DOCSLIB.ORG

Amicus Brief

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Amicus Brief No. 17-1498 IN THE Supreme Court of the United States ATLANTIC RICHFIELD COMPANY, Petitioner, v. GREGORY A. CHRISTIAN, ET AL., Respondents. On Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the Supreme Court of Montana BRIEF OF TREASURE STATE RESOURCES ASSOCIATION OF MONTANA, MONTANA MINING ASSOCIATION, MONTANA PE- TROLEUM ASSOCIATION AND THE MON- TANA CHAMBER OF COMMERCE AS AMICI CURIAE IN SUPPORT OF PETITIONER KYLE ANNE GRAY Counsel of Record WILLIAM W. MERCER BRIANNE C. MCCLAFFERTY HOLLAND &HART LLP 401 N. 31st St., Ste. 1500 Billings, MT 59101 (406) 252-2166 [email protected] Counsel for Amici Curiae May 30, 2018 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page TABLE OF AUTHORITIES ....................................... ii INTERESTS OF AMICI CURIAE .............................. 1 SUMMARY OF THE ARGUMENT ............................ 4 ARGUMENT ............................................................... 5 A. What’s Past is Prologue. ................................ 5 B. Superfund and Sunburst. ............................ 13 C. Certainty, Consistency and Finality are Essential to Industry. .................................. 22 CONCLUSION .......................................................... 23 i TABLE OF AUTHORITIES Cases Page(s) Bliss v. Anaconda Copper Min. Co., 167 F. 342 (D. Mont. 1909) ................................ 9, 10 Bliss v. Washoe Copper Co., 186 F. 789 (9th Cir. 1911) ....................................... 8 Bliss v. Washoe Copper Co., 231 U.S. 764 (1913) ................................................ 11 Cadillac Fairview/California, Inc. v. Dow Chemical Co., 299 F.3d 1019 (9th Cir. 2002) ................................ 17 Chevron Mining v. United States, 863 F.3d 1261 (10th Cir. 2017) .............................. 17 $ISJTUJBOW"UMBOUJD3JDImFME$P(Christian I), 356 P.3d 131 (Mont. 2015) ................................11, 19 Kipp v. Davis-Daly Copper Co., 110 P. 237 (Mont. 1910) ................................... 10, 11 Sunburst School District v. Texaco, Inc., 165 P.3d 1079 (Mont. 2007) ............................. 20, 21 Pakootas v. Teck Cominco Metals, Ltd., 646 F.3d 1214 (9th Cir. 2011) ............................... 18 Penn Central Corp. v. United States, 862 F. Supp. 437 (Reg’l Rail Reorg. Ct. 1994) ...... 16 Statutes MCA § 1-1-501 (En. Sec. 1, p. 42, L. 1893) ................. 1 Books Michael Basso, Meet Joe Copper: Masculinity & Race in Montana’s World War II Home Front (2013) .............................................................. 6 ii Robert Cuff, The War Industries Board: Busi- ness-Government Relations During World War I (1973) ............................................................. 7 Bill Dedman, Empty Mansions: The Mysterious Life of Huguette Clark and the Spending of a Great American Fortune (2014) ............................... 7 L.P. Hartley, The Go-Between (1953)........................ 13 Adam Hochschild, To End All Wars: A Story of Loyalty and Rebellion, 1914-1918 (2011) ................ 7 William Kitteridge & Annick Smith, The Last Best Place: A Montana Anthology (1990) ................ 1 Michael Malone, The Battle for Butte: Mining and Politics on the Northern Frontier, 1864- 1906 (1981) ............................................................... 5 Bode Morin, The Legacy of American Copper Smelting: Industrial Heritage versus Envi- ronmental Policy (2013) ......................................... 11 Other Authorities EPA, Superfund Sites in Region 8 ........................... 15 George Everett, The Captain Who Fought World War I in Butte, Montana ............................... 7 Findings & Recommendations of U.S. Magis- trate Judge (F&R), United States v. Atlantic 3JDImFME$P, CV-89-39-BU-SEH (D. Mont. Oct. 7, 1998) ................................................ 13, 15, 16 .POUBOBHPW0GmDJBM4UBUF8FCTJUF About Montana ................................................................... 1 Mont. Dep’t of Envtl. Quality, Texaco Sunburst 8PSLT3FmOFSZ Mont. Dep’t of Justice, Natural Resource Damage Program Consent Decrees ...................... 15 iii Anne Peters, The Great 19th Century Champi- on Salvator (Apr. 8, 2014) ........................................ 