Contributions to the Eocene Palaeontology and Stratigraphy of B Eira Alta, Portugal

Contributions to the Eocene palaeontology and stratigraphy of B eira Alta, Portugal

11 - New Late Eocene Inamlnalian remnants from Coja (Portugal) and the presence of Palaeotherium magnum Cuvier

M. T. ANTUNES *t

.. Academia das Cicncias de Lisboa tCentro de Estratigrafia e Paleobiologia da UNL, Faculdade de Ciencias e Tecnologia, Quinta da Torre, P-2825 Monte da Caparica, Portugal

pp. 83-89 Cicncias da Terra (UNL) Lisboa NQ 11 1992 tab. 1

RESUMO

Palavras- chave: MamIJeros-Eocenico superior-Coja -Portugal.

E registada a ocorrencia de Palaeotherium magnum na fauna de Coja, prescnya que e concordante corn a previa atribuiyao ao nivcl de Montmartre (Ludiano). Observayoes de campo, conjugadas corn a identidade da fossilizayao de todos os exemplares conhecidos e a compatibilidade de todos os taxones de vertebrados, indicam proveniencia de idcntico nivel da mesma unidade litostratigrafica, as "Arcoses de Coja".

RESUME

Mots - des: Mammiferes-Eocene superieur-Coja Portugal.

La presence de Palaeotherium magnum est signalee parmilafaunedeCoja. Elleestenaccordavccl'attribution, faite auparavant, au niveau de Montmartre (Ludien). Des observations sur le terrain, la compatibilite avec les autres taxons de la faune et la fossilisation identique de toutes les pieces montrent que les vertebres fossiles proviennent du mcme horizon de l'unite lithostratigraphique denommee "Arcoses de Coja".

ABSTRACT

Key - words: Mammals-Late Eocene-C6ja-Portu gal.

The presence of Palaeotherium magnum in the fauna frolll Coja is recorded. It is well in agreement with the earlier reporting to the Montmartre level from the Ludian stage. Field data as well as compatibility with the remain ing taxa and the identical fossilization of all the specimens indicate that all the vertebrate fossils come from the same horizon in the lithostratigraphic unit "Arcoses de Coja".

INTRODUCTION meters North of the exploitation front) a Diplobune secundaria hemimandible, and M.T.Antunes found The clay exploitation by Empresa Cerfunica da in August of the same year a Peratherium cuvieri Carri~a Lda. at Coja (Coimbra District) is the only maxillary. portuguese site that yielded a significant late Eocene The fossilization pattern of the white and very (Ludian) mammalian fauna. Hence its paramount fragile bones in a greenish clayey matrix is always the importance as a strati graphic reference for the depos same. This holds for the 1953 and subsequent sam its on the huge platform, North of the Iberian Central ples as wen. Available field data also point out to a Mountain Range. single origin of the vertebrates, the lenticular green Furthermore, it represents the westernmost oc ish clays referred to before (ANTUNES, 1967, text currence of the "Gypse de Montmartre" classical fig. 1 , pl.l). fauna, as it was firstly recognized by ANTUNES All the identified taxa are indeed compatible (1964). Some papers followed (see ANTUNES, 1986, and do not suggest even slight differences in age which includes a bibliography on this subject). among them. For these reasons we regard the Coja No collecting was successful after our August vertebrate fauna as a coherent assemblage from but 1964 researches. Meanwhile, development of me one and same horizon of the strati graphical unit chanical exploitation rendered even more difficult to known as "Arcoses de Coja" formation. look for fossils. However some bones from the same This corroborates and is corroborated by obser site stored long ago at the Museu Mineralogico e vations at another site at the clay exploitation from Geologico of Coimbra University were rediscovered Ceramica da Beira, Lda. at Naia (about 30 kilometers (December 1988) by Mr. P. Proen~a e Cunha. This North), in beds correlative of those from Coja led to further study of the Coja fauna, presented here. (ANTUNES & DE BROIN, 1977, p.184): white bones were often seen and sometimes collected in greenish clays, but never in an underlying unit of NEW DATA AND DISCUSSION darker, grey carbonaceous clays with trunks from Gymnosperms and tree ferns (and some pollen and The fossils here reported were collected in 1956 spores as well), accounted for by J. Pais (see Part Ill). by the geologist P. Martins de Carvalho, who sent them to Professor M. Montenegro de Andrade, then at Coimbra University. Mr. Carvalho was carrying DESCRIPTION out field work for the Empresa Ceramica da Carri~a Lda. under demand from Mr. L.S. Filipe, Director. Most of the collection consists of poorly pre A few years earlier, fossil bones were collected served, small and uncharacteristic bone fragments. at the same site. They were reported by G. Zbyszewski Only three specimens seem to be identifiable: (a) a in 1953, but their true paleontological and chrono rear caudal vertebra that may perhaps be ascribed to logical significance was not realized then. Anoplotherium; (b) an Anoplotherium caudal verte According to Mr. Carvalho (who recently in bra close to another one, probably a 14th, previously formed Mr. Proen~a e Cunha) these fossils would described (ANTUNES, 1986), possibly from the have been found in some clay prospection pits in the same individual; and (c) the distal part of a metacar same greenish sediments where in April 1964 work pal or metatarsal from a rather large-sized mammal, ers collected (in a prospection pit about one hundred representing a hitherto unknown taxon.

