Kleonai, the Corinth-Argos Road, And
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
HESPERIA 78 (2OO9) KLEONAI, THE CORINTH- Pages ioj-163 ARGOS ROAD, AND THE "AXIS OF HISTORY" ABSTRACT The ancient roadfrom Corinth to Argos via the Longopotamos passwas one of the most important and longest-used natural routes through the north- eastern Peloponnese. The author proposes to identity the exact route of the road as it passed through Kleonaian territoryby combining the evidence of ancient testimonia, the identification of ancient roadside features, the ac- counts of early travelers,and autopsy.The act of tracing the road serves to emphasizethe prominentposition of the city Kleonaion this interstateroute, which had significant consequences both for its own history and for that of neighboring states. INTRODUCTION Much of the historyof the polis of Kleonaiwas shapedby its location on a numberof majorroutes from the Isthmus and Corinth into the Peloponnese.1The most importantof thesewas a majorartery for north- south travel;from the city of Kleonai,the immediatedestinations of this roadwere Corinthto the north and Argos to the south.It is in connec- tion with its roadsthat Kleonaiis most often mentionedin the ancient sources,and likewise,modern topographical studies of the areahave fo- cusedon definingthe coursesof these routes,particularly that of the main 1. The initial fieldworkfor this Culturefor grantingit. In particular, anonymousreaders and the editors studywas primarilyconducted as I thank prior ephors Elisavet Spathari of Hesperia,were of invaluableassis- part of a one-person surveyof visible and AlexanderMantis for their in- tance. I owe particulargratitude to remainsin Kleonaianterritory under terest in the projectat Kleonai,and Bruce Stiver and John Luchin for their the auspicesof the American School the guardsand residentsof Archaia assistancewith the illustrations. of ClassicalStudies at Athens. I would Nemea and Kondostavlofor their ac- All of the photographsand trans- like to thankthen-director James Muhly tive help. I would also like to thank lations of ancient texts are mine unless for supportingthe project,Maria Pilali Ronald Stroud,Stephen G. Miller, otherwise indicated.Spelling and punc- for her crucialrole in obtaining the IouliaTzonou-Herbst, andJames tuation in quotationsfrom earlytrav- necessarypermit, and the Fourth Herbst for readingearlier drafts of elers'reports have been modified to Ephoreiaof Classicaland Prehistoric this article.Their comments and conform to modern English. Antiquities and the Greek Ministry of suggestions,as well as those of the © The American School of Classical Studies at Athens IO8 JEANNETTE C. MARCHAND Corinth-Argos road.2 Nevertheless, controversy over the basic route of the road remains, important portions of the road have yet to see extensive investigation, and the relationship between this road and Kleonai s history has received little emphasis. The purpose of this article is thus threefold. The first aim is to sup- port those who have argued that this important road followed, at least in part, the route of the Longopotamos River, and to argue that the road on this basic route was the main, direct interstate route between Corinth and Argos throughout antiquity. The second aim of the article is to document physical evidence for the road itself in greater detail than has previously been done, and to compare it with the ancient literary evidence. The northern portion of the route in Corinthian territory has already been well documented, but topographi- cal investigations within the Kleonai valley have been few; here I propose that it is possible to identify the course of the road within Kleonaian territory more precisely, particularlywhere the road passed near the site of the To this end I build a case based on evidence as diverse city proper. 2. 1 should clear as ancient roadside the of local old begin by making features, reports residents, monopatia the distinctionbetween a route and a of the and the of travelers to (or footpaths), autopsy region, reports early road.A routeis a "natural"way through Greece. These last are particularlyimportant, since I argue that the early the landscapedictated by topography. modern road from Corinth to Argos and the ancient road are essentially A basic route may incorporatea num- ber of differentroads. Routes be the same.This is demonstrablefor the better-documented northernportion may utilized more or less heavilyin different of the route, as a close comparison of the physical features of the ancient periods,but unless the landscape road and the itineraries of the travelers will show; the early identifying changes,they continue to exist as an early modern road in the Kleonai valley and relating it to evidence for the option for travel.One can discuss a ancient road will thus form a basis for reconstructing this crucial portion specific roadwhen there is physical of the route. evidence for its exact course,such as A discussion of the of interstate routes for