7 Matt Volz, Montana Landowners Say Govern- ment Botched Arsenic Cleanup, U.S. News (Feb. 24, 2017) ................................................... 17-19 Arthur Wells, Report of the Anaconda Smelter Smoke Commission, Oct.1, 1920, National Archives (Record Group 70, Box 278) ................... 13 iv INTERESTS OF AMICI CURIAE1 “Oro y Plata,” gold and silver in Spanish. Since 1893, by statute these are the words on the “Great Seal of the State of Montana.” MCA § 1-1-501 (En. Sec. 1, p. 42, L. 1893). The past, present and future of the Treasure State is encapsulated in this seal, which shows in its center “a plow and a miner’s pick and shovel,” on its left the “Great Falls of the Mis- souri River,” and on its right “mountain scenery.” Id. Amici Curiae BSF OPOQSPmU .POUBOB USBEF BTTPDJB tions with members engaged in all aspects of busi- ness, the Great Seal’s center, including members who continue to produce “oro y plata” and the other “treasure” that forms such a critical part of the story of this Last Best Place.2 The federal government has long played a role here as well, with the Comprehen- sive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA) becoming in the late 20th century part of the complicated equation that is Montana. Amici, concerned with balancing all inter- ests represented on Montana’s Great Seal, concur with Petitioner that the Montana Supreme Court de- cision at issue is poised to throw this balance “into chaos,” and ask this Court to grant the petition and reverse the Montana court’s dangerous misinterpre- tation and misapplication of CERCLA. 1 Pursuant to this Court’s Rule 37.2(a), counsel of record for all parties received timely notice of amici’s intent to file this brief and consented to it. No counsel for a party authored this brief, in whole or in part, and no person other than amici or their counsel made a monetary contribution to this brief’s prepara- tion or submission. 2 “Treasure State” is the “official nickname” of the State of Montana. See Montana.gov Official State Website, About Mon- tana, http://www.mt.gov. See also William Kitteridge & Annick Smith, The Last Best Place: A Montana Anthology (1990). 1 2 Amicus Treasure State Resources Association of .POUBOB 543" B OPOQSPmU WPMVOUBSZ USBEF BTTP ciation, brings together diverse industry, labor, agri- cultural and recreation groups to work together on issues that affect land use and resource development in Montana. TSRA’s members include mining and mineral production companies, transportation com- panies, unions, energy companies, water users and others (including PRPs at some of the 17 Superfund sites in Montana), all vitally interested in the con- TJTUFODZ DFSUBJOUZ mOBMJUZBOEBCJMJUZUPQMBOGPSSJTL provided by CERCLA, a comprehensive federal envi- ronmental scheme that precludes and preempts TUBUFMBXUPSUDMBJNTUIBUDPOnJDUBOEJOUFSGFSFXJUI federal cleanups and the federal statute’s rules, re- quirements and protections. TSRA is concerned that the decision below, which misreads and wrongly re- fuses to apply CERCLA’s jurisdictional and litiga- tion limits will result in the very type of chaos and inconsistency that is the bane of its members’ ability to function and prosper. Founded in 1919, amicus Montana Mining Asso- DJBUJPO .." JTBOPOQSPmUWPMVOUBSZUSBEFBTTPDJ ation comprised of members from every sector of the mining industry in Montana. Producing members NJOF BOEPS CFOFmDJBUF DSVDJBM NJOFSBMT VTFE JO manufacturing, medicine, construction, agriculture and other endeavors. These minerals include copper, garnets, gold, lime, manganese, molybdenum, nickel, palladium, platinum, silver, talc and zinc. MMA’s purpose is to be an advocate for its members, who as important contributors to the state’s economic fabric dating back to Montana’s territorial days, help pro- vide the necessary materials for our everyday lives, along with affording countless Montana families and graduates from local universities the opportunity to 3 prosper from well-paying employment. One of MMA’s primary functions is to share the compelling story of the industry’s history in Montana, a perspec- tive that is often left unsaid and unheard today, and which, as amicus, MMA can bring to the attention of the Court. Amicus Montana Petroleum Association (MPA) represents another sector of industry in Montana, i.e., members who explore and produce oil and natu- SBMHBT XIPPQFSBUFQJQFMJOFT BOEXIPSFmOFQFUSP