A Challenge to Lepton Universality in B-Meson Decays

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

A Challenge to Lepton Universality in B-Meson Decays A Challenge to Lepton Universality in B-meson Decays Talk by Kla Karava Original Paper by Gregory Ciezarek et al (Nature22346) 23/04/18 University of Oxford Lepton Universality SM assumes Lepton Universality—same weak coupling constant for all 3 generations of leptons. Precision test 1: comparison of Kaon leptonic decay rates: and − − − − → � → Precision test 2: comparison of heavy lepton decay rates: and − − − − → � → � No definite lepton universality violation has been observed. Challenge to Lepton Universality Leptonic B-meson decay: − − → � Semi-leptonic B-meson decay: ( ) ∗ − � → � BaBar at SLAC, USA Belle at KEK, Japan LHCb at CERN, Switzerland (Credit: SLAC) (Credit: KEK) (Credit: CERN) SM Predictions of B-meson Decay Rates Leptonic decay: Semi-leptonic decay: ( ) − − ∗ − → � � → � B-meson Production BaBar and Belle: = 10. 579 GeV (1999-2010) + − � decays exclusively (>96%)→ Υ 4 to → (51.4%) or (48.6%). + − 0 0 Υ 4 LHCb: pp inelastic collisions = 7 and 8 TeV (2008-2012) Production of a pair of B hadrons via interactions of gluons in roughly 1 in every 100 pp collisions Measurements of (BaBar and Belle) − − • At BaBar and Belle, production via: → � + − → Υ 4 → � • A BB pair can be tagged by the reconstruction of a hadronic or semi- leptonic decay of one of the two B-mesons, referred to as Btag. • All remaining particles in the event originate from the other B decay, either a signal leptonic or semi-leptonic decay (the one we are interested in this experiment), or another B decay passing the selection criteria. Measurements of (BaBar and Belle) − − Two tagging algorithms: → � 1. Hadronic Tag (HT) • Search for the best match between one of more than a thousand possible decay chains and a subset of all detected particles in the event • Low efficiency of 0.3% 2. Semi-leptonic Tag (ST) • Exploit the large branching fraction for ( ) with = ∗ + + , → + + • Efficiency of 1% Measurements of (BaBar and Belle) − − • Tau decay modes: → � − − − − → � → − − − − 0 • The signature for signal events is a→ single charged particle, → either a charged lepton, a or a accompanied by a , plus a Btag. − − 0 • Combining the fitted signal yields for the 4 modes of Tau decay, corrected for the efficiency of the tag and signal B decays, the branching fraction can be determined. Measurements of ( ) (BaBar, Belle, and LHCb) ∗ − ( ) • Measure the ratio of branching fractions �( ) →between � ( ) ∗ ∗ − (signal) and (normalization)ℛ � → � ∗ − • BaBar and Belle� → events � consist of a hadronic Btag, a D or D* meson, and a charged lepton = , . − − − • D mesons are reconstructed from pions and kaons with invariant mass compatible with the D meson mass. • The higher mass D* mesons are identified by their and ∗ ∗ decays. → → • At LHCb, only decays of mesons producing a and a meson 0 − ∗+ are selected. Muons are chosen over electrons because of higher detection efficiency. Results (Blue = SM expectation, Red = Experimental average) Results 1-sigma contours Possible Explanations New vector boson —similar to SM but with larger mass and varying coupling strengths′− for quarks and leptons;− no change in kinematics. Charged Higgs boson —part of MSSM; mediates weak interaction but different coupling strengths− for leptons of different mass; q2 and angular distribution affected due to its spin-0. , ′− − , ′− − Possible Explanations Leptoquarks (LQ)—particles with both electric and colour (strong) charge; allow transitions from quarks to leptons and vice versa; various properties depending on different theories. Conclusions and Outlook Enhancements of leptonic and semi-leptonic B-meson decay rates have been observed but their significance is not sufficient to declare new discovery. The measurements are limited by the size of data samples and uncertainties in the reconstruction efficiencies and background estimates. Future improvements include increasing the number of data samples, improving the tagging algorithms, adding additional decay modes, etc. BACKUP Measurements of (BaBar and Belle) − − → � Two tagging algorithms: 1. Hadronic Tag (HT) • Search for the best match between one of more than a thousand possible decay chains and a subset of all detected particles in the event • MET and pT of all undetected particles can be inferred. • Events with one neutrino have 0. 2 • Events with multiple neutrinos or other≈ undetected particles have > 0. 2 • Low efficiency of 0.3% Measurements of (BaBar and Belle) − − → � Two tagging algorithms: 2. Semi-leptonic Tag (ST) • Large branching fraction for ( ) with = , ∗ + + + + • Search for these decay products → to tag the B meson • Weaker constraints on the Btag and signal B decay • Efficiency of 1%.
