The Bates Student Archives and Special Collections
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Bates College SCARAB The Bates Student Archives and Special Collections 10-22-2014 The Bates Student - volume 144 number 06 - October 22, 2014 Bates College Follow this and additional works at: https://scarab.bates.edu/bates_student The Bates Student THE VOICE OF BATES COLLEGE SINCE 1873 WEDNESDAY October 22, 201-1 Vol, 144, Issue, 6 Lewiston, Maine FORUM A variety of perspectives on Bates social culture This issue highlights the varying opinions that students, administration, and alumni have SPECIAL ISSUE toward the cancellation of Trick or Drink See Pages 2, 3, 8t 4 Students unsatisfied with forum Students President Spencer and Dean McIntosh defend, decision to cancel Trick or Drink stand, 1 ■ sign petition EVAN HANSEN-BUNDY STAFF WRITER The cancellation of Trick or Drink was announced October 14th, the eve¬ ning before the fall recess. Dean McIntosh spoke about the need for making a “safer, smarter” social community at Bates. The move comes in concordance with the clearly set prec¬ edent that President Spencer initiated at the beginning of the academic year via email. The student body reaction has been heard loudly and clearly. The overwhelming reaction to this newest installment in a sequence of policy re- evaluation and change has been largely Ice President of Student Affairs and Dean of Students Josh McIntosh negative. during Tuesday's foriim. On Tuesday the 15th, a petition was ABER JENSEN/COURTESY PHOTO penned by senior Sean Murphy voicing concerns about the crackdown of the gan by saying she was “in wild agree¬ campus residents should not play host “A lot of questions did not have administration. As of October 21”, over ALEX DAUGHERTY ment” with the issues Tolosky raised. to freshmen and that there needs to be to do with the reinstatement of binge 500 people have put their names down LYDIA O’BRIEN She proposed, “How do you change alternative social options on campus for drinking, and I’m disappointed that in defense of what they feel to be an EDITOR-IN-CHIEF something like a drinking culture? We first-year students. the administration chose to interpret injustice. It is a well-documented and & COPY EDITOR have to work on this together.” “Personally, my question wasn’t an¬ and answer the majority of questions widely propagated fact that while the President Spencer acknowledged swered,” Pellegrini said. “I understand through the language of binge drink¬ drinking age in the U.S. is 21, underage the conversation she had at the begin¬ you can only accomplish so much in a ing,” senior Allie Skaperdas said. drinking still exists. Glancing briefly at ning of Short Term with students about forum with hundreds of students, but President Spencer and Dean Mc¬ the comments posted on the petition On Tuesday evening, President campus culture. However, she found only about five percent of the questions Intosh also revealed that more funds website, it is readily apparent that many Clayton Spencer and Dean McIntosh that even after that conversation, “it in the entire forum were actually an¬ will be provided for on-campus social people feel a lack of communication has met hundreds of students in Old Com¬ was a horrible Short Term” in terms of swered.” events. “Part of the job is figuring out led in the large part to the growing ani¬ mons to answer questions about the drinking and its repercussions. A number of students were inter¬ what the alternatives are,” Spencer said. mosity. For all the promise of an open cancelling of Trick or Drink and larger Dean McIntosh found out about ested in how future decisions about President Spencer noted that this and communicative campus, many stu¬ concerns about Bates’ social culture. Trick or Drink through conversations social life at Bates will be made, given process will take time due to the com¬ dents feel now that their voice is not be¬ The event was moderated by Stu¬ with students and the administration that there was no student input in the plex issues surrounding college drink¬ ing heard at all. dent Body President Alyssa Morgosh during his first few weeks on campus. decision to cancel Trick or Drink. Dean ing culture. “These problems are really Murphy himself put his concerns to and was an open question-and-answer “Do we want to continue and endorse McIntosh and President Spencer intend hard—it’s a problem all over the U.S.,” voice in his second story room in Frye session. Senior Patrick Tolosky, who an event that we know causes harm?” he to create a committee of students that she said. House. “There was a lack of discourse,” facilitated a meeting of student leaders said. “I couldn’t in good faith say yes. will evaluate aspects of Bates social life. Many of Spencer’s and McIntosh’s he said. “[The administration] refused