DOCSLIB.ORG

NEWTON V. DMMOND 349 F.3D 591 (9Th Cir. 2003)

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
NEWTON V. DMMOND 349 F.3D 591 (9Th Cir. 2003) 734 BERKELEY TECHNOLOGY LAW JOURNAL [Vol. 20:723 NEWTON V. DMMOND 349 F.3d 591 (9th Cir.2003) The Ninth Circuit held that. sampling, or use of a brief segment of a musical re- cording for incorporation into a new recording, was de minimis and therefore not infring- ing of the underlying musical composition, where the sample consisted of "three notes separated by half-step over a.background C note" and the sampler had obtained a license to excerpt the sound recording. Jazz flutist James Newton composed the song "Choir" in 1978. In 1981, he per- formed and recorded "Choir" and licensed all rights in the sound recording to ECM Re- cords, but retained all rights to the composition. The rap band the Beastie Boys obtained a license from ECM Records in 1992 to sample portions of the sound recording of "Choir" in various renditions of their song "Pass the Mic." The band did not, however, obtain a license from Newton to use the underlying composition. Pursuant to their li- cense from ECM Records, the Beastie Boys digitally sampled the opening six seconds of Newton's sound recording of "Choir," and repeated this six-second sample as a back- ground element throughout their song. Newton brought suit, claiming that the Beastie Boys infringed his copyright in the underlying composition of "Choir." The district court granted summary judgment in favor of the Beastie Boys, hold- ing that no license of the underlying composition was required because the three-note segment of "Choir" lacked the requisite originality and was therefore not copyrightable. The court further held that even if the segment were copyrightable, the Beastie Boys' use of the work was de minimis and therefore not actionable. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the district court's decision for the defendants on the ground that the use was de minimis. The court applied the "average listener" test articu- lated in Fisher v. Dees, 794 F.2d 432 (9th Cir. 1986), in determining whether the use was de minimis. Under this test, a taking is considered de minimis only if it is so meager and fragmentary that the average audience would not recognize the appropriation. Because the Beastie Boys had lawfully licensed the sound recording, the court confined its inquiry to whether the unauthorized use of the three-note sequence transcribed in the composition was substantial enough to sustain an infringement claim. The court found that there was a high degree but limited scope of similarity between Newton's and the Beastie Boys' work, and thus placed Newton's claim for infringement into the class of cases that allege "fragmented literal similarity." In such cases, the question is whether the similarity goes to trivial or substantial elements of the original. This phenomenon is measured by considering the qualitative and quantitative significance of the copied portion in relation to the plaintiffs work as a whole. The court noted that when viewed in relation to Newton's composition as a whole, the sampled portion was not quantitatively significant as it appeared only once in New- ton's composition and lasted only six seconds in the Beastie Boys recording. In addition, it was not qualitatively significant because the sampled section was a generic three-note sequence that lacked any distinctive elements. The court concluded that the average audi- ence would not discern Newton's hand as a composer from the Beastie Boys' use of the sample and that the works in question were not substantially similar; therefore, the Beastie Boys' use of the "Choir" composition was de minimis..
