The Reform Club: Architecture and the Birth of Popular Government Transcript

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Reform Club: Architecture and the Birth of Popular Government Transcript The Reform Club: Architecture and the birth of popular government Transcript Date: Tuesday, 25 September 2007 - 12:00AM THE REFORM CLUB: ARCHITECTURE AND THE BIRTH OF POPULAR GOVERNMENT Peter Marsh It is a great honour to be asked to provide a short historical introduction to the existing work that Paul Vonberg is doing, designing and carrying through the renewal of the Reform Club building. The Reform Club, the building, is a great stage in the theatre of politics. It often reminds me when I am there of the opera houses built at the end of the Eighteenth or beginning of the Nineteenth Century to bring the affluent middle classes into what had hitherto been an aristocratic preserve. In the Great Hall of the Reform Club, merchants from Manchester could literally rub shoulders with Whig Dukes. No one who enters the Reform Club can mistake it for a setting for democracy. The Reform Club was founded as much to control as to promote the popular form of government to which the great Reform Act of 1832 gave rise. The great Reform Act was breathtakingly radical for its time, and it was breathtakingly radical in order to be the last Reform Act. Yet in no sense that it was the first - to think of that would be failure. It widened the franchise to embrace the whole of the propertied middle class, in an attempt to resist the demands of the Birmingham political union and leader of the Chartists for the enfranchisement of all adult males - no one was so daring as to think of women. I often think as I walk down New Hall Hill in Birmingham that is where the tens of thousands gathered in the autumn of 1831 and really intimidated Parliament into passing a radical reform act. They wanted more than they got. The founders of the Reform Club were the men responsible for the Reform Act. When you go into the Reform Club, you will see high up on the left Earl Grey, who was the Whig Prime Minister, that carried through the Reform Act. There he is, benignly overseeing the Reform Club. The founders of the Reform Club hoped at least to slow down, if not to stop, the march toward democracy. They shuddered at the handiwork of democracy, which they had seen in France, in revolutionary France, in the 1890s. That was back a bit, but in the 1830s, they were seeing the handiwork of democracy also in Jacksonian America. Andrew Jackson had been elected President of the United States in 1828, and immediately introduced, as a measure of democratisation, a spoils system which threw out of office all the well-qualified civil servants and installed in their place his partisan support, the less qualified the better for his purposes, because these were to be the real people. The British governing classes were horrified - Whig as well as Tory - horrified by the democracy that they saw as they were debating the Reform Act in 1832, which is indeed the year in which Jackson was re-elected. The Reform Club Building accordingly furnished to the newly formed Liberal Party in Parliament, and among the enlarged electorate. I will talk about the formation of the Liberal Party in a moment. But the facilities that the Club established were a large central hall where the Parliamentary Liberal Party could assemble, grand dining rooms, rooms for smaller meetings of Party members, and - this is very important - office space in the basement for the creation of a nationwide constituency organisation to register the Party's supporters as qualified under the terms of the 1983 Reform Act. In order to get a properties middle class electorate, you had to establish that they owned the requisite amount of property, and that involved, inevitably, solicitors. They would go over the electoral register, making sure that all the good Liberal supporters were kept on, and all of the benighted Conservatives were kicked off. That organisation was going on in the basement of the Reform Club, and a Library, a wonderful Library - still a wonderful Library - to inform and nourish parliamentary debate. Now, the Reform Club served these purposes well during the middle third of the Nineteenth Century, when the Liberal Party was nearly always in power. The Liberal Party was an alliance of aristocratic Whigs and the likes of Lord Grey, middle class merchants, members of the professions, and moderate Irish Nationalists. They governed Britain and the British Empire for most of the middle third of the Nineteenth Century. As a Canadian, I am continually reminded when I am at the Club of the ways in which those imperial responsibilities challenged and eventually shattered the Liberal alliance. Along, again, the left hand wall of the upper gallery of the Reform Club, there are two portraits: one of Lord Durham; and