IN THE HIGH COURT OF CIRCUIT BENCH AT

DATED THIS THE 9th DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2009 BEFORE THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A.S BOPANNA REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO.1302J 2006 cjw. REGULAR HEA NO.125J 2006

REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO.1302/2006

BETWEEN:

R JES\E3 OI)D M(YL I ASB PEERAR R IN( 1)ECE \Sf) Br I R f A A\B’ W/O AL PA A N A\\AI’ ARE C RF II

I )r) AR, C TJ[ i :L it

MIE 0CC

R PEERkKA

• 0CC CC. OCC.AGRICULI

S R ‘. £ !WDI)t R:0 MAIM MOUL

— it Ac;F. GE IQ IQ .4(si .)

Ii rQ •

AAF is

IAtFRI

• a ;(\

\GE

‘II t) U

0

0 0 ‘,

0CItM.1btZM3HT9MV1T:

I —. C

.i

ANt &DIST

.KTL

ALAI)AKAIII

I i

40

4 4LAL)AKAtTI AGRICtLTURF _fl “i

MADAKATTIVI -% uRIcT;LTURE. —•

3

(iRICt.’d,Tt.RF. ‘.i Jrj

ATL ATE

Mi l

3(1 1

••‘1AKs

Nifli

Al)A1’

)NHT PIC. .t—(

Xi)AI’

I3ASHF

YEARS.

‘rEARS. VF4R

F4LI.F I

DI ‘A s)I DI •t

NN.VkR

‘rI &t ‘—‘. •

RA a

HAVFR

\RS.

I •t—

I •_ Ti..._,B

TESAB

TT

ESAL3 M4’F’

ETI’

it

r: •i

URb. F ‘

SDNI

1W s14

R ‘.‘

1’zE Pt

S Wi. , flLL(.,I..

; V

IL

! i’r,EPAI.

PFERAKANN PEERLflN4\V.

flGU,

1 A(,j

\(IF.

V I’

L ‘.‘ —

R “c

Wi 3

AGE ‘OYEARS, 0CC AGRIC’T.LIURE R 0 ATADAKATTQ11IGF TQ AND DIET. FU\VERI APPFIIANTS

B RIRK KT.IIARNI AD ORkPPPLIANTN I ‘A)TO I)

AND:

ABUT.LREHMANSAIIEB MOHADINSAB KRAJAGI

5INCE DECEASED BY IRS

IA DADIMA BI W/O ABDUI RF H MANSAHF B KARAJAG GFD 50 YRS 0CC HOT.SEHOI D FZf0 ALADAKAIFI \IIIA( F, TQ AND DIET HAVFRI

B AIL\FJAKSH ( ABUT.I RF HAMANSAF I I TARJAG GF 50\FARS C C E)ISIIIC U ROA\IAK I TI I N ISII\R

A I If

C F MADARASAB S () ABDFLRFFI\MS HUB RARJGI, AGED \BOI I Xi AGRICUI RU I C \L\DF’\I \‘I I \( IQ \NDI)IT H\\IR

I1AJARAT AB MOD DINSAB KARJ \GI IGLI) \BOI I X ‘ O( C AGRIQ I 1DPI R I M AI)ARA I I I H WI I

i I)UMA HI W 0 B I3CSAB MALLIDID GFI) BOL I F ER )( ( IIOUSF HOLD WORK I \IADAKAU III\iER

MOHADIN 131 V 0 ( U )L AI IIOMMAR\I ICED BO I YFAR )( FI( SF H \iOR S ABDI LSAI3 M\D1NS\R I)T\1EIOS R \GLI) ABOU I 70 YHAR O( C AGRICUI TI RF P \ ALADkPTT HAvI RI PESP )NF)ETS

EF r4 I-i C Iii \ARU)DLR PUP P RiP. S P \ i{IRE \1 \FJI iA P2 RI M JYkE MAR m I \III ASEFIS ADVs EOR R [0 SRI GM. RAS\MMANAV\R ADV I OR R8)

‘I HIS APPL \L IS i-Ti-EL) I S Qt Ci- C PL MiAINST I HE 1 DGME\i Hi-P PEE. DT. PS 4 )pu PASSEL) IN (‘PS) 0N i-HE PILL . I I HE (Ti-IL 1ETL[E (SR.LF\ H-VFRi DECREEPSO THE SPIT E’()R PARTITI( F\ AND P’ )SSESSIUE

REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO 125312006

BETWEEN:

Si-IAMBI Ji\ç$Ai-\ hi1 )Ay55 PED AI3OPT 3 bARs ACRICLLfi$PE P U ALJ)Sk.AT[ 1EHA\r AND:

lB. IA,

1C. 1D.

E

AGED ABDULREHAMANSAB ALLABAXSH JAFFAR MO

0CC, SiNCE S’O W/O.ABDULRAHAMANSAB MADARSAB I DCC. AC.TE. SO,ABDULREHAMANSAB VILLAGE (3CC, 5/0. SMTJKCTEJAB1 IsARJAOI DCC. DCC: R/O. DIST. HAMIDABI R/O.ALADAKATTI, HAJA —C

\ARTAGT

\PASGJ C

‘‘L

HADINSAB

ABDULREHAMANSAB

ABDULREHAMANSAB

BYADAGI

RE/SAL AGRiCULTURE. AGRICULTURE.