Recommended publications
  • Three Lectures on Meson Mixing and CKM Phenomenology
    Three Lectures on Meson Mixing and CKM phenomenology Ulrich Nierste Institut f¨ur Theoretische Teilchenphysik Universit¨at Karlsruhe Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, D-76128 Karlsruhe, Germany I give an introduction to the theory of meson-antimeson mixing, aiming at students who plan to work at a flavour physics experiment or intend to do associated theoretical studies. I derive the formulae for the time evolution of a neutral meson system and show how the mass and width differences among the neutral meson eigenstates and the CP phase in mixing are calculated in the Standard Model. Special emphasis is laid on CP violation, which is covered in detail for K−K mixing, Bd−Bd mixing and Bs−Bs mixing. I explain the constraints on the apex (ρ, η) of the unitarity triangle implied by ǫK ,∆MBd ,∆MBd /∆MBs and various mixing-induced CP asymmetries such as aCP(Bd → J/ψKshort)(t). The impact of a future measurement of CP violation in flavour-specific Bd decays is also shown. 1 First lecture: A big-brush picture 1.1 Mesons, quarks and box diagrams The neutral K, D, Bd and Bs mesons are the only hadrons which mix with their antiparticles. These meson states are flavour eigenstates and the corresponding antimesons K, D, Bd and Bs have opposite flavour quantum numbers: K sd, D cu, B bd, B bs, ∼ ∼ d ∼ s ∼ K sd, D cu, B bd, B bs, (1) ∼ ∼ d ∼ s ∼ Here for example “Bs bs” means that the Bs meson has the same flavour quantum numbers as the quark pair (b,s), i.e.∼ the beauty and strangeness quantum numbers are B = 1 and S = 1, respectively.
    [Show full text]
  • Strong Coupling Constants of the Doubly Heavy $\Xi {QQ} $ Baryons
    Strong Coupling Constants of the Doubly Heavy ΞQQ Baryons with π Meson A. R. Olamaei1,4, K. Azizi2,3,4, S. Rostami5 1 Department of Physics, Jahrom University, Jahrom, P. O. Box 74137-66171, Iran 2 Department of Physics, University of Tehran, North Karegar Ave. Tehran 14395-547, Iran 3 Department of Physics, Doˇgu¸sUniversity, Acibadem-Kadik¨oy, 34722 Istanbul, Turkey 4 School of Particles and Accelerators, Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences (IPM), P. O. Box 19395-5531, Tehran, Iran 5 Department of Physics, Shahid Rajaee Teacher Training University, Lavizan, Tehran 16788, Iran Abstract ++ The doubly charmed Ξcc (ccu) state is the only listed baryon in PDG, which was discovered in the experiment. The LHCb collaboration gets closer to dis- + covering the second doubly charmed baryon Ξcc(ccd), hence the investigation of the doubly charmed/bottom baryons from many aspects is of great importance that may help us not only get valuable knowledge on the nature of the newly discovered states, but also in the search for other members of the doubly heavy baryons predicted by the quark model. In this context, we investigate the strong +(+) 0(±) coupling constants among the Ξcc baryons and π mesons by means of light cone QCD sum rule. Using the general forms of the interpolating currents of the +(+) Ξcc baryons and the distribution amplitudes (DAs) of the π meson, we extract the values of the coupling constants gΞccΞccπ. We extend our analyses to calculate the strong coupling constants among the partner baryons with π mesons, as well, and extract the values of the strong couplings gΞbbΞbbπ and gΞbcΞbcπ.
