The Coolest Bird: a Natural History of the Black Swift and Those Who
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Coolest Bird A Natural History of the Black Swift and Those Who Have Pursued It Rich Levad ~ 2007 ~ © 2010 American Birding Association. ~ Table of Contents ~ Foreward . .4 Acknowledgements . .6 1. Hawk Creek Falls, Colorado: A glimpse of things to come. 8 2. Semiahoo Bay, Washington: A new bird . 11 3. California’s Santa Cruz Coast: The first nest . 14 4. Johnston Canyon, Alberta: First inland nest site . 19 5. California: Charles and Enid Michaels at Yosemite . 22 6. California: Emily Smith and Berry Creek Falls . 27 7. California: Sequoia & King’s Canyon National Parks & San Jacinto Mountains . 31 8. Colorado: Niagara and Cataract Gulches . 34 9. Colorado: Al Knorr—more and more . 39 10. Arizona . 47 11. New Mexico . 53 12. Utah . 56 13. Southern California . 60 14. Northern Rocky Mountains: Montana, Idaho, Alberta . 67 15. NW Pacific Coast: British Columbia, Washington, Oregon . 73 16. Colorado post-Knorr: 1958-1996. 80 17. Colorado: Sue Hirshman and Box Canyon Falls . 87 18. Colorado 1995-1997 . 90 19. Colorado 1998 . 95 20. Colorado 1999-2000 . 102 21. Colorado: 2001-2002 . 107 22. Colorado and New Mexico 2003-2006 . 116 23. Following through in the Southern Rockies . 120 24. Recent events in the North . 125 25. The Southerners . 132 26. Today and Tomorrow . 136 Conservation Issues . 142 Bibliography . 149 3 ~ Foreword ~ y husband, Rich, was somewhat of a late comer to the hobby of bird watching; it was ducks that first lured him. He hunted them. In Colorado heavy fines can be levied for possessing certain Mspecies of ducks, so it pays to know the difference. For Rich, that need to know led to a life- long investigation into the birds of Colorado and beyond. He soon set hunting with a gun aside and armed himself instead with a pair of binoculars, a Peterson Field Guide to Western Birds, pen, and pad, and in an old Toyota pick-up, scoured the mountains and deserts of Colorado. His keen interest, insatiable curiosity, and love of the outdoors led eventually to a position with Rocky Mountain Bird Observatory where he served as special species coordinator for eight years. In that position he monitored those birds not easily tracked by conventional means. Owls, grebes, herons all fell under that category. So did Black Swift, a bird that Rich soon regarded as “the coolest bird.” Along the way, he became acquainted with a rather extensive cast of characters (see his Acknowledgement section) who shared his interest. I use the term “character” lovingly; Rich and his cohorts (and predecessors) seemed to value the quest and the risks involved nearly as much as they loved the birds. My brother-in-law’s comment on reading an early manuscript of The Coolest Bird: “They sure had fun!” They did. On the face of it, this is a book about a bird, but as is often the case, there is a story behind the story. Over the course of seven years, Rich and Owen A. Knorr (the guru of Black Swift exploration) had exchanged a spirited correspondence marked with a bit of intellectual sparring, a common desire to better understand this remarkable bird, and an interest in promoting further monitoring of the species. Rich believed that the letters formed the basis for a rather exciting story on the adventure of bird research, and he talked about “some day” setting aside time to write an article or book related to the topic. Rich would have been most contented to continue his birding adventures and to keep The Coolest Bird on a “to do” list. However, his life changed drastically in 2004 when he was diagnosed with Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS), an awful, debilitating disease, known more commonly as Lou Gehrig’s Disease. People famil- iar with this illness know that it affects the bodies of its victims in myriad ways. In Rich’s case, he first noticed weakness in his thumbs and strange spasms in his muscles called fasciculations. Over the next few years, symptoms progressed to where he could no longer walk, move his fingers, or lift his arms—what seemed to his family and friends as cruel blows to a man who thrived on hiking, writing, and holding binoculars to his eyes for endless moments while counting whatever bird crossed his path. In adjusting to the circumstances that ALS imposed on him, Rich turned to the material he had already collected on the Black Swift and delved into a major research project that would absorb him for the next several years. As he approached the material, Rich considered whether he ought to use the writing as an opportunity to process his experience with illness. He deliberately chose not to and instead focused on the bird that energized and fascinated him. Rich was very clear about who this book was for. He wrote for those intelligent, thoughtful adventurers who would value a historical review of the activity of bird watching as well as a unified presentation of what is known about Black