MFVNQSPEVDUT"OPOQSPmUGPDVTFEPONBJOUBJOJOH a positive business climate in Montana for its mem- bers, MPA shares the concerns of its fellow voluntary trade associations that the decision of the Montana Supreme Court allowing tort claims to interfere with and supersede remedial actions carried out under the orders and auspices of a federal regulatory agency like EPA, is a recipe for disaster for business, includ- ing the petroleum industry. The Montana Chamber of Commerce (MCC) of- ten serves as amicus curiae in a wide variety of cases involving business in Montana, sometimes in tandem with the national Chamber of Commerce, which is also an amicus curiae in this matter. Like its co- amici .$$ JT B WPMVOUBSZ OPOQSPmU USBEF BTTPDJB tion. MCC champions economic development and a favorable business climate in the Treasure State on behalf of its over 750 members. MCC, too, sees the decision of the Montana Supreme Court as a disaster for industry and the state’s economy as a
Load more

Recommended publications
  • University of Montana Bulletin Bureau of Nines and Mintalluroy Series No
    UNIVERSITY OF MONTANA BULLETIN BUREAU OF NINES AND MINTALLUROY SERIES NO. 2 THE MONTANA STATE BUREAU OF MINES AND METALLURGY DIRECTORY MONTANA METAL AND COAL MINES STATE SCHOOL OF MINES BUTTE, MONTANA DECEMBER, 1919 STATE BUREAU OF MINES AND METALLURGY STAFF CLAPP, CHARLES H. Director and Geology PhD., Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1910 ADAMI, ARTHUR E. Mining Engineer E. M., Montana State School of Mines, 1907 PULSIFER. H. B. - - - - - - - Metallurgy and Safety B. S., Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1903; C.E., Armour Institute of Technology, 1915; M. S., University of Chicago, 1918. FOREWORD The purpose of this bulletin is to serve as a directory of all the metal and coal mining companies in the State of Montana. Although every effort possible by correspondence was made in the attempt to get information on every mining company in Montana, it is possible that some companies have been overlooked. However, it is believed that this bulletin contains the names of most of the operating com- panies of the State, together with some general information on each company, and that the bulletin will serve as a valuable reference book for those interested in the mining industry. This bulletin is supple- mentary to a report on the various mining districts of Montana which is now being prepared by the Geological Department of the State Bureau of Mines and Metallurgy. —4— DIRECTORY OF MONTANA OPERATING METAL MINES ALICE GOLD AND SILVER MINING CO. Butte. Location: Summit Valley Mining District, Silver Bow County. Officers: Pres., John D. Ryan; Secy-Treas., D. B. Hennessy, 42 Broadway, New York, N.
    [Show full text]
  • In the Shadow of the Big Stack: Black Eagle
    In The Shadow of the Big Stack: Black Eagle In The Shadow of the Big Stack: Black Eagle. Martin, 384, 456, & Mildred (Amy) Black Eagle History Book Committee. Lillegard, 30-31, 310, 441, 479-482, 484, 511, 567, 575 Mary Lou, 31 ACM See Anaconda Copper Mining Co. Richard (Dick) & Lynette, 31 ADAMS Roland, 30, 429 David, 55 Ruth, 31 Donald & Delores Benedetti, 55 William, 31 Dr., 234, 236 AMERICAN SMELTING & REFINING Prohibition Federal Agent, 459 COMPANY OF GREAT FALLS Karen, 55 [aka old Silver Smelter], 8 AFRICA ANACONDA COPPER MINING CO., 6-22 Emigrants from Orange Free State, 197 Anaconda Zinc Plant, 22 ALAIR Black Smith Shop, 568 Harry, 578 Bowling Alley, 33 ALBANAS Cadmium Plant, 11 Mr., 478 Change Houses, 9 ALBERTINI Church, 474 Cheryl, 421 Copper Commando, 412 Dick, 455 Electrolytic Copper Refinery, 9-10 ALBRIGHT Employees Club, 14, 42 Kay, 375-377 Furnace Refinery, 9-10 ALDEN Great Falls Reduction Dept., 7 Janell, 73 History of, 511 Jody, 73 Klepetico Boarding House, 12 Wayne & Jo Anne Corr, 73 Laboratory, 9 ALINE Leaching Division, 11 Clotilda (Tillie), 214 Little Church, 13, 474 Enrico, 25, 269 Roasting Furnaces, 11 Gertrude, 267, 269 Rolling Mills, 9-10 Henry, 214 Safety Dept., 12, 221 Henry & Annie, 269 Shops, 9 Henry V., 214, 489 Smelter Hill Residential Area, 12-13, 64 Joe, 197, 331, 408 Smelter Stack, 22, 582 Sam, 214 Strikes, 14 ALLISON Tramming System, 11-12 Tex, 500 Unions and Strikes, 22 ALLAN Wire & Cable Plant, 8+, 36 Ada, 91 Wire Mill, 8+, 22 George & Veda, 91 Zinc Plant, 9-11 Jim & Kay Sanders Aragon, 91 ANDERSON ALLEN Alden K.