    [Show full text]
  • Search for Non Standard Model Higgs Boson
    Thirteenth Conference on the Intersections of Particle and Nuclear Physics May 29 – June 3, 2018 Palm Springs, CA Search for Non Standard Model Higgs Boson Ana Elena Dumitriu (IFIN-HH, CPPM), On behalf of the ATLAS Collaboration 5/18/18 1 Introduction and Motivation ● The discovery of the Higgs (125 GeV) by ATLAS and CMS collaborations → great success of particle physics and especially Standard Model (SM) ● However.... – MORE ROOM Hierarchy problem FOR HIGGS PHYSICS – Origin of dark matter, dark energy BEYOND SM – Baryon Asymmetry – Gravity – Higgs br to Beyond Standard Model (BSM) particles of BRBSM < 32% at 95% C.L. ● !!!!!!There is plenty of room for Higgs physics beyond the Standard Model. ● There are several theoretical models with an extended Higgs sector. – 2 Higgs Doublet Models (2HDM). Having two complex scalar SU(2) doublets, they are an effective extension of the SM. In total, 5 different Higgs bosons are predicted: two CP even and one CP odd electrically neutral Higgs bosons, denoted by h, H, and A, respectively, and two charged Higgs bosons, H±. The parameters used to describe a 2HDM are the Higgs boson masses and the ratios of their vacuum expectation values. ● type I, where one SU(2) doublet gives masses to all leptons and quarks and the other doublet essentially decouples from fermions ● type II, where one doublet gives mass to up-like quarks (and potentially neutrinos) and the down-type quarks and leptons receive mass from the other doublet. – Supersymmetry (SUSY), which brings along super-partners of the SM particles. The Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM), whose Higgs sector is equivalent to the one of a constrained 2HDM of type II and the next-to MSSM (NMSSM) are among the experimentally best tested models, because they provide good benchmarks for SUSY.
    [Show full text]
  • Physics with B-Mesons in ATLAS
    Physics with B-mesons in ATLAS Lidia Smirnova1, Alexey Boldyrev, on behalf of the ATLAS Collaboration* *Moscow State University , E-mail: [email protected], [email protected] Abstract B-physics is an important part of studies with the LHC beams at low luminosities. Ef- fective B-meson reconstruction in ATLAS can produce a clean sample of events for detailed physics analysis with first data. The analysis includes measurements of B-meson masses and proper lifetimes to verify the performance of the Inner Detector, and to estimate back- grounds and trigger efficiencies for rare decays. ATL-PHYS-PROC-2009-135 23 November 2009 XXXIX International Symposium on Multiparticle Dynamics 4-9 September 2009 Gomel Region Belarus 1Speaker 1 Introduction B-physics is one of the important fields that can be studied with the first ATLAS data. Until now the in- formation about B-meson production come from B-factories, high-energy electron-positron and electron- proton colliders and proton-antiproton colliders. The proton-proton collisions at the LHC will be the next step in studies of B-meson production in hadron interactions with large b-quark production cross section and high luminosity. The ATLAS experiment will be able to reconstruct exclusive B-meson decays. After the introduction, section two describes briefly the ATLAS detector and triggers, relevant for B- physics, with stress on di-muon channels. Reconstruction of inclusive J=y! mm decays and separation of J=y from direct and indirect (B-hadrons) production mechanisms are discussed. The efficiency of B+-meson reconstruction with B+ ! J=yK+ decay mode is presented.
    [Show full text]
  • 1. Introduction
    EXPERIMENTAL ASPECTS OF B PHYSICS * Persis S. Drell Laboratory of Nuclear Studies Cornell University Ithaca, NY 14853 1. Introduction The first experimental evidence for the existence of the b quark came in 1977 from an experiment at FNAL”’ in which high energy protons were scattered off of hadronic targets. A broad resonance, shown in Fig. 1, was observed in the plot of the invariant mass of muon pairs seen in a double armed spectrometer. The width of the resonance was greater than the energy resolution of the apparatus and the data were interpreted as the three lowest lying quark anti-quark bound states of a new quark flavor: b flavor, which stands for either beauty or bottom. These bb bound states were called the f, Y’, and Y”. When the & bound state, the J/qb, was discovered, it was found simulta- neously in proton-nucleus collisions at Brookhaven IN and at SPEAR’“’ in e+e- collisions. However, it took a year for the e+e- storage ring, DORIS, to confirm the f discovery:’ and it was still 2 years later that the then new e+e- storage ring at Cornell, CESR, also observed the Y(lS), T’(2S), T”(3.57 states and dis- covered a fourth state, T”‘(4S)!“] Both storage rings were easily able to resolve the states of the Upsilon system. Figure 2 shows the observed cross section at CESR versus energy in the Upsilon region, and although the apparent width of the 3 lower lying resonances is due to the machine energy spread, the true width and the leptonic width of the T could be inferred from the peak cross section and the leptonic branching ratio!’ The leptonic width is proportional to the square of the quark charges inside the Upsilon and the b quark was inferred to have charge l/3.
