Interpreting Phoenician Iron Production at Tel Akko
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Pennsylvania State University The Graduate School College of the Liberal Arts RE-FORGING THE PAST: INTERPRETING PHOENICIAN IRON PRODUCTION AT TEL AKKO, ISRAEL A Thesis in Anthropology by Mark T. Van Horn Submitted in Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts August 2017 The thesis of Mark Van Horn was reviewed and approved* by the following: Ann E. Killebrew Associate Professor of Classics and Ancient Mediterranean Studies Thesis Co-Adviser Kenneth Hirth Professor of Anthropology Thesis Co-Adviser Mark Munn Department Head and Professor of Classics and Ancient Mediterranean Studies *Signatures are on file in the Graduate School. ii Abstract Tel Akko, located in northern Israel, has recently seen the discovery of large quantities of iron slag and metal working remains during excavations conducted from 2010 – 2016 by Drs. A. E. Killebrew and M. Artzy. Using geospatial analysis through geographic information systems (GIS), this thesis aims to present the findings of metal remains from the Killebrew-Artzy excavations. Material will be discussed by type -- e.g. slag, fused earth, iron lumps, etc., -- and then by spatial location across the site and diachronically. The GIS distributions for recovered metallurgical materials and the examination of the context of these finds will provide evidence for the location of a Persian period iron smithy at Tel Akko and the continuation of metalworking at Akko into the Hellenistic period. The relationship between the iron production at Tel Akko and the local economy and methods of production will be examined, and I will attempt to demonstrate that Persian period Akko represents a craft production context which is constituted by independent producers who have been consigned to nucleated centers of production for short term crafting of products, likely by order of the local temple or ruling administration, for the production of gifts as a form of tribute. iii Table of Contents List of Tables ...................................................................................................................... vi List of Figures .................................................................................................................... vii Acknowledgements .......................................................................................................... viii 1. Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 1 Tel Akko – General Overview ............................................................................................. 7 Killebrew – Artzy (2010 – 2016) Excavations: Total Archaeology at Tel Akko .............. 17 2. The Technology of Ancient Iron Working ........................................................................ 29 3. Methodology of Analyzing Metallurgical Remains at Tel Akko, Israel ........................... 37 Slag .................................................................................................................................... 37 Hammerscales .................................................................................................................... 39 Iron Lumps ........................................................................................................................ 40 Vitrified Earth .................................................................................................................... 41 Tuyѐres .............................................................................................................................. 43 Tabuns ............................................................................................................................... 46 4. Tel Akko 2010 – 2016: Distribution of Metallurgical Material ........................................ 51 th th Stratum A6: Iron IIC (late 8 – 7 centuries BCE) ........................................................... 51 Stratum A5: Babylonian / Early Persian (6th century BCE) ............................................. 57 Stratum A4: Persian (c. 500 – 332 BCE) ........................................................................... 61 th nd Stratum A3: Early Hellenistic (Late 4 – Mid 2 century BCE) ...................................... 77 Summary ............................................................................................................................ 84 5. Comparative Evidence for Ironworking in the Southern Levant ....................................... 87 Tel Beth-Shemesh (Veldhuijzen and Rehren 2007) .......................................................... 87 Tell Hammeh (Veldhuijzen and Rehren 2007) .................................................................. 88 Tel es-Safi/Gath (Eliyahu-Behar et al. 2012) .................................................................... 89 Tel Rehov (Eliyahu-Behar et al. 2013) .............................................................................. 90 Tel Megiddo (Yahalom-Mack et al. 2017) ........................................................................ 91 Hazor (Eliyahu-Behar et al 2013; Yahalom-Mack et al. 2014) ......................................... 92 Tel Beer-sheba (Eliyahu-Behar et al. 2013) ...................................................................... 92 Tel Dor (Eliyahu-Behar et al. 2008) .................................................................................. 93 Summary ............................................................................................................................ 94 iv 6. Aspects of Ancient Craft Production ................................................................................. 97 th rd 7. Ironworking at Ancient Akko: The 7 – 3 centuries BCE ............................................ 109 8. Bibliography .................................................................................................................... 2 9. Appendix .............................................................................................................................. 9 Iron Slag .............................................................................................................................. 9 Vitrified Earth .................................................................................................................... 16 Iron Ore .............................................................................................................................. 17 Tabun Fragments ............................................................................................................... 18 Tuyѐre Fragments .............................................................................................................. 22 Crucible Fragments ............................................................................................................ 23 v List of Tables Table 1: Relative stratigraphy of the Tel Akko TAP and the Dothan excavations ................. 9 Table 2: Tel Akko Excavated Tuyѐre Fragments: 2010 – 2016 ............................................ 44 Table 3: Tel Akko Excavated Tabun Fragments: 2010 - 2016 .............................................. 47 Table 4: Stratum A6 Slag Cakes ............................................................................................ 52 Table 5: Stratum A6 Vitrified Earth ...................................................................................... 54 Table 6: Stratum A6 Tabun Fragments ................................................................................. 57 Table 7: Stratum A5 Slag Cakes ............................................................................................ 58 Table 8: Stratum A5 Vitrified Earth ...................................................................................... 60 Table 9: Stratum A5 Tabuns .................................................................................................. 61 Table 10: Stratum A4 Slag Cakes .......................................................................................... 62 Table 11: Stratum A4 Iron Blade Fragments ......................................................................... 65 Table 12: Stratum A4 Vitrified Earth .................................................................................... 68 Table 13: Stratum A4 Tuyѐres ............................................................................................... 70 Table 14: Stratum A4 Tabun Fragments ............................................................................... 71 Table 15: Stratum A4 Crucible Fragments ............................................................................ 76 Table 16: Stratum A3 Slag Cakes .......................................................................................... 77 Table 17: Stratum A3 Vitrified Earth .................................................................................... 81 Table 18: Stratum A3 Tuyѐres ............................................................................................... 82 Table 19: Stratum A3 Tabun Fragments ............................................................................... 84 Table 20: Density of Metallurgical Debitage ........................................................................ 86 vi List of Figures Figure 1: Satellite imagery of the tell ...................................................................................... 2 Figure 2: Geoarchaeological evolution of Akko harbor .........................................................