MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1 Ann Petronio Annie's Escapes, Inc. MLM participants are in it for the referral fees and free travel, 2 Stephen Mencik not to sell travel. The Vacation Stop 3 Laura Frazier amen sister!! 4 Loraine Adams Carlson Wagonlit Travel 5 Lynn Dudish, CTC Support your professional travel partner! CWT/Good News Travels, Inc. 6 Monique Peragine TRIPS A PLENTY TRAVEL 7 John Frenaye Suppliers....can you hear me now? Travels With Fred 8 Mindy Gilbert get rid of the Amways of Travel 9 Sean Karcher 10 Kathleen McAndrews Four Seasons Travel 11 Gary Goldstein Pan World Travel 12 Eugene L. Vickers, Sr. Global Travel International 13 Michele Russell 14 Krista Wilson Coleman Travel 15 Enrique Brener KC Travel 16 Barbara Oliver Protect our professions reputation! All Together Now Travel 17 Dean Greenhoe Travel Planet 18 Steve Cousino, CTA 19 Robert VanBogelen I hope there is a stop put to these "so called" travel agents. I get people from "YTB" coming to my office frequently, trying to convince me to join. Personally, I am sick of hearing about 20 Calvin Davis III them,(YTB) Heavenly Escapes Travel 21 Carnita Washington Pink Ribbon Travel 22 Susan Schaefer 23 Jennifer Prymula Please place a value on your true partnerships. Sand & Sun Vacations 24 Kathy Murray Professional Travel Services, Jacksonville FL 25 Karen Johansen Bonanza World Travel 26 Russette Walter Personalized Travel and Tours YTB only cheapens the value of travel agents to potential 27 Mary McGrath clients 28 Lori Power Power Trips

MLMs cheapen the travel industry. I worked hard to earn my certificate, and don't feel MLMs should receive the same 29 Patricia Maxwell benefits as those of us who are truly trained professionals! Galavant Travel 30 Mary Stephan 31 Henry Power Power Trips, Haymarket, VA 32 Rick Ponath Travel By Rick 33 MC Hutchinson Respect the profession EXCEL Travel 34 Ann Ruhman, CTC

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 1 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company As a tour opertor we already do NOT extend commission to 35 Phil Carta any MLM agent. Egypt Magic / New Adventures 36 Cassie Mann CTC I've been in the industry too many yars to have MLM's claim to be agents. If they truly want to be an agent, there's other 37 Suzanne Russell-Parks, CTA ligitimate ways! Lighthouse Travel Agency 38 Jodie 39 Donna Gussow Please stop these imitators Darlington Travel Center 40 L Katz 41 Deb Shilaos Journey of Distinction 42 Sally Watson Rueffer Please consider standing up for a level of professionalism The Travel Store 43 John Felker Go Away Travel/Travel Quest-CWT 44 Richard Bothroyd MLM agents give the entire travel industry a bad name. Carefree Vacations

I have actually gotten announcements from several of my own clients who have joint one of these MLM Agencies. We need professionally trained agents in this business, not those 45 Joyce Andrews who just want cheap travel which does not exist anyway. Principal Travel Company YTB "Agents" are giving the industry a bad name with their lack of professionalism, knowledge and service to clients. Something the serious travel agents work so hard to represent 46 Nina Van Harn in this industry. Ambiance Travel 47 Jeri Bothroyd These people are not travel agents, just maketers Carefree Vacations 48 Debra Shipp 49 Jason Schulz Macy's Travel 50 Launa Allphin All Fun Travel Agreed! I would like to see more vendors sign this petition or 51 Claudia Machell comment! Picture Perfect Vacations 52 Ricki Holliman-Ryan 53 Peter Stilphen Thanks John Coral Sands Travel MLMs are in the business of selling their own business opportunities. They should NOT be in a industry where 54 Annette Easton people rely upon actual service. 55 Tom Walsh I've been in this field since 1971. I AM A BONA FIDE TRAVEL 56 HENRY A. SEIGEL AGENT !! Sigmund Travel Bureau, Inc. 57 Gregg Welpe Order Makers are not Order Takers 58 Sherri Shelton 59 Kathy Scott Kruzn with Kathy 60 Sharon Little 61 Marc White As an agent for 37 yrs, alot of the mlm 'agents' don't even know what they are getting into, lack of education, makes bad 62 Bobbi Hoenigman name for the true professional. allpoints travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 2 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 63 Hayden Gonzales 64 J.J. Lasne 65 Cheryl Frank 66 Shelli Nornes Shelli's Vacation Travel 67 Chiann Hager 68 Richard Gertler 30 Years of travel agency experience 69 Kristi Wren Coral Sands Travel 70 Holly Norris Lets all ban together and get rid of the MLM's 71 Michael J Thibodeaux 72 Bonnie Lee YTB came into our town...my client invited me! Travel Quest/CWT 73 Miguel Rodriguez Mobile Travel 74 Debbie Gioquindo 75 Cheyanne Witte 76 Betty Fisher United we stand, divided we fall! No Pressure Travel

These businesses (not travel agencies) make the entire industry look bad, and they need to be stopped from selling 77 Patricia Bannister memberships in a travel club and calling themselves agents. Bannister Travel 78 Pamela Ashenmacher Ashenmacher Travel 79 SHANNON RADEL Set a standard for travel agents everywhere. RISING STAR TRAVEL 80 Lynn Aldis Vendors need to be aware and put a stop to this. Up In Cumming Travel, Inc. 81 Joanne Connellan 82 Bob DeAgazio 83 Tim Richmond Craig's Travel 84 Craig Dodge  Â

Many come right out and say "No experience necessary" yet they try to call those people agents. I think there should be another name for them such as wanabe an agent or mabe "no 85 Linda Grauer service use at your own risk wanabe an agent" 86 Paula Niemeyer Nexion 87 Tracee Williams 88 Debi White My Travel Consultant 89 DENISE MELLO 90 Dina Krulikowski Cruise Planners 91 Robert Auclair 92 Julie Kolberg Smooth Sailings & Travel There needs to be some sort of industry standards and they 93 Karen Shipman, CTA need to be enforced! Shipman Travel 94 Karen Petralia 95 Loretta Lucky Save our industry now! Travel Discounters 96 Susan Feldstein Cruise Magic Inc

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 3 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company This is true agent bypass plain and simple. And to give these people better commission than true agents who study your products to be able to sell effectively, is a sad sad tail. Please respect us for the professionals we are and stop supporting 97 Helga Leonard these MLMs. A Dream Trip 4 U 98 Paul O'Neil CTC Travel Concepts International 99 Pamela Severance CWT/Travel Quest 100 Brittannia Norward We have the experience and are proven professionals-they are in it to get free benefits. If they happen to sell something, they mess it up and ruin everyone's reputation! Please get rid of CARD MILLS and MLMs but cutting them off. You have the 101 Carole Criddle power. Cruise Planners 102 Jelka Shelton Dream Caribbean Vacations 103 Nikki Taylor 34 yrs of experience Jetaway Travel-Maple Valley Washington 104 Sue Clark Koenig Luxury Cruise & Travel We work hard supporting our suppliers, and we need some 105 Robert Bergman support from them now. I agree - and can't believe the industry want to give them 106 Tommie Imbernino anything. Travel Travel 107 Cora Simpson CTA As a Newbie this past year. I have been workng my BLANK off .learning to be the Best .not fair that a person can get a 108 John Cohen CARD and just REAP the REWARDS Coral Sands Travel 109 Oshana M. Brooks GDS Travel Solutions 110 Tina Beckles 111 todd shanaman Coral Sands Travel 112 Phyllis Wing Lincoln Travel & Cruise MLMs are not confined to US borders. If left unabridged, the adverse effects of MLM travel schemes will eventually be felt throughout the travel industry...world-wide. Thank you for 113 Janie G. Ikegami starting the petition, John. Yutori Wings

I totally agree that these MLM's have got to stop. Many of us have worked for years (29 for me) and have worked in gaining knowledge and experience, client base, and the professionalism that any reputable business should have. Why do these so called agents travel so much? Because they are in it only for the benefits and are not working the business. Many good agents are so busy working and taking care of their clients, they can't take advantage of many of the 114 Nancy Ganz Lindley, CTC benefits.Stop these YTB selling membership individuals. Travel With Me 115 Barbara Peterson Nexus Travel, Minnesota

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 4 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

It's time 'professional travel agents' and 'professional suppliers' to the Industry (who have the interests of agents genuinely at heart) drew the 'line in the sand' and said enough Seawind Group - developing tomorrows new generation of 116 john chilton is enough - it's time for a clean up within the industry!! travel agents 117 Heather Berube Magical Moments Travel 118 David Prymula Sand & Sun Vacations 119 Jeri Burdett Fat Cat Travel 120 Ann McDonnell 121 Courtney Baade 122 Melissa Giles 123 Therese & Mark Vollmer MT Cruises 124 Mary Hornsby Castlerock Tours International 125 Lisa Barlow

126 Lynda Hawkins In this instance, imitation is NOT the sincerest form of flattery! Best Connection Travel, Annapolis, MD 127 Paul Elefante Joystar Real Travel Agents can be a great asset to travel providers. The phony agents lack knowledge and professionalism, and 128 Paul E Cunningham provide no value to travel suppliers. Seaside Park Travel I have been a travel agent since 1975, and have every state mandated license, insurance, and seller of travel requirement. I am tired of having to defend myself to both clients and vendors. We support our travel suppliers and expect them to 129 Debbie Marshall support us. Travel Diva Productions 130 Liliana Calendine 131 Sherrie Fun Just Cruisin' Plus 132 Jonathan Hernandez I agree 100 \%. Things have to be done the right way! Jay's Travel

133 Margaret Kelley I am sick of these card mills that invalidates our profession. Travel Travel 134 Tracy E Salvesen Over 20 years in the business and providing service to my 135 Nancy Frost clients. I work way too hard to take care of my customers to loose them to these companies. They have even solicited me...saying that I can now get all commissions from my air ticket sales. After 30 year in this business, it is really upsetting to have my clients tell me about their "free trips" and 136 Connie Barth how much they are making by doing NOTHING! Vacation Specialists 137 Penny Simpson 138 Kerry Wendell Stange Xpertise Cruise Travel & Vacations, LLC 139 Nancylee Stange Xpertise Cruise Travel & Vacations, LLC

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 5 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company IT does bother me that I can work 50 to 60 hours a day and have my work, studying, certification and all be prositituted by the MLM's. If a person can get higher commissions on their one and only sale, which is their own trip, get client upgrades just because they pay a monthly fee then it is certainly the time to have everyone look at the model of travel. My education and experience alone should be enough vs those get rich quick schemes and those who are in it for only the benefits. Benefits that I work hard to get and can't even use as they are being used by the MLM people who are in it only for 140 Regina Nickels the perks. Cruises, Tours and More 141 Brooke Cerny Majestic Travel 142 Maria Pahl Majestic Travel 143 Craig Pahl 144 Karen Bray It is time to put the brakes on these MLM companies. Cruise & Leisure Travel 145 Shirley Binder Cruises...and more

They call themselves Referring Travel Agents and their clients must book the travel on their site. They should not be able to receive IATAN cards. They have not done any work and most have not visited the places that their clients are booking. The referring agent will make their money from selling the MLM scheme to someone else. They are not doing any travel work 146 Garvin Arnett and therefore should not be able to gon on fam trips. Travel Concepts International 147 Bob Poland Don't Go There-Personal Travel Advisors 148 Ahmed Nabawy Palma Tours 149 Miki Schnackel, ECC Cruise Planners 150 Rita Abry Roarty 151 Mehmet Dervis Tachda Tours You wouldn't go in a store and join a membership and get the same discounts that agents get now would you? Not that we get much in the way of benies any more but I think that is due 152 Donna Zeigfinger to the part of these people Green Earth Travel LLC I am incensed that for $50 per month people are calling 153 Saralynn Turner themselves a travel agent! Easy Divers Travel 154 Anne Takach Anne's Travel 155 Penny YTB's are bottom feeders! Penny's Personal Travel 156 Jennifer Welsh CTA One does not become a travel agent simply by having a 157 Maria Maher website Agora Travel 158 Patricia Saizan 159 Lisa Shepherd Global Travel, OH 160 Dolores Gifford Merry Meeting Travel 161 Yvonne Pond

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 6 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 162 Cathy Jackson Sunsational Vacations 163 Lin Balogh Travel Around The World / Joystar 164 Amy Johnson

These inexperienced so called agents reflect badly on the entire travel industry of educated, experienced, and dedicated 165 Terri Fallon true travel consultants in the eyes of the public and suppliers. First Class Travel 166 Maryann Kane Penny's Personal Travel It is time to kick them to the curb and charge them with fraud! Why don't the vendors stop allowing them? Ask that question 167 lindsay first? They are in on this too! We work too hard for our REAL credentials to have others 168 Mechtild M. Kosin, CTC, DS purchase theirs Travel House of Quinc y 169 Alan Fiermonte down2earth adventures, LLC A REAL Travel Agency serving clients and supporting 170 Maryb Smallwood suppliers since 1966 Citizens Travel 171 Cynthia Erickson Take Me Away Travel, a cwt agency The selling of credentials leads to licensing and mandatory E&O insurance for agents in order to prevent abuse and 172 Ruby L. Degenhard, CTA protect consumers and legitimate businesses! Best Connection Travel, Inc. 173 MIKE TAYLOR Our agecy has been an ARC and IATA appointed agency since it's inception. There USED TO BE STRICT qualifications for this appointment. It will take a concerted effort on the part of IATAN as well as the suppliers to put a halt to card mills. Until BOTH feel it is in THEIR best 174 Marilyn Atkins, ECC interests to take action, this dishonesty will persist. Atkins Cruise and Tours 175 Lissette Hollingsworth 176 Jennifer Sammartino Whirlaway Travel I say you have to pick a niche to be successful. YTB has picked cars and insurance. Mazel Tov I wish them success in their new products. Just leave travel to those of us who know 177 Linda Androlia it. Sunstone Tours & Cruises 178 Daniel D. Abt Beyond Cruises 179 Joe Anello Beyond Cruises 180 Susan B. Holloway Holloway Tours 181 Kyle Bruening 182 Gigi M. Four Seasons Travel 183 jim atkins,ECC Atkins Cruise and Tours 184 Jeanine Flaugher YTB= You Travel Bad; MLM= Much Large Mess Flowers Tavel 185 Marcia Perkins Perkins' Speciality Travel 186 Frani Hahn Francesca & Co. Travel 187 Frank Sutter Universal Travel Services 188 Debra J Burger, CTC Burger Travel Service

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 7 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company It is a PYRAMID SCHEME that will ultimately result in anger 189 Scott Holland toward travel agencies. Coral Sands Travel 190 Nancy Aronson Gullivers Travel American Express 191 Evelyn Spector Luxe Travel Services

It's taken me 30 years to develop the expertise that I have. These MLM "travel agents" are just in it to get discounts. It's a 192 Harriet Warner shame that they cheapen the industry the way they do! Skiers Advisory ytb is a scam - I was approached at a business expo last week and asked if I liked to travel and would I like to be a travel agent. I almost went thru the roof and gave him a piece of my mind. The State of RI makes us hold an agency license, a managers license, an agent license and also requires licenses for outside sales agents and these people come in and try to recruit people who have absolutely no 193 Susan Rezendes knowledge for the perks. The Travel Connection, LLC Cranston, RI 194 ROY RINKER Travel Team LLC 195 Lenita L. Hunt, ACC MLM Travel Agents Cheapen Industry!! Lenita's Travel & Marketing

These are inexperienced individuals with little or no credentials or education, passing themselves as 'agents' of travel. They are an embarrassment to the entire travel industry of highly educated, well-experienced, and dedicated travel specialists. The public's contact with them reflects badly on the rest of us. I am extremely disappointed that suppliers are offering them the same benefits as the rest of us who have invested so much and been so loyal at fatting their 'bottom 196 Kathryn Dawson line.' This is our thanks? I personally don't care if someone wants to spend their time and money on yet another MLM venture. What I do care about is the fact that those same people are calling themselves travel agents and receiving the VERY limited benefits available in our industry. Add to that the fact that they have NO idea about selling travel and it is clear that this 197 Kristin Hunnibell Kennedy, CTA industry has a major problem that must be addressed. Perfect Journeys Travel These people are popping up here in SW Florida like 198 Ruth Kuehn cockroaches an Affiliate of Travel Planners International 199 Martine Arndt Stargazer Travel 200 Kathleen Naftluin 201 John Getz John's Travel and Cruises 202 Kari Hagaman Sheridan Travel 203 Karyn Gueck Sheridan Travel 204 Nichole White Travel Quest/IC 205 Fred Munroe Travel With Fred

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 8 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 206 Julie Blackman, DS, CTC Focus On Travel, Inc. 207 Sharon Stewart Shore Travel 208 Ron Stiles Majestic Vacations Only qualified, professional travel agents should be allowed 209 Lisa Shea such perks. Sand and Sea Getaways 210 Lura T. Conner-Castles 211 Amy Dismukes A & D Travel, LLC 212 Derryl Dismukes A & D Travel, LLC 213 Sara Barakat 214 James Saizan Saizan's Travel, LLC 215 Dena Moonen 216 Strat Arapkiles Royal Coach Travel I have lost 2 clients to YTB and they book only their own personal travel and recruit other people to do the same. They are NOT travel agents, but want only fam trips and discounts on their personal travel. They have no intention of becoming serious travel agents. YTB and similar companies should be blacklisted and denied the benefits offered to legitimate travel 217 Marjorie Miloro agents. Great Escape Travel, Inc. 218 Sue Karger Roadrunner Travel, Inc 219 Becky Carley Coral Sands Travel 220 Edward R Mergenthal, Jr Amazing Destinations Travel & Cruise Company 221 Linda Starkey J.A.B. Travel 222 Judy Warsaw Thanks John! 223 JIM TRANTHAM SOUTH GEORGIA TRAVEL 224 Barbara Bogacki Penny Wise Travel 225 Laura Alto Travel 226 Dave Miller Imperial American Express Travel 227 Carrie Yelland Give us back our legitimacy.... Carlson Wagonlit Travel 228 Troy Metzger Fun Destinations 229 Dianne Herschelman Carlson Wagonlit Travel 230 Dr. Joyce W. Sligh We must be proactive! CARIJAMES Travel Agency 231 Donna James Cruises, Tours & More 232 Tina Juniker 233 Anise Morris, CTA, ACC Travel Works 234 Paula Selke MLM Not Good For Travel Industry Luxury Cruise & Travel 235 Phyllis Ann Iervello Francesca & Co. Travel 236 Debbie OKane Beyond the Horizon Travel 237 Jennifer Vogel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 9 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company I was on an 80 passenger FAM - 50\% were not bonafide agents and theagency running the trip knew it. They were the most demanding (best room, best seats, no travel knowledge - mostly school teachers who thought they had a good deal. Copper Canyon trip about 6 years ago and the worst FAM I 238 marjorie turgel ever took. 239 Bobbie Murphy Bobbie's Travel, Ltd. 240 Christine Correll All About Cruises and Travel 241 Ronda Koska Went to attend a travel function last week, only to find while waiting in line that 70\% of the attendees were ytb types. Decided that, as a 37 year dedicated full time travel agent, I had no reason to remain in this group of neo-agents, and left. Makes me sad to see this damaging encroachment on our 242 Bob Cayer industry. Milford Travel,Milford N.H. 243 Nan Stacy Nonstop Travel 244 Anastasia Walters 245 Michelle Voeller Travel Quest Carlson Wagonlit 246 Valerie Novak Adventures in Paradise 247 Karin G. Hamilton, CTC Adventures in Paradise I would urge the industry suppliers to seriously reconsider supporting these types of businesses. I would also urge ASTA and other corporations who represent travel agents to loudly question the validity of these pyrimad schemes and ask industry suppliers why these "agents" are entitled to agent 248 Steph benefits w/o any questions asked. Carlson Wagonlit -Travel Quest 249 Charles LoPresto   250 Joe Raube Please stop these types now! Dream Come True Vacations 251 Beverly Weigand 252 Louine Kolb Travel Galore - NY 253 john tanzella 254 Craig A. Pahl 255 Rachel Suarez-Banmann Incentive Connection Travel 256 Tamara Renneke This will be the total ruin of our industry! TravelQuest/Fairways Travel 257 Lisa VanSalisbury 258 Mary Ganier Ganier Travel 259 Hannelore Moreno Fuller & Durden Travel Inc 260 Joan H Dann

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 10 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company I urge ASTA, NACTA and other industry associations to finally begin to speak out on our behalf. YTB and others like them are a blight to the industry. When suppliers and industry associations fail to recognize these businesses for what they are it cheapens the industry. Agents work hard for their earned credentials unlike those who have paid a price to gain a website for free perks. It is obscene to see our industry go 261 Christine Whitaker down this path unchecked. Discover Your World Travel I have over 20 years of experience in the corporate travel world. Legitimate travel agents truly love what we do and realize what it takes to help our mutual clients get the most from their travel experience. We, as a concerned travel community, want you to seriously reconsider extending benefits and courtesies to MLM (YTB) types of "travel agents". If you understand MLM and really think about this, these people are simply "using you" the vendor for their own gain. Chances are they won't even ever sell travel, so why in the world would you extend a travel agent discount to someone who claims to be a travel agent? I see no value to our vendors at all by working with these types of organizations. People who are in this business just so they can "travel" are not the types of travel agents most agencies want to hire, so why would you?? Thank you for your time in considering our petition. Help us put a stop to YTB'er's "cheapening our 262 Luanne Lane profession". 263 tammy 264 Beth Caldwell Incentive Connection Travel 265 Karen Dunlap We need to put a stop to this. We work hard to support the 266 Steve Maibach travel industry and they do not!!! 267 andrea nielson Incentive Connection Travel 268 Ruth Hershberger Incentive Connection Travel 269 Sue Clark Shame on suppliers and industry affiliations Times To Remember Travel

As a hard working business owner and one that has survived the myriad of changes in the travel industry, please keep the our industry that of professionals. It's too easy to just "buy a card" and say you're a travel agent rather than actually 270 Cathy Belcher working at something that you know and love. Travel Ventures of Bay County, Inc. 271 Robbie McCandless, MCC 272 Stan Thomas MyGreatTrip.com 273 Phyllis Evenson 274 Chris Lounder I completely agree Cruise Adventure Travel, LLC 275 Carol Flinner

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 11 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 276 Christine Mano keep it honest around the world travel of racine 277 Barbara Stankus 278 Renee Bishop 279 Jeannette Savarese Cruise On Travel 280 Kim Campbell 281 Joanne Burke I agree completely P & J Travel 282 Stephanie Cannon I agree Incentive Connection Travel 283 Krystal Kelley Travel Works in Birmingham, AL 284 Douglas Culver 285 Brian Driesenga Get-Away travel 286 Bill Page Down with MLM's Pinnacle Travel LLC ARC & IATAN should be the first to drop MLM's. Lets get this 287 Nina Page petition over to them. Pinnacle Travel LLC 288 Sheri Kimmel 289 Vincent Nadaskay 290 Kathryn Fry Quality control!!!! Please enforce it! Everyday Travel Agency 291 Sue Tanea 292 Keya Tucker World Travel, Inc. Plymouth Michigan proud to be a "real travel agent" with professional training and 293 Heather Holtzer experience! 294 Polly Foster

295 Mary Hricik International Tours- GalaxSea Cruises & Honeymoons LTD. 296 Binnie Coppersmith Westshore Travelworld 297 Wendy Epstein This is hurting all of the "real" travel agents out there! All Ways Travel, Bethesda, MD Clients will learn about YTB's just as they have learned how 298 KathyC bad the online booking engines are. Without a REAL Travelagent you are on your Own!!! 299 Jackie Counts Exec-U-Travel 300 Susan Gunnell 301 Chris L 302 Laurie Galletta Go Travel 303 Phyllis Shanks 304 Debbie Stewart Tampa Palms Travelworld 305 Sharon Mattson As a vendor, we need trained and experienced travel professionals to represent our product to the traveling public. 306 David Lippiard This is not a hobby. Operation Europe 307 Dawn Salvo Incentive Connection Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 12 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

As a Professional Travel Agent, I take pride in my education, experience, and knowledge of the travel industry! Many of the so called 'referral agents' of these MLM's cannot say the same and I challenge the Suppliers to really take a look at what is going on and do something about it! These MLM's 'agents' are all about selling memberships (and in some cases 308 Penney Rudicil cars or flowers) NOT travel! The Travel Planner 309 Karen Gearhart Kaye Britton Travel 310 Ellen Sisser 311 Joan bank ect., ect. SouthSide Travel 312 Nancy Hartley H3 Travel & Events 313 Connie Nix 314 Carrie King 315 Julie Nimtz 316 AnnaLynne Bogner Travel, Ports & Voyages 317 ALISON FONTECCHIO 318 Tina King They take business away from us! They are Not Travel Agents! 319 Debbie Gonzalez Travelworld 320 Kevin Rudicil 321 Mary Steiner 322 SHERRI BLAND 323 Eileen Kenneally CTC Travelhost Tours & Cruises 324 Eileen Kenneally CTC Travelhost Tours & Cruises 325 ESTER HERZ House of Cruises 326 Robert McLaughlin Stellar Travel Services 327 SUE HERRICK These fly by night operators disgust me! The parent companies enlist people with the enticement of using the service for themselves with no real regard for actually selling 328 Richard H. Smith, Jr travel to customers. Toursource Travel 329 Karen Andrews I agree Thanks for doing this. I am so tired of YTB quoted cruises with 330 Rhonda Link out taxes or port charges. TraveLink 331 Jordan Pattee Travel Quest/CWT 332 Dorothy Sherrow Travelworld 333 SUSAN QUASEBARTH

