From the Muddy Banks of the Mae Kha
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
From the muddy banks of the Mae Kha An environmental justice perspective on the human-environment interactions along the urban streams of Chiang Mai, Thailand. By Christie Mettes 3105261 Source: Kon Jai Baan, 2012 Thesis Supervisor: Maggie Leung University Utrecht Master Sustainable Development International Development Track April 8 2014 From the muddy banks of the Mae Kha canal Abstract Cities have historically developed near water bodies. The increasing prevalence urban space has had a marked effect on the ecology of urban waterways. Many rapidly urbanizing areas experience a growth in informal housing often located on environmentally fragile land. These communities of urban poor are often unjustly blamed for the degradation of the environment, while carrying the largest burden of said degradation. Processes of urbanization in Chiang Mai, the second largest city in Thailand, have been accompanied by a decrease in air and water quality. This thesis researches the human-environment interactions between the city and the urban canals in Chiang Mai, Thailand? An environmental justice approach is applied to this study looking at how the environmental ills, recognition, and capability to participate in the management of the canal differ between different stakeholder groups. The research is based on water quality tests in 10 sites in July, September and November, and interviews with 52 stakeholders from the business, chuchom, governmental and not-for-profits sectors. Water quality tests indicated the canals to be severely degraded, with the lowest water quality measured in July. However, no significant differences were found in the water quality between sites. Notwithstanding, chumchon experienced more disamenities including flooding and health impacts. The tourist area benefited from water infrastructure, with lower levels of flooding. A top-down management of the canals is centered on the national government. This restricts the capabilities available to local stakeholder to affect the present situation. Any long term solution to the state of the canals would need to recognize both the root causes of environmental degradation and informal housing. While there are no easy solutions, a participatory approach including all stakeholders is likely to be an important part of it. 1 Contents From the muddy banks of the Mae Kha canal .......................................................................................................... 1 Abstract ........................................................................................................................................................................ 1 List of Figures ............................................................................................................................................................... 3 List of Tables ................................................................................................................................................................ 3 List of Annexes .............................................................................................................................................................4 Introduction ................................................................................................................................................................. 5 Objective of the study ............................................................................................................................................ 6 Research question .................................................................................................................................................. 6 Geographical Framework ............................................................................................................................................ 7 The study site .......................................................................................................................................................... 7 Thailand .................................................................................................................................................................. 8 Chiang Mai City ...................................................................................................................................................... 9 Ping River Basin...................................................................................................................................................... 11 Urban Streams ........................................................................................................................................................... 14 Urban stream syndrome ....................................................................................................................................... 16 Theoretical Framework of Environmental Justice ............................................................................................. 19 Definitions ............................................................................................................................................................. 23 Methodology .............................................................................................................................................................. 25 Stakeholder Analysis ............................................................................................................................................. 25 Water quality ......................................................................................................................................................... 28 Results Distribution .................................................................................................................................................. 37 Distribution of environmental Ills....................................................................................................................... 37 Urban hydrology of the Mae Kha ........................................................................................................................ 41 Results of water quality measurements ............................................................................................................. 48 Environmental Services of the Mae Kha ............................................................................................................. 67 Urban Development ............................................................................................................................................ 69 Results Justice of Participation ................................................................................................................................ 72 Participation with the Mae Kha ........................................................................................................................... 72 Governmental actors............................................................................................................................................. 76 Chiang Mai Provincial Government ................................................................................................................... 80 Chiang Mai City Municipal Government ............................................................................................................ 82 Chumchon ............................................................................................................................................................ 88 NFPs........................................................................................................................................................................ 93 Businesses .............................................................................................................................................................. 95 Deciding on the Mae Kha .....................................................................................................................................97 Results Justice of Recognition ................................................................................................................................ 100 2 The root of power ................................................................................................................................................ 103 The way forward .................................................................................................................................................. 107 Conclusion.................................................................................................................................................................. 111 References ................................................................................................................................................................. 116 Annexes ..................................................................................................................................................................... 121 List of Figures Figure 1 Study site ........................................................................................................................................................ 7 Figure 2 Daily rainfall and temperature values for 2013 ........................................................................................ 10 Figure 3 Land use of the Ping River Basin, 2000 ....................................................................................................