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Drums • Bobby Bradford - Trumpet • James Newton - Flute • David Murray - Tenor Sax • Roberto Miranda - Bass
    1975 May 17 - Stanley Crouch Black Music Infinity Outdoors, afternoon, color snapshots. • Stanley Crouch - drums • Bobby Bradford - trumpet • James Newton - flute • David Murray - tenor sax • Roberto Miranda - bass June or July - John Carter Ensemble at Rudolph's Fine Arts Center (owner Rudolph Porter)Rudolph's Fine Art Center, 3320 West 50th Street (50th at Crenshaw) • John Carter — soprano sax & clarinet • Stanley Carter — bass • William Jeffrey — drums 1976 June 1 - John Fahey at The Lighthouse December 15 - WARNE MARSH PHOTO Shoot in his studio (a detached garage converted to a music studio) 1490 N. Mar Vista, Pasadena CA afternoon December 23 - Dexter Gordon at The Lighthouse 1976 June 21 – John Carter Ensemble at the Speakeasy, Santa Monica Blvd (just west of LaCienega) (first jazz photos with my new Fujica ST701 SLR camera) • John Carter — clarinet & soprano sax • Roberto Miranda — bass • Stanley Carter — bass • William Jeffrey — drums • Melba Joyce — vocals (Bobby Bradford's first wife) June 26 - Art Ensemble of Chicago Studio Z, on Slauson in South Central L.A. (in those days we called the area Watts) 2nd-floor artists studio. AEC + John Carter, clarinet sat in (I recorded this on cassette) Rassul Siddik, trumpet June 24 - AEC played 3 nights June 24-26 artist David Hammond's Studio Z shots of visitors (didn't play) Bobby Bradford, Tylon Barea (drummer, graphic artist), Rudolph Porter July 2 - Frank Lowe Quartet Century City Playhouse. • Frank Lowe — tenor sax • Butch Morris - drums; bass? • James Newton — cornet, violin; • Tylon Barea -- flute, sitting in (guest) July 7 - John Lee Hooker Calif State University Fullerton • w/Ron Thompson, guitar August 7 - James Newton Quartet w/guest John Carter Century City Playhouse September 5 - opening show at The Little Big Horn, 34 N.
    [Show full text]
  • Too Many Notes: Complexity and Culture in Voyager Lewis, George E
    Too Many Notes: Complexity and Culture in Voyager Lewis, George E. Leonardo Music Journal, Volume 10, 2000, pp. 33-39 (Article) Published by The MIT Press For additional information about this article http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/lmj/summary/v010/10.1lewis.html Access Provided by University of California @ Santa Cruz at 09/27/11 9:42PM GMT W A Y S WAYS & MEANS & M E A Too Many Notes: Computers, N S Complexity and Culture in Voyager ABSTRACT The author discusses his computer music composition, Voyager, which employs a com- George E. Lewis puter-driven, interactive “virtual improvising orchestra” that ana- lyzes an improvisor’s performance in real time, generating both com- plex responses to the musician’s playing and independent behavior arising from the program’s own in- oyager [1,2] is a nonhierarchical, interactive mu- pears to stand practically alone in ternal processes. The author con- V the trenchancy and thoroughness tends that notions about the na- sical environment that privileges improvisation. In Voyager, improvisors engage in dialogue with a computer-driven, inter- of its analysis of these issues with ture and function of music are active “virtual improvising orchestra.” A computer program respect to computer music. This embedded in the structure of soft- ware-based music systems and analyzes aspects of a human improvisor’s performance in real viewpoint contrasts markedly that interactions with these sys- time, using that analysis to guide an automatic composition with Catherine M. Cameron’s [7] tems tend to reveal characteris- (or, if you will, improvisation) program that generates both rather celebratory ethnography- tics of the community of thought complex responses to the musician’s playing and indepen- at-a-distance of what she terms and culture that produced them.
    [Show full text]
  • Great Jazz Imports From
    N U.S. Jazz Label Directory Continued from page J -1 Cannonball Adderley, Thelonious thony Davis, James Newton, Ja- GREAT Monk, JAZZ Dave Brubeck, Eric Dolphy maaladeen Tacuma, Oliver Lake & stream and experimental titles by Jessica Williams, Phil Woods Quar- and many others. Original albums Jump Up, Bob Moses, Jay Hoggard tet, Cedar Walton and Dr. John. by these and other acts who re- and Tony Dagradi. corded for the three labels are Concord Jazz Inc., P.O. Box 845, Hannibal Records, Inc., 611 being included in a new midline, IMPORTS Concord, Calif. 94522. Tel: (415) Broadway, Suite 415, New York, launched earlier this year, in which 682 -6770. N.Y. 10012. Tel: (212) 420-1780. original cover art, liner notes and la- Mainstream jazz independent with Eclectic independent has released bel graphics have all been restored recent inroads into crossover ac- one multi -artist work, a tribute to under the Original Jazz Classics ceptance. Roster includes Jim Hall, Italian film music composer Nino Pii banner. Contemporary fusion and Rota, featured an array jazz FROM of top Al Cohn, L. A. Four, Herb Ellis, Scott mainstream releases are also re- names, and also records avant - Hamilton, - George Shearing, Lau leased on Fantasy, Milestone and rindo funk ensemble Defunkt. Almeida, Emily Remler and Galaxy, with artists including Sonny Tania Maria. BLACK SAINT /SOUL NOTE JMS Subsidiaries include Rollins, Azymuth, Ron Carter, Fred- Headfirst Records, Inc., 9000 Concord Picante (Latin, Caribbean die Hubbard, Red Garland, Johnny Sunset Blvd., Suite 611, Los An- ECM IMPORTS JAPO WATT and South American music) and geles, Calif.
