Constant Mean Curvature Spheres in Homogeneous Three-Manifolds
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Constant mean curvature spheres in homogeneous three-manifolds William H. Meeks III∗ Pablo Miray Joaqu´ın Perez´ Antonio Rosz June 29, 2017 Abstract We prove that two spheres of the same constant mean curvature in an arbitrary homoge- neous three-manifold only differ by an ambient isometry, and we determine the values of the mean curvature for which such spheres exist. This gives a complete classification of immersed constant mean curvature spheres in three-dimensional homogeneous manifolds. Mathematics Subject Classification: Primary 53A10, Secondary 49Q05, 53C42 Key words and phrases: Constant mean curvature, Hopf uniqueness, homogeneous three- manifold, Cheeger constant. 1 Introduction In this manuscript we solve the fundamental problem of classifying constant mean curvature spheres in an arbitrary homogeneous three-manifold, where by a sphere, we mean a closed im- mersed surface of genus zero: Theorem 1.1. Let M be a Riemannian homogeneous three-manifold, X denote its Riemannian universal cover, and let Ch(X) denote the Cheeger constant of X. Then, any two spheres in M of the same constant mean curvature differ by an isometry of M. Moreover: (1) If X is not diffeomorphic to R3, then, for every H R, there exists a sphere of constant mean curvature H in M. 2 arXiv:1706.09394v1 [math.DG] 28 Jun 2017 (2) If X is diffeomorphic to R3, then the values H R for which there exists a sphere of constant mean curvature H in M are exactly those with2H > Ch(X)=2. j j ∗This material is based upon work for the NSF under Award No. DMS - 1309236. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the NSF. yThe second author was partially supported by MINECO/FEDER, Grant no. MTM2016-80313-P, and Programa de Apoyo a la Investigacion, Fundacion Seneca-Agencia de Ciencia y Tecnologia Region de Murcia, 19461/PI/14. zResearch of the third and fourth authors partially supported by a MINECO/FEDER grant no. MTM2014-52368-P. 1 Our study of constant mean curvature spheres in homogeneous three-manifolds provides a natural parameterization of their moduli space and fundamental information about their geometry and symmetry, as explained in the next theorem: Theorem 1.2. Let M be a Riemannian homogeneous three-manifold, X denote its Riemannian universal cover and let SH be a sphere of constant mean curvature H R in M. Then: 2 (1) SH is maximally symmetric; that is, there exists a point p M, which we call the center 2 of symmetry of SH , with the property that any isometry Φ of M that fixes p also satisfies Φ(SH ) = SH . In particular, constant mean curvature spheres are totally umbilical if M has constant sectional curvature, and are spheres of revolution if M is rotationally symmetric. (2) If H = 0 and X is a Riemannian product S2(κ) R, where S2(κ) is a sphere of constant × curvature κ > 0, then it is well known that SH is totally geodesic, stable and has nullity 1 for its stability operator. Otherwise, SH has index 1 and nullity 3 for its stability operator and the immersion of SH into M extends as the boundary of an isometric immersion F : B M of a Riemannian 3-ball B which is mean convex1. ! Moreover, if M (p) denotes the space of spheres of nonnegative constant mean curvature in M M that have a base point p M as a center of symmetry, then the map SH M (p) H R 2 2 M 7! 2 that assigns to each sphere SH its mean curvature is a homeomorphism between: (i) M (p) and 3 M [0; ) if X is not diffeomorphic to R , or (ii) M (p) and (Ch(X)=2; ) if X is diffeomorphic to 1 M 1 R3. This homeomorphism is real analytic except at H = 0 when X = S2(κ) R. × The classification of constant mean curvature spheres is an old problem. In the 19th century, Jellet [16] proved that any constant mean curvature sphere in R3 that is star-shaped with respect to some point is a round sphere. In 1951, Hopf [14] introduced a holomorphic quadratic differ- ential for any constant mean curvature surface in R3 and then used it to prove that constant mean curvature spheres in R3 are round. His proof also worked in the other simply-connected three- dimensional spaces of constant sectional curvature, which shows that these spheres are, again, to- tally umbilical (hence, they are the boundary spheres of geodesic balls of the space); see e.g. [6,7]. In 2004, Abresch and Rosenberg [1,2] proved that any constant mean curvature sphere in the product spaces H2(κ) R and S2(κ) R, where S2(κ) (resp. H2(κ)) denotes the two-dimensional sphere (resp. the hyperbolic× plane)× of constant Gaussian curvature κ = 0, and more generally, in any simply connected Riemannian homogeneous three-manifold with6 an isometry group of dimension four, is a rotational sphere. Their theorem settled an old problem posed by Hsiang- Hsiang [15], and reduced the classification of constant mean curvature spheres in these homoge- neous spaces to an ODE analysis. For their proof, Abresch and Rosenberg introduced a perturbed Hopf differential, which turned out to be holomorphic for constant mean curvature surfaces in these spaces. The Abresch-Rosenberg theorem was the starting point for the development of the theory of constant mean curvature surfaces in rotationally symmetric homogeneous three-manifolds; see e.g., [8, 10] for a survey on the beginnings of this theory. 