    [Show full text]
  • ACM Smelter Residential Soil Health Consultation
    Health Consultation Exposure to Lead and Arsenic in Surface Soil, Black Eagle Community ANACONDA COPPER MINING COMPANY SMELTER AND REFINERY SITE GREAT FALLS, CASCADE COUNTY, MONTANA EPA FACILITY ID: MTD093291599 SEPTEMBER 15, 2016 U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry Division of Community Health Investigations Atlanta, Georgia 30333 Health Consultation: A Note of Explanation A health consultation is a verbal or written response from ATSDR or ATSDR’s Cooperative Agreement Partners to a specific request for information about health risks related to a specific site, a chemical release, or the presence of hazardous material. In order to prevent or mitigate exposures, a consultation may lead to specific actions, such as restricting use of or replacing water supplies; intensifying environmental sampling; restricting site access; or removing the contaminated material. In addition, consultations may recommend additional public health actions, such as conducting health surveillance activities to evaluate exposure or trends in adverse health outcomes; conducting biological indicators of exposure studies to assess exposure; and providing health education for health care providers and community members. This concludes the health consultation process for this site, unless additional information is obtained by ATSDR or ATSDR’s Cooperative Agreement Partner which, in the Agency’s opinion, indicates a need to revise or append the conclusions previously issued. You May Contact ATSDR Toll Free at 1-800-CDC-INFO or Visit our Home Page at: http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov HEALTH CONSULTATION Exposure to Lead and Arsenic in Surface Soil, Black Eagle Community ANACONDA COPPER MINING COMPANY SMELTER AND REFINERY SITE GREAT FALLS, CASCADE COUNTY, MONTANA EPA FACILITY ID: MTD093291599 Prepared By: Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry Division of Community Health Investigations Western Branch Table of Contents 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Health Consultation
    Health Consultation Evaluation of Residential Soil Arsenic Action Level ANACONDA CO. SMELTER NPL SITE ANACONDA, DEER LODGE COUNTY, MONTANA EPA FACILITY ID: MTD093291656 OCTOBER 19, 2007 U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES Public Health Service Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry Division of Health Assessment and Consultation Atlanta, Georgia 30333 Health Consultation: A Note of Explanation An ATSDR health consultation is a verbal or written response from ATSDR to a specific request for information about health risks related to a specific site, a chemical release, or the presence of hazardous material. In order to prevent or mitigate exposures, a consultation may lead to specific actions, such as restricting use of or replacing water supplies; intensifying environmental sampling; restricting site access; or removing the contaminated material. In addition, consultations may recommend additional public health actions, such as conducting health surveillance activities to evaluate exposure or trends in adverse health outcomes; conducting biological indicators of exposure studies to assess exposure; and providing health education for health care providers and community members. This concludes the health consultation process for this site, unless additional information is obtained by ATSDR which, in the Agency’s opinion, indicates a need to revise or append the conclusions previously issued. You May Contact ATSDR TOLL FREE at 1-800-CDC-INFO or Visit our Home Page at: http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov HEALTH CONSULTATION Evaluation of Residential Soil Arsenic Action Level ANACONDA CO. SMELTER NPL SITE ANACONDA, DEER LODGE COUNTY, MONTANA EPA FACILITY ID: MTD093291656 Prepared By: US Department of Health and Human Services Agency for Toxic Substance and Disease Registry Division of Health Assessment and Consultation Atlanta, Georgia 30333 Anaconda Co.