the other one of Lord Sidnam of Toronto, which is my home town. These are portraits that commemorate, that honour their work in bringing about what was called responsible government to upper and lower Canada. Responsible government simply meant that the executive of these colonies would have to be responsible to the majority of an elected legislature, and the elected legislature, in upper and lower Canada, would be all the adult males. So it was a genuinely democratic assembly that Lord Durham and Sidnam of Toronto were bringing into effect. However, the legislatures in both upper and lower Canada, challenged the Liberal assumptions of the politicians who had given them responsible government. They challenged it by immediately exercising their powers to impose protective tariffs against the goods coming in from the mother country. Now, if there was anything dearer to Liberals than a propertied middle class electorate, it was free trade. It is a classic question: what do you do when liberal institutions adopt illiberal policies? These radical Whigs were liberal enough to say, 'Well, the Canadians are benighted, they are wrong, but we have got to let them, we hope, find out the errors of their ways.' Canadians are very slow to do that. That was a real test of Liberal principles, to which the leaders of the Liberal Party rose triumphantly. But the Reform Club was not designed to cope with democracy on that Canadian scale, certainly not in Britain. The Liberal Party, and hence the Club, failed to accommodate themselves to the further enlargements of the electorate in the Second and Third Reform Acts of 1867 and 1884/5, which enfranchised a substantial proportion of the working class. Those acts unleashed electoral forces and passions which tore the Liberal Party, and hence the Reform Club, apart. They were epitomised by Joseph Chamberlain, not a landed gentleman - no one ever mistook him for that - but a screw manufacturer from metal manufacturing Birmingham. He took to public life in order, with some considerable high principle of a sort, to ensure the wealth that he got from his labour, as a big factory-owning capitalist manufacturer. So he wanted to protect that wealth by ensuring that its benefits were widely spread, but these are not the kinds of issues for which the Whigs of the 1830s, '40s, and '50s had much interest or capacity. Chamberlain, the formation of the National Liberal Party (again in Birmingham) in 1877, the radical programme that Joseph Chamberlain issued in 1883/84, and his unauthorised programme of 1884/5 really shook the Liberal Alliance badly. In the spring of 1884, he used the word 'ransom' - 'What ransom will property pay to ensure the perpetuation of its privileges?' - a word that shook the Whig assumptions of the Reform Club to its foundations. But it was the simultaneous challenge from Ireland that irrevocably split the Liberal Party and deprived the Reform Club of its political purpose. As you enter the Reform Club, to me, the strangest portrait in the whole building is on your immediate left, and it is Daniel O'Connell, the Liberator, there with his green sash. He was the most restless, unsettling of the founders of the Reform Club, but he was peace itself compared to the man who took over the leadership of the Irish in Parliament in the middle of the 1870s, Charles Stuart Parnell. It was he, with his uncompromising version of home rule that began the earthquake. In order to calm down the earthquake - never a very good tactic - Gladstone offered to give a very large measure of home rule to Ireland, and it was that that split the Liberal Party and split the Reform Club, depriving it of its political purpose. The Reform Club still served political purposes after its disruption, but those purposes were no longer clear. I came recently upon a bit of information about the Reform Club. In June of 1940 Neville Chamberlain had been thrown out as Prime Minister but still retained an important position really as the right hand man of Winston Churchill in the new Government. It was in the Reform Club that three men - Harold Macmillan, Leo Amery and Robert Boothby met, Conservatives all 'met nightly in June of 1940, plotting to see what they could do to throw Neville Chamberlain out of office completely. He was kept in, interestingly, at the insistence of Churchill. But that is a murky episode far from the broad sunny uplands of the middle of the Nineteenth Century, which were the glory days of the building about which Paul Vonberg is now going to speak. Paul Vonberg **Why would a group of men determined to give 'power to the people' build themselves a socking great palace like this? Because, as we've heard, the aims of the Club's founders, who were also the founders of the 'Great' Reform Act of 1832, were not quite as altruistic as one might have imagined, or as history has generally presented them.
