What General Comments Would You Like to Make Regarding the Commission's Proposals for Councillor Numbers and Wards in Highland C
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
What comments would you like to make What comments would you like to make What comments would you like to make What comments would you like to make What comments would you like to make What comments would you like to make What comments would you like to make What comments would you like to make What comments would you like to make What comments would you like to make regarding the number of councillors and ward What comments would you like to make What comments would you like to make regarding the number of councillors and ward What comments would you like to make What comments would you like to make What comments would you like to make What comments would you like to make What comments would you like to make regarding the What comments would you like to make What comments would you like to make regarding the number of councillors and ward regarding the number of councillors and ward What general comments would you like to make regarding the Commission's regarding the number of councillors and ward regarding the number of councillors and ward regarding the number of councillors and ward regarding the number of councillors and ward regarding the number of councillors and ward regarding the number of councillors and ward boundaries for the proposed Tain, Easter Ross regarding the number of councillors and ward regarding the number of councillors and ward What comments would you like to make regarding the number of boundaries for the proposed Caol, Mallaig and regarding the number of councillors and ward regarding the number of councillors and ward regarding the number of councillors and ward regarding the number of councillors and ward number of councillors and ward boundaries for the regarding the number of councillors and ward regarding the number of councillors and ward boundaries for the proposed Badenoch and boundaries for the proposed Fort William and proposals for councillor numbers and wards in Highland Council area? - Please boundaries for the proposed Sutherland ward? - boundaries for the proposed Caithness ward? - boundaries for the proposed Wick ward? - Please boundaries for the proposed Thurso ward? - boundaries for the proposed Wester Ross and boundaries for the proposed Cromarty Firth and Edderton ward? - Please share your views boundaries for the proposed Dingwall and boundaries for the proposed Black Isle ward? - councillors and ward boundaries for the proposed Eilean a' Chèo ward? - the Small Isles ward? - Please share your views boundaries for the proposed Aird ward? - Please boundaries for the proposed Inverness North boundaries for the proposed Inverness North boundaries for the proposed Inverness South proposed Inverness South East ward? - Please share boundaries for the proposed Culloden and boundaries for the proposed Nairn and Cawdor Strathspey ward? - Please share your views Ardnamurchan ward? - Please share your views type your answer in the box below Please share your views below Please share your views below share your views below Please share your views below Lochalsh ward? - Please share your views below ward? - Please share your views below below Seaforth ward? - Please share your views below Please share your views below Please share your views below below share your views below West ward? - Please share your views below East ward? - Please share your views below West ward? - Please share your views below your views below Ardersier ward? - Please share your views below ward? - Please share your views below below below I appreciate that this review is solely based on population numbers per councillor but in island wards and in Ward 20 consideration has been given to distance and remoteness. Ward 5 is currently the biggest council ward in area in the UK, and probably Europe. The proposed alteration removes Garve and district but does not reduce the area much or the travel distances within Ward 5. For instance to travel from Reiff to Arnisdale is 133.5 miles and takes 3.5 hours. I think that it is right that in the proposals, island wards and ward 20 get special treatment due to poor transport links and distance. The present 4 councillors deal with the large distances by informally splitting up the ward so I think that Ward 5, Wester Ross, should retain 4 councillors for the same they can attend all 20 CC's. I think this ward, due to reasons. It is currently the biggest ward by area in the UK and probably Europe. its size, needs 4 councillors. I think the proposal makes sense for Inverness. As it is currently divided I find it difficult to contact my local councillor as they aren't often aware of what's happening in my particular area. Perhaps a shake up will reinvigorate local councillors to take their jobs more seriously and work for all the people they represent rather than the convenient ones. Highland desperately requires to be broken up into its 8 District Council components. An area the size of Wales with a single council is not "local", it's "sub- national". Time for a (Royal) Commission to fully explore the needs and roles of 21st century local government. "In general", greater emphasis should be given by BC to "natural, cultural" boundaries. Secondary school catchments often work well in rural Scotland. I believe Ward 10 could function adequately with 3 Councillors. This seems appropriate for the geography & population. However, being a "remote, rural area," deprived in a number of categories (as defined by the Scottish Government), the "quality" of our representatives is all the more important if "quantity" is reduced. I have concerns about the lack of equality & diversity in those standing for election & being successful (all "middle-class" (for want of a better expression), white males. In 21 years residency, I can only remember 3 women standing for election & no-one from a "minority" group. Skye is a traditional Ward but I would welcome greater encouragement & support for new prospective candidates to put themselves forward. av,3 = 2340 pop / councillor this ward should only have Why is Inverness allocated 18 councillors - 25% of total, when its pop is only 72 councillors for 18300 pop = ~ 1 councillor per 3 councillors 22..5% of total and so should only have 16 councillors. i allocated to Inverness, 2540 pop so a pop of 11000 - this ward should so 4 INVERNESS WARDS SHOULD HAVE 5,4,4 AND 3 = therefore object to these extra councillors it would help to supply ward pops. again no ward pop again no ward pop again no ward pop again no ward pop again no ward pop again no ward pop again no ward pop again no ward pop again no ward pop again no ward pop again no ward pop ok have only 4 councillors 16 COUNCILLORS again no ward pop again no ward pop again no ward pop again no ward pop Although there is a lot of detail, it still seems like 25% of Highland councillors are from Inverness and it will just reinforce the feeling that Highland Council is really Inverness Council and the rest of the Highlands are just incidental to the purpose of spending money in Inverness. Scotland continues to have much poorer representation at this level than most or Europe and the real solution is not to tinker with ward boundaries, but to split Highland council into 3 or 4 smaller councils with more councillors in total and a greater relationship with the population. I strongly object to these proposals. 3 councillors for our large geographical area is simply not adequate. I’m a member of my community council and our councillors struggle to travel to our meetings or they may clash with other community council meetings within our ward - because we have so many within our ward. We need more representation not less. This would in effect mean a reduction in local councillors and I am therefore against the proposal. I understand that the local Highland council have also taken this view recognising the importance of local responsibility We need MORE councillors for this area NOT less. We are an ever changing population with ever changing complex needs and our councillors need to know their area, good points and had points, problems and residents so that they can do what is best for the residents. This area losing a councillor so that Inverness gains one is wrong on every level. The name is to be changed to reflect the inclusion of the Small Isles. Surprised to realise, from the map in this document, that the ward also covers Spean Bridge and Roybridge. As Caol is west of Ft William, this seems just as big an anomaly, if not greater, than the previous name not mentioning the islands.... i would like to see the numbers kept that we have i feel the numbers of councillers we have in caithness are just the right balance for as it seems to be working just fine and does not i see no reason for a change from what we have at the two towns and rural areas require a change present i see no reason for change from what is at present Highland Council covers a land mass similar to the size of Belguim, with the vast majority of it's population living in a condensed settlement area within the inner Moray Firth. Presently more than 50% of the political representation within Highland lies within less than 10% of the landmass. Whilst it may be a simple sum for the electoral commission to equate representation to population, then investment in the whole council area does not follow. This form of calculating political representation takes no account of the distrubution of asset and infrastructure, or pressures from tourism.