earlier this week, opened the discussion Continuing that kind of event was not “We need to have a process that’s concerns about Trick or Drink and the us a chance to talk about this before by presenting a number of recommen¬ in our best interest.” not hand-picking students,” Spencer drinking culture at Bates stem from sex¬ they acted. The choice to treat students dations for the administration to im¬ Senior student Sophie Pellegrini, said. The committee will be formed and ual assault cases, our relationship with like children, unable to make their own prove communication with the student who lives off campus, raised the issue of meet during the month of November. the Lewiston/Auburn community, and responsible decisions, worries me.” body. underage students coming to oflf-cam- One change that Spencer and Mc¬ dorm and property damage. Last year Murphy also discussed the large “We need policies that take into ac¬ pus houses because of a lack of viable Intosh emphasized is the curbing unac¬ there was over $500,000 in dorm dam¬ amount of collaboration that went into count the huge gray area in Bates drink¬ on-campus social options and an in¬ ceptable social behavior at large events. age, according to Spencer. the petition that was published under ing culture—policies that recognize that creased Security presence. “Were being “I saw the fall-out from 80s Dance,” While there will not be any imme¬ his name. He feels strongly that it pro¬ the vast majority of students who drink put in a really awkward situation where McIntosh said, “And we need to do diate alternative to Trick or Drink, the vides a large number of students who do so safely and moderately,” Tolosky we’re forced to choose between getting something to help the drinking issue.” administration aims to include a variety have policy-related grievances against said. His opening remarks were met in trouble ourselves or telling students For example, McIntosh mentioned that of student voices in future discussions the administration to voice their con¬ with wide approval from the students in to stand in the street.” pizza will be provided at Halloween about Bates social life. cern regardless of its specific intent. attendance. Dean McIntosh replied that off- Dance. In response, President Spencer be¬ See PETITION, PAGE 2 The year without Trick or Drink: “Its something we have Tradition unexpectedly cancelled the power to change” Goals for “civility and moderation” driving force behind decision Patrick Tolosky ’15 leads student forum to student groups, and other student lead¬ ions vocalized on social media. Perhaps create a unified message JULIA MONGEAU ers to gain some understanding of the the most controversial issue was the HANNAH GOLDBERG social scene at Bates. It was in one of timing of the announcement. MANAGING & ASSISTANT ing and the student body isn’t complete¬ these conversations that he first learned McIntosh explained his email deci¬ ALEX DAUGHERTY ly right, so there needs to be a middle NEWS EDITORS LYDIA O'BRIEN of Trick or Drink. sion, “If I do it before fall break it looks ground that will be sustainable over the EDITOR-IN-CHIEF Dean McIntosh gained insight like I am doing it right as people walk next few years so that we don’t create a Bates students were overwhelm¬ & COPY EDITOR about the event from veteran faculty out the door—-which is what I did,” he problem again,” Tolosky said. ingly disappointed last week when an members and met with neighbors who said. “Or I wait five or six more days The group came up with a list of six announce email informed the campus were concerned, frustrated, and upset until there is more talk about the event A group of 40 student leaders con¬ that the long-celebrated Halloween tra¬ recommendations that Tolosky shared with some student behavior on this and students that are here, particularly vened on Sunday evening to discuss a dition, Trick or Drink, was cancelled. with a wide range of student leaders to night and other weekends during the students who are maybe living off-cam¬ plan of action in the wake of the ad¬ get them to sign on their support. As of As Dean of Students and Vice academic year. McIntosh, in addition to pus...maybe still planning. I felt like I ministration’s decision to cancel Trick President of Student Affairs Joshua Mc¬ October 21", 139 people have signed other members of the faculty, decided would rather say I did the best I could or Drink. Senior Patrick Tolosky orga¬ Intosh explained in his message to the the list of recommendations: that enabling an event that is disruptive to get the communication out earlier nized the meeting to create a coherent student body, the binge drinking and Weekly office hours for Dean McIn¬ to people in Lewiston “was in direct op¬ than to delay it even further.” dialogue among student leaders.