The Famous Mather Byles

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Famous Mather Byles THE FAMO US MATHER BYLES THE NOTED BOSTON TORY PREACHER P D OET, AN WIT 1 707-1 788 ARTHUR WENTWORTH HAMILTON ILLUSTRATED WITH um ENGRAVINGS F RO" ORIGINAL P BY OPLEY T H P I-R A MS A INTING S C , E E AND O TBRRB BOSTON W . A . BUTTERFIELD 1 91 4 CO NTENTS THE FAMOUS MATHER BTLES D T N BIRTH, E UCA IO , JO URNALISTIC WRITINGS ORDINATIO N AND FIRST MARRIAGE EVENTS IN EARLIER MINISTRY PASTORATE AT HO LLIS STREET CHURCH DO C TO R BYLmAS A PO ET ’ DO CTO R BTLmS HUMO UR D ISMISSAL FRO MHIS CHURCH TRIA L BEFO RE THE TOW N SOCIA L STANDING . FRIENDSHIPB LAST YEARS THE BYLES FAMILY NOTES CHIET PUBLISHED WRITINGS MANUSCRIPT LETTERS INDEX ILLUSTRATIO NS Dr Math r B l . e y es Frontispieoe Fro mthe o ri inal aintin le g p g by Co p y. 1 774, in he ssession of illiamB lmn t o W ru A o . ce Es M . p . q , D N FAG! PLO. v n a Mather Re . I cre se Fromthe o ri inal aintin b Vander r e g p g y sp i t. 1 088. in the possession of the Massachusetts Historical Society. n Mather b eter ha v . tt o el m Re Co , y P P ravin Froman eng g by Peter Pelham. nc ons than Belcher b R His Excelle y J , y . Phillips m m in n Fro a en ot t e graving by Faber. Province Ho use ma drawin . P. Fro g by M Kenway. B l Dr. Mather y es romthe o ri inal aintin Peter Pelham F g p g by . in e ion of Mr. eri a the poss ss Fred ck Lew is G y. Hollis St . Church ’ Fro mBonner s ma of Boston 1 709. p . mas Hollis b James Hi hmore Tho , y g Alexander Pope. by Arthur Pond Froman w a ving by Houbrsken. Dr. Iss ac Watts Froman w n i b h o tter 1 788. a ng y . n A Cano o f 6, words by Dr. Byles ro tbe l S ur h F m o tbe HoliS t . 1 Recordn l Ch c . 770. Tho mas Prince b ohn G Rev . y J reenwood l . Frommmp aving by T . B. We ch Dr. Mather Byles mthe r inal aintin b o le 1 707 in the Fro o ig p g y C p y. n r i a . possessio of Mr. Me ick Lew s G y Mather B les Jr. Rev . y . Froman originalpainfing in the posaealion olllr. Frederick le wis Gs y. P Fro mtbe originalpsinting by Henry elham. View of Bosto n Co mmon l ll 1 780. Frommengn ving by Samue Hi . THE FAMOUS MATHER BYLES CHAPTER I THE FAMOUS MATHER BYLEB FROMthe shadows Of pre-Revolutionary Boston no single figure emerges in whom sympathetic historians find a greater variety Of interest than in the Tory re her h ris ho a p ac , poet, and umou t, w p pears commonly in o ur annals as the ” “ ” famous o r celebrated Doctor Mather Byles . In days when religious discus sion w as acrid and local political feeling ran high and vituperation o f opponents ’ was en in r i i r h B les s Oft c ed bly b tte , Mat er y witticisms kept Boston laughing im der i n mo ately fo r at least a generat on, a d no doubt tended no t a little t o the soften in ri i s in h r i d g of aspe t e t e popula l fe, an a l 2 THE FAMOUS MATHER BYLES ’ it is naturally as o ne of New England s earliest humourists that Byles has been most conspicuously mentioned in periodicals d an books . But the man has an interest “ ” i e ne far w d r than that of a punning divi , the age through which he lived w as the most dramatic in o ur annals and his o wn life lacks no single element that gives the i i r en hi e e n t me p ctu esqu ess, w l th aloof ess from politics he persistently maintained puts himout of the category of those who in the fierce Revolutionary struggle actively helped or