Recommended publications
  • Summer Closure 2019 Members Are Asked to Note That the Club Will Close from 4Pm on Thursday 8 August and Will Re-Open at 4Pm on Monday 2 September
    Summer Closure 2019 Members are asked to note that the Club will close from 4pm on Thursday 8 August and will re-open at 4pm on Monday 2 September. The Clubs below have offered hospitality. Members and Lady Associate Members who propose to visit hospitality clubs are advised to telephone the clubs concerned to confirm hospitality dates, to ascertain what facilities are available, and to establish dress requirements and any restrictions on use. When using clubs offering hospitality, Members and Lady Associates should expect to show their membership card. All accounts must be settled before leaving these clubs. Letters of Introduction may be prepared online via the Members Only area of the Club website. * Army and Navy 36 Pall Mall London SW1Y 5JN 020 7930 9721 Letter of Introduction required, additional information can be found in the OandC weekly eNewsletter and on the website Athenaeum 107 Pall Mall London SW1Y 5ER 020 7930 4843 Lunch and dinner Caledonian Club 9 Halkin St London SW1X 7DR 020 7235 5162 All facilities, enquiries welcome Carlton Club 69 St James’s Street, SW1A 1PJ 020 7493 1164 All facilities, book in advance for dining and accommodation Cavalry and Guards 127 Piccadilly London W1J 7PX 020 7499 1261 All facilities City University 42 Crutched Friars, EC3N 2AP 020 7863 6681 *East India 16 St James’s Square London SW1Y 4LH 020 7930 1000 Book in advance for dining Goodenough Club 23 Mecklenburgh Square London WC1N 2AD 020 7769 4727 All Facilities *Lansdowne 9 Fitzmaurice Place London W1J 5JD 020 7629 7200 All dining, sporting, business and accommodation facilities are included in hospitality arrangement.
    [Show full text]
  • AUSTRALIA the Melbourne Savage Club 12 Bank Place Melbourne
    Australia The Ontario Club The St. James Club The Melbourne Savage Club 30 Wellington Street West 7-8 Park Place 12 Bank Place Toronto, Ontario M5O 1A1 CANADA London SW1A 1LP ENGLAND Melbourne Victoria 3000 T: +1 416 862 1270 - F: +1 416 363 9717 T: +44 20 73 16 16 08 - F: +44 20 73 16 16 02 +61 3 9670 0644 www.ontarioclub.com www.stjameshotelandclub.com www.melbournesavageclub.com The Union Club of British Columbia The Travellers Club The Royal Automobile Club of Australia 805 Gordon Street 106 Pall Mall 89 Macquarie Street, NSW 2000 Sydney Victoria, British Columbia V8W 1Z6 CANADA London SW1Y 5EP ENGLAND T: +61 (0)2 8273 2300 - F: +61 (0)2 8273 2301 T: +1 250 384 1151 - F: +1 250 384 0538 T: +44 20 79 30 86 88 - F: +44 20 29 30 20 19 www.raca.com.au www.unionclub.com www.thetravellersclub.org.uk Canada The Calgary Winter Club China Germany 4611 14th Street N.W. The Ambassy Club Anglo-German Club e.V. Calgary, Alberta T2K 1J7 CANADA 1500 Central Shanghai Road Harvestehuder Weg 44 T: +1 403 289 5511 - F: +1 403 289 2035 Shanghai 200031 CHINA 20149 Hamburg GERMANY www.calgarywinterclub.com T: +86 21 64 31 27 28 - F: +86 21 34 01 08 14 T: +40 45 01 55 12/13 - F: +40 44 77 74 The Hamilton Club www.anglo-german-club.de 6 Main Street East England Hamilton, Ontario L8N 1E8 CANADA The Carlton Club Greece T: +1 905 522 4675 -F: +1 905 546 5022 69 St.
