Outer North East Gypsy and Traveller Sites Proposed Allocations

APPENDIX 1

SUMMARY OF REPRESENTATIONS TO HMCAS:

Outer North East Proposed Allocations and Gypsy and Traveller Sites Outer North East

Identified housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-27 Linton Springs, Sicklinghall Road, Linton 2 1 0 1 7 Issues raised General approach/methodology, Policy omission/Site requirements

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Capacity should be 7 not 16. Response The 2016 refresh of the identified sites and planning permission has already amended this figure Action Capacity change to 7 units

Detail Capacity change from 16 to 7 following April 2016 identified refresh Response Capacity change Action Capacity change • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-28 Spofforth Hill, Wetherby LS22 2 0 1 1 325 Issues raised Highways and transport, Local services, Schools

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Site is deleted due to technical considerations meaning the capacity at this site is now considered to be windfall and therefore not to be set against the requirement Response Site deleted Action Site deleted • Outer North East

Identified housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-30 Wetherby Health Centre 2 1 0 1 0 Issues raised General approach/methodology, Policy omission/Site requirements

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Site deleted as rebuilt as health centre and housing units will not be advanced Response Site deleted Action Site deleted • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-31 FORMER GEORGE & DRAGON, HIGH STREET, WETHERBY, LS22 6LT 0 0 0 0 2 Issues raised None

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Identified housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-33 HALLFIELD LANE WETHERBY 0 0 0 0 9 Issues raised None

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Identified housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-36 Moor End (7-14) - Boston Spa LS23 6ER 2 1 0 1 9 Issues raised Factual correction required, Policy omission/Site requirements

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Suggestion that the capacity of the site should be amended to 1 given that this represents the net number of new dwellings on the site. Response The units to be demolished in the course of development are included within the Council’s demolition allowance of 250 units per annum. Consequently no change is required and all of the new dwellings can be counted. Action No change • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-37 Churchfields, Boston Spa 3 1 1 1 153 Issues raised General approach/methodology, Policy omission/Site requirements

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Capacity should be amended from 170 to 153 to reflect on site delivery. Response The 2016 refresh of the identified sites has already amended this figure Action Capacity change to 153 units

Detail Capacity change from 170 to 153 following April 2016 identified refresh Response Capacity change Action Capacity change • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-38 REAR OF 134-140 HIGH STREET, BOSTON SPA, WETHERBY, LS23 6BW 3 2 0 1 6 Issues raised Factual correction required, Greenfield/brownfield, Policy omission/Site requirements

Identified housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-39 Church Lane (27) - St Vincents School, Boston Spa 0 0 0 0 13 Issues raised None

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Capacity change from 18 to 8 following April 2016 identified refresh Response Capacity change Action Capacity change

Detail The capacity of the site should be change from 18 to 8 units to reflect the latest planning permission. Response The 2016 refresh of the identified sites has already amended this figure Action Amend the capacity of the site to 8 units • Outer North East

Identified housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-42 First Avenue, Bardsey 0 0 0 0 5 Issues raised None

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-43 Keswick La, Bardsey 3 0 3 0 9 Issues raised Ecology/Landscape/Trees, Flooding and drainage, Highways and transport, Ownership/Delivery

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Identified housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-45 Wetherby LS23 6HJ 0 0 0 0 5 Issues raised None

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Identified housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-48 Wetherby Road (land to east at Castle Mona Lodge), Scarcroft 0 0 0 0 11 Issues raised None

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Identified housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-51 Bowcliffe Road - Bramham House, Bramham 1 0 1 0 30 Issues raised Conservation and heritage, Ecology/Landscape/Trees

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Status change from dormant to live following withdrawal of Headley Hall allocation Response Status change Action Status change • Outer North East

Identified housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-54 Black Horse Farm, South Approach, Aberford 0 0 0 0 5 Issues raised None

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-55 Station Road (37-51), Scholes 2 0 2 0 1 Issues raised Ecology/Landscape/Trees, Greenbelt, Greenfield/brownfield, Highways and transport

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Identified housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-57 White House Farm, Bunkers Hill, Aberford, LS25 0 0 0 0 5 Issues raised None

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG1-288 East Leeds Extension 12 2 6 4 675 Issues raised Agricultural land, Consultation process, General approach/methodology, Greenbelt, Greenspace/Green infrastructure, Highways and transport, Housing target, Local services, Noise/Air quality, Ownership/Delivery, Site boundary, Sustainability appraisal

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Highways agency comments - need for further highways improvements and potential developer contributions should be recongised in SAP. Further modelling work required. Response HG1-288 is an identified site and is therefore not subject to Transport and Highways Site Requirements, other than set out through the UDP. Action No Change

Detail Land owner requesting new alignment for ELOR and ELE allocation Response HG1-288 is an identified site and therefore the boundary is not subject to change. In addition the timescales involved in redrawing boundaries do not fit with the timescales for the delivery of ELOR, and would unnecessarily slow the delivery of the project. Action No Change • Outer North East

Housing allocation

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG2-19 Land at Sandbeck Lane Wetherby 3 2 1 0 165 Issues raised Ecology/Landscape/Trees, Flooding and drainage, Greenbelt, Greenfield/brownfield, Ground conditions, Highways and transport, Local services, Noise/Air quality, Ownership/Delivery, Phasing, Schools, Site status

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Additional flood risk site requirements required following additional flood risk assessment work Response Amend site requirement to include requested change Action Add wording to site requirements under Flood Risk : 'A small part of the site is affected by flood risk. A sequential approach should be taken to the layout of the site so that no housing or other more vulnerable development is located in the zone 3 high flood risk part of the site' • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG2-20 Mercure Hotel, Wetherby Road, Wetherby 2 1 0 1 67 Issues raised Conservation and heritage, Ecology/Landscape/Trees, Policy omission/Site requirements

Housing allocation

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG2-22 Church Street (land to the east of), Boston Spa 3 1 1 1 36 Issues raised Conservation and heritage, Greenbelt, Local services, Ownership/Delivery, Phasing, Policy omission/Site requirements, Schools, Site boundary

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Historic England advises that an assessment needs to be undertaken of the contribution the site makes to the significance of heritage assets. If it is considered that the development of this site would harm elements which contribute to the significance of heritage assets, the Plan needs to set out the measures by which that harm might be removed or reduced. If, at the end of the process, it is concluded that the development would still be likely to harm elements which contribute to the significance of the heritage assets, then the site should not be allocated unless there are clear public benefits that outweigh the harm. Response This has been considered through the Heritage Background Paper. Action Sites HG2-22 and HG2-23 are to be merged. The Conservation Area site requirement for the merged allocation should be amended to state: •Conservation Area: The site is within the Boston Spa Conservation Area. Any development should preserve or enhance the character or appearance of the Conservation Area. The openness of the southern part of the site has an important role in contributing to the significance of the Conservation Area, and so no built development should take place on this part of the site. Development should also seek to preserve historic field boundaries. Further guidance on these requirements is provided in the Heritage Background Paper.

