Judgement of NGT on Patancheru Pollution Case App. No. 90 of 2013
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BEFORE THE NATIONAL GREEN TRIBUNAL SOUTHERN ZONE, CHENNAI Application No. 69 of 2013 (SZ) (THC) (WP. No. 3158 of 1996 AP High Court) IN THE MATTER OF: 1. Kasala Malla Reddy, S/o. Raghava Reddy. 2. Gadila Narsimha Reddy, S/o Anjagowd 3. Kasala Mohan Reddy S/o Dharma Reddy 4. Patti Narayana S/o Venkaiah 5. Seri Ram Reddy S/o Narayana Reddy 6. Kummari Mallaiah S/o Yellaiah 7. Kasala Venkata Reddy S/o Raghava Reddy 8. Golla Kumar S/o Mallaiah 9. Yarala Manemma W/o Malla Reddy 10. Basupalli Vittal Reddy S/o Raghava Reddy 11. Masula Baiamia S/o Patte Mohammad 12. Chamakura Venkat Reddy S/o Narayana Reddy 13. Vadla Veeraiah S/o Narayana 14. Pandaraiah S/o Venkatesam 1 15. Gandi Reddy S/o Kistta Reddy 16. K. Gangamma W/o Mall Reddy 17. Kasala Manikkamma W/o Raghava Reddy 18. Kasala Lakshminarasamma W/o Venkat Reddy 19. Lakshminarasamma W/o Anantha Reddy 20. Pathi Ramulu S/o Venkaiah 21. G. Vijayalakshmi W/o Narsimha Gowd 22. Kammari Anjaiah S/o Mallaiah 23. Kummari Ananthi D/o Mallaiah 24. Nandigama Anjamma W/o Ram Reddy 25. Gani Pasha S/o Abdul Khadar 26. Pati Kanti Reddy S/o Narayana Reddy 27. Kummari Krishna S/o Butchaiah 28. Jakkula Krishna S/o Mallaiah 29. Chevella Krishna S/o Lakshmaiah 30. Uppari Krishna S/o Ramulu 31. Khaja Miya Bhasha Miya 2 32. Jakkala Yadagiri S/o. Mallaiah 33. Sivvampeta Gopal reddy S/o. Malla Reddy 34. Gopal S/o. Mallaiah 35. Kummari Ganesh S/o. Rajaiah 36. Gantalagari Gopal S/o. Veera Gowd 37. Gowsumiya S/o. Bashamiya 38. Gudu Sabu S/o. mahabub Sabu 39. Chennaiah S/o. Mallaiah 40. Gangaram Chandraiah S/o. Devaiah 41. Jaganmohan Reddy S/o. Narayana Reddy 42. Janabal W/o. Anthi Reddy 43.B.Vinadha W/o. Kistta Reddy 44. Jnaneswar S/o. Manaiah 45. Devamma W/o. Manaiah 46. Sivvampeta Damodar Reddy S/o Malla Reddy 47. Golla Durgaiah S/o Advaiah 48. S.Narayana Reddy S/o. Malla Reddy 49. Patti Narayana Reddy 3 S/o. Advaiah 50. Narsimha Reddy S/o. Ram Reddy 51. Gangaram narayan S/o. Devaiah 52. Palpanoori Narayana Gowd S/o. Narsagowd 53. B.Nagaiah S/o. Veera Gowd 54. Nabbi Saboo S/o. Mahabooba Sabu 55. Narayana Swamy S/o. Veeraiah 56. ChevellaPrabhakar S/o. Manayya 57. Battumeedi Papaiah S/o. Mahammad 58. Pashamiya S/o. Patte Mohammad 59. Bashaiah S/o. Bagaiah 60. Bala Krishna S/o. Beeraiah 61. Brahma Chari S/o. Kistaiah 62. Y.Pedda Balram S/o. Veeraiah 63. Y.China Balaram S/o. Guravaiah 64. Venkat Reddy S/o. Guravaiah 65. Mukunda Reddy S/o. Anji Reddy 66. S.Manik Reddy 4 S/o. Ram Reddy 67. Patti Mallaiah S/o. Ramaiah 68. Golla Manaiah S/o. Mallaiah 69. Banda Mallaiah S/o. Narsimhulu 70. Golla Muttaiah S/o. Mallaiah 71. Serella Malaiah S/o. Venkanna 72. Mohinuddin S/o. Basu Sabu 73. Sivvampeta Yadav reddy S/o. Malla Reddy 74. Gantalagari Yadaiah S/o. Veera Gowd 75. Yendikidi Yellaiah S/o.Butchaiah 76. Kummari Ramulu S/o. Mallaiah 77. Palpanoori Rama Gowd S/o. Raghava Reddy 78. Gangalagari Srisailam S/o. Pentaiah 79. Gangaram Raja Mallaiah