87 The latter specimen is the only one that really figured by DE BLAINVILLE (ibid.) and reported to justifies a closer look. Its symmetrical shape is P. medium. enough to exclude the larger artiodactyls of those Regardless of morphological differences, size times, the anoplotheres. Hence the only remaining alone is enough to eliminate the medium-sized possibility is that it belongs to a quite large Palaeotherium species and, with even stronger rea perissodactyl. As there were then no rhinoceroses sons, the lesser Palaeotherids. nor any other large representatives of this order, it The only remaining possibility is the largest may undoubtedly be ascribed to Palaeotherium mag species P. magnum Cuv. At Paris Museum, all the num. third metacarpals and third metatarsals from the The specimen under study is a median (Ill) spectacular Vitry skeleton are poorly preserved. Size metapodial. However one cannot be sure whether it is about the same as that from the Coja specimen but is a metacarpal or a metatarsal, since the lack of the useful measurements cannot be taken. The metatar proximal part, some deformation and the loss of bony sal III from the Mormoiron skeleton is rather crushed material do not let much room for speculation. and apparently is broader than it should really be. It may be somewhat larger than the Coja specimen, even if such eventual differences is not reall y signifi cant. THE LARGE PALAEOTHERID: DISCUSSION One recognizes that in general there is a good AND IDENTIFICATION compatibility in shape and size with Palaeotherium magnum. In a revision of the Palaeotherids, Comparative work took into account published FRANZEN (1968) showed that there are significant data but was based mainly on direct examination of intraspecific variation, justifying the distinction of collections at the Institut de Paleontologie, Museum several forms (or subspecies). The largest are the last National d'Histoire Naturelle de Paris. We also ob ones, from the Frohnstetten level, latest Ludian, served some specimens at the Departement des Sci uppermost Eocene. A few even cross the "Grande ences de la Terre, Universite Claude-Bemard (Lyon coupure" (sensu Stehlin) boundary into the lowermost I), and in particular the P alaeotherium mag num skel Oligocene. eton from Mormoiron, Vaucluse. Uncomplete as it is, the specimen under study Comparisons have been attempted with other offers no definite proof of a post-Eocene age, and Palaeotherium species, the middle-sized P. crassum does not point out in that direction. The trend seems Cuv. and P. medium Cuv. Specimens from the indeed to be the reverse, for it looks closer to earlier, Montmartre Gypsum were checked against the one less large forms. The size is apparently that of under study, i.e.: Palaeolherium magnum girondicum from the lower -left Metatarsale III number GY 511 e, at the Ludian of La Dcbruge (cf. FRANZEN, idem, pl.lO, Galerie de Paleontologie, figured by DE fig.7). Summing up, classification at the subspecies BLAINVILLE (1839-1864, pl.lV) and ascribed to level does not seem to be possible. In conclusion, we P. crassum. ascribe the Coja metapod to Palaeotherium magnum - left Metatarsale III number GY 410 f, also Cuvier ssp.

