Dear Sarah, thank you for the transcript, I have agreed to table certain documents during the course of the hearing. I'm currently in the Kimberley and will table some documents from here and Emily Peters from my office in Perth will send you the relevant Burrup Maitland Industrial Estates Agreements from my office in Perth.

The first documents I present are the ACMC minutes of 18 December 2013, I am providing you with two copies of the minutes as they seem to differ. The first copy “23. Extract ACMC minutes” was provided to the Australian newspaper after a request under FOI the second copy “ACMC minutes 18 December 2013” comes from my personal records of a tabled paper provided to me in response to a question on notice to the Minister a number of years ago.

When it comes to resolution 2013/199 they are identical in respect of Hamersley Iron Pty Limited - Development of Pit One at the Brockman 4 mine – A portion of mining lease AML70/00004, located approximately 65km west of Tom Price (13/0767).

I can't for the life of me work out why different information is contained within both minutes from the same day on the same issue and you will note that redacted version has page numbering that is inconsistent with the version that I was supplied with a number of years ago which does not have page numbering. The redacted version has the chair noting that he contained a small shareholding in CRA () and yet the earlier version did not mention this, so which one was correct.

You will note that the consent with conditions contained within the ministerial decisions June 2011 to December 2015 identifies that the Minister agreed with the ACMC decision of the 18th on 31 December 2013. (ACMC Ministerial decisions downloaded from the department's website)

Also you will note in DOC210920-21092020121259 (tabled paper in the Legislative Council of Western ) that Gavin Fielding consistently declared interests in BHP and Rio Tinto as his family either held shares or worked for a subsidiary of Rio Tinto.

All the best

Robin Chapple MLC Member for the Mining and Pastoral Region in the Western Australian Legislative Council