Wholesalers and suppliers have prostituted themselves with any one who has a dime. Greediness is the active word of the day for them. We need to pull together as travel agents. Used too the suppliers took care of the travel professional that is not 334 Linda Campbell CTA true anymore. Indeed who is pulling for the agents now? Tropical Cabana Travel 335 Sheila Haston Most Fam trips are taking "agents" that are not agents. Newbys Travel Service

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 13 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 336 Elizabeth Krupa Unique Travel of Palm Beach 337 Patti Rossetti about time 338 rosemarie murphy Unique travel of palm beach inc. 339 Bill Cleveland Antietam Travel Service, Inc. 340 Shawna Orman newbys travel 341 Carol Frazier 342 Brenda Wagers 343 J Roddey Miller, CTC This is a very serious problem. Thomas Tours A YTB "agent" actually solicited my 23 year old agency to join his network "under" him to increase my commissions. Then he told me YTB provided him NO training - but he paid his $499.00 and is now a "travel agent". I am very disappointed that this card mill scheme has reimerged. The industry needs 344 Linda Cleveland to put an end to this scheme for good. Not only do the MLM “Travel Agents” cheapen the travel industry, they also take advantage of the travel industry. I see these “agents” at local events all the time. They have no problem telling you why they attend as well. I was told by one MLM Agent recently at a supplier function that they were only there for the free food and to win the door prizes. So I ask the suppliers and vendors… is the really the kind of “travel 345 Jeff Grieder agents” you want for travel partners???!!! ASAP Cruise Vacations 346 Teresa Jeske 347 Shari Sulser 348 Belinda England This is a disgrace to our industry 349 Nicole Backlin DreamWorld Travel 350 Bruce Horner Leave the Travel Industry to the professionals CWT - Virginia Beach Office 351 Karen Salentine AKS Travel I had to clean up a mess made by a YTB agent that my client thought was reliable and she clearly didn't have an idea what 352 Lollie Ellis she was selling. Getaway Tours, Inc. 353 Robin Goris I am thoroughly against the issuing of cards to non professional agents. It serves only to muddy the waters and confuse unknowing customers who think they are using a 354 Jan Hurst professional agent. 355 Susan Bell AAA Oklahoma 356 Marina Leonov Aquamarine Cruises and Tours 357 Lynda Reich Master Travel and Cruises 358 Desiree Hall This is a very important effort. Paradise Vacations 359 PAUL DUBRUILLE BOLACK TOTAL TRAVEL 360 Joyce Fawver Sea the World

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 14 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company I HAVE ATTENED 9 MONTHS OF SCHOOL AND YEARS OF ADDITIONAL TRAINING TO CONTINUE TO SELL TRAVEL 361 DEA HART EVERYDAY AAA TRAVEL 362 Sally Goldwasser full support of petition Unique Travel of Palm Beach 363 Lou Ann Twitty Trips And Ships 364 Isobel Zweifel We work very hard for very little pay in most cases and its just not right that someone can 'buy' their way in! They are ruining our hard earned reputation, because most of these so called agents know absolutely nothing about the products they are 365 Diana Dempsey selling! Gullivers Travel - Fort Worth TX I have worked very hard as have my agents to be credible, knowledgeable sales people in the travel industry. This 366 Martha A Pierce cheapens us all! MAP Travel Co. 367 Kathleen Pickering Pic-A-Place Travel inc 368 Carolyn Norman Gullivers Travel 369 Lisa Foster 370 Joan Salentine AKS Travel 371 Alan Psimas 372 Karen Tucker/Royal Palm Travel Travel Resources 373 Thea J Foley 374 LORRAINE FULLER I WORK HARD TO EARN MY IATAN CARD!! INCENTIVE CONECTION TRAVEL 375 Paula Odom Gullivers Travel 376 Tricia Morrison Travel Ventures 377 Gary Saxton CTC The Travel Place When I first went out on my own, I was "taken in" by one of these companies. BIG MISTAKE. Glad I got away from 378 C'Ana Stanfield them!!! Travel by C'Ana 379 Lamar Miller 380 Joanie Davis I hope we can shut down some of this. PR Travel 381 Sharon Oldham Why reward people for doing nothing? Ticket to Travel Let's keep our certified agents in business. They are the true 382 Kelli Greenhoe experts in travel. 383 Kaye Bergstrom, CTC 384 Robert Ensten American Made Travel Adventures 385 Tyrone Gentry Travels Unlimited 386 MaryLyn Klein 387 Sara Harloff, CTC, ACC 388 Georganna Johnston 389 Leslie Smith These people are attending professional business networking seminars and it is a shame as they are creating interest 390 Lorene Stone among professionals Unique Travel of Palm Beach 391 Nancy M. Walker Sunset Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 15 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company Not surprised. Carnival seems to be taking the lead in the cruise industry, as Delta took the lead in the airline industry, less service, more profit. It's all about "NOT CARING". Follow 392 Philip Foley the money. Sheridan Travel Service 393 Nancy Hyde Bliss Honeymoons.com 394 sandi berns Shame on any supplier who knowingly accommodates these faux travel agents. Shame also on people who are stupid enough to book something with them. The time has come again to stress working with a professional travel agent in the 395 Patricia Klug media. Just Travel 396 Susan Bonesso Rogers Travel Agency ** I think YTB should be banned from the industry,I have had numerous calls from YTB referrel agents trying to get me to come over--I continue to share with them that they do not offer a professional service, and have no valid training to be held accountable--I think they should not be able to get the same benefits that educated travel agents have to keep the 397 Jacquelyn Fisher professional status-- FISHER TRAVEL 398 Charles Keoho

399 Lauren Liebert They should work for their credientials, not just pay for them! Ticket to Travel 400 Michael Matz 30+ Year Agent losing business to 30 Second Agents 401 David Budwash Enchanting Vacations and Travel 402 Shannon Moore AAA Colorado 403 Chuck Brook 404 Connie Brook 405 Ryan Sandlin 406 Debbie Budwash Enchanting Vacations and Travel 407 NEAL DEMBO CWT/TRAVEL DISCOUNTERS 408 Linda M Shipp Travel Counsellors 409 Anthony Gagliano 410 Stephanie Rinehart Any Cruises and Tours This is one step closer to reclaim our Professionalism . I have been one for 32 years !!! Besides being shameful to let anyone claim the title of Travel AGent - I find it very 411 Ildiko Varga DANGEROUS !!! CrissCross Tours and Travel 412 Bruce A Hamrick Northwestern Travel Service Inc 413 Donna Alkarmi Carlson Wagonlit Travel 414 Christi Rush 415 Ken Gagliano Travel Planners International 416 Martha Kelley 417 damon webb Carlson Wagonlit Travel 418 Patsie Vaughan, CTC, acc,D.S Carlson Wagonlit Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 16 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 419 Michael D. McCarthy CTC The Cadillac Travel Group, Inc. 420 Susie Jones Credentials = Integrity. I don't want to lose that. Ticket to Travel 421 Mary McCarley Avanti Travel, Inc. 422 CAROL KOENIG GROUP TREK TRAVEL, LLC 423 Candy Smits 424 karen kleman northwestern travel service 425 Sheryl Stypul 426 Joyce B. Vantrease I agree fully with this statement ! Villa Travel Service, Inc. 427 Carlos Delvalle 428 PamAndrews This is a very serious issue and I am confident that you will find it as damaging to our industry as we do. FAMs and industry discounts were designed to be a training tool so that we may be personally familiar with the products / vendors we support. It is demeaning to serious, hard working consultants that anybody with a few hundred dollars can 'have', for 429 Jae Shavers nothing, what we have 'earned'. Classic World Travel We need to raise the bar (or create one) for travel agent 430 Ken Kimi credentials A Touch Above Travel Services 431 Carolyn Dudgeon 432 Sally Scott Hader 433 Kimberly Oehrlein  Barbsgetaway 434 Candi Deem 435 Darrmita Joyce 436 Kim Hernandez 437 Julia Jones 438 Phillip Powell

439 Harold Hodges I've personally complained to some of these "so called agents" Cruise Crazy Travel Consultants 440 Pauline Courselle 441 Karen Davis 442 JoAnn Thode Imperial Travel Experts 443 Jeanne Coston Non-professionals (pay-to -play)do a disservice to the 444 Joan Small industry and should not be recognized by the suppliers. Complete Travel Arrangements 445 Virginia Barthel Booked By Barthel,LLC 53 Years in travel but absolutely NO respect from suppliers. Agents need to recognize the "problem' is suppliers desperate 446 Ray Wilson, CQC, ACC, DS for ANY bookings they can get. Wilson Travel Service, Newark, Ohio 447 Kerry Haberkern It is sickening what YTB & others like them are doing to the 448 Larry Jordan travel industry 449 Susan Reavis The Travel Planner

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 17 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 450 Mary Kennett Even a somewhat simple certification will weed out those individuals that are in the business only for cheap personal 451 Pamela Ward travel and not to work as a reliable, educated travel agent Paradise Destinations 452 Robin Bryant 453 John Nigro Vineyard Travel 454 Robin Lockard Total Cruise and Travel I was on a Travel Egypt fam trip where 70\% of the agents 455 Joann were "YTB". They were a disgrace to the industry. Great Vacations 456 Maryellen Iobst, CTC 457 Robert Budreau All About Travel 458 Dean Markwardt 459 tammie holleran 460 Renate Finn, CTC 461 Debbie M. Blaske, CTC Suburban Travel/American Express 462 Carla Plaster-Camp Renaissance Travel & Events 463 Carla Plaster-Camp Renaissance Travel & Events

Real Agents Unite against this blasphemy! I have over 30 yrs 464 Greg Palmer in this business and these psuedo businesses hurt us all. Sun City Travel 465 Billie Leas 466 Rose F. Middleton Have been in the business for 45 years. Diana's Travel/Vacation Connection 467 Francine Beifeld 468 Shelby Palmer 469 Shelley Martin-Hansen 470 louise bird 471 Deanna Quinn 472 loyda coulombe 473 Jean Schneider Renaissance Travel & Events 474 Elliott Camp Renaissance Travel & Events 475 Ann Plaster Renaissance Travel & Events Bad News for the Specialist like myself. Would think the vendors would go over backwards to keep the legitmate travel 476 Marcia Pooler agent happy. 477 Yvette Mullins 478 Kimberly S Michaux 479 Gerda Myer World Travel Management 480 Jean Hopkins World Travel Management 481 Rob Schneider  Renaissance Travel 482 Donna Zabel World Travel Management 483 Etha Carruthers Desert Sun Travel 484 Debby Leong Bravo Travel 485 Pamela Horst Pams Path to Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 18 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 486 Jim Thompson Renaissance Travel And Events 487 Bill Horst Pams Path to Travel 488 Cormac Somerville 489 Kelly Kienzlen These wannabes really embarass me in public, and I am 490 FAY SUMMERS, CTC, DS soooo tired of being solicited by them. Arstella's Cruises & Tours 491 E.H. McCuaig Morrison Int'l Travel 492 Jacqueline Deppiesse Just Travel 493 Debbi Espino Corporate Accounts Manager Morrison International Travel 494 Lisa Parascandolo Little World Travel 495 Renee Gerbert 496 Linda Koenig Anywhere Cruise and Travel 497 Kathleen Roth At Leisure Travel 498 Dana Gander CAA Travel 499 Donald E. Oneal Jr. Travelworld 500 Nancy Harmon I'm delighted someone is getting this going! TRAVEL by TRELLIS 501 Sara Volking CTC 502 Elizabeth Lombardo This has to end! Â 503 Darryl Abbott Flite II Travel American Express This company needs to be stopped. You have hard working travel agents that have devoted their lives to this industry, to have a company like this misinform the public and give our 504 Pamela Courtney industry a bad name. PR Travel 505 Sally Killoran In the Travel Industry for 20 years. TravelMasters 506 Adria Oliver TravelMasters 507 Kristy Bedoian TravelMasters 508 Victor Bedoian TravelMasters 509 Colleen Gillette 510 Rhonda McDowell MLM's are a disgrace to the profession A & I Travel I WILL CHECK TO SEE IF THESE "AGENTS" HAVE A VALI D SELLER OF TRAVEL LICENSE WHICH IS A 511 MARY ANN EVANS REQUIREMENT IN CALIF. AND MANY OTHER STATES. Hope mlm will be lost soon in the system. it hurt people and 512 Ivy Istok hurt country 513 Janette Rabin 514 Leta Bennafield Cornucopia World Travel & Events 515 Renata Paterson Ticket to Travel 516 Dawn Sunday I agree they have given us a a bad rap for years 517 Holli Sohler Renaissance Travel & Events 518 Marilyn Ross 519 Loretta Lamberth Round Trip Travels 520 Barbara Frangie

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 19 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

It's time for the vendors and associations to step up and 521 Ross Pagano support those of us who have been supporting them for years. Synergy Cruise and Travel 522 Aletha Ferguson 523 Meloney Kelly This is really hurting REAL Travel Agents The Travel Planner This is bad for hard working travel agents and the total idustry. They lessen the public view of the need and value of a 524 Kenneth Reid professional agent. Cruise Innovations We provide a valuable service to our clients, MLM makes a 525 David Rien mockery of that. Travel Planners, International Met a US Airways ticket agent in YTB. One that's happy to book 600.00 total sales per day. That is not a travel agent! YTB may provide income, but at what cost to the tour 526 David Wood company/cruise line? Wood Travel - 2 full time agents with 2 million in annual sales.

We need to expose these card mills for what they are. Many folks looking for a deal like the baloon morgagues are leaving folks without what they thought they were buying. Cheap 527 Ron Mitchell travel and cheap interest on homes and who wins? Be There Travel 528 Donna Marshall B.C. Travel Company 529 Greg Marshall B.C. Travel Company 530 David E. Smith Owner, Directional Strategies Travel 531 Michael Sachs It's about time! Bits of Paradise 532 Aurora & Mathhew Daly Travel Daly I have had formal training as a Travel Agent and continue to broaden my education and knowledge in this industry. I do not appreciate people posing as something they are not just to 533 LaDonna Lloyd make a quick buck. Custom Designed Tours and Travel 534 Karoline Bolin Get Away Travel 535 Michelle Ariel

We were amazed when we were exhibiting at a bridal show (our bread & butter) and YTB also has a booth to solicit couples to become members and be qualified to get free trip from vendors for their honeymoon. We also have taken note of the fact that several of our former Independent agents, that we "cut" because they did not have any interest in selling just getting free and heavily discounted travel, are now afilliated 536 Sandra Smith with of YTB or similar companies. Directional Strategies 537 Sandra K. Young Thank God that someone is taking a STAND! Funtastic Tours and Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 20 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

We were amazed when we were exhibiting at a bridal show (our bread & butter) and YTB also has a booth to solicit couples to become members and be qualified to get free trip from vendors for their honeymoon. We also have taken note of the fact that several of our former Independent agents, that we "cut" because they did not have any interest in selling just getting free and heavily discounted travel, are now afilliated 538 Sandra Smith with of YTB or similar companies. Directional Strategies 539 Gwethalyn Huff 540 Linda Daily Uniworld Travel In Florida I have to pay for extra licensing with the state....it's time that ALL states require this for travel agency 541 K. L. KING organizations. CRUISE KING, LLC 542 ernest g. morrison

I agree with this proposal by the cruise lines, this should of stopped a long time ago. Its a shame when we the travel agent community attend seminars and find many "so called" travel agents attending them for the freebies, and then there are those of us who are looking for the updates and promotions that are upcoming for the industry. Maybe the cruise lines and Land Operators can make it harder to register for their seminars so they get the proper audience they need. Hope this petition will help us all out and deny Card MIll agents the right to sell travel so we can continue to represent 543 Reina Sachs the industry in an honorable way. Bits Of Paradise 544 Bruce Beattie Foreign Currency Exchange Services 545 John Brawley Premier Travel Service 546 Sophia Kulich, CTC I ask for ban YTB like agents from travel biz 547 shontell nelson vacation escapes 548 Carole Shallenberger 26 years Triple S Travel, Inc 549 Nakia Campbell Travel Escapes by Kia 550 Lisa Allen Bullock's Travel While most of the "Agents" at YTB have no training or knowledge, I have met a couple who appear to be legitimate. I would urge those to choose their associates more carefully 551 Patti Wilkie CTA, ACC and find a genuine host agency Travel Connection 552 Jason Butler 553 jacqueline williams 554 Deena Gainor 555 Daniel Hanes 556 Cindy Nelson Sunscape Travel 557 Arlene Yearn This needs to be stopped American Travel Society

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 21 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 558 Elizabeth Madden I am in support of getting rid of MLM agents Sunnyside Travel 559 cindy Reber

Long range the true, working travel agent is your best marketing tool. You need our hard work in your companies' 560 Miv Hickey behalves. We need and deserve your support. It's a win,win. mivbna Travel 561 Johanna C. Zamora, ECC ClassicTour & Cruise Shoppe Shame on the vendors that would allow these pseudo travel agents to sully the professionalism that we have strived hard 562 Donna Barron to attain. Hip, hip hooray for RCCL! The Cruise 'N Tour Store 563 Craig Daniger Clarion Mortgage 564 Tony Oliver I whole heartedly agree! 565 ODESSA GOODMAN Travel Partners, Inc.

As a full-time home based travel agent--I wish to thank Royal Caribbean and Celebrity for taking this bold stand to support those of us trying to earn our living in this business as 566 Don Akin, ACC opposed to just getting the benefits of the business. Akin Travel Adventures 567 Sandy Elson, MCC 568 Marnie O'Neal 25 year travel industry veteran 569 christine murrey sheridan travel service 570 Ray Ramage 100\% agree Piedmont Travel American Express 571 marlene williams carlson travel exchange

THANK YOU FOR LETTING US TAKE A STAND ON THIS 572 SANDY ZIELINSKI AND KEEPING OUR PRIDE AS A TRUE TRAVEL AGENT GENESIS TRAVEL 573 Evelyn Rodriguez 574 Catherine Andersen Greatly appreciate the support Cruise N Time Travel 575 Deanna Serbenta Travel Creations 576 Mary Lomax, CTC, DS Avanti Travel 577 Lynn Pfister Travel One 578 Karen Archibald Travel Escapes 579 Cheryl Dworman, MCC Multi Destination Specialties 580 Sarah Henschen 581 T Patrick Toal 582 Kelly Roberts 583 Sally J. Martinez Good Job RCCL 584 Terri L Walter Travel One Inc, Highland IL 585 HILARY OLNEY TRIPS AHOY! 586 Mary Wardlow 588 Felecia Armstrong Unique Choice Travel & Tours

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 22 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

I spent time & money to educate myself in the travel business and feel it is unfair for people to come in and try to get the same type of benefits that is offered to travel professionals 589 Dedra Jenkins and there should be some restrictions given to these people EILEEN CAROLE LLC 590 Daniel Castrillo 591 Hayley Whorrall Beach Bum Vacation Inc I strongly agree that it's about time we take this stand. You won't believe the amount of ytb agents who have tried to get me to switch to ytb. When I test them with specific questions about making certain reservations, they have no idea how to even begin. These MLMs water down the business of servicing the consumer as a true, professional, full-service 592 Margaret L King travel agency. Above the Clouds Travel 593 Karen Rehkemper Travel One Highland IL 594 Becky Simone 595 Robert Elking Grandview Travel 596 patty pemberton 597 gary pemberton 598 Cari Lewis Hager 599 victoria boyd 600 Laura Sopko Genesis Travel Company 601 Susan Rottschafer Amen! 602 Lori Williams Creative Travel Center Someone needs to stop the madness. It degrades the value 603 Leslie Kepplinger of a legitimate travel agent Trips Ahoy! 604 Teresa Stewart Stewart Travel Inc 605 Helen Vacca Let get Professional Vacation Bound Travel 606 Teddi Scanlon Vacation Bound 607 BENITA LUBIC CTC Transeair Travel LLC 608 Kathleen DiMeglio 609 Diana Greer 610 Skip Fortier 611 Cyd Scarpella 30+ year Professional Traveltime/SLO I am happy about this decision as well. I too have spent over 14 years trying to increase my knowledge in the travel industry, which benefits both me & my clients. Over these many years, I have built a very good client database & do not 612 Sandra want to lose them to MLM. Sandy's Travel Connections 613 Sandie Black Altair Travel 614 Dave Aldrich-Thorpe Designs Travel Inc 615 Robert Whorrall STOP the NONSENSE This is taking out industry to a LOW level 616 Craig Murray MLM has to be stopped They are not even training their people right

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 23 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

617 Careen McNiel WOW, well it is about time someone did this, THANK YOU Please stop this BS 618 Margo McCullough Cruisegirl 619 David L Amason, ACC Ideal Travel Agency & Ideal Travel for Cruises 620 Robin Neil Are We There Yet Travel 621 gwynn loomstein altair travel 622 brenda cole 623 Linda Shema 624 paula dozier sr Strongly Agree Suppliers should take note, and stop the abuses by these 625 lynn kupchik pseudo agents 626 dennis kupchik return to professionalism in the industry 627 kate hadfield 628 Moi Youngblood 629 Pauline Davis DTS Midway Vacations 630 Maureen Angles 631 Patricia Mitchell 632 Pamela Saddler DTS Midway Vacations 633 Jessie Burbank 634 Tomica May DTS Midway Vacations 635 Kim Wilson Hollowbrook Travel 636 Desny Bradshaw 637 Lisa M. Saunders DTS Midway Vacations 638 Evelyn Spencer How low can one go? Chadds Ford Travel 639 Rebecca Martin, CTC, CTIE A & I Travel Service, Inc. Only true professionals should be allowed to represent our 640 Betty Sterling industry Altair Travel & Cruise 641 Yvonne Coates DTS Midway Vacations 642 Lourdes Bada 643 susie johnson 644 Stephen M. Nagel Uniglobe VIP Travel 645 Vicki Rush A & I Travel Service 646 KELLEY FIFE 647 Shirley Lin Great Southern Global Travel 648 Francie Carnell 649 Kimberly Baer Great Southern Travel 650 Patricia Teague A & I Travel Service 651 Meghan Guhman 652 Deanna Sutherland-Tracey CDT Travel Inc 653 gail hindman please help 654 Patricia Telano 655 Richard Gordon Let's Go Travel, Inc.

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 24 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company Calypso Vacations "an afflitale of Travel Planners 656 Bridget Sackett International" 657 Harvey McGarry 658 Susan Bohrer Suppliers: Listen up! MLMs are bad for us & the traveling 659 Rachael Altemose public. Tucker's Travel Shoppe 660 Kenny Mooney 661 Lilly Patitucci 662 Jeanette Great Southern Travel 663 Linda Van Buren Carlson Wagonlit/Your Travel Center 664 Maryjo Slabaugh Hudson Reserve Travel 665 jerry thorne 666 Cynthia Judd 667 eileen starkey sheridan travel denver co 668 Victoria Shomshor AAA Travel 669 Sarah Widzinski Bob Neugebauer Travel 670 Trudi Chesney Bob Neugebauer Travel 671 Bob Neugebauer Bob Neugebauer Travel I think these practices need to stop, we work too hard for what 672 Frances Driscoll, CTC we get legitimately. Your Travel Center 673 Christine Fiorelli Fairytale Dreams & Destinations Inc. 674 Lynn Price Cruise With Us Now 675 Lisa Bright Great Southern Tiger Travel 676 PAULA MACLELLAN Cruise With Us Now

While reading the petition a YTB rep. came to my office wanted me to join their org. took me one second to say no 677 shirley redd thanks. I have over 30 years in the travel ind.Get rid of them . 678 Jacintha Perera Island Getaways 679 Sharon Ladd Dolphin Travel 680 Donna Stoop stop them now!! Jade Travel Services 681 Ann Marie Monroe Beach Bum Vacation 682 Helen Elston 683 ERNEST M KRAUS 684 Priscilla Sharpless 685 Bonnie Baskin Universal Travel/American Express 686 Christine Meny Your Travel Source 687 Rich Gudknecht 688 Karen Griffith Exotic Travel Emporium 689 Phillip W. Hruska Genesis Travel Co. I have had clients contact me to join them at YTB - I told them 690 karen bang they are NUT!!! Oviously they do not know the Travel Agency Business!

