A&A 616, A75 (2018) Astronomy https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201832810 & © ESO 2018 Astrophysics
The triple system HD 150136: From periastron passage to actual masses ?,?? L. Mahy1,2,???, E. Gosset2,????, J. Manfroid2, C. Nitschelm3, A. Hervé4,5, T. Semaan2,6, H. Sana1, J.-B. Le Bouquin7, and S. Toonen8
1 Instituut voor Sterrenkunde, KU Leuven, Celestijnlaan 200D, Bus 2401, 3001 Leuven, Belgium e-mail: [email protected] 2 Space Sciences, Technologies, and Astrophysics Research (STAR) Institute, Université de Liège, Quartier Agora, Bât B5c, Allée du 6 août, 19c, 4000 Liège, Belgium 3 Unidad de Astronomía, Facultad de Ciencias Básicas, Universidad de Antofagasta, Antofagasta, Chile 4 Astronomical Institute ASCR, Fricova˘ 298, 251 65 Ondrejov,˘ Czech Republic 5 Visitor Scientist at Gemini Observatory, Northern Operations Center, 670 North A’ohoku Place, Hilo, HI 96720, USA 6 Institute of Astronomy, University of Geneva, 51 chemin des Maillettes, 1290 Versoix, Switzerland 7 UJF-Grenoble 1/CNRS-INSU, Institut de Planétologie et d’Astrophysique de Grenoble (IPAG), UMR 5274, Grenoble, France 8 Anton Pannekoek Institute for Astronomy, University of Amsterdam, 1090 GE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Received 12 February 2018 / Accepted 30 April 2018
ABSTRACT
+ Context. The triple system HD 150136 is composed of an O3 V((f∗))–O3.5 V((f )) primary, of an O5.5–6 V((f)) secondary, and of a more distant O6.5–7 V((f)) tertiary. The latter component went through periastron in 2015–2016, an event that will not occur again within the next eight years. Aims. We aim to analyse the tertiary periastron passage to determine the orbital properties of the outer system, to constrain its incli- nation and its eccentricity, and to determine the actual masses of the three components of the system. Methods. We conducted an intensive spectroscopic monitoring of the periastron passage of the tertiary component and combined the outcoming data with new interferometric measurements. This allows us to derive the orbital solution of the outer orbit in three- dimensional space. We also obtained the light curve of the system to further constrain the inclination of the inner binary. Results. We determine an orbital period of 8.61 0.02 years, an eccentricity of 0.682 0.002, and an inclination of 106.18 0.14◦ ± ± +8.45 +4.96 ± for the outer orbit. The actual masses of the inner system and of the tertiary object are 72.32 8.49 M and 15.54 4.97 M , respectively. From the mass of the inner system and accounting for the known mass ratio between the primary− and the secondary,− we determine actual masses of 42.81 M and 29.51 M for the primary and the secondary components, respectively. We infer, from the different
mass ratios and the inclination of the outer orbit, an inclination of 62.4◦ for the inner system. This value is confirmed by photometry. Grazing eclipses and ellipsoidal variations are detected in the light curve of HD 150136. We also compute the distance of the system to 1.096 0.274 kpc. Conclusions.± By combining spectroscopy, interferometry, and photometry, HD 150136 offers us a unique chance to compare theory and observations. The masses estimated through our analysis are smaller than those constrained by evolutionary models. The formation of this triple system suggests similar ages for the three components within the errorbars. Finally, we show that Lidov–Kozai cycles have no effect on the evolution of the inner binary, which suggests that the latter will experience mass transfer leading to a merger of the two stars. Key words. stars: early-type – binaries: spectroscopic – stars: fundamental parameters – stars: individual: HD150136
1. Introduction massive star formation and evolution are still to be understood. Most of their fundamental parameters are poorly constrained, Massive stars are key objects in the galaxies. They influence both especially their masses. In this context, investigating the binary the chemical and the mechanical evolution of their surround- system population is the best way to derive these masses. The rel- ings through the creation of bubbles and of induced or inhibited atively small number of extremely massive galactic stars implies star formation. They are also the main sources of ultraviolet and that any system whose orbital parameters are accurately deter- ionizing radiations. Despite their importance, actual details of mined provides important new constraints to stellar evolution. Binarity, however, affects the way that stars evolve, making their ? Based on observations collected at the European Southern Observa- evolution more complex than that of single stars. This is espe- tory (Paranal and La Silla, Chile). cially relevant for massive stars, given their high fraction of ?? The journal of observations and the radial velocity data are only available at the CDS via anonymous ftp to multiple systems (Duchêne & Kraus 2013; Sana et al. 2012, cdsarc.u-strasbg.fr (130.79.128.5) or via 2014). The situation is even more complex with gravitationally- http://cdsarc.u-strasbg.fr/viz-bin/qcat?J/A+A/616/A75 bound hierarchical systems since the evolution of the stars in ??? F.R.S.-FNRS Postdoctoral Researcher. those systems can be ruled by the Lidov–Kozai cycles (Kozai ???? F.R.S.-FNRS Research Director. 1962; Lidov 1962). The latter can modulate the eccentricity