hindered the great cause to which the majority of his fellow townsmen gave h ir e r t e ard nt suppo t . That no o ne has hitherto taken the trouble to write the life of Mather Byles He nds n is no t strange. was a gra o of h n Mh r Increase and a nep ew of Cotto at e , r i n i i i and his st ik ng perso al ty , h s keen ntel i h r r in i e lectual g fts , and is p olific w it gs g v hima worthy place beside those remarkable me h i ed hr h the Revo lu n, but e l v t oug THE FAMOUS MATHER BYLES 8 tion and in that momentous conflict gave he in countenance to t los g side, and among the Congregational ministers o f New Eng n ith the a ri s ener la d , as w P t ot g ally, he r hi i n stood for the est Of s l fe, a d his name continued to stand when he w as n i dead , as a syno ym fo r d sloyalty and r h r h as ind . t eac e y Of t e b est k Moreover, at the evacuation Of Boston his only living s n Mh r e i r e o , at e Byl s, Jun o , w nt to Halifax ’ e nd in t e with Howe s fl et, a h Anglican r t . in h n n chu ch Of S Paul t at tow , a d in ri h r h . hn T nity C u c , St Jo , New Bruns wick, later, pursued the ministry which he had previously exercised at Christ h r h s n and hen h i C u c , Bo to , w e d ed , all his des endan s ere i i c t w l v ng, as most o f in them have s ce lived , under the British fl ag. Mather Byles has lately been brought r nd i before us pictu esquely, a probably n n r a rather truthful w ay, i that cha ming r h h imaginative brochu e, that as ad wide 4 THE FAMOUS MATHER BYLES ’ re in r er i ad g, Ea l P cy s D nner Table. I ha e fin im n n t t book, w d h duri g the i e n n s eg of Bosto , amo g British Officers in s ar e ni an d or in c l t tu cs d gol lace, the blue ’ ni r s Hi M u fo m of s ajesty s Royal Navy, and rich gentlemen merchants of the town in si and n lk brocade, in velvet a d lace, ie enan - e in i L ut t Colon l John Gunn g, Franc s ’ o r n n L d Rawdon ; Lo rd Holla d s son, Ho . e r rd in e H n y Edwa Fox, Capta Evelyn of th ’ in i K g s Own, the young Cuthbert Coll ng i n wood , Major John Pitca rn, Colo el Isaac ff i in is Royal , and Roger Shea e s pp g h n r n in port, a d th owi g the company to fits “ of laughter by his witty sallies o n the holy hypocrisy which is ruining the prov in r ce, o r o n much less impo tant personal ’ he e E r n t m s . But a l Percy s Din er Table is only the latest writing in which Doctor Byles figures: no faithful chronicler of Rev “ o lutionary Boston but exploits his per ” “ ” is n r i r i r i i s te t To y sm , o h s irrep ess ble w t , and no conscientious reviewer of early New THE FAMOUS MATHER BYLES 5 England literature but has something to say about the poetry and the published dis courses Of this brilliant descendant Of the a M rs n n f mous athe , a d e thusiastic disciple h of t e poet Pope. For more than forty years Doctor Byles ’ w as the faithful pastor Of Boston s Hollis e i h an i Str et Congregat onal C urch , d h s i h n striking g fts as a preac er, a d the close relationship he bore t o the Mathers and n himan i r n re in Cotto s, make mpo ta t figu New England ecclesiastical annals . But he w as besides a literary man Of much i i E ab l ty, and reviewers Of early New ng and r n i n l p ose a d poetry, wh le o t always enthusiastic in praise Of his literary pro du i r i ed a e e ct ons, have neve fa l to t k r spect ful notice Of his work .
