Curriculum Vitae Helen Elizabeth Haste

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Load more

Curriculum Vitae Helen Elizabeth Haste Harvard Graduate School of Education 613 Larsen Hall Appian Way Cambridge, MA 02138, USA Department of Psychology, University of Bath, Bath BA2 7AY England. Telephone: (USA) +1 617 354 1544 (UK) +44 1225 420230 email [email protected] [email protected] 1 Contents 1.1 Appointments and distinctions 2 2.1 Research activities – summary 5 2.2 Current work 5 2.3 History of my thinking and research 8 3.1 Writings and publications: 10 Books 3.2 Journal articles, scholarly chapters and extended 12 review essays 3.3 Reviews in refereed journals 18 3.4 General and popular science writings 20 4.1 Conferences and public lectures: 23 Keynote addresses and invited conference presentations 4.2 Conference papers 27 5.1 Professional Activities 33 6.1 Contributions to the University community 35 2 1.1 Appointments and Distinctions Date of Birth 17 March 1943 Degrees 1967 B A Honours in Psychology, Class II (i) University of London 1971 M Phil in Social Psychology University of Sussex 1985 PhD in Psychology, University of Bath 1.1.1 Appointments University of Bath 1971 Lecturer in Psychology 1983 Senior Lecturer in Psychology 1992 Reader in Psychology 1998 Professor of Psychology 1997- 2001 Head of Department of Psychology 2008 Emeritus professor Harvard University 1980 Associate, Center for Moral Education, Harvard Graduate School of Education 1981 Mellon Foundation Research Scholar, Henry Murray Center, Radcliffe College 1983 Visiting Scholar, Henry Murray Center, Radcliffe 1998 Visiting Professor, Harvard Graduate School of Education 2003 – Visiting Professor, Harvard Graduate School of Education 3 1.1.2 Distinctions and Offices 1990 Fellow of the British Psychological Society 1991 President, Psychology Section, British Association for the Advancement of Science 1997-99 Vice President, International Society for Political Psychology 2002 President, International Society for Political Psychology 2002 Fellow of the Royal Society of Arts 2002 Honorary Fellow, British Association for the Advancement of Science 2002-08 Vice President, British Association for the Advancement of Science 2004-05 Chair of Council, British Association for the Advancement of Science 2003-04 Leverhulme Research Fellow 2004-06 Research Director, Nestlé Social Research Programme 2005 Nevitt Sanford Award for Contributions to Political Psychology, International Society of Political Psychology 2005 Fellow, Academy of Social Sciences 2007-13 Chair, Journal of Moral Education Trust 2009- Visiting Professor, University of Exeter 2009 Jeanne Knutson Award in recognition of long-standing service to the International Society of Political Psychology 2011 Kuhmerker Career Award, Association for Moral Education 2013 Senior Research Fellow, Hong Kong Institute of Education 2013 Honorary Guest Professor, University of Jinan, China. 4 2.1 Research Activities My work is broadly within developmental, social and cultural psychology. Much of it has focused on adolescence. It is underpinned by a common theoretical framework: the relationship between social/cultural and individual factors in the understanding and construction of meaning I classify my contributions under four interlocking webs of enterprise: theory: theory of development theory of culture and the individual, language, rhetoric and metaphor contributions to moral theory contributions to feminist theory values, morality, politics and citizenship: moral development and ethics relationship between moral, political and social values activism and citizenship competence gender: the psychological effects of stereotyping gender and values cultural metaphors : gender, rationality and science science and culture: public engagement with science: role of metaphor in innovation, representation and change public image, cultural representations, and metaphors of science 2.2 Current Work 2.2.1 Research –ongoing 1. Harvard China Fund in collaboration with Robert Selman and Xu Zhao This 12 month project during 2011-12 involved designing and supervising the collection of data in Shanghai and Nantong, with over 400 students in 8th and 11th grade, on their understanding and beliefs around civic, moral and relational issues, and their emotional regulation. The study involved questionnaires. interviews and focus groups with students, and interviews with teachers (HH, RS and XZ). An experimental study of emotional regulation was conducted in parallel by Sang Biao. Xu Zhao organized the translation and data collection with the help of Sang Biao’s graduate students. Coding and analysis are being conducted by HH, RS and XZ and involving other HGSE doctoral students in coding. The findings suggest important cultural differences between China and our previous Western samples (US and