Article published by EDP Sciences A75, page 1 of7 A&A 616, A75 (2018) of the inner binary triggering modulations in their interactions spectroscopic monitoring covering both sides of the periastron (Toonen et al. 2016). In this context, HD 150136 is perfectly passage of the tertiary component. suited to better constrain this phenomenon. The present paper provides the analysis of the new spectro- This system is one of the two brightest stars hosted scopic data coupled with new interferometric and with unprece- in the center of the young open cluster NGC 6193 in the dented photometric observations of HD 150136. The paper Ara OB1 association, for which the distance was first esti- is organized as follows. In Sect.2, we present the observa- mated by Herbst & Havlen(1977) to be 1.32 kpc. This object tional campaign and the different instruments used. Section3 is a triple hierarchical system formed of an inner binary with is devoted to the determination of the radial velocities of the + an O3 V((f∗))–O3.5 V((f )) primary and an O5.5–6 V((f)) sec- three components. Section4 presents the global orbital solution ondary1, orbiting around each other with a period of 2.67455 for the inner and the outer systems by combining spectroscopy days, and of an O6.5–7 V((f)) physically bound tertiary com- and interferometry. The light curve of the system is studied ponent located on a much longer orbit (Mahy et al. 2012). in Sect.5. Section6 discusses the evolutionary statuses of the This object is the nearest system harbouring an O3 star. It thus different components and, finally, we give our conclusions in constitutes a target of choice for investigating the fundamental Sect.7. parameters of such a star. HD 150136 is one of the X-ray-brightest massive stars known (log L = 33.39 (cgs), log(L /L ) = 6.4; Skinner et al. 2005), 2. Observations and data reduction X X bol − most likely as the result of a radiative colliding-wind interac- 2.1. Spectroscopic observations tion. Its X-ray light curve, however, presents variations whose origin remains unclear. The star was also reported as a non- We collected and retrieved 177 optical spectra of HD 150136 thermal radio emitter (Benaglia et al. 2006; De Becker 2007). obtained with the Fibre-fed Extended Range Optical Spec- This suggests that the system harbours a relativistic population trograph (FEROS) mounted successively on the ESO 1.52 m of electrons, probably accelerated through shocks in colliding- (for observations before 2002) and on the MPG/ESO 2.2 m wind regions. Mahy et al.(2012) showed that a non-thermal radio (for observations after 2002) telescopes at La Silla observa- emission originating in the inner system would hardly escape. tory (Chile). These data were partially presented and analysed The presence of the third object is thus required in order to in Mahy et al.(2012) and in Sana et al.(2013) but spectra that displace the emitting region in the outer system. were newly acquired around the periastron passage of the third Following the study of Mahy et al.(2012), the third com- component are introduced in the present paper. The monitoring ponent is expected to be sufficiently far from the inner system of HD 150136 on FEROS started in 1999, and went on every year to be observable with long baseline interferometric facilities. until 2016, with breaks in 2007 and in 2010. FEROS provides The first detections of the outer pair were reported by Sana a resolving power of R = 48 000 and covers the entire optical et al.(2013) from the Precision Integrated-Optics Near-infrared range from 3800 to 9200 Å. The data were reduced following the Imaging ExpeRiment (PIONIER) and by Sanchez-Bermudez procedure described in Mahy et al.(2012). et al.(2013) from the Astrometrical Multi BEam combineR We also obtained Director’s Discretionary Time (DDT) (AMBER). Sana et al.(2013) combined the preliminary inter- with the UV-Visual Echelle Spectrograph (UVES; PI: Mahy ferometric observations with high-resolution spectroscopic data 297.D-5007, PI: Gosset 295.D-5025, and PI: Gosset 294.D-5041) to derive a first orbital solution of the outer companion in the mounted on the ESO-VLT to acquire eight additional spectra, three-dimensional space. These authors reported a period of which we have completed with two additional spectra pro- 3008 days, and an eccentricity of 0.73 for the outer orbit. Mean- vided by the EDIBLES team (see Cox et al. 2017; PI: Cox; while, interferometric and spectroscopic observations continue Large Programme: 194.C-0833(C)) taken in June and July 2015. to be obtained to constrain the full orbit. With the analysis of These data have a resolving power of R = 80 000. The eight these data, we realized that the expected periastron passage was DDT time spectra were acquired with the DIC 2 437+760 setup not yet observed and that the values provided by Sana et al. whilst the spectra taken in June and in July were obtained with (2013) needed to be revised. The parameters of the outer orbit the DIC 1 346+564 and the DIC 1 437+860 setups, respectively. were updated through the analysis of the interferometric data by The data reduction was performed with the standard reduction Le Bouquin et al.