Recommended publications
  • Genealogy of the Mather Family : from About 1500 to 1847 ; with Sundry Biographical Notices
    ^ cP -p ^ ^..7.mr,vr,i The iihovp is 3^ fuc s-imile of the Arms of the Mathf.r Familv originally of Lancashire in England, which was gnnited l.y itif I'.ng. lish Crown, Feb. Uth, 1575, in consequence, as is siipjtostd. of some meritorious conduct on the part of some member of tlio family, the history of which has never been handed down. Ir is pr..>);tbif that many of the descendants are not aware of its existence, anil we now present it as a matter that will be likely to interest tiie reader of rh following paaes. Till': AI'I'lHUl j-MaTWi!', JdVinJ -^ GENEALOGY OF THE MATHER FAMILY, About 1500 to 1847; WITH SUNDRY BIOGRAPHICAL NOTICES. -i^^M-g 6 Thou hast given a Banner to them that fear thee, that it may be displayed because of the truth. — Psalms Ix. 4, HAR^T^rORD. PRESS CF;ERrHV jSEER,, 1 ST.iJE STFEET. MDCCCXLYIII. I -r-csr/ PREFACE The writer of the following pages, containing the Gene- alogy of the Mather family, has endeavored to make it as complete as possible, and with that view has devoted much time and labor, in searching the ancient family records, and in carryingon a protracted correspondence with the dif- ferent branches of the family located in various parts of the country. He believes it to be the most particular and full account of the family that has been published, and he wishes to embrace this opportunity to tender his thanks to those individuals who have felt sufficient interest in this work to give the author the benefit of their advice and knowledge.
    [Show full text]
  • An Account of the Mather-Byles Portraits by John H
    1923.] A.n Account of Mather-Byles Portraits 285 AN ACCOUNT OF THE MATHER-BYLES PORTRAITS BY JOHN H. EDMONDS HE gift of Mrs. Frederick Lewis Gay consists of T five portraits purchased by our late associate, Frederick Lewis Gay, from the estate of Hon. Mather Byles Des Brisay of Bridgewater, N. S., at Libbie's, April 4, 1908. For years, in conjunction with Mr. Goodspeed, he had been watching these very portraits, and he was surprised indeed when, on returning from Libbie's in a search for other Byles material some months before the sale, I informed him that I had seen the portraits so long sought. Because Boston dealers and collectors knew so little of this group of paintings and they were in bad condi- tion from exposure to fire and smoke, Mr. Goodspeed secured them for Mr. Gay, with very little competition, inside of ten minutes, the only serious bidding being for Copley's Mather Byles. The condition of the portraits as shown in Libbie's sale catalogue and their condition today is an interesting study of restoration properly done. Shortly after they came into Mr. Gay's possession they were turned over to Messrs. Allerton and Thompson of the Museum of Fine Arts, and the result is plainly evident. The portraits are as follows: Rev. Cotton Mather (1727) and Rev. Mather Byles (1739), by Peter Pel- ham; Rev. Mather Byles (1767), by John Singleton Copley; Rev. Mather Byles, Jr., (1784), by Mather Brown; and a self-portrait of Mather Brown (1812). Rev. Cotton Mather, 1663-1728, son of Increase Mather, one of the most famous of the early American theologians and Fellow of the Royal Society, wrote at 286 American Antiquarian Society [Oct., least 465 books and tracts that not only were published but read.
    [Show full text]
  • Prosecution and Persecution for Concealment in Puritan Massachusetts
    University of Louisville ThinkIR: The University of Louisville's Institutional Repository Electronic Theses and Dissertations 5-2019 Vile transgressor of the womb : prosecution and persecution for concealment in Puritan Massachusetts. Jennifer White University of Louisville Follow this and additional works at: https://ir.library.louisville.edu/etd Part of the Women's Studies Commons Recommended Citation White, Jennifer, "Vile transgressor of the womb : prosecution and persecution for concealment in Puritan Massachusetts." (2019). Electronic Theses and Dissertations. Paper 3142. https://doi.org/10.18297/etd/3142 This Doctoral Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by ThinkIR: The nivU ersity of Louisville's Institutional Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of ThinkIR: The nivU ersity of Louisville's Institutional Repository. This title appears here courtesy of the author, who has retained all other copyrights. For more information, please contact [email protected]. VILE TRANSGRESSOR OF THE WOMB: PROSECUTION AND PERSECUTION FOR CONCEALMENT IN PURITAN MASSACHUSETTS By Jennifer White B.A., SUNY Potsdam, 2004 M.A., University of Louisville, 2010 A Dissertation Submitted to the Faculty of the College of Arts and Sciences of the University of Louisville in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy In Humanities Department of Comparative Humanities University of Louisville Louisville, Kentucky May 2019 VILE TRANSGRESSOR OF THE WOMB: PROSECUTION AND PERSECUTION FOR CONCEALMENT IN PURITAN MASSACHUSETTS By Jennifer White B.A., SUNY Potsdam, 2004 M.A., University of Louisville, 2010 A Dissertation Approved on December 3, 2018 by the following Dissertation Committee _____________________________________ Dissertation Director Nancy M.