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 25 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company I have been in this business for 37 years, and have never seen anything like what YTB has been doing. I am so proud of RCCL, and do sincerely hope all other suppliers will follow 691 PAULA EATON their much appreciated stand. Paula's World of Travel 692 judy nurre 693 rosann corpolongo [email protected] Thank you RCI! The MLMs need to go for the Travel Industry's sake! We have studied and worked to supply the 694 Carol Hall best service for the traveling public. Accents On Cruises & Honeymoon Dreams I have been an outside agent for 15 years and have seen much discussion regarding the MLM - Card Mills or whatever you wish to call them. They are a disgrace to the industry and no supplier should do business with them. I have worked full time and received my IATA card the first year after I started. Credibility in this industry is difficult enough to maintain with out providing credentials to those who only see it as an opportunity to travel. Frankly There is a lot that needs to be cleaned up in this industry and shutting down the MLMs is a 695 Judy Cilla start. Journeys Unlimited 696 Sheryl Saul Chaparral Travel I congratulation RCCL and any other suppliers and vendors who will take a stand against these "so called" travel companies and agents. We are sending a letter signed by all of the agents in our office to all suppliers such as Carnival who will deal with these phony agents.We are going to start 697 Linda Scott supporting only the vendors who support us. Jetway WorldTravel 699 Edna Gjertson Will the real travel agent please stand up? CCN Inc. 700 John C Foulstone IC 703 Laura R. Sangster MLM has no place in the travel industry. Caribbean Journey 704 Nkechi Osei Harmony Travel

As President of SSTP, an organization comprised of more than 140 travel professionals, I applaud RCCL for stepping up and taking a stand to no longer do business with card mills and their associates. We at SSTP have been trying for more than a year to get vendors as well as seminar organizers to put a stop to this influx of 'travel agent wannabes'. It's shameful the way these card-mill associates 'storm' seminars, swooping up food, giveaways and whatever else they can grab. SSTP will be drafting a petition as well, signed by its members, and calling for vendors to cease doing business with card mill companies and their affiliates. We must stand together and our mesage to the vendors must be strong; no Jetway World Travel, President, South Suburban Travel 705 Linda Sadlowski, more card mills. Professionals 706 Joel Mills

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 26 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 707 Nicolle Hahn Bravo Ms Bauer / RCCL! Francesca & Co. Travel

It's about time and I applaud Royal Caribbean!! I do want to make note that I went onto one of the websites of a YTB agent and as of today, Oct. 12, 2007, Royal Caribbean cruises still come up to select from and purchase a cruise. Also, land based tours operators: Apple Vacations, Travel Impressions and Rockwell Tours make up their suppliers list.. My suggestion would be to support and book through those tour 708 Jody Barbato operators that do not support YTB and the like. My Honeymoon Specialist My first "host agency" was a scam MLM company in disguise. Didn't take me long to get out of there! I can't believe any 709 Kelly Rivera legitimate supplier works with these guys. Always The Best Travel IT'S A SHAME AND EXPENSE THAT THESE PEOPLE SHOW UP TO ALL THE FUNCTIONS AND COST THE SPONSOROS MILLIONS OF DOLLARS TO FEED THEM 710 JOANN AUSTIN FOR NOTHING. MAKES US ALL LOOK BAD. YTB has not increased travel sells. Wholesalers & Associations that have agreements with such companies should be ashamed of themselves and frankly has me questioning the intergrity of such wholesalers and 711 Heather Alvarez associations. Enchanted Journeys 712 Paul Moran 713 Pam Perry Parsons Public Relations 714 ted f. friedli I have seen too many good people get hurt ... excel travel 715 joanna friedli bravo Royal Caribbean excel travel 716 Joseph Goodman 717 Nicole Carlson 718 Todd Williams Vacations Unlimited 719 Vickie Toalson 720 Kimberly Crocco Excel Travel,Long Branch,NJ Our valued clients as well as professional vacation specialists have earned the right to have MLM and 'Card Mill' entities barred from booking travel with legitimate suppliers. Suppliers: take a stand as RCI has done; rid our industry of leeches and 721 Syb Verkleir promote professionalism! GTM Travel Group 722 Kelley Sexton Magic Carpet Travel 723 Dale Stubbart Yellow Bear Journeys 724 Eileen Sellers Encore Travel Inc 725 Myles Merling Excel Travel 726 Margie Jordan ASAP Travel 727 Don S. Overend, M.D., CTC The Travel Group 728 Charles Mika 729 Carolyn Smith Cruise-N-Sand Travel, LLC

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 27 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 730 Lura Conner-Castles

This pyramid scam by YTB and their "Referral Travel Agent" program is an embarassment to the industry. The RTA's represent themselves as true agents at all local events, and their presence at ASTA's "The Trade Show" in their bright green shirts that read "Ask Me How You Can Travel For Free!" and trying to not only recruit travel agents but also the suppliers at their tables and during presentations to purchase YTB websites is a disgrace. Organizations and Suppliers need to stand firm and rid the industry of this type of cancer to 731 Pattie Mitchell the travel industry ... say no to MLM!!! 732 Renee Dream Come True Vacations 733 Daniel M Giordano Seabreeze Cruise & Travel 734 marv weber YTB are an embarrassment on FAM trips 735 Trini Corchado Trini Travel 736 Erik van Voorhees SeaMaster Cruises 737 Barb Cerbie Dugan's Travels 738 Linda Stein This is a shame! Regulate this now. Zosimos Botanicals LLC 739 Kathryn Dream Come True Vacations 740 Mrs D. H. Simmons 741 Darlene Sheppard Paradise Travel 742 Dee Petrantis Excel Travel 743 Jack L. Weber ...and ASTA is a turncoat....I'm not going to renew my 744 Pat Story membership. Gwinnett Travel 746 Marilyn Miller 747 clyde washington Support your professional agents/agencies, do not sell to 748 Kimberly Banks MLM or card mills! Gwinnett Travel 749 Marie Jernigan Please stop the piracy of our occupation/industry. Independent Agent, Nexion, Inc. 750 Todd Russell 751 betty s. lazarus Travel With Betty 752 Michelle Duchatellier Excel Travel, Inc 753 Sharon Oberritter Oberritter Travel 754 Patti Kurtz Excel Travel 755 CHRISTINE TOLFA GORGE TRAVEL INC this is ridiculous,and is only going to make the whole entire 756 Ricky Christian travel industry expendable. 757 Sandi McConnell Get rid of MTM & YTB! Travel Professionals Int'l 758 Jack Perkins 759 Candy Burnaine Travel Planners 760 Bruce Hamrick Northwestern Travel Svc Inc 761 mary jane vanderlee good for you!!!!!!!!! excel travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 28 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company I live in a small town and am tired of these MLM agents who are uneducated in selling travel ruin the professional travel 762 Christina Ernst agents name VIP Alpine Tours 763 Donna Di Biase 764 John Cosco AAA Travel 765 Tanya Rampulla VIP Alpine Tours 766 Lisa Racz I didnt invest 30 years in this industry to have it cheapened by 767 Stephanie Petros the cardmills!!! Inglewood Travel,Crofton MD 768 Rose Alston Rose Alston Travel 769 Lisa D Philpott 770 Nancy Riordan Travelplex/American Express 771 C Denise Miller 772 Cecily Macdonald Nautical Adventures 773 Jennifer Koeppen 774 Rhonda Robinson Indigo Journeys, LLC 775 LaTrelle Blige Enchanted Journeys 776 Sue Rudolph Absolutely Amazing Travel 777 JANNESE JONES I'm ready for the industry to support licensing of professional agents. I want credentials that will mean something to the 778 Debbi Calabrese general public. Anyone else??? Embassy Travel, Inc We cannot let this happen, they are given a bad name to all 779 Gabriele Suhr us professionals 780 Jake Haupert 781 Jan Sutton Gwinnett Travel 782 Catharina Apodacc 783 mary brundage TRAVELOCITY

If any issue was important to travel agents right now, this must top the list. Many agents for a long time have been resisting any kind of travel agent licensing employing standards we generate ourselves. What we get is ridiculous bonding requirements. Anyone even with NO agent credentials can put up a few dollars to meet that requirement, and it still does not meet standards of professionalism. This MLM practice that all The Hemispheres, and Hemispheres SANDA Publications. 784 Douglas Shachnow CTC CTIE MCC agents should get together NOW to nip in the bud. Boca Raton FL The MLM and referral business models are not good for the industry or the would be client who believes they are dealing with a trained, knowledgable and professional agent. The travel industry must start regulating iteslf before goverment 785 Tony Gagliano Jr does it for us; this is an excellent first step. Travel Planners International 786 Kristina Baker Excel Travel 787 Angie Simpson Complete Travel Service

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 29 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company I am a professional agent with over 20 years experience. I am 788 Lyn Zan lunghi in support of banning MLM agents. Anywhere Travel IT'S TIME TO GET RID OF THESE LEECHES - I WORK HARD FOR MY CREDENTIALS - THESE SHOULD NOT 789 LINDA HERRON JUST BE "BOUGHT" TEMPO TRAVEL

I know this is a second entry, but I noticed one important item from Scott Holland (#189). MLMs are the things that make the public dislike agents in general, even the qualified ones. This is the truth. I also see others commenting "stop this practice". Well, the truth is that no one can stop this practice but us. The suppliers are interested in making money, and you can't blame them for selling to whoever comes to them with a sale. If we're going to put an end to MLMs, we have to take matters into our own hands, and establish the standards that make an agent a "professional" and make these standards known to the general public. To rephrase a line from Karl Marx: Travel agents of the world Unite! We've got nothing to lose but the MLMs!. And that wouldn't be much of a loss; it would be a 790 Douglas Shachnow CTC CTIE MCC DSs major gain. The Hemispheres, and Hemispheres SANDA Publications I've been in the industry too many yars to have MLM's claim to be agents. If they truly want to be an agent let them take the time to learn the business and actualy offer a service rather 791 Ray Pierce than take a benefit. Â 792 Linda S Smith stop the fraud CVC Centering Vacations and Cruises 793 Normus_Johnson 794 Rosie Holliday Holliday Adventures 795 Hely Merle Benner Insulting to professional travel agents. 796 Nancy Heck, CTC 797 Sally McCann Travel Services, Inc. 798 Marion Huiberts 799 Anne Tuthill 800 Stevie Ryer Your Travel Source 801 Sabrina Miller We stand united as a profession! CWT/Travel Discounters 802 Janice Katsaounis Lincoln Travel & Cruises, Inc. 26 years of professionalism don't let the MLM's cheapen our 803 Debra Overing industry Classic Travel, Woodbridge VA The suppliers know who the professionals are, don't let the 804 Steven Overing MLM's hurt our solid relationships! Classic Travel, Woodbridge, VA 805 Doreen Boisvert Vacation Bound 806 Richard H. Weinberg Stop this practice! 807 Susan Janneck 808 Sherrie Goodman Goodman And Associates, Inc. 809 Russ Dunlap International Tours & Cruises

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 30 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 810 Elsa Atayan 811 Pamela Turcotte Four Seasons Travel Yuba City Ca 812 Crystal Williams Four Seasons Travel Yuba City Ca 813 Christina Dzingala 814 Terri Henderson Geneva Travel & Cruise 815 Diana Howsden Diana Howsden Travel YTB is speading like wildfire in our town, and many people are going to be badly burned...they recruit anyone, some people with no hope of booking anyone, it is sad. We have even been approached on our office to sign on to this good deal...we are a reputible businss for over 10 years, and what is happening to some of our former and current clients makes us ill....we will not push business to companies that do business witn 816 SANDRA BRAZEAL mlm's such as YTB B C CRUISES & TOURS 817 Carol Walker Spanning The Globe Travel 818 Betsy LaVier Travelmax, Inc 819 Karen Griffo Travel Store Inc 820 Alessio Barberi 821 Lynda Wojt 822 Suzanne Alexander Let's stamp out the phoney travel agents!! Concierge Travel, President/Owner 823 Vickie Baehner Travel Store, Inc. 824 Rebecca Hernandez Cruises, Tours and More 825 Yvette Cook 826 Daniel Minter DS CTC 827 Neal Miller NEAL MILLER TRAVEL COMPANY 828 Karen Gindroz We need to keep the travel industry "professional" President, Gindroz & Co. Inc. (European tour operator) 829 Robin Gindroz and Company 830 Claudia Young-Hill The Travel Industry Association of GA salutes this petition American Express Travel MLM is a scourge to our industry, our customers and professional agents. Its about making the trade better, and we all have to stick together with our good hosts, suppliers and our consortia. If we all band together against this MLM 831 Lawrence A. Martino SR business model, we all will win. MARTINO TRAVEL I had to go to Travel School for formal training and have invested many hours into research and making sure my Clients best intrests are ment! And I do not feel these MLM 832 Leslie Darga Agents can give the same quality of service!!! Universal Travel 833 Jill Frailey 834 Mary Germano 835 Kim Smith Enchanted Journeys I was also approached by someone to join this MLM group--I 836 jennifer depew knew right away what it was. Enchanted Journeys 837 Vicki Wood Pier 1 Travel 838 Lisa Thompson/LT Travel dont cheapen the buisness

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 31 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 839 John Kolberg 840 John Stacy It's Your Trip! Travel & Tours 841 Kate Schweiger 842 diane habell-jower 843 Laurie Hargrove MCC 844 Kevin La Van Village Cruise and Travel 845 Barry Fisher 847 richard sacco mcc 848 Iris M Rivera Cruise Planners/International Conferences 849 Janet Boyce Travel One, Highland, IL

I have worked hard to further my education and build a business only to have this type of program infiltrate my area and confuse people. I often call calls from YTB's clients who are lost and without real guidance. I try to be helpful when possible, but I don't think it is fair that I've invested years in my business and now everyone can have the designation of a 850 Kristin Webb-Walker "travel agent," with no training or requirements. 851 Tina Kibodeaux K&T Travel

My wife made a comment in a travel trade magazine article on cruise line air commissions. She received 28 "opportunity" letters promising her HUGE commissions on air bookings - ALL from YTB members. We investigated each one to see where they were from. Now, we're afraid to allow one of us to be quoted in a trade magazine again for fear of having these ruthless MLM'ers beating on our door and flooding our inboxes. When we asked them specific questions just to test them on their knowledge, not a one could answer but several 852 Joe Walker promised to "get back to you on that." Enough said. 853 Gene Webb Ships 'n Sand Travel 854 Kathi Webb Ships 'n Sand Travel 855 Patricia Mortensen Breakaway Travel & Tours, LLC 856 Laura Smith-Thompson The Travel Center 857 Myisha Balke Vacation Memories Travel I have had multiple clients discontinue booking and actually had the nerves to give me a card stating they are now travel agents after signing up with the MLM Travel Companies. After over sixteen years in the industry and countless hours to attain my credentials, I feel it is wrong and should be stopped 858 Sharon Harrison immediately. American Express

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 32 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company MLM's cheapen our entire industy. They cause great harm to the reputation of professional travel agents, as well as create ill will between the professional agents and their suppliers who 859 Susan Sammons, TSI, DS, MCC allow the MLM's to flourish. Accent On Travel 860 Walter Ward Jacquin Travel 861 Al Ferguson Vendors need to follow RCI's lead! Legendary Journeys 862 Rhonda Crist South of the Border Vacations 863 Diane Clifford A & M Travel, Inc. Travel Professionals need to remain professionals. MLMs confuse our consumers, and create mistrust and 864 Michelle Mangio, DS, LS misinformation about travel agents. Magical Escapes Vacations 865 cindy campbell I totally agree - this needs to stop! We are true professionals, and we cannot allow our experience and training to be 866 Mechtild (Mecki) Kosin, CTC, DS cheapened by wanna-bees! Travel House of Quincy 867 Liz Burch Miller Travel Services 868 Sallie Holt I don't believe it is fair for these companies to misrepresent 869 Marline King-Carrillo the travel industry Option 1 Travels 870 Kathy Gvildys 871 Traviaun Golden 872 David Busskohl Allied Tour & Travel 873 Lynda Maxwell, CTC Destinations, Incorporated 874 Nancy Psimas-Shoshan 875 Tim Krenzien Paul Klein Travel 876 Elizabeth M Psimas Travel Designers Inc 877 Donna Dykstra CTC, MCC Sol Provider Travel Company, Inc. They are now working bridal shows to sign people up. They 878 Mary Jane Leininger offer a "free honeymoon" as a prize to get names. Gold Key Travel We firmly believe Card Mill travel priveleges offered by 879 Greg Guiteras Suppliers should be abolished ! Lorraine Travel, LLC 880 Byron Alvarez IATA, ASTA, CLIA accredited Enchanted Journeys 881 Dixie Fitzpatrick I feel travel agents need to be certified. Escape Travel 882 JP Alvarez IATA, CLIA, ASTA accredited Enchanted Journeys 883 Jack Klauss Windjammer Villa Rentals 884 PC Frailey CLIA, IATA, ASTA accredited Enchanted Journeys 885 Raelle Frailey IATA, CLIA, ASTA accredited Enchanted Journeys 886 Donna Klein, CTC Home Base affiliate Travel Planners International 887 Deborah Lane Tempo Travel 888 Sabrina Schafer Travel House of Quincy 889 Lindsay Monell 890 Robin Zell, CTA Just keeping it real Just Girl Trips 891 Lynn Yancey

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 33 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 892 CHARLOTTE POINTER 893 Sue Collado 894 PATRICIA GRIMES GRIMES TRAVEL 895 Pam Watts Magnolia Travel 896 Tracy Mueller 897 Carl Henderson Travel Professionals International 898 Deborah Schwan Maxxam Travel it is time to stop rewarding people who are not activically working in the industry- it hurts us all- let's look at joystar, 899 Norma Akins global and tpi next- who needs 16,100 agents 900 Julie Buchanan WorldClass Travel Network this action can only help the travel industry and the people 901 Stephen DePotter who travel Cruise Planners of Spring Hill, Fl 902 Peggy Slider Travel Emporium 903 Cathy Laubaugh Cruiseahoy.com - Munroe Falls Travel 904 Gary Ellis ADVENTURE TRAVEL 905 Kyle 906 Robin Miller Pieper TravelPlex American Express 907 Cathy Cerutti The Travel House of Quincy Please support this petition. These multi level marketing programs amount to little more than self sales, and it was my understanding that these types of programs are illegal in many 908 Kathy Smith States. All Purpose Travel 909 Diane Ferro 910 CLAY ALVERNAZ ANCLA TRAVEL SOLUTIONS 911 Ellen Wagner Let's keep this a profession!

I have been in the travel agency business for over 30 years, and until the last 10, I have never seen our industry and our knowledge so decimated by the so called card mill travel agents. They are like locust and cheapen our profession. The majority know less about travel and could care less about the profession. They are in it to travel more cheaply, show up at trade shows trying to get more people to join, and further confuse the general public who still does not seem to know the benefits of using a REAL travel consultant Unfortunately I have had calls from clients who have used a card mill agent, a coworker, a neighbor, a friend of a friend, a relative, some one in their social club or church, the list goes on. In many cases the experience was was disappointing and now they want full proof from me that I am a long standing agent. Thanks to 912 Beth Miller Augerinos, CTC, CEO these "fake" agents, our whole industry has suffered. Pefect Honeymoons 913 Fran Genthert I agree, they make confusion and disappointment 914 Frank King CTC Help us maintain Professionalism Kings House of Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 34 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 915 Frederick Wood MA, MS 25 years selling millions in travel Adieu Travel Cruises & Tours 916 Mary Ellen Cook 917 Joyce Stephens 918 Cathy Hoffman, MCC Cruise Planners 919 Kaelin Rybak, CTC, MCC Professionalism in our industry is imperative The Travel Authority - Louisville, KY

I am also in the real estate business and on October 16, the Corporate Broker of my real estate company, was promoting YTB as another source of income for the slow market in real estate. One of the Realtors of my office handed me her YTB card and asked me to sign up, as it was a great deal for saving money to travel. I told her I was already in the travel business - and that it was frowned upon in the travel industry for this type of business (MLM). She didn't of course care. She also said after asking her how she handles her bookings, that once she books a trip - her customer has to deal directly with the company she books with if there are any problems in wanting to change or cancel their bookings. It was very upsetting to me to see our Corporate Broker promoting YTB. So I have not wanted to be around the hype of this office. Its very upsetting to hear other Realtors talk about this program. I have since been asked through other Real Estate 920 Sandra Boring Companies to join YTB as well. I'm for stopping this!! YOUnique Travel 921 Jonathan Spinosi I strongly support this petition Jonathan's Travel Inc. We must all work together for the integrity of this industry and stop allowing a FEW to dismantle what we've all worked to 922 Debbie Taylor build. World Travel We need this petition. From a professional celebrating his 923 James E Masson PhD CTC 60th year as a counselor and educator. I have worked hard for 22yrs and do not appreciate the 924 Sharon Smith Nolen recognition of someone who buys their credentials. Full Service Travel of Bedford 925 Fred Morey Maintain Professionalism - say NO to MLM organizations! New Horizons Travel 926 Dollye Stark ARC and IATAN since 1982 IT Travel Service dba Apple-IT Travel & Cruise 927 Dennis Fenton Your Travel Connection 928 Dale Torgrimson 929 Judith A Rawls Great Escapes Travel, Audubon NJ 930 Linda Coan Thank You Global Travel 931 Clare Williams support this 1000\% Traveler's Fare Inc 932 Generose Hetzel Above and Beyond Travel, Inc. 933 Kathy Liccardo Liccardo Travel 934 Martha Oneal Travel Professionalism should not be for sale by MLMs! Travelworld MLM agents are a disaster waiting to happen when it comes 935 Mary Caldwell to customer service , they are clueless. Caldwell Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 35 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 936 Anneke Wagner 937 Cindy Brunotte I have invested 26 years in professionalism! Captains Travel Service, Inc. 938 Bill Forlenza Full Service Travel Agency since 1982 Rainbow Travel 939 Liza Leister 940 Claudette Ostrander Join RCI and do The Right Thing! Town & Country Travel - Sacramento, CA 941 Marilyn Urban This should have been stopped years ago 942 Deb Ruis Traveler's Fare, Inc. 943 Jill Burge 944 John Cline Hickory Travel & Tours 945 Erik Paulson CWT/Paulson Travel Service 946 Eileen Gombos Please sign my name to petition Travelhost 947 Debbie Schwab Above and Beyond Travel 948 Judith Ann Stiles, CTC don't cheapen my vocation!! 949 Jenifer Klee Above And Beyond Travel Are these MLMs really the type people you want too deal 950 Philip Banks with? Legacy Travel - Plano Tx 951 Patty Jefferis WhirlAway Travel 952 Robin C Smith Caladesi Travel 953 Morris S. Jordan AAA Colorado 954 Suzi Berry 955 Lynne Adams Akins Travel, Inc. 956 Richard Adams Akins Travel, Inc. I had a client tell me he signed up and now has an "aorta" card so he could get discounts like I do. This is wrong and we 957 diane hoffman need to stop this degrading of our industry Hoffman Travel 958 Robert M. Adams, M. D. Akins Travel, Inc. I will only book suppliers that do not support MLM 959 Russell Schweiger organizations. Travel R Us, LP 960 Miguel Martinez American Travel Club 961 Katie Levent Elite Travel 962 Kay Skordilis 963 carol hotto 964 Georgette Lake My Special Events

I had a customer who recently joined YTB, and he admitted to me that he joined this organization mainly to receive discounts on travel for his business. He also said he was primarily interested in referring his contacts to join YTB so that he could earn a $1000,00 bonus for his referrals. He also said he is encouraging his contacts to send referrals to YTB so the also could make a $1000.00 bonus. There is absolutly very little 965 Rosemary Schweiger interest in selling travel products. Travel RUs 966 Frank White

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 36 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 967 Sheila B Hyman, ctc TANFORAN tRAVEL 968 Kim Norwood we work hard to give our clients top notch service. Kym's Travel and Tour Company 969 Judith A. Malmgren Minnesota Travel Connections, Inc. 970 Catherine Banks Legacy Travel I strongly support this petition. Only true and real agent should 971 Naim Alabed be given travel discounts. Travel at Caughlin Ranch 972 Karen Thomas 973 David Holt 974 Judy Walters I am more than happy to sign this petition. Hoffman Travel

975 Hilda Morrison It is time to band together as a team to save our profession. Travel Shoppe Fresno 976 mike bennett adventure travel 977 J. Douglas Risser, CTIE, MCC Menno Travel Service/American Express 978 Kristen Gray Thank you for taking the iniative! Let's hope it works! 979 Barbara Ovittore Scully Travel of HP 980 Cheri Verrastro keep the industry professional Travel Shope 981 Ellen Tetu