(2017). The latter changed the values of the pipeline. period and of the eccentricity to 3067 days and 0.68, and inferred Finally, we took three spectra of HD 150136 with the actual masses of 87 M for the inner system and of 27 M for the CORALIE spectrograph mounted on the Swiss 1.2 m Leonhard third component. However their lack of spectroscopic observa- Euler telescope at La Silla. CORALIE is an improved version tions close to the periastron passage prevented them from strictly of the ELODIE spectrograph (Baranne et al. 1996) covering the constraining the semi-amplitude of the outer orbit and therefore spectral range between 3850 and 6890 Å. Its resolving power is the minimum masses. R = 55 000. The data were reduced with the CORALIE pipeline. This emphasizes the uncertainties linked to the determina- The entire journal of observations is available at the CDS. tion of the dynamical masses of the three components. It indeed The heliocentric Julian date (HJD) is the time taken at mid- depends on the maxima of amplitudes of the radial velocity (RV) exposure and is given in the format HJD–2450000. curves for the outer orbit. In this context, we have undertaken a 2.2. Photometric observations 1 The ((f∗)) reports a spectrum with the N IV 4058 emission line stronger than the N III 4634–41 lines and a weak He II 4686 absorption The photometric observations of HD 150136 were carried out line, the ((f+)) refers to a spectrum with medium N III 4634–41 emission between April and August 2017 at Siding Spring Observatory lines, the weak He II 4686 line, and the Si IV 4089–4116 lines in emis- with the 0.43-m f/6.8 telescope (T17) of the iTelescope net- sion, and the ((f)) means that the emission N III 4634–41 lines are weak work2. The camera was equipped with a 1K*1K FLI ProLine and that the He II 4686 line is present in strong absorption (see Walborn 1971, for further details). 2 http://www.itelescope.net
A75, page 2 of7 L. Mahy et al.: The tripleL. Mahy system et HDal.: The 150136: triple From system periastron HD 150136 passage to actual masses
400 E2Vthe only CCD47-10-1-109 star in the field CCD with giving a suitable a 15 brightness.50 field at and a resolution it proved 1 ofto0 be.92 su00ffipixelciently− . A stable. narrow-band An aperture O III offilter 3.7 was arcsec used was in used order and to 300 avoida small saturation empirical of seeing the target correction star. The was observations applied because were ofmade the 200
innearness sequences of the lasting stars. about The best 20 minutesdata of each of short sequence exposures. were ave Ther- ] 1 − reductionsaged in order were to build done the with final the data IRAF set. daophot packages. The 100 nearby HD 150135 was used as a comparison. It is the only star in the field with a suitable brightness and it proved to be suffi- 0 2.3. Interferometric observations ciently stable. An aperture of 3.7 arcsec was used and a small 100 − empiricalIn complement seeing to correction the spectroscopic was applied and because photometric of the nearness data, we Radial velocities [km s 200 ofalso the used stars. the The astrometric best data observations of each sequence compiled were by averagedLe Bouqu inin − order to build the final data set. et al. (2017)to better constrain the orbital parameters of the outer 300 orbit. Two additional points were obtained in May and August − 400 2.3. Interferometric observations − 0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 2017 (PI: Sana, 596.D-0495(J))with the PIONIER combiner (Le − Phase [Φ] InBouquin complement et al. 2011). to the We spectroscopic refer to Le Bouquin and photometric et al. (2017) data, for we a alsodescription used the of astrometric the data reduction observations procedure. compiled by Le Bouquin Fig. 1. RV curves of the inner system corrected for the presence of ththee et al.(2017) to better constrain the orbital parameters of the outer tertiary component. component. Red dots give the RVs of the primary whilwhilstst the orbit.3. Radial Two additional velocity pointsmeasurements were obtained in May and August black ones indicate the secondary component. 2017 (PI: Sana, 596.D-0495(J)) with the PIONIER combiner In order to attain a good accuracy on the radial velocity (RV) (Le Bouquin et al. 2011). We refer to Le Bouquin et al.