Arxiv:1102.1108V1 [Astro-Ph.EP] 5 Feb 2011

Draft version January 17, 2019 A Preprint typeset using LTEX style emulateapj v. 8/13/10 THE STEPPENWOLF: A PROPOSAL FOR A HABITABLE PLANET IN INTERSTELLAR SPACE D. S. Abbot1 and E. R. Switzer2,3 Draft version January 17, 2019 ABSTRACT Rogue planets have been ejected from their planetary system. We investigate the possibility that a rogue planet could maintain a liquid ocean under layers of thermally-insulating water ice and frozen atmosphere as a result of geothermal heat flux. We find that a rogue planet of Earth-like composition and age could maintain a subglacial liquid ocean if it were ≈3.5 times more massive than Earth. If a rogue planet had about ten times higher water mass fraction or a thick cryo-atmospheric layer, it would need to be only ≈0.3 times the mass of Earth to maintain a liquid ocean. Such a planet could be detected from reflected solar radiation and its thermal emission could be characterized in the far-IR if it passed within O(1000) AU of Earth. Subject headings: Steppenwolf planet, rogue planet, free-floater, habitability 1. INTRODUCTION effect of a thermally-insulating frozen cryo-atmosphere. As a planetary system forms, some planets or plan- We reach the perhaps surprising conclusion that it would etesimals, referred to as “rogue” planets, can enter hy- be possible for such a planet to harbor a subglacial ocean. perbolic orbits and be ejected from the system as a re- This point is of interest since a subglacial ocean could sult of gravitational interactions with gas giant plan- serve as a habitat for life which, because of energy sources ets (Lissauer 1987). The ability of a rogue planet to provided by an active mantle, would be more feasible support life is of interest as a sort of pathological ex- than Gaidos et al. (1999) have argued it would be for icy ample of planetary habitability, because such a planet moons such as Europa and Callisto. We will refer to a could potentially represent a viable option for interstel- rogue planet harboring a subglacial ocean as a Steppen- lar panspermia (Durand-Manterola 2010), and because wolf planet, since any life in this strange habitat would such a planet could be the closest source of extrasolar exist like a lone wolf wandering the galactic steppe. life for exploration by humanity in the distant future. We can imagine that the ice layer on top of an ocean Since some sort of starting point is required to discuss on a Steppenwolf planet will grow until either it reaches the issue, a planet is often defined as habitable if it can steady-state or all available water freezes. Geothermal sustain liquid water at its surface (Kasting et al. 1993). heat from the interior of the Steppenwolf planet will be Stevenson (1999) argued that if a rogue planet had an carried through the ice layer by conduction, and poten- extremely high pressure hydrogen atmosphere, pressure- tially by convection in the lower, warmer, and less viscous broadening of far-infrared molecular hydrogen absorp- portion of the ice layer. Since convection transports heat tion could cause a greenhouse effect strong enough that much more efficiently than conduction, the steady-state liquid water could be maintained on the planet’s surface ice thickness will be much larger if convection occurs, as a result of the geothermal heat flux alone, making the making it harder to maintain a subglacial ocean. planet potentially habitable. Here we will calculate steady-state ice thicknesses as- Subglacial liquid water oceans on icy bodies represent suming that heat is lost through conduction alone, then an alternative type of habitat. It is well-known that argue that it is reasonable to assume that heat loss will subglacial oceans are possible around moons of giant be dominated by conduction in the parameter regime planets and trans-neptunian objects in the solar system of interest. We must acknowledge, however, that it is arXiv:1102.1108v1 [astro-ph.EP] 5 Feb 2011 (Hussmann et al. 2006), as well as water exoplanets in very difficult to establish definitively whether convection distant orbits (Ehrenreich et al. 2006; Fu et al. 2010). In would occur without detailed knowledge of conditions in this paper, we will consider whether an Earth-like rogue and microscale composition of the ice (Barr & Showman planet, not attached to any star and receiving negligible 2009). More generally, we will make many simplifi- energy at its surface, could sustain a subglacial liquid cations, including considering the question within the ocean. By Earth-like, we mean specifically within an or- framework of a one-dimensional (vertical) model, since der of magnitude in mass and water complement, similar we wish to establish whether or not a Steppenwolf planet in composition of radionuclides