    [Show full text]
  • Miners, Managers, and Machines : Industrial Accidents And
    Miners, managers, and machines : industrial accidents and occupational disease in the Butte underground, 1880-1920 by Brian Lee Shovers A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in History Montana State University © Copyright by Brian Lee Shovers (1987) Abstract: Between 1880 and 1920 Butte, Montana achieved world-class mining status for its copper production. At the same time, thousands of men succumbed to industrial accidents and contracted occupational disease in the Butte underground, making Butte mining significantly more dangerous than other industrial occupations of that era. Three major factors affected working conditions and worker safety in Butte: new mining technologies, corporate management, and worker attitude. The introduction of new mining technologies and corporate mine ownership after 1900 combined to create a sometimes dangerous dynamic between the miner and the work place in Butte. While technological advances in hoisting, tramming, lighting and ventilation generally improved underground working conditions, other technological adaptations such as the machine drill, increased the hazard of respiratory disease. In the end, the operational efficiencies associated with the new technologies could not alleviate the difficult problems of managing and supervising a highly independent, transient, and often inexperienced work force. With the beginning of the twentieth century and the consolidation of most of the major Butte mines under the corporate entity of Amalgamated Copper Company (later the Anaconda Copper Mining Company), conflict between worker and management above ground increased. At issue were wages, conditions, and a corporate reluctance to accept responsibility for occupational hazards. The new atmosphere of mistrust between miners and their supervisors provoked a defiant attitude towards the work place by workers which increased the potential for industrial accidents.
    [Show full text]
  • Southwest MONTANA
    visitvisit SouthWest MONTANA 2017 OFFICIAL REGIONAL TRAVEL GUIDE SOUTHWESTMT.COM • 800-879-1159 Powwow (Lisa Wareham) Sawtooth Lake (Chuck Haney) Horses (Michael Flaherty) Bannack State Park (Donnie Sexton) SouthWest MONTANABetween Yellowstone National Park and Glacier National Park lies a landscape that encapsulates the best of what Montana’s about. Here, breathtaking crags pierce the bluest sky you’ve ever seen. Vast flocks of trumpeter swans splash down on the emerald waters of high mountain lakes. Quiet ghost towns beckon you back into history. Lively communities buzz with the welcoming vibe and creative energy of today’s frontier. Whether your passion is snowboarding or golfing, microbrews or monster trout, you’ll find endless riches in Southwest Montana. You’ll also find gems of places to enjoy a hearty meal or rest your head — from friendly roadside diners to lavish Western resorts. We look forward to sharing this Rexford Yaak Eureka Westby GLACIER Whitetail Babb Sweetgrass Four Flaxville NATIONAL Opheim Buttes Fortine Polebridge Sunburst Turner remarkable place with you. Trego St. Mary PARK Loring Whitewater Peerless Scobey Plentywood Lake Cut Bank Troy Apgar McDonald Browning Chinook Medicine Lake Libby West Glacier Columbia Shelby Falls Coram Rudyard Martin City Chester Froid Whitefish East Glacier Galata Havre Fort Hinsdale Saint Hungry Saco Lustre Horse Park Valier Box Belknap Marie Elder Dodson Vandalia Kalispell Essex Agency Heart Butte Malta Culbertson Kila Dupuyer Wolf Marion Bigfork Flathead River Glasgow Nashua Poplar Heron Big Sandy Point Somers Conrad Bainville Noxon Lakeside Rollins Bynum Brady Proctor Swan Lake Fort Fairview Trout Dayton Virgelle Peck Creek Elmo Fort Benton Loma Thompson Big Arm Choteau Landusky Zortman Sidney Falls Hot Springs Polson Lambert Crane Condon Fairfield Great Ronan Vaughn Haugan Falls Savage De Borgia Plains Charlo Augusta CONTENTS Paradise Winifred Bloomfield St.
    [Show full text]
  • A. Clifford Edwards, Esquire
    “WHY DO YOU HURT ME SO?” By: A. Clifford Edwards, Esquire THE INTERNATIONAL ACADEMY OF TRIAL LAWYERS DEAN’S ADDRESS APRIL 7, 2017 SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA A Publication of the International Academy of Trial Lawyers Why Do You Hurt Me So? Good morning Academy! The opinions, express or implied, in this Dean’s Address are solely my own; nothing more, nothing less. President Burbidge; soon-to-be President Noël; fellow officers; my sisters and brothers of our special Academy, guests and my Edwards’ family supporting me here today; Page | 1 Susan – my wife, of such beauty, both of spirit and appearance, my soulmate, as hand-in-hand we experience our lives together; My cherished sons Christopher and John, the proudest achievements of my life; my best friends and only law partners; Their wives, my Daughters-in-law, Kelly and Hollis, who have so enriched and enhanced our Edwards’ family; And, an unexpected bonus that came into my life with her mother Susan over a decade ago when she was just 12, my stepdaughter Alex. Now, we welcome her significant, Patrick Lopach. Then, our little shining family Beacons, – the Edwards’ grandchildren – Ellie Marie, Wright, A.C. and Bella! Now please, you four, sit. Be still! Grandpa’s going to be givin’ a speech. Mother Nature I posit the title of my Dean’s Address – “Why Do You Hurt Me So?” as a troubled query from our wounded Mother of this beautiful and bountiful planet we each absorb every day of our lives. Susan and I share an instilled love for Mother Nature from our Montana upbringings.