    [Show full text]
  • B Meson Decays Marina Artuso1, Elisabetta Barberio2 and Sheldon Stone*1
    Review Open Access B meson decays Marina Artuso1, Elisabetta Barberio2 and Sheldon Stone*1 Address: 1Department of Physics, Syracuse University, Syracuse, NY 13244, USA and 2School of Physics, University of Melbourne, Victoria 3010, Australia Email: Marina Artuso - [email protected]; Elisabetta Barberio - [email protected]; Sheldon Stone* - [email protected] * Corresponding author Published: 20 February 2009 Received: 20 February 2009 Accepted: 20 February 2009 PMC Physics A 2009, 3:3 doi:10.1186/1754-0410-3-3 This article is available from: http://www.physmathcentral.com/1754-0410/3/3 © 2009 Stone et al This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/ licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. Abstract We discuss the most important Physics thus far extracted from studies of B meson decays. Measurements of the four CP violating angles accessible in B decay are reviewed as well as direct CP violation. A detailed discussion of the measurements of the CKM elements Vcb and Vub from semileptonic decays is given, and the differences between resulting values using inclusive decays versus exclusive decays is discussed. Measurements of "rare" decays are also reviewed. We point out where CP violating and rare decays could lead to observations of physics beyond that of the Standard Model in future experiments. If such physics is found by directly observation of new particles, e.g. in LHC experiments, B decays can play a decisive role in interpreting the nature of these particles.
    [Show full text]
  • Kaons in Flavor Tagged B Meson Decays
    Kaons in Flavor Tagged B Meson Decays by Henric Ivar Cronström A Thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Technology at the University of Lund Elementary Particle Physics Department of Physics University of Lund <&Corrri|kl \i HXCfMiltia OcKfctr Jl, 1MI Kaons in Flavor Tagged B Meson Decays by Henric Ivar Cronström Civilingenjör / Master of Science Lund October 29, 1991 ISBN 91-628-0454-5 Document name LUND UNIVERSITY DOCTORAL DLSSERTATION Department of I'hysics Date of issue Oct 31, 1991 University of Lumi, Sölvcgatan S-223 62 Lund, SWEDEN CODEN: u)NFD6/(NFFL-7066) 1991 Authors) Sponsoring organisation llcnric Ivar Cronström Title and subtitle Kaons in Flavor Tagged B Meson Decays Abstract Using the ARGUS detector at the e e storage ring DORIS II, measurements of multiplicities of pseudoscalar kaons, of K'"'(892) and of ^(1020) in B meson decays have been performed through studies of angular and charge correlations between the above particles and high momentum leptons produced in semileptonic B decays. The method has made it possible to measure the multiplicities separately for B- mesons and anti-B-mesons. The excess of like charge lepton-kaon pairs over opposite charge pairs in semilepto- nic decays was used for estimating the ratio of charmed decays over all decays, and thus also the fraction of charmless decays. A search for an excess of fast neutral kaons from rare B decays was also made. All the results obtained support the assumption that almost all B mesons decay through b -> c transitions into charmed hadrons.