    [Show full text]
  • Jewel Theatre Audience Guide Addendum: London Gentlemen’S Clubs and the Explorers Club in New York City
    Jewel Theatre Audience Guide Addendum: London Gentlemen’s Clubs and the Explorers Club in New York City directed by Art Manke by Susan Myer Silton, Dramaturg © 2019 GENTLEMEN’S CLUBS IN LONDON Nell Benjamin describes her fictional Explorers Club in the opening stage directions of the play: We are in the bar of the Explorers club. It is decorated in high Victorian style, with dark woods, leather chairs, and weird souvenirs from various expeditions like snowshoes, African masks, and hideous bits of taxidermy. There is a sofa, a bar, and several cushy club chairs. A stair leads up to club bedrooms. Pictured above is the bar at the Savile Club in London, which is a traditional gentlemen’s club founded in 1868 and located at 69 Brook Street in Mayfair. Most of the gentlemen’s clubs in existence in London in 1879, the time of the play, had been established earlier, and were clustered together closer to the heart of the city. Clubs in the Pall Mall area were: The Athenaeum, est. 1824; The Travellers Club, est. 1819; The (original) Reform Club, 1832; The Army and Navy Club, 1837; Guard’s Club, 1810; United University Club, est. 1821, which became the Oxford and Cambridge Club in 1830; and the Reform Club (second location), est. 1836. Clubs on St. James Street were: Whites, est. 1693; Brooks, est. 1762; Boodles, est. 1762; The Carlton Club, 1832; Pratt’s, est. 1857; and Arthur’s, est. 1827. Clubs in St. James Square were: The East India Club, est. 1849 and Pratt’s, est. 1857.
    [Show full text]
  • A Room of His Own: a Literary-Cultural Study of Victorian Clubland
    &A Room of His Own A Literary-Cultural Study of Victorian Clubland B ARBARA BLACK ohio university press • athens Contents List of Illustrations vii Acknowledgments ix Prologue 1 Introduction The Man in the Club Window 5 Chapter 1 A Night at the Club 33 Chapter 2 Conduct Befitting a Gentleman Mid-Victorian Clubdom and the Novel 88 Chapter 3 Clubland’s Special Correspondents 112 Chapter 4 Membership Has Its Privileges The Imperial Clubman at Home and Away 147 Chapter 5 The Pleasure of Your Company in Late-Victorian Pall Mall 175 Chapter 6 A World of Men An Elegy for Clubbability 201 Epilogue A Room of Her Own 219 Notes 239 Bibliography 277 Index 293 v Illustrations P.1. “The Guys Who Look Remarkably Alike Club,” by Hilgerdt, 2007 4 I.1. “The Man in the Club Window,” frontispiece for Hogg’s Habits of Good Society, 1859 13 I.2. Frequency of use of club and gentlemen’s club, 1800–2000 29 1.1. Travellers’ Pie recipe 35 1.2. Cotelettes de Mouton à la Reform recipe 35 1.3. Garrick Club Beefsteak dinner menu, 1890 36 1.4. Garrick Club dinner menu featuring turtle soup, 1899 37 1.5. Garrick Club dinner bill of James Christie, 1892 38 1.6. Garrick Club dinner bill of James Christie, 1891 39 1.7. Garrick Club dinner bill of Mr. Kemble, 1893 39 1.8. Illustrated Garrick Club house dinner menu, 1913 40 1.9. Garrick Club menu card (autographed), 1880 41 1.10. “The Smoking Room at the Club,” by Doyle, 1862 43 1.11.
    [Show full text]
  • Club Architecture a Vessel of Behavior, Language and Politics
    Club ArChiteCture A vessel of behAvior, lAnguAge And politiCs Without constituting a heterotopia, since it is not a place to confine ‘otherness’ but to bring together those who precisely turn away from it, the club is perhaps the best-known urban manifestation of a space of exception. Explaining its emergence in Victorian England, and analyzing one of its emblematic cases in London, this text allows us to understand not only the club spatiality but also its architectural politics of exclusion. Keywords · typology, exclusion, gentlemen, Reform Club, London Clubbism is a great mystery, and its adepts must be cautious as to how they explain its shibboleth to the outer barbarian. (Sala, 1862:207) There is something about clubs that inspire curiosity; they are at- tractive because you are not a part of them. They are exclusive with codes that are furtive to non-members. Club architecture works as a boundary that divides public life from private space where only mem- bers and their guests can access, a condition that is usually reinforced by staircases, vestibules or grand entrances. The facade can give you some hints about the club’s life, but only the interior can unravel what it is about. Its way of life is transmitted through its spaces. Once inside the clubhouse, space triggers a change in attitude; an effect that is only similar to religious architecture, where rituals establish the appropriate way to act. Churches and clubs are gath- ering spaces for closed communities that have speech and social interaction as their main activity. In the club, as in the temple, the relation between behavior and space becomes more evident when you don’t understand the ‘belief’ or culture behind the conduct.