Detail Landowners agent suggests boundary of the site should be extended to include the adjacent identified St Vincents Schools site (HG1-39) in the same ownership. Response Retain as existing with separate identified site and allocation, with site requirement for access through identified site. Action No change to the plan

Detail Amending the green space site requirement to 'Provide a pedestrian link to the adjacent Green Space at Stables Lane from Church Street and Lonsdale Meadows'. Response No specific response required Action Amend site requirement

Detail Site to be merged with HG2-23 Response No specific response required Action Merge HG2-22 and HG2-23 • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG2-23 Church Street 3 1 1 1 17 Issues raised Conservation and heritage, General approach/methodology, Highways and transport, Local services, Ownership/Delivery, Phasing, Schools, Sustainability

Housing allocation

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG2-24 Keswick Lane (land to north of), Bardsey - site of The Blessed Sacrament Church 132 1 131 0 10 Issues raised Affordable housing, Community and local character, Conservation and heritage, Consultation process, Duty to Cooperate, Ecology/Landscape/Trees, General approach/methodology, Greenbelt, Greenfield/brownfield, Greenspace/Green infrastructure, Highways and transport, Housing mix, Housing target, Local services, Ownership/Delivery, Phasing, Schools, Sustainability appraisal

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail The council has taken into account the issues raised and considers that no changes are required to make the plan sound Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG2-25 Farfield House, Bramham 111 4 107 0 14 Issues raised Affordable housing, Agricultural land, Community and local character, Conservation and heritage, Consultation process, Ecology/Landscape/Trees, Flooding and drainage, General approach/methodology, Greenbelt, Greenfield/brownfield, Greenspace/Green infrastructure, Highways and transport, Housing mix, Housing target, Local services, Noise/Air quality, Ownership/Delivery, Schools, Site boundary

Housing allocation

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG2-26 Wetherby Road - Scarcroft Lodge, Scarcroft 5 1 3 1 100 Issues raised Conservation and heritage, Ecology/Landscape/Trees, Flooding and drainage, Greenbelt, Greenfield/brownfield, Greenspace/Green infrastructure, Ground conditions, Highways and transport, Local services, Noise/Air quality, Ownership/Delivery, Policy omission/Site requirements, Schools, Site boundary, Site status, Sustainability

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Site classed as 'sieved out' within Green Belt background paper. Should be allocated. Response Change to Green Belt background paper required Action Update Green Belt background paper: Note - to remain washed over by Green Belt

Detail The capacity of the site appears unachievable given the site and policy constraints. In particular the site requirements stipulate that only the developed parts of the site can be built on. The site also lies within the Green Belt and Conservation Area. Consequently a bespoke capacity is more appropriate than using the standard density multiplier approach. Response Recommend the capacity of the site is reduced to 100 to reflect the site contriants. Action Capacity of the site is reduced to 100 • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG2-28 Land to the East of Belle Vue Avenue, Scholes 144 2 138 4 15 Issues raised Affordable housing, Agricultural land, Community and local character, Conservation and heritage, Consultation process, Duty to Cooperate, Ecology/Landscape/Trees, Flooding and drainage, Greenbelt, Greenfield/brownfield, Greenspace/Green infrastructure, Highways and transport, Housing mix, Housing target, Local services, Ownership/Delivery, Phasing, Schools

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 70 Linton Spring (office building), Sicklinghall Road, Wetherby 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 830 Thorner Lane - Oaklands Manor, Scarcroft 0 0 0 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1028 Wetherby Road (land to west), north of Scarcroft 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1055A Thorpe Arch Estate, Wetherby LS23 7BJ 108 83 25 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail An alternative site boundary with a lower capacity (up to 1000 units) has been submitted for consideration Response The alternative boundary and revised capacity has been considered, however it is not deemed to alter Officers overall conclusions not to allocate the site for housing. Whilst interest has been expressed to bring forward this large brownfield site which currently in employment and retail uses concerns have been epxressed in regard to the deliverability and viability of the site given infrastructure and site specific considerations. The site is not required to meet the housing numbers due to an alternative strategic option. Action No change - Site to remain not allocated