(2017) We applycompare the the Heck-Manfroid-Mersch different sets of RVs method in Fig. (HeckA.1 and et we al. formeasurements, a description we of the proceed data reduction in different procedure. steps to measure them conclude to a global agreement. In the following, we use the for the three components. In the first step, we fit the line pro- 1985), revised by Gosset et al. (2001), on the difference between theset ofRVs RVs of the obtained primary by and cross-correlation, the secondary givento determine that they the rep- or- files with Gaussian profiles. Given the spectral classification of resent average values on several main spectral lines. The RVs 3. Radial velocity+ measurements bital period of the inner (primary/secondary) system and on the O3V((f∗))-O3.5V((f )) attributed to the primary component, its are given with the journal of observations that is available at the spectrum presents lines of N v 4604–19that only this component RVs of the tertiary component for the orbital period of the outer In order to attain a good accuracy on the radial velocity (RV) CDS. exhibits. We also focus on the N iv 4058, He ii 4542, O iii 5592, (primary + secondary/tertiary) system. For the inner system, an measurements, we proceed in different steps to measure them We apply the Heck–Manfroid–Mersch1 method (Heck et al. and He i 5876 lines. The lines formed by elements in higher ion- outstanding peak at 0.373895d− , corresponding to a period of for the three components. In the first step, we fit the line pro- 1985), revised by Gosset et al.(2001), on the difference between ization stages are expected to be created closer to the stellar pho- 2.674548 0.000007 days is detected. This value confirms that files with Gaussian profiles. Given the spectral classification of the RVs of± the primary and the secondary to determine the tospheres, which infers a better estimation of the amplitudes of obtained by Mahy et al. (2012). For the outer system, the pe- O3 V((f ))–O3.5 V((f+)) attributed to the primary component, orbital period of the inner (primary/secondary) system1 and the RVs.∗ These sets of lines, however, have their disadvantages: riodogram provides an outstanding peak at 0.000318d− , corre- its spectrum presents lines of N V 4604–19 that only this com- spondingon the RVs to a of period the tertiary of 3144.7 component days, which for isthe slightly orbital larger periodthan of ponent– the Nexhibits.iv 4058 We line also is present focus in on emission the N IV in4058, the primary He II 4542, spec- the period outer (primary of 3067 days+ secondary/tertiary) provided by Le Bouquin system. et For al. (2017).the inner 1 O IIItrum.5592, This and line He I shows5876 anlines. asymmetry The lines that formed can be by due elements to the system, an outstanding peak at 0.373895 d− , corresponding in higherwind-wind ionization interaction stages zone are expectedbetween the to beprimary created and closer the sec- to to a period of 2.674548 0.000007 days is detected. This ± the stellarondary photospheres, (see Mahy et which al. 2012) infers or a to better tidal estimation interactions of thebe- 4.value Orbital confirms parameters that obtained for the by Mahy global et system al.(2012). For the amplitudestween these of the two RVs. components. These sets Furthermore, of lines, however, this line have is their con- outer system, the periodogram provides an outstanding peak at We combine1 the RV measurements of the three components ob- iii 0.000318 d− , corresponding to a period of 3144.7 days, which disadvantages:taminated by the C 4070 line, especially at the maximum tained through spectroscopy with the interferometric datapoints is slightly larger than the period of 3067 days provided by – theof separation, N IV 4058 which line is can present make the in assessmentemission in of the asymmetry primary to perform a global fit of the inner and outer orbits. The orbital Le Bouquin et al.(2017). spectrum.uncertain. This line shows an asymmetry that can be due parameters of the inner system confirm those given by Mahy the spectral widths of the He ii 4542 lines are different for the – to the wind-wind interaction zone between the primary and et al. (2012) and Sana et al. (2013). Figure.1 shows the RV three components, given their spectral classifications. There- the secondary (see Mahy et al. 2012) or to tidal interac- curves of the inner system corrected for the presence of the ter- fore, the primary’s line is the most prominent feature, in 4. Orbital parameters for the global system tions between these two components. Furthermore, this line tiary. comparison with that of the secondary or the tertiary com- is contaminated by the C III 4070 line, especially at the WeWith combine the two the new RV interferometric measurements datapoints, of the three the components outer orbit ponents, making the latter barely detectable outside epochs maximum of separation, which can make the assessment of isobtained now well through constrained, spectroscopy and confirms with the the values