Analogous Pacific and Atlantic Meridional Modes of Tropical
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1NOVEMBER 2004 CHIANG AND VIMONT 4143 Analogous Paci®c and Atlantic Meridional Modes of Tropical Atmosphere±Ocean Variability* JOHN C. H. CHIANG 1Department of Geography, and Center for Atmospheric Sciences, University of California, Berkeley, Berkeley, California DANIEL J. VIMONT Department of Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences, University of WisconsinÐMadison, Madison, Wisconsin (Manuscript received 4 December 2003, in ®nal form 28 May 2004) ABSTRACT From observational analysis a Paci®c mode of variability in the intertropical convergence zone (ITCZ)/cold tongue region is identi®ed that possesses characteristics and interpretation similar to the dominant ``meridional'' mode of interannual±decadal variability in the tropical Atlantic. The Paci®c and Atlantic meridional modes are characterized by an anomalous sea surface temperature (SST) gradient across the mean latitude of the ITCZ coupled to an anomalous displacement of the ITCZ toward the warmer hemisphere. Both are forced by trade wind variations in their respective northern subtropical oceans. The Paci®c meridional mode exists independently of ENSO, although ENSO nonlinearity projects strongly on it during the peak anomaly season of boreal spring. It is suggested that the Paci®c and Atlantic modes are analogous, governed by physics intrinsic to the ITCZ/ cold tongue complex. 1. Introduction mode (hereafter the meridional mode, also known as the gradient or interhemispheric mode) arises. Nobre and The dominant statistical mode of tropical Atlantic in- Shukla (1996) argued from observational analysis that terannual±decadal atmosphere±ocean variability is an trade wind variations in the north tropical Atlantic pre- anomalous meridional SST gradient across the mean intertropical convergence zone (ITCZ) latitude and a cede the tropical basinwide anomalies that in turn pro- cross-gradient atmospheric boundary layer ¯ow toward duced SST anomalies there (and hence an anomalous the anomalously warmer hemisphere (Nobre and Shukla SST gradient across the mean ITCZ latitude), implying 1996; Chang et al. 1997). Hastenrath and Greischar that the mode is externally forced. Two sources of ex- (1993) proposed that this boundary layer ¯ow is driven ternal forcing have been identi®ed: ENSO and the North by the anomalous meridional SST gradient through its Atlantic Oscillation (NAO; e.g., Curtis and Hastenrath hydrostatic effect on sea level pressure (Lindzen and 1995; Nobre and Shukla 1996; Xie and Tanimoto 1998; Nigam 1987). The cross-gradient ¯ow implies a shift of Giannini et al. 2000). They directly perturb the boreal the ITCZ and associated convection toward the anom- winter north tropical Atlantic (NTA) trade wind alously warmer hemisphere (e.g., Hastenrath and Heller strength, changing the underlying SST through latent 1977). This basic pictureÐlinking anomalous SST, heat ¯uxes. The resulting NTA SST perturbation peaks winds, and convectionÐhas been supported in subse- in boreal spring, creating the near-equatorial meridional quent observational and modeling studies (e.g., Ruiz- SST gradient. Barradas et al. 1999; Chang et al. 2000; Chiang et al. Chang et al. (1997) proposed an alternative expla- 2002). nation for the origins of the meridional mode, pointing Two interpretations had been proposed for how this to a positive feedback [sometimes known as wind±evap- oration±SST (WES) feedback (e.g., Xie 1999)] between the SST gradient and the cross-gradient ¯ow. The cross- * National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Contribution Number 1010. gradient ¯ow reduced the strength of the trade winds in the anomalously warmer hemisphere and increased the trades in the cooler hemisphere, and this reinforced the Corresponding author address: John Chiang, Department of Ge- SST gradient through wind speed impact on anomalous ography, University of California, 547 McCone Hall, Berkeley, Berkeley, CA 94720-4740. evaporation. Idealized modeling studies (e.g., Chang et E-mail: [email protected] al. 1997; Xie 1999) have shown that this feedback can q 2004 American Meteorological Society Unauthenticated | Downloaded 09/30/21 06:48 PM UTC 4144 JOURNAL OF CLIMATE VOLUME 17 qualitatively reproduce the observed behavior, though march lagging by a quarter cycle the seasonal cycle of it was found that under realistic coupling strength the the ITCZ over land (Mitchell and Wallace 1992). An model behavior was not self-sustaining, and that exter- idealized tropical coupled general circulation model nal forcing was required to sustain the variability. Sub- study (Xie and Saito 2001) shows that in the absence sequent modeling and observational studies show this of thermocline±SST feedback central to the ENSO phys- feedback is relatively weak and limited to the deep Trop- ics, interannual variations in the north±south oceanic ics (Chang et al. 2000; Chiang et al. 2002; Czaja et al. ITCZ position are present, suggesting that this vari- 2002), further underlining the need for external forcing. ability is intrinsic to the ITCZ/cold tongue climate. In- A more recent