Swift. There were two dynamics at play during the last years of Rich’s life: the illness slowed him down, giving him the opportunity to write, and The Coolest Bird gave Rich an outlet to transcend the relentless betrayal of his body. What was remarkable for those observing 4 the process was how Rich brought his quiet determination, intellectual fervor, sweet nature, and humor to the challenge. This book enlivened Rich; he adjusted and refined the text until the day before his death in Febru- ary 2008, when he completed the acknowledgments. Rich was fascinated by those who pursued the Black Swift. I think he recognized kindred spirits. I also think in telling their story that he was providing a cautionary tale. Knowledge of the Black Swift begins in 1857 with Dr. Caleb Burwell Rowen Kennerly first identifying the species. The Coolest Bird traces the progres- sion of knowledge gained over the past century-and-a-half; what may be disturbing is how sporadically that knowledge was gained. Research of the Black Swift is marked by fits and starts, with relatively few individuals adding to the pool of information about the bird over the decades. The past fifteen years has provided the most consistent and wide-ranging effort to monitor Black Swift with the primary emphasis being the attempt to identify colony nest sites. The concerted effort of the last decade was encouraging and necessary. And it needs to continue. We need more people and organizations committed to the quest. Rich died on February 28, 2008, some would say after “an heroic struggle.” I wouldn’t. Rich simply lived each day to the fullest as he was able to, not focused on what he couldn’t do, but rather on what he could. He continued to live on the edge even if that was far from a canyon rim with a roaring waterfall as backdrop. Each new physical limitation provided opportunity, and he continued to find new and creative ways to meet those challenges. ALS brought Rich back to his true vocation, that of teacher. Through his skill, we have the opportunity to learn more about a fascinating species, about some intrepid explorers, about new and exciting monitoring opportunities, and about a really cool and remarkable birder—in my eyes, the coolest. Karen Levad June 16, 2010 5 ~ Acknowlegements ~ wish to thank the many volunteers and cooperators who aided our search for Black Swift nest sites in the Southern Rockies, a collection of interesting people who have been intrigued by that bird over the I past 150 years, and a circle of good friends who read drafts, made corrections, offered suggestions, and provided moral support. To this crowd, I owe a deep debt of gratitude. Those who visited and evaluated waterfalls for the Southern Rocky Mountain Region included Rod Adams, Bev Baker, Wendy Beard, Jason Beason, Ken Behrens, Lisa Belmonte, Brad Benter, Nancy Berry, Bob Bethel, Mike Blanck, Karen Burrell, Cameron Cox, Jeff Conner, Aaron Crawford, Bill Day, Dan Derbyshire, Beth Dillon, David Dittmer, Matthew Dufort, Doug Faulkner, Bob Frey, Michael Garrard, Peter Gent, Brian Gibbons, Glenn Giroir, Matt Gracey, Jeremy Greene, Craig Grother, Carolyn Gunn, Dave Hallock, Lauren Hall, John Hawkins, Mike Henwood, Sue Hirshman, Eric Koch, Paul Hurtado, Dave Khaliqi, Gwen Lee, Tony Leukering, Nick Lowe, Kalen Malueg, Josiah Malueg, Micah Malueg, Joshua Malueg, Monica Mellaci, Virginia Maynard, Jane McGarry, Patrick McEachern, Jason McLich, Mike Mechau, Skip Mottram, Ava Mullins, Bill Palmer, Arvind Panjabi, Kim Potter, Liz Roberts, David Rubenstein, Chris Schultz, Malene Shannon, Jeremy Siemers, Robert Skorkowsky, Paul Slingsby, Brett Smithers, John Sovell, Rob Sparks, John Stanek, Chuck Reichart, Alan Versaw, and Walt Wilson. Among these, Ken Behrens, Jason Beason, and Caro- lyn Gunn merit recognition for the size of their contributions and unflagging enthusiasm—Ken and Jason as seasonal field techs and Carolyn as an occasional tech but mostly as a volunteer. A legion of professional and amateur biologists shared information, insights, and leads to others sources. An archivist at the Smithsonian, whose name I have regrettably lost, provided a copy of Kennerly’s notes and his letter to Spencer Baird describing the type specimen collected at Semiahoo Bay. Peter Capainolo and Paul Sweet of the American Museum of Natural History and René Corado of the Western Foundation of Verte- brate Zoology, Santa Barbara Museum graciously supplied information on egg collections. Bob Altman pro- vided details about efforts to locate Black Swift nest sites along the Pacific coast from northern California to southeastern Alaska. He also provided leads to others in the region who volunteered information. These oth- ers included Gwen Baluss in Southeastern Alaska; Dick Cannings, Syd Cannings, Clive Keen, Doug Leighton, Paul Levesque, and Kirk Safford in British Columbia; Larry Schwitters and Theresa Stone in Washington; and Barbara Combs, Alan Contreras, Jeff Harding, Tom Mickel, Roger Robb, and Mark Smith in Oregon.