interferometric provided by data- Le close to the maxima of separation. asymmetry uncertain; Bouquinpoints to et perform al. (2017). a global The fit global of the fit inner depends and on outer 14 parametersorbits. The – the spectralO iii 5592 widths line is of not the included He II 4542 in thelines UVES are different setting, for which the orbital parameters of the inner system confirm those given by prevents us from obtaining the related RVs close to the peri- because we keep fixed the eccentricity and the argument of the three components, given their spectral classifications. There- periastronMahy et al. for(2012 the) inner and Sana system. et al.Besides(2013). the Figure orbital1 shows parame theters, fore,astron the passage. primary’s line is the most prominent feature, in RV curves of the inner system corrected for the presence of the – the He i 5876 line is formed further away from the photo- the combination of the astrometric data with the spectroscopic comparison with that of the secondary or the tertiary com- onestertiary. from the intensive monitoring during the periastron pas- ponents,sphere and making can give the latterlarger barely errors detectable on the actual outside RVs epochs of the With the two new interferometric datapoints, the outer orbit components. sage of the tertiary component allows us to obtain more accurate close to the maxima of separation; minimumis now well masses constrained, than those and reported confirms in the Sana values et al. provided (2013) and by To– determinethe O III 5592 the RVs line for is not the includedthree components, in the UVES we used setting, the inLe Le Bouquin Bouquin et al. et( al.2017 (2017).). The globalThe RV fit curves depends computed on 14 parameters from the restwhich wavelengths prevents provided us from by obtaining Conti et the al. (1977) related and RVs Underhi close toll systemicbecause we velocities keep fixed of the the inner eccentricity system and at di thefferent argument epochs of and the (1995)the forperiastron wavelengths passage; shorter and longer than 5000Å, respec- fromperiastron the RVs for of the the inner tertiary system. are shown Besides in the the orbital left panel parameters, of Fig. 2 tively.– the He I 5876 line is formed further away from the photo- whilstthe combination the best fit of of the the astrometric relative motion data on with the the sky spectroscopic plane of the sphereIn the second and can step give we larger disentangled errors on the the spectra actual RVsand refined of the tertiaryones from around the theintensive inner system monitoring is displayed during in the the periastron right panel pas- of by cross-correlationcomponents. the RVs of each component. This method Fig.2.sage of The the tertiary global orbital component parameters allows for us to the obtain inner more and the accurate outer Towas determine already described the RVs for in Mahythe three et al. components, (2012), and we we used refer the to rest this systemsminimum are masses listed inthan Table those 1. reported in Sana et al.(2013) and wavelengthspaper for any provided additional by details.Conti et This al.(1977 method) and allows Underhill us to(1995 obtain) in LeBy Bouquin combining et al. the(2017 SB3). Theradial RV velocity curvesamplitudes computed from with the the forRVs, wavelengths constituting shorter average and values longer on than all the 5000 line Å, profiles. respectively. sizesystemic and inclination velocities of the the relative inner system orbital at motion different on the epochs sky, itand is InWe the compare second the step, diff weerentsets disentangled of RVs the in Fig.A.1 spectra and and we refined con- possiblefrom the to RVs determine of the tertiary the individual are shown masses in the of left each panel compone of Fig.nt2 byclude cross-correlation to a global agreement. the RVs In of the each following, component. we useThis the method set of andwhilst the the distance best fit to of the the system.relativemotion We use on the the same sky approachplane of the as wasRVs already obtained described by cross-correlation, in Mahy et al. given(2012 that), and they we represe refer tont this av- thattertiary given around by Le the Bouquin inner system et al. is (2017) displayed to estimate in the right the distanc panel ofe papererage for values any onadditional several details. main spectral This method lines. Theallows RVs us areto obtain given andFig.2 the. The individual global orbital masses parameters of the inner forsystem the inner and and the the tertiar outery RVs,with theconstituting journal of average observations values that on all is theavailable line profiles. electronically. componentsystems are (see listed their in Table Equations1. 1, 2 and 3).
Article number,A75, page 3 of7 8 A&A proofs:A&Amanuscript 616, A75 no.(2018) hd150136_le
40 ✻ 2017
20 ✹ 2016
0 2018
] ✷ 1 − 20
−
✠
✁
✟ ✞
40 ✝
− ✆
◆
✦ ✷
60 ☎
− ✦✹
Radial velocities [km s 2012 80
−
✦ ✻ 100 2015 2013 −
2014 ✦
120 ✽