Sonoma Creek Baylands Strategy Final Report – May 2020
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Sonoma Creek Baylands Strategy Final Report – May 2020 Sonoma Creek Baylands Strategy 1 May 2020 Acknowledgements Project Team Kendall Webster, Sonoma Land Trust Julian Meisler, Sonoma Land Trust Wendy Eliot, Sonoma Land Trust Jeremy Lowe, San Francisco Estuary Institute Ellen Plane, San Francisco Estuary Institute Scott Dusterhoff, San Francisco Estuary Institute Sam Veloz, Point Blue Conservation Science Michelle Orr, ESA James Gregory, ESA Stephanie Bishop, ESA Renee Spenst, Ducks Unlimited Steve Carroll, Ducks Unlimited Anne Morkill, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Meg Marriott, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Melissa Amato, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Science Advisory Panel Susan Haydon, Sonoma Water Carlos Diaz, Sonoma Water Larry Wyckoff, California Department of Fish and Wildlife Karen Taylor, California Department of Fish and Wildlife Jessica Davenport, San Francisco Bay Restoration Authority Peter Baye Stuart Seigel, San Francisco Bay National Estuarine Research Reserve Joy Albertson, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service John Klochak, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Jessica Pollitz, Sonoma Resource Conservation District Laurel Collins, Watershed Sciences Steve Lee, Sonoma Ecology Center Funded By San Francisco Bay Restoration Authority U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Resources Legacy Fund Dolby Family Fund Sonoma Creek Baylands Strategy 2 May 2020 Table of Contents Chapter 1 .......................................................................................................................................................7 Introduction ...............................................................................................................................................7 1.1 Background ......................................................................................................................................7 1.2 Purpose and Goals ...........................................................................................................................9 1.3 Guiding Principles ............................................................................................................................9 1.4 Stakeholder Outreach................................................................................................................... 11 1.5 Organization of This Report .......................................................................................................... 11 Chapter 2 .................................................................................................................................................... 12 Existing Conditions ................................................................................................................................. 12 2.1 Setting ........................................................................................................................................... 12 2.2 Habitats and Species..................................................................................................................... 12 2.3 Environmental Conditions ............................................................................................................ 24 2.4 Current Land Uses ........................................................................................................................ 43 2.5 Future Environmental Conditions ................................................................................................ 48 Chapter 3 .................................................................................................................................................... 51 Scenario Development ........................................................................................................................... 51 3.1 Hydrologic Scenarios .................................................................................................................... 51 Chapter 4 .................................................................................................................................................... 52 Feasibility Considerations ....................................................................................................................... 52 4.1 Existing Resources and Landscape ............................................................................................... 52 4.2 Co-Benefits ................................................................................................................................... 52 4.3 Habitat .......................................................................................................................................... 53 4.4 Rail and Road ................................................................................................................................ 53 4.5 Sonoma Valley Airport .................................................................................................................. 55 4.6 Utilities .......................................................................................................................................... 55 4.7 Land Use ....................................................................................................................................... 56 4.8 Regulatory .................................................................................................................................... 57 4.9 Public Access ................................................................................................................................. 58 4.10 Feasibility Considerations by Parcel ........................................................................................... 61 4.11 Uncertainties .............................................................................................................................. 63 Chapter 5 .................................................................................................................................................... 65 Alternative Strategy Development ......................................................................................................... 65 5.1 Alternative 0: No Restoration (Figure 5.1) ................................................................................... 66 5.2 Alternative 1: Maximum Tidal (Figure 5.2) ................................................................................... 69 Sonoma Creek Baylands Strategy 3 May 2020 5.3 Alternative 2: Avoid Railroad (Figure 5.3) .................................................................................... 73 5.4 Alternative 3: Enhanced Maximum Tidal (Figure 5.4) .................................................................. 76 Chapter 6 .................................................................................................................................................... 82 Alternative Strategies Feasibility Analysis .............................................................................................. 82 6.1 Evaluation of Alternatives ............................................................................................................ 82 6.2 Availability of Properties .............................................................................................................. 86 6.3 Constructability ............................................................................................................................ 87 6.4 Sequencing ................................................................................................................................... 91 6.5 Implications for Public Access ...................................................................................................... 92 6.6 Infrastructure Considerations ...................................................................................................... 93 6.7 Cost of Implementation ................................................................................................................ 99 6.8 Regulatory Requirements ........................................................................................................... 103 6.9 Groundwater .............................................................................................................................. 110 6.10 Feasibility Summary.................................................................................................................. 110 6.11 Opportunities to Accelerate Restoration ................................................................................. 111 Chapter 7 .................................................................................................................................................. 113 Conclusion ............................................................................................................................................ 113 Chapter 8 .................................................................................................................................................. 116 References ............................................................................................................................................ 116 Sonoma Creek Baylands Strategy 4 May 2020 Figures Figure 1.1. The planning area in context. Figure 1.2. Planning area and surrounding areas. Figure 2.1. Site Names used in this report, adapted from the Lower Sonoma Creek Flood Management and Ecosystem Enhancement Plan (ESA 2012). Figure 2.2. Habitat types. Figure 2.3. Upper boundary approach