132 fl,i

AGRICULTURE. AGRICuLTURE,

HOUSE

H

HA•VE•RI

ABOUT ‘

2I DECEASED t

YEARS. ‘C

IN

U L<’’

AGED AGE

GE

23/ _ A

TQ.

‘Rz flQ

Mu!.-IAHINtHA.Li

WIFE

60 L

OANWP.RSAB

KARJAGI

IN

20

K

ASYEARc

ABOU1

YEARS,

F

DADIMA

LYADAGI

LIST.

YEAUT

HAVER1

BY ‘

HIS

HAVERI. 26

LAs,

BI

KARAJAGI,

YEARS

TALUE, EARJA(./I

Y./.JDWA

D A

“b

,

(IHUDUMABI OC( 10 (iCC .GED AGED

.‘5E. C11%M’NBI I4JTtSAH 0(1 ‘INC C)ED t)(j’ HAVLRI

I TV-T V)iT

,‘ •GED

fr

I,

;

in.

VCGOt.SIM(

IOH

FM

ZARV”i1BI

a_

T1

4)

0 U

•:

001!

AND

B

..;-.:c

L

DflBI

Al jTj.

HOUSF 50 -

XKANN4V HOUSE ‘\ORICI

H01TSEVIFF

‘FP’ 4’S

ABOUT

ABOUT .‘L3()UT .1

38

$ it

DFC

Uk. I

•.

ADAKAEflI

DTST

i:-4’,-’, 1 JALUK

YE4RS.

EARS

DODDAML\L\

‘t.

)T.

‘N

F

1)

W10

HO!

J±I)

‘:

V

iTt.

HA% WIFE.

A\’i-’. Ni’

00

7”

1’

kB

•

.1

i

I

&

0

!

‘rE4RS ‘ ‘tE

I RE

)

Dis

ER!

fCMB’fl Si 113

bARS

‘4

s

KARl -1TF

BY

I I•TI

t \

WORE

‘R

rLt’_rCI.i

R

HIS

I

—‘

R¼TI’SMI

tSAB

0.I-iAVFRI

‘AIs 2.!1

L

A

P

Rs

:s’

MLIADAD

0

PEERKiAN

R -1 ••

GAD

C

NtM. 3G. SF.

11 La.

V

OCt T.? ia_C R oCC. MOULASAI3 0CC S RO R DUDDUSAB S

IQ rQ. %GL. r. t Q GE

A,

AOL .._t I ‘C •

kRENM3I

RD4NBI

C) (I.

o 0 t). 0. ,J I•.t’

0 I

)I

c. AND

&

AL LUE tUE . • 3.’ MAUND1iLLAbE. K.4RkJAGT i)EiSs1R1 df -

AGRICULTbRF

HfltsSEIbr.,

H0USE1

32 B1f 1 .GR1cfl.Tt’RE, (

P1ST — P1ST ‘

LiD4K —. DDTSI

“1 O’rEkR. •.

AK1RSAB •I

4DAK4flI

‘rEARS.

YLA! Pit’

r

fliS’l. if . , .

EARL

‘Is,

ti

R4JESAL3

P.’.r.4’ RAJESAB

F1

R’-.

11% H.t •

!TPF 4,L

_t

IFE. — 1{A\hRi

1

‘I, \ii).ACt.

Viii

11

ERI kRI

re) VALIF

YL

IL i!j4’’.

FE

J.IA(

401-:.

PEKRM-IANA PEbRi.f{AN\

LAG! trf..t.TJi\j_

R ..

S

AR.

R. fe I

I

j PEA tLL’ V

)

‘lb

O”R

113Y

S.NO

;

REEI\C.r •

HVERI R:O.kLADIjK4VrT

RI THIS

THESE RI SRI

Meir

.2

A S

?l

I)ELI

11 r1

I

p

IXxMFNI • II.GA.

R

Mi

.fl

“lie

APPEAL

I°9b

7n..

V

file

.•r

lTL

APPE’U

1

581

tIIPEM\TH.

RFD

HIKKARADDER

‘e-’q’c’n

1. .,.—

4R

ON

LKARN I

Slit

•13r1

n

110. • tIa(

FILED

NU

IHI

IHL

c

AMMP’ik

i

itts

e

FOR ..

(OMING

r.

FOILOWINC :‘

P11

DLCREF

D .jDV

UNDER

rr _:. ..

PARTI1TO%

F

JUDGMENT %n.5

t•:.

OF FOR

u—

FORR.(

FORR2

c.

‘R ‘

C.

ON

1’ c

3 :‘.

9

SEC

THF

a:.d

RI .‘

AD’

FOR bliP

jc i

.%NIJ

ITO -

CIVIL

O ‘

R1E ..

P01

ADMISSION

F)

1)

i

+ rfr

fl

POSSFSSION. ‘• t

ADUlt ....