    [Show full text]
  • Reciprocal Club Listing Domestic List
    Reciprocal Club Listing The Racquet Club of Philadelphia has reciprocity with over 200 clubs worldwide. Members of the club enjoy the extraordinary benefit of choosing from a plethora of four and five star accommodations and facilities in nearly every major city during business and personal travels. A Racquet Club member in search of overnight accommodations, dining reservations or use of athletic facilities must contact the visiting club directly. In order for a member to use reciprocal facilities, a letter of introduction must be sent by The Racquet Club. Letters of introduction are only issued to members in good financial standing with the club. After personal arrangements are made, please contact Devron Owens, the Front Desk Manager of The Racquet Club at [email protected] or (215) 735-1525 to request a letter of introduction. In order to expedite your request, please provide your name, membership number, the name of the reciprocal club, and the dates of your visit. Guests of members are not permitted to visit the reciprocal clubs unless accompanied by a Racquet Club member. The subsequent pages list both our domestic and international Reciprocal Clubs. Domestic List ALASKA EL PASO CLUB THE COLLIER ATHLETIC CAPTAIN COOK ATHLETIC CLUB CLUB THE UNIVERSITY CLUB OF DENVER THE ST. PETERSBURG THE PETROLEUM CLUB OF YACHT CLUB ANCHORAGE CONNECTICUT THE SURF CLUB THE GRADUATE CLUB ALABAMA THE UNIVERSITY CLUB OF ORLANDO THE CLUB THE HARTFORD CLUB THE UNIVERSITY CLUB OF ARIZONA THE NEW HAVEN LAWN TAMPA CLUB THE UNIVERSITY CLUB OF GEORGIA PHOENIX THE QUINNIPIACK CLUB THE CHATHAM CLUB CALIFORNIA DELAWARE THE CITY CLUB OF CALIFORNIA YACHT CLUB THE UNIVERSITY & WHIST CLUB BUCKHEAD CORAL CASINO BEACH & THE HEALY POINT CABANA CLUB DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA COUNTRY CLUB THE LOS ANGELES THE ARMY AND NAVY THE PINNACLE CLUB ATHLETIC CLUB CLUB THE UNIVERSITY THE ARTS CLUB OF HAWAII ATHLETIC CLUB WASHINGTON THE HONOLULU CLUB THE CITY TAVERN CLUB THE SANTA BARBARA CLUB THE PACIFIC CLUB THE GEORGETOWN CLUB OF D.C.
    [Show full text]
  • Reform Club Victorian London
    this page is from The Dictionary of Victorian London see also cookies policy Victorian London - Entertainment and Recreation - Clubs - Reform Club The Reform Club is a majestic building, practically square and reminiscent of the Farnese Palace in Rome. It is two floors high, with nine windows along the frontage and eight on the sides. A porter sits at a desk in the lobby, to answer visitors' questions and probably to see that none but members penetrate within its imposing portals. The interior hall is surrounded by colonnades supporting a large gallery. The floor is tessellated in imitation of Roman mosaic. The pillars are made of stucco of the colour of Siennese marble; the dome which lights the hall is of diapered flint glass and is supported by twenty Ionic columns; their red porphyry basements breaking the line of a stone balustrade rest on the gallery, which is reached by a broad white marble stairway. This gallery, where one can stroll as in a covered cloister, is fitted with easy chairs, mirrors, pictures and a thick carpet. It is a kind of general sitting-room from which you can observe the hall below into which visitors are ushered. A drawing-room so large that it must intended for dancing, a card-room, reading-room, and private reception-rooms open into this gallery, as do also the two important libraries; the one containing literary works, the other legal and political ones. There are two librarians on the staff of the club. On the upper floor there are a considerable number of bedrooms.