Detail Reference to site 1055 (includes 1055A & 1055B) and SA scores for the site. SA1 & SA2 (employment) -do not reflect that the loss of employment will be limited and there are employment opportunities elsewhere in Thorp Arch. SA3 (education) - does not acknowledge that a primary school is proposed, but acknowledge secondary school beyond 30m walk from Boston Spa. SA6 (culture, leisure & recreational activities) - score doesn't acknowedge existing activities within the TA estate. At the Issues & Options stage the site was scored neutral against SA6, there's been no change of circumstance since that stage.SA8 (social inclusion and community participation) - the site has the potential to accommodate new community facilities. SA11 (greenfield land) - the score was minor positive as occupied brownfield site, however it is predominantly derelict. SA13 (greenhouse emissions) & SA16 (local needs) - scored major negative at Publication stage, but neutral at Issues & Options. There have been no change of circumstances and there are a range of local bus services. SA17 (Waste) - scored major negative as considered to be designated waste site. The household recycling centre is on nearby land. SA19 (landscape) - the presence of TPOs on the site, should not score major negative as objective is to maintain and enhance landscape quality. SA20 (quality & distinctivenss of built environment) - scored negative (large greenfield site, out of character with settlement). Should be scored neutral (not unattractive brownfield site). SA21 (historic environment) - The site 'uncertain' (within or adjacent to heritage asset (100m) but scored neutral at Issues & Options stage. There are no heritage assets within or adjacent to the site boundary, so should be scored neutral. Response The SA process is based on the current status of the site, not what improvements, additional facilities, or mitigation measures may be proposed by a development proposal. So any new measures proposed are not reflected in the SA score for the site. SA1 & SA2 - the presence of existing employment uses (even if limited) are reflected in the negative score. SA3 - the score is based on existing accessibility to schools. SA6 & SA8- reflect the accessibility of the site and thereby access to a range of facilities.SA11 - the site was assessed minor negative for 10551055A and neutral for 1055B reflecting the different parts of the site.SA13 & SA16 - the score was corrected at the Publication stage to reflect the existing accessibility of the site (which was incorrect at the Issues & Options stage). SA17 - 1055A & 1055B are both affected by a waste designation in the Natural Resources & Waste DPD. SA20 - a single negative score was given to reflect the site being out of scale with the settlement (rather than it's brownfield status). SA21 - heritage assets are present within 100m of the site. Action No change to SA • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1055B Thorpe Arch Estate, Wetherby LS23 7BJ 6 0 4 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Reference to site 1055 (includes 1055A & 1055B) and SA scores for the site. SA1 & SA2 (employment) -do not reflect that the loss of employment will be limited and there are employment opportunities elsewhere in Thorp Arch. SA3 (education) - does not acknowledge that a primary school is proposed, but acknowledge secondary school beyond 30m walk from Boston Spa. SA6 (culture, leisure & recreational activities) - score doesn't acknowedge existing activities within the TA estate. At the Issues & Options stage the site was scored neutral against SA6, there's been no change of circumstance since that stage.SA8 (social inclusion and community participation) - the site has the potential to accommodate new community facilities. SA11 (greenfield land) - the score was minor positive as occupied brownfield site, however it is predominantly derelict. SA13 (greenhouse emissions) & SA16 (local needs) - scored major negative at Publication stage, but neutral at Issues & Options. There have been no change of circumstances and there are a range of local bus services. SA17 (Waste) - scored major negative as considered to be designated waste site. The household recycling centre is on nearby land. SA19 (landscape) - the presence of TPOs on the site, should not score major negative as objective is to maintain and enhance landscape quality. SA20 (quality & distinctivenss of built environment) - scored negative (large greenfield site, out of character with settlement). Should be scored neutral (not unattractive brownfield site). SA21 (historic environment) - The site 'uncertain' (within or adjacent to heritage asset (100m) but scored neutral at Issues & Options stage. There are no heritage assets within or adjace to the site boundary, so should be scored neutral. Response The SA process is based on the current status of the site, not what improvements, additional facilities, or mitigation measures may be proposed by a development proposal. So any new measures proposed are not reflected in the SA score for the site. SA1 & SA2 - the presence of existing employment uses (even if limited) are reflected in the negative score. SA3 - the score is based on existing accessibility to schools. SA6 & SA8- reflect the accessibility of the site and thereby access to a range of facilities.SA11 - the site was assessed minor negative for 10551055A and neutral for 1055B reflecting the different parts of the site.SA13 & SA16 - the score was corrected at the Publication stage to reflect the existing accessibility of the site (which was incorrect at the Issues & Options stage). SA17 - 1055A & 1055B are both affected by a waste designation in the Natural Resources & Waste DPD. SA20 - a single negative score was given to reflect the site being out of scale with the settlement (rather than it's brownfield status). SA21 - heritage assets are present within 100m of the site. Action No change to SA • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1056 Main Street (off) - Cricket Field, Shadwell 1 0 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1070 Linton Lane - Cragg Hall Farm, Wetherby LS22 0 0 0 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1106 First Avenue (land west of), Bardsey 3 1 2 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail A substantially reduced site boundary proposal has been received from the site promoters for assessment through the Site Allocations process. Response The revised site boundary and associated masterplan has been assessed by Officers, however these changes are not considered to alter the overall conclusions for the site. Action Site to remain not allocated for housing

Detail Site assessment is based on a site area of 14 ha with a capacity of 300 units. The site promoters now propose circa 6 ha.The negative scores are reduced or eliminated by reducing the developable area, avoiding areas of flood risk and providing improved highways access and pedestrian linkages. Response The SA assessment was based on the full site area of 14 ha. A revised site boundary is not proposed to be allocated therefore a separate SA assessment is not required. No change to site 1106. Action No change to SA. • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1107 Green Lane (land east of), Boston Spa LS23 1 0 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1109 Cinder Lane (land west of), Clifford, LS23 0 0 0 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1132 Lotherton Lane (land south of) 0 0 0 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1156 Bramham Road (land to east of), Clifford 1 0 0 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1162 Parlington Drive (east of), Aberford, LS25 1 0 1 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1233 York Road (land at)- Sandbeck Lane, Wetherby, LS22 1 0 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Consideration for site to be merged with adjacent sites 2158 and 3125 to create a more appropriate development site Response Merging of the sites is appropriate to maximise the development opportunities/benefits. Action Merge site with 2158, 3125 - amend capacity and site description

Detail Following the withdrawal of Headley Hall, new site allocations are required to help meet the housing target for the HMCA. Response Following further assessment work the site is considered suitable for allocation as a housing site (HG2-226) for the following reason. The site currently forms part of a collection of agriculture fields to the eastern edge of Wetherby. The site is not within the UDP Green Belt, however it is open countryside which is currently safeguarded by rural land policy (RL1) within the UDP. The site would be well contained and the wider area currently contains several urbanising developments such as the adjacent Young Offenders Institute. As such the development of the site would not be unduly detrimental to the character of the area. The site is situated adjacent the Wetherby which is the only major settlement within the HMCA. The site would have reasonable access to the Town Centre and local services. The site, alongside 2158 and 3125, is considered to form the best option for extending Wetherby when compared against reasonable alternatives. Action Allocate merged site for residential use and redraw Green Belt boundary