S/o. Devaiah 80. Sevella Ravinder S/o. Mallaiah 81. Bajapalli Lakshmamma W/o. Narayana Reddy 82. Patti Lingamaiah S/o. Narayana 83. Patnam Manemma 5 W/o. Lakshmaiah 84. Venkatamma W/o. S.Ramreddy 85. Vittal Gowd S/o. Narsa Gowd 86. Paipanuri Veera Gowd S/o. Gowra Gowd 87. Gangaram Veeraiah S/o. Rajaiah 88. Kummari Veeraiah S/o. Rajaiah 89. Yeluri Viswanadham S/o. Antaiah 90. Gajendla Venkatesam S/o. Narayana 91. Srinivas Gowd. S/o. Veera Reddy 92. Golla Sangaraiah S/o. Mallaiah 93. Shaik Hussain S/o. Mahabuba Sai 94. Nandigama Sai Reddy S/o. Raghava Reddy 95. S.Satyanarayana reddy S/o. Sanga Reddy 96. Gajaendra Sudarsanam S/o. Narayana 97. Yeluri Sudarsanam S/o. Viswanadhanm 98. Juleman S/o. Basha Sabu 99. Kummari Agamaiah S/o. Mallaiah 6 100. Kummari Srisailam S/o. Mallaiah 101. Mandumula Mallaiah S/o. Yella Gowd. 102. Manne Bharathamma W/o. Kisttaiah 103. Reddi Gari Vijayalakshmi W/o. Vijaya Reddy 104. Golla Mallaiah S/o. Mutyalu. 105. Bajupalli Bal Redy S/o. Sriram Reddy 106. Muttangi Nagamanemma W/o. Dasna Gowd 107. Kummari Anjaiah S/o. Rajaiah 108. Nummari Narayana S/o. Yellaiah 109. T.Ramulu S/o. Lakshmi Gowd 110. Kummari Ramulu S/o. Venkaiah 111. Kummari Lakshmaiah S/o. Venkaiah 112. Veeraiah S/o. Pullaiah 113. Patti Prvathamma W/o. Burraiah 114. Yendikota Rajamma W/o. Mallaiah 115. Kasala Balamani W/o. Ramachandra Reddy 116. Gangaram ,Sayamma 7 W/o. Veeraiah 117. Manne Kisttaiah S/o. Pentaiah 118. Banda Sai Gowd 119. Patlolla Anitha W/o. Amrender Reddy (All are R/o, Arutla Village, Sangareddy Mandal Medak District.) ... Applicant(s) AND 1. State of Andhra Pradesh, Rep by its Chief Secretary to Government, Secretariat, Hyderabad – 4. 2. The District Magistrate & Collector, Sangareddy, Medak District. 3. Andhra Pradesh State Pollution Control Board, Rep by its Member Secretary, Kawadiguda, Hyderabad. 4. Central Pollution Control Board, Parivesh Bhawan, CBD-CUM Office Complex, East Arjun Nagar, New Delhi – 110 032. 5. Patancheru Enviro Tech Ltd., No.23-24/25, IDAm Phase-IV, Patancheru, Medak District, Hyderabad. 6. Bulk Drug Manufacturers Association,rep.by C-25, Industrial Estate, Sanat Nagar, Hyderabad, Telangana – 500 018. (Respondents No. 4 to 6 have been impleaded Suo Moto as per the order of Tribunal dated 22.12.2015) ... Respondent(s) 8 Counsel appearing for the Applicant: M/s. P. Niroop and Srinidhi Srinivasan Counsel appearing for the Respondents: Mr. Ramachandra Rao, Additional Advocate General, Telengana for Mrs. H. Yasmeen Ali for R-1 and R-2 Mr. T. Saikrishnan for R-3 Mr. D.S Ekambaram for R-4 M/s Lakshmi Kumaran and Sridharan for R-5 Mr. Y. Srinivasamurthy, counsel for M/s. V.B. Subramanian & P. Rajashekhar for R6 Application No. 70 of 2013 (SZ) (THC) (WP. No. 3159 of 1996 AP High Court) IN THE MATTER OF: 1. Ashok Reddy, S/o. Srinivas Reddy. 