    [Show full text]
  • Masses of Scalar and Axial-Vector B Mesons Revisited
    Eur. Phys. J. C (2017) 77:668 DOI 10.1140/epjc/s10052-017-5252-4 Regular Article - Theoretical Physics Masses of scalar and axial-vector B mesons revisited Hai-Yang Cheng1, Fu-Sheng Yu2,a 1 Institute of Physics, Academia Sinica, Taipei 115, Taiwan, Republic of China 2 School of Nuclear Science and Technology, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou 730000, People’s Republic of China Received: 2 August 2017 / Accepted: 22 September 2017 / Published online: 7 October 2017 © The Author(s) 2017. This article is an open access publication Abstract The SU(3) quark model encounters a great chal- 1 Introduction lenge in describing even-parity mesons. Specifically, the qq¯ quark model has difficulties in understanding the light Although the SU(3) quark model has been applied success- scalar mesons below 1 GeV, scalar and axial-vector charmed fully to describe the properties of hadrons such as pseu- mesons and 1+ charmonium-like state X(3872). A common doscalar and vector mesons, octet and decuplet baryons, it wisdom for the resolution of these difficulties lies on the often encounters a great challenge in understanding even- coupled channel effects which will distort the quark model parity mesons, especially scalar ones. Take vector mesons as calculations. In this work, we focus on the near mass degen- an example and consider the octet vector ones: ρ,ω, K ∗,φ. ∗ ∗0 eracy of scalar charmed mesons, Ds0 and D0 , and its impli- Since the constituent strange quark is heavier than the up or cations. Within the framework of heavy meson chiral pertur- down quark by 150 MeV, one will expect the mass hierarchy bation theory, we show that near degeneracy can be quali- pattern mφ > m K ∗ > mρ ∼ mω, which is borne out by tatively understood as a consequence of self-energy effects experiment.
    [Show full text]
  • Measurement of B Meson Production Cross-Sections in Proton-Proton
    EUROPEAN ORGANIZATION FOR NUCLEAR RESEARCH (CERN) CERN-PH-EP-2013-095 LHCb-PAPER-2013-004 Oct. 1, 2013 Measurement of B meson production cross-sections inp proton-proton collisions at s = 7 TeV The LHCb collaborationy Abstract The production cross-sections of B mesons are measured in pp collisions at a centre-of- mass energy of 7 TeV, using data collected with the LHCb detector corresponding to −1 + 0 0 a integrated luminosity of 0:36 fb . The B , B and Bs mesons are reconstructed + + 0 ∗0 0 in the exclusive decays B ! J= K , B ! J= K and Bs ! J= φ, with J= ! µ+µ−, K∗0 ! K+π− and φ ! K+K−. The differential cross-sections are measured as functions of B meson transverse momentum pT and rapidity y, in the range 0 < pT < 40 GeV=c and 2:0 < y < 4:5. The integrated cross-sections in the same pT and y ranges, including charge-conjugate states, are measured to be σ(pp ! B+ + X) = 38:9 ± 0:3 (stat:) ± 2:5 (syst:) ± 1:3 (norm:) µb; σ(pp ! B0 + X) = 38:1 ± 0:6 (stat:) ± 3:7 (syst:) ± 4:7 (norm:) µb; 0 σ(pp ! Bs + X) = 10:5 ± 0:2 (stat:) ± 0:8 (syst:) ± 1:0 (norm:) µb; arXiv:1306.3663v2 [hep-ex] 1 Oct 2013 where the third uncertainty arises from the pre-existing branching fraction measure- ments. Submitted to JHEP c CERN on behalf of the LHCb collaboration, license CC-BY-3.0. yAuthors are listed on the following pages. ii LHCb collaboration R.