Detail A number of the SA scores are questioned. SA13 - the site scores double negative. It is on a bus route and within walking and cycling distance of Wetherby. Headley hall which is a remote location is scored neutral. Likewise other large urban extensions are scored better than 1233. SA14 - The site is mainly flood zone 1, a small area falls within zone 3 where playing fields are proposed. SA16 - the scoring assessment accepts that large sites have the ability to introduce components to improve accessibility. The site can deliver circa 1,000 dwellings. SA19 - the site is not in a Special Landscape. Response SA13 - the score is correct. The Headley Hall site was scored incorrectly (the highway score for accessibility is 1 ie double negative. SA14 - the score is based on the worst flood zone even if only occupies small area of the site. SA16 - it is acknowledged that large sites potentially could accommodate new services, however the SA score is based on the current accessibility of the site. SA19 - sites are scored double negative where there is a potential effect on SLAs or Tree Preservation Orders. The site must be affected by a TPO. Action No change • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1239 Dowkell Lane (land south of), Thorp Arch LS22 1 0 1 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1240 Church Causeway (land north of), Thorp Arch 1 0 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail An alternative site boundary has been submitted for consideration Response The alternative boundary has been considered, however it is not considered to alter Officers overall conclusions Action No change - Site to remain not allocated • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1241 Walton Road (land at), Thorp Arch LS22 1 0 1 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1262 Roundhay Park Lane, Sandy Lodge (site of) LS17 8AS 1 0 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1288 Manor Farm (land at), Shadwell, LS17 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail An alternative site boundary has been submitted for consideration Response The alternative boundary has been considered, however it is not deemed to alter Officers overall conclusions Action No change - Site to remain not allocated • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1290 Thorpe Arch - The Vicarage (land to rear of), Boston Spa 1 0 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail An alternative site boundary has been submitted for consideration Response The alternative boundary has been considered, however it is not deemed to alter Officers overall conclusions Action No change - Site to remain not allocated • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1292 Jewitt Lane (paddock at), Collingham, LS22 3 2 1 0

Detail An alternative site boundary has been submitted for consideration Response The alternative boundary has been considered, however it is not deemed to alter Officers overall conclusions Action No change - Site to remain not allocated • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1293 Harewood Road (land at), Collingham LS22 6 2 4 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Site submitter has suggested that the site could come forward alongside the adjacent site (3334) to create a comprehensive development Response The alternative boundary has been considered, however it is not deemed to alter Officers overall conclusions Action No change - Site to remain not allocated • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1300 Linton Lane - land opposite the Ridge, Linton LS22 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1301 Linton Lane - Wetherby Golf Course house and car park, Wetherby LS22 0 0 0 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1316 Bridle Path Road (land to north of), Shadwell, LS17 1 0 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 1368 Rakehill Road (land south of), Barwick in Elmet 0 0 0 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 2158 Sandbeck wood (south of), Wetherby 1 0 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Following the withdrawal of Headley Hall, new site allocations are required to help meet the housing target for the HMCA. Response Following further assessment work the site is considered suitable for allocation as a housing site (HG2-226) for the following reason. The site currently forms part of a collection of agriculture fields to the eastern edge of Wetherby. The site is not within the UDP Green Belt, however it is open countryside which is currently safeguarded by rural land policy (RL1) within the UDP. The site would be well contained and the wider area currently contains several urbanising developments such as the adjacent Young Offenders Institute. As such the development of the site would not be unduly detrimental to the character of the area. The site is situated adjacent the Wetherby which is the only major settlement within the HMCA. The site would have reasonable access to the Town Centre and local services. The site, alongside 1233 and 3125, is considered to form the best option for extending Wetherby when compared against reasonable alternatives. Action Allocate the merged site for residential use and redraw Green Belt boundary

Detail Consideration for site to be merged with adjacent sites 1233 and 3125 to create a more appropriate development site Response Merging of the sites is appropriate to maximise the development opportunities/benefits. Action Merge site with 1233, 3125 - amend capacity and site description

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3020 Land at Elmete Lane Shadwell 0 0 0 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3125 Carr Lane, Wetherby 1 0 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail A number of the SA scores are questioned. SA13 - the site scores double negative. It is on a bus route and within walking and cycling distance of Wetherby. Headley hall which is a remote location is scored neutral. Likewise other large urban extensions are scored better than 1233. SA14 - The site is mainly flood zone 1, a small area falls within zone 3 where playing fields are proposed. SA16 - the scoring assessment accepts that large sites have the ability to introduce components to improve accessibility. The site can deliver circa 1,000 dwellings. SA19 - the site is not in a Special Landscape. Response SA13 - the score is correct. The Headley Hall site was scored incorrectly (the highway score for accessibility is 1 ie double negative. SA14 - the score is based on the worst flood zone even if only occupies small area of the site. SA16 - it is acknowledged that large sites potentially could accommodate new services, however the SA score is based on the current accessibility of the site. SA19 - sites are scored double negative where there is a potential effect on SLAs or Tree Preservation Orders. The site must be affected by a TPO. Action No change

Detail Following the withdrawal of Headley Hall, new site allocations are required to help meet the housing target for the HMCA. Response Following further assessment work the site is considered suitable for allocation as a housing site (HG2-226) for the following reason. The site currently forms part of a collection of agriculture fields to the eastern edge of Wetherby. The site is not within the UDP Green Belt, however it is open countryside which is currently safeguarded by rural land policy (RL1) within the UDP. The site would be well contained and the wider area currently contains several urbanising developments such as the adjacent Young Offenders Institute. As such the development of the site would not be unduly detrimental to the character of the area. The site is situated adjacent the Wetherby which is the only major settlement within the HMCA. The site would have reasonable access to the Town Centre and local services. The site, alongside 1233 and 2158, is considered to form the best option for extending Wetherby when compared against reasonable alternatives. Action Allocate the merged site for residential use and redraw Green Belt boundary