    [Show full text]
  • ANACONDA COMPANY HERITAGE Hardware, Lumber, Banking LARGEY Rolla Butcher BuE C
    Bu*e 1881 ANACONDA COMPANY HERITAGE Hardware, lumber, banking LARGEY Rolla Butcher Bu*e c. 1898 0ew York City: Bannack 1893- W. Farlin Walker Bros. Horsehair products Deer odge bank; Comstock ode ,tate ,avings Bank Dexter Mill Alice Mine Bu*e c. 1832 CLARK DALY 0evada- STANDARD OIL A.J. DAVIS LEWISOHNS (Metals) Travona Mine Bu*e 1839 18.2 Warehouse DIRECTORS Chas. E. & W. Colusa, 1839 M. Hickey Explosions 18.8 argey 0orth Bu*e Mining 1.12 Hearst, Haggin, et al. Meader Leonard mines Anaconda Mine First 0a4onal Bank murdered A Minnesota corp. Henry Rogers, C. 1832 1833 Colorado 1884 Washoe Copper Co. Anaconda Copper Co. 1881 William Rockefeller exington Mine ,.B. Water Co. 183. ,peculator Mining Co. 1.12 ,melter 1881 8rphan Girl Montana Copper Co. C.X.Larrabee 183. Anaconda ,melters, BA&5 Bu*e 0eversweat 1881 Workingmen’s 5ublic ibrary T.Cole Anaconda ,tandard 188. E1 million Union 1838 Mountain View Mining Rothschilds: 22% 18.2 Bluebird Mine 1882 Meader: Clark’s Colusa Granite Mtn Mining Co. ,ociDtD anonyme des Bell Mine 1.1. United 5arro* Co. Mountain Con 1883 mines de exington Bu*e Water Co. 18.1 (erde 1883 1881 HEINZE Boston & Montana Columbia Great Falls ,melter- Bu*e 188. Gardens Hennessey A.J. Davis (elder) died 18.1 Hydroelectric plant To B&M 1883 1888 Merc. 18.. HeinFe lease 1882 18.3 E121,111 Diamond Coke & Coal Amalgamated 18.. 1.11 Apex awsuits J. Tuohy c. 1882 18.2 East Bu*e 1.12-13 1.13 Great Balaklava Mine Bu*e & Boston Claims 1.13 Bu*e Water Co.
    [Show full text]
  • Montana's "Boodlers"
    MONTANA'S "BOODLERS": MONTANANS AND THE AFTERMATH OF THE 1899 SENATORIAL SCANDAL by WILLIAM J. YAEGER 'll*- Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for Graduation with Honors to the Department of History at Carroll College Helena, Montana March, 1983 3 5962 00083 098 Tv This thesis for honors recognition has been approved for the Department of History. Director x fko-. 1 . <1 Reader ^7^/ j>z /are Date ii CONTENTS PREFACE...................................................................................................... iv Chapter I. FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO BRIBERY IN U.S. SENATORIAL ELECTIONS................................................................. 1 II. THE "WAR" THAT LED TO A SCANDAL.............................................. 6 III. THE BUYING OF A LEGISLATURE.................................................... 13 IV. THE CHANDLER HEARING: THE RESIGNATION AND REAPPOINTMENT OF W.A. CLARK................................................... 27 V. AFTERAFFECTS OF MONTANA'S SCANDAL OF 1899............................ 34 VI. CONCLUSIONS..................................................................................... 40 APPENDIX A. THE VALEDICTORY OF SENATOR FRED WHITESIDE........................ 44 B. THE EVERETT BILL......................................................................... 47 SOURCES CONSULTED................................................................................... 51 i i i PREFACE As a newsman, I have had to endure accusations at various times that I (meaning my profession) had fabricated
    [Show full text]
  • A Study of Early Utah-Montana Trade, Transportation, and Communication, 1847-1881
    Brigham Young University BYU ScholarsArchive Theses and Dissertations 1959 A Study of Early Utah-Montana Trade, Transportation, and Communication, 1847-1881 L. Kay Edrington Brigham Young University - Provo Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/etd Part of the Mormon Studies Commons, and the United States History Commons BYU ScholarsArchive Citation Edrington, L. Kay, "A Study of Early Utah-Montana Trade, Transportation, and Communication, 1847-1881" (1959). Theses and Dissertations. 