our wheel ruts or terracewalls, or other significance major evidence of the modificationof the of is the of this article, but it should understanding history beyond scope landscapefor or by travel.Occasionally, not be controversialto assert that as artifacts for the reconstruction roads, even when physicalevidence is lacking, of the ancient past, are as significant as any other edifice uncoverable by it is possible to speakof a roadwhen archaeology. In an age of increased agricultural mechanization (and the there is enough literaryand circum- stantialevidence as roadside use of explosives in road construction), the Greek landscape and the ways (such in which one moves it are traces of roadside structures)to pinpoint the courseof through changing rapidly; travel a in a features and old are as inaccessible land is through landscape given paths disappearing previously period.I would like to thankYiannis exploited. It is therefore important to document the results of autopsy and Pikoulasfor helping me in the field and the memories of older residents, who remember a less-ravaged landscape, instructingme on the basics of ancient before traces of old routes and local memories are gone. For this reason, the roads;I direct the readerto his works of this is devoted to the evidence for the course (1995, 1999) and their bibliographies majority paper detailing for on all of ancient of the road in the belief that the road evidence specifics aspects itself, represents primary road constructionin Greece and their that should be recorded for its own since its accurate identification sake, detection by autopsy.I have also relied is important for any future study of the history of the area. heavilyon the works of W. K. Pritchett The final aim of this study,which requiresthat a careful exposition of (e.g., 1969, 1980; his discussionof ancient Greek roadsin 143- the road and its related features first be laid out, is to stress the significance 1980, pp. best introductionto of the between the of its and 196, remainsthe relationship polis Kleonai, territory borders, the and on YannisLolos for and the course of the road. I will show that the topic), Corinth-Argos Indeed, adviceand assistancein the field;Lolos road passes directly below Kleonai s walls, and that the city thus had the 2003 is an invaluablesource for the capabilityof functioning much like a fortresson this majorroute. Adopting ancient terminologyof roads. KLEONAI AND THE CO RI NT H~A RGO S ROAD 109 a phrase coined by Fernand Braudel, Kate Adshead called the road from Corinth to (Argos and thence to) Tegea "anaxis of history."3It seems that this axis centered on Kleonai. The close relationship between Kleonai and this interstate route (and the city's command of any easy alternative branches of it), which is reflected in the ancient sources for the road, had important ramifications for Kleonai s history. The city's topography and its potential control of this direct route ultimately had a significant impact on the city's own political alliances and, to a certain extent, on those of its more powerful neighbors. CONTROVERSY AND THE LITERARY SOURCES In antiquity, the most direct and easiest route from northern Greece via the Isthmus and Corinth into the central and southern Peloponnese passed - through the plain of Kleonai (Fig. 1). The other options a coastal route along the Corinthian Gulf as far as Sikyon, or a mountainous route to the - southeast toward Epidauros constituted a significant detour for most destinations, and were preferable only when political reasons dictated.4 From the ancient city of Corinth, the direct route led first to Kleonai;from Kleonai, the travelercould branch off to head west via Nemea and Phlious to Elis or Sparta, or continue south directly to Argos. The earliest referenceto this route for long-distance travelappears in a fragment of Stesichoros, which places Kleonai on a route between Corinth and Argos as early as the 6th century B.C.The passage in question recounts the story of the Seven againstThebes, and Polyneikes'journey from Thebes to Argos takes him through Corinth and Kleonai: a\)Ta[p ejueix'arcepav en'] aoxeot mA,a KopivGoi) piucpoc8' [ei)KTiueva<;]KAecovaq fivGov and [then Polyneikes and the Theban lords departed for] the fair cities of Corinth, and swiftly arrived at [well-built] Kleonai5 In Stesichoros's poem, Polyneikes' route takes him directly to the city of "well-built"Kleonai from Corinth, and the closeness of these two locations via the Corinth-Argos road is emphasized. Although the passage is heavily restored and, as poetry, should be used with caution, it clearly indicates that a route providing swift access from Corinth to the city of Kleonai and thence to Argos was alreadyin use in the Archaic period. By the Roman period, we have direct literary evidence in the form of reports by Strabo (8.6.19) and Pausanias (2.15.1) that confirm that the 3. Adshead 1986, p. 2, n. 3, citing not merelyfor access to the sanctuary beyond the ancient Nemea valley Braudel1949, p.