthy, and others again have analyzed the cases presented pro and con by the believers and the disbelievers. To my knowledge, there exists no disinterested analysis of the opposing cases, and books and book reviews tend to be highly polarized. For the present book, fulsome praise has come from those who share Nattrass’s belief that HIV causes AIDS; the opposite comes from those who disagree with her. This reviewer disagrees with Nattrass (Bauer 2007a, 2009a), and the reader is thereby warned to be on the alert for bias in this review even as its author strives to focus on verifi able points. The book’s title refl ects accurately that the discussion concerns tactics, strategies, and psychological and sociological and political aspects of the to-and-fro between believers and disbelievers. Regarded as insightful, consequently, are such passages as Notably, Paula Treichler locates AIDS conspiracy beliefs within what she terms a broader “epidemic of signifi cation” or parallel cultural process in which people generate, reproduce, and perform meanings in an attempt “to understand—however imperfectly—the complex, puzzling and quite terrifying phenomenon of AIDS.” (p.
    [Show full text]
  • The Social and Symbolic Power of AIDS Denialism
    July August pages_SI new design masters 5/31/12 12:22 PM Page 34 The Social and Symbolic Power of AIDS Denialism AIDS denialism has proved socially resilient because dissident “hero scientists” provide legitimacy, “cultropreneurs” offer fake cures in the place of antiretroviral treatment, and HIV-positive “living icons” seem to provide proof of concept. NICOLI NATTRASS he discovery of antiretroviral therapy (ART) trans- a recent “documentary” funded in part by Rethinking AIDS. formed HIV infection from a death sentence into a Duesberg does more than merely 1 Tmanageable chronic disease. Yet a small group of question or rethink HIV science: he ac- “AIDS denialists” rejects the science underlying ART, be- tively publicizes his unfounded claims. Mark Wainberg, a microbiologist and lieving it rests on rotten foundations and that the therapy is past president of the Inter national toxic. These ideas have had deadly consequences. Most in- AIDS Society, called him “probably the famously, South African president Mbeki set up a panel of closest thing we have in this world to a scientific psychopath.”6 Duesberg’s sup- AIDS denialists and HIV scientists to debate the issue while porters, however, interpret such criti- delaying the use of ART in the public sector. Over 330,000 cism as evidence of his unfair oppres- South Africans died unnecessarily as a result.2 sion by a corrupt “AIDS establishment.” Accord ing to Celia Far ber, Duesberg’s In an earlier article3 for the SKEPTICAL powerful community-building effects. leading praise-singer, “As AIDS
    [Show full text]
  • Lost AIDS: Luc Montagnier's
    Friday, June 18, 2010 Home Get Audio/Vide The Board Contact Us Q&A Languages Donate to RA About Involved! o Part I · Part II · Part III · Part IV NoName TV interviews RA board member Dr. Etienne de Harven and Jean-Claude Roussez, authors of "Ten Lies about AIDS" An Interview with Tommy Morrison Former World Boxing Organization Champion February 10, 2010 — On top of the world in 1996, heavyweight boxing champion, star of Rocky V with Sylvester Stallone, winner of almost every fight, his life was turned upside down when he tested positive for HIV antibodies just before a fight. In 2006 he re-tested negative and has tested negative many times since. In an interview with Celia Farber, RA president David Crowe and Terry Michael, Morrison states: "HIV doesn't hurt anybody...It's a passenger virus, it doesn't do anything...I thought the medication was what was killing people." Listen to the entire interview at HowPositiveAreYou.com: Recently, another renowned athlete, Olympic Gold Medalist Lee Evans, spoke of AIDS and Africa, expressing his doubts about widely accepted beliefs: "I have been all over Africa for almost 30 years and when I first heard there was a new sexually transmitted disease epidemic I was alarmed...All I ever saw was more and more of the same diseases we saw in 1975...but nobody except the media and the people living off AIDS money ever called that AIDS." Djamel Tahi January, 2010 Speak out, Monsieur le Professeur Montagnier! A few days ago, a video clip was posted on the Internet, which produced the kind of buzz that is shaking the world of AIDS research.