    [Show full text]
  • 2003 Festival Brochure
    A Program of the Healdsburg Arts Council * Jessica Felix, Artistic Director 5th Annual Healdsburg Jazz Festival June 1-8, 2003 Abbey Lincoln, the last of the great jazz divas Jazz flute virtuoso James Newton and his Quartet Joe Lovano & Friends with guest vocalist Judi Silvano Bobby Hutcherson, George Cables, and Ray Drummond: Solos, Duos, Trios, and More. Gala dinner and concert featuring guitarist Julian Lage with Billy Hart and Ray Drummond INSIDE 5th Annual Healdsburg Jazz Festival Celebrating the jazz artform in Sonoma County’s lush vineyards and intimate theaters, just 65 miles north of San Francisco Pre-festival Kickoff Concert! Sunday, June 1 2p.m. Join us when we kickoff the 5th annual Healdsburg Jazz Festival at a free outdoor concert in Healdsburg Plaza in the heart of the downtown area, featuring Tacuma King and the Children’s Percussion Workshop, the Healdsburg High School Jazz Band, and the Khalil Shaheed Sextet. This high-energy, family friendly event reflects the festival’s ongoing commitment to nurturing the next generation of jazz players through its innovative jazz education programs. In recent years, Bay Area trumpeter Shaheed, the founder of the Oaktown Jazz Workshops, has delivered precious one-on-one mentoring and advice to members of the Healdsburg High School Jazz Band in two special after-school classes. Chicago-born Afro-Cuban percussionist King is a veteran of the Sun-Ra-Arkestra and the Deep Space Posse, and the founder of Sun Drummers of Urban Africa Ensemble. He is widely respected for his work with special needs children and at-risk youth.
    [Show full text]
  • The Kitchen Presents a Power Stronger Than Itself: a Celebration of the Association for the Advancement of Creative Musicians Curated by George E
    Press Contact: Blake Zidell & Associates tel: 718.643.9052 fax: 718.643.9502 [email protected] For Immediate Release The Kitchen presents A Power Stronger Than Itself: A Celebration of the Association for the Advancement of Creative Musicians Curated by George E. Lewis and Christopher McIntyre Two evenings of music, October 9 and 11, will include performances by Nicole Mitchell, Amina Claudine Myers, Muhal Richard Abrams, Matana Roberts, Craig Taborn, Chad Taylor and Wet Ink Panel discussion moderated by Christopher McIntyre and Book signing with George E. Lewis will take place prior to the October 11 concert New York, NY, September 11, 2008—In conjunction with the recent publication of George E. Lewis’s book, A Power Stronger Than Itself: The AACM and American Experimental Music (University of Chicago Press, 2008), The Kitchen presents A Power Stronger Than Itself: A Celebration of the AACM, Thursday and Saturday, October 9 and 11. The Kitchen and Lewis—a composer, musician, former Kitchen music curator and long-time AACM member—will host two evenings of performances paying tribute to the seminal music collective, which has reconfigured the trajectory of music-making through its devotion to furthering artistic experimentation and its forward-thinking approach to composition, performance, improvisation and collectivity. The first concert, on Thursday, October 9, will feature Muhal Richard Abrams, Amina Claudine Myers and the ensemble Wet Ink performing the works of AACM composers. The second, on Saturday, October 11, will feature Nicole Mitchell, Matana Roberts, Craig Taborn, Chad Taylor and Wet Ink. Both concerts will take place at 8:00 P.M.