    [Show full text]
  • Arxiv:1606.09602V2 [Hep-Ph] 22 Jul 2016
    Baryons as relativistic three-quark bound states Gernot Eichmanna,1, Hèlios Sanchis-Alepuzb,3, Richard Williamsa,2, Reinhard Alkoferb,4, Christian S. Fischera,c,5 aInstitut für Theoretische Physik, Justus-Liebig–Universität Giessen, 35392 Giessen, Germany bInstitute of Physics, NAWI Graz, University of Graz, Universitätsplatz 5, 8010 Graz, Austria cHIC for FAIR Giessen, 35392 Giessen, Germany Abstract We review the spectrum and electromagnetic properties of baryons described as relativistic three-quark bound states within QCD. The composite nature of baryons results in a rich excitation spectrum, whilst leading to highly non-trivial structural properties explored by the coupling to external (electromagnetic and other) cur- rents. Both present many unsolved problems despite decades of experimental and theoretical research. We discuss the progress in these fields from a theoretical perspective, focusing on nonperturbative QCD as encoded in the functional approach via Dyson-Schwinger and Bethe-Salpeter equations. We give a systematic overview as to how results are obtained in this framework and explain technical connections to lattice QCD. We also discuss the mutual relations to the quark model, which still serves as a reference to distinguish ‘expected’ from ‘unexpected’ physics. We confront recent results on the spectrum of non-strange and strange baryons, their form factors and the issues of two-photon processes and Compton scattering determined in the Dyson- Schwinger framework with those of lattice QCD and the available experimental data. The general aim is to identify the underlying physical mechanisms behind the plethora of observable phenomena in terms of the underlying quark and gluon degrees of freedom. Keywords: Baryon properties, Nucleon resonances, Form factors, Compton scattering, Dyson-Schwinger approach, Bethe-Salpeter/Faddeev equations, Quark-diquark model arXiv:1606.09602v2 [hep-ph] 22 Jul 2016 [email protected] [email protected].
    [Show full text]
  • ELEMENTARY PARTICLES in PHYSICS 1 Elementary Particles in Physics S
    ELEMENTARY PARTICLES IN PHYSICS 1 Elementary Particles in Physics S. Gasiorowicz and P. Langacker Elementary-particle physics deals with the fundamental constituents of mat- ter and their interactions. In the past several decades an enormous amount of experimental information has been accumulated, and many patterns and sys- tematic features have been observed. Highly successful mathematical theories of the electromagnetic, weak, and strong interactions have been devised and tested. These theories, which are collectively known as the standard model, are almost certainly the correct description of Nature, to first approximation, down to a distance scale 1/1000th the size of the atomic nucleus. There are also spec- ulative but encouraging developments in the attempt to unify these interactions into a simple underlying framework, and even to incorporate quantum gravity in a parameter-free “theory of everything.” In this article we shall attempt to highlight the ways in which information has been organized, and to sketch the outlines of the standard model and its possible extensions. Classification of Particles The particles that have been identified in high-energy experiments fall into dis- tinct classes. There are the leptons (see Electron, Leptons, Neutrino, Muonium), 1 all of which have spin 2 . They may be charged or neutral. The charged lep- tons have electromagnetic as well as weak interactions; the neutral ones only interact weakly. There are three well-defined lepton pairs, the electron (e−) and − the electron neutrino (νe), the muon (µ ) and the muon neutrino (νµ), and the (much heavier) charged lepton, the tau (τ), and its tau neutrino (ντ ). These particles all have antiparticles, in accordance with the predictions of relativistic quantum mechanics (see CPT Theorem).
    [Show full text]
  • The Quark Model and Deep Inelastic Scattering
    The quark model and deep inelastic scattering Contents 1 Introduction 2 1.1 Pions . 2 1.2 Baryon number conservation . 3 1.3 Delta baryons . 3 2 Linear Accelerators 4 3 Symmetries 5 3.1 Baryons . 5 3.2 Mesons . 6 3.3 Quark flow diagrams . 7 3.4 Strangeness . 8 3.5 Pseudoscalar octet . 9 3.6 Baryon octet . 9 4 Colour 10 5 Heavier quarks 13 6 Charmonium 14 7 Hadron decays 16 Appendices 18 .A Isospin x 18 .B Discovery of the Omega x 19 1 The quark model and deep inelastic scattering 1 Symmetry, patterns and substructure The proton and the neutron have rather similar masses. They are distinguished from 2 one another by at least their different electromagnetic interactions, since the proton mp = 938:3 MeV=c is charged, while the neutron is electrically neutral, but they have identical properties 2 mn = 939:6 MeV=c under the strong interaction. This provokes the question as to whether the proton and neutron might have some sort of common substructure. The substructure hypothesis can be investigated by searching for other similar patterns of multiplets of particles. There exists a zoo of other strongly-interacting particles. Exotic particles are ob- served coming from the upper atmosphere in cosmic rays. They can also be created in the labortatory, provided that we can create beams of sufficient energy. The Quark Model allows us to apply a classification to those many strongly interacting states, and to understand the constituents from which they are made. 1.1 Pions The lightest strongly interacting particles are the pions (π).
    [Show full text]