UK) and will contribute to understanding both developmental and cultural processes in civic and moral engagement and development. We have 5 presented several papers at international conferences on this material during the year. 2. EU-funded study of Science Education and Diversity, director Rupert Wegerif, University of Exeter This 6-nation study on Science Education and Diversity, funded by the EU 2010-2013, involves several ‘work packages’ each lead by a different nation, collecting a variety of data on educational practices and on students’ and teachers’ beliefs about the nature of science. The goal is to understand what make science attractive to young people (or otherwise) and how educational practices and policies might improve motivation towards science. The six nations are the UK, Netherlands, Lebanon, Turkey, India and Malaysia. The students are aged 10 and 14. My primary attachment has been to the Dutch team who are responsible for collecting the data on students’ and teachers’ beliefs, understanding and motivation. I worked with this team to develop the questionnaires, interviews and focus groups, and the classroom observations. We drew on a variety of sources for these measures including my own past work on science and culture. The sample has over 9000 questionnaires and over 400 interviews. Some of the measures are also being used in the intervention activity headed by the Lebanese team. I and the Dutch team have continued analysing the questionnaire data and the qualitative material. The findings indicate quite strong cultural variation, notably that Western European students have a less favorable view towards science as a school subject and a longer term career than do the other nations, and that, also, Western European students’ view of the nature of science is less positivistic (‘science is true’) than other nations. Some surprising findings also have been that ‘minority’ students, contrary to assumptions about diversity, are more rather than less interested in science than majority students, and that religious beliefs are positively rather than negatively associated with enjoying science. While there are gender differences in most countries, they are fewer than expected and apply only with 14 year olds, not with 10 year olds. The intervention study explored different forms of classroom teaching (more ‘dialogic’). This study will also make a contribution to understanding cultural as well as developmental processes. We have presented several papers at international conferences and publications are in progress. 2.2.2 Research –recent 1. Project: ‘Picturing to Learn’. The project was part of the Envisioning Science Program at Harvard University’s Initiative in Innovative Computing (IIC). It is funded by NSF, the PI is Felice Frankel. The project explored how using visual representations of concepts in science can both reveal the nature of understanding, or lack of understanding, in students, and also whether engaging in drawing a concept itself leads to increased understanding. Over 3000 drawings from students at Harvard, MIT and Duke Universities were analysed. 6 The team also conducted workshops which revealed the process of concept construction in teams working with visual representations and images. This study has implications for science education, and also for understanding the intersections of visual and linguistic conceptualization. 2. Projects on young people and science. I have directed two recent projects on young people’s images of science and technology, their motivations towards and away from pursuing science beyond school, and the relationship between these and their social values. The data come from two British studies of over 1500 young people aged 11-21. The goals of the projects were to unpack the complex relationships between values and orientations towards, or away from, science and technology and to avoid the rather simplistic ‘pro versus anti-science’ image that sometimes emerges from this domain. The findings show gender effects but these are strongly mediated by interest in science and technology, and undermine some stereotypes. Girls are not as uninterested in science as some studies suggest. A striking finding is that girls care rather more than boys about ethical issues, and the profile of girls who would like a career related to science is rather different from that of boys who would like a career in science. These ‘pro- science’ girls are sceptical of ‘techno-fixes, are quite pessimistic about the future, and care about ethical issues in relation to science. Pro-science boys are more optimistic about the future and about the potential of technology and science to ‘fix’ problems, they are less concerned about ethics and they hold a more positivistic view of the nature of science (2004-9).
Recommended publications
  • Sex Differences in Self-Perception