Let "Real Agents" take care of clients. Not car salemen..They 982 Louis F. Ovittore Jr. are not real agents! Bravo to RCCL & Marriot Scully Travel of HP 983 Connie Begly Classic Travel 984 Dortha Vela All About Travel 985 Susan Hull HMS Consulting 986 Claire MacDonald They definitely hurt the legitimate travel agencies. A Destination Travel 987 Larry Buxton 988 Frank Fish Stop the Card Mills Travel Gallery, Inc. 989 Kristi Jefcoat Magnolia Travel, Hattiesburg, MS 990 Paige Tucker A Destination Travel / Altour 991 Kathy Alter 992 Wayne W Smith MLM POOR SERVICE 993 Angela Hendricks, CTA Bentley Hedges Travel 994 Halina Haussmann A traditional agent is the key to the cruise industry's integrity 995 Ron Dello Russo and success Cruise Planners of Aventura 996 Mine Seckler TOUR & TRAVEL 997 April Windmann Let's Unite - I've been in this business since 1974 and it's time 998 Michael Hennes we stand up and become professionals AskAboutTravel.com A traditional and/or Professional travel agent have all the tools to sell the cruise industry. Profesionalism, Integrity, Product Knowledge, the backing of CLIA and all it takes to give 999 Linda (aka) Bunny Osborn Personal Service cruises123@atl;anticbb.net 1000 Sophia DeSherlia Travel One, Highland, IL

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 37 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1001 Nancy Bjerstedt TRAVEL ON PARK 1002 monica de la cruz nick lugo travel 1003 victor joubran quality travel services 1004 Stephanie Phillips About time Steph's Travel

MLM do not offer poor service, they offer NO service....heaven help the traveler with a booking...they even admit not all their 1005 LORI ZORBO phone center people are agents...-give me a break! This needs to end, the vendors need to stop selling to these 1006 CHERYL SCHURR people! B C Cruises & Tours 1007 Janet Evans 1008 DONNA JOHNSON RED BIRD TRAVEL 1009 Everett Munro 1010 Dolores Strait Global Express Travel 1011 Jay Getman 66th STREET TRAVEL 1012 JoEllen Shatz 1013 Barbara A Rothman ( Conell) Manager with over 30 years experieince Burkhalter Travel 1014 Kathy Miller travel agent since 1978 former agency owner 1015 Michelle Hamilton Majestic Travel Inc. 1016 GLORIA GOODWIN GI-GI TRAVEL AGENCY 1017 Deanna Senna I am a professional agent with 20 years in the business. Smith World Travel 1018 Elaine Goodman Its about time we take action Interanatioanl Tours 1019 Gwendy Hays Redbird Travel Plus 1020 Wendy Goodman 1021 Christina Carroll, CTA Thank you for this opportunity! Travel Marketing Consultants, LLC 1022 Joyce Carta Egypt Magic 1023 Sheryl Kemp Red Bird Travel Plus People should not be allowed to BUY a well-earned, 1024 Ali Schofield professional title. Lincoln Travel and Cruise 1025 Cheryl Cherubini I strongly support this petition 1026 Cheryl Reese 1027 Karen Dalrymple

I have spent years learning the travel business, And have 1028 Barbara Patterson educated myself in being a professional agent and agency. All Around Travel Inc. 16 years 1029 Sandra May Bullock's Travel 1030 Luis Hernandez Professionalism and knowledge is key to maintain our credibility as travel consultants, suppliers should know that 1031 Jackie Cross this also pertains to their business and reputations. Refined Journeys 1032 jeannifer brady 1033 Sharon Popek 1034 Bill Wert

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 38 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1035 Sherry Talbot Agent since 1970. About time we unite and weed out the 1036 Pamela Vermons CTC, MCC, Princess Commodore imposters. Glendora Travel Service & Cruise Gallery We have worked long and hard to acheive our status, don't 1037 Linda Carsella belittle our efforts by supporting MLM's. 1038 Jennifer Czerwinski 1039 Terri Quintarelli, CTC 1040 Joyce Neal I strongly support this petition. Travel with Joy 1st, LLC 1041 lisa haden 1042 Jacqueline Payne-Butler 1043 mike vela All About Travel, Ltd. 1044 Kirstin Docken 1045 Dolores Roberson Global Express Travel Services 1046 Suzanne L. Heily Their lack of professionalism will cause their demise! Renaissance Travel 1047 Charlene Murphy Global Express 1048 Rosemarie Litchfield Global Express Travel Services, Inc. 1049 Pat Nichols Nichols Travel, Inc. (Since 1978) 1050 ALLAN HAWKINS UMOJA TOURS

Support in any form for professional "working" travel 1051 Donna Keefe consultants is very important to the integrity of the industry. Departures These card mills are a discrace to all professional agents. I've been in this industry since the 1060's. I"ve seen many changes, but nothing like this. My window washer informed me that he is a part time travel agent & it only cost him $400. 1052 Marie Casella, MCC to YTB. VERY NICE! Cruise Concepts, Inc. 1053 Brad Hudson Travel Zone 1054 Betty Cox, CTIE Travel Concepts 1055 Janet Taylor 1056 Dale Borchelt These agents do nothing to promote the industry. They abuse 1057 LauraL Vucich the term "travel professional". By not giving the consumer complete, informed, service; MLM programs cheat travelers out of the vacation guidance they deserve, thus lowering the professionalism of the entire travel 1058 William Moore business. Dash Away Travel 1059 SANDRA WIDMANN 1060 Barbara Sieve 1061 Nancy Mize, CTC, ACC 1062 Reginald Osborne 1063 David W. Moody David's Cruise Vacatons 1064 Kenneth Smith Dreams Come True Travel 1065 Bob McMillen This is a very good idea! Travelwizard.com

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 39 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1066 Jessica Weeks Majestic Travel 1067 Debbie Smith 1068 charlene monachese what about BNW in Vancouver Canada 1069 Paula Downing 1070 Donna Morton 1071 Dee Carr

1072 dona edwards I am semi-retired, but agree with this petition completely!!!!! Eagle Trace, Inc. Bravo....suppliers should understand that it is in their best 1073 Michael M. Cabral interests to deal with "real" travel agents. Travel Odyssey, Inc. 1074 Lisa Loya holiday travel 1075 Peggy A. SHapiro Asssociated Travel Inc. 1076 Karl E. Rosen Towne Centre Travel 1077 Ruthanne Barron Exec-U-Travel Inc 1078 Judith Rainey Over the Rainbow Cruises 1079 Timothy Fitzpatrick Escape Travel 1080 Linda Elkin I am a 20 year veteran travel professional, it is a travesty that operations like this are accepted by any of our travel partners. Eliminating these amateur players (and the operators that enable them and collect their fees), produces a better trained and informed corps of travel counselors and improves the 1081 Mark Willis quality of service overall. Vacations To Go 1082 amy scutt 1083 Linda Marsh 1084 Anita Carew 1085 Christine Austin A & B Travel Services 1086 Deborah Souccar LuxExperience 1087 Darla Singletary Cruise Now, Tours & Travel 1088 Angela Schrenk 1089 Jodee Mufich K.C. Tours & Travel 1090 Ziad El-Atrache, CTA Travel Concepts International 1091 Ann Kenney 1092 Irene Markham Tafoya Please stop the Card Mill Agencies A Destination Travel / Altour 1093 LaVonne Dahlstrom 1094 Kathy Summers, CTA 1095 Barbara Pokornowski 1096 carillon torgerson Panda Travel 1097 Kay Hicks CruiseOne 1098 Kathryn W. Sudeikis , CTC All About Travel 1099 Jerry Leavitt Carefree Travel 1100 Sylvia Chambers See to Sea Travel 1101 Betty J. Barnett, CTC, DS Gaelic Adventures Incorporated

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 40 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1102 Cricket Maclin Holiday Travel Agency, Inc

My 20 years of experience and training can't be sold this devalues and insults my experience and professional. Would anyone allow any goof ball to say hey I am a lawyer. I've a degree in Hospitality and Tourism and have worked 20 years to build my resume. These companies basically say anyone 1103 Elite Travel Inc. can do my job without training. It is an insult Elite Travel Inc. 1104 Emelda Williams 1105 BEVERLY OVERDEVEST, MCC Nexion Inc 1107 Amy Rogers Travel With Us 1108 Dennis Hein 1109 Lavonda Jeffries 1110 Dennis Hein, CTC Long overdue. Firstworld Travel and Cruises 1111 Elizabeth Postell B and B Travel 1112 Jan Anderson Panda Travel-Phx 1113 Rose Wylie Travel 100 Group 1114 LaTasha DeLeaver Destiney's Adventures 1115 David Brotman American Express 1116 Wendy Loff 1118 heather williams   1119 Ruth Ewing I agree with my travel company to stop MLM now. Majestic Travel 1120 Jennifer Dahlstrom 1121 Pamela Jones Red Bird Travel 1122 Andreas Lemperg Wings Travel Center 1123 AUDREY TILLETT GLOBAL EXPRESS TVL SVCS 1124 Marion Greenberg 1125 Jo Ann Askey, CTC Happy Vacations 1126 Barbara Friedman 1127 Sue C Merritt 1128 Lisa Leonard As a travel professional for more than 15+ years (in many different capacities) I was thrilled to find out Royal Caribbean International had taken a stand on this issue. We don't need unprofessionals/card mills tarnishing our industry. Other cruise lines need to also follow Royal Caribbean 1129 Cindy Bertram International's lead. 1130 Janice Strickland 1131 Bill Potuchek Agree with RCCL Dream Vacation Travels 1132 Susan Kincanon Travel Concepts International 1134 Dan Ilves TravelStore 1135 Alma Beverly Grissom Afrotravel By Bev 1136 Helaine Zagaro offensive to all professional agents Alpha-J Travel, Ltd.

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 41 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1137 Carolyn Charney 1138 Gay Lam 1139 CARL BOWER BOWER TRAVEL SERVICE INC. 1140 Laura C Wickiser 1141 Laurie Bentley Craig's Travel 1142 Karen Herrera Craigs Travel 1143 Diane Richmond Craigs Travel 1144 Carolyn McCellan Craigs Travel 1145 Faye Shaver Craigs Travel 1146 Martha Jones 1147 jennifer I work hard as a home based agent and the few perks available these days from suppliers should go to legitimate 1148 Jennifer Terzi agents such as myself and others from my company. Travel Professionals International Vendors are allowing these people to turn the product into a commodity! Haven't they seen what has happened to the air 1149 Mindy Milliron, CT carriers? 1150 Shannon Juelich TPI 1151 sandra berns 1152 Joe Lang Thank You! 1153 Lorraine Seiberlich Travel One 1154 Donna Marie Stackhouse Let's get rid of them all Cruise Masters Ltd.

1155 Julie Kokos I will not support suppliers who support YTB type companies Sunset Travel 1156 Christine Belge 1157 Fred Verschelden TPI 1158 Tricia Hinds TravelPlex American Express 1159 Kali Gray Travel Professionals International 1160 Bobbie Jo Walker,CTA Travelplex I have been in the travel business for 20 years and don't 1161 Lisa Prince appreciate the benefits given to the MLM's HTC Vacations 1162 Marc Berman Berman Travel LLC 1163 shari brown please sign 1164 Terry Coles CTC, ACC Travel Professionals International 1165 Wendy Lawlor Travel Professionals International 1166 Mary Watson All Travel Service 1167 Bradley Brown TPI 1168 Robin Smith TPI 1169 Debbie Vandermaas Travel Professionals International 1170 Barbara Juchert CTC, MCC 1171 Martha Sikes Traveling By Design I have been in the travel industry for more than 30 years and 1172 Carole Johnson applaud this petition! Keys Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 42 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1173 michael reich 1174 Scott Irish, DS PrideOne Travel and Cruises 1175 Ruth Terrell Cruise-Sales.Com 1176 Ilene Furgang 1177 Wendy Knelsen Travel Professionals International 1178 Susan Berman Berman Travel 1179 Julie Brogan Brogan Travel 1180 Clare Brogan Brogan Travel 1181 Marylou Boal it is time to stop card mills Total Travel Service,inc 1182 Sharon Lasater, CTA, MCC 1183 Steve Zellers America's Vacation Center 1184 Bryant Terrell 1185 John McBride Dream Travel 1186 Jeff Jordan About Time! Simply Superior Cruises and Tours 1187 Mercedes Griffin Travel Agents International Thank you for taking a stand and recognizing us as true 1188 Kim Morgan professionals. International Tours of Rolla 1189 Dav Kronk Damar Travel and Cruise 1190 Lu Ann Edger 1191 Joanne Kilborn 1192 Janet Cole, ACC 1193 Martha Barber 1194 Deborah Watson Dreamward Vacations I've worked with a good host agency for the pass five years. I work hard and go to the trade shows and take classes to understand the world that I sell. So mad that people will take 1195 Rosetta Ruth what I work hard for. Very mad!!! Accent Travek and Crusies 1196 Maxine Nohrr,CTC, MCC 1197 leza vaughan 1198 Rosemary Saganic CTC Anderson Travel 1199 Carmina V. Vitullo Whole heartedly support this measure Vitullo Travel Agency Inc 1200 Doris Dunn AVC Professionals Stand Together - Nonprofessionals take 1201 Mark Moorhead Advantage The Travel Agent 1202 Celeste Burger 1203 John J. Chapman Pittsburgh, PA 1204 Don McCann Cruise Escapes 1205 Glen Flowers, CTC Worldwise Travel Co, Inc. 1206 Francine Rudden 1207 Traude Wilson CTC Travelplex American Express Time to stop this. The legitimate agencies will be stuck with 1208 Lucy Hirleman, CTC, MCC expensive legislation due to non-professionals. Berkshire Travel, Inc. 1209 Mimi Schuchet I totally support this petition. TRAVELPLEX AMERICAN EXPRESS

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 43 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1210 Cheryl Lamprecht way to go!!! 1211 Kathryn Burns Lamphier these are not professional people and hurt our industry. POSH TRAVEL LTD 1212 Patricia A Richardson This needs to be done 1213 Sharon S Turnau CTC Landmark Travel Services Inc 1214 Kathleen Ralston World Travel Inc 1215 Sarah Gladstone 1216 Karena Dawson World Travel, Inc. 1217 Sandy Hollander 1218 Melissa Leibold 1219 Joan Stolove I support this petition! 1220 Carol Dimopoulos Celtic Tours 1221 Rosemary DAugusta Perna Travel Service 1222 Connie Martin, CTC Dateline Travel Inc I find that MLMs debase our profession's reputation as they have no training, research background and expertise which is what gives the true professional properly earned respect. Their interest is to make quick money and take cheap trips 1223 Helen E Land basically 'cheating' the suppliers/vendors. Casto Vacations, San Francisco CA USA 1224 Lynne Schroeder CTC WTI Portland Oregon 1225 Pamela Silverwise Kings Crossing travel 1226 Patrick Silverwise Agency Affiliate Network 1227 Maureen Dahlstrom World Travel, Inc. 1228 Marilyn Somics It's about time! Travelhost Travel Agency 1229 Scott Robertson CTC 1230 Maureen Rosen Right on! Towne Centre Travel - Diamond Bar, CA 1231 Joanne Gomes 1232 sharon kedich world travel, inc. 1233 patricia bukieda world travel 1234 Toni Snyder California State Automobile Association 1235 heidi kazemi 1236 joel torgerson

This petition is long overdue. Non-professionals portray a different image from those of us that are career travel agents. The fact that one can be a travel agent without all the years of education and training required to be a professional makes all 1237 Mary Barclay CTC, DS the hard work and educational achievments meaningless. AAA Travel Agency 1238 Kristi Johnson Owner Temecula Travel Hopefully California is being checked closely also. We are 1239 Lucille Carter tired of it. Carter Country Travel 1240 Simon Let's do it!! Carlson Wagonlit Travel 1241 MARY CONTENTO 1242 Patricia Bradley Is it worth it to you to lose our business?

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 44 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1243 Marlain Wietzes Travel Professionals International 1244 Laurie Nytroen Bravo Rccl, Celebrity, Azamara Temecula Travel 1245 janet c frank don't cheapen my job-get rid of the fakes 1246 Marlene Rapka Rapka Travel, Inc. 1247 Linda Blew Travelhost Travel Agency in Grants Pass,Or 1248 Lynette Morris, CTA, DS 1249 Nancy Beachum 1250 Nadine Cloute IT IS TIME!!!! Places II Go Travel

agents should have to show a minium of 24k per year to have access to any perks. This would distinguish professional 1251 Beth Pederson agents from people just wanting travel discounts. World Travel Inc. 1252 Carol Lehman, CTC, ACC Destinations Unlimited of Northern CA., Inc 1253 Judy Wilder 1254 Debi Michaud let's make a difference and stop those that aren't legitimate 1255 Julie Mitchell from benefiting Design Travel, Inc. 1256 Debra Custer Thank you for putting an end to these fraudsters! WTI Happy to take a stand with all other Professional Agents who 1257 Barbara French value our profession. Carter Country Travel 1258 Paula Dozier Jr DTS Midway Vacations 1259 Margie Himes, CTA, DS AAA Travel 1260 Donna Stover Barrood Travel, Inc. - New Jersey 1261 Jody Forcum 1262 Eileen Kenneally, CTC Travelhost Tours & Cruises 1263 Devlet R. Getson World Travel Inc. Portland, Ore. As a owner for many years. I strongly appose MLM . We 1264 Mae Cheeks need professionally trained agents in this business. Your Personal Travel Agency LLC I agree that there are now too many non-agent pretending to be professionals. Some vendors caused this to happen and 1265 Asha Hillman CTC they need to put a stop to this. Uchida travel 1266 T.R. Phyle 1267 Kathy Moroney Distinctive Destinations 1268 Elizabeth Helton Five Star Worldwide Travel 1269 JEFFREY MUTNICK Giselle's Travel 1270 Lauren Richardson Union Vacations 1271 Gwendolyn Duncan. CTIE, CTC, MCC, LS, DS, BA Thank you for helping the true and bonifide Travel Industry Cordially Yours Travel 1272 mae kelley 1273 Rebecca Palmer

1274 Kenneth Brown Established Sept. 1978. Millions in revenue over the years. Gold Country Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 45 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company Let's put the professionalism back into our industry . . . . .out with the prima donas that only want the perks that we work so 1275 Sue Brown, DS hard to earn! Woodland Travel 1276 FRANK ORLANDO 1277 Arline B.Wall,CTC I support this movement 100\%!!! Bowen-Keppie Travel 1278 David Brams It's about time! World Wide Cruises, Inc. 1279 Mary Weismann Vacations Extraordinaire 1280 Katherine Jochen Ethiopian Airlines 1281 CAROL NILSEN, ACC, MCC, DS Passport to Cruising

This is an industry of professionals so let us protect the 1282 Anne Erdmann suppliers and the public by recognizing true professionals only 1283 Katherine Jochen Ethiopian Airlines 1284 Laurianne Manchester 1285 MICHAEL BATT 1286 Mary Garitone CTC 1287 Lynn Wilson Shared Travel 1288 Cathy Sanchez It's about time! We strongly support this petition! Easy Escapes Travel, Inc. I am proud to consider myself a true travel consultant. These 1289 Julie Hatter MLM practices disgrace my profession. Jewels of the World Travel 1290 Julie Garcia Journeys By Ambassador 1291 George E. Oldham, III CTC Oldham Travel Being a travel agent should not a part time job. It should be left to those who are dedicated professionals providing a 1292 David Phelps professional service. 1293 Larry Smith 1 Agree L & E Travel Agency My family has owned and operated an agency for 30 yrs and would love to see it survive another 30 yrs but with the card 1294 Dezorea Whiteaker mills it is very unlikely. All Ports Travel, Inc. 1295 mary marlowe only professional agents should be acknowledged. 1296 Alene Peaceman This is long over due. It is very frustrating to go to many vendor events with limited seating to find half the room is represented by card mills, leaving legitamate travel planner 1297 Debbie Coate unable to attend. Adventures in Travel 1298 john millsaps 1299 Susan Mason 1300 Paula Ryan 1301 dale w caudle 1302 Suzanne Lande, MCC 1303 Poulina Scott Absolutely support this movement!! MLMs have to be 1304 Sharon Nuuhiwa discontinued somehow! Independent Contractor w/Pioneer Travel 1305 Patricia "Patsy" Williamson TLC Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 46 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1306 Lauren Hawkins   1307 ALICE IUEN LANDMARK TRAVEL, FT LAUDERDALE 1308 Gwen Wells, CTC 1309 April Schmitt 1310 Hannah Bradley 1311 Fred Kerner 1312 Rebecca Greenberg   1313 Christian Halvorson   1314 Abby Stevens I have worked in the industry for 30years and have strived to become knowledgeable and professional. MLM agents 1315 Tina Williams cheapen us all. Independant with America's Vacation Center 1316 Charles H Johnson Stop the insanity

Travel Agencies and Homebound agents should invest their time in education and real "FAM" trips. There is no substitute for experience and on the job training. Those in the travel 1317 Diane Panasci industry should be proud of their professional status. Foreign Independent Tours 1318 Charlie Johnson, ACC Real Benefits to Real Agents 1319 Sam Duluth Travel 1320 Matt Knowles Sea Escape TRAVEL 1321 Nancy Pemberton 1322 Lee Pemberton 1323 Judy Haas I hope this will help to stop this kind of practice Travelplex American Express 1324 Ingeborg Sanders, CTC 1325 Uwe Thaysen, CTC Expo Travel 1326 Donald Trappler Ambassador Cruises 1327 Ilona Kupec Giselle's Travel 1328 Alison Hawthorne Over The Rainbow Travel 1329 susan tanzman martin's travel 1330 Dennis Wade Oakdale Travel Service Inc 1331 joanne 1332 Kathy Price Oakdale Travel Service Inc We back your efforts 100\% to rid our industry of these 1333 Ken Fredricks imposters! Royalty World Cruises 1334 Diana Rivera Oakdale Travel Service Inc 1335 Donald Kiselewski 1336 Pamela McCurdy Oakdale Travel Service Inc 1337 Amina B. Khan 1338 Robin Little Get rid of the Pyramids UnionVacations.com I am so happy that something is being done at least on especially YTB. I do hope the travel industry will take serious 1339 Eugenia Chinsman cognisance of our petition MANSTRAVEL

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 47 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

ONLY AGENTS WITH STORE FRONT OFFICES AND ARC SHOULD BE CONSIDERED AS TRUE AGENCYS AS IT 1340 JAMES M. LASCHER WAS IN THE PAST AND ALL SHOULD BR BONDED. MARS TRAVEL INC. 1341 Casey Rice   1342 MARIJKE GROTZ 1343 Lynda Garrett Alpine Travel of Saratoga 1344 Christy Jourdan I'm an 11-year industry veteran and home based agent Ships and Trips Travel 1345 Sandy Hahn Carlson Wagonlit Travel 1346 Kristi DeSylvia 1347 Georgia Shoemaker I agree whole-heartedly! Giselle's Travel / Global Travel 1348 Linda Carpentier Celtic Tours International 1349 Anita Young You need to earn your Iatan Cards-not buy them Cordially Yours Travel 1350 Dana McNulty Carlson Wagonlit Travel 1351 Catherine Stouffer 1352 mary ann fuhs 1353 Janet Dudley Celtic Tours 1354 Katherine E Lindquist consumer/former Travel Agent 1355 Jean Tozloski Black Diamond Travel 1356 Teresa Jackson 1357 Chad Jackson 1358 Tonda Snyder this is long over due AAA Travel 1359 Lindsay Williams (Professional Travel Consultant) Here Today Gone To Maui 1360 laura forrest 1361 vicky stone CruiseOne 1362 Nikki Bowers Ships and Trips Travel 1363 Edith Roach Acacia Travel 1364 Shirley Silvestri The scheme has to stopped! 1365 Juanita R. Roca Pyramid recruiting of people a sign of MLS A certificate of school of travel a requirement 1366 Christine Breit Ticket Express Travel 1367 Lynnda Fair, CTC Respect the profession, education and professionalism Giselle's Travel 1368 Lilly Handler Plan for VACATIONS 1369 Judy Connors Whirlaway Travel 1370 Yolanda Byrd 1371 Mary Fergus, CTC DS 1372 Nina Giunta WhirlAway Travel 1373 Grace Feuerhelm, MCC, CTC, DS(5) 1374 Marilyn Bechman Indy Car Travel 1375 christine stewart 1376 Lauri 1377 mary blackstock 1378 Jacque Myers

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 48 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company independent as Clayton Cruise and Vacation and Hosted by 1379 Bitsy Clayton America's Vacation Center 1380 Caroline Sosa Destinations 1381 Rita Moore I think this is terrible to cheapen our industry like this Majestic Travel 1382 Terri Ferrll 1384 Pat Rugel The Travel Connection, Ltd. 1385 RENNAE R ESTRELLA IT IS ABOUT TIME SIGNATURE TRAVEL INC 1386 Patricia Lattanzio This petition has my support The Travel Depot, Tomball, Texas 1387 Jennifer Hayes 1388 Barbara Gross 1389 Johnny D, Kovalcik 1390 Anne Gengler Magic Carpet Travel 1391 Sandy Thomas 1392 Ken Bates 1393 Rosemary Martelli Its about time those who do not deserve agent deals stop 1394 Russell W. Reid getting them. It only hurts us legitimate travel sellers. Carlson business & Pleasure Travel 1395 Judy Schenberg, CTC MCC I hope something can be done 1396 Ida Marilyn Gant 1397 Nelson Hollins Finally!!! 1398 MARY HALASZ 1399 Colleen Ladwig AA Worldwide Travel It's time for legitimate agents and agency organizations to 1400 Jerry Funkhouser, MCC stand up for themselves and their livelihood. Cruise Travel Services 1401 Judy Riley CruiseOne 1402 June Marcus BBM Travel, Inc. We have worked too hard to gain our knowledge, expertise, and benefits to allow our clients to be misled by unskilled faux 1403 Myra Funkhouser, MCC agents. Cruise Travel Services 1404 Kay Berke Royal Travel and Tours, Inc./American Express 1405 allison conrad We have been approached several times about YTB and they are quite indoctrinated by the company to the extent that they will not listen to any negative comments and think they have a 1406 Nancy Kupperian, MCC great deal! 1407 Sally Fine Vendors lose the value of what they offer, as products are rebated. Travel Agents lose clients. Victims (card buyers) do not UPGRADE without guidance towards what is best for them! Who is really losing? The VENDOR! STOP MLM 1408 Gloria Levine Travel Agents! Uniglobe Adventure Travel 1409 Emily Williams Yes, this practice should be stopped and seen for what it is, 1410 Marilyn Lewis fraud! Aweigh-To-Go Travel, Inc.