    [Show full text]
  • Improvised Music After 1950: Afrological and Eurological Perspectives
    Improvised Music after 1950: Afrological and Eurological Perspectives George E. Lewis Black Music Research Journal, Vol. 22, Supplement: Best of BMRJ. (2002), pp. 215-246. Stable URL: http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0276-3605%282002%2922%3C215%3AIMA1AA%3E2.0.CO%3B2-Y Black Music Research Journal is currently published by Center for Black Music Research - Columbia College Chicago. Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/about/terms.html. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use. Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at http://www.jstor.org/journals/cbmr.html. Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed page of such transmission. The JSTOR Archive is a trusted digital repository providing for long-term preservation and access to leading academic journals and scholarly literature from around the world. The Archive is supported by libraries, scholarly societies, publishers, and foundations. It is an initiative of JSTOR, a not-for-profit organization with a mission to help the scholarly community take advantage of advances in technology. For more information regarding JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. http://www.jstor.org Tue Oct 9 15:15:54 2007 IMPROVISED MUSICAFTER 1950: AFROLOGICALAND EUROLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES GEORGEE.
    [Show full text]
  • Roots and Folklore: Episodes in the Development of American Folk Music
    Roots and Folklore: Episodes in the Development of American Folk Music [http://nightafternight.blogs.com/night_after_night/2006/09/even_more_recor.html] A performer, composer and educator born in Fort Worth, Texas and based for most of his career in Los Angeles, the late John Carter (1929-1991) spent the '80s crafting his magnum opus: "Roots and Folklore: Episodes in the Development of American Folk Music," a five-suite (or five-disc, if you prefer) cycle that encompasses the whole of the African-American musical experience, from its roots in tribal Africa through slavery, rural folk and blues traditions, gospel music and the birth of jazz. It's admittedly uneven, but majestic in both scope and achievement. Pressed to think of artists who attempted to create anything of similar scope, the only names that come readily to mind are Ellington and Mingus...and Wynton Marsalis, much later. The first disc, Dauwhe, was recorded in Los Angeles in 1982, and issued on Black Saint that year. By this point, Carter had laid down his alto saxophone to devote himself to clarinet, at a time when it was still unusual to do so - - Don Byron had yet to emerge. At Carter's side, then and always, was Bobby Bradford -- a sterling cornetist and, like Carter himself, a musician in the Ornette Coleman circle. (Bradford appears on Coleman's often- cited Science Fiction, and Carter and Bradford recorded a number of valuable Coleman-esque quartet records for Flying Dutchman in the '60s.) The rest of the band included Red Callender on tuba, flutist James Newton, reedist Charles Owens (on soprano sax, clarinet and oboe), bassist Roberto Miranda, drummer William Jeffrey and percussionist Luis Peralta.