    Sex Differences in Self-Perception

    A Publication of the Society Inside-Out: for General Psychology Division One Sex Differences in Self-Perception of the American Psychological Association by Susan Pinker, Author of THE SEXUAL PARADOX Past William James Award Winner Inside Out: Pinker “Susan Pinker is a developmental ..........................1 psychologist and national newspaper columnist in Canada who writes regularly APA D1 Convention Preview about human behavior for the international .........................4 press, and whose writing has garnered several international awards. She has Book Review: Meir taught psychology at McGill University, and ........................9 has given invited addresses in the US, the UK, Canada, the Netherlands, Austria, and Interest in Science: Li Germany. Susan’s book on the science of unexpected sex differences, The Sexual Paradox, has been published in 17 countries. Her next book, on the .......................11 science of social bonds, will be published by Random House in 2013.” ECP Task Force: Charles ........................15 now thyself, Plato instructed us 2,500 years ago. Most of us don’t, of Sacred Application: Colby Kcourse, and women are experts at a certain type of self-deception. Over the last two decades studies show that women are more likely than men to ............................16 underestimate their influence, and this mismatch between how they feel In Memoriam: Parker: and their effect on the outside world creates a jarring paradox. Though they can be spectacularly competent – not only to observers but on tests of their ........................18 skills – many women often feel like imposters. Photopsychology: Morgovsky That’s just one of many incongruities emerging from our latest understand- ........................20 ing of the subtle differences between the sexes--an understanding that rests APA Council Report: Strickland as firmly on a commitment to empirical science as on an ability to tolerate some ambivalence.
  • Gender Issues in Science/Math Education (GISME): Over 700 Annotated References & 1000 URL’S – Part 1: All References in Alphabetical Order * † § 

    Gender Issues in Science/Math Education (GISME): Over 700 Annotated References & 1000 URL’S – Part 1: All References in Alphabetical Order * † § 

    Gender Issues in Science/Math Education (GISME): Over 700 Annotated References & 1000 URL’s – Part 1: All References in Alphabetical Order * † § Richard R. Hake, Physics Department (Emeritus), Indiana University, 24245 Hatteras Street, Woodland Hills, CA 91367 Jeffry V. Mallow, Physics Department (Emeritus), Loyola University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois 60626 Abstract This 12.8 MB compilation of over 700 annotated references and 1000 hot-linked URL’s provides a window into the vast literature on Gender Issues in Science/Math Education (GISME). The present listing is an update, expansion, and generalization of the earlier 0.23 MB Gender Issues in Physics/Science Education (GIPSE) by Mallow & Hake (2002). Included in references on general gender issues in science and math, are sub-topics that include: (a) Affirmative Action; (b) Constructivism: Educational and Social; (c) Drivers of Education Reform and Gender Equity: Economic Competitiveness and Preservation of Life on Planet Earth; (d) Education and the Brain; (e) Gender & Spatial Visualization; (f) Harvard President Summers’ Speculation on Innate Gender Differences in Science and Math Ability; (g) Hollywood Actress Danica McKellar’s book Math Doesn’t Suck; (h) Interactive Engagement; (i) International Comparisons; (j) Introductory Physics Curriculum S (for Synthesis); (k) Is There a Female Science? – Pro & Con; (l) Schools Shortchange Girls (or is it Boys)?; (m) Sex Differences in Mathematical Ability: Fact or Artifact?; (n) Status of Women Faculty at MIT. In this Part 1 (8.2 MB), all references are in listed in alphabetical order on pages 3-178. In Part 2 (4.6 MB) references related to sub-topics “a” through “n” are listed in subject order as indicated above.
  • Mcgill Psychology September 2018 Newsletter

    Mcgill Psychology September 2018 Newsletter

    Psychology McGill behavioural neuroscience | clinical | cognitive neuroscience | developmental | health | quantitative modelling | social & personality 3rd Issue | SEPTEMBER 2018 3rd Issue A Message from our Department Chair Psychology now spans the campus from Stewart Biology Building in the north west to 2001 McGill College in the south east – but we also cast a wide reach across the University in the thousands of non-psychology “students we teach, the linchpin courses we offer to programs in cognitive science and neuroscience, and the research collaborations our faculty and students have with researchers spanning ALL faculties at McGill. We continue to be privileged in the extremely high caliber of students in our classes and labs, whom we expect will go on to great things, similar to the impact of their predecessors briefly highlighted in our alumni section. Indeed, to keep pace with the number and energy of students, we now have 13 assistant professors, whose creativity and vitality inspire students and senior faculty alike. At the same time, we reflect on the legacies of giants. Associate member Brenda Milner turned 100 in July and a two day symposium in September will celebrate her career and the impact she continues to have on research today. In June, we celebrated the legacy of Ginny Douglas, a trailblazer in clinical science and in the place of women in STEMM disciplines. Similarly this Fall, we will memorialize Peter Milner, a pioneer in behavioral neuroscience. May we continue to push the boundaries of science and academic life. • Meet our two new Faculty Members and learn about their work. • As she turns 100, there’s no stopping the trailblazing Brenda Milner! • Breaking gender barriers in STEMM: whose responsibility is it? In This ” ISSUE • Read about the exciting work our Alumni are doing since they left McGill.
  • Thevoice-May2020 WEB