in the mantle, and of sim- is feasible, rather than to make a detailed study of it. ilar age. In addition to standard considerations relating to ice thermodynamics, we also consider the potential 2. GEOPHYSICAL CONSIDERATIONS First we calculate the conductive steady-state thick- ≈ [email protected], [email protected] ness, H. Above 10 K, the temperature de- 1 Department of the Geophysical Sciences, University of pendence of the thermal conductivity of water ice Chicago, 5734 South Ellis Avenue, Chicago, IL 60637 −1 2 is well-approximated by k(T ) = AT , where T Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics, University of −1 Chicago, 5640 South Ellis Avenue, Chicago, IL 60637 is the temperature in Kelvin and A=651 W m 3 Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of (Petrenko & Whitworth 2002). Dimensional analysis Chicago, 5640 South Ellis Avenue, Chicago, IL 60637 shows that thermal steady-state is reached in ∼ 106 2 Abbot and Switzer years, much shorter than the timescale of decay of the that even a layer with thermal conductivity and density geothermal heat flux. Geothermal heat flux through the which are each five times lower than those of solid carbon shell will be constant at steady-state, since no heat is dioxide, to account for possible snow-like behavior, will produced within the ice, as would occur by tidal heating still intersect first with the melting curve at its base, with of a frozen moon. Since the Steppenwolf planets we con- pressure exceeding the triple point’s at 0.52 MPa. Be- sider would be much larger and dryer than the icy moons cause of the weak temperature dependence of the melting on which subglacial oceans are typically studied, we can curve in this regime (Giordano et al. 2006), we find that assume that the ice thickness is much less than the plan- the maximum supportable temperature at the base of a etary radius, which yields an exponential temperature carbon dioxide layer is robustly ≈ 220 K for Earth-like profile through the ice and steady-state-thickness Steppenwolf planets. Setting T0 = 220 K reduces the steady-state water-ice thickness by an order of magni- A T H = log H , (1) tude. F T0 At Earth mass, the temperature at the bottom of a layer of solid CO2 reaches the melting temperature of 6 −2 where TH is the temperature at the ice-water interface CO2 for a layer thickness of ≈ 2 km, or ≈ 3×10 kg m . (the melting temperature), T0 is the temperature at the Venus’ atmosphere has a partial pressure of CO2 of top of the ice, and F is the geothermal heat flux. ≈90 bar (≈ 106 kg m−2), which is roughly the vapor Decay of radioactive elements in Earth’s interior and pressure of carbonate rocks at Venus’ surface tempera- primordial heat remaining from Earth’s formation lead to ture, implying that there may be more carbon locked in an average geothermal heat flux emanating from Earth’s rock in equilibrium with the atmosphere (Pierrehumbert −2 surface of F⊕=0.087 W m (Pollack et al. 1993). This 2010). The store of carbon in carbonate rocks in Earth’s heat flux decays with time such that Earth’s geother- interior is uncertain, but is estimated to be roughly 5 mal heat flux may have been roughly twice its present 10 times that in atmospheric CO2 (Berner 2004), or value 3 Gyr ago (Turcotte 1980). In order to con- ≈ 3 × 105 kg m−2. Therefore it appears reasonable to sider Steppenwolf planets of different sizes, we use the assume that a Steppenwolf planet could have a sufficient radius–mass scaling R ∝ M v for Super-Earths with complement of CO2 to significantly elevate T0, although v =0.27 (Valencia et al. 2006). Heuristically, this yields a Steppenwolf planet might need a larger carbon com- 1−2v a geothermal heat flux that scales as (M/M⊕) , or plement than Earth or Venus for the bottom of the cryo- roughly as the square root of the mass. atmospheric layer to reach the melting point of CO2. The pressure at the bottom of the ice layer is ≈ Finally, we note that to find an upper bound on the im- 9 MPa for each kilometer of ice, scaling with mass as pact of a cryo-atmospheric layer we have ignored possible 1−2v (M/M⊕) . The melting point of pure ice is 250–270 K convection of solid CO2 into the water-ice. at pressures less than 620 MPa (Choukroun & Grasset 2007), although contaminants to pure ice could suppress the melting point (Hussmann et al. 2006). The steady- 240 state thickness is only logarithmically sensitive to TH , so we simply take TH = 260 K in the estimates here. In steady-state, the temperature at the surface of a Step- 120 penwolf planet (Ts), i.e., the top of the ice or cryo- atmospheric layer, will be set by a balance between ther- 4 mal emission and geothermal heat flux, F = σTs , where σ is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant.

Load more