Attitudes Toward Homosexuality: American and Canadian Patterns, 1981-2000 by Mark Crowell a Thesis Presented to the University
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Attitudes Toward Homosexuality: American and Canadian Patterns, 1981-2000 by Mark Crowell A thesis presented to the University of Waterloo in fulfillment of the thesis requirement for the degree of Master of Arts in Sociology Waterloo, Ontario, Canada, 2007 © Mark Crowell 2007 Author’s Declaration I hereby declare that I am the sole author of this thesis. This is a true copy of the thesis, including any required final revisions, as accepted by my examiners. I understand that my thesis may be made electronically available to the public. ii Abstract Previous research has determined that Canadians often exhibit more tolerant attitudes toward homosexuality than Americans, yet few studies have attempted to uncover why this pattern persists. Using World Values Surveys data, this study compares attitudes toward homosexuality between Canadians and Americans from 1981 to 2000. The study re-examines directly Reginald Bibby’s (2004) assertion that divergent levels of religious commitment, rather than other socio-demographic, cultural and socio-structural factors, largely account for attitudinal differences between the two neighbouring nations. Consistent with previous research, the findings suggest that differences in gender, marital status, age, education, home language, community size, region, and many indicators of religious involvement and religiosity assist in predicting attitudes toward homosexuality. Overall, the findings support Bibby’s theory that religious differences between Americans and Canadians largely explain more tolerant attitudes among Canadian citizens. Particular attention is also paid to factors outside of religion that may influence attitudes, but which are not directly observable in quantifiable data analysis. iii Acknowledgements This thesis project is dedicated to James Ensign Curtis (1942-2005). As the original supervisor for this thesis, Jim provided me with much needed direction in my beginning days as a graduate student. It was an honour and privilege to know him and to learn from such an esteemed Sociologist. Jim’s incredible character and eternal wisdom continue to inspire all of the lives that he touched. I especially wish to thank Dr. John Goyder (University of Waterloo), who seamlessly stepped in after Jim’s passing, and essentially rescued the project. I will never forget Dr. Goyder’s kindness, patience, and expertise in seeing this project through. I wish to thank Dr. Edward Grabb (University of Western Ontario), and Dr. Lorne Dawson (University of Waterloo) for their incredible support and insight in the latter stages of the project. I was extremely fortunate to have such a benevolent and accomplished group of thesis supervisors. I also wish to thank Joel Lynn whose friendship has inspired me beyond words, and Tony Conte whose courage and integrity fueled my interest in this project. Lastly, I wish to thank my wife, Leah, for her never-ending love and support. iv Table of Contents AUTHOR’S DECLARATION ........................................................................................................................... II ABSTRACT.................................................................................................................................................. III ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS............................................................................................................................... IV TABLE OF CONTENTS .................................................................................................................................. V LIST OF TABLES......................................................................................................................................... VII CHAPTER ONE........................................................................................................................................... 1 RESEARCH PROBLEM AND REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE LITERATURE REVIEW .................................................................................................................................. 3 i) Studies based on convenience samples .............................................................................................. 3 ii) Studies based on nationally representative samples and public opinion surveys ............................. 5 ATTITUDES TOWARD HOMOSEXUALITY AMONG CANADIANS AND AMERICANS......................................... 9 A GROWING AND CONTINUED INTEREST................................................................................................... 13 LITERATURE REVIEW SUMMARY .............................................................................................................. 16 RESEARCH QUESTIONS.............................................................................................................................. 17 HYPOTHESES ............................................................................................................................................. 17 CONCLUSION............................................................................................................................................. 19 CHAPTER TWO........................................................................................................................................ 22 DATA SOURCE, METHODS, AND PROCEDURES DATA SOURCE........................................................................................................................................... 22 WEIGHT..................................................................................................................................................... 24 DEPENDENT VARIABLES ........................................................................................................................... 24 INDEPENDENT AND CONTROL VARIABLES ................................................................................................ 26 MAIN TECHNIQUES OF ANALYSIS.............................................................................................................. 28 HISTOGRAM OUTPUT................................................................................................................................. 29 STATISTICAL MODELING STRATEGY ......................................................................................................... 31 CHAPTER THREE.................................................................................................................................... 32 RESULTS EXPLORATORY ANALYSIS ......................................................................................................................... 32 1981 WVS LOGISTIC REGRESSION ANALYSIS........................................................................................... 36 1981 WVS OLS REGRESSION ANALYSIS .................................................................................................. 42 1990 WVS LOGISTIC REGRESSION ANALYSIS........................................................................................... 47 1990 WVS OLS REGRESSION ANALYSIS .................................................................................................. 52 2000 WVS LOGISTIC REGRESSION ANALYSIS: JUSTIFIABLE - HOMOSEXUALITY SCALE ITEM (1) ............ 57 2000 WVS LOGISTIC REGRESSION ANALYSIS: JUSTIFIABLE - HOMOSEXUALITY SCALE ITEM (10) .......... 64 2000 WVS OLS REGRESSION ANALYSIS .................................................................................................. 69 CONFIRMATORY ANALYSES ...................................................................................................................... 75 1990 WVS– Neighbour: Homosexual ................................................................................................... 75 2000 WVS– Neighbour: Homosexual ................................................................................................... 77 1990 WVS– Should the Church Speak Out On Homosexuality? .......................................................... 80 Conclusion: Confirmatory Analysis ..................................................................................................... 83 CONCLUSION TO CHAPTER THREE............................................................................................................. 83 CHAPTER FOUR ...................................................................................................................................... 89 REGIONAL VARIATION 1990 WVS LOGISTIC REGRESSION............................................................................................................ 90 1990 WVS OLS REGRESSION ................................................................................................................... 93 2000 WVS LOGISTIC REGRESSION - ( JUSTIFIABLE: HOMOSEXUALITY SCALE ITEM (1) ) ......................... 96 v 2000 WVS LOGISTIC REGRESSION - ( JUSTIFIABLE: HOMOSEXUALITY SCALE ITEM (10) ) ....................... 99 2000 WVS OLS REGRESSION ................................................................................................................. 102 THE IMPORTANCE OF ASSESSING PATTERNS OF REGIONAL VARIATION.................................................. 106 CHAPTER FIVE...................................................................................................................................... 110 DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION RE-ADDRESSING THE HYPOTHESES.......................................................................................................... 110 ACCOUNTING FOR