13.4

‘?S

C

,

OP

;‘rai’cj

ppcl

2(’

IHE

rr

S —

(SR

e’

IHN

‘iF ‘“

(1k. a

ir

v

SI

PA’SFD

, D’1)

ON

‘AV

‘he

AG4ISi

ci

:r,

t. IIAFRI

r

)

C

I

rllF

‘il

I

I

1% V apprlliit—.

t j

de’r inIdj the ?o’O Nt’.!

h.

.idg’ucnt

n

a1

a

t

is

e (

•

pI.untitts

— nf

rc

c’

‘‘ tu .

4

d 4(1111

4

p

n:

4

d .

ir 4

pron’is %l

:h.

:

and t

n

sñ

lV

Dtsnn. a—.

alt .

it t

ftc

t1a,cl

a

jj

RFA

h?ve ‘b

thc

c rierre’e

omprc.r .

• S4

itt

lain

IL

,i.. .

xu 1%

N’

sai;1

RF

agreetl

(ti

hit .1

r.

t

1

ckted

)j

,.: j’ns

3(1

a”

s’llap usc

xi xi uppea

pendtnc

1

‘i

et.::x!etj to

Ihcr

Sts”

im

.10Cm

1

‘ ‘im

15

Ui

‘eeeiic-

car

(14

‘ig

ngst

n

br

1._

Ha c”)rn I-I

tedg

2O)( ts

ci’ )(fl.

she

10

themsel’

the

lhe%t .

.,b.tl

ede .

thc

r

icrt .‘.‘

d

•p a..ri— I,

i

prnp.-rties

f.—ndatits

gairist

that pit •‘

‘Uk

1o

also

j. ‘,

in

i

I.

•j

!tL.

cs .t

ntilbs

±nsread

auptals. j

tt’

b nil

I

4e

igntii’zrs.

the tcfrc .

n1,

ks t

No.2

indicated

who

per )ist very

v3re

l

t_. e ‘(

r,4#.,

of I

f” ‘

t•’

t

tiit

axe

his

same

she

x t,c

U

f

t

4

‘ii ri.

pafle%

r

i)

in

omprotrust

‘n

(ott . ,

spondent

judgment

:‘

ar.’

t

part. —

the •

chtn’

mc ‘ — I . •‘

lxix

IUflC

suP

ti’fs

the

4

‘Hi

ot*

P’. I

‘1 ic

C”nflpi’flflise piE sk. ‘irli regard pat 4’,..zfi.c’ his

cC’

A ‘

‘-ned

this

ties,

nfl!!

‘%tV bet

tbe

n• L

tc,

d

r

C

one

rIkinner

r

)pe4 o”nsci

111f and

settled

ti’

icigi

t.

(

cxtent

petition

srim’

rirsid’

r’q

pr

the

*

‘ipp’

of

betw

twit’s

I

piainrilts

nfl’! •

ot

xFt

isv

tie

ompromise

the

r’a,etl

anng

tlt

en

siP -

judn

titi’ -

nnipi:In1’

oropert

the

i

($1.bc.t20,’o)

f

h

i

r

ttt

1

t’

parue

the

ci’.

ye

Ed

tntc’rc’d

‘‘i’

pLc..’i’Iffs

-is

fin?

•ndirated

p

avl

II

sa%

artics

iflt .

.tcCCi)’

s

the 1%

bL e

into

mi’e

‘a

made .nnthiIi2

en indicatc

had

compromise

That

between

allotted

‘lied

cIat’d

ornpr

ri

thr

part

that

3 ‘

iii

ontruiv

the

t)

1

misc

ot

ar

5.01

is sli. they

tic

irties.

the

icc.

sitisfied £

sctflI

lg

an shaie 0tb

1)r.jj

c

pted

‘Ut’

satisticd

eedlluc%

r ‘.

in

n

t

g -,

Ui’h

mc sid

lift ‘I

r

is

c S

I —

j ) 7 co t ;S 7) p C Zr 3 - Zr — -% Zr

t 41 - % c - 411

i I - ? 1’ 7 I) Zr Ct) LI C’ —t IC 41 tI - (I (1) 0 Zr LI U -4 4- -t - Zr — T3 C) II) C’ Zr t 1 Zr C ‘a. - m - c 41 t Zr 1 Z 0 t IC Zr Zr C C Zr (C) — I 7 1 C) -t 7 (9 Zr - Ct’ j

Ct as

S

w4) fl be a’ - b) I> b 0’

o be be be 0 5• 0 b4 0 0’ go .0 0’ g’ 1 0 0 ‘ B 0 be C, 0’ a’ e S 0 —. n c 0 go 0 0 I. z j 0 0 ba

b 0’ WI C) C) CD m 0 w —

CD CD 9, W$ . go 9: E ‘ CD 0 0 CD B 0 B 8’ 0flWI Os CD a’ CD 0 WI 0 CO • CD e3b3 CD g CD 0 8’ ‘ 0 0 WI WI 0 I L’S’ 1 CD 0 CD CD