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 49 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1411 Patsy Burdine I have been in all phases of this business for 26 years. I resent the fact that they can get freebees when hard working 1412 Virginia Parkin agents can't. Temecula Travel 1413 Loretta Liang Down with YTB and the like! 1414 Sarah Amidi In my contact with one of these "companies" for company travel I found them not to be competent, and not to know basic things about travel which I knew as a professional who travels 1415 Ned S. Levi regularly. NSL Associates Inc. 1416 Suzanne Heffner CTC, DS The Travel Pro 1417 Judy Tedrow ACC 1418 Brandi Floyd I've worked hard for 7 years to get where I am! 1419 Mike Ziegenbalg CruiseOne 1420 Deborah Bachler It is important to maintain our relationship I think it's time for the suppliers who say "We Love Travel 1421 Phil Maro, ACC, DS Agents" to step up and really SHOW it! We're waiting. 1422 Marjorie Purnell The Sedona Group It's hard to believe that this farce has been going on for so 1423 Ina Vaughn many years. Should have been stamped out immediately! Travel Design Associates 1424 Melody Gyorfy Melody G Travel Have worked hard for over 23 years, have earned every dime in commissions, which sometimes never receive but company enjoyed business I sent to them. Legimate travel agents need 1426 Barbara Parker backing!! Travel Fever 1427 Tammy Levent Keep real travel agents in the industry Elite Travel Management Group 1428 LIZ MAER UFX TRAVEL

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 50 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

Being a travel agent has all ways been a dream and a serious passion. In June 2007 I began researching th field of travel and what is required. and after spending months I was torn between two different host agencies, but before making my decision I was also approached by a YTB agent. After hearing her sales speech I was convinced that it sounded too much like a pyramid and I was not interested. I did choose a host agency and spent the last month training. I have completed Carnival and Royal Caribbean's travel agent courses and earned certificates. I also completed through Travel Agent Academy Cancun, BVI, Destination Wedding Specialist, Bahamas, Dominican Republic, Couples Resort and I have begun Princess and Cunard certificate programs. I have subscribed to every (and I mean every) online and print magazine, as well as any other organization that provieds me with education that is needed to stay ahead. I have also begun the ACC certificate through CLIA. I am serious about 1429 Laurell this business of travel. Dream Destinations by Laurell 1430 jeanne f tallman 1431 Patricia Snyder Thank You Destinations Unlimited of Northern California 1432 Sonia Burke  Destinations Unlimited of Northern California 1433 tom perna 1434 David Robinson Americas Vacation Center 1435 catherine demichiel destinations unlimited 1436 Janet Sutton Gwinnett Travel 1437 Maxine DeLaOssa Elan Travel Services 1438 Mary Ellen Dzigiel, A.C.C., L.C.S. The Cruise Company 1439 Joyce Davis America's Vacation Center 1440 Richard Beaudoin 1441 Bea Thompson 1442 Deborah Eck Entrepreneur Travel & Tours THESE COMPANIES HAVE BEEN ALLOWED TO EXIST FOR TOO MANY YEARS. ALL VENDORS NEED TO 1443 DEBRA LEVIN RETHINK THEIR POLICIES. TRAVEL HOUSE INC 1444 Geraldine Gelfand Travel Travel by Gerry 1445 Priscilla Mooshian, MCC Cruise With Us ARE THERE NO LOCAL AGENCY NEAR WHERE THESE SO CALL TRAVEL AGENT LIVE THAT THEY NEED TO ASSOCATE WITH AN INTERNET AGENCY IN ORDER TO 1446 MARGARET BOWER CONDUCT BUSINESS BOWER TRAVEL SERVICE INC. I am very UPSET about YTB - I have been a travel agent for 1447 Trudie Robinson over 26 years- I though this was against the law Robinson travel 1448 Norma Bowers Robinson Travel Agency

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 51 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1449 Gabriella Ribeiro Truman Excellent idea- keep it going! 1450 Jan M Enke Air, Land & Sea Travel 1451 Carole Laurie The Cruise Company 1452 Susan Cavotta 1453 Pat Thomas The Travel Source 1454 Mitch Bank 1455 Sandra Salling, CTC 1456 Beth Baran 1457 Trude Peterson Vasquez Cruises Inc 1458 Melissa Tamaro Berman Travel 1459 kenneth scott 1460 Emma Holmon Mad About Travel 1461 paula it's about time 1462 Heather Troutman 1463 Robbie Weadick 1464 Marcy Hickman 1465 Susan Rosenberry  Islands in the Sun Cruises & Tours, Inc. 1466 Bernadette Cramer Pioneer Travel Service Independent Agent 1467 Thomas Hutchinson Inglewood Travel 1468 Vicky Garcia Hats off to RCI, CEL & AZA...hope others follow suit soon! Cruise Planners 1469 Fred Frankel CTA, ACC American Cruise & Travel 1470 Daria Tomashosky 1471 Stanley Gawel 1472 Marianne Murphy 1473 Haisley Smith Brownell 1474 Greg Thien, CTA RWD Travel 1475 Jennifer Belt CTA and CLIA certified Executive Travel 1476 Tom Schrader That is ridiculous that we have worked so hard for so long, 1477 Amber Burt and they are just handed everything we have earned.

1478 gwen bourgeois I have been in the travel industry since 1978, please stop this Dickinson Travel Is no one loyal anymore? These people make me embarrassed to a be travel agent. A profession I've worked 1479 Michele Ross hard at and been educated in for over 15 years 1480 Sharon Kay Howell,CTC,MCC Travel Masters 1481 Douglas Anderson Cruise & Travel Masters - Salt Lake City, Utah 1482 Holly Boatman Travel Masters 1483 Karen Barber, CTA, ACC 1484 LaRae Jonkman 1485 Lisa Schoonover,CTC,DS,ACC 1486 Jeannie Sipp BERGER TRAVEL AGENCY INC.

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 52 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company Thank you for your efforts to protect our profession and to 1487 Doris Mundy protect our clients and potential clients. I work to hard to have them get the perks for them not selling travel. I feel that we have lost any perks that we had because 1488 Gypsy Hummel of them. Cruise and Travel Masters 1489 Donna Oliver Travelplex American Express Thank you RCI, 30 years as a Travel Agent, protect the Travel 1490 Cynthia Jo Van Wagner-Alt, CTA Agents that has earned their wings! Berger Travel Agency Thank you. I work hard for the little benefits that we still 1491 Steve Rice receive The Cruise Butler

Professional, dedicated, experienced and knowledgeable individuals are the backbone of the hospitality industry; lower 1492 Donna Beck, CTC, DS, CSS or eliminate these standards and you destroy the industry Advantage Travel Consultants, Chesterfield, MO 1493 Cody Smith Travel Masters with 25 years full time in the industry and I really glad to take a 1494 Wanda Logsdon stand on such un-ethical practices. Cruise and Travel 1495 B Kathleen Krebsbach storefront agency for 18 years! Travel, etc 1496 betty tice 1497 shalona goodfellow cruise & travel masters It is important to know you are dealing with a professional who is experienced in the travel business. Working with someone who is poorly trained and only working for freebies is of no 1498 Frederick Hawkins benefit to the customer! 1499 Rosalind Bangs CTC It's about time we do something to stop this. I have worked in the industry for 22 years and see these people too often 1500 Greg Albury cutting into my business. Travel Spot - Abaco Island. Bahamas 1501 Harry Todd Frosch - Burlingame, CA 1502 Richard Gutwein Cruise centeer Inc. 1503 Valerie Zisfain Vacation Station 1504 Debbie Hansen 1505 Sherri Brewer Creative Travel 1506 Camille Hutchison Travel 2 Travel 1507 Sara Leonard Off We Go Travel 1508 barbara turner north rockland travel 1509 Monika Leuenberger  Avenues of the World Travel 1510 Mary Evans A Piece of the World Travel 1511 Linda Margolin FROSCH 1512 Ellen Chorba SHAMROCK TRAVEL 1513 Jerry Barnhardt Best Connection Travel, Inc 1514 Cheryl Wilson 1515 Helen Robison, ACC Cruise Planners 1516 Michael Geraci, CTC

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 53 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1517 Sharon Parker Very needed Parkers Travel Solutions 1518 Billy Parker Very needful Parkers Travel Solutions 1519 Tracy Ann Bobak-Ho View the World Tours, Inc I too was approached to "sell" for YTB, and declined. I have a wonderful relationship with my host agency, and can see no reason to cheapen my value as a travel agent by associating Sea the World Cruise & Tours, host agency America's 1520 Sue Ratliff with a pyramid scheme. Vacation Center

MLM Travel is a scam. Next will be a MLM doctor...who Cruise and Travel Masters. I am a trained and Licensed 1521 Jill Nunley wants heart surgery from an untrained non licensed doc??? Travel Agent since 1984. 1522 Patti Ihli Destinations Unlimited 1523 Patti Ihli Destinations Unlimited 1524 Karen McComb 1525 Barbara King Great Getaways 1526 Betsy Geiser 1527 Keith Tucker Amen, go for it. Acacia Travel 1528 Brenda Macklyn Cruise and Travel Masters 1529 Stephen Daigle none Daigle Travel 1530 Kim Sullivan 1531 Susan Jenkins 1532 VICTORIA OLDFIELD 1533 Marilyn Lohf 1534 Joe W. Howell Travel Masters 1535 Elizabeth Elston CruisePlanners 1536 Marilyn Clark, ACC, DS Lighthouse Travel 1537 Marcia Perkins 1538 Jeanne Mirisola Cruise Planners 1539 LuAnne McNamara 1540 Marty Harris, ACC Americas Vacation Center / American Express You shouldn't be allow to sell your industies CLIA or IATAN 1541 Mary L. Adams CARD . It is supposed to be earned 1542 Judith Carr BRAVO!!!! Holiday Travel 1543 Carrie Willard Support the REAL Travel Agents!!! Majestic Travel- St. Peters, MO 1544 Toby Nash Cruise & Travel Masters 1545 Rebecca Swoboda Travel Express in WDC 1546 Andrea Logsdon Cruise and Travel Masters 1547 Sharon DeLano Frosch Travel 1548 Kathy J. Withers Firmly agree! Holiday Travel Agency I am a 24 year full time agent and I fully agree with this position.card mill mlms are idoits and count on a certain segment of society still believing that you CAN get something for nothing. I,AND i'm sure-all the REAL travel agents that I 1549 EARL FOX know-will agree.

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 54 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1550 Emma Hanson Master Travel I am proud of my professional I have worked hard at for 22 1551 Rebecca Roberts years. The Travel Store,Inc. 1552 Mary Ann Curry Cruise & Travel Masters 1553 Pamela Lively Trans Global Travel 1554 Marilyn Botzenhardt, CTC First Travel of California 1555 Vicki Cox Kuddo's - This has gone on too long. Carlson Wagonlit Travel 1556 mary kay cretan ctc gurnee travel inc 1557 Diane Spinelli - Travel EEZ Inc. This must stop! FOREVER Travel EEZ Inc. 1558 Kristy Graham, CTA I've been in the travel industry since 1979 and am deeply offended by the ability of YTB and other card mills to operate 1559 Gail Bradley, ACC fraudulently America's Vacation Center/American Express 1560 Ramona Quiroz Stop!!! your business access to travel 1561 kenneth hooper access to travel 1562 christopher ortencio access to travel 1563 dolores hoffman access to travel 1564 judy marshman 1565 Karen Bocci - Frosch Travel Frosch 1566 Fred Teichen CWT/Travelcade 1567 barbara sanchez access to travel 1568 david sanchez access to travel 1569 norma padilla access to travel 1570 Shelley Ewing Calgary, AB. Canada 1571 adriana ortencio access to travel 1572 Gillian Scott 1573 Terri Maldonado 1574 Diana G. Jurin A.C.C. Home-based travel agency since 1991 Cruises + Plus 1575 Chris DeRose We work too hard for too little First Travel of California 1576 Robert Clifford 1577 Daniel Irvine Around The Globe Travel 1578 Ruth Hewlin Uniglobe Instant Travel, Inc. 1579 Diane Spooner Wildwood Travel 1580 Pat Bennett It's about time somebody did something! 1581 Tabby Raya 1582 Gary Thompson 1583 Mike Eiden 1584 angie vanaria/manager 1585 cindy swensen 1586 Monique Powell 1587 Jennifer Pickering Seahorse Travel 1588 Shonne Epperly-Elgin Havalark Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 55 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

The fellow who was working on our home paid $250.00 for one of these just to get discounts on travel. He knows nothing 1589 Patricia Allred CTC about the travel business and did not care to learn anything Cruise and Travel Masters 1590 Tina Bradshaw Uniglobe Above & Beyond Travel I EARN EVERY DISCOUNT I RECIEVE, WHY SHOULD SOMEONE BEING A POSER IN TRAVEL,WHO IS NOT AN AGENT,REAP THE BENEFITS I WORK HARD FOR? NOT FAIR,LETS STICK TOGETHER,WE NEED TO STAND BY 1591 JOHNNY DAVIS EACH OTHER . BRIDGEPORT NEWS TRAVEL AND TRS INC

Many years ago I worked as an inside agent for the first "card mill" company. It was World View later to become Inteletravel. 1592 SHARI GRENKA If you would like an insiders view please contact me. 1593 Vera Sanford Great idea to block card mills. 1594 Stacy Cramblit 1595 Catherine Inness Travel Consultant 23 years Tours and Cruises Unlimited 1596 George Loftin  Carefree Travel 1597 Joey Kemple Agent for over 17 years Outdoor Adventure Travel 1598 Carol Soto Elite Travel 1599 marlene morse martin's travel and tours 1600 Jim Cavender, CTC, MCC A Plus Cruise and Tour 1601 Lori Grygalonis VIP Leisure Travel 1602 Martha Card Mills should be shut down Maupin Travel 1603 Martha Van Horne Card Mills should be shut down Maupin Travel 1604 Judy Herwig, CTC 1605 Paul Catterson 1606 Timothy D. Thompson, DS, CTC 1607 Beth Breen America's Vacation Center I wholeheartedly agree that it is cheapening our business - wouldn't the vendors rather have someone that knows what they are doing selling their product?? I wouldn't think so but the almighty dollar seems to be the only thing they care about 1608 Tara Walker anymore. Great 34 yrs in business should be worth something that the 1609 Gloria Wright overthe night agent can't gtet. Huntsville Travel, Huntsville, TX 1610 Mark Silva Americas Vacation Center 1611 Sandi Waryck, CTC ENOUGH!!!!! SW TRAVEL INC This cheapens the value and service of studied and 1612 Diane S McMahon CTC experienced travel consultants Spirit Cruise and Travel 1613 sharon jory First Travel of California 1614 Barbara Artel Robinson Travel 1615 Barbara Glass In the Travel Industry for 34 years Travel Masters 1616 Richard Silva MCC Clear Skys Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 56 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1617 Eileen Gauthier, CTA, MCC They also solicit for insurance, web sites All Ways Travel

AMEN...these organizations jeopardize my job everyday. This is a small agency that gives customer service 1st priority. We battle internet and airlines everyday wanting to do away 1618 Terry Aebischer with us. Thank you Royal Caribbean for your support. Travel One Inc. 1619 Shirley McCreary, MCC, CTA, CSS Help us help you! Cruise & Travel of Brandywine Valley 1620 Jody Kozak Travel House, Phoenix AZ 1621 Janice Ross 1622 Al Been 1623 Karen Hellman ACC It is important for our industry to take a stand against YTB! Americas Vacation Center/American Express 1624 Diane 1625 Andrea M 1626 Janet Higton We have to compete with on line prices that are the same 1627 Linda don't take away any of the few benefits we have left Finally someone is actually doing something about this 1628 Jim McCreary, MCC problem! Cruise & Travel of Brandywine Valley, Inc.

IT's about time we stand up for our profession. I have over 30 years in this business and work hard to maintain my professionalism and knowledge of this changing world. Card 1629 Wanda Mansfield CTC mill "agents" do not and do indeed cheapen this industry. We vigorously train our agents and they are not allowed an IATA card until they have been here a full year. MLM is not 1630 Christy fair to the hard working legitimate agents FVC 1631 Rita Conte America's Vacation Center/American Express 1632 Kelly McCreary Cruise & Travel of Brandywine Over 25 yrs selling travel, now retired. Thanks John for trying to make the next generation experience the respect we 1633 Carol Cheney, CTC, ACC worked so hard to achieve for all travel professionals 1634 Ellen Wilson Finally! Crystal Travel 1635 joanna 1636 DONNA WADE MAJESTIC TRAVEL 1637 Merry Larsen I've waited a long time for this!!! Hooray RCCL America's Vacation Center/American Express 1638 Missy FVC 1639 Amanda Williams Thank you for this petition Getways Tours and Cruises 1640 Dennis Bonade These MLM's have no right to travel or even to sell travel. Cruise Planners 1641 Deborah A. Gillespie Premiere Travel of Plant City 1642 Valerie FVC

Self-dealing, which is what this type of business promotes is 1643 Diana Cashman Howard, CTC never professional and a cancer within the travel industry. Vista Travel, Las Cruces, NM 1644 Marilyn Johnson

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 57 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1645 Janice Eyman 1646 Connie Gottas 1647 Terri Murray 1648 Mateja Harrington I have been an agent for 14 years 1649 Chris Heuwetter 1650 Lu Ann Cortese DS CTA All World Travel YTB is becoming quite an epidemic in my area. I am very tired of being recruited by YTB agents who want to sell me 1651 Joan Miller their $450 agent I.D. card so I can join their pyramid. 1652 Elizabeth Lo Ships and Trips Travel 1653 Elena Yasno Ticket To Travel 1654 Stephanie Hernandez Broadway Travel 1655 Carol Varga Carol's Travel Houston Tx 1656 Zenobia Chien, DS Zen Vacations 1657 Evelyn Staton, CTA, DS

We work very hard in this industry for 27 years to be eligible for the benefits and this MLM scam have to stop at once forever now. This have been denegrating our travel industry.Thank you for taking a step forward on this serious matter and let us know if you need more information or any 1658 Elisabeth Casanova, CTA, CSS support to stop the MLM Travel Agents Cheapen Industry TRAVEL 4 LESS LLC 1659 Stephanie Warrington I personally sell over $1million per year World Travel Inc. 1660 Ed Atz Stop Allowing Amateurs a Professionals Credentials Travel Guide Inc. 1661 Iris Messina 1662 Glenys Lowy AVC/American Express 1663 Susan Bridgeford Bridgeport News Travel & Tours 1664 Denise Owens Excellent!! Fraud Companies!!! 1665 DONNA LEE KREUTZER CRUISE HOLIDAYS 1666 MINDI COOK 1667 Valerie Smith 1668 Tammy Buck 1669 David Dober There's no room or need for MLMs in the travel industry. The Travel Group 1670 barbara myers Working agent for 17 years travel smart, inc I am thrilled we are finally going to remove the unqualified who 1671 Robin Souder misuse the Travel Industry and steal our clients The Cruise Experts Int'l 1672 Kevin Souder Shut down the Frauds! The Cruise Experts Int'l Thank you Royal Caribbean for Finally protecting the integrity 1673 Robert Auclair of YOUR PRODUCT The Cruise Experts Int'l 1674 Sandra Edwards FROSCH 1675 Pete DeRuyter Covina Hills Travel 1676 John P. Sarlo, A.C.C. Castoff Cruises LLC

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 58 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company Proud to be with a LEGIT host agency...not an MLM or pyramid scheme. I have worked hard over 22years to be a 1677 Belinda Herring, ACC real Travel Agent! Way to go RCCL! America's Vacation Center/American Express 1678 Mary Kay Pucci Carefree Travel Scottsdale Inc. 1679 Evelyn W. Wood It is time that we make this stand! Robinson Travel As a dedicated travel professional, I am overjoyed to hopefully see the "card mills" as a blot on the history of real travel 1681 Vickie Thomas professionals. Anchors Away w/ host - America's Vacation Center

1682 kathy gross ctc its about time someone is doing something abot this problem travel house 1683 Robin Crosby it is about time 1684 Mervyn Spiro 1685 Barbara Richardson 1686 Scott Larson 1687 Peggy Forgotch 1688 Georgia Sowers BGS Travel Services Inc 1689 Pat Thank you Royal, Celeb & Azamara. Let's see the others take 1690 Debbie Devine a stand as well. Cruise Planners, NJ 1691 Valerie VanEpps 1692 Arlene Marcus 1693 Pearl Irby MCC CTC Thanks RCCL 1694 nancy wolfe tzell/sundance travel phoenix az 1695 Anita McAllister I am a 10-year travel consultant who agrees 100\%. Tumbleweed Travel/Independent Affiliate for Andavo Travel 1696 Leona Earlington Travel Professionals 1697 Monique Donahue Cruiserrific 1699 Diana Kollaritsch The Travel Team Inc. We are seeing customers with problems dealing with such "agents" but there is little we can do to help them. This is a growing problem for the public at large. This "chain letter" type of organization makes it difficult on established travel 1700 Stanley Hendricks agents to uphold professional standards. Â 1701 Dave Goldhirsch This should have been addressed a long time ago Binn's Travel 1702 Linda Drake Please do away with perks to Card Mills! Cruise & Travel Bargains International 1703 Brandi Stanton I have been waiting for this day so it becomes a REAL 1704 Susan Carr profession again. The more you weaken the true travel agent community by supporting these groups, the fewer real agents will be left to 1705 Ruth Myers sell your product. Preferred Travel & Cruise Inc. 1706 Anne Dymond 1707 Chelsea

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 59 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

I give my full support to the 'true' agents in the industry who continue to educate themselves in geography, and travel to improve their knowledge of the areas they are selling - which in turn benefits their clients, not just themselves... these 'other' agents seem to just want to get travel perks for their own benefit & could care less about where they go or what they are selling. The few I've spoken to have shown a lack of 1708 Lori Maloney knowledge and professionalism. 1709 Vanessa Fowler simply not right-something needs to be done One Stop Travel/Port 21 1710 Lisa Elsbury Travelpath Inc 1711 Judene Cardinale Please do something as it is cheapening the advice of REAL 1712 Roxanna (Roxie) Seales, CTC agents. Acacia Travel, Inc. 1713 Nanci Londeree 1714 Dale Graham Morgan Creek Cruiseshipcenters 1715 Kathy Jones I just lost business to Inteletravel Zenith Travel 1716 Donna Worley Lake Country Travel 1717 Anni Reynolds A RTA came into our office and tried to solict us to buy into their pyramid scheme and become an RTA for them - and solict our families and friends. Also to capture the business that people are already going online to buy. All for $49.99 a 1718 Deb Lawendowski month!!!! The Cruise Wizards, Whitesboro, NY 1719 Linda Schwedock 1720 Lisa Kehl 1721 Teresa Vibe 1722 Sara Guinn, CTC Hanson Travel Ideas 1723 Michele Thomas Cruise Holidays of St. Johns 1724 Theodore G. Bradpiece Two Bears Travel 1725 Gary Lee Martinez The Traveling Traveler 1726 Andy C. Mosetti NEXTSKY Travel 1727 Daniel Itzcovich 1728 georgi butler I applaud RCCL for taking a stand Classic Travel

I applaud RCCL's stand against the Card Mll Agencies and 1729 Cathie Gerhart encourage other Cruise lines and TourOperators to follow Suit Above The Rest Vacations 1730 Fred R. Munroe Magellan360 1731 Ralph Cooper Please support this Bon Voyage Travel 1732 Paula Naruo, ACC Pacific Harbor Travel 1733 DEBBIE MEIER I applaud RCCL for taking a stand 1734 Wendy Simon help keep our industry professional! Pacific Harbor Travel, inc.