    [Show full text]
  • The Reform Club, Pall Mall, London
    AROUND THE WORLD IN 80 DAYS – CHECK THAT A.C. THE REFORM CLUB, LONDON by Lew Toulmin We stayed at the Reform Club for two nights in late June 2010 and have written up a full report. SUMMARY The Club is in a beautiful building in historic Pall Mall, a super location just a few hundred yards from St. James Palace. Room rates are acceptable if not cheap. Visitors should avoid the non-air-conditioned second floor sleeping rooms during warm weather, and request the third floor instead. This newly-installed floor has no windows but does have a modern AC system. HISTORY The Reform Club was founded in 1836 and the current building was designed in 1841 by Charles Barry, one of the leading architects of the day, as a large Italian-style palace based on Palazzo Farnese by Michelangelo. Membership was originally limited to liberal (and Liberal) supporters of the Great Reform Act of 1832, and new members had to sign a document attesting their support, hence the name of the Club. The Club is no longer politically affiliated. Famous members have included Winston Churchill, E.M. Forster, Henry James, Lord Palmerston, William Makepeace Thackeray, Arthur Conan Doyle, David Lloyd George and H.G. Wells. These and other member’s pictures line the walls of the ground floor. I was surprised and pleased to find a picture of a distinguished relative there too. William Lygon, KG, KCMG, CB, KStJ, PC, seventh Earl of Beauchamp, was a Cabinet member and sword-bearer to the King at his coronation. Unfortunately, as documented in Madresfield, the Real Brideshead by Jane Mulvagh, he was forced to flee the country (and resigned the Club) in 1931 to avoid prosecution for homosexual activities.
    [Show full text]
  • Champion of Liberalism Helen Langley Honor Balfour and the Liberal Party an Archival Perspective Will Pinkney C
    For the study of Liberal, SDP and Issue 78 / Spring 2013 / £6.00 Liberal Democrat history Journal of LiberalHI ST O R Y Champion of Liberalism Helen Langley Honor Balfour and the Liberal Party An archival perspective Will Pinkney C. E. Montague, Liberal war writers and the Great War Peter Urbach The Reform Club’s Jubilee Ball End of an era Tudor Jones ‘Reluctant’ or Liberal collectivists? The Social Liberalism of Keynes and Beveridge Ruth Polling Mothers of Liberty How modern Liberalism was made by women Liberal Democrat History Group 2 Journal of Liberal History 78 Spring 2013 Journal of Liberal History Issue 78: Spring 2013 The Journal of Liberal History is published quarterly by the Liberal Democrat History Group. ISSN 1479-9642 Liberal history news 4 Editor: Duncan Brack History Group plaque; PhD in political history; Archiving the ‘Red Guard’; The Deputy Editor: Tom Kiehl Liberal Party, Unionism and political culture Assistant Editor: Christine Headley Biographies Editor: Robert Ingham Reviews Editor: Dr Eugenio Biagini Honor Balfour and the Liberal Party 6 Contributing Editors: Graham Lippiatt, Tony Little, An archival perspective; by Helen Langley York Membery C. E. Montague, Liberal war writers and the Great 20 Patrons Dr Eugenio Biagini; Professor Michael Freeden; War Professor John Vincent Will Pinkney examines the war writings of a Liberal author Editorial Board Letters to the Editor 25 Dr Malcolm Baines; Dr Ian Cawood; Dr Roy Douglas; D. S. Macdonald (David Steel); Immigration (Sandy S. Waugh); Roy Jenkins and Dr David Dutton; Prof. David Gowland; Prof. Richard Lloyd George (Alan Mumford); C. L. Mowat and Lloyd George (Rufus Adams) Grayson; Dr Michael Hart; Peter Hellyer; Dr Alison Holmes; Dr J.