    [Show full text]
  • Mather Byles, the Rogerenes, and the Quest for Religious Order in Late Colonial New England
    ABSTRACT NO PEACE IN NEW LONDON: MATHER BYLES, THE ROGERENES, AND THE QUEST FOR RELIGIOUS ORDER IN LATE COLONIAL NEW ENGLAND by Jonathan Blake Vaughan In April, 1768 Congregational minister Mather Byles abruptly left his parishioners in New London, Connecticut and converted to the Church of England. Even though Anglicanism had been marginal in colonial New England, Byles joined a growing number of “apostates” who abandoned Congregational orthodoxy for the sense of order and stability afforded by the official church of imperial Britain. Byles stated that among his primary reasons for leaving New London and Congregationalism were the incessant conflicts that arose between him and the religious dissenters known as the Rogerenes. This thesis narrates the conflict between Byles and the followers of John Rogers—a little known series of incidents that occurred during Byles’s tenure in New London—as well as Byles’s subsequent reassessment of the viability of the New England Way and conversion to the Church of England. NO PEACE IN NEW LONDON: MATHER BYLES, THE ROGERENES, AND THE QUEST FOR RELIGIOUS ORDER IN LATE COLONIAL NEW ENGLAND A Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of Miami University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Department of History by Jonathan Blake Vaughan Miami University Oxford, Ohio 2009 Advisor__________________ Carla Gardina Pestana Reader___________________ Andrew R. L. Cayton Reader___________________ P. Renée Baernstein Table of Contents Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 1 Chapter 1: Land of Steady Habits? ..................................................................................... 6 Chapter 2: From Bliss to Crisis: Mather Byles’s New London Ministry ......................... 21 Chapter 3: A Congregational Loss—An Anglican Gain .................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Observations on the Winthrop, Bentley Thomas and 'Ex Dono' Collections of the Original Library of Allegheny College, 1819-1823
    Observations on the Winthrop, Bentley Thomas and 'Ex Dono' Collections of the Original Library of Allegheny College, 1819-1823, First listed by President Timothy Alden in Catalogus Bibliothecae Collegii Alleghaniensis, E Typis Thomae Atkinson Soc. apud Meadville. 1823. Edwin Wolf, 2nd Mr. Edwin Wolf, 2nd, Librarian of The Library Company of Philadelphia, was commissioned by Allegheny College to make a survey of the Original Library, March 6-16, 1962. Notes: Through his observations, Mr. Wolf uses the original spelling of the College's name: Alleghany. This document is a typed transcript of Mr. Wolf’s original work. Permission to publish this document has been granted by the Library Company of Philadelphia. Section V. General Remarks As I wrote, speaking of books in the Library Company which had belonged to famous Englishmen: "A provenance is at once a cachet of excellence and a sentimental link in a cultural chain which binds one age to another." The most exciting feature of the old library of Alleghany College lies in the distinguished early pedigrees of so many of the books which later came into the hands of the Winthrops and Bentley. The cachet of excellence was the ownership of individual volumes by successive generations of New Englanders. The sentimental link was one with Harvard, for nowhere outside the Boston area exists a larger accumulation of volumes which had once belonged to 17th and early 18th-century Harvard students, tutors and professors. In 1933 in the Transactions of the Colonial Society of Massachusetts, Arthur O. Norton published a monograph, the product of over twenty years' research, on "Harvard Text-Books and Reference Books of the Seventeenth Century." There he listed all the books formerly owned by 17th-century Harvard students which he had been able to find in such major collections as the American Antiquarian Society (82 volumes), Harvard College Library (76 volumes), Boston Public Library (48 volumes) and Massachusetts Historical Society (29 volumes), and a few others, 257 volumes in all.