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 60 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

I'm glad the travel industry is finally taking a stand and weeding out these card mills in a small town this can really hurt a store front agency that has the education, time and 1735 Karen Wright money wrapped up in being an accredited travel consultant. 1736 Trent Zundel 1737 Misty Harmon

Nothing can replace the service of a professional travel agent. We all live and breathe for our clients. MLM agents have no idea the work involved in true customer service. My clients 1738 Kathy Carroll Orr have my cell and I availbable 24/7. Our office opened in 1984. La Palma Travel/Honeymoon Travel 1739 Annette McPeak 1740 Diane Santana 1741 Christine Whittemore Finally my "friends" who purchased mill cards will no longer receive benefits I work long hours to achieve! Thank you so 1742 Susan Blum much. 1743 Margaret Sunnie Templeton It's about time! Class Act Tours 1744 Alice Kissel Love Travel 1745 Barbara Allen Navigant Vacations 1746 Lynn Dye 1747 Bridget Flynn 1748 Clint Schrader I hope all the suppliers thinks about how much damage the 1749 Carman Hubbs ACC CTC DS MLM agencies can do the the whole travel industry. Travel Professionals International 1750 Allan Vavra Dial Travel 1751 Kim Copenhaver 1752 Dyann Lake One of my clients tried recruiting me !!!! Welcome Aboard Travel 1753 Rose Lambert ASA Travel OR Thank you for not supporting MLM agents!! They degrade the 1754 Karen Oliver-Allie professionalism of legitimate travel agents. TMI 1755 Johnna Brown, CTC world wide travel service We need to have specific qualifications .. please go back to 1756 Jan Paytas mandetory IATAN cards or perhpas CLIA cards World Wide Consolidated Travel, Inc. 1757 Carol Kidd 1758 Brooke Johnson,ACC 1759 Debra Dickerson 1760 jane grebil Island Travel 1761 Janeen Gaisford Cruise and Travel Masters 1762 Ella Murphy 1763 Heidi Cusworth Thank you Royal Caribbean and Celebrity for taking this 1764 David Gedansky stand. Carlson Wagonlit Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 61 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1765 Mark Johnson 1766 Julia Pond 1767 Lea Ann Kunkle 1768 Amy Yetter Boscov's Travelcenter 1769 Dorothy MOwbray stop the madness leave it to the professionals Boscov's Travelcenter 1770 Marie Judge Boscov's Travelcenter 1771 Kim Hitchner 1772 JOAN HAYNES A AND I TRAVEL SERVICE 1773 Kendra Singer Boscov's Travel 1774 Joanne Hays Boscov's Travelcenter 1775 Gayle Martin, MCC 1776 Irene Allawh Boscov's Travel 1777 CAROL ROESSER OWNER CAMBRIAN PLAZA TRAVWL 1778 Alex Varghese Boscov's Travel 1779 Karen Chieppa Thank you RCCL!!! Hope more will follow 1780 Barbara Kelley BLUE SKYZ TRAVEL, iNC 1781 debra callaway Travel source 1782 Galina Guydik Boscov's Travelcenter 1783 phyllis lesagonicz boscov's travelcenter 1784 Karla Mundell Travel In Style, Inc 1785 Gabriela Aragon Aragon Travel 1786 Sue Collins Cascade Travel 1787 Judy Matthiessen 1788 Ruth Enslin-Johnson Boscov's Travel 1789 Lynn Rhodea Gotta Go! Travel, LLC 1790 Allie Huberty I applaud your efforts to alert suppliers Ships and Trips Travel, Sacramento, CA 1791 Jan Yascko BOSCOVS TRAVELCENTER 1792 Cindy Blachly

I'm so frustrated with MLM "agencies", it's one of the primary 1793 Marian Nagel reasons I'm getting out of the travel agency industry Personal Travel (formerly) 1794 Donna Wellworth Boscovs Travel 1795 Ken Fronk THANK YOU RCCL Boscovs Travel 1796 Sharyn D Prokurat 1797 Roger Ridings R & R Worldwide Travel & Cruises It's about time something is being done to promote and 1798 Lena Glace protect the REAL TRAVEL AGENT Welcome Aboard Travel 1799 Penny Hurst Totally agree Boscov's Travelcenter 1800 Kathi Angelos

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 62 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

How 'bout going after World Ventures? On the website, their co-founder Wayne Nugent's profile even proclaims him to be "the most passionate evangelist for Network Marketing as the premier distribution channel of leisure travel." Network marketing IS MLM. Yes, you too, can instantly become a travel agent for $400 registration, and $39.96/month for the rest of your life. Heck, give us your credit card number, and you can register your dead gramma too. We don't care, we just need one more person to put on the left side of our network, and you'll get a $100 bonus. And, if you act today, we'll throw in 2 free nights in Vegas! (Sorry Mr. Nugent, don't take it personally, I just don't like your company! Oh, and Mr. Nugent, have you ever had to stay at the Holiday Inn in Paris? 1801 Marian I don't think you'd like it...) Personal Travel 1802 kathryn annelli get rid of them 1803 Mary Ann Raudibaugh 1804 Randy Laub Boscov's Travel Lebanon 1805 David Hauser Cruise Value Center 1806 joanne karas 1807 Lisa Rohrbach 1808 Donna Mantie We are Travel Professionals and it takes time to reach this 1809 caroline mitchel status Euro Russia Travel 1810 Susann Fleener, CTA, MCC 1811 Janice Klash 1812 Teri Raymond I hope all suppliers will follow Royal Caribbeans lead A World of Travel This is so wrong because those of us whom came up through the ranks and paid our dues and we have a passion for the 1813 Joyce Washington business 1814 Katina Khan-Watkins 1815 Sally Thiele 1816 Maryann Carlson 1817 Shirley Reeves CTC 1818 Barbara Miller 1819 Caryl Ladd 1820 Christine M. House 1821 Dawn Tresenrider Professional Travel Agents spend years (not 400.00) to 1822 Scott Caddow become qualified to be called Travel Agents. The Cruise Place 1823 Isabella Deisley Boscov's Travelcenter Thanks RCCL. We appreciate your support! Hopefully more 1824 Linda Rader suppliers will follow your lead. 1st Choice Travel 1825 Leslie Edwards, CTC TA for 35 years!! Edwards LaLone Travel Inc

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 63 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1826 JOANNE DECHAINE WORK TOO HARD FOR MY PERKS!!!

1827 Clay Carter OK all suppliers - Follow Royal Caribbean & Celebrity's lead. Carter Country Travel 1828 IRENE M EMMONS,CTC GLOBAL EXPRESS CRUISE AND TRAVEL 1829 HELEN LUCY RENWICK, CTC G:LOBAL EXPRESS CRUISE AND TRAVEL 1830 shelley luskey 1831 LINDA RICHMOND, CTC Global Express Cruise and Travel 1832 Paula Quon, CTC All MLM should be banned from selling travel products Supreme Travel 1833 Cheryl Nestico-Venier Affordable Travel Inc. 1834 Joanne Gardner, CTC THE Travel Specialist 1835 NORIMAR CAMPOS PANORAMA TRAVEL, WILSONVILLE, OREGON 1836 Jack Forman 1837 mindy Carnese Thank you RCCL for recognizing the value and distinction 1838 Ilene Koenig, CTC between true travel professionals and imposters. Let's Travel - Santa Monica, CA 1839 Rodney Rodgers, CTA Another slap in the trained professionals face. Precision Travel, Inc. 1840 Julie Bailey -Owner, Excursions, LLC 1841 christine jeynes please look at "protravel" imagine holidays 1842 Gregg Murasso

1843 LOUISE MCCABE TRAVEL AGENTS WORK HARD FOR THE CRUISE LINES BOSCOVS TRAVEL

we are in a small town, and YTB agents are just starting to rear their ugly heads in our area! They are trying to woo people with false claims and advertising. And they completely unexperienced and have no business in the travel industry. As you said they are merely a MLM and trying to get travel agent 1844 julie hoffman discounts by paying cost for their travel. Effingham Travel Agency Thanks, my congratulations to RCI, other vendors please 1845 Robbert van Bloemendaal follow suit. CWT/All About Travel 1846 Bonnie Wyandt I think this is a great thing! Boscov's Travel Lebanon 1847 Sylvia Levin Let'sTravel (Santa Monica california) 1848 Donna K. Cravens cheapens our industry!!! 1849 Ron Cowan Bristol Travel Incentives 1850 BARBARA NEISTAT It's about time. I am tired of my profession being cheapened 1851 Christine McCabe by these so called "agencies" Harbor Light Cruises and Travel

Considering I was burned when I first started out in this industry by one of these lovely people while trying to be a legitimate agent and they STILL owe me money...they need to go. It's time to shut 'em down so they stop ripping off the 1852 Renee Daigle people and people who REALLY want to be travel agents. 1854 Allan R Hoffman III CTC DS MCC Hoffman & Hoffman International

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 64 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1855 Yana Naber Boscovs Travelcenter 1856 Tamara Breidegam Boscov's Travelcenter I agree so-called "card-mills" need to go!! Just don't classify Professional Host Agencies, such as Joystar, Inc., as a "card- mill". We, as Profressional Travel Agents, work hard for our clients. If RCCL wants to classify us as a "card-mill" company, then they are the potential losers, not us. We will take our clients elsewhere! It would be nice to have a "card", but guess what, as an Affiliate with Joystar, INC., we must first follow Industry Requirements to obtain them. Thanks 1857 Lisa Ayres Joystar for all of your support! Vacations Galore by Lisa an Affiliate of Joystar, INC 1858 Onassis Pertuz 1859 Onassis Pertuz A real travel Agent for 26 Years of Hard Work Travel by Onassis 1860 SYLVIA FROMMER-MRACKY Am frustrated that they exist. Production Travel & Tours 1861 Kerry Banwart Ark To Air Travel LLC 1862 Paola Costantino 1863 Chris Morse Corporate Travel USA 1864 Mary E. Backous This is a good thing...too many phonies 1865 Sandra Peters 1866 Lois B Brooks Cruise Fantasies Ltd. 1867 HilahJane Hawkins Canum Travel--Gilroy Ca 1868 Rhonda Fitzgerald That's to RCCL for supporting us and helping us to be 1869 Lorelle Hardt recognised as a professional industry again. 1870 Ronald S. Mracky Production Travel & Tours 1871 Connie Cunningham We need to be rid of these imposters. Thank you RCCL. 1872 Doreen Allen. A.C.C. Great idea. and not before time. Worldwide Distinctive Cruising 1875 marie henley We trained agents have worked hard for our privileges and 1876 Carol Phillips Blue, MCC want to keep them as earned benefits 1877 Raymond Lunz This is the best way to correct this problem. Cruise Planners/Udreamtravel Congratulations on finally differentiating between hard working 1878 David E. Miller full time travel agents and card mills. Imperial American Express Travel Services Nothing in our industry makes me as frustrated as "fake agents". Maybe we should take a closer look at the CLIA card 1879 Doreen W. McDonald give away. Your Personal Travel Consultant 1880 LINDA BOERNER YELLOW BIRD TRAVEL 1882 Rob Gillmore Venture Travel Center 1883 Debbie Barbara 1884 Rhonda Drayer CTA 1885 Rhonda Drayer, CTA 1886 Kay Mitchell

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 65 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company When I attend a cruse line seminar to update my skills, I just love sitting next to a former client who's got a "card" and came 1889 LINDA BLUM for a free lunch. ADVENTURE PRO TRAVEL 1890 laurence peters ctc over 30 yrs full time how would u expect me to feel modesto travel company Most MLM travel agents are not travel agents at all. Booking travel should be left to skilled professionals who deserve the benefits of their hard work and increase product knowledge 1891 Leslie Ickowitz through destination exploration. 1892 Rafi Lunz Cruise Planners 1893 ALFRED MICHAEL PRECISION TRAVEL, INC 1898 Pam Yerby Your Travel Agent It is totally unexceptable and a real put-down for the honest hard working real travel agents that our supplers would honor 1899 Nancy Haney anyway belonging to a card mill. 1900 Joni Notagiacomo CruiseOne 1905 Gisele Morris I work hard to keep a client. 1906 jennifer issendorf 1907 Bridget Dignle 1908 Michael Malaney Carlson Wagonlit Travel R and B International Travel, Instructor for the Travel and Tourism Program at PTEC - Pinellas Technical Education 1909 Inna Reznik Center I'm all for weeding out the travel agent "want to be's" who are just in it for the perks. My 40+ hours per week is what puts food on my table and my agents here in the office feel the same way! We have all worked hard at becoming professional travel agents furthering our educations with CTC's, CTA's MCC's etc. I'm all for rigid standards and 1911 Laura Baker licensing! Berger Travel Agency Inc. I work very, very hard for my clients, so it is nice to get a few perks now and then; I don't appreciate freeloaders getting 1912 Deborah Hicks those perks for being a fake travel agent. Travel One of Indiana, INC 1913 DENISE CONFORTE 1914 Gina Gulinska 1915 Fritzi Lurton I agree with RCL Boscovs Travel Dover 1916 Jennifer Lloyd 1917 Charles Quevedo 1918 Margie VanWynsberghe 1919 Jo Via Star Vision Travel 1920 Robert Haynie Haynie Travel/American Express 1921 Daniel Beach Cruise & Travel Masters 1922 Lori Fowler Boarding Pass Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 66 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company A true professional should be treated as such and those of us who qualify should not be selling through companies that 1923 Toni J. Stanley, CTC endorse and condone these non-professionals. All Destinations Travel, LLC 1925 Mary Jo Cohen Suburban Worldwide Travel Agency 1926 Camellia Pohl Gulliver s Travel 1927 donald j. carlson courtyard travel, inc., tustin, california 1928 Joanne Baker Anything that is too good to be true is probably too good to be 1929 Martha Brannan true BRANNAN TOURS 1930 Cathy Olesen 1931 Denise Terkosky, ACC Thank you! 1932 Paula Heyman Good Work! Boscov's Travelcenter And I THANK you for including JOYSTAR in the card mill line 1933 Teresa L. Gilbert up!!!! TEC Tours & Cruises 1934 SUSAN PELUSO, CTA What a scam!!! NEW HORIZONS TRAVEL, ATLANTA GA I am tired of hearing being a travel agent is no big deal anyone 1935 Linda Mitchell can do it. Be There Travel 1936 Caroline Acuna Please hear us Terra Nova Travel 1937 Dave Blackburn Encourage everyone in your office to sign! Active Travel 1938 O A Glenn Guyway Travel Services Inc 1939 Devin Hansen Sunflower Travel We have been in business since 1979 & weathered a LOT of change.Earlier this year the local real estate agent did a neighborhood drop of a booklet touting her professionalism- the back page,8x11 was devoted to signing on to a mill,via her husband,so everyone could be a TRAVEL agent & reap the 1940 Barbara Holland discounts AS THEY WERE DOING! Michael Holland Travel Ltd 1941 Susan Campos Pacific Heights Travel 41 years as an agent - We career agents are ridiculed when former clients let us know they now receive the "same perks" that "all agents" do! Whatever happened to "partners in 1942 Cynthia Major, CTC CAAS travel"? 1943 Anastasia L. Schuster, CTC FROSCH 1944 Janice Jacobs Kudos to RCI for taking the first step! Travel Travel 1945 Jacquelin Lybbert Cruise and Travel Masters 1946 Elaine Hamilton 1947 Gayle Botti In 100\% agreement! Let's Travel! 1948 Linda Gunther Travel Travel, Irvine glad to hear that YTB is targeted. They charge people a 1949 Rachel Swarrs monthly fee to work as an "agent" Travel Travel at the Mark

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 67 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company I just spoke with a woman the other day that is involved in this very thing. She had me look something up and then disappeared. So these people are using the expertise of a travel agent and then sell the travel to a client or buy it 1950 Cindy Arbogast Royer themselves. Boscovs Travel 1951 Vonnie Hicks First Class Travel & Tours, Inc. 1952 Susan Wasolek 1953 Hank Pawski We Must Stop YTB & Unprofessional Host Agencies Town Plaza Travel LLC 1954 Debbie Lotz 1955 PAUL AND MARIKA LUTHRINGER i am glad you are finally doing something about this AROUND THE WORLD TRAVEL 1956 Dottie Burke Boscov's Travelcenter 1957 Shawn Byfield 1958 Donna Marko Great move by RCI - looking for more suppliers to do the 1959 Catherine Johnston same. We've supported you, it's time to support us. Travel Creations 1960 Kim Kinsman Boscov's Travel I lost a group of 20 to YTB. The leader of that group purchased her credentials from YTB, rebooked with them, got a discount for herself and a commission on the other 19 1961 Cecil T Salmon passengers! These card mills are killing an industry that is difficult at best. 1962 CLAUS VAN DYCK, CTC, ACC 1963 Renita Cervantes Why are our professional associations NOT speaking out with force??? After 30 years of training and certifications 1964 Pam Hauswirth, CTC etc...... means NOTHING !!!! Escapes Travel 1965 Marla Mehring Gannon Travel Associates 1966 Patricia Cronin Cronin Cruises and Travel 1967 Kathy Uroff, CTA 1968 Patricia Frye 1969 Carrie Mezes Travel Creations 1970 Debie Parker Crossroads Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 68 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

Joystar hates card mills! Before ever mentioning the Joystar name, in the same breath, grouping, or comparing Joystar with YTB, please check the facts. There are only 2 people in the world who ever called Joystar anything other than a PROFESSIONAL HOST AGENCY and they were and still are very mistaken. If anyone does the research, they will find out that Joystar is not, will not be, nor has ever been a card mill, MLM, nor encourages their agents to simply sell themselves their own travel or to refer people to a website for fulfillment. It is simply not true. I have been with 2 hosts prior to Joystar, and researched Joystar for over a year prior to joining them because they have the one of best programs, support, and vision. I challenge anyone and everyone to provide just a hint of real evidence to prove Joystar is anything other than a very 1971 JERRY TAPP strong fast growing professional host agency. 1972 john bernatz huntington harbour travel 1973 Cheryl LeBoeuf 1974 Jean Williams 1975 Sherry Conley

RCCL should be congratulated, The card mills seem to be just what those who what to sell more direct are after, maybe thats why we hvae such long waits with ccl when we are trying 1976 Marvin Matteson to get thru on the rare occasion that we call them K & M Tra vel, Inc Zephyrhills, FL 33542 1977 Brenda F. Baty- Smith Ambassador Cruises 1978 Barry Donnan IATAN Agent since 1994 Nexion/At home 1979 Judyth M. Jackson Tour operators should follow RCCL's lead also. Travel Connections 1980 Pascale LeJeune CM Travel is a card mill agency in Seattle, WA Issaquah Travel 1981 Nancy Walker Sunset Travel

Unearned FAM's are the least of it - MLM's take our clients by telling everyone they can be an agent. We have lost one group to an Inteletravel member who told group members they 1982 Corinne Waterbury could join, earn commission and get TA discounts Zenith Travel 1984 Antoinette Scott 1985 Steve Clark Carolina Cruise/Travel 1986 Jose' M. Brito Deluxe Travel Ltd. 1987 marylou cantarella world travel bureau I had a passenger who became a YTB agent told me that she could have paid the trip she took from me on the Golden Yangtze Discovery for 15 days to China for $ 600 and not $3000 as per the tour operator. She had been recruiting 1988 Sharon Geraneo some of my passengers to join this MLM.

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 69 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 1989 Alex 1990 Carol I strongly agree with this petition! 1991 BERNA SORSCHER I have been fighting this for years. I have written to Travel Trade and John Stone has been investigating many of these. 1992 Sharon Emerson, CTC, ECC, DS I am so glad the supplier's are finally on our side. 1993 Walter W. Rice Waldorf Travel Service 1995 Rebecca Sommers-Giek Dugans Travels 1996 Lenni Curl 1997 Ardyth Howard 1998 Ardyth Howard 2000 Ann Cardena, ACC Uniglobe In-House Innovations in Travel ITS about time that something was done! KUDOS to RCCL 2001 susette whitfield and for those who got this Petition going Cruise Outlets and Travel 2002 Rachel Lowe 2003 Eric Karl 2004 corinne goligers travelplus 2005 Jacqueline Mizon disgraceful and unacceptable Lasalle Travel Services 2006 Bonnie Sandberg 21 years in the industy Great Escapes Travel Shoppe 2007 Chad Morton 2008 Traci Hildreth 2009 William P. Lyons, Jr., M.C.C., D.S., L.S. B & B Travel, Inc. 2010 Barbara Lyons, A.C.C., D.S., L.S. B & B Travel, Inc. 2011 Barby White Wanderlust Travel 2012 TERRY L. HAND CruiseOne As a 25 year professional, it has been sad to see our commisions taken away by the ailines. Having to also loose our hard earned commissions and dwindling benefits to these 2013 Pam MacLennan bogus "agencies" is the ultimate insult. Focus On Travel 2014 Pam Heuerman Effingham Travel Agency 2015 Napoleon Zambrano I only wish you good luck to solve this matter Best Travel And Tours Please stop MLM in the Travel Industry! Real bonafide Travel Agency are trying to carve out a living in an Industry that we are very passionate about. These organizations undermine the whole Travel Industry. Tour Operators & Cruise Lines; please take a stand against MLM in our beloved industry. Kudos to RCCL for initiating this action, hope to see more 2016 Laure Poffenberger vendors follow their lead. Travel & Cruise Vacations-Bellville, Texas

2017 Steve Perillo We have just cut off YTB and are now looking at the others. Perillo Tours 2018 Cynthia Brewer Yes, let's finally clean-up our travel industry!!! Travel Travel Irvine 2019 Janet Bonafede 2020 Jeanette Furman it's about time sthg is done about this problem LYNX INTERNATIONAL 2021 Jessilyn Carver Help my best friends leave the big scam Carlson Wagonlit Travel Network

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 70 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 2022 Maria L Allen Anytime Travel 2023 Joan Hyman LYNX INTERNATIONAL 2024 Sydney Cohen GO GET THEM Lynx International 2025 mary p bliss I am a owner of a small agency and would like to continue giving quality and professional service to consumers as we 2026 Akiko Matsuno have done for the past 30 years! AMGM, Inc dba Season's Travel 2027 Joanne Knable 2028 Ingrid Hunnewell Great news! Carlson Wagonlit Travel Thanks to RCCL for taking action on this. Hopefully all others 2029 Barbara (Penny) Smith will follow suit. 2030 Mark Bliss Travel Agents Unite! Bliss Travel Inc 2031 Gwen Fromme 2032 Laura J Childress All About Travel, Inc 2033 Patricia EdmundsonCTC,MCC Thank you RCL Your Personal Travel Consultant 2034 rose sutton effingham travel they are destroying the credibility of hard working, well trained 2035 Lynn Ferrara travel agents & abusing the few perks we have left. The Travel Designers 2036 Phyllis G Mackey Small World Tours & Cruises, Inc 2037 Gerrie Flores 2038 Sandy Schmidt Travelmax

To those of us who actually consider this a profession, this is long overdue. To allow untrained, inexperienced and self- serving consumers to represent themselves as travel agents demeans the entire profession. This should be just the beginning of a long concerted effort to rid our industry of such unprofessional influences. In accordance with that it would also be in our interest to do more to educate the public on the difference and do more to steer them toward bona fide agents 2039 Rosie Katz and agencies. Thank you for doing this. Yankee Clipper Travel I feel that it is definitely time to clean up our industry. Airlines, cruise lines, hotels, etc need to reward agents/agencies which are legitimate, work hard to sell their products, and are trying 2040 Wanda Bonham to survive in this industry. Taylor Made Travel Co Inc 2041 Natasha Nester 2042 Stephanie D. Chavis Travel Time Cruises 2043 robert mitchell contra costa travel 2044 wendy daniels Thank you Travel Management Systems

2045 Luegenia Most of them really don't know anything about selling travel. Prestige Travel Systems 2046 Ken Voige YTB and other MLM need to be ousted Cruise & Tour Specialists

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 71 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company A member of YTB came in to our office to see if would sign up with them. I decided to go to a meeting to get more information about the company, so when I was asked about it I would have all the information. I was outragged by the presentation in which they said, No experience necessary. Whether you went to Yale or just got out of jail. (Followed by 2047 Jennifer Bowser laughter) Travel Managment Systems St. Peters, Missouri 2048 GARY W FROEMMING CTC 2049 Kathie Hosmer Agency for 8 years! eTravelAway.com 2050 Donna Girolami Wozny Travel Inc 2051 Steve Jones Custom Travel 2052 Kim Moxom Hoorah! 2053 Debbie Taylor Vendors need to support 'real' travel agents Bear Creek Travel 2054 Jackie Vander Zwan Bear Creek Travel It is about time we take a stand with the "card mills". I can not tell you how many times I myself have been approach by a YTB or other card mill member toting that they travel like a 2055 Denise Zencka agent without ever selling travel. All About Travel- St John Indiana 2056 Lina DiCola I agree! Cruise Planners 2057 Anna Saltis Bear Creek Travel 2058 melinda johnson I'm so glad this is happening. I got approached by another MLM Scam, www.worldventures.com. They supply IATA numbers to their members, my friend is in it for the travel 2059 Debbie Norwitz deals. All of these Mills hurt legitimate travel agents. Adventure Travel, LLC 2060 Lise O'Donnell 2061 Alfred Archer Archer Cruise Connection 2062 Chris Alfonso Zambo's Travel by Design 2063 Andrea Kaubris Only The Best Travel I've worked hard to learn and get my Certifications in the Travel Industry. I don't think it's fair for someone to be able to 2064 Gina Richards buy their way into this Industry and reap the benefits. 2065 Alan Ickowitz 2066 Bruce Burns Thanks to RCCL, CCL, going to step up? The Cruisecrafter 2067 Leonard Wohletz A serious threat to our industry! Pres, Welcome Aboard Travel, Reno