    Thevoice-May2020 WEB

    Spring 2020 / 5780 Senior Rabbi Officers 2020-2021 Lisa J. Grushcow, D. Phil President [email protected] In This Issue Neil Wiener Rabbi Educator [email protected] 7 | From the Rabbi’s Study Ellen Greenspan Immediate Past President 9 | President’s Message [email protected] Susan Greenberg SpiriTual engagemenT Rabbi Emeritus Vice Presidents 10 | Shabbat Services Live Leigh Lerner Glen Grossman 11 | Just Between Us | Shavuot [email protected] Robert Katz communiTy Executive Director Nancy Maklan Shellie Ettinger 3 | Temple Together during the COVID-19 Treasurer [email protected] Testimonials from our members Michael Tinkler 5 | Caring Cooks Assistant to Rabbi Grushcow Honourary Secretary 12 | News from our Rabbi Educator Sally Ayrton Jewel Lowenstein 13 | Temple Together in Spirit and Song | [email protected] Member Connections Board of Trustees Director of Community Engagement 16 | LIFE & LEGACY David Abramson Sari Roston 17 | May is Mitzvah Month Sam Berliner [email protected] Temple Mitzvah Masks Project Susyn Borer Director of Marketing and Stephanie Chabot learning and growTh Communications Nicole Ginsberg 14 | Shabbat Specials Live Barbara Peisajovich Maggie Jacobs Connecting | Online Programs [email protected] Gerald Levy 15 | Lunch Together Online Music Director Rick Liverman Temple family Rona Nadler Gloria Mintz 16 | New Arrivals | Congratulations [email protected] Jesse Prupas New Members A.J. Rubineau Accounting 18 | Special Birthdays | Milestone Anniversaries | Stephen Schneider Emma Cohen 19 | Donations Jordanna Vamos [email protected] Rabbi Lisa Grushcow 22 | Yahrzeits Rabbi Ellen Greenspan 23 | Yizkor Administrative Assistant Adela Muszynska Shellie Ettinger [email protected] Administrative Assistant Rosie Zizek [email protected] Submissions deadline for our next issue Food Services Please send all submissions for the Maria Leszuzynska next edition of THE VOICE to Building Manager [email protected] Ricky Muise by July 8, 2020.
  • Cordelia Fine's “Delusions of Gender”

    Cordelia Fine's “Delusions of Gender”

    Praise for A Mind of Its Own ‘We are all vain bigots, thanks to the foibles of the human brain, so argues Fine in her witty survey of psychology experiments … An ideal gift for anyone interested in psychology’ Focus ‘Clear, accessible writing makes her a science writer to watch.’ Metro ‘Filled with quotable stories and interactive ways of how our brain has a buoyant ego of its own and is not the objective tool we might like to believe’ Bookseller ‘A light and amusing introduction to the brain and how it works on our perceptions and actions’ Publishing News ‘Consistently well-written and meticulously researched … [Fine’s] touching vignettes about life with her young son and her rational but tender husband suggest the buried presence of someone who could in the future rewardingly illuminate the workings of the mind with the studied casualness of the gifted novelist.’ Alain de Botton, Sunday Times ‘In breezy demotic, Fine offers an entertaining tour of current thinking … [she] is especially fascinating on the blurring of the line between pathological delusions and the normal deluded brain.’ Telegraph ‘Fine, with a sharp sense of humour and an intelligent sense of reality, slaps an Asbo on the hundred billion grey cells that – literally – have shifty, ruthless, self-serving minds of their own.’ The Times ‘Fine’s style is chirpy … [with] many affectionately amusing scenes.’ Guardian ‘Engaging, intelligent’ Scotland on Sunday ‘Fine’s flair for the humorous and anecdotal makes this a delightful read.’ Irish Times ‘Fine sets out to demonstrate that the human brain is vainglorious and stubborn.
  • American Psychological Association, Person and Context