    [Show full text]
  • Newton V. Diamond: When a Composer's Market Is Not the Average Joe: the Ni Adequacy of the Average-Audience Test Reid Miller
    Golden Gate University Law Review Volume 36 Article 3 Issue 1 Ninth Circuit Survey January 2006 Newton v. Diamond: When a Composer's Market Is Not the Average Joe: The nI adequacy of the Average-Audience Test Reid Miller Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.law.ggu.edu/ggulrev Part of the Intellectual Property Law Commons Recommended Citation Reid Miller, Newton v. Diamond: When a Composer's Market Is Not the Average Joe: The Inadequacy of the Average-Audience Test, 36 Golden Gate U. L. Rev. (2006). http://digitalcommons.law.ggu.edu/ggulrev/vol36/iss1/3 This Note is brought to you for free and open access by the Academic Journals at GGU Law Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Golden Gate University Law Review by an authorized administrator of GGU Law Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Miller: Inadequacy of the Average-Audience Test NOTE NEWTON v. DIAMOND: WHEN A COMPOSER'S MARKET IS NOT THE AVERAGE JOE: THE INADEQUACY OF THE A VERAGE­ AUDIENCE TEST INTRODUCTION In 1978, avant-garde jazz flautist and composer James Newton composed "Choir," a song inspired by his early memory of four women singing gospel church music in rural Arkansas. I "Choir" is not a traditional song. 2 In addition to its gospel music influence, "Choir" contains elements of Japanese ceremonial court music, classical music, and African music? The most untraditional sonic characteristics of the song, however, are achieved by playing the flute in a very unorthodox manner.4 The song requires that the performer play one note on the flute by over-blowing into the instrument while simultaneously singing a pattern of three other notes.5 The effect of this simultaneous over­ blowing and singing is a unique sound that is described as multiphonics.6 I Newton v.
    [Show full text]
  • The John Carter Recordings, 1929-1990 an Inventory of Holdings at the American Music Research Center
    The John Carter recordings, 1929-1990 An inventory of holdings at the American Music Research Center American Music Research Center, University of Colorado at Boulder The John Carter recordings, 1929-1990 Descriptive summary Title John Carter recordings Date(s) 1929-1990 Identification COU-AMRC-18 Creator(s) Carter, John, 1929-1991 Repository The American Music Research Center University of Colorado at Boulder 288 UCB Boulder, CO 80309 Location Housed in the American Music Research Center Physical Description 1 Linear foot 1 box Scope and Contents Recordings and supporting materials of John (1929-1991), composer, jazz clarinetist, band leader; M. Mus, University of Colorado (1956); Down Beat Magazine Jazz Hall of Fame. Administrative Information Arrangement Arranged by title. Access The collection is open for research. Usage Restrictions Copyright is not held by the American Music Research Center. Requests to publish materials should be directed to the copyright holder. Custodial history Donated by Karl Eggert Preferred Citation [Identification of item], John Carter recordings, University of Colorado, Boulder - Page 2 - The John Carter recordings, 1929-1990 Index Terms Access points related to this collection: Personal names Carter, John, 1929-1991 Corporate names American Music Research Center Subject headings Jazz Biography of John Carter John Carter was born on September 24, 1929 in Ft. Worth, Texas. He was an only child and his father died when John was a child. John was a multi-instrumentalist. He played soprano, alto and tenor sax, oboe and flute. He attended college at Lincoln University in Jefferson City, Missouri. He earned a degree in Music Education and graduated at the age of 19.
    [Show full text]
  • FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: August 27, 2007 WHAT: the Roswell Rudd/Mark Dresser Duo
    NEWS RELEASE UMass Amherst Fine Arts Center Magic Triangle Jazz Series www.fineartscenter.com/magictriangle CONTACT: Glenn Siegel, Ken Irwin, (413) 545-2876 [email protected] FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: August 27, 2007 WHAT: The Roswell Rudd/Mark Dresser Duo WHEN: Wednesday, October 17, 2007 at 8:15pm WHERE: Bezanson Recital Hall IMAGES: To download images relating to this press release please go online to http://www.umass.edu/fac/centerwide/pressRoom (Roswell Rudd, trombonist of choice for avant-garde jazz legends and world musician performs at UMass.) Best known as trombonist of choice for avant-garde luminaries like Cecil Taylor, Archie Shepp, Charlie Haden’s Liberation Music Orchestra, and his own New York Art Quartet, Rudd’s musical résumé also features a fascinating mix of Dixieland, straight ahead jazz and, more recently, world music. His lifelong friendship with Steve Lacy has resulted in numerous recordings and performances of the music of Thelonious Monk and Herbie Nichols. His recent recorded cross-cultural collaborations include, MALIcool, (with Toumani Diabaté), Blue Mongol, (with a traditional Buryat group from Mongolia) and El Espiritu Jibaro (with Yomo Toro). The New York Times calls Rudd, "...a trombonist of such sweeping power and majesty that he transcends all styles." Roswell Rudd was born in Sharon, Connecticut in 1935 and graduated from Yale University. He taught music-ethnology at Bard College and the University of Maine and, assisted Alan Lomax with his world song style project on and off for a period of three decades. He is a three time (2003-2005) Jazz Journalists Association “Trombonist of the Year” and recipient of a Guggenheim Fellowship in composition.