    [Show full text]
  • The SPECTRUM Magazine, June 2001
    TheThe SPECTRUMSPECTRUM “Achieve the wisdom of knowledge of Truth as this will enable you to wisely follow the Laws of The Creation.” A Non-Profit Educational Corporation Dedicated To Bringing You The Truth VOLUME 3, NUMBER 1 NEWS REVIEW $ 4.50 JUNE 12, 2001 Merging Science With Spirit The Isaiah Effect Lost Wisdom Of Forgotten Peoples 6/1/01 RICK MARTIN IN THIS ISSUE: “Gregg Braden is a rare blend of scientist, visionary, and scholar with the ability to speak to our minds, while touching the wisdom of our Happy Second Anniversary! p.2 hearts.” — Deepak Chopra, M.D. The News Desk, p.3 It is always fascinating to watch as stories come together despite seemingly impossible odds, “coincidences”, and crazy schedules. This is Conspiracy-Con Show Update, p.9 one such powerful story. It reminds us WE are very much in the driver’s SOLTEC: Learning To Allow seat of our lives. But that process happens so fluently, with every For Your Growth, p.16 seemingly small choice we make each moment, that we don’t generally recognize this exquisite process in action. Or that it has been known from Clearance Sale On High-Tech Weapons: very ancient times. That’s where Gregg Braden enters the picture. Inside The Weekly Arms Bazaar At Gregg Braden is an author of several most unusual books, a traveler Redstone Arsenal, p.35 and tour guide to some of the most interesting ancient places on this planet, and a world-class lecturer who speaks as much to our inner heart Revisiting The Diabolical knowing as to the questions of our scientific intellect.
    [Show full text]
  • Death by Denial: the Campaigners Who Continue to Deny HIV Causes
    Death by denial: The campaigners who continue to deny HIV causes Aids As each of their followers dies, those who campaign against HIV treatments simply move on to the next level of denial Karri Stokely is a poster girl for a different way to look at health. After receiving an Aids diagnosis in 1996, at the age of 29, she was treated for 11 years with a cocktail of drugs. But then she saw an internet video saying that HIV was a hoax, stopped taking her medicines – and felt terrific. "I'm not getting any answers from the mainstream as to why I'm healthy, and why my husband is negative, and why I can quit these drugs," she explains in her own video, which is currently being promoted online. "I think it's a crime. It's crimes against humanity." Peter Duesberg in 1995. He still promotes the discredited hypothesis that HIV 'is not sufficient to cause Aids'. Photograph: Susan Ragan/Associated Press Her doctor was aghast – HIV treatment is for life. "He looked me right in the eyes and said: 'You have done a very stupid thing, and you will be dead very soon,'" Stokely recalls. "My response to him was: 'That's funny, because right now I'm feeling pretty good.'" That was in April 2007. She died four years later, so her comments are a postcard from the past. "Karri Stokely passed away on April 27th 2011," explains a website run by London journalist Joan Shenton. "She said she wouldn't go quietly so we are keeping her moving interview below on our homepage." But Stokely's path (via pneumonia) was already well trodden.
    [Show full text]
  • AIDS Post-HIV : Beat of a Different Drummer
    cover 6/1 9/10/00 3:30 pm Page 1 O C conscious health for radical times AIDS post-HIV : beat of a different drummer The South African Panel of Inquiry Conference in Uganda CONTINUUM Nutrition and immunity Isolation and rejection - the scientific struggles Vol. 6 No. 1/2 autumn 2000 Vol. UUM CONT IN UU M towards a healthier body politic v o l 6, no 1/2 October 2000 C o n s u l t a n t s Michael Baumgartner ,I.F.A.S., Contents Switzerland Lluis Botinas , Co-ordinator COBRA, 2. First International Holistic AIDS Conference - Uganda. Spain Co-organiser Rosalind Harrison reports Leon Chaitow , ND, DO, MRO, England Kevin Corbett, BA(Hons), HDFA, 6. Life cycle - no handicap! An interview with a test-positive MSc, RGN, England man with attitude! Prof. Peter Duesberg , Molecular Biologist, USA Nigel Edwards , MA (Oxon), 8. HIV diagnosis and the potential of a holistic healing process Journalist/Broadcaster, England - research study on the therapeutic effect of Tai Chi, by Carolyn Michael Ellner , DD, MSH, CHt, Howell President HEAL, USA Felix de Fries, Public Relations Consultant, Switzerland 13. President Thabo Mbeki’s letter to President Clinton and Volker Gildemeister , MA, DPhil Prime Minister Blair (Oxon), Biochemist, England Dmitri Gouskov, PhD, Sociologist, Ukraine 15. Folly or Grace - Joan Shenton’s report on the first South Prof. Alfred Hässig , Immunologist, African AIDS Panel meeting Switzerland Neville Hodgkinson , Author/Journalist, England 22. The Second Meeting - Huw Christie’s report on the followup Christine Johnson , Science meeting in Johannesburg Information Co-ordinator, USA Dr med.