    American Psychological Association, Person and Context

    A Publication of the Society for General Psychology AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGICAL Division One ASSOCIATION of the American DIVISION ONE Psychological Association CONVENTION PREVIEW APA Convention 2010 Preview 2010 ..........................1 Convention Co-Chairs for Division One Evolutionary Psychology: Harrison .........................10 Mark Terjesen, Ph.D. Presidential Column: Hogan St. John’s University .........................13 CIRP Liaison Introduction ........................14 Milgram Forum: Takooshian Mark J. Sciutto, Ph.D. .......................15 Muhlenberg College Pursuing Patterns: Gottfredson ........................26 Retro Review: Pickren ............................33 We have thoroughly enjoyed serving as co-chairs of the Division 1 Book Review: Brady-Amoon program for the 2010 convention in San Diego. Division 1 takes great pride ........................35 in providing a forum for research that reflects the diverse subspecialties in psychology. We have tried to compile a program that puts these Grad Corner: Vaughn-Blount subspecialties into conversation with one another. We have a variety of ........................37 invited speakers and symposia as well as a sizable number of submitted programs. This year, we will also host two poster sessions, with one being What They’re Reading: McCann specifically dedicated to showcasing student research. Below are some ........................41 highlights of the Division 1 program. Leona Tyler Principle: Our Division President, John Hogan will give his address on The Secret Cummings & Byrd Lives of APA Presidents. Other invited speakers will include Dean Keith Simonton from the University of California – Davis (Creativity and ........................44 Discovery As Blind Variation: Donald Campbell’s BVSR Theory After Strickland: APA Council Report the Half Century Mark), Joseph E. LeDoux from New York University ........................49 (Why You Should Know About Fear in Rats if You Are a Therapist), Andres De Los Reyes from the University of Maryland College Park Volume 45, No.
  • Speaker Biographical Sketches

    Speaker Biographical Sketches

    How to Strengthen News Coverage of Social and Behavioral Science Roundtable on the Communication and Use of Social and Behavioral Sciences August 9, 2016 Speaker Biographical Sketches Kathleen Hall Jamieson is the Elizabeth Ware Packard Professor of Communication at the Annenberg School for Communication and Walter and Leonore Annenberg Director of the Annenberg Public Policy Center at the University of Pennsylvania. She is the author or co- author of 15 books including: Presidents Creating the Presidency (University of Chicago Press, 2008), Echo Chamber: Rush Limbaugh and the Conservative Media Establishment (Oxford, 2008) and unSpun: Finding Facts in a World of Disinformation (Random House, 2007). Her book, co-authored with Kate Kenski and Bruce Hardy, The Obama Victory: How Media, Money, and Messages Shaped the 2008 Election, received the 2010 American Publishers Award for Professional and Scholarly Excellence (PROSE Award) in the area of government and politics. https://www.asc.upenn.edu/people/faculty/kathleen-hall-jamieson-phd Brian Lin is the director for editorial content strategy at EurekAlert!, an online, global news service operated by AAAS, the science society. EurekAlert! provides a central place through which universities, medical centers, journals, government agencies, corporations and other organizations engaged in research can bring their news to the media. Prior to coming to EurekAlert!, Lin served as a press officer at the University of British Columbia, leading the design of a media training curriculum for faculty, and as a writer and technology reporter for television in Vancouver. http://www.eurekalert.org/ Kellina Craig-Henderson currently serves as the Deputy Assistant Director for the Social, Behavioral and Economic Sciences Directorate of the National Science Foundation (NSF).
  • The-Language-Instinct-How-The-Mind