Table I Upper Eocene Vertebrates from two sites in Beira Alta

Empresa Ceramica da Carrica Lda .. C6ja Ceramica da Beira Lda., Naia

MAMMALIA Metatheria Peratherium cuvieri (Fischer 1829) Undet. mammals, among them maybe a P alaeolhe rium Theria Palaeotherium cf. crassum Cuvier 1805 Palaeotherium magnum Cuvier 1805 ssp. Anoplotherium cf. commune Cuvier 1804 Diplobune secundaria (Cuvier 1822)

REPTILIA Testudines Geochelone (s.gen. indet.) sp. Geochelone (?Cheirogaster) sp.

88 THE C6JA VERTEBRATE FAUNA AND ITS taxa previously known at C6ja and with the ascribed AGE age, upper Ludian.4 level (Monunartre), late Eocene; or MP 19 Standard level (Escamps) according to The presence of Palaeotherium magnum, an tables 1 and 2 (see SCHMIDT-KIITLER. ed .• olhcrcommonelement of the classical fauna from the Internal. Symposium Mammal. Biostratigraphy and Montmartre Gypsum . late Eocene. does not change Paleoecol. European Paleogene, Mainz, 1987). the previously recognized age for the C6ja site and • The identity of fossilization and matrix as well correlative ones including that of Naia (see as fi eld data clearly indicate that venebrate fossils ANfUNES. 1986. p.l04-105). TheC6ja faunaprob come from the same horizon from the "Arcoses de ably indicates the 4 (Montman re) level in the Ludian COja" Formation. (RUSSELL et al .• 1982). The venebrate checklist is now as follows (table I).

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS CONCLUSIONS Wc thank Drs. L. Ginsburg and P. Mein for their This study leads to the following conclusions. assiSlance. respectively at the Mus~um National d'Histoire • The presence of Palaeotherium magnum ssp. Natu relle de Paris and at the Univers it~ Claude-Bemard (Lyon I): Mr. P. Proenya e Cunha, from lhe Universidade is recorded for the first time among the COja fauna de Coimbrn, for valuable dala; and Professor F. d'Orey, and in Ponugal. from the Faculdade de Cicncias e Teenologia da • This occurrence is compatible with the other Universidade Nova de Lisboa, for lhe revision of the text.

REFERENCES

ANTUNES, M.T. (1986) - Anopfolherium (Mammalia, Artiodactyla) et Geochelolle (Reptilia, Testudines) aCoja: les vertt5bres fossiles et !'Eocene sUpCrieur au Portugal. Ciellcias do Terra (UNL), Lisboa, nO 8, p.99-110, 1 pI. ANTUNES, M.T. & DE BRQIN, F. ( 1977)-? Cheirogasler sp. (0. Testudines. Fam. Testudinidae, Geochefone s.l .) du Paloogene de Naia, Toodela et l'iigedu gisement. Cienciasda Terra (UNL). Lisboa, n" 3, p.179-195, 5 fig .. 2 pI. BLAlNVILLE, H.D. DE (1839-1864}- Ostoographie ou Description lconographique comparee du Squelette et du SystCme denlairedes MammilCres recents et fossilcs pour servirde base a la Zoologie eta la Geologie. Atlas - tome quatrieme/ Compose de 93 planchesl Qu atcmat~s - Maldent ~s. J.B. Bailli~re et Fils, Paris. FRANZEN, J.L. (1968) - Revision der Ganung Pafaeolherium Cuvier 1804 (palaeotheriidae, PerissOOactyla, Mammalia). Inaugural-Oisserlation zur Erlangung der DoktorwUrde der Naturwissenseh.-math. FakulUlt der Albert-Ludwigs Uni versitJit zu Freiburg i. Br. 2 vol. RUSSELL, O.E.; HARTENBERGER, J.-L.; POlvtEROL, C.; SEN, S.; SCHMIDT-Kl'ITLER, N. & VIANEY -LtAUD, M. (1982) - Ma mmals and Stratigraphy: the. Paleogene of Europe. Palaeollerlebrala, M~m.Extrnordinaire, Montpellier 1982,77 p., 23 fig. KITIl..ER, N. SCHMIDT (cd.) (1987) _International Symposium on Mammalian Biostratigraphy and Paleoeeology of lhe European Paleogene -Mainz, February 18th-21 st 1987. MunchnerGeowiss.Abh .. (A). MUnchen. 10, pp.I-312.