    [Show full text]
  • AIDS – the End of Dogma and Taboo!
    AIDS – The End of Dogma and Taboo! What we realize ...and what is hidden. Nothing is harder and needs more character, As to be in open dissent with your time and to say: No! (Kurt Tucholsky, German writer, 1890-1935) Content: Why I want to write this book ………………………………………………….…3 Violation of Human Rights: The Unbelievable Story of the Seebald Family in Austria…………………….…… 5 Introduction…………………………………………………………………….….. 11 1. Progress and Errors in Science and Medicine…………………………………..13 2. The Conflict of Gallo and Montagnier………………………………………….33 1 3. HIV-Tests: Cui bono? (Whose profit?)………………………………………….38 4. What is AIDS? Does a Virus exist?......................................................................44 5. Retrovirus, Research, Revision…………………………………………………..49 6. The Human Genome Project and HIV…………………………………………..53 7. Gene Expression instead of HIV: Epigenetics and RNA……………………….60 8. Pregnancy, Nursing and Positive Testing……………………………………….63 9. The Immune System and AIDS………………………………………….……...71 10. Stress and Disease……………………………………………………………….75 11. Medication and Vaccination…………………………………………………….81 12. AIDS – Latest Findings, that should not be kept secret…………………………86 13. AIDS-“Dissidents”................................................................................................90 14. Epigenetics: About Environmental Influence on the Genome ………………….95 15. Media and the Freedom of Expression……………………………..…………....99 16. Forces that Suppress the Truth …………………………………………………124 17. Consciousness, Freedom and Responsibility……………………………………138 18.
    [Show full text]
  • “Of the Virus Party”: Ecofeminist Perspectives on Dissent in AIDS Science
    Nebula 1.1, June 2004 “Of the Virus Party”: Ecofeminist Perspectives on Dissent in AIDS Science. By Serena Anderlini-D’Onofrio Abstract My analysis of the controversies in AIDS science demonstrates that due to the influence of the allopathic scientific collective, the course of mainstream research about the disease has been overdetermined. 1 During the disease’s early outbreaks, allopathic medicine dominated medical discourse. As a result, AIDS science focused on infectious rather than environmental and ecological causes. Later, this focus caused controversies voiced by dissenters from a more holistic perspective. I argue that persisting uncertainties in the etiology of AIDS challenge conventional understandings of this disease. In an ecofeminist perspective, these challenges can be seen as signs of an important shift in the philosophy of health. Thomas Kuhn would describe this shift as harbinger of a “scientific revolution,” resulting from a new “scientific paradigm” struggling to get center stage. 2 If, as ecofeminists claim, the Earth is an animated being and not a Cartesian res extensa , humans are particles of the larger superorganism environmentalists often call Gaia. In this perspective, AIDS is an illness of the biosphere that affects its human particles. This planetary illness denotes toxicity in Gaia’s body, including its air, soil, and waters. If so, AIDS reads as an environmental disease, not an infectious one. This hypothesis is based on a holistic philosophy of health, which is the major current challenge to allopathic philosophy. In his article, I argue that AIDS can be situated at the interstice between cause and effect in the paradigm change, where the collision of two modes of thinking produces new perspectives.
    [Show full text]