    [Show full text]
  • The Great Famine Douglas Kanter Gladstone and the Great Irish Famine Iain Sharpe the Myth of ‘New Liberalism’ Continuity and Change in Liberal Politics, 1889–1914 J
    For the study of Liberal, SDP and Issue 81 / Winter 2013–14 / £6.00 Liberal Democrat history Journal of LiberalHI ST O R Y The great famine Douglas Kanter Gladstone and the great Irish famine Iain Sharpe The myth of ‘New Liberalism’ Continuity and change in Liberal politics, 1889–1914 J. Graham Jones The ‘Land and the Nation’ and Wales Russell Deacon Richard Livsey Welsh Liberal Democrat leader remembered Douglas Oliver Survival and success: 25 years of the Liberal Democrats Meeting report Liberal Democrat History Group New from the Liberal Democrat History Group The Dictionary of Liberal Quotations ‘A liberal is a man or a woman or a child who looks forward to a better day, a more tranquil night, and a bright, infinite future.’ (Leonard Bernstein) ‘I am for peace, retrenchment and reform, the watchword of the great Liberal Party thirty years ago.’ (John Bright) ‘Few organisations can debate for three days whether to stage a debate, hold a debate, have a vote and then proceed to have a debate about what they have debated. But that is why the Liberal Democrats hold a special place in the British constitution.’ (Patrick Wintour) Edited by Duncan Brack, with a foreword from Paddy Ashdown. Writers, thinkers, journalists, philosophers and politicians contribute nearly 2,000 quotations, musings, provocations, jibes and diatribes. A completely revised and updated edition of the History Group’s second book (published originally in 1999), this is the essential guide to who said what about Liberals and Liberalism. Available at a special discounted rate for Journal of Liberal History subscribers: £10 instead of the normal £12.99.
    [Show full text]
  • APPENDIX I the Carlton Club Meeting, 19 October 1922
    APPENDIX I The Carlton Club Meeting, 19 October 1922 This appendix lists the vote at the Carlton Club Meeting of all Conservative M.P.s It is based on a list in the Austen Chamber­ lain Papers (AC/33/2/92), and has been checked against public statements by the M.P.s of their votes at the meeting. In two cases the public statements disagreed with Chamberlain's list. They were Sir R. Greene (Hackney North) and C. Erskine-Bolst (Hackney South). Chamberlaine's list said that Greene supported the Coalition, while Erskine-Bolst opposed it. The two men indicated that they had the opposite opinion, and their votes may have been transposed in Chamberlain's list. The appendix gives information on the attitude of Conserva­ tive M.P.s towards the Coalition before the Carlton Club Meet­ ing, and it also lists some M.P.s who were present but who according to Chamberlain did not vote. R. R. James, using a different source, published a list of the M.P.s voting at the Carlton Club (Memoirs Of A Conservative, 130-3). He gave the total vote as 185 opponents of the Coalition, and 88 supporters, and he lists 184 opponents of the Coalition. M.P.s who were listed differently from Chamberlain's accounting were: H. C. Brown (Chamberlain, anti; James, absent) C. Carew (Chamberlain, absent; James, pro) G. L. Palmer (Chamberlain, absent; James, anti) H. Ratcliffe (Chamberlain, absent; James, pro) 222 THE FALL OF LLOYD GEORGE N. Raw (Chamberlain, absent; James, anti) R. G. Sharman-Crawford (Chamberlain, anti; James, absent) R.
    [Show full text]
  • Club Life of London by John Timbs
    Club Life of London by John Timbs ORIGIN OF CLUBS. The Club, in the general acceptation of the term, may be regarded as one of the earliest offshoots of Man's habitually gregarious and social inclination; and as an instance of that remarkable influence which, in an early stage of society, the powers of Nature exercise over the fortunes of mankind. It may not be traceable to the time "When Adam dolve, and Eve span;" but, it is natural to imagine that concurrent with the force of numbers must have increased the tendency of men to associate for some common object. This may have been the enjoyment of the staple of life; for, our elegant Essayist, writing with ages of experience at his beck, has truly said, "all celebrated Clubs were founded upon eating and drinking, which are points where most men agree, and in which the learned and the illiterate, the dull and the airy, the philosopher and the buffoon, can all of them bear a part."2 For special proof of the antiquity of the practice it may suffice to refer to the polished Athenians, who had, besides their general symposia, friendly meetings, where every one sent his own portion of the feast, bore a proportionate part of the expense, or gave a pledge at a fixed price. A regard for clubbism existed even in Lycurgan Sparta: the public tables consisted generally of fifteen persons each, and all vacancies were filled up by ballot, in which unanimous consent was indispensable for election; and the other laws, as described by Plutarch, differ but slightly from those of modern Clubs.
    [Show full text]