1That the ball B is mean convex means that the mean curvature of the boundary @B with respect to its inward pointing normal vector is nonnegative. 2 It is important to observe here that a generic homogeneous three-manifold M has an isometry group of dimension three, and that the techniques used by Abresch and Rosenberg in the rotation- ally symmetric case do not work to classify constant mean curvature spheres in such an M. In 2013, Daniel and Mira [9] introduced a new method for studying constant mean curvature spheres in the homogeneous manifold Sol3 with its usual Thurston geometry. Using this method, they classified constant mean curvature spheres in Sol3 for values H of the mean curvature greater than p1 , and reduced the general classification problem to the obtention of area estimates for the 3 family of spheres of constant mean curvature greater than any given positive number. These crucial area estimates were subsequently proved by Meeks [22], which completed the classification of constant mean curvature spheres in Sol3: For any H > 0 there is a unique constant mean curvature sphere SH in Sol3 with mean curvature H; moreover, SH is maximally symmetric, embedded, and has index one [9, 22]. In [25] we extended the Daniel-Mira theory in [9] to arbitrary simply connected homogeneous three-manifolds X that cannot be expressed as a Riemannian product of a two-sphere of constant curvature with a line. However, the area estimates problem in this general setting cannot be solved following Meeks’ approach in Sol3, since the proof by Meeks uses in an essential way special properties of Sol3 that are not shared by a general X. In order to solve the area estimates problem in any homogeneous three-manifold, the authors have developed in previous works an extensive theoretical background for the study of constant mean curvature surfaces in homogeneous three-manifolds, see [27, 25, 26, 24, 23]. Specifically, in [27] there is a detailed presentation of the geometry of metric Lie groups, i.e., simply con- nected homogeneous three-manifolds given by a Lie group endowed with a left invariant metric. In [25, 27] we described the basic theory of constant mean curvature surfaces in metric Lie groups. Of special importance for our study here is [25], where we extended the Daniel-Mira theory [9] to arbitrary metric Lie groups X, and we proved Theorems 1.1 and 1.2 in the case that M is a ho- mogeneous three-sphere. In [23] we studied the geometry of spheres in metric Lie groups whose left invariant Gauss maps are diffeomorphisms. In [26] we proved that any metric Lie group X diffeomorphic to R3 admits a foliation by leaves of constant mean curvature of value Ch(X)=2. In [24] we established uniform radius estimates for certain stable minimal surfaces in metric Lie groups. All these works are used in the present manuscript to solve the area estimates problem. We note that the uniqueness statement in Theorem 1.1 does not follow from the recent Galvez-´ Mira uniqueness theory for immersed spheres in three-manifolds in [11]. Indeed, their results imply in our context (see Step 2 in the proof of Theorem 4.1 in [25]) that two spheres Σ1; Σ2 of the same constant mean curvature in a metric Lie group X are congruent provided that the left invariant Gauss map of one of them is a diffeomorphism (see Definition 3.3 for the notion of left invariant Gauss map); Theorem 1.1 does not assume this additional hypothesis. The main results of this paper, Theorems 1.1 and 1.2, can be reduced to demonstrating Theo- rem 1.4 below; this reduction is explained in Section3. To state Theorem 1.4, we need the notion of entire Killing graph given in the next definition, where X is a simply connected homogeneous three-manifold. Definition 1.3. Given a nowhere zero Killing field K on X, we say that an immersed surface Σ X is a Killing graph with respect to K if whenever Σ intersects an integral curve of K, this ⊂ 3 intersection is transversal and consists of a single point.