A History of the Roman Catholic Parochial School System in the United States: a Documentary Interpretation
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Loyola University Chicago Loyola eCommons Dissertations Theses and Dissertations 1971 A History of the Roman Catholic Parochial School System in the United States: A Documentary Interpretation Glen E. Gabert Loyola University Chicago Follow this and additional works at: https://ecommons.luc.edu/luc_diss Part of the Education Commons Recommended Citation Gabert, Glen E., "A History of the Roman Catholic Parochial School System in the United States: A Documentary Interpretation" (1971). Dissertations. 1180. https://ecommons.luc.edu/luc_diss/1180 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses and Dissertations at Loyola eCommons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Loyola eCommons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License. Copyright © 1971 Glen E. Gabert 1. lU"l'fllrt al nm ~GttJ.li CAnu..IC PJUt:OelJLU. f3CW0t. ~S'm'! m 'llil WI'c-w ~t /.. DICfl·:Drl<ltY ~n.m A Itt.. ttacion S~t.ted to tM P~ltr af tM Cnidv.i1te Se.hool •f L>J'oJ.4 tt&tvenilJ ~ Pa~ti&l 1\l.lfil~ of t~ ~u~ta fl>• t~ Ih:asr" tlf ~t- ·Of ~U,l,~~11° J\tfte ( an. ABSTRACT HISTORY OF THE ROMAN CATHOLIC PAROCHIAL SCIDOL SYSTEM IN THE UNITED STATES: ooCUMENTARY INTERPRETATION • 111e Subject Matter and Its Significance. The Roman Catholic parochial school system in the United States ~ unique ir. the istory of education. It is the largest private school system in the world and in the istory of the world. Unlike most other private school systems, it does not draw its nrollment from an elite social class, but rather it is within the financial grasp of he masses. Built largely by the n\.Uilberless small contributions of immigrant Catholics, t has educated millions of American children. Technically speaking, a parochial school 8 a private and denominational schools that is supported by a single church unit or rish. In the case of the Roman Catholic parochial schools, they are drawn together nto a series of loose diocesan systems throughout the country. Though few foresaw it a ecade ago, the Roman Catholic school system has entered into a period of unprecedented ecline. Between 1965 and 1971, enrollments have fallen by at least nine hundred housand (out of about four and one half million), and the actual number of school units s dropped by about one thousand (out of about ten thousand five hundred). The plight of these schools should be of interest to Roman Catholic and non-Roman atholic alike. For many years they have provided a significant segment of the popula ion with an education at virtually no cost to the .American taxpayer. They have been f inestimable value to the public schools if for no other reason than they helped to eep them more accountable to the general public by offering a viable educational alter ative. If public funds are now awarded to private schools or if public schools have to bsorb students who would have be~n educated in parish schools, the taxpayer will find ignif icant new demands made upon him. There is much contemporary debate about arochial schools. Some feel that they should be preserved unchanged; others, that they hould be radically altered; still others, that they should be abandoned. Yet, what is o surprising, very few persons seem to know anything of the real history of these choola: most see the red brick building next to the church but never stop to ask how t came to be there or why it was built. It is really not possible to plan adequately or the future unless one can realistically assess the present. A knowledge of the ecent past makes any such assessment easier. This paper is not intended to be a lueprint for future policy but rather as an analysis of the official policy that has irected the schools to the present day. II I vOU,::.::.tl::.;i=:n:.:e~o·f~th~e;;;..o;Ma=;;:n~u-.s~cr~i.,.p....,t: I • chapter- I: Introduction and Statement of Purpose a.nd Scope. chapter II: The Era of the English: Early Origins to 1826. (Though many do not know it, the early beginnings of Roman Catholicism in what is now the United States were English in origin. The roots of the Church were pl&nted in waryland, southern Pennsylvania, and Kentucky. Though there were a few parish schools during this era, the bases of the present-day system do not rest in this period.) Chapter III: The Era of the Irish: 1826 to 1866. (Beginning in the 1820's the nature of American Catholicism began to change markedly with the great influx of Irish immigrants. The Church grew in numbers, but it also developed something of a ghetto complex. It was during this period that American catholicism took on a militant cast that it did not have earlier. Parish schools became more common; but, still, they were not mandatory.) Chapter IV: The Era of the Germans: 1866 to 1919. (After the Civil War, the origins of immigration to the United States changed. The Germans became more numerous than the Irish, and in many sections there arose conflicts within the Church closely paralleling the nativist conflicts that existed outside the Church. Germans were more willing to support Catholic schools than the Irish for several reasons, the most significant being the greater contrast of their culture and language to the dominant Anglo-Sax.on-American culture and their comparatively better socio-economic status. The Vatican was eventually persuaded by the Germans and other conservative factions that public schools in America posed a great peril to the faith, and it ordered the construction and patronage of parish schools. It was during this period that the famous Baltimore Council was held. Parish schools were made mandatory.) Chapter V: The Era of Consolidation: 1919 to 1958. (It was in the period between World War I and the pontificate of John XXIII that the Rom.'.111 Catholic schools experienced what was perhaps their golden era. The beginnings of the present school crisis were already apparent, but few saw them.) Chapter VI: The Era of the Americans: 1958 to 1971. (The Vatican Council was itself the effect of certain currents in the Church more than a cause of changes that are now so manifest. Many mistakenly argue that the school crisis stems from Vatican II or a lack of financial ability on the part of rank-and file Catholics. Yet John XXIII and Paul VI have been very traditional in their state ments on education; an-0 the socio-economic status of American Catholics has never been . higher.) Chapter VII: Conclusions and General Sunmary. Appendix: At the end of the text there is a table giving the number of schools and number of pupils enrolled on a year•by-year basis from 1880 to 1971. These figures have been drawn from Catholic directories. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • na ttif.i or ~ mot.tDih C1J.1nuc DYUCAi"lm m nm m11u ~ '1l> ta• . • • • 1 11. ·t~E itYA cw 1211& unmit 1'8!9-!866 •••• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Ill. ·nm &PA at Ttm ~11H1t1h CA'~.·:»u.c fA.rrJCllUL St>VCAnm, 1866•1919 • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 'l'!B ooua.; Ur!A: 1919•19'$ • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • T2£ £1~ CV ?!B At&U!Clllh OA'i'tm.!C 1\\~ imt'CA~"Dll,, 1958•1"1 ••••••••••• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Ai.~U tt • • • ••• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Di.iJliogri~ • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ·• • • • • • • • • • • ti ~q of theM wttiup ~ • .._.a ~ion of*- 1D !UM~l CGQ~. ,.i 'Wf.tmp, oftiof.al ......................... of.~ ~~ .. a. -.J• ...... of..._. ........... A~ ...ial of. tblM wtti..'1P -....u ...,...1 .-aue. ,_ 1*icb att:a pttMI ....., ba'9 bGfA atwa in tbta ,.._. -.. tlbe ~1 Wl'itlap of tU ~ W f»1fl ftaU,, aiplff.• ~ dhot. - tile..,.. of.~ of~ C.dlolic ~l ~' lklw ~ ...... ....w .. ~1 i.uiSM 01' ~. of tba U.. a _.en drD pal$ flf tile~~ tllet W1ld ~ baw • fll'PAl ....... bid .... ta. .._lat -- of ta a&ac.eau of tbe f~ bi.....,. hlml a., .._ ...._.1, taflumuitld t,, ,.al ~11nt• ;;~l(J a.. Jllllf .... - a. ·~ ... .,,..,..,.. of,.... ~ ~, ~ rdlht M fllPlllO* al ..-ir PH'G'J ..t ..... ~'••ltt't 1.'!»llt i• .... ~ .......... ~-1 .....111. a.. l•l tbaC .. ~14 k ......... ~I; ..... t"8:t t;beJ .-w be .-,ull7 Dlt-..1; •UU ~. that tMJ .-w .,. ~. Yet... Q - ~Stllh w.q '-,..... .._to ~~of die -.1 bta'°'7 of ~ eolwaobt tbot- ~ red~bld.WiDI--* ---~- ........... ,t ~ co be ~ • ..., tc ws buf.11. lt :ta aal~ not ..-.•i. to plan ~11' for tM 6atua _.._. ._ .,_ IU.1DU..1lJ ..... the ,__t. A ~of the ~t pmt .... .., aaob u1ea..- wtn'. 'itil4J ,.,_. ta iW>f: ~ • a blueprint !ow ... tct1Sft.7 ttut act.• • • ••d;pu of the oftkUl pol~ t.b.lt ~ 41~te4 tM .-u to the ~ -,. l'bla Wi•l!' WO&lW U.ka to ~ wilb ~l~ dlo .,_141 4llUla~ of ~•• ._ ~.. w eutek, Job1.1 u~. 11111 1*__,. ~otu. all of. LoJttLI Utd.wnlt)' of ~caao. ln the ~4tka .t dte ~pt. Bl -.d4 al.M like w to t.Oi;;:\~ ti- ••u .• i• 4W $- di~ pt,"@:i.:,;,Wtl j~ \~ 1At~~.1tc'~ v.it:h ~ adjoct1.·;;e u'f~il ·~ tbe ,... b .. j 'wC>l;; {~ ~~ fJ7 ~ ~ton. ~t ~~~n - "'~ ~lid.~'t t;il:.'O ~Ui'Qt ·~· CMP'l'IJl I TR DA or THI lllCLISB; CA'l'HOLlC ll>UClftOI 11 'l'8I UllIDD S1'A'DI TO 1129 The atory of Catholic• in Aaerlca ta •• old •• ColUllbue1 and, if one accept• the lreadaa L•aead• or coaatdere tbe lore.... the real dlacoverere, it 11 eveo ol4er.