DOCSLIB.ORG

Clearcutting: Good Or Bad? by Anthony P

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Clearcutting: Good Or Bad? by Anthony P Clearcutting: Good or Bad? By Anthony P. Quadro, Forester Westmoreland Conservation District Greensburg, PA 15601 There has been a lot of negative press lately cutting, which is removing all trees over a regarding the practice of clearcutting. It can selected diameter such as 14 inches (often be a very emotional issue because of per- called “select cutting”), leaves a lot of trees in ceptions about environmental damage. But the woods, and can look better than a clearcut, many of these perceptions are not accurate. but it degrades the long term health of the forest because it does nothing to clear away The principal objective of clearcutting is to the small, elderly, slow-growing “junk” trees. regenerate the forest with healthier trees, not to harvest timber. Timber harvesting is a Clearcuts can be beneficial to wildlife. New secondary objective. In a true clearcut, all of openings grow very quickly into small trees the trees greater than 2 inches in diameter are and berry- and seed-producing shrubs, which cut, as opposed to a commercial clearcut provide both food and shelter for wildlife. where only marketable trees are removed. Clearcutting increases the biological diversity Clearcutting is especially useful in regenerat- of the forest, which enhances the habitat for a ing species of trees whose seedlings cannot variety of wildlife. Some species of wildlife thrive in the shade of a forest understory. actually thrive better in brushy thickets of Shade-intolerant species such as black cherry seedlings and small saplings. need full sunlight for optimum development. Clearcutting is not deforestation. Most of Clearcutting actually mimics openings created the time clearcuts regenerate initially into naturally from tornadoes and fires. dense thickets with thousands of tree seed- Clearcutting does not cause soil erosion. lings per acre, then gradually thin themselves Soil erosion is caused by poorly laid out road out as the stronger trees show dominance and systems, whether or not the forest is clearcut crowd out the weaker trees. Many of Pennsyl- or only partially cut. Clearcutting can be done vania’s hillsides that are densely forested without significant erosion or sedimentation if today originated as clearcuts in the early part roads are pre-planned and built correctly by of the last century. using accepted Best Management Practices to Is clearcutting always the best way to protect streams. regenerate a forest? No, but it is often the Logging companies do not clearcut just best approach in certain situations, especially because it is the most economical way to if advanced regeneration (seedlings) is harvest timber. In fact, many loggers dislike present. It then allows the forest to start over, clearcutting because it forces them to spend usually with the healthiest, genetically superi- time and money cutting trees they have no use or trees outcompeting their slower-growing for. Trees smaller than 10 inches in diameter neighbors. Clearcuttiing is not the only way to are often stunted, poorly formed trees just as regenerate a forest. Other traditional old as the larger trees. They are also likely to silvicultural techniques include the be genetically inferior specimens that have no shelterwood, seed-tree, and selection methods. chance of ever growing to a large size. It is All four are important and viable tools to re- obviously best not to leave them behind as generate a forest. As long as a clearcut has residual trees taking up space in the next been carefully planned using sound forestry generation of the forest. principles, and is carried out using proper erosion-control practices, it is consistent with Clearcutting is ugly—at first. Yes, that’s true, sustainable forest management. especially to the untrained eye. Diameter-limit .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Story About Understory Why Everyone on Bald Head Island Should Care
    Bald Head Association 910-457-4676 • www.BaldHeadAssociation.com 111 Lighthouse Wynd • PO Box 3030, Bald Head Island, NC 28461 The Story About Understory Why Everyone on Bald Head Island Should Care Bald Head Island is truly unique. As a barrier island, it at ground level. Bald Head Island’s latitudinal position is bordered by the Atlantic Ocean and Cape Fear River. BHI has supports both northern and southern species of plants.” 14 miles of pristine beaches; 12,400 acres, of which 10,000 acres Important understory plants include vines, small plants and are protected; over 244 species of birds, including the bald eagle; trees, mosses, lichens and even weeds. All are needed to have and the North Carolina Forest Preserve of nearly 200 acres. a healthy forest habitat. Many extreme forces of nature that have helped shape this The BHIC explains, “Vines play an important role. The very special island include hurricane-force winds, salt water and vines and herbaceous plants intertwine, further developing the salt spray, flooding and drought. There is another force of nature structural integrity of the forest and forming pockets of vegetation that impacts BHI — humans — and with us, development. that provide a base for songbirds to build nests. The vines twist The Bald Head Association is mandated by its Covenants to around the canopy and are the secret to wind protection. These help sustain BHI by managing the buildout of homes and by vines actually weave together the canopy so blowing winds don’t managing vegetation trimming/removal, to help protect its penetrate through the top layer and keep homes, plants, and members’ property values.