    [Show full text]
  • NEWTON V. DIAMOND 591 Cite As 349 F.3D 591 (9Th Cir
    NEWTON v. DIAMOND 591 Cite as 349 F.3d 591 (9th Cir. 2003) Graber, Circuit Judge, dissented and James W. NEWTON, Jr., dba Janew filed opinion. Music, Plaintiff–Appellant, v. 1. Federal Courts O762 Michael DIAMOND; Adam Horowitz; Appellate court may affirm grant of Adam Yauch, dba Beastie Boys; Capi- summary judgment on any basis supported tol Records, Inc., a Delaware Corpora- by record, and need not reach each ground tion; Grand Royal Records, Inc., A relied upon by district court. California Corporation; Universal Po- lygram International Publishing, Inc., 2. Copyrights and Intellectual Property a Delaware Corporation; Brooklyn O66 Dust Music, an entity of unknown ori- Even if three-note sequence from au- gin; Mario Caldato, Jr., an individual; thor’s musical composition was sufficiently Janus Films, LLC, a New York Limit- original to warrant copyright protection, ed Liability Company; Criterion Col- hip-hop band’s sampling of sequence in its lection, a California Partnership; own song was de minimis, and thus not Voyager Publishing Company, Inc., a infringing; band had licensed author’s re- Delaware Corporation; Sony Music cording of composition and, though band Entertainment Group, a Delaware had looped sample throughout their song, Corporation; BMG Direct Marketing, it was neither quantitatively nor qualita- Inc., a Delaware Corporation; The tively significant portion of author’s com- Columbia House Company, an entity position. of unknown origin, Defendants–Ap- pellees. 3. Copyrights and Intellectual Property O53(1) No. 02–55983. For unauthorized use of copyrighted United States Court of Appeals, work to be actionable, there must be sub- Ninth Circuit. stantial similarity between protected and accused works, that is, copying must be Argued and Submitted April 7, 2003.
    [Show full text]
  • David Murray ‘77 Pomona College Commencement 2012 May 13, 2012
    David Murray ‘77 Pomona College Commencement 2012 May 13, 2012 Wow. Okay. Thank you all. Thank you, Bobby. Good morning graduates, Oxtoby, all of the alumni, my family — I’m so happy they all came. This is an opportunity for us to have a family reunion. I live in Paris with my wife, Valerie, and our two kids, so thanks for the family reunion as well. I’d like to dedicate this honorary degree to my father, the late Walter Pendleton Murray, and my mother, the late Katherine Hackett Murray. And also to my stepmother, who’s here today: Myrna Murray. She came all the way from Middleton, Texas for this. I would also like to thank a gentleman who’s no longer with us: Mr. John Payton, for his efforts and guidance as the Claremont Colleges’ admissions officer, who initially recruited me to Pomona College from St. Mary’s College Prep High School. Also, Margaret Cohen, who was my piano teacher here, and her husband, who was a great composer, Karl Cohen, for their dedication as well. She helped me to excel through Béla Bartók’s creations. And there are some friends here as well — the thing is, about these colleges: I met so many incredible people in the few semesters I was here. One gentleman, Cedric Johnson, from CMC, he’s just been honored recently at CMC for his efforts in business. Also, two other friends from CMC: Claris Anthony Bush, who is one of the head economists for the FCC in Washington, and he’s here today as well.
    [Show full text]