4662. https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/etd/4662 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. A STUDY OF EARLY UTAH-MONTANA TRADE TRANSPORTATION, AND COMMUNICATION 1847-1881 A Thesis presented to the department of History Brigham young university provo, Utah in partial fulfillment of the Requirements for the degree Master of science by L. Kay Edrington June, 1959 This thesis, by L. Kay Edrington, is accepted In its present form by the Department of History of Brigham young University as Satisfying the thesis requirement for the degree of Master of Science. May 9, 1959 lywrnttt^w-^jmrnmr^^^^ The writer wishes to express appreciation to a few of those who made this thesis possible. Special acknowledge­ ments are due: Dr. leRoy R. Hafen, Chairman, Graduate Committee. Dr. Keith Melville, Committee member. Staffs of; History Department, Brigham young university. Brigham young university library. L.D.S. Church Historian's office. Utah Historical Society, Salt lake City.
    [Show full text]
  • Citizens United, Caperton, and the War of the Copper Kings Larry Howell Alexander Blewett I I School of Law at the University of Montana, [email protected]
    Alexander Blewett III School of Law at the University of Montana The Scholarly Forum @ Montana Law Faculty Law Review Articles Faculty Publications 2012 Once Upon a Time in the West: Citizens United, Caperton, and the War of the Copper Kings Larry Howell Alexander Blewett I I School of Law at the University of Montana, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarship.law.umt.edu/faculty_lawreviews Part of the Election Law Commons Recommended Citation Larry Howell, Once Upon a Time in the West: Citizens United, Caperton, and the War of the Copper Kings , 73 Mont. L. Rev. 25 (2012), Available at: http://scholarship.law.umt.edu/faculty_lawreviews/14 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Faculty Publications at The choS larly Forum @ Montana Law. It has been accepted for inclusion in Faculty Law Review Articles by an authorized administrator of The choS larly Forum @ Montana Law. ARTICLES ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST: CITIZENS UNITED, CAPERTON, AND THE WAR OF THE COPPER KINGS Larry Howell* He is said to have bought legislaturesand judges as other men buy food and raiment. By his example he has so excused and so sweetened corruption that in Montana it no longer has an offensive smell. -Mark Twain' [T]he Copper Kings are a long time gone to their tombs. -District Judge Jeffrey Sherlock 2 I. INTRODUCTION Recognized by even its strong supporters as "one of the most divisive decisions" by the United States Supreme Court in years,3 Citizens United v. * Associate Professor, The University of Montana School of Law.
    [Show full text]
  • 31762001122363.Pdf (2.394Mb)
    Copper kings, populists and log-rollers : the third session of the Montana State Legislature, 1893 by Jean Marie Schmidt A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS in History Montana State University © Copyright by Jean Marie Schmidt (1981) Abstract: The 1893 session of the Montana legislature deserves close study because of its long-term effects upon the state, All of the issues that made Montana politics especially- turbulent in the years immediately following statehood were present in this session: the rivalry between mining kings William A, Clark and Marcus Daly, the contest over the permanent location of the state capital, Clark's campaign to be elected to the United States Senate, labor's demands for protective legislation, the rise of Populism, and the national debate over the free coinage of silver. In spite of these distractions, the legislature had a great deal of work to do. The unproductive first and second sessions had passed on a number of unfinished tasks-, some as simple as designing an offical seal for the new state, others as complex as creating its higher education system. The Popultsts held the balance of power in the House of Representatives and helped pass some laws favorable to labor, but were blamed afterwards for not accomplishing more. The joint assembly was deadlocked throughout the session and failed to elect a United States Senator, leaving one of Montana's Senate positions vacant for two years while the repeal of the Sherman Silver Purchase Act was debated in Congress. The action of this legislature that had the most lasting consequences for the state was the distribution of the state's educational and custodial institutions in separate towns.
    [Show full text]