    [Show full text]
  • Old-Growth Forests
    Pacific Northwest Research Station NEW FINDINGS ABOUT OLD-GROWTH FORESTS I N S U M M A R Y ot all forests with old trees are scientifically defined for many centuries. Today’s old-growth forests developed as old growth. Among those that are, the variations along multiple pathways with many low-severity and some Nare so striking that multiple definitions of old-growth high-severity disturbances along the way. And, scientists forests are needed, even when the discussion is restricted to are learning, the journey matters—old-growth ecosystems Pacific coast old-growth forests from southwestern Oregon contribute to ecological diversity through every stage of to southwestern British Columbia. forest development. Heterogeneity in the pathways to old- growth forests accounts for many of the differences among Scientists understand the basic structural features of old- old-growth forests. growth forests and have learned much about habitat use of forests by spotted owls and other species. Less known, Complexity does not mean chaos or a lack of pattern. Sci- however, are the character and development of the live and entists from the Pacific Northwest (PNW) Research Station, dead trees and other plants. We are learning much about along with scientists and students from universities, see the structural complexity of these forests and how it leads to some common elements and themes in the many pathways. ecological complexity—which makes possible their famous The new findings suggest we may need to change our strat- biodiversity. For example, we are gaining new insights into egies for conserving and restoring old-growth ecosystems. canopy complexity in old-growth forests.
    [Show full text]
  • Sass Forestecomgt 2018.Pdf
    Forest Ecology and Management 419–420 (2018) 31–41 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Forest Ecology and Management journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/foreco Lasting legacies of historical clearcutting, wind, and salvage logging on old- T growth Tsuga canadensis-Pinus strobus forests ⁎ Emma M. Sassa, , Anthony W. D'Amatoa, David R. Fosterb a Rubenstein School of Environment and Natural Resources, University of Vermont, Burlington, VT 05405, USA b Harvard Forest, Harvard University, 324 N Main St, Petersham, MA 01366, USA ARTICLE INFO ABSTRACT Keywords: Disturbance events affect forest composition and structure across a range of spatial and temporal scales, and Coarse woody debris subsequent forest development may differ after natural, anthropogenic, or compound disturbances. Following Compound disturbance large, natural disturbances, salvage logging is a common and often controversial management practice in many Forest structure regions of the globe. Yet, while the short-term impacts of salvage logging have been studied in many systems, the Large, infrequent natural disturbance long-term effects remain unclear. We capitalized on over eighty years of data following an old-growth Tsuga Pine-hemlock forests canadensis-Pinus strobus forest in southwestern New Hampshire, USA after the 1938 hurricane, which severely Pit and mound structures damaged forests across much of New England. To our knowledge, this study provides the longest evaluation of salvage logging impacts, and it highlights developmental trajectories for Tsuga canadensis-Pinus strobus forests under a variety of disturbance histories. Specifically, we examined development from an old-growth condition in 1930 through 2016 across three different disturbance histories: (1) clearcut logging prior to the 1938 hurricane with some subsequent damage by the hurricane (“logged”), (2) severe damage from the 1938 hurricane (“hurricane”), and (3) severe damage from the hurricane followed by salvage logging (“salvaged”).
    [Show full text]
  • Understory Forest Monitoring: a Guide for Small Forest Managers
    Understory Forest Monitoring: A Guide for Small Forest Managers With funding provided by BEFORE: A dense monoculture of invasive periwinkle (Vinca species). AFTER: A diverse mix of native vegetation beginning to establish. It will mature into a lush forest Á oor of native wildÁ owers. Managing a healthy forest is not just about having healthy trees. Foresters, scientists, and private woodland owners have an interest in what is growing on the forest Á oor. A healthy understory can offer: • Flowers for native pollinators • Food for wildlife • Resiliency against invasion by forest weeds • Organic material to build healthier soil • Stable soil that doesn’t erode into nearby streams • Beautiful views while recreating in the forest Just like taking inventory of the forest, measuring tree diameters and spacing, it is also important to monitor the changes over time on the forest Á oor. Herbaceous forest plants tend to reach their peak bloom and cover in mid to late spring (mid-May to mid-June in western Oregon). It’s best to monitor forest understory consistently at this time of year. There are dozens of ways to monitor the understory plants in a forest. Two effective methods are described here. Point intercept method This method is performed by laying out a straight line transect in the forest and documenting what is growing on the forest Á oor at one- foot increments along the transect. West Multnomah Soil & Water Conservation District often sets up multiple transects that are 33’ in length giving us 33 data points per transect. The data gathered from the plots can be used to À nd the average cover of different vegetation types in your forest.