2068 Carol McConnell Very important to the Professional Travel Agency Community Around The Globe Travel 2069 edward goldberg let professional agents do the work. dewitt travel & cruises 2070 pauline goldberg travel agents are a professional group. dewitt travel & cruises 2071 marlea j goldberg way to go rccl dewitt travel & cruises Where are "CARNIVAL & NCL" and the other CLIA 2072 RICHARD DAVIDSON members???????? Cruise Planners 2073 Janet Hindbo I work hard to be a professional, my job is my livelehood! Bayview Travel Ltd. 2074 Lori M Nelsen

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 72 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 2075 Pete Peterson Cruise Planners 2077 Anna McCord Cruise Planners 2078 Carol Schraeger Firmly support this move by the Cruise Lines! Cruise Planners 2079 Richard Schraeger Cruise Planners 2080 Marti Gooding Four Seasons Travel West 2081 Diane Rudolph 2082 Jerry Tomkinson The Tomkinson Group 2083 BRAD CASE 2084 Shelly Boedeker 2085 Byron Chrisler Cut the head off the snake. Heartland Cruise Planners, Inc. 2086 john robinson old capital travel 2087 Faye Steiner Cruise Planners, Inc. 2088 Diana Blalock Cruise Planners 2089 Cheryl Jones Thank you Custom Travel 2090 Deborah Smith 2091 LINDA OLENIK 2092 Sharon Viotto Cruise Planners 2093 Melody G Sands Cruise Planners 2094 Marla DeCero All About Travel, St. John, In.46373 2095 Walter Guptill Cruise Planners 2096 Pat Haynes Travel Center 2097 JoAnne Weeks 2098 Susan McCarley MK Travel and Tours, Inc. 2099 Tina Griffin Cruise Holidays 2100 Barbara Arendt Cruise Planners 2101 Tracy van Assendelft League City Travel, Inc. 2102 Ailid Beckstrom Williamsburg Travel 2103 Bill Calvin good work Ship To Shore Travel former District sales manager with RCCL now and agent 2104 Deborah McNair selling cruises. 2105 Andy Obot We are not selling Avon Products. Dove Travel and Cruises Intl. 2106 DOREEN THOMAS I just completed a rigorous travel agent course that required passing a 100 question test. I'm offended that YTB can call themselves travel professionals without having any travel 2107 Linda De St Jean education All About Travel 2108 thomas brown seaside travel 2109 Nora Slack 2110 scott wacker ci travel 2111 Diane Brock 2112 SheriLee Burton Bear Creek Travel 2113 Linda Brown

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 73 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company Let's separate the wheat from the chaff - stop kowtowing to 2114 Susan Bryker card mills! Travel Planners 2115 Debbie Clauson Bliss Travel Inc. 2116 Jenifer Snyder By taking this stand , it will only make the Industry stronger and better to service the client, and after all isn't that what its 2117 Janine Elder all about. TravelSeeker4u 2118 mona quiroz access to travel 2119 ken hooper access to travel This is long overdue. How can any company want to offer travel benefits to someone who is not really in the business of selling travel. Kudos to those companies who are taking a 2120 Ada Brown stand against "card mills." 2121 Adrianus Khoe against this activities Vacation Planner 2122 Maria M. Khoe Vacation Planner Travel 2123 Patty Lenczewski 2124 Stella Harsono against this activities Vacation Planner 2125 dottie bresset 2126 Judy Drucker 2127 Monica Shaw 2128 Stephony Duda 2129 Dirk Schmitz Accent Travel I would like to see a stop to this, as this is ruining Travel Agents. I just talked to someone that's supppose to be a Certified Agent with Traverus, which is like YTB a pyramid. The people that they recruit or referrals sign up they are automatically Certified Agents and receive a card, and they 2130 Vivian Rollins will start training after they receive their cards. Viviano's Cruises & Tours, Inc. Our industry should assert control of itself & stop the frauds 2131 Kirk Dalrymple from demeaning its value. Yankee Clipper Travel 2132 Ken Baker The MLM Travel Agents are flooding the industry and ruining the industry for everyone legitimate - whether it be Agents or 2133 Martha Conway Vendors.

The dcard mills do a great diservice to the travel industry and those people who have invested time, education and money into the business of selling travel. We end up having to clean 2134 William Mault up the card mills customer problems all the time. L & L Travel 2135 SEIRRA LAUGHHUNN CROSS COUNTY TRAVEL

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 74 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company Legitimate agents are the suppliers' best avenue for longterm sales growth because that is also the legitimate agent's primarary goal. The succesfull MLMer's primary goal is to recruit a downline that recruits more and more people who will recruit more and more people and etc., the sales of a successful MLMer are a distant secondary concern to their 2136 Graham McCormick business plan 2137 Gerry L:yons We need to stop this insanity! Best Connection Travel, Inc. 2138 bobbi brown brick and mortor owner,25 years empress travel,westbury ny 2139 Alex Caylor CruiseOne 2140 michael dargan 2141 Robert Cook 2142 Cindy Throne This needs to stop NOW CruiseOne 2143 John J Powell Cruise Planners 2144 Robert A Louchheim Thanks for your efforts Travel Destinations, Inc. Scottsdale, AZ 2145 Colleen Robinson CruiseOne

Heard at a YTB seminar - No experience necessary - go to Penn State or just get out of the State Pen, this is the company for you ! I find it hard to imagine why any reputable wholesaler would ever consider doing business with a 2146 Diane Gibson company or person that has this type of business philosophy. Travel Management Sstems 2147 Julie Godden 2148 Donna Pierce All Aboard for Travel 2149 JACI ANN MILAN CRUISEONE 2150 Bonnie Waite Preferred Travel 2151 Robin Mazzerina 2152 Christi Sanders Travel Management Systems 2153 Beth Cunningham About Travel 2154 John Lindlof, CTC, MCC 2155 zofia spagnuolo 2156 Donna Caruso First Class Travel 2157 Debi Steele Brookside Travel 2158 Nell Poston CruiseOne 2159 Ray Schutter 2160 ROSEMARIE RADOSSICH aaa worldwide travel - fair lawn nj 07410 2161 Ken Preuss It is now time for other vendors to step up E Travel Unlimited Pass this one to legitimate agents so they can help raise the 2162 Angela da Silva hew and cry. 2163 Kathryn Cianciolo CruiseOne 2164 Marlys Aballi It's About Time!!!! Connection to Cruise 2165 George C Aballi Connection to Cruise 2166 Eli Deutsch American Vacation Center

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 75 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 2167 Marsha Spring 2168 M A Davino Stop the Nonsense with the MLM's in reality they help NO 2169 Jim Rozelle ONE, yes that includes you Carnival! CruiseOne 2170 JERRE MARTIN ABOUT TRAVEL 2171 Janice Kuykendall CruiseOne 2172 Alan Brauning CruiseOne 2173 rod roberts 2174 Debra Roberts CruiseOne 2175 Christopher Bishopp CruiseOne 2176 Rick Cabaniss Many of these agents don't have a clue of how to service the client and it makes agents all over look like ragtag salespeople. There is a lot of work in booking travel for people and this operation cheapens and minimalizes all of the hours, research and training that legitimate agents submit to 2177 Christol Powell year after year. Escape Travel This must stop! These types of companies ruin the image of 2178 Beverly Bentley hard working legitimate agents and agencies.. Bentley Travel Services 2179 Maurice Thurston Precision Travel, Inc. 2180 James Herrin CruiseOne 2181 Drake Hiller Ace Travel House, Inc. 2182 Ben Slater 2184 Susan Cuervo CruiseOne This industry has enough challenges already! There is NO 2185 Sandra Scott way this should be allowed to happen! MAP Travel Co. 2186 Robert Bush Travel With Joy 2187 Sally Armiger CruiseOne 2188 Diane Minnich Any vendor who rewards these shams doesn't deserve our 2189 David Barquist respect or business! CruiseOne It's about time that something is being done to rid these card 2190 Ann Weiner mills. A & A Travel 2191 Bob Wood UNI-Travel Cruises & Tours 2192 Katherine Killen 2193 Pati Russell Pleasant Travels 2194 Dona Weller CI Travel 2195 Diane Amodio, ACC AAA Worldwide Travel 2196 Edwin Stanley Escape Travel 2197 roseann goffredo 2198 t james schwartz its about time Windsor Travel Corp. 2199 Jackie Tucker Cross County Travel 2200 mohamed habal aaa north jersey

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 76 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 2202 Jane Inserra 2203 LINDA CHAGARIS AAA NORTH JERSEY 2204 Laura Ell 2205 RODDEY MILLER THOMAS TOURS 2206 Katherine Ryan Cruise One 2207 claudine r. auge' the travel store inc. 2208 Jeanne Fischer Thanks for trying to get rid of the card mills. Travel Connection 2209 Kay Allred Help the legitimate ones! CruiseOne 2210 Ed Gagliardo CruiseOne 2211 linda paganucci 2212 Vermelle P. Smith CruiseOne 2213 Elaine Nolan CruiseOne Card mill agents are one of the reasons so many people distrust travel professionals. So many card mill "agents" are 2214 Kim O. Bennett poorly trained and provide substandard service The Travel Co. of Columbia, Inc. 2215 Myrna Cohen About time somehing was done 2216 Robert Cardaneo 2217 Barbara Sabula Thanks for getting it started! Perfect Journeys

I applaud RCCL for their brave step to eliminate MLM companies and support the traditional travel professional. We traditional agents as well as myself have worked many long hours, expended large amounts of monies to train ourselves to provide the client excellent service. These MLM companies cheapen the value of the traditional travel agent as most know very little about seervicing a client. One bad experience with a MLM referring agent makes the whole industry look like idiots. Thanks again RCCL!! Carnival, you need to jump on 2218 Marcelene Rucker the band-wagon and along with RCCL become a forerunner. Just-N-Time Travel Inc 2219 Barbara Payne CruiseOne 2220 Kathy Eng CruiseOne 2221 Marilyn Bennett The Travel Co. of Columbia INC. 2222 Melinda S. Csergei, CTC Your Travel Place/Outside Sales/Forest Grove, OR 2223 Mary Petty 2224 David Kunze, CTC 2225 Roseann Freeman Spring House Travel 2226 Kathy Lebryk All About Travel 2227 Laura Avital Mill Brook Travel 2228 Jessica Thompson Fairway Travel Services Rep of American Express 2229 Prill Hurst 2230 Tami Farley 2231 Robert M. Overholt CSV, Inc. d/b/a Carol's Travel 2232 Victoria Anthaume I hope all the cruiselines join RCCL Cruise One

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 77 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 2233 Brooke Peterson The Travel Co 2234 Chris Anthaume The vendors should realize these card mills will negatively 2235 Brian McPhillips affect them as well as us The Travel Co. of Columbia, Inc. 2236 Kate Koziol K Squared Marketing and Public Relations 2237 melissa ochoa 2238 Betsi Jordan this cheapons the industry, you have these say so agents with no knowledge or experience trying to sell products they know 2239 Barbara Nelson nothing about 2240 Glenn Jones  CruiseOne 2241 Jeni Miller 2242 Phyllis Nolan Travelplex 2243 Sandra Gibbs Paradise Travels and Tours

Our agency has a host program and I manage Independent 2244 Deborah Freeman Contractors. Only our qualified agents received any benefits. CWT All ABout Travel 2245 Karin Milillo 2246 Michael McManus Thank you for doing this Overboard Cruises 2247 Debi Schneider We all work hard to help our clients and I resent being put into 2248 Angelika Johnson the same mold as these MLM people . One World Travel 2249 Sonja Michael CruiseOne 2250 Kathleen Sutter CTC, ECC, DS What has take so long for this to be addressed? 2251 Robert Schlobohm, ACC Protect the integrity of the Travel Agent profession. CruiseOne 2252 Teri Schaffer International Travel Consultants, Inc 2253 MARA HARGARTHER CRUISEONE

2254 SANDRA CHUTE I don't understand why they think they should get our perks! ALL ABOUT TRAVEL It's wonderful to know that someone has stepped up on behalf 2255 Rob Lane Cesareo of all Travel Industry Professionals. Thank you.

2256 Patrice Stafford I strongly feel that make believe agents should be prohibited. Liberty Travel 2257 Tom Merkens VILLAGE TRAVEL I was just doing a presentation for my local chamber, and one of the attendees was an MLM agent. All she could talk about was how much she was saving on her personal travel. She even gave me a flyer she has printed up that 2258 Donna Wilcoxson reads..."wholesale travel savings". Let's get rid of them. 2259 Tony Pendleton Travel Associats Inc. of Salisbury 2260 Karen McCrink, CTC 2261 Bonnie S.Roth we work hard to bring integrity to homebased business CruiseOne 2262 Jean Paterson Nomad Travel Agency 2263 Sarah Ausmus J. A. Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 78 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company After working in the travel industry for over 23 years, I feel that my profession has been cheapened and degraded by the underhand tactics of these slimey people who profess to being 2264 Pamela Kvidera, CTC DS "travel experts." 2265 Judy Bjorback it's about time and we appreciate your help Carlson Wagonlit Travel 2266 Aubrey Rogers 2267 Joe Avola 2268 Patricia Lubetzki CruiseOne 2269 John Martiss 2270 Lori McIntyre 2271 Lucy Vogliardo 2272 eileen gombos maybe we'll get respect back by the industry Travelhost Real Agency I commend Royal Caribbean for their actions against the MLM 2273 Tom Pullara card mills CruiseOne 2274 Ellie Swinney, CTC Finally, suppliers are getting wise to the abuse Carlson Wagonlit Travel 2275 William Morrison Morrison Travel & Cruise 2276 Susan Crozier Enerson I am a bonified agent with credentials 2277 Diana Donsbach 2278 Jacqueline Garmire 2279 Rosemary Siemens 2280 Charles DeRose MCC 2281 Darci Upham CruiseOne 2282 Harriet Roop thank you I started this fight 1 yr ago here in Murrieta, the 2283 Margaret D Jones, CTC inland empire region A-1 Tuscany Travel 2284 Patricia Barton encourage real agents to favor booking travel & cruise 2285 DAVID L. RICO companies that reject card mills and ytb type operations You Need A Vacation 2286 Laurence W. Page Pinnacle Travel LLC 2287 Nina J. Page Pinnacle Travel LLC 2288 Sandy Milis Joyful Journey Travel/ICT 2289 Rose Reckas 2290 Michael Brill Cruise One 2291 Tom Delaney CruiseOne 2292 Lori Mezzapesa Keep our profession professional! SeaMaster Cruises I have been solicited by YTB in a most distasteful way to become one of their agents. Don't you repect yourself by respecting what you do? I wouldn't want a dentist to work with 2293 Snow E. Piccolo me if he had no credentials either. Vacationquest, Inc. 2294 Chervyl Hammerley TraveLine 2295 Linda Cahill Cruise Planners 2296 Dolores Feldman Cruise Planners 2297 Linda Lundburg Cruise Planners

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 79 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 2298 Diane Rose Cruise Planners 2299 Carrie Erdman Ft Lauderdale Travel 2300 Janet Fong Brians Ft Lauderdale Travel Have "lost" clients( a Dr & family ) to this scam.They got their "agent " cruise after pricing with me & then told his "sordid" 2301 Michele Ramming tale. They are thieves of professionalism Sun Bird Travel Co. 2302 Sharon Lombardo I had to pay to go school I think everyone else should have to 2303 Carree Oltman have some education from a travel school 2304 Sab Hany Travel should be sold by professional travel agents only! encountered one with a sign made from cardboard and 2305 Amy Kafer construction paper at a local home show 2306 Marsha Rosner Rosner Travel/Partners In Travel 2307 Virginia Rioja 2308 Sydney J. Hosking Cruise Planners Sixteen years in the industry / Agent & Owner- Lots of hard work, continuing education and endurance through 911. Say 2309 Ruth Bradley goodbye to those just in it for the benefits! National Travel congratulations and kudos to RCCL - finally someone stepped 2310 Donna Davis up to the plate! Outland Travel 2311 Christopher Nigro AAA World Wide Travel 2312 Bette Mundine I absolutely agree with the statements in this petition! Bravo! Get Rid of them for those of us who are legitimate 2313 Robert McCall agents Your Ticket Out of Here Travel 2314 Becky Bownds

On a recent seminar at sea in Europe, two participants talked openly about the "cards" they bought so they could travel at reduced rates as travel agents, and they didn't even have to sell cruises" . They also received a CLIA card, with their membership in the MLM, which cost them about $495 each. The criteria for being accepted for the seminar at sea, was to 2315 BettyJo Vlay, CTC, MCC have your own CLIA card, which of course they each had.

If your are serious in stopping the MLM's, then require each travel agent to have a copy of their Errors and Omissions 2316 George J Vlay - MCC insurance policy with their name on the Agencies list. 2317 Sharon Comitz Way to start the balling rolling, RCI. Jewelcor Travel 2318 TONY LE FEVRE TRAVEL MASTERS 2319 Terry Wilsey, IGLTA, MCC A Destinaiton Travel/Altour/Signature 2320 becky moreau Androy Travel Service Inc 2321 Sue OKray Discount-All-Inclusive.com 2322 Janet Biermann ITA Travel Advisors, Inc.

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 80 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

MLM business model is nothing more then a scam designed to appeal to the 'get rich quick' and 'get something for nothing' crowd. It doesn't matter what they are selling, it's always the 2323 Linda Day same. Someone (up line) wins; someone (down line) loses. Il Viaggio - Ultimate travel to Italy 2324 Moe Rondeau already moved market share to RCCL / 3 times in 1 week CWT/Travel Advisors International - Lincoln, RI 2325 Mary Guccione ITA Travel Advisors 2326 Linda Harger CWT/Sunbeam Travel 2327 Gail Woloz Thank you! TravelStore 2328 Loreene Orgoralini Can I Go, Too? Travel 2329 DEBI WALLIN TRAVEL CONCEPTS 2330 Barbara Ford 2331 J. Michael Walker MLM types are just there for a quick FAM Sunset Travel, Grass Valley, CA 2332 Lauren Wickenhauser ITA Travel Advisors 2333 Sarkis Vakian Sidon Travel & Tourism, Inc 2334 Cathy Hunt Accent Travel Agency 2335 Ron Meadows stop the card mills now TLG 2336 Steve Biermann Nothing but pyramid schemes - not travel professionals 2337 David Hodgkinson 2338 Karine Yengulyan Sidon Travel & Tourism 2339 Jonathan Sutter Thank you, we have been waiting for this day! I HAVE BEEN ADVISED BY A YTB PERSON THAT EVERY AIRLINES IS PAYING THEM A COMMISSION FOR SELLING 2340 KAY KOSMICKI AIRLINE TICKETS COTTONWOOD TRAVEL CO. 2341 Keith Johnson Bulldog Travel 2342 Nathan Henry 2343 Kathy Haack Cottonwood travel 2344 Julie Alm Kudos to RCCL!!! Cottonwood Travel 2345 jody j. yetti jody's travel, inc

THE REST OF THE CRUISE LINES AND WHOLESALLER SHOULD JOIN RCCL , CELEBRITY & AZAMARA, THEY JUST DON'T HAVE THE BALLS TO DO IT. THEY WANT THAT OLD MIGHTY DOLLAR IN ANY WAY, SHAPE AND FORM. THANK YOU RCCL. I HAVE BEEN SUPPORTING FOR 16 YEARS AND WILL CONTINUE TO DO SO AS LONG 2346 MARTA PEREZ SALONIUS AS I AM IN THIS BUSINESS ROGERS TRAVEL 2347 ginny johannes 2348 Daniel Browning

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 81 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company IATAN needs to be held accountable for this blunder as well. After all, it is they who are issuing cards to anyone that sends in their $30 fee. Do away with the cards, and go back to verification of employment and valid productivity; that's the way is was before the card, and the problem will be 2349 Ron Algood eliminated. Traveleaders 2350 Debbie Goode, MCC CRUISE PLANNERS 2351 MICHELLE DAVIS, AZ TRAVEL CENTER thanks to RCCL. Globus/Cosmos should now step up to the 2352 Linda Leventhal plate. Lazy Days Travel 2353 Sofia Creque, CTC 2354 SANDRA R. CUNNINGHAM I am thrilled that the cruise lines are cutting them off Cruise One CARNIVAL FAMILY AND ALL OTHER CLIA MEMBERS -- ARE YOU GOING TO FOLLOW. AGENTS SHOULD SUPPORT THOSE SUPPLIERS WHO CARE ABOUT LEGITIMATE TRAVEL AGENTS AND RESTORE 2355 Gary Leventhal PROFESSIONALISM TO THE INDUSTRY Lazy Days Travel 2356 Deborah Tenney, (Elite) I think that this is a GREAT move! Thank you! Cruising to Paradise Inc. 2357 Judy Woods Damar Travel and Cruise 2358 Paula Publicover All About Travel 2359 barbara smith 2360 heather putnam 2361 Danny Gonzalez CruiseOne 2362 Alvertis Smith YTB/World Ventures/TraVersus/GTT need to go Blue Nile Travel Group 2363 La Tricia Austin-Downer Blue Nile Travel Group I have worked full time for 18 years as an indpendent contractor specializing in FIT European travel. People who buy a card, link a website and claim they are travel agents give those of us who have taken the classes, participate in destination specialist programs, and actually provide a service to our clients a bad name. I resent when someone who is in the business for the perks takes the space, at a seminar or on a fam, of someone who really needs the knowledge and experience to better serve their clients. Tour operators that do business with these individuals and companies should have Diamond Travel of Capistrano Beach/Travel Planners 2364 Ellen McDannel higher standards! International 2365 Sylvia Gonzalez CruiseOne 2366 Lisa Goff

Having been in the business for 25years it's nice to see the 2367 Ann Baucom cruise lines step up to stop this. I hope they all follow suit. Merced Travel 2368 Richard Walke SeaMaster Cruises 2369 Daniel Giordano 2370 Linda Van Buren, CTC

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 82 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 2371 Larry Spencer It's about time we all stand together! Chadds Ford Travel 2372 D James Sounds better than the agency I'm at. How do I join YTB? 2373 Jenny Hollinger Cruise Planners 2374 Cindy Grant Expert Family Travel 2375 Priscilla Adelman I have been in the tvl business for 21 yrs and this really has diminshed the worth of professional s in the travel business and this back door marketing is not about travel but to make the people who have created this scheme wealthy and take the quality out of not only the travel professionals but the 2376 Nancy DiGiglio traveler as a whole. Anyplace Travel of Johnston 2377 Helen Semak Outland Travel I have seen this business change over the years, but these card mills are not about travel, but to make money by exploting the persons signing up for this scam and cheapen the professional travel business. I can not think of any other 2378 alexia mancini industry that would allow this to go on. I know some who have bought their CLIA ID and get all the 2379 Suzanne Sloan discounts and have NEVER sold even one cruise! Dreamscape Group Travel 2380 Joan Janus 2381 Tracey Barbieri 2382 Katie Cadar TravelStore 2383 Jennifer Quimby, DS, LS Time Off Travel No more MLM Card Mills Already!! Thank you RCI and Celebrity! We will do more business with you because of this 2384 Nick Mageloff bold step. GRX, Inc. 2385 RUTHEL WALTON 2386 Roseann M. O'Rourke Traverus doesnt make money off of any products,they pay commissions mostly by their monthly fees,this is a nono because you have to have a real tangible product,this should 2387 mike mikovich be investigated 2388 Richard Johnson CruiseOne 2389 Carie Ann Duncan Canyon Lake Travel & Cruises 2390 Don Kirkorian The Cruise Doctor Travel Agency 2392 Richard J Fernandez MCC The Travel Address/Galaxsea Cruises 2393 Robert Bean MCC The Travel Address/Galaxsea Cruises I was at my local Safeway & was told by the checker that she & her husband had become Travel agent to get the perks. I 2394 Brandy Macken will no longer shop there. Brandys Travel Service Hopefully this petition will shut down the MLM Pyramid 2395 Sharon Johnson scheme that preys on innocent victims CruiseOne 2396 John McMullin,CTC This is giving home-based professionals a bad name Travel Professionals International 2397 James Dargan

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 83 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 2398 Patricia Smith Roger's Travel Agency Inc. Patchogue 2399 Alexandra Morlock 2400 Shirley Hockett Thank you for doing this. It's long over due. Travel Tips 2401 Sandy Chisholm Travel Concepts 2402 Tolun Cerkes 2403 Ruth Louie Best Connection Travel, Inc. 2404 Deborah Gibbons CruiseOne 2405 Gail Pensabene Spring House Travel 2406 Marion E. Orgettas, CTC 2407 Pat Conway YTB is the biggest scam going Travel Innovations 2408 Sherri Nelsen Nomad Travel Agency 2409 Ed Mani Burkhalter Travel 2410 Angel McCracken Aztec Travel Service 2411 Elaine Osgood 2412 Ortha Splingaerd All Travel 2413 Hollis J. Davis Julie's Travel Desk 2414 Shannon Routh 2415 Saskia Jensen 2416 Katherine Hartley 2417 Mike Jervis Great idea, let's hope all the companies listen. TJ Travel 2418 Malinda Hodge 2419 Vickie Morris 2420 PAM CARTER 2421 lauren richardson No Card Mills Union Vacations 2422 Linda Solywoda 2423 Joh Spellmann Jr This is one way to help save our industry 2424 Kathy Rettberg 2425 LISA FONDELL 2426 Anne Kulhanek Premier Travel LLC 2427 Antoinette Meliti Advantage Travel, Inc. 2428 Eileen Entin 2429 Doris Spellmann 2430 Brenda Walsh

2431 Marina S. Byrum, CTC Card mills are hurting the entire industry. Please stop them!! Ascot Travel 2432 harold penn 2433 Sandra Meyer 2434 Jodi K. Vandiver My Time Is Yours LLC 2435 Janet Fly Thank you for giving legitimate agents and agencies a way to 2436 Robin L. Bailey voice our concerns!!! Riverside Travel Service, Inc. Please do EVERYONE a favor and stop the card mills. This 2437 Sonia L. Robledo is a scam Riverside Travel Service, Inc.