Detail Consideration for site to be merged with adjacent sites 2158 and 1233 to create a more appropriate development site Response Merging of the sites is appropriate to maximise the development opportunities/benefits. Action Merge site with 1233, 2158 - amend capacity and site description • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3126 Syke Lane, Scarcroft 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3127 Wetherby Road, Scarcroft 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Status change from Not allocated to Allocated for housing for the following reasons. Green Belt Site. Small site which would have a limited impact on the Green Belt given that it is well related to the existing settlement and would round off the settlement form with strong defensible boundaries. Response Status change - allocate the site for housing and redraw Green Belt boundary Action Status change - allocate the site for housing and redraw Green Belt boundary and add site requirements. • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3130 Primrose Lane (west), Boston Spa 1 1 0 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3131 Primrose Lane (east), Boston Spa 1 0 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3136 Land south of Wetherby Race Course, Walton Road 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3319 Main Street, Aberford 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3332 High Trees School, Boston Spa 2 1 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail The site at High Trees Nursery, Boston Spa (SHLAA ref: 3332) should be removed from the Green Belt and allocated for future development under Policy HG2 or alternativly it should be safeguarded under Policy HG3 Response The site has been considered, however the officers overall conclusion has not altered. Action No change - site to remain not allocated • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3333 Land off Ling Lane, Scarcroft 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Site submitter has suggested that the site could come forward alongside the adjacent site (1294) to create a comprehensive development Response The alternative boundary has been considered, however it is not deemed to alter Officers overall conclusions Action No change - Site to remain not allocated • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3363 Mill Lane, Bardsey 6 0 6 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3371 Sweep Farm, Wetherby 1 0 1 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3438 Aberford Road, Aberford 1 0 0 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3461 Land off Tithe Barn Lane, Bardsey 0 0 0 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 4096 Nidd Vale Motors, Wetherby 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Status change from Not allocated to Allocated for housing Response Status change Action Status change

Detail Consideration for the site to be split into two separate sites for consideration Response The site has been split into two separate sites, both of which have been considered for inclusion within the Site Allocations DPD Action Note the site has been split into two separate new sites • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 4154A Wike Ridge Lane, Alwoodley

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Site now proposed to be allocated for the following reason. Green Belt site. Small site which is well related to the main urban area. The site would have a limited impact on the Green Belt given that it would round off the urban area and is well contained. Response Allocated site for housing and redraw Green Belt boundary Action Allocated site for housing and redraw Green Belt boundary • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 4155 Land at Harewood Road, Collingham 1 0 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 4163 Woodland Gardens, Scarcroft 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 4176 High Street, Boston Spa 1 1 0 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 4229 Land behind Wyncroft Court, Barwick in Elmet 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Boundary change following rep PDE01978 Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 5134 Land at Wetherby Road/Walton Road Walton 1 0 1 0

Not allocated for housing

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 5162 Land at Whinmoor Lane Redhall 1 0 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail An alternative site boundary has been submitted for consideration Response The alternative boundary has been considered, however it is not deemed to alter Officers overall conclusions Action No change - Site to remain not allocated • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 5163 Land at Wike Ridge Lane Slaid Hill 1 0 1 0

New site suggestion - not allocated

Ref Address Capacity 5198 Nursery at Clifford Moor Road Clifford LS23 0

Assessment summary Green Belt site. Although the site is part brownfield it falls outside the settlement hierarchy and therefore would have been sieved out at Issues and Options stage. The development of the site for housing would have a significantly greater effect on Green Belt principles than the existing development which is low impact. • Ref Address Capacity 5240 Land adjacent to Mars Hall, Wetherby Road, Scarcroft, Leeds. 0

Assessment summary The site falls outside the settlement hierarchy and would have been sieved out at Issues and Options stage. The site contains numerous trees which are likely to be adversely affected by its development. The site would also have an unacceptable ecological impact given that UK BAP Priority Woodland occurs across the majority of the site. • Ref Address Capacity 5252 Land off A58 Wetherby Road, Scarcroft 0

Assessment summary The site falls outside the settlement hierarchy and would have been sieved out at Issues and Options stage. The site is considered to have an unacceptable ecological impact given that most of the site is semi-improved grassland that contributes to the Leeds Habitat Network. • Ref Address Capacity 5256 Land north of Hall Park Road, Walton 0

Assessment summary The site falls outside the settlement hierarchy and would have been sieved out at Issues and Options stage. The site is considered to have an unacceptable ecological impact given that the entire site lies within the Leeds Habitat Network due to its terrestrial and connectivity value to Great Crested Newts using breeding ponds in the local area. • Ref Address Capacity 5257 Land to the North of Wighill Lane, Walton 0

Assessment summary The site falls outside the settlement hierarchy and would have been sieved out at Issues and Options stage. The scale of development would be out of character with the existing small village. • Ref Address Capacity 5273 Harewood Avenue, Harewood 0

Assessment summary The site falls outside the settlement hierarchy and would have been sieved out at Issues and Options stage. The site is all considered to have an unacceptable impact on Green Belt principles. • Outer North East

New site suggestion - not allocated

Ref Address Capacity 5274 Harrogate Road, Harewood 0

Assessment summary The site falls outside the settlement hierarchy and would have been sieved out at Issues and Options stage. The site is not well related to the existing settlement and would have an unacceptable impact on Green Belt principles. • Ref Address Capacity 5275 Harrogate Road/Malt Kiln Lane 0

Assessment summary The site falls outside the settlement hierarchy and would have been sieved out at Issues and Options stage. The site is not well contained and is considered to have an unacceptable impact on Green Belt principles. • Ref Address Capacity 5277 Kings Meadow Close, Wetherby 0

Assessment summary Site situated between the main urban area of Wetherby and the administrative boundary of Harrogate Borough Council. The site is not within the UDP Green Belt, however it is open countryside which is currently safeguarded by rural land policy (RL1) within the UDP. The site appears to have no highway frontage, consequently there are highways concerns regarding the development of the site. • Ref Address Capacity 5312 SE of A1(M), N of R Wharfe, S of Walton Road, Wetherby 0

Assessment summary The site is not within the UDP Green Belt, however it is open countryside which is currently safeguarded by rural land policy (RL1) within the UDP (proposed to be designated as Green Belt in the Site Allocations Plan). The site forms an extensive area of land between Wetherby and the River Wharfe which is recognised as being a special landscape area. The area is recognised as having high scenic quality which would be significantly impacted upon if the site was developed. The site is also of a significant scale and does not relate well to the existing settlement of Wetherby. The site is not considered to form the best option for an extension to Wetherby when considered against other reasonable alternatives. • Ref Address Capacity 5319 Becca Hall, Aberford 0