idealized model study by Kushnir et al. deed, a mode in the Paci®c with spatial pattern remi- (2002) incorporating the deep Tropics±limited WES niscent of the Atlantic meridional mode was identi®ed feedback suggests, however, that the feedback is essen- in a recent coupled model study with realistic con®g- tial to the decadal nature of meridional mode variability. uration (Yukimoto et al. 2000). Finally, recent detailed Our current knowledge of the meridional mode physics observational and general circulation model (GCM) thus suggests that it is externally forced through trade analyses by Vimont and collaborators (Vimont et al. wind variations, with limited WES feedback in the deep 2001, 2003b) shows that a leading mode of wintertime Tropics. atmospheric variability in the North Paci®c [the North An outstanding issue with the meridional mode is the Paci®c Oscillation (NPO); Rogers 1981] forces varia- issue of (out of phase) coherence between the SST tions of the north tropical Paci®c (NTP) SST through anomalies on either side of the anomalous SST gradient. its control of the subtropical trades there, a mechanism Houghton and Tourre 1992) showed that the dipolelike similar to the external forcing of the tropical Atlantic nature of the anomalies derived from a straight empirical meridional mode by the NAO. orthogonal function (EOF) analysis of tropical Atlantic These similarities motivate us to search for analogous SST anomalies do not survive under varimax rotation; tropical meridional modes in the two basins. We will instead, the two SST lobes appear to vary independently show that once the ENSO in¯uence is linearly removed of each other, a result supported by subsequent obser- from the SST and wind data we analyze, the dominant vational analysis (Mehta and Delworth 1995; En®eld et mode of atmosphere±ocean variability extracted sepa- al. 1999), and also the modeling study by Dommenget rately from the tropical Paci®c and tropical Atlantic ba- and Latif (2000). On the other hand, Xie and Tanimoto sin resembles each other in spatial and temporal char- (1998) argue using observational and modeling evi- acteristics (section 2). The Atlantic pattern is the me- dence for anticoherence between the two lobes at de- ridional mode pattern, whose interpretation is fairly well cadal time scales and part of a coherent pan-Atlantic established from previous studies. A nonlinear com- decadal oscillation characterized by zonal bands of SST ponent of ENSO does, however, project strongly on the and wind anomalies with alternate polarities from the derived Paci®c mode. We show that by additionally ®l- tropical South Atlantic to Greenland. The ``dipole'' is- tering out the strong ENSO years from our analysis, the sue is intimately tied to the physical interpretation of derived Paci®c mode stays essentially the same, indi- the mode, since independent behavior between the cating that this mode does not depend on ENSO for its northern and southern SST lobes suggests an externally existence (section 3). We then show that the Paci®c and forced mechanism with little to no positive feedback in Atlantic modes share the same physical interpretation, the Tropics, whereas dipole behavior between the north- and on that basis we argue that the Paci®c mode is the ern and southern lobes implies a stronger role for pos- analogue to the Atlantic meridional mode pattern (sec- itive feedback. At present, the prevailing evidence sug- tion 4). We reinforce our interpretation by showing the gests that the SST lobes act essentially independently, similarity between the two basins using a different in agreement with the prevailing physical interpretation; (composite) analysis (section 5). A summary and dis- although we emphasize that this issue is not yet fully cussion of the potential implications of our results is resolved in large part because of inadequate length of given in section 6. data, but also in part because simple models hint at dipolelike anomalous SST structures even with WES 2. Data, method, and results feedback limited to the deep Tropics (Kushnir et al. 2002). We use monthly mean SST and 10-m winds from the A similar tropical Paci®c mode of variability (here- National Centers for Environmental Prediction±Nation- after the meridional mode, following Servain et al. al Center for Atmospheric Research (NCEP±NCAR) re- 1999) has heretofore not been identi®ed, in large part analysis (Kalnay et al. 1996, hereafter simply the re- because the El NinÄo±Southern Oscillation (ENSO) dom- analysis) spanning January 1948±December 2001. For inates the variability there (Wallace et al. 1998). There each ®eld, we spatially averaged over six adjoining (two are, however, compelling reasons for its existence. Each latitude by three longitude) grid points, computed de- basin possesses similar mean states: namely, a cold trended monthly mean anomalies, and applied a 3-month tongue over the equatorial oceans (weighted to the east) running mean. The spatial averaging does not unduly and an ITCZ at its northern edge that follows an annual impact the result, as the extracted dominant mode pos- Unauthenticated | Downloaded 09/30/21 06:48 PM UTC 1NOVEMBER 2004 CHIANG AND VIMONT 4145 FIG.