2. B. Janardhar Reddy, S/o Vittal Reddy 3. P. Narsimha Reddy, S/o Venkat Reddy 4. B. Narayana Reddy S/o. Anji Reddy 5. B. Kista Reddy, S/o Lakshma Reddy 6. Basupalli Bal Reddy, S/o Sreeram Reddy 7. Bade Ballaiah, S/o Ramaiah 8. Banuru Veeresalingam S/o Balaiah 9. Gandla Papaiah S/o Linganna 10. Bade Ramesha alias Narayana 9 S/o Lingaiah 11. Vannapuram Vittlaiah S/o Lingaiah 12. Banuru Ellaiah S/o Bhoomaiah 13. Vennapuram Srisailam S/o Adivalah 14. Chakali Ramaiah S/o Veeraiah 15. Akkamgari China Drugs Gowd S/o Veera Gowd 16. Chakali Kistaiah S/o Veeraiah 17. Chakali Lakshamaiah S/o Sayanna 18. Erra Kista Gowd S/o Saya Gowd 19. Akkamgari Durga Gowd S/o Malla Gowd 20. P. Ram Reddy S/o Kistta Reddy 21. Akkamgari Veera Gowd S/o Durga Gowd 22. Akkamgari Malla Gowd S/o Durga Gowd 23. Vavilala Venkata Reddy S/o Sangareddy 24. Ramannalla Buchi Reddy S/o Chandra Reddy 25. P. Mukund Reddy S/o Jogi Reddy 26. P. Sangareddy S/o Jogi Reddy 10 27. Vavilala Narsimha Reddy S/o Narayana Reddy 28. Vavilala Narayana Reddy S/o Sangareddy 29. P. Narahari Gowd S/o Baga Gowd 30. P. Narsa Gowd S/o BalaGowd 31. Sonnayala Ramulu S/o Kisttaiah 32. Kothagadi Ratnamani W/o Raja Mowli 33. Janagam Eswarappa S/o Sangan Basappa 34. Patlolla Ramchandra Reddy S/o Kistta Reddy 35. Mulugu Kamakota Bhoga Tumeena Karadhara Sastry S/o Mulugu Kakmata Hastalinga Sastry 36. Byagari Gopal S/o Ramaiah 37. Byagari Chinna Venkaiah S/o Gangaiah 38. Mangali Anjaiaj S/O Durgaiah 39. Akkamgari Santhamma W/o Balaiah 40. Manasanapalli Pochaiah W/o Durgaiah 41. Chowdagoni Narasimhulu W/o Lingaiah 42. Chowdagoni Pedda Yadamma W/o Narsimhulu 43. Ramanoolla Muttam Reddy 11 S/o Balvanth Reddy 44. Byagari Papaiah S/o Bojaiah 45. Chowdagoni Asaiah W/o Chowdaiah 46. T. Jaganmohan Reddy W/o Anantha Reddy 47. Madapati Pandari S/o Balram 48. T. Ram Reddy S/o Narayana Reddy (All are R/o Ismailkhanpet village, Sangareddy Mandal, Medak District) ... Applicant(s) AND 1. State of Andhra Pradesh, Rep by its Chief Secretary to Government, Secretariat, Hyderabad – 4. 2. The District Magistrate & Collector, Sangareddy, Medak District. 3. Andhra Pradesh State Pollution Control Board, Rep by its Member Secretary, Kawadiguda, Hyderabad. 4. Central Pollution Control Board, Parivesh Bhawan, CBD-CUM Office Complex, East Arjun Nagar, New Delhi – 110 032. 5. Patancheru Enviro Tech Ltd., No.23-24/25, IDAm Phase-IV, Patancheru, Medak District, Hyderabad. 6. Bulk Drug Manufacturers Association,rep. by C-25, Industrial Estate, 12 Sanat Nagar, Hyderabad, Telangana – 500 018. (Respondents No. 4 to 6 have been impleaded Suo Moto as per the order of Tribunal dated 22.12.2015) ... Respondent(s) Counsel appearing for the Applicant: M/s. P. Niroop and Srinidhi Srinivasan Counsel appearing for the Respondents: Mr. Ramachandra Rao, Additional Advocate General, Telengana for Mrs. H. Yasmeen Ali for R-1 and R-2 Mr. T. Saikrishnan for R-3 Mr. D.S Ekambaram for R-4 M/s Lakshmi Kumaran and Sridharan for R-5 Mr. Y. Srinivasamurthy, Counsel for M/s. Y. Srinivasamuthy, V.B. Subramanian & P. Rajashekhar for R6 Application No. 71 of 2013 (SZ) (THC) (WP. No. 3160 of 1996 AP High Court) IN THE MATTER OF: 1. Bade Ballaiah, S/o, Ramaiah. 2. Mangali Mallaiah, S/o. Venkaiah. 3. Mangali Narsaiah, S/o.