Assessment summary Development of the site (of significant size) would create a significant incursion within the Green Belt and the site currently performs an important role in safeguarding the countryside from encroachment. The scale of proposed development (based on revised submission of boundary April 2016) will have significant impact on heritage assets including the historic environment which includes the hamlet of Potterton. The site is situated within a special landscape area and contains some of the highest quality accessible landscape in Leeds. The proposed site is readily visible from key viewpoints from surrounding roads, public footpaths and nearby settlements and would have a significant adverse impact on this sensitive landscape setting. The Outer North-East area is already characterised by numerous free standing settlements. If developed, the new settlement would be situated along the southern side of the A64 lying between the villages of Aberford and Barwick-in- Elmete, marginally closer to the latter. No merging of settlements will occur, but it would significantly reduce the greenbelt gap between settlements. • Outer North East

New site suggestion - not allocated

Ref Address Capacity 5341 Land at Main Street Shadwell 0

Assessment summary The site falls outside the settlement hierarchy and would have been sieved out at Issues and Options stage. The site would have an unacceptable impact on the Green Belt in terms of sprawl and coalescence, as it would significantly reduce the gap between Shadwell and the main urban area of Leeds. • Outer North East

New site suggestion - allocated

Ref Address Capacity HG2-224 Land at Micklethwaite Farm, Wetherby 19

Assessment summary Small piece of unallocated land which lies within the defined urban area of Wetherby. Close to the Town Centre with good links to local services. Residential development acceptable in principle. • Ref Address Capacity HG2-225 Land at the Rowans, Wetherby 18

Assessment summary Small area of vacant land adjacent to an existing area of development which includes a cluster of residential properties. The site is not within the UDP Green Belt, however it is open countryside which is currently safeguarded by rural land policy (RL1) within the UDP (proposed to be designated as Green Belt in the Site Allocations Plan). Given that the area adjacent to the site contains significant urbanising features it is not considered that a small residential development will be unduly detrimental to the rural character of the wider area. The site is considered to have reasonable access to services and facilities within Wetherby. The site has some flood risk concerns, which can be mitigated through appropriate site requirements. • Ref Address Capacity HG2-227 Land bound by Grange Avenue, Rudgate Park, Street 5 and Wealstun Prison, Wealstun 142

Assessment summary The site forms an area of vacant land which is situated in between existing residential properties and Thorp Arch Trading Estate. A small part of the site is brownfield and contains a former social club which is now derelict. The majority of site is currently protected in the UDP as protected playing pitches. However, the pitches have not be used for a considerable amount of time and now have significantly limited public access. The site is located within a urbanised setting outside of the Green Belt. • Outer North East

New site suggestion - allocated

Ref Address Capacity MX2-39 Parlington Estate, Aberford 1750

Assessment summary Development of the site (of significant size) would create a significant incursion within the Green Belt and the site currently performs an important role in safeguarding the countryside from encroachment. Without mitigation the scale of development will have significant impact on a number of heritage assets across the site. The site is well screened being surrounded by mature woodland. The site contains a SSSI and is in an area of Special Landscape. Further scope exists for significant landscaping works to be incorporated into any scheme, which will help to contain the development in the long term. The Outer North-East area is already characterised by numerous free standing settlements. If developed the new settlement would be situated equi-distance from neighbouring villages of Aberford and Barwick-in-Elmete and is seperated from Garforth to the south by the M1. As such no merging of settlements will occur, but it would significantly reduce the greenbelt gap between settlements. • Outer North East

Identified general employment

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity EG1-8 Land at Rudgate Walton Wetherby 33 28 4 1 0.37 ha

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Objector requests deletion of EG1-8 as it already has gained planning permission for a single storey extension to a factory and so continued inclusion in the plan would be ineffective. Response The extension was permitted and implemented within the Plan Period hence contribute towards the employment supply. However the general employment capacity needs amending in order to reflect recent permission on extension applying consistant methodology. Total permitted extension within plan period is 1406sqm. This equals to a site area of 0.37ha (=0.14/37.5%). Action To amend the site capacity to 0.37ha. • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity EG1-9 Units 512 & 515 Thorp Arch Trading Estate Wetherby Ls23 7bj 34 31 3 0 1.9 ha

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Site area and capacity needs amendment to reflect planning permission (ref 08/05903/FU). Response To amed EG1-9 site area and capacity to 1.90ha. Action To amed EG1-9 site area and capacity to 1.90ha. • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity EG1-10 Holmecroft York Road Ls13 4 2 1 1 0 2.29 ha

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Land owner requests site to be considered as a flexible mixed use allocation for both employment and housing use. Response Note that this site was previously considered but discounted for residential use (SHLAA ref 1089). It has active use, and also benefits from extant planning permission for general employment. It is an identified employment site that contributes to the district's employment land supply. Action No change.

Detail Land owner in support of identifying EG1-10 for general employment use as site currently benefits from an extant planning permission. However land owner requests that the permitted floorspace capacity to be increased in order to assist marketing and help the site to be deliverable and viable. Response EG1-10 reflects the capacity in the extant planning permission. It does not prevent further increase of capacity which is a matter to be considered in the planning application process. Action No change. • Outer North East

Identified general employment

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity EG1-63 Avenue D Thorp Arch T E 34 29 4 1 4.32 ha

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Objector states that site constitutes tipped land which include contaminated materials hence would not be viable for employment use. Objector requests this site to be deleted from employment allocation. Response Local planning authorities should work with developers to find acceptable ways forward if there are concerns about land contamination. Responsibility for securing a safe development rests with the developer and/or landowner. It is considered that development for general employment will be appropriate subject to conditions and/or planning obligations which can be sought following consideration of a detailed assessment of contamination and establishing any necessary remediation measures and standards. It is considered that employment use does not pose an unacceptable risk. Action No change to the plan. • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity EG1-64 Wighill Lane & Rudgate, Thorp Arch Ind Estate 33 28 3 2 3.49 ha

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Objector states that this site should be kept under review as part of the housing proposal in Thorp Arch. Response Following further assessment work a new housing allocation is proposed at Thorp Arch which exclude this site. This site is proposed to remain as an 'Identified Employment' site. Action No change. • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity EG1-65 Avenue D & E Thorp Arch Estate 93 89 3 1 8.06 ha

