234 MOTION for Permanent Injunction.. Document Filed by Capitol
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Arista Records LLC et al v. Lime Wire LLC et al Doc. 237 Att. 12 EXHIBIT 12 Dockets.Justia.com CRAVATH, SWAINE & MOORE LLP WORLDWIDE PLAZA ROBERT O. JOFFE JAMES C. VARDELL, ID WILLIAM J. WHELAN, ffl DAVIDS. FINKELSTEIN ALLEN FIN KELSON ROBERT H. BARON 825 EIGHTH AVENUE SCOTT A. BARSHAY DAVID GREENWALD RONALD S. ROLFE KEVIN J. GREHAN PHILIP J. BOECKMAN RACHEL G. SKAIST1S PAULC. SAUNOERS STEPHEN S. MADSEN NEW YORK, NY IOOI9-7475 ROGER G. BROOKS PAUL H. ZUMBRO DOUGLAS D. BROADWATER C. ALLEN PARKER WILLIAM V. FOGG JOEL F. HEROLD ALAN C. STEPHENSON MARC S. ROSENBERG TELEPHONE: (212)474-1000 FAIZA J. SAEED ERIC W. HILFERS MAX R. SHULMAN SUSAN WEBSTER FACSIMILE: (212)474-3700 RICHARD J. STARK GEORGE F. SCHOEN STUART W. GOLD TIMOTHY G. MASSAD THOMAS E. DUNN ERIK R. TAVZEL JOHN E. BEERBOWER DAVID MERCADO JULIE SPELLMAN SWEET CRAIG F. ARCELLA TEENA-ANN V, SANKOORIKAL EVAN R. CHESLER ROWAN D. WILSON CITYPOINT RONALD CAM I MICHAEL L. SCHLER PETER T. BARBUR ONE ROPEMAKER STREET MARK I. GREENE ANDREW R. THOMPSON RICHARD LEVIN SANDRA C. GOLDSTEIN LONDON EC2Y 9HR SARKIS JEBEJtAN DAMIEN R. ZOUBEK KRIS F. HEINZELMAN PAUL MICHALSKI JAMES C, WOOLERY LAUREN ANGELILLI TELEPHONE: 44-20-7453-1000 TATIANA LAPUSHCHIK B. ROBBINS Kl ESS LING THOMAS G. RAFFERTY FACSIMILE: 44-20-7860-1 IBO DAVID R. MARRIOTT ROGER D. TURNER MICHAELS. GOLDMAN MICHAEL A. PASKIN ERIC L. SCHIELE PHILIP A. GELSTON RICHARD HALL ANDREW J. PITTS RORYO. MILLSON ELIZABETH L. GRAYER WRITER'S DIRECT DIAL NUMBER MICHAEL T. REYNOLDS FRANCIS P. BARRON JULIE A. NORTH ANTONY L. RYAN SPECIAL COUNSEL RICHARD W. CLARY ANDREW W. NEEDHAM GEORGE E. ZOBITZ SAMUEL C. BUTLER WILLIAM P. ROGERS, JR. STEPHEN L. BURNS GEORGE A. STEPHANAKIS GEORGE J. GILLESPIE, IB JAMES D. COOPER KATHERINE B. FORREST DARIN P. MCATEE STEPHEN L. GORDON KEITH R. HUMMEL GARY A. BORNSTEIN DANIEL L. M OS LEY DANIEL SLIFKIN TIMOTHY G. CAMERON OF COUNSEL GREGORY M.SHAW JEFFREY A. SMITH KARIN A. DEMASI PETER S. WILSON ROBERT I. TOWNSEND, HI LIZABETHANN R. EISEN CHRISTINE BESHAR January 31,2008 Arista Records LLC. et al. v. Lime Wire LLC. et al. 06 CV 5936 (GEL) Dear Joe: For the purpose of addressing the liability issues in this case, listed below are the tracks on which plaintiffs, pursuant to the Court's ruling during the December 7th hearing, have provided discovery regarding ownership: Copyright Plaintiff Artist Song Title Album Title SR Don't Rock the Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Someday Jukebox 138-302 Arista Records LLC Brooks & Dunn Lost And Found Brand New Man 140-290 Atlantic Recording Hootie & The Only Wanna Be Corporation Blowfish With You Cracked Rear View 193-960 Atlantic Recording Yourself or Someone Corporation Matchbox 20 Long Day Like You 227-755 BMG Music Lorrie Morgan He Talks To Me Leave the Light On 105-180 BMG Music SWV I'm So Into You It's About Time 146-905 So Much for the Capitol Records, Inc. Everclear Father of Mine Afterglow 181-328 Capitol Records, Inc. Maze Joy and Pain Joy and Pain 20-598 Elektra Entertainment Group Didn't See Me Inc. Keith Sweat Games Coming 293-086 Elektra Entertainment Group Semi -Charmed Inc. Third Eye Blind Life Third Eye Blind 188-673 Interscope Records No Doubt Dark Blue Return Of Saturn 279-727 Interscope Records Wallflowers Hand Me Down Breach 214-646 LaFace Records LLC OutKast Mainstream Atliens 233-296 LaFace Records LLC Usher Final Goodbye Usher 200-154 Motown Record Company, L.P. 98 Degrees Invisible Man 98 Degrees 249-152 Copyright Plaintiff Artist Song Title Album Title SR Motown Record Company, L.P. Brian McKnight Last Dance Back At One 279-471 Priority Records LLC Lil' Romeo Little Star Lil' Romeo 317-620 Priority Records Da Game Is To Be LLC Snoop Dogg Slow Down Sold, Not To Be Told 260-056 SONY BMG MUSIC Anytime You ENTERTAINMENT Mariah Carey Need A Friend Music Box 178-631 SONY BMG MUSIC ENTERTAINMENT Nas One Love Illmatic 207-177 UMG Recordings, Recovering The Inc. Counting Crows A Long December Satellites 226-415 UMG Recordings, Inc. George Strait Lead On Lead On 200-310 Virgin Records America, Inc. Kelis Game Show Kaleidoscope 277-087 Virgin Records America, Inc. Paula Abdul Cold Hearted Forever Your Girl 93-688 Warner Bros. Records Inc. Green Day Pulling Teeth Dookie 185-457 Warner Bros. Records Inc. Linkin Park Papercut Hybrid Theory 288-402 Copyright Plaintiff Artist Song Title SR Atlantic Recording Corporation Ray Charles I Got A Woman Pre-72 Capitol Records, Inc. The Beach Boys Surfer Girl Pre-72 Elektra Entertainment Group Inc. The Doors Light My Fire Pre-72 Motown Record You're A Wonderful Company, L.P. Marvin Gaye One Pre-72 SONY BMG MUSIC ENTERTAINMENT The Byrds Wasn't Born To Follow Pre-72 Also, attached is an amended version of plaintiffs' Schedule A reflecting the additional tracks that Katherine raised during the December 7th hearing. For the avoidance of any doubt, we expressly reserve the right to make additional changes to Schedules A and B. Specifically, we will likely identify additional tracks prior to the conclusion of the liability portion of this lawsuit. Sincerely, 49W(af 'eena-Ann V. Sankoorikal™1l * Joseph