Line Voltage Connected Thermostats
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N Line Voltage Connected Thermostats June 2017 Updated February 2018 A Report of BPA’s Emerging Technologies Initiative Prepared for Bonneville Power Administration Prepared by Washington State University Energy Program Contract 71419 TABLE OF CONTENTS Summary ............................................................................................................................... 4 Background ........................................................................................................................... 4 Research Methods ................................................................................................................. 5 Technology Overview ............................................................................................................ 5 Thermostat Definitions ............................................................................................................................. 5 Thermostat Features ................................................................................................................................. 8 Electric Resistance Heaters ....................................................................................................................... 9 Product Overview ................................................................................................................ 10 Product Analysis ...................................................................................................................................... 11 Product Comparison ............................................................................................................................... 12 Quality Standards .................................................................................................................................... 13 Market Assessment ............................................................................................................. 13 ER Heated Homes in the PNW ................................................................................................................ 13 Market Sales ........................................................................................................................................... 14 Number of Manufacturers ...................................................................................................................... 14 Energy Savings..................................................................................................................... 15 Regional Technical Potential ................................................................................................................... 17 Cost Effectiveness ................................................................................................................................... 18 Measure Development ........................................................................................................ 20 Product Readiness................................................................................................................................... 20 Barriers .................................................................................................................................................... 20 Customer uptake..................................................................................................................................... 21 Non Energy Benefits................................................................................................................................ 21 Demand Response .................................................................................................................................. 21 Current Measures ................................................................................................................................... 22 Research .................................................................................................................................................. 23 Conclusions ......................................................................................................................... 25 Recommendations .............................................................................................................. 26 Perform Field Studies and/or Modeling ................................................................................................. 26 BONNEVIL LE P OWER ADMINISTRATION 2 Upgrade BPA Measure for Electronic Thermostats ................................................................................ 26 Promote Non-Energy Benefits ................................................................................................................ 26 Engage Manufacturers ............................................................................................................................ 27 Support National Recognition of Line-Voltage Connected Thermostats ................................................ 27 Appendix A. References ....................................................................................................... 28 Appendix C. Research Studies .............................................................................................. 34 Eugene Water and Electric Board (EWEB) .............................................................................................. 34 University of Quebec at Trois-Rivieres .................................................................................................... 34 Hydro Quebec ......................................................................................................................................... 34 The Institute of Research at Hydro Quebec (IREQ-LTE) .......................................................................... 35 Appendix D. Product Details ................................................................................................ 37 Line-Voltage Thermostats ....................................................................................................................... 37 Appendix E. BPA Product Readiness Levels .......................................................................... 41 TABLES Table 1. Comparison of Line-voltage thermostat products ........................................................................ 12 Table 2. Baseboard Heating as Primary and Secondary Heating Source in Various Housing Types........... 14 Table 3. Estimated Energy Savings Results per Research Study* ............................................................... 16 Table 4. Annual Heating Energy Use (kWh/year) for ER Homes Estimated with SEEM in the BPA region. 17 Table 5. Regional Technical Potential (RTP)* .............................................................................................. 18 Table 6. Benefit Cost Ratio of Electronic Line-Voltage Thermostats .......................................................... 19 Table 7: BPA Technology Readiness Criteria and Scores for line-voltage connected thermostats ............ 20 FIGURES Figure 1. Bimetallic, mechanical, thermostat ............................................................................................... 5 Figure 2. Example of Comparison of Thermostat Deadbands ...................................................................... 6 Figure 3. Example of Energy Use Reporting per Zone .................................................................................. 9 Figure 4. RTF Heating Zone Map ................................................................................................................. 17 BONNEVIL LE P OWER ADMINISTRATION 3 SUMMARY BPA is interested in exploring controls for electric resistance zonal heaters as an opportunity for regional efficiency improvements. Zonal electric resistance heat is used in many homes in the Pacific Northwest including multifamily homes. Its popularity is driven by its low first cost compared with other more efficient heating systems, lower price of electricity and reduced need for cooling in the region, and lack of natural gas availability in rural areas. Most line-voltage thermostats used to control electric resistance heat In the Bonneville Power Administration region are simple bimetallic mechanical thermostats. Preliminary studies show that replacing them with electronic connected line-voltage thermostats (line-voltage connected thermostats) may offer approximately 13% energy savings. This paper provides an overview of line-voltage thermostats that have connected features to control residential zonal electric resistance (ER) heat in the Pacific Northwest (PNW). It provides background on the various types of thermostats, their energy efficiency potential, non-energy benefits, and key features. Key findings include (1) there are at least 13 line-voltage connected thermostats on the market; (2) the market is introducing new features; (3) there is not much current data on energy savings potential but a conservative estimate is 13%; and (4) more research needs to be completed to determine the savings for single-family and multi-family applications. Based on inferences of energy savings and the number of ER heated homes in the PNW, the estimated regional potential is 120aMW. Payback, without any incentives, appears to be 5.2 years single-family and 8.2 for multifamily. Supporting adoption of line-voltage connected thermostats through field studies and modeling, engaging thermostat manufacturers,