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Objectors states that EG1-65 should be deleted as the northern part of the site includes contaminated demolition materials including asbestos as such redevelopment of the site would not be viable. Response Local planning authorities should work with developers to find acceptable ways forward if there are concerns about land contamination. Responsibility for securing a safe development rests with the developer and/or landowner. It is considered that development for general employment will be appropriate subject to conditions and/or planning obligations which can be sought following consideration of a detailed assessment of contamination and establishing any necessary remediation measures and standards. It is considered that employment use does not pose an unacceptable risk. Action No change to the plan. • Outer North East

Identified general employment

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity EG1-68 Unit 204 Avenue C Thorp Arch Estate, Wetherby 1.12 ha

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail New site from April 2016 planning permissions refresh Response New site added Action New site added • Identified office employment

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity EO1-3 Park Hill Farm Park Hill Studio Walton Road Wetherby 0 0 0 0 579 sqm

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail New site from April 2016 planning permissions refresh Response New site added Action New site added • Outer North East

Not allocated for employment use

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3103830 Deighton Rd Wetherby 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Not allocated for employment use

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral 3104100 Adj Former Linton Springs Hotel Sicklinghall Road Wetherby Ls22 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

New employment site suggestions - not allocated

Ref Address EMP00340 Park Hill, Business Park

Assessment summary This site consists of two separate plots of land of existing Park Hill Business Park (on the western plot) and an area of B2/8 employoment land (on the eastern plot). A large strip of open land and a couple of dwelling houses (excluded from the proposed employment site boundary) are sandwiched between the two plots. Both parts of the proposed employment land are flat with road frontage access. The site is washed over by the UDPR RUL6 Rural Land designation. It is surrounded by agricultural land to the south, east and the north. This is an area of predominate rural feature to the east of A1(M) outside of Wetherby. The proposed general employment allocation would intensify existing employment use in a piecemeal approach, and would represent an encroachment into the countryside. • Outer North East

Mixed use allocation

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Housing Office (sqm) General (ha) MX2-33 Headley Hall, Bramham, Leeds 235 162 67 5 3000 7

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail The availability of the site for development has been withdrawn by the landowner Response The site is no longer considered to consitute a delieverable housing site. Action Site to be deleted as a proposed housing allocation and returned to the Green Belt • Outer North East

Not allocated for mixed use

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral CFSM033 NEB Site, Scarcorft Lodge, Scarcroft, Leeds 0 0 0 0

Safeguarded land (PAS)

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG3-7 The Ridge, Linton 9 1 8 0 100

Safeguarded land (PAS)

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Capacity HG3-11 Chapel Lane (land to the east of), Clifford LS23 2 0 2 0 36

Outer North East

New gypsy and traveller site suggestions

Ref Address GT317 The Old Telephone Exchange, Coal Road

Assessment summary • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G99 The Ings Wetherby 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G420 St Joseph's School Playing Field 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G425 Lazenby Drive Greenspace 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G512 Woodlea (Primrose Lane) Allotments 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G536 Nidd Approach 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G542 North Grove Road 3 0 3 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail The green space allocation is incorrect as there is a deed that goes with each of the five residents- so it is soley for their use, it does not contribute to the supply of land for green space use. Response Whilst it is fully acknowledged that the site is privately owned and soley for the use of 5 residents, the site is an intergal part of the wide grassed "verge" that extends between Deighton Road and Noth Grove Road/Ainsty View. This is an important feature visually which contributes to the open setting of Deighton Road as well as acting as a buffer to it, and is part of the specific character of the area. National Planning Policy Guidance states that land can be considered for designation even if there is no public access. Designation as green space does not give any rights to access the site. Action No change to the plan. • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G543 Deighton Road 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G554 Keswick Lane Allotments 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G574 Clifford Village Hall 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G612 Jubilee Gardens 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G673 Aberford Road Greenspace 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G993 Gateways School 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1407 Aberford Albion FC 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1455 The Yorkshire Conductive Education Centre 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Land to allocated for housing. Response Delete the green space designation. Part of housing site 5300 (Land to north of HMP Wealstun) and a car park.. Action Delete the green space designation. • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1457 Thorp Arch HM Prison Sports Ground 4 3 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Land be allocated for housing. Response Delete the green space designation. Majority of the site is part of housing site 5300 (Land to north of HMP Wealstun). Part of remaining land is inside the perimeter wall of the prison. Action Delete the green space designation. • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1458 Bramham Park Cricket Pitch 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1459 Wetherby Cricket Ground 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Planning permission for 4 houses (14/01048/FU) on western extent of site. The central area is the private curtilage to Thorp Arch Grange therefore it is not green space. Response Delete the area with residentail permission and the private garden area to Thorp Arch Grange which is not publicly accessible nor has any outstanding value e.g. visual. Action Delete the green space designation with residential permission (14/1048/FU) and where it is a private garden. • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1464 Leeds United Training Ground 30 29 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Mainly support for green space designation. One rep highlighted the intention to relocate the training facilities and that the site should not be designated as green space. Response The site is currently used for training and in a green space (outdoor sport) use therefore it is appropriate to designate it as such. Delete western extent with residential planning permission (14/01048/FU). Action Retain green space designation though delete the eastern extent with residential planning permission (14/01048/FU). • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1465 St Peters Church Walton 1 1 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Suports green space designation Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan. • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1466 Thorp Arch and Boston Spa Cricket Ground 58 58 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Supports green space designation Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan. • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1467 Woodland Drive 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1468 Rudgate Park 1 0 1 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Land be allocated for housing Response Delete the green space designation. Part of housing site 5300 (Land to north of HMP Wealstun). Action Delete the green space designation. • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1470 Clifford Allotments 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1473 Rigton Hill 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1477 St Mary Magdelene's Church East Keswick 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1482 Bardsey Bowling Green and Tennis Courts. 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1488 Thorner Church of England Primary School 0 0 0 0