    [Show full text]
  • Biographical Notices of Distinguished Men in New England
    BIOGRAPHICAL N OTICES DISTINGUISHED M EN NEW E NGLAND : Statesmen, f tgttioi$ \Phystciaas, -Lawyers, Clergymen ; jjid . Mccbaiiics. BY A IDEN BRADFORD, LL. D. Memberf o the Massachusetts Historical Society ; Corresponding Member of American H istorical Socioty ; of Hist. Soc. of New York, Peon., and G eorgia ; and of Nat. Int. of Science, at Washington. BOSTON: PUBLISHED A CCORDING TO ACT OF CONGRESS, BY. S G. SIMPKINS. J.. G Torrey, printer. 1842... ' ADVERTISEMENT. sIt i a natural and laudable desire to know the principles, character and- services of our ancestors. Curiosity may induce us to read the history of other countries, and to learn the customs, opinions and character of the inhabitants ; and some useful information maybe thus acquired; affording infor mation and admonitions, which merit attention for the conduct of life. But a knowledge of the princi ples and chataEHter.t>f'.q,ur*.ajic.estefSi by whose insti- tutions, literary-, polrtidal, STrtd rdtgODUs, the present and coming generations: jo'Ja great measure, af fected, or to b.e "a'flfecTed}* "is fur more important. Changes in socieCy; ."WtK j»;yiejv to improvement, may be expected ; for mankind do not long pause at the point already reached. The great aim of human effort is progress — and yet a reference to the con dition and state of former generations may fur nish lessons for good, to a subsequent one. In the present volume, the desire has been to give the char acter and state the opinions and services of the pat riots of the Revolution, as well as of the original founders of New England ; some of the most dis tinguished Clergymen in every period of its history: and of men in more private life, who, by their writings or inventions, have been useful in the Commonwealth.
    [Show full text]
  • The Life and Works of John Singleton Copley, Founded on the Work Of
    I JOHN SINGLETON COPLEY FROM THE ORIGINAL PAINTING BY COPLEY IN THE NEW YORK HISTORICAL SOCIETY THE LIFE AND WORKS of JOHN SINGLETON COPLEY FOUNDED ON THE WORK OF AUGUSTUS THORNDIKE PERKINS By FRANK W. BAYLEY OF COPLEY GALLERY BOSTON, MASS. BOSTON THE TAYLOR PRESS 1915 - -. Preface The author of this memoir is an admirer of the work of John Singleton Copley and has for many years been familiar with his pictures. In the collec- tion of the data, the basis of effort was the admirable work performed by the late Augustus Thorndike Perkins and published privately by him in 1873, an<^ the author freely admits that his compilation of Copley's pictures has only been made possible by Mr. Perkins' efforts. The author desires to acknowl- edge his indebtedness to Mr. Frederic Amory, Mrs. W. Austin Wadsworth, Mr. Lawrence Park, Mr. Wor- thington C. Ford, Mr. Harcourt Amory, Mr. Charles Henry Hart, Lord Aberdare, and the many owners of Copley portraits who have allowed him to see them and who have assisted in correctly recording them. John Singleton Copley John Singleton Copley was the son of Richard Copley of County Limerick, Ireland, and Mary Singleton of County Clare, Ireland, descending from the Lancashire family of that name. Richard and his wife arrived in Boston in 1736 and the future artist was born July 3, 1737, the father dying on a trip to the West Indies soon after John was born. There is no evidence that Copley received any other education than that aiforded by the primitive schools of the time supplemented by the family tuition.
    [Show full text]