    [Show full text]
  • Accelerating the Development of Old-Growth Characteristics in Second-Growth Northern Hardwoods
    United States Department of Agriculture Accelerating the Development of Old-growth Characteristics in Second-growth Northern Hardwoods Karin S. Fassnacht, Dustin R. Bronson, Brian J. Palik, Anthony W. D’Amato, Craig G. Lorimer, Karl J. Martin Forest Northern General Technical Service Research Station Report NRS-144 February 2015 Abstract Active management techniques that emulate natural forest disturbance and stand development processes have the potential to enhance species diversity, structural complexity, and spatial heterogeneity in managed forests, helping to meet goals related to biodiversity, ecosystem health, and forest resilience in the face of uncertain future conditions. There are a number of steps to complete before, during, and after deciding to use active management for this purpose. These steps include specifying objectives and identifying initial targets, recognizing and addressing contemporary stressors that may hinder the ability to meet those objectives and targets, conducting a pretreatment evaluation, developing and implementing treatments, and evaluating treatments for success of implementation and for effectiveness after application. In this report we discuss these steps as they may be applied to second-growth northern hardwood forests in the northern Lake States region, using our experience with the ongoing managed old-growth silvicultural study (MOSS) as an example. We provide additional examples from other applicable studies across the region. Quality Assurance This publication conforms to the Northern Research Station’s Quality Assurance Implementation Plan which requires technical and policy review for all scientific publications produced or funded by the Station. The process included a blind technical review by at least two reviewers, who were selected by the Assistant Director for Research and unknown to the author.
    [Show full text]
  • Silviculture Is Trees
    Forests and Iorestry are much in the news these days. More and more [he public is looking over the forester’s or the landowner’s shoulder and asking, "What is gi?ing on here?" Indeed, what-to-do-about-our-forests is such a newsworthy topic that there is an increasing need for a clear understanding of what foieslry really is. The essence of forestry-the art and science of grow- ing foresls-is called silviculture. And that is what this booklel is all about. Of course, there is mere to forestry than silviculture, but understanding the basic silvicultural options available for treating a forest is a first big step in exploring the entire range of foreslry. In its broadesl sense, forestry includes economic, social, and phil- osophical as well as biological considerations; silviculture deals primarily with the biological aspects of growing trees. Oespite its recent emergences as a national "issue’,’ forestry-and mere specifically, silviculture-is not a new invention. It has been known and practiced in Europe for hundreds of years and in Ibis country for nearly a century. A brief treatment of a complex subiect must, of course, generalize and simplify, and that is what we have done in the following pages. We are more concerned here with Ihe principles of silviculture than wilh specific applica- tions. The discussion should help the reader to better un- derstand what he reads and hears about forestry, and sees for himself in the woods. He will also learn Io use some of the terms defined and-more importantly per- haps-know when they are being misused.
    [Show full text]
  • Clearcutting on State Forests
    (Harlow,ONR-DLF-3 1997) (Harlow, 1997) / Clearcutting on State Forests New York State Department of Environmental Conservation DEC Program Policy Issuing Authority: Christopher Amato, Asst. Commissioner Title: Clearcutting on State Forests for Natural Resources Date Issued: 3/21/11 Latest Date Revised: N/A I. Summary: This Policy provides the procedures for clearcutting or conducting other regeneration cuttings on State Forests, including Reforestation, Multiple Use, and Unique Areas. II. Policy: It is the policy of the DEC Division of Lands and Forests (Division) to ensure all even-age regeneration methods on State Forests, including clearcutting, are undertaken in a sustainable and ecologically responsible manner with appropriate levels of agency oversight and public notice and in accordance with the Standards and Procedures of this policy. III. Purpose: The purpose of this policy is to ensure that clearcutting and other regeneration cuts undertaken by the Division as a forest management tool are done in a manner that (i) promotes long-term sustainability of the forest and the temporary establishment of early successional forest habitat, (ii) maintains the presence of shade intolerant species, and (iii) enhances biological diversity. This policy also describes the procedures to minimize negative visual impacts to the surrounding landscape from clearcutting and other regeneration cuts. In addition, this policy establishes procedures to keep all levels of the Division and the public informed of and educated concerning management decisions when conducting clearcutting and other regeneration cuts. This policy supports the Division’s goal to sustainably manage New York’s State Forests and to maintain green certification under the most current and applicable standards set forth by the Sustainable Forestry Initiative® (SFI® ) and Forest Stewardship Council® (FSC® ).