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 84 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 2438 Mark L. Johnstone Sanborn's Travel Service 2439 Alan Hess 2440 Harry Walker Stop travel MTM Kona Kai Travel 2441 Sheryl Krom 2442 Jack vanHorn GO Go Go College Center Travel 2443 Esther Thomas Riverside Travel Agency 2444 Frances Moogan About time!!! London Travel Center, Santa Monica CA I am pleased that you are taking a stand against the "card mill agents", who with their representation, cheapen the hard work and dedication, we (the real travel professionals) provide for 2445 Pam Ubrun our clients. Riverside Travel Service, Inc. 2446 Charles Clark 2447 Marianna Meeks 2448 Terry Pohl stop the free ride Globetrotter Travel 2449 Sharon Stacey agent for over 25 years Having been in the travel industry 20 plus years, I am offended by people passing themselves off as agents when they have little knowledge or expertise in handling travel 2450 Ginger Minoletti arrangements. Bay World Travel

Their addition to the industry has forced us to have to accept 2451 Wilton M. Warnecke, JR 'dumbed down' formats that take longer to complete a sale. Ascot Travel 2452 Rhonda Shumway 2453 Dalen 2454 Vivistine Baylor I agree with Royal Caribbean Cruise Line International Tours MLM agents have caused the public to distrust and have a 2455 E. Patricia Coleman, MCC, Vacation Specialist negative opinion of legitimate agents. 2456 Maureen Ward Rennie Kitty Ward Travel, Inc AMEX Rep 2457 MELANIE ADAMS 2458 David Tinney 2459 Jo Ann Muzny Noel's World of Travel 2460 Shirley Matchett Thank you for the opportunity Golden Anchor Travel 2461 Ron Kinkade Only Fun Vacations / Travel Agent Pros 2462 Vicki Black Customer Service is #1 Stop the MLM Scams/Card Mills. Us professional agents 2463 Lisa Rapavi deserve more respect then that. CWT/TLG 2464 Carol Heminger Bay World Travel 2465 melissa kinion 2466 Sandy Rodley Via Verde Travel 2467 Marci Zied A Love of Travel

2468 Pamela Sanders I am strongly apposed after 18 years of exp erience and paying thousands for an accredited trade school. 2469 Ella Grondahl THANK YOU!!! Global Escapes Travel, Athens GA

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 85 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 2470 Leroy daleen 2471 Kathleen Johnson Via Verde Travel 2472 angie knop Thank you for doing this! EZ Travel 2473 Helen Baldovinos 2474 Vicki Freeman 2475 Gayla Tregre 2476 Manon C Kaplan Thank you for doing this RMK Travel 2477 Susan Carr The Travel Society LLC 2478 Colleen P. Miller have been an agency owner for 20 years, what a shame for our industry and hope other suppliers will realize the negative 2479 Darrell Hoffman effects of the MLM's Effingham Travel 2480 jenny mosier Effingham Travel thank you Royal Caribbean. It's time for other suppliers to 2481 Nancy F Yoffe, ECCS follow your lead. 2482 audrey domzalski 2483 Jason Little 2484 Gary Sheridan Strongly support this action ! TravelVacations 2485 betsey roberts THANK YOU for all your hard work in this regard Nelson Custom Travel 2486 Bob Motl AAA Auto Club South 2487 Roy Anderson This is long overdue 7 Seas Cruise Co. another abuse of the capitalist system which cheapens 2488 traci potgieter authentic work travel league, inc

It is irritating when their clients call our agency to obtain information such as whether or not a visa is required, general destination information, etc., when their AGENT should have been the one advising them. Usually "their friend, the agent" doesn't have a clue! I always refer them back to their own booking source. I think the public should be more educated about the importance of booking with qualified professionals in this business to protect their investment because travel is an investment in their well being. I also feel the general public has the misconception that all travel agencies are somehow subsidized by the government; therefore, it's okay for them to call us to obtain general information with regards to travel. They don't understand that we operate in a competitive business world and need to make money to survive. Because of this, we do our best to provide the best customer service so 2489 Nita Gesner, CTC, DS that we can retain our clientele. It is not a "hobby" for us. 2490 Suzanne Clem Riverside Travel Service 2491 Suzanne Dollman Thank you Royal Caribbean Ltd.! All Seas Cruises & Travel, Inc. 2492 Maureen Beach

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 86 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 2493 Porter Brown Travel Mania Vacations 2494 Beverly Brown 2495 Michael Gecht Hurray for Royal Caribbean International Travel Ease, Ltd. 2497 Michelle Benthall Park Place Travel 2498 Peter Johnson Anderson Travel & Cruises 2499 Melissa Michener 2500 Michelle Coupe YaY!!!!!!! We rock!!! Travel Discounters 2502 Deborah W Brantley 2503 dean fenton 2504 James Hartman Carlson Wagonlit Sun Lakes Travel 2505 Adrian Surgeon Efforts like these hurts the industry on a whole Antigua & BarbudaTourist Board 2506 Sandre E. Mitchell 2507 Elizabeth Tetlock 2508 Sharon Mageloff GRX Inc 2509 PJ Darnell 2510 Dana Rice 2511 Susan Micale  Destinations Unlimited 2512 John Cook 2513 Mary Rose Dobbs All-Ways Travel They are ignorant and give the professionals a bad name by 2514 Gillian Rosenthal their lack of knowledge. Travel Travel COS 2515 Julie Knaust 2516 Jeane Rozycki 2517 Connie Byrne Five Star Travel and Cruises 2518 Marilou Housman Five Star Travel and Cruises 2519 Dennis A. Hubbs, CTC/MCC the sooner the better! D&D Travel Services, LLC 2520 Donna L. Hubbs, MCC D&D Travel Services, LLC I applaud Royal Caribbean and will continue to support 2521 James Ehehalt companies like that Brookside Travel 2522 Holly Schaeferle Travel Solutions Group 2523 Corinne Reeves THANK YOU for starting this much needed process ! Nexion 2524 Debbie Johnson 2525 Hannah Lowry why should these un-professionals get the same benefits as 2526 andrea west the professionals?!?!? your travel agent, inc. 2527 Sandi Bainbridge Top Shelf Travel Agency 2528 Barbara Poczyniak Continental Travel Service Ltd 2529 Lisa Lewis 2531 Linda Markarian We work hard at our jobs Not just buy Paper work Gone with the Wind Travel 2532 Anne L. Schrader, CTC, ACC Dream Destinations 2533 Christine Folkins I hope this helps, its about time CSF Travel, Inc 2534 Adelheid Shillus CSF Travel, Inc

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 87 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company Thank you Royal Caribbean! Now to get the other cruise lines 2535 Tim Utzig to pay attention! Utzig Travel 2536 Bridget Dingle B Unique Travel 2537 Sara Gilbert 2538 Ms. Bobbi Adams, CTC,DS Carlson Wagonlit Travel Network Kent I almost fell for this but something told me not to do it. As a student of the travel and tourism industry I know how important is to have some certificate that accredits you as a professional. Lima, Peru and Peru, IL are not the same thing 2539 Maria Ramirez-Gregg to cite an example. 2540 Beverly Lewandowski CruiseOne 2541 Dawn Garvelink Cruise Together 2542 Richard Bowman 2543 J White 2544 Christina Laird 2545 Claudia Augustson Riviera Vacations/Cruise Planners 2546 Christopher Silva It is about time these card mills get the boot! Travel Planners International There are more than 3 of these companies, I would ask that hotels and cruiselines discontinue accepting clia cards as verified travel industry personnel. Full time realtors are calling themselves "travel agents" and using benefits that they don't 2547 Shary Dyer deserve American Expressex 2548 Rebecca Lewis CruiseOne 2549 Deborah Hughes CruiseOne 2550 Shelley Pyle Travel Planners International 2551 Guida Ferreira Atlas Travel Internatinal 2552 Jo-Anne Vadeboncoeur Atlas Travel International 2553 Terese M Ternullo THANK YOU Hibiscus Travel 2554 Terri Williams Card mill companies are a detriment to the travel industry and 2555 Kieron Keady the U.S. consumer Qantas Vacations 2556 Karen Walton Wings of Travel 2557 Vicki Fernandez 2558 Nancy Peklo-Nosal Design Travel Inc. 2559 Helen Himple Travel Meetings and Incentives 2560 Kathryn Shipman Voyages You should hear how they reel people in.Telling them they get 2561 Terrie Rodriquez free travel and free hotel suite upgrades Cottonwood Travel A Neighnor who knows nothing and does not want to sell travel just paid $500.00 to join YTB to save $$$ This is 2562 Devora Tweedell terrible!!!!! 2563 sue bruno 2564 Sam Cumpston 2565 Jessica Burton

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 88 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 2566 Gunilla Godebu Its time to end the card mills! CruiseOne 2567 Elise Perry 2568 Lynn Rueff PS Tours & Travel, Inc. 2569 Debra Myers Travel Marketing While there may be a few legitimate agents that are part of the MLMs, that does not make up for the thousands that are there only for their own travel benefits. I have been to travel seminars where these people have won travel prizes that should have gone to real agents. These people do not earn the commissions that other agents work hard to get by 2570 Peter Ulbrich servicing the customers of the travel suppliers. Holiday Cruise and Travel, Inc. 2571 EVELYN SPECTOR 2572 Elaine Pearson 2573 VICTOR SHIRY 2574 Barbara Hayes Franklin Great Escapes Travel & Tours 2575 Cindy Binkley

I have worked to hard for the card mills sell a scam this should 2576 Debbie Maier be stopped for the recpect of the travel professionals. Professional Travel Consultant 2577 Leonid Riley Bad News 2578 Carol-Anne Kendall-Pierik Advantage Ultra Travel 2579 Carol Ulinger CruiseOne 2580 JoEllen Luncher kudos to RCCL, Celebrity, Azamara Anywhere Travel Service

I have been to business gatherings that had upto 500 or more attendees. Safe to say about 5\% were YTBer's networking either walking around or with open displays indicating the easyness to be a travel agent.Flashing ID cards, intrupting when I was talking to potential clients, my way was old fashioned, you did not have to look out for your clients interest and trainiing was not needed. Along with this they were offering lower than the standard cruise prices by providing kickbacks. They also indicated that CLIA training was a waste of money. I have owned a franchise for over 6 years before I became comfortable that I had enough knowledge to start my own LLC. Most of that knowledge come through some form of CLIA training via the corporation or individual training. In order to provide the best to your customers you need to invest in experience and training. I have no problem with people making money as long as it is honest, ethical and the correct 2581 Edward G. J. Suhy Jr service was provided. MLM's don't cut it. ED'S TRAVEL & CORPORATE SEMINARS 2582 Shirley Rosiak 2583 Nicole McTague

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 89 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company Though a few are genuinely attempting to be Travel Agents, we all know the majority are doing it just for the benefits they didn't not rightfully earn or deserve. My Husbands best friend from HS just emailed us as to what a wonderful thing this was "For about 500 I can get the same benefits you guys get" OUCH ! ! ! (If someone handed you a candy bar would you 2584 Julie Davidson say NO ?) Cruise Planners The MLM "so called travel agents" are mining the "Real Travel 2585 Marta Izquierdo Industry"..It is about time to stop them ! Alameda Travel & Tours 2586 Sherri Keith 2587 Becky Jones It's unfortunate that these MLMs are allowed to operate. It's 2588 Donna Becker important that we stop them! Creative Travel Zone 2589 Andrew McKeown In the travel industry as a supplier 2590 Krista Maldonado 2592 Loyal B. Charles, CTC, MCC My hat is off to RCI/Celebrity./Azamara for not doing business with them! Hopefully all other cruiselines will follow and then 2593 Lisa Small hotels, car companies, etc. 2594 Tonya Hodgson ACC Cruise Holidays 2595 Sondra Glazer 2596 David Holman Dave Holman Travel Services 2597 marissa barker Save our professional trade name, with real agents. 30 yrs in 2598 Angela Lanktree the business. Cruise Savers Inc. 2599 michael webb Its hard enough being a Travel Agent without people abusing 2600 Bridget Sackett, ACC it Calypso Vacations 2601 Elaina Schlesinger 2602 Brian Conroy 2603 Tina Henson Salem Travel 2604 Lisa Rapavi Enough nonsense...stop the MLM already Carlson Wagonlit Travel 2605 Daniel Altman MLM Agents make us all look bad  With all the time, effort and years I have put in to this 2606 Sabine Crysler industry!!!!! 2607 Greg Beneby   2608 Lance Donovan It's time for Vendors to step up to the plate and recognize the experience, knowledge and value a travel agent provides. 2610 Nancy Nelson Please follow RCI's lead. CruiseOne 2611 Joyce Whiteford Keep travel agents professional Traveljoys Travel 2612 Ron Raridon

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 90 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company Only trained travel agents, who went to school, passed exams and are connecting to a legitimate travel agency should sell 2613 mariana behdjet travel. 2615 Sylvia Shattuck I am enraged! Worked 15 yrs for what? High Seas Travel We joined World Ventures about a year ago and realized soon after that we felt it was a MLM company charging fees for monthly dues. We tried desperately to reach a live person to stop our monthly payments, only to learn they didn't even have a telephone for us to call them on. We finally just stopped our payments. I hope they will be investigated as a Card Mill. We have since joined a valid travel agency that we 2616 Sharon Calvert are proud to be a part of. Grand Ventures affiliate of International Tours of Houston 2617 Gerri Staffiery Glad you are listening to real travel agents Great Cities Travel 2618 Richard Staffiery Great Cities Travel 2619 Gina Staffiery Great Cities Travel 2620 David Staffiery Great Cities Travel 2621 Betty Washington 2622 Rita Lawler 2623 Linda 2624 Deana Petro 2625 Roena Dumlao Capitol City Travel 2626 Penny Sheldon It's about time! Let's STOP this now. Penny Sheldon Travel 2627 Brenda Bodine Central Valley Travel 2628 rusha ouyang 2629 LOIS U. WATSON BAYWAY TRAVEL GROUP, INC. 2630 Shirley E. Shiry Granada Hills, CA. 2631 greta gilford we work hard to obtain an iata 2632 Lisa Derby Personal Travel Management Ltd 2633 Diane Palella Cruise Planners 2634 Margaret Joy ctc Praise for RCCL ! ValleyWestTravel 2635 Paula Hobble 2636 Sheila Vogel 2637 Debra E Edwards Luxury Voyages 2638 Jennifer Moss The Travel Store 2639 liz kharrat atlas travel international 2640 Cathy Knowlton 2641 Christine Johnson 2642 Juel A. Fitzgerald 2643 Grace Wincklhofer Thank you! It's about time. Cruise Planners 2644 Karen K Taufer, CTC Vacations Plus 2645 Pat O'Donoghue - Granada Hills, CA 2646 Patti Courville 2647 Aletha Ferguson Cloud 9 Travel

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 91 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 2648 Mary Hanson 2649 Ernest Lemoncelli MAXIMA World Travel Services, Lake Worth Florida Let's put an end to YTB and others like it. I work long and hard in this business, and make it a point to keep up with trainging and seminars, etc. Organizations like YTB cheapen our industry and professional image. Kudos to those suppliers 2650 Jeanni Prescan, ACC who have signed this petition. Cruise & Travel Quest, Owner 2651 Dee Shoaf Cruise and Travel Quest 2652 Adrienne Coates CAA British Columbia 2653 Dianne Morgan Cruise & Travel Quest AS an cruise specialist, I believe it is knowledge and service that is the value that the consumer needs and the partners (c/l's) need. This makes it a win-win-win for the industry, the 2654 Alan Richman agent and most important the consumer. Cruises Inc 2655 Amity Tingley Distinct Destinations

I'm glad to see that these card mills are being stopped. They jeopardize the future of the real travel agent. Another card mill is WorldVentures.com Unexperience people go around with a picture ID card soliciting people stating they will get free 2656 Deborah Paine travel, upgrade to first class, etc.by being a member. All Points Vacations 2657 Sharri Moore, CTA Fly Me To The Moon

Card Mills undermine the professionalism of legitamate travel 2658 Julie Roggow agents! CLIA should stop selling ID cards to these card mills! Thompson Travel & Tours, LLC 2659 Jim Brunson 2660 Jill Fuller Thank you for doing this! It's the right thing to do! World Travel Service I have had travel agent training. YTB and World Ventures, along with others need to be regulated, or else cease and desist all togetherThey are a discredit to the travel industry as a whole, and their falsifications and hypocrisey in advertising is without merit. OSSN, ASTA, and other governing travel agency organizations need to step up to the plate to the authorities and legal counsel to enforce CLIA, and IATAN regulations much more strictly. Travel agencies who follow rules and regulations are losing their financial and customer bases to YTB and World Ventures because of YTB's and 2661 Claudette Marie Moran World Ventures lack of integrity. 2662 Michael van Straubenzee All vendors should stop accepting these cards Blaney's Travel 2663 Joyce Bush

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 92 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

I'm sure there are some YTB Referring Travel Agents who are diligently training to become accredited travel agents. However, for the most part you can simply just pay a membership fee and say you're a travel agent. Would we be so open to the same concept if Doctors, Lawyers, Teachers, or Dentists could just pay a membership fee and say that they offer the same services as those who spent years being 2665 Terri Brown trained in their particular field of specialty? AATravel We have worked hard for Professionalism - MLM's are giving 2666 Susan Hakenjos us a bad name DAMAR TRAVEL AND CRUISE 2667 Brian Walker 2668 Marcie Crater Magic Happens Travel 2669 Jason True TotallyTrips.com 2670 Debbie Kaiser Magic Happens Travel

YTB has hit our town promoting on a weekly basis how to get agent discounts without being an agent-what an insult. I plan 2671 June Bessette to support those suppliers who do not allow card mills. CWT 2672 Bobbi-Jo Sherman CWT It's about time that suppliers are doing something to keep the validity of true producing travel agents. We are awaiting to hear what other suppliers will follow suit and continue to get 2673 Diane Macedo, Pres. our support. CWT 2674 Tara Clemens World Travel Services, Inc. 2675 Meredith Myrick AAA Oregon I joined YTB with the intent of becoming a travel agent. I found out that YTB' s main interest is to double its' 2676 Dorothy Travis membership. Travel For Pleasure Tours 2677 Francine Beifeld Thanks for doing this Travel Harmony 2678 Jo-Ann Pelletier CWT 2679 Kim Libertore 2680 Judith Christensen 2681 Marilyn Bell Zelaya Willow Glen Travel Agency, San Jose, Ca

Thank you for promoting professionalism in the travel industry. 2682 Patti Absher It has to be earned, not purchased with a worthless ID card. Great Travels 2683 R. Laks YTB is a joke, I feel bad for people who are involved and 2684 Robert Conners blinded by it. AAA 2685 John Mowbray Orange County Travel Services, Inc. 2686 Stephen Sandall 2687 Renee Beckley I think this awesome!! www.luckybets7.com 2688 Joni Wells

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 93 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 2689 LARRY FORD 2690 Patricia Duvell Totally outrageous! Marlin Travel MB

2691 Hanna Uehre 30 year of experience counts for more than 4 hrs of training ! this is crazy, people with no training and knowledge of the 2692 krista leblanc industy have no business booking trips for other people. aero travel 2693 Patricia Surette Voyages Travelaide 2694 MARIE 2695 Carla Nelson Suppliers need a wake up call. So unethical! GO Travel & Cruises 2696 Mark Crone Worked many years to earn the knowledge and experience I have to serve my clients in the manner they deserve and it 2697 Joanne Thachuk wasn't to get a 50\% discount at a hotel Travel Sensations Downtown Inc 2698 Bill Hughes Travelmasters 2699 Linda Kasza Shelley 2700 Tara Kowal Uniglobe Graduate of a Travel and Tourism College and International 2701 Erin Fletcher Travel Consultant Multi Travel 2702 Colin Hart CTC 2703 Greg Barsalou 2704 Sheila O'Neill 2705 Lillian E. Zimmerman You have my support. EZ Travel and Tours MY PERSONAL COMMENT, There is no alternative to 2706 Andrew Dawson training, experience, expertise and service 2707 jenn having been an agent for 20 years I find it hard to believe you 2708 Patricia Johnson CTC can be a trained agent in 4 hours. Not in my office. Flair Travel Planners I went to college for 2 years to be a travel agent. Its an insult to say that someone can do my job after a 4 hour training 2709 Amanda Flebotte session. South Travel Inc 2710 Rob Nelson Bad news CWT 2711 Amy Y 2712 Joanne Horan This is just not right! 2713 Lesley Keyter South Travel Inc. Calgary 2714 Yusimi Valdesuso I think they are a total waste of time and the only people making money are the ones at the top of the pyramid-I have been approached at least 2x's and have rejected them each 2715 Teresa Saxe time. Holiday International Travel 2716 Maria Hoover 2717 Julie Dunn Harbourside Travel 2718 Adria DiBrizzi 2719 Chris Reimer

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 94 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company 2720 BERNADETTE CORCORAN let stop these card mills Advantagae Uxbridge Travel. 2721 GAYLE BRISLEY ADVANTAGE WHITEHORSE TRAVEL 2722 Diane Pothan 2723 Karen Gay

I went to school for 2 years to learn how to become a travel agent. I have been in this industry for 5 years and I am still learning! It is not that I have anything against direct marketing companies - I am a consultant with one myself - but there is a big difference between selling sensual products and being a travel consultant. I should know - I do both! (And they both 2724 Lasia Matwijszyn took more than 4 hours of training!) Luxe Destination Events 2725 Cynthia Hawbolt 2726 Barbara Young discounting is disgusting! Another problem I see is a consumer using one of these "so called travel agents" and having serious complications which hit the news then all the ligitament agents are painted with the 2727 WENDY CHAPUT same unethical brush. A.L.&S. TRAVEL SERVICES INC This is simply unacceptable. I went to Travel school and 2728 Sherry Froess worked hard to achieve my CTC designation. I just wonder why Royal Caribbean is the only vendor standing 2729 Fay Neher behind qualified agencies? Flair Travel Planners 2730 Jamie Tennis Holiday International Travel 2731 Deanne Cleveland 2732 Keith McFarlane McFarlane Travel and Cruise 2733 Michael Keith CTC Travel Professionals International 2734 Susan Birkenshaw CTC, ACC Travel Professionals International 2735 june hampton this is an insult to the true professionals faro travel services ltd. dba marlin travel 2736 Mary Jane Hiebert Harvest Travel Ltd. 2737 Terry Larke CTC Travelsource Network 2738 Eileen Henderson, CTC This needs to be stopped, it cheapens the industry. CAA education and training is a must in this industry don't like "agents" for just getting discounts, joing avon and other MLM 2739 Arlene Henderson and earn your discounts. Windward Travel Ltd 20 yrs in the industry, earned CTC and ACC, travelled worldwide including as group escort...and some 4hr training hack shares my title as agent....preposterous...must be 2740 Bruce Bennewith stopped 2741 Monica Werner 2742 beth gerault 2743 Elizabeth Rodgers

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 95 of 96 MLMs and Travel Are A Bad Mix

Number Name Comments Company

I've worked hard to get my credentials. It is unfair to allow these people to slip in through the back door and get access 2744 Marcia Korsch CTC to what is supposed to be for REAL travel agents only. Carlson Wagonlit Travel 2745 Jill Cummings 2746 Yisrael Teichman 2747 Joyce Kublin TravelSource Network

Printed 12/5/2007 8:50 PM Page 96 of 96