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1547 Bardsey Catholic Church of the Blessed Sacred 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1551 Aberford Pond - Field Lane 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Land be allocated for housing. Response Delete the green space designation. Part of housing site 5300 (Land to north of HMP Wealstun). Action Delete green space designation. • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1556 Grange Avenue 2 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Site proposed for housing (part of site 5300, Land to north of HMP Wealstun) Response Delete green space designation. Action Delete green space designation. • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1561 Thorp Arch Tennis Courts 48 48 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1587 Shadwell Primary School 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1609 Mill Lane Collingham 1 1 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1627 Linton Tennis Courts 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1631 Boston Spa Primrose Lane Primary School 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1635 Bramham Primary School 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail The site does not function as green space and therefore should not be designated as such. Response There is no public access to the site and it is not considered to be demonstrably special e.g. historic, recreational, wildlife value. Action Delete the green space designation. • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1669 Wetherby Golf Club 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1670 Thorner Road Allotments 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1689 Aberford Road Allotments 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1748 Bowcliffe Wood 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1760 Hell Pot Woods / Dam Wood 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Site not been used for outdoor sport for over 10 years. Cricket club has relocated elsewhere. Response Site no longer in a green space use Action Delete the green space designation. Reinstate Green Belt boundary. • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1764 All Hallows Church, Badsey 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1766 Scarcroft Cricket Pitch 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1796 Welfare Avenue OS 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1800 Scholes Playing Field 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

Greenspace

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1880 Woodhouse Farm/Oakhill Woods 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Site should be allocated for housing development under policy H2 or as safeguarded land under policy HG3. Response Site not being allocated for development. The nursery's website mentions a range of outdoor play facilities, talking about "...extensive grounds for outside play and physical activities", "..an enclosed grassed area", "..a hard surfaced playground..", "..the big field where we have an adventure playground and where there’s plenty of space to run, jump and climb." and "We also have the old tennis courts which is a lawned area for games, PE and Sports Day." These areas are clearly currently in use and therefore justify protection as green space. Action No change to the plan. • Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral G1906 Whinmoor Grange Cemetery 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Outer North East

New greenspace site suggestions

Ref Address G1925 Wetherby Race Course

Assessment detail The actual race course and associated structures are a strategic leisure facility and access is restricted to race days. The more open areas to the east and south are used on race days and for other activities such as car boot sales and there is informal access which allows informal recreation such as dog walking and running. These other areas are ancilliary to the main race course use and their primary function is to serve that race course. It is expected that the informal access and opportunites for recreational activities will continue. Assessment summary No changes to the plan. • Outer North East

Retail centres

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral TLC001 Collingham Local Centre 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan • Aireborough

Allocated travelling showpeople site

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG8-2 Town Street, Yeadon 1 0 0 1

Safeguarded gypsy and traveller site

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG6-2 Kidacre Street, City Centre 6 3 3 0

Allocated gypsy and traveller site

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG7-3 Bullerthorpe Lane, Temple Newsam 687 5 679 3

Safeguarded gypsy and traveller site

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG6-3 Former Moorend Training Centre, Tulip Street, Hunslet 30 4 26 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Representors detail a variety of detrimental impacts that they consider would arise from the allocation of the site for G&T use. These do not raise issues of soundness or relate to planning reasons for allocation. Response No change to the plan Action No change

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG6-13 Urn Farm, Middleton Road 1 1 0 0

New gypsy and traveller site suggestions

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral Dolly Lane, Leeds 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan Outer North East

New gypsy and traveller site suggestions

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral The Old Telephone Exchange, Coal Road 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Landowner suggested that this site should be provided to meet private need Response The site is a small brownfield site, in the green belt, located in between the main urban area and Shadwell, which would have reasonable access to local services. The site is considered suitable for allocation as a private Gypsy site, would help to meet the private requirement target set in the CS and would be allocated on the basis that a single pitch is delivered. Site requirements are suggested to improve existing highways access, the telephone exchange should be utilised for amenity block provision and limit the scale of the site. Site requirements are proposed to address the need for access improvements to the site with access taken from Coal Road, that the site shall only be occupied by persons who meet the legal definition of Gypsy and Travellers and that the site accommodate one pitch for one household, that trees on the perimeter of the site are protected and that the existing building on the site is utilised as an amenity block rather than any further built development occurring. Action Agree and allocate Outer North West

Safeguarded gypsy and traveller site

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG6-7 Knotford Nook, Old Pool Road, Otley 1 1 0 0

Safeguarded gypsy and traveller site

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG6-6 Ninevah Lane, Allerton Bywater 3 0 3 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail The owner wish es to relinquish the site and move off following sale to the neighbouring land owner. Response the site will not be available in the future. Action Delete site allocation for G+T and allocate for general housing as an extension to the existing site

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG8-3 Land off Phoenix Avenue, Micklefield 8 3 5 0

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG6-1 Cottingley Springs, Gelderd Road, Nr Gildersome 7 2 5 0

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG6-4 Nepshaw Lane South, Morley 1 1 0 0

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG6-8 Springfield Villas, Gildersome 2 1 1 0

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG6-9 Dunningley Lane, Middleton 1 1 0 0

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG6-10 Thorpe Lane, Tingley 4 3 0 1

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Representation by one of the landowners split the site into two to reflect two landownerships and increase the capacity of the eastern allocation from 1 to 2 pitches. Response No undue amenity concerns are likely due to the small increase in number of overall pitches. The site helps to meet the overall private need provision which is in shortfall Action Split site into two separate sites and increase the capity of the eastern site to 2 pitches Safeguarded gypsy and traveller site

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG7-1 West Wood, Dewsbury Road, Tingley 9 3 5 1

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG8-1 Whitehall Road, Gildersome 1 0 0 1

Safeguarded gypsy and traveller site

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG6-5 Roseneath Place, Wortley 2 0 2 0

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG6-11 White Rose Stables, Whitehall Road, Gildersome 0 0 0 0

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail No representations on this site were received Response No specific response required Action No change to the plan

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG6-12 Scarecrow Farm, Whitehall Road, Gildersome 2 0 1 1

Ref Address Total reps Support Object Neutral HG7-2 Land on the corner of Tong Road and Lakeside Road, Wortley 78 5 70 3

IssuesNo proposed requiring changes further assessment Detail Heritage England have requested that the site requrement relating to heritage impact is amended Response Agree to amend the site requirement as follows This site is in the setting of a number of Listed Buildings. Any development should preserve their special architectural or historic interest and setting Action Amend site requirement