    The-Language-Instinct-How-The-Mind

    STEVEN PINKER THE LANGUAGE INSTINCT The New Science of Language and Mind PENGUIN BOOKS for Harry and Roslyn Pinker who gave me language Preface I have never met a person who is not interested in language. I wrote this book to try to satisfy that curiosity. Language is beginning to submit to that uniquely satisfying kind of understanding that we call science, but the news has been kept a secret. For the language lover, I hope to show that there is a world of elegance and richness in quotidian speech that far outshines the local curiosities of etymologies, unusual words, and fine points of usage. For the reader of popular science, I hope to explain what is behind the recent discoveries (or, in many cases, nondiscoveries) reported in the press: universal deep structures, brainy babies, grammar genes, artificially intelligent computers, neural networks, signing chimps, talking Neanderthals, idiot savants, feral children, paradoxical brain damage, identical twins separated at birth, color pictures of the think­ ing brain, and the search for the mother of all languages. I also hope to answer many natural questions about languages, like why there are so many of them, why they are so hard for adults to learn, and why no one seems to know the plural of Walkman. For students unaware of the science of language and mind, or worse, burdened with memorizing word frequency effects on lexical decision reaction time or the fine points of the Empty Category Principle, I hope to convey the grand intellectual excitement that launched the modern study of language several decades ago.
  • The LANGUAGE INSTINCT How the Mind Creates Language STEVEN PINKER the Language Instinct

    The LANGUAGE INSTINCT How the Mind Creates Language STEVEN PINKER the Language Instinct

    NATIONAL BESTSELLER UA brilliant, witty, and altogether satisfying book.” — New York Tima Btn.<k Review The LANGUAGE INSTINCT How the Mind Creates Language STEVEN PINKER The Language Instinct Steven Pinker HarperPerennial A Division of HarperCollinsPublishers for Harry and Roslyn Pinker who gave me language This book was originally published in 1994 by William Morrow and Company. It is here reprinted by arrangement with William Morrow and Company. THE LANGUAGE INSTINCT. Copyright © 1994 by Steven Pinker. All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America. No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles and reviews. For information address William Morrow and Company, Inc., 1350 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10019. HarperCollms books may be purchased for educational, business, or sales promo­ tional use. For information please write: Special Markets Department, Harper- Collins Publishers, Inc., 10 East 53rd Street, New York, NY 10022. First HarperPerennial edition published 1995. Designed by Charlotte Staub Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Pinker, Steven, 1954- The language instinct / [Steven Pinker], p. cm. Originally published: New York : W. Morrow and Co., cl994. Includes index. ISBN 0-06-097651-9 (alk. paper) 1. Language and languages. 2. Biohnguistics. I. Title. P106.P476 1995 400—dc20 94-39138 95 96 97 98 99 RRD 10 9 8 7 6 Preface I have never met a person who is not interested in language. I wrote this book to try to satisfy that curiosity. Language is beginning to submit to that uniquely satisfying kind of understanding that we call science, but the news has been kept a secret.
  • Litigating Private Health Insurance in Chaoulli V. Quebec Christopher P

    Litigating Private Health Insurance in Chaoulli V. Quebec Christopher P

    Osgoode Hall Law Journal Volume 44, Number 2 (Summer 2006) Article 1 Symposium on Chaoulli Guest Editor: Bruce Ryder "The Last Line of Defence for Citizens": Litigating Private Health Insurance in Chaoulli v. Quebec Christopher P. Manfredi Antonia Maioni Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/ohlj Part of the Health Law and Policy Commons Special Issue Article Citation Information Manfredi, Christopher P. and Maioni, Antonia. ""The Last Line of Defence for Citizens": Litigating Private Health Insurance in Chaoulli v. Quebec." Osgoode Hall Law Journal 44.2 (2006) : 249-271. http://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/ohlj/vol44/iss2/1 This Special Issue Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at Osgoode Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Osgoode Hall Law Journal by an authorized editor of Osgoode Digital Commons. "The Last Line of Defence for Citizens": Litigating Private Health Insurance in Chaoulli v. Quebec Abstract Litigating health care policy under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms has become an increasingly common phenomenon. The judicialization of health policy in this form raises important questions about the general phenomenon of legal mobilization. This article examines these questions in the context of Chaoulli v. Quebec (2005), in which the Supreme Court invalidated Quebec's prohibition against private insurance for medical services provided through the public health care system. Among the questions this article explores are: How do such cases get into the judicial system? Under what conditions are such claims likely to be successful? What is the impact of such litigation on the broader policy environment? Keywords Health policy; Judicial review; Quebec; Canada This special issue article is available in Osgoode Hall Law Journal: http://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/ohlj/vol44/iss2/1 "THE LAST LINE OF DEFENCE FOR CITIZENS": LITIGATING PRIVATE HEALTH INSURANCE IN CHAOULLI V.