    [Show full text]
  • E666134Z Enhance Development of the Forest Understory to Create
    CONSERVATION ENHANCEMENT ACTIVITY E666134Z Enhance development of the forest understory to create conditions resistant to pests Conservation Practice 666: Forest Stand Improvement APPLICABLE LAND USE: Forest RESOURCE CONCERN ADDRESSED: Degraded Plant Condition PRACTICE LIFE SPAN: 10 Years Enhancement Description: Forest stand improvement that manages the structure and composition of overstory and understory vegetation to reduce vulnerability to damage by insects and diseases of forest trees. Managing the understory vegetation will also reduce the risk of wildfire, and promote development of herbaceous plants that benefit wildlife. This enhancement provides for management of the understory vegetation in a forested area, using mechanical, chemical or manual methods to improve the plant species mix and the health of the residual vegetation. These practices encourage the development of a less dense forested ecosystem. The canopy gaps and open understory allow for air circulation that reduces the incidence of disease, and the improved health of the residual trees increases their ability to withstand insect attacks. Forest stand improvement (FSI) activities are used to remove trees of undesirable species, form, quality, condition, or growth rate. The quantity and quality of forest for wildlife and/or timber production will be increased by manipulating stand density and structure. These treatments can also reduce wildfire hazards, improve forest health, restore natural plant communities, and achieve or maintain a desired native understory plant community for soil health, wildlife, grazing, and/or browsing. Criteria: States will apply general criteria from the NRCS National Conservation Practice Standard (CPS) 666 as listed below, and additional criteria as required by the NRCS State Office. The enhancement will be applied to sites which have an uncharacteristically dense understory of shrubs and small trees that limit development of ground cover.
    [Show full text]
  • Clearcutting in the National Forests: Background and Overview
    98-917 ENR CRS Report for Congress Received through the CRS Web Clearcutting in the National Forests: Background and Overview November 6, 1998 (name redacted) Natural Resources Economist and Policy Specialist Environment and Natural Resources Policy Division Congressional Research Service The Library of Congress ABSTRACT Clearcutting is a controversial method of harvesting and regenerating stands of trees in which all trees are cleared from a site and a new even-aged stand is grown. It is a proven, efficient method of harvesting trees and establishing new stands, but is criticized for degrading soil and water quality, wildlife habitat, and aesthetics. Clearcutting is still the primary timber management method used in the national forests, although its use has declined over the past decade. Legislation to ban clear-cutting on federal lands has been introduced in the past few Congresses. This report provides background and an overview on clearcutting use and effects; it will probably not be updated. Clearcutting in the National Forests: Background and Overview Summary Clearcutting is a method of harvesting and regenerating trees in which all trees are cleared from a site and a new, even-aged stand of trees is grown. Clearcutting is the primary method of timber production and management in the national forests. However, this method of harvesting trees has been controversial since at least the 1960s. Many environmental and citizen groups object to clearcutting in the national forests, citing soil and water degradation, unsightly landscapes, and other damages. The wood products industry argues that clearcutting is an efficient and successful silvicultural system. Between 1984 and 1997, clearcutting accounted for 59% of the area harvested for regeneration in the national forests.
    [Show full text]
  • Managing Forests for Fish and Wildlife
    Wildlife Habitat Management Institute Managing Forests for Fish and Wildlife December 2002 Fish and Wildlife Habitat Management Leaflet Number 18 Forested areas can be managed with a wide variety of objectives, ranging from allowing natural processes to dictate long-term condition without active management of any kind, to maximizing production of wood products on the shortest rotations possible. The primary purpose of this document is to show how fish and wildlife habitat management can be effectively integrated into the management of forestlands that are subject to periodic timber harvest activities. For forestlands that are not managed for production of timber or other forest products, many of the principles U.S. Forest Service, Southern Research Station in this leaflet also apply. Introduction Succession of Forest Vegetation Forests in North America provide a wide variety of In order to meet both timber production and wildlife important natural resource functions. Although management goals, landowners and managers need commercial forests may be best known for production to understand how forest vegetation responds following of pulp, lumber, and other wood products, they also timber management, or silvicultural prescriptions, or supply valuable fish and wildlife habitat, recreational other disturbances. Forest vegetation typically opportunities, water quality protection, and other progresses from one plant community to another over natural resource benefits. In approximately two-thirds time. This forest succession can be described in four of the forest land (land that is at least 10% tree- stages: covered) in the United States, harvest of wood products plays an integral role in how these lands are managed. Sustainable forest management applies Fish and Wildlife Air and Water biological, economic, and social principles to forest Wood Products Habitat Quality regeneration, management, and conservation to meet the specific goals of landowners or managers.
    [Show full text]
  • Landowner's Guide to Woodland Wildlife Management University
    G3578 A LANDOWNER’S GUIDE TO WOODLAND WILDLIFE MANAGEMENT with emphasis on the ruffed grouse By Stephen DeStefano, Scott R. Craven, Robert L. Ruff, Darrel F. Covell and John F. Kubisiak Cover photo of the Leopold shack, Leopold Memorial Reserve, Baraboo, Wisconsin by Darrel Covell University of Wisconsin–Madison, University of Wisconsin–Extension, Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources and the Ruffed Grouse Society of North America i CONTENTS PREFACE iii INTRODUCTION v Focus on the ruffed grouse vi The Wisconsin private woodland owner: a profile vii 1 A FOREST ECOSYSTEM PRIMER 1-6 5 MANAGING MATURE FORESTS AND THEIR Wildlife needs 1 WILDLIFE 31-35 Wildlife management principles 2 What is a mature forest? 31 Forest succession: the growth of The value of mature forests 33 a woodland 4 Turkeys 33 Managing the forest as an ecosystem 6 Squirrels 33 2 THE NATURAL ZONES OF WISCONSIN 7-10 Woodpeckers, wood ducks and other cavity-users 34 The Northern Forest 8 Songbirds 34 The Eastern Deciduous Forest 9 Mammals 35 The Central Sand Counties 9 Reptiles and amphibians 35 The Western Upland 9 6 FINANCIAL CONSIDERATIONS 36-39 3 DESIGNING A HABITAT MANAGEMENT Marketing timber 36 PLAN 11-14 Seven steps to successful timber harvest 36 Set management objectives 11 Cost-sharing programs 36 Inventory and evaluate your land 12 Tax considerations 38 Seek professional assistance 13 Finalize your management plan 14 CONCLUSION 40 4 MANAGING YOUNG FORESTS FOR GROUSE REFERENCES FOR FURTHER READING 41-42 AND OTHER WILDLIFE 15-30 Woodland wildlife management 41
    [Show full text]
  • Canada's Rainforests Under Threat
    CLEARCUTTING CANADA’S RAINFOREST STATUS REPORT 2005 Canada’s Rainforests Under Threat anada’s coastal temperate Key Findings rainforest is a magnificent ○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○ C and globally significant old- ➊ Clearcutting continues in Canada’s growth forest ecosystem that rainforests contains the highest biomass of any 74% of logging in Canada’s rainforest is ecosystem on the planet. Found on clearcut logging.1 the Pacific Coast of the province of British Columbia (B.C.), this rainforest ecosystem supports a ➋ Salmon streams under threat wide range of species, including 46% of logging in Canada’s rainforests is large wild Pacific salmon runs, taking place in the most productive salmon Grizzly bears, wolves, unique white watersheds. Kermode/Spirit bears, and rare species including the Northern Goshawk and the endangered ○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○○ ➌ Logging of old growth continues Marbled Murrelet. 78% of logging in Canada’s rainforests has been in old growth forests-home to majestic Compared to other areas of old growth cedar and sitka spruce. B.C., this region has remained relatively inaccessible to industrial- style resource extraction, leaving ➍ large areas impressively preserved. Species at risk Proposed protection for the Great Bear The largest remaining intact areas Rainforest leaves 80% of white “spirit” bear of this unique forest are found habitat at risk to logging.* between the northern tip of Van- couver Island and the Alaska Panhandle, including Haida Gwaii 1 Clearcutting is defined by the removal of over 70% of the trees
    [Show full text]