D. Cohen, Esq. Porter & Hedges, LLP 1000 Main Street, 36th Floor Houston, TX 77002 Encls. BY FEDERAL EXPRESS w/ ends, and BY ELECTRONIC TRANSMITTAL w/o ends. Copyright Plaintiff Artist Song Title Album Title SR 1 Arista Records LLC 5ive Until The Time Is Through 5ive 189-301 2 Arista Records LLC 5ive When the Lights Go Out 5ive 189-301 3 Arista Records LLC Ace of Base Cruel Summer Cruel Summer 189-302 4 Arista Records LLC Ace of Base The Sign The Sign 169-749 5 Arista Records LLC Ace Of Base Don't Turn Around The Sign 169-749 6 Arista Records LLC Ace Of Base Living In Danger The Sign 169-749 7 Arista Records LLC Adema Freaking Out Adema 302-233 8 Arista Records LLC Adema Giving In Adema 302-233 9 Arista Records LLC Adema The Way You Like It Adema 302-233 10 Arista Records LLC Air Supply All Out Of Love Lost In Love 38-070 11 Arista Records LLC Air Supply Every Woman in the World Lost In Love 38-070 12 Arista Records LLC Air Supply Lost in Love Lost In Love 38-070 13 Arista Records LLC Air Supply Come What May Now And Forever 37-592 14 Arista Records LLC Air Supply Now And Forever Now And Forever 37-592 Two Less Lonely People in the 15 Arista Records LLC Air Supply World Now And Forever 37-592 16 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Dallas Don't Rock the Jukebox 138-302 17 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Don't Rock The Jukebox Don't Rock the Jukebox 138-302 18 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Love's Got A Hold On You Don't Rock the Jukebox 138-302 19 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Midnight In Montgomery Don't Rock the Jukebox 138-302 Page 1 of 331 20 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Someday Don't Rock the Jukebox 138-302 21 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson There Goes Everything I Love 227-719 22 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Chasin' That Neon Rainbow Here in the Real World 120-465 23 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Here In The Real World Here in the Real World 120-465 24 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Home Here in the Real World 120-465 25 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson I'd Love You All Over Again Here in the Real World 120-465 26 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Wanted Here in the Real World 120-465 Lot About Livin' (And a Little 27 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Chattahoochee 'bout Love) 147-716 Lot About Livin' (And a Little 28 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Mercury Blues 'bout Love) 147-716 Lot About Livin' (And a Little 29 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson She's Got The Rhythm 'bout Love) 147-716 (Who Says) You Can't Have It Lot About Livin' (And a Little 30 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson All 'bout Love) 147-716 31 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson I'll Try The Greatest Hits Collection 216-936 32 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Tall, Tall Trees The Greatest Hits Collection 216-936 33 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Farewell Party Under The Influence 303-828 34 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson It Must Be Love Under The Influence 303-828 35 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Kiss An Angel Good Mornin' Under The Influence 303-828 36 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Margaritaville Under The Influence 303-828 37 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Pop A Top Under The Influence 303-828 38 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson The Blues Man Under The Influence 303-828 39 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson A Love Like That When Somebody Loves You 289-367 Page 2 of 331 40 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson I Still Love You When Somebody Loves You 289-367 41 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson It's Alright to Be a Redneck When Somebody Loves You 289-367 42 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Life Or Love When Somebody Loves You 289-367 43 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson When Somebody Loves You When Somebody Loves You 289-367 44 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Where I Come From When Somebody Loves You 289-367 45 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson WWW.MEMORY When Somebody Loves You 289-367 46 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Gone Country Who I Am 202-090 47 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson I Don't Even Know Your Name Who I Am 202-090 48 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Livin' On Love Who I Am 202-090 49 Arista Records LLC Alan Jackson Summertime Blues Who I Am 202-090 50 Arista Records LLC Annie Lennox Walking On Broken Glass Diva 145-693 51 Arista Records LLC Annie Lennox Little Bird Diva 145-693 52 Arista Records LLC Annie Lennox Why Diva 145-693 53 Arista Records LLC Anthony Hamilton Better Days Comin' From Where I'm From 340-393 54 Arista Records LLC Anthony Hamilton Charlene Comin' From Where I'm